CLAREMONT METROLINK STATION STUDY Claremont Town Hall Meeting December 11, 2017
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CLAREMONT METROLINK STATION STUDY Claremont Town Hall Meeting December 11, 2017 1 Welcome Larry Schroeder Claremont Mayor 2 Agenda 1. Introduction of Panelists 2. Background 3. Metro Board Motion - Metrolink Claremont Station 4. Goal and Purpose of the Meeting 5. Claremont Station Presentation 6. Q&A 3 Background 1. Metro in partnership with Southern California Regional Rail Authority and Foothill Gold Line Construction Authority has been invited by the City of Claremont to share the preliminary results of the Claremont Station Study and solicit your feedback. 2. To build the Gold Line Phase 2B project, existing freight/Metrolink train tracks must be relocated to a new location within the railroad corridor. The Gold Line Phase 2B EIR includes the relocation of the Claremont Metrolink Station. This study evaluated potential impacts and mitigations to Claremont if the Metrolink station is eliminated in lieu of relocation. 4 Goal and Purpose 1. Timely completion of this study is critical since the Foothill Gold Line Construction Authority will soon hire its design-build team. The Claremont Station relocation or elimination issue must be resolved by early 2018 to be integrated into the design-build contract. 2. Your feedback will be incorporated into a recommendation which will be presented to the Metro Board at the January 17, 2018 Planning and Programming Board Committee Meeting. 3. Metro, Foothill Gold Line Construction Authority, and Southern California Regional Rail Authority (aka “Metrolink”) are committed to working together with the City of Claremont to identify the best path forward. 5 Introduction of Panelists Name Agency Sam Pedroza , Council Member City of Claremont Colin Tudor, Assistant City Manager Jeanet Owens, Senior Executive Officer, Regional Rail Los Angeles County Metropolitan Frank Ching, Deputy Executive Officer, Operational Transportation Authority (Metro) Programs, Countywide Planning & Development Chris Burner, Chief Project Officer Foothill Gold Line Construction Authority Roderick Diaz, Director, Planning Southern California Regional Rail Justin Fornelli, Director, Engineering & Construction Authority (SCRRA or Metrolink) 6 Metro Board Motion 21.1 On September 28, 2017, Metro Board Directors Solis, Barger, Fasana, and Najarian introduced a Board motion directing staff to study the potential benefits and impacts of eliminating the Claremont Metrolink Station. The study includes the following tasks: 1. Ridership - Current and projected ridership at 7. Impacts and potential mitigations to the the Metrolink Claremont station under existing City of Claremont if it becomes the Gold conditions (without Gold Line Phase 2B). Line terminus with and without a Metrolink 2. Metrolink Operations - Impacts to Metrolink Station scenario. operations and travel times with the 8. Parking - Total parking spaces and current elimination of the Metrolink station. parking utilization rate at the co-located 3. Analysis of changes to gate operations at all Metrolink and proposed Gold Line stations crossings in Claremont if the Metrolink station (Pomona North, Claremont and Montclair is eliminated. stations). 4. Analysis of when Metrolink service would be 9. Determine the formal process by which to discontinued in Claremont during Gold Line eliminate a Metrolink station, should that construction, and length of time during which local station city agree. no rail transit options would be available in 10. Include City of Claremont staff in the Claremont. project team during all phases of the study 5. Gold Line Phase 2B - Cost savings associated 11. Report back to the Board within 60 days with the construction of the Gold Line Phase with a final report, findings and 2B. recommendations after presenting the 6. Impacts and potential mitigations to draft to the City of Claremont (extension Metrolink riders that currently board at the was approved to January 2018) Claremont station. 7 Distances between Metrolink Stations on the San Bernardino Line (SBL) Stations Distance (miles) San Bernardino to Rialto 3.7 Rialto to Fontana 3.8 Fontana to Rancho Cucamonga 7 Compared to Rancho Cucamonga to Upland 5 distances Upland to Montclair 2.8 between other (Connection To Transit Center) stations on the Montclair to Claremont 1.2 SBL, the (0.9 miles to future relocated station) Claremont station is 1 to 2 miles Claremont to Pomona (North) 2.1 (2.3 miles from future relocated station) from the Montclair and Pomona (North) to Covina 8 Pomona (North) Covina to Baldwin Park 4.1 stations Baldwin Park to El Monte 6.3 El Monte to Cal State LA 8 Cal State LA to Union Station 4.6 Source: SCRRA 8 TASK Claremont Station Boardings 1 AVERAGE WEEKDAY STATION BOARDINGS FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY25* CLAREMONT 415 402 394 400 397 406 482 * 2025 projection from Metrolink Strategic Plan Note: Foothill Gold Line forecasts 1361 Metrolink boardings without the Gold Line and 1162 boardings with the Gold Line by 2035 SAN BERNARDINO LINE STATION BOARDINGS FY17 RANCHO CUCAMONGA 719 COVINA 708 SAN BERNARDINO 665 CAL STATE LA 567 POMONA NORTH 534 UPLAND 511 FONTANA 493 CLAREMONT 406 EL MONTE 328 MONTCLAIR 322 BALDWIN PARK 314 RIALTO 241 9 Source: SCRRA - Ticket sales data TASK Claremont Station Average Weekday 1 Ridership Profile Claremont Station as Trip Origin / Destination Profile of 406 Passengers 175 Destination 32% XX% XX% (128 riders)a XX origin destinationXX% Origin 43% % XX% 68% (278 riders)b 74 54 18% 33 18 21 19 12 8% 13% 4% 5% 5% 3% ADULT SENIOR / STUDENT YOUTH DISABLED a. 65% (85 out of 128 riders) go to Claremont for work b. 84% (235 out of 278 riders) go to LA or elsewhere for work Source: SCRRA - 2015 Onboard Survey 10 TASK Claremont Station Average Weekday 1 Ridership Profile Station Access/Departure 70% (285 riders) drive to or 25% (102 riders) 5% (19 riders )arrive at or depart the station by car walk/bike to or from the leave the station by bus station or other means s Unable Unable to s s No car s to drive, drive, 8% ss available, 8% 2% No car s available, 15% I have a car I have a car available, 77% available, 90% Source: SCRRA - 2015 Onboard Survey 11 TASK Impacts of Eliminating the Claremont Metrolink Station 2 to Metrolink Operations and Travel Times 1. No travel time saved and negligible impacts to Metrolink Operations due to constraints by single track infrastructure on either side of Claremont. Trains need to “meet” at double track sections a. 70% of the San Bernardino Line is single track b. Spacing between double track sections affects whether a travel time reduction can be incorporated into the schedule c. In this case, reduction needs to be >10 minutes to realize a schedule savings 2. Therefore, only early morning trains and last 2 night trains saves approximately 2-3 minutes of travel time 12 Source: SCRRA 12 TASK Analysis of changes to gate operations at crossings in 3 Claremont if the Metrolink station is eliminated Gate Down Timea (Minutes per Peak Hourb) Future Condition Existing Future Condition Railroad Grade Gold Line with Condition Gold Line with Relocated Crossingsc Metrolink Station Metrolink Station Eliminated d Indian Hill 9 minutes 11 minutes 5 minutes College 9 minutes 30 minutes 27 minutes Claremont 11 minutes 35 minutes 30 minutes Number of 4 Metrolink 6 Metrolink trains 6 Metrolink trains trains during trains 24 Gold Line trains 24 Gold Line trains peak hour a. Gate down times are estimates and could change with final design and project implementation b. Peak hour is from 6 AM to 7 AM and from 5 PM to 6 PM c. Cambridge Avenue will not be impacted by the station relocation or elimination due to its distance from the Station d. Gold Line tracks will be grade separated at Indian Hill 13 Sources: SCRRA and City of Claremont TASK If Metrolink Station is Eliminated 4 Period of No Rail Service to City of Claremont Approximately 5 years with no rail service if Metrolink Station is not reconstructed as planned (from end of 2021 to opening Gold Line Phase 2B in 2027) Source: Foothill Gold Line 14 TASK Cost/Time Savings to Gold Line Phase 2B 5 Without Metrolink Claremont Station Eliminating the Metrolink station could: 1. Save 5 (five) months from the Gold Line Phase 2B construction schedule 2. Reduce the Gold Line Phase 2B cost by approximately $40 million (not including parking) Source: Foothill Gold Line 15 TASK Impacts and Measures of Metrolink Station Elimination 6 to Riders during construction of Gold Line Phase 2B IMPACTS MEASURES TO ADDRESS IMPACTS – Not all impacts can be fully addressed Riders can connect to the Montclair Metrolink station (1.2 miles) by bus, car, or bike b Metrolink regular roundtrip fares: • Claremont to Union Station = $18.50 • Montclair to Union Station = $ 19.50 Loss of direct rail connection Take a free courtesy shuttle provided by the Foothill Gold Line Authority from Claremont from Claremont station to Montclair station (cost to Gold Line Authority = $400,000/year) to San • Current total travel time to LA with Metrolink = 55 minutes Bernardino • Estimated total travel time with shuttle service = 66 minutes stations and other Drive a car to Montclair station c destinations for • Current total travel time to LA with Metrolink = 55 minutes five years a • Estimated total travel time including drive time to Montclair = 64 minutes Ride a bike to Montclair station • Current total travel time to LA with Metrolink = 55 minutes • Estimated total travel time including bike ride to Montclair = 66 minutes Notes: a. Over 400 riders currently use the Claremont station, and the Gold Line forecasts Metrolink