Zealous Democrats: Islamism and Democracy in Egypt, Indonesia and Turkey

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Zealous Democrats: Islamism and Democracy in Egypt, Indonesia and Turkey Lowy Institute Paper 25 zealous democrats ISLAMISM AND DEMOCRACY IN EGYPT, INDONESIA AND TURKEY Anthony Bubalo • Greg Fealy Whit Mason First published for Lowy Institute for International Policy 2008 Anthony Bubalo is program director for West Asia at the Lowy Institute for International Policy. Prior to joining the Institute he worked as an Australian diplomat for 13 PO Box 102 Double Bay New South Wales 1360 Australia years and was a senior Middle East analyst at the Offi ce of www.longmedia.com.au National Assessments. Together with Greg Fealy he is the [email protected] co-author of Lowy Institute Paper 05 Joining the caravan? Tel. (+61 2) 9362 8441 The Middle East, Islamism and Indonesia. Lowy Institute for International Policy © 2008 ABN 40 102 792 174 Dr Greg Fealy is senior lecturer and fellow in Indonesian politics at the College of Asia and the Pacifi c, The All rights reserved. Without limiting the rights under copyright reserved above, no part Australian National University, Canberra. He has been a of this publication may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means (including but not limited to electronic, visiting professor at Johns Hopkins University’s School mechanical, photocopying, or recording), without the prior written permission of the of Advanced International Studies, Washington DC, and copyright owner. was also an Indonesia analyst at the Offi ce of National Assessments. He has published extensively on Indonesian Islamic issues, including co-editing Expressing Islam: Cover design by Longueville Media Typeset by Longueville Media in Esprit Book 10/13 Religious life and politics in Indonesia (ISEAS, 2008) and Voices of Islam in Southeast Asia (ISEAS, 2005). National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry Author: Bubalo, Anthony 1968- Whit Mason is currently the UN’s justice coordinator for Title: Zealous democrats : Islamism and democracy in Egypt, southern Afghanistan, a non-resident fellow in the West Indonesia and Turkey / Anthony Bubalo, Greg Fealy and, Whit Mason. Asia Program at the Lowy Institute and the director of Edition: 1st ed. ISBN: 9781921004353 (pbk.) the program on justice, peace-building and development in Notes: Bibliography. the Centre for Interdisciplinary Studies of Law, Faculty of Subjects: Islam and politics--Egypt ; Islam and politics--Indonesia ; Islam and politics- Law, University of New South Wales. He was previously -Turkey ; Political culture--Egypt ; Political culture--Indonesia ; Islam and politics-- based in Istanbul as a fellow of the Institute of Current Turkey. ; Democracy--Egypt. ; Democracy--Indonesia ; Democracy--Turkey. World Affairs and taught at Fatih University. He has lived Other Authors/Contributors: Fealy, Greg, 1957- , Mason, Whit. Dewey Number: 320.5 and worked abroad since 1989 as a journalist, political analyst, UN offi cial, NGO chief of party and diplomat. He Printed and bound in Australia using fibre supplied from plantation or sustainably is the author, with Iain King, of Peace at any price: How the managed forests. Inks used in this book are vegetable based (soy or linseed oil). world failed Kosovo. Executive summary The fear of Islamists coming to power through elections has long been an obstacle to democratisation in authoritarian states of the Muslim world. Islamists have been, and continue to be, the best organised and most credible opposition movements in many of these countries. They are also commonly, if not always correctly, assumed to be in the best position to capitalise on any democratic opening of their political systems. At the same time, the commitment of Islamists to democracy is often questioned. Indeed, when it comes to democracy, Islamism’s intellectual heritage and historical record (in terms of the few examples of Islamist-led states, such as Sudan and Iran) have not been reassuring. The apparent strength of Islamist movements, combined with suspicions about Islamism’s democratic compatibility, has been used by authoritarian governments as an argument to defl ect both domestic and international calls for political reform and democratisation. Domestically, secular liberals have preferred to settle for nominally secular dictatorships over potentially religious ones. Internationally, Western governments have preferred friendly autocrats to democratically elected, but potentially hostile, Islamist-led governments. The goal of this paper is to re-examine some of the assumptions about the risks of democratisation in authoritarian countries of the Muslim world (and not just in the Middle East) where strong Islamist movements or parties exist. While the risks of democratisation in these i ZEALOUS DEMOCRATS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY contexts should not be underestimated and the democratic commitment democratisation and political change in the Muslim world. of Islamists should not be taken at face value, the costs and pitfalls of Against this background, Islamism’s relationship with democracy the status quo in many of these countries are also increasing. has received considerable attention from scholars, researchers and The Faustian pact that secular liberals have made with authoritarian commentators. What this paper does, however, is to turn the traditional rulers in many of these states has not prevented the repression these question about Islamism’s relationship with democracy, on it’s head. regimes use against Islamists being used against others as well; nor, Instead of asking ‘What will Islamists do to democracy?’ it asks, ‘What indeed, has it stopped these regimes from adopting the types of social and does democracy do to Islamists?’ religious restrictions favoured by Islamists in an effort to co-opt popular To that end this paper compares three cases of Islamist movements religious sentiment. For the West, partnership with friendly despots in in three progressively more democratic contexts. The paper begins Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan has not prevented nationals from with a discussion of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, a movement these countries carrying out terrorist attacks against Western targets; that avows a commitment to democracy and democratic reform, but in fact, quite the reverse is often true. operates in a non-democratic political context. It then considers the This is not to say that democratisation holds all the solutions to Partai Keadilan Sejahtera (the Prosperous Justice Party or the PKS), that these problems. Democracy will undoubtedly complicate efforts by the has adapted a Muslim Brotherhood model of activism to Indonesia’s countries in question to deal with the often deep social, economic and relatively new, but maturing, democracy. Finally, it examines the case political problems they face, even if it would undoubtedly strengthen the of the Adalet ve Kalkinma Partisi (the Justice and Development Party legitimacy of those having to make the diffi cult decisions necessary to or the AKP) a ‘post-Islamist’ party operating in Turkey’s older, if still confront these challenges. Likewise, terrorist movements like al-Qaeda incomplete, democratic political system. and its partisans are unlikely to suddenly abandon bullets and bombs for Each case study provides a self-contained discussion of how one ballot boxes. But democratisation in parts of the Muslim world would particular Islamist movement or party has adapted, or attempted to adapt, suck some of the oxygen out of the extremists’ incendiary rhetoric to democratic participation. But our goal is also to compare the three case — not least the charge that Western governments preach democracy studies in order to identify any consistent shifts in ideas and activism that and human rights but in practice ally themselves with governments seem to occur across these cases and indeed manifest more strongly in committed to neither. Moreover, while Islamist militancy is not solely a the more democratic contexts. In other words, our aim is to understand product of authoritarian states, repression has played an unmistakeable the ways in which political context shapes the Islamist response. The part in the process of radicalisation in many cases. goal in this regard is not so much to establish whether democracy Our goal in this paper, however, is not to advocate or justify muscular ‘moderates’ Islamists as it is to understand the ways and conditions interventions for the sake of ‘exporting democracy’. We recognise that under which participation in democratic politics may normalise them. By democratisation is most likely to succeed when it results from endogenous normalisation we refer to a process whereby Islamists become integrated drivers and processes. Yet it is also true that the international community members of the political system, operating by the rules and norms of shapes and affects these processes in myriad ways, from the human democracy, developing more transparent leadership and party structures rights representations made by individual countries, to the provision or and expanding the bases of their membership. withholding of aid and fi nancial assistance, to the recognition afforded A review of the three case studies suggests six fairly consistent shifts new governments. In short, even if it is not actually promoting it, the in Islamist ideology and activism that appear to become more manifest international community will continue to infl uence and respond to as one moves from non-democratic to democratic contexts: ii iii ZEALOUS DEMOCRATS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY From shari’a state to shari’a values:
Recommended publications
  • Dynamics of Youth Euroscepticism a Thesis
