Ysssbf
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
ERN>01620233</ERN> D384 2 ANNEX ~ LIST OF CIVIL PARTY APPLICATIONS INADMISSIBLE 3|b SifIffe Full Name Reasons for Inadmissibility Finding Province Foreign Lawyer Isis \b 2 The Applicant described the following enslavement and OIA at various locations murder of her father and s I uncle s family in Siem Reap Province While it is recognised that these are traumatising events they do not UTH Rathana }tctf Banteay Meanchey 5 Chet Vanly S relate to any matter which would permit the admission of the Applicant to be joined as a civil party as they fall a Q Sr 5 outside of the territorial scope of the Case File ~~ n 3 The Applicant described being ordered to carry out hard labour from 1975 onwards including at Trapeang 23 ru I Thma Dam However her identification document confirmed in the information entered in her VIF state that 02 CHEN Savey she was bom in 1974 and was thus an infant in 1975 While this is traumatising these inconsistencies make it Banteay Meanchey s Chet Vanly s 02 ~ to deduce that it is more than not to be true that she suffered as a of one of the 3 ~~ impossible likely consequence crimes ~~ charged n 3 s ¦02 The Applicant s VIF and Supplementary Information are contradictory The Applicant was not sent to 3 a Khnol Security Centre He was a RAK soldier throughout DK While he witnessed various crimes and NHOEK Yun c Banteay Meanchey 5 Chet Vanly S numerous members of his family died during the Regime it is not established that it is more likely than not to b 3 Q £ a true that the Applicant suffered as a result of one of the crimes charged ~~ n Enslavement of and OIA Preak Norint Commune Aek Phnom District and Pailin 3 tr Applicant Battambang 5 provinces throughout DK murder Applicant s aunt and her family his uncle and his family and his cousin in 02 I SDEUNG Mach Kirirum probably in Banan District no clear timeframe and exact location Because of the insufficiency of thdBanteay Meanchey 5 Chet Vanly 3 1~ ’~6 details provided by the Applicant through his lawyers it is not possible for the ICIJ to be satisfied that it is ~~ more likely than not to be true that he suffered harm as a result of one of the crimes charged The factual account provided by the Applicant is word for word the same as for Applicants D5 1359 D5 1361 3 and D5 1631 While it is not impossible that these Applicants went through the same events at the same time ’S CHHIM Sampoeung °2 the complete lack of personalization of the application is disconcerting and make it hard to be satisfied from Banteay Meanchey 5 Chet Vanly 2 iQ these accounts that it is more likely than not to be true that they suffered harm as a result of one of the crimes ~~ 5 § charged The factual account provided by the Applicant is word for word the same as for Applicants D5 1357 D5 1361 3 s and D5 1631 While it is not impossible that these Applicants went through the same events at the same time 02 MLIS Kimchhat £ the complete lack of personalization of the application is disconcerting and make it hard to be satisfied from Banteay Meanchey 5 Chet Vanly 3 ~ these accounts that it is more likely than not to be true that they suffered harm as a result of one of the crimes d£D2 ~~ charged The factual account provided by the Applicant is word for word the same as for Applicants D5 1357 D5 1359 2 a and D5 1631 While it is not that these went the same events at the same time 6 impossible Applicants through ’S the lack of of the is and make it hard to be satisfied from KHVEK Pach c complete personalization application disconcerting Banteay Meanchey 5 Chet Vanly 1 these accounts that it is more than not to be true that suffered harm as a result of one of the crimes 2 Q 2 likely they ~~ 5 charged 3 According to her identifying information the Applicant was bom in 1974 and was thus a toddler throughout £ 02 CO DK However he described being forced to work hard on a daily basis The Applicant also mentions that his KHUT Khonh Banteay Meanchey 2 Chet Vanly parent worked at Trapeang Thma Dam but fails to mention the timeframe He also fails to provide sufficient 3 ~ 3‘ information about the deaths of his grandparents and uncles ~~ The factual account provided by the Applicant is word for word the same as for Applicants D5 1357 D5 1359 2 and D5 1361 While it is not that these went the same events at the same time s impossible Applicants through ’S PIK Oeup “3d the complete lack of personalization of the application is disconcerting and make it hard to be satisfied from Banteay Meanchey 5 Chet Vanly S a Q these accounts that it is more likely than not to be true that they suffered harm as a result of one of the crimes Sr ~~ 5 charged Enslavement of Applicant at Thmar Koul District Battambang Province in 1975 at Trapeang Thma Dam Paoy 3 £ rU i JD Char Commune