    DYNAMICS OF YOUTH EUROSCEPTICISM A THESIS SUBMITED TO THE GARADUATE SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES OF MIDDLE EAST TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY BY ÖNDER KÜÇÜKURAL IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE IN SOCIOLOGY DECEMBER 2005 Approval of the Graduate School of Social Sciences Prof.Dr. Sencer Ayata Director I certify that this thesis satisfies all the requirements as a thesis for the degree of Master of Science. Assoc. Prof. Dr. Sibel Kalaycıoğlu Head of Department This is to certify that we have read this thesis and that in our opinion it is fully adequate, in scope and quality, as a thesis for the degree of Master of Science. Dr. Mustafa Şen Supervisor Examining Committee Members Assoc. Prof. Dr. Galip Yalman (METU, ADM) Dr. Mustafa Şen (METU, Sociology) Assist. Prof. Dr Aykan Erdemir (METU, Sociology) I hereby declare that all information in this document has been obtained and presented in accordance with academic rules and ethical conduct. I also declare that, as required by these rules and conduct, I have fully cited and referenced all material and results that are not original to this work. Name, Last name : Önder Küçükural Signature : iii ABSTRACT Dynamics of Youth Euroscepticism Küçükural, Önder M.Sc., Department of Sociology Supervisor: Dr. Mustafa Şen December 2005, 138 pages The aim of this thesis is to describe the dominant features of Euroscepticism in Turkish context and to understand its main dynamics with special reference to a particular group, the youth in Turkey. A field research was conducted in order to understand youth’s EU support.
    [Show full text]
  • Islamising Indonesia: the Rise of Jemaah Tarbiyah And
    ISLAMISING INDONESIA THE RISE OF JEMAAH TARBIYAH AND THE PROSPEROUS JUSTICE PARTY (PKS) ISLAMISING INDONESIA THE RISE OF JEMAAH TARBIYAH AND THE PROSPEROUS JUSTICE PARTY (PKS) Yon Machmudi A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of The Australian National University, Southeast Asia Center Faculty of Asian Studies, July 2006 Published by ANU E Press The Australian National University Canberra ACT 0200, Australia Email: [email protected] This title available online at: http://epress.anu.edu.au/islam_indo_citation.html National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry Author: Machmudi, Yon, 1973- Title: Islamising Indonesia : the rise of Jemaah Tarbiyah and the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS) / Yon Machmudi. ISBN: 9781921536243 (pbk.) 9781921536250 (pdf) Series: Islam in Southeast Asia series. Notes: Bibliography. Subjects: Partai Keadilan Sejahtera. Political parties--Indonesia. Islam and politics--Indonesia. Islam and state--Indonesia. Indonesia--Politics and government. Dewey Number: 324.2598082 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher. Cover design by Teresa Prowse Printed by University Printing Services, ANU This edition © 2008 ANU E Press Islam in Southeast Asia Series Theses at The Australian National University are assessed by external examiners and students are expected to take into account the advice of their examiners before they submit to the University Library the final versions of their theses. For this series, this final version of the thesis has been used as the basis for publication, taking into account other changes that the author may have decided to undertake.
    [Show full text]
  • TRANSFORMATION of POLITICAL ISLAM in TURKEY Islamist Welfare Party’S Pro-EU Turn
    PARTY POLITICS VOL 9. No.4 pp. 463–483 Copyright © 2003 SAGE Publications London Thousand Oaks New Delhi www.sagepublications.com TRANSFORMATION OF POLITICAL ISLAM IN TURKEY Islamist Welfare Party’s Pro-EU Turn Saban Taniyici ABSTRACT The recent changes in the Islamist party’s ideology and policies in Turkey are analysed in this article. The Islamist Welfare Party (WP) was ousted from power in June 1997 and was outlawed by the Consti- tutional Court (CC) in March 1998. After the ban, the WP elite founded the Virtue Party and changed policies on a number of issues. They emphasized democracy and basic human rights and freedoms in the face of this external shock. The WP’s hostile policy toward the European Union (EU) was changed. This process of change is discussed and it is argued that the EU norms presented a political opportunity structure for the party elites to influence the change of direction of the party. When the VP was banned by the CC in June 2001, the VP elites split and founded two parties which differ on a number of issues but have positive policies toward the EU. KEY WORDS European Union party change political Islam political oppor- tunity structure Turkey Introduction The Islamist Welfare Party (WP) in Turkey recently changed its decades-old policy of hostility toward the European Union (EU) and began strongly to support Turkey’s accession to the Union, thereby raising doubts about the inevitability of a civilizational conflict between Islam and the West. 1 This change was part of the party’s broader image transformation which took place after its leader, Prime Minister Necmettin Erbakan,2 was forced by the Turkish political establishment to resign from a coalition government in June 1997.
    [Show full text]
  • Democracy in Crisis: Corruption, Media, and Power in Turkey
    A Freedom House Special Report Democracy in Crisis: Corruption, Media, and Power in Turkey Susan Corke Andrew Finkel David J. Kramer Carla Anne Robbins Nate Schenkkan Executive Summary 1 Cover: Mustafa Ozer AFP / GettyImages Introduction 3 The Media Sector in Turkey 5 Historical Development 5 The Media in Crisis 8 How a History Magazine Fell Victim 10 to Self-Censorship Media Ownership and Dependency 12 Imprisonment and Detention 14 Prognosis 15 Recommendations 16 Turkey 16 European Union 17 United States 17 About the Authors Susan Corke is Andrew Finkel David J. Kramer Carla Anne Robbins Nate Schenkkan director for Eurasia is a journalist based is president of Freedom is clinical professor is a program officer programs at Freedom in Turkey since 1989, House. Prior to joining of national security at Freedom House, House. Ms. Corke contributing regularly Freedom House in studies at Baruch covering Central spent seven years at to The Daily Telegraph, 2010, he was a Senior College/CUNY’s School Asia and Turkey. the State Department, The Times, The Transatlantic Fellow at of Public Affairs and He previously worked including as Deputy Economist, TIME, the German Marshall an adjunct senior as a journalist Director for European and CNN. He has also Fund of the United States. fellow at the Council in Kazakhstan and Affairs in the Bureau written for Sabah, Mr. Kramer served as on Foreign Relations. Kyrgyzstan and of Democracy, Human Milliyet, and Taraf and Assistant Secretary of She was deputy editorial studied at Ankara Rights, and Labor. appears frequently on State for Democracy, page editor at University as a Critical Turkish television.
    [Show full text]
  • Pesantren) in Indonesia
    Examining the Socio-Economic Role of Islamic Boarding Schools (Pesantren) in Indonesia M. Falikul Isbah A thesis in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Humanities and Social Sciences UNSW Canberra June 2016 THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES Thesis/Dissertation Sheet Surname or Family name: lsbah First name: M. Falikul Other name/s: Abbreviation for degree as given In the University calendar: PhD School: School of Humanities and Social Science Faculty: University College Title: Examining the Socio-Economic Role of lslM'lic Boarding School (Pasantren) In Indonesia Abstract 350 words maximum: This thesis examines the role of Indonesian Islamjc boarding schools' <.pesanlrm) engagement in the socio-economic issues of their communities. In undertaking such initiatives, pe.rantrtn are moving beyond their core business of Islamic education and propagation. This thesis shows that these pesantrm have made significant contributions to the prosperity and welfare of their neighbouring communities. By discussing case studies of four pesontren, this thesis will analyse the ways pesantrtn have engaged with their communities. It will also examine local contexts and factors that have shaped the form of their engagement, further impact on their standing as educational and da'wah institutions, and their relationships with government and non-government organisations which offer support and partnership. This thesis also highlights why there are pesantrtn which have undertaken significant engagement activities with their neighbouring communities, while others have not. This study is placed within the growing scholarly interest in analysing Islamic organisations as non-state actors in the provision of welfare services and as development agencies at grass roots level in contemporary Indonesia.