Phnom Srok District Banteay Meanchey Province in early 1976 forced marriage of Applicant 02 I VINH SaMinh 5 at Spean Sreng Commune in December 1975 Disappearances of several Khmer Krom relatives in 1975 The Banteay Meanchey 2 Chet Vanly 3 S £ VIF and supplementary information do not contain enough detail on the time frame to establish that it is more ~~ than not to be true that the suffered as a of one of the crimes likely Applicant consequence charged n 2 In the information of the Applicant state that she was bom in 1982 after DK This cannot be s MOUK identifying §2 Chet I Samay ë Banteay Meanchey ~~ 02 Vanly reconciled with the accounts provided in the VIF and accompanying documents a 5 i ar D 5 02 The described the following enslavement and OIA incl inhumane living conditions at various ~~ Applicant £ locations in Prey Kabass and Samrong districts Takeo Province death of her siblings and other relatives While ¦g OUCH Sokhân 2‘ Battambang Chet Vanly it is that these are events do not relate to matter which would the tc s D recognised traumatising they any permit ~ 5 I «X» admission of the Applicant to be joined as a civil party as they fall outside of the scope of the Case File ySSSBf IflMs ERN>01620234</ERN> D384 2 The Applicant described the following murder of Applicant s uncle at Phnom Pros Kampong Siem District X £ § Campong Cham Province in 1977 murder of her aunt uncle in Kampong Siem in 1978 enslavement of ~ Is ~~~ Nhâr Kampong Cham SI Chet Vanly 5 5 I E Applicant her parents and her older sibling and OIA at various locations including in Sector 43 Although this Q ¦t is traumatising the facts described fall outside of the scope of the Case File The Applicant described the following OIA disappearance of Applicant s older brothers from Kampong Siem § District Kampong Cham Province in 1978 murder of her two uncles in Kampong Siem District in 1977 KHIM Dâm Kampong Cham Chet Vanly ^x enslavement and OIA incl inhumane conditions of this is the facts s ~ living Applicant Although traumatising c ~ SI described fall outside of the scope of the Case File 02 X» X The described the enslavement and OIA at various locations in Siem District 2 X Applicant following Kampong «SG ~ Is HEM Kim Aun Kampong Cham Province in 1977 and 1978 Although this is traumatising the facts described fall outside of Kampong Cham S3 Chet Vanly X 51 the of the Case File Q 5 scope 02 The Applicant described the following enslavement and OIA incl inhumane living conditions at various ~ S locations including in Batheay District in 1978 and other locations in Kampong Cham Province throughout UON Choeum Kampong Cham Chet Vanly 02 DK murder of s brother s former Lon Nol soldier and murder of her sister s I 5 § Applicant family family Although c ~ X» this is traumatising the facts described fall outside of the scope of the Case File The Applicant described the following enslavement and OIA at various locations of Applicant including at x 2 Anlong Chrey Dam Batheay District in 1976 and other locations in Kampong Cham Province throughout DK 4 ~ v CHAI Long Seng Sr OIA disappearance of his uncle possibly in Kok Pring Execution Site Kampong Siem District Kampong Kampong Cham S3 Chet Vanly Q Cham Province in 1976 Although this is traumatising the facts described fall outside of the scope of the Case 5 File The Applicant described the following enslavement and OIA at various locations incl inhumane living conditions of Applicant and her husband at various locations in Kampong Cham Province including in { VANN Keat Siem District DK OIA death due to starvation of her child OIA of her Cham Chet •02 Kampong throughout disappearance Kampong Vanly c ~ brother and her nephew after they were sent to Kok Pring Execution Site Kampong Siem District Although this is traumatising the facts described fall outside of the scope of the Case File The Applicant described the following enslavement and OIA incl inhumane living conditions of Applicant in X Ponha Krek District Kampong Cham Province murder of her husband in Kok Pring Execution Site S s ~ I v CHHAI Chheng unspecified date Kampong Siem District Kampong Cham Province OIA death due to sickness and Kampong Cham Chet Vanly Q ~ starvation of her daughters in 1977 murder of her sister and her nieces nephews at Kok Pring Execution Site £ unspecified date Although this is traumatising the facts described fall outside of the scope of the Case File The Applicant described the following enslavement and OIA incl inhumane living conditions at various i 02 X locations of Applicant and her husband in Kampong Siem District Kampong Cham Province throughout DK 5 ~ ~ VÂN Hen OIA death due to starvation and starvation of her husband murder of her brothers at Kok Execution Site Cham Chet s Pring Kampong S3 Vanly ~ Kampong Siem District Although this is traumatising