    [Show full text]
  • Elizabeth Fuller Collins
    Islam and the Habits of Democracy: Islamic O rganizations in Post-New O rder South Sumatra Elizabeth Fuller Collins "Democratization will not proceed in Indonesia until it is actively supported by the Islamic community and until the values of democracy are explicitly articulated as compatible with Islamic doctrine." 1 This paper looks to the grassroots to see how Islamic organizations in the post- Suharto period are responding to the challenge of democratic reform.2 Islam has played a crucial role in shaping the politics of Indonesia, and since 1998 Indonesia has been viewed as a test case for the compatibility of Islam and democracy.3 However, 1 "Islam in Modern Indonesia," a conference sponsored by the United States-Indonesia Society and Asia Foundation, February 7, 2002. This statement is one of the "key conclusions" in the Executive Summary of the Conference Proceedings. Speakers at the conference included Mark Woodward, Robert Flefner, Ulil Abshar Abdalla, Lies Marcoes Natsir, Greg Fealy, Douglas Ramage, Moeslim Abdurrahman, Rizal Sukma, and Donald Emmerson. 2 Research for this paper was funded by a grant from the Ford Foundation in Jakarta. I thank Ann Tickameyer, Laurel Fleydir, Muhammad Sirozi, and Ann Shoemaker for their comments. I also want to thank the young researchers in Palembang who helped to collect information about the organizations discussed in this paper. 3 See Robert Hefner, Civil Islam: Muslims and Democratization in Indonesia (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1999); Anders Uhlin, Indonesia and the "Third Wave o f Democratization": The Indonesian Pro- Democracy Movement in a Changing World (New York, NY: St.
    [Show full text]
  • The Political Analysis of the Muslim Brotherhood and the Akp Tradition: Why Did Turkish Model Fail in Egypt?
    THE POLITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD AND THE AKP TRADITION: WHY DID TURKISH MODEL FAIL IN EGYPT? A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES OF MIDDLE EAST TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY BY DÜZGÜN ARSLANTAŞ IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE IN THE DEPARTMENT OF INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS SEPTEMBER 2013 Approval of the Graduate School of Social Sciences Prof.Dr. Meliha B. ALTUNIŞIK Director I certify that this thesis satisfies all the requirements as a thesis for the degree of Master of Science. Prof. Dr. Hüseyin BAĞCI Head of Department This is to certify that we have read this thesis and that in our opinion it is fully adequate, in scope and quality, as a thesis for the degree of Master of Science. Prof. Dr. Süha BÖLÜKBAŞIOĞLU Supervisor Examining Committee Members Assist. Prof. Dr. Işık KUŞÇU (METU, IR) Prof. Dr. Süha BÖLÜKBAŞIOĞLU (METU, IR) Prof. Dr. Recep BOZTEMUR (METU, HIST) I hereby declare that all information in this document has been obtained and presented in accordance with academic rules and ethical conduct. I also declare that, as required by these rules and conduct, I have fully cited and referenced all material and results that are not original to this work. Name, Last name : Düzgün ARSLANTAŞ Signature : iii ABSTRACT THE POLITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD AND THE AKP TRADITION: WHY DID TURKISH MODEL FAIL IN EGYPT? Arslantaş, Düzgün M.Sc., Department of International Relations Supervisor : Prof. Dr. Süha Bölükbaşıoğlu September 2013, 154 pages This thesis aims to analyze the transformation of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt and the AKP tradition in Turkey with a reference to the model debate.
    [Show full text]
  • Religious Studies (BJRS) Volume 3 Number 1 June 2014
    AL ALBAB - Borneo Journal of Religious Studies (BJRS) Volume 3 Number 1 June 2014 THE PHENOMENON OF (ISLAMIC) RELIGIOUS FUN- DAMENTALISM IN A NON-‘RELIGIOUS’ CAMPUS: A CASE STUDY AT HASANUDDIN UNIVERSITY MAKASSAR Taufani University of Eastern Indonesia, Makassar Abstract This research aims to describe and examine the phenomenon of Islamic funda- mentalism on the campus of Hasanuddin University (UNHAS). Islamic funda- mentalism is a phenomenon that emerged after the reform and it is common- ly encountered in the campus world. The trend shows that the phenomenon of Islamic fundamentalism is growing in the campus that has no particular reli- gious affiliation and is often driven by the propagation of the Campus Dakwah Organization (LDK). This research would like to test the thesis that whether it is relevant to the context of the Hasanuddin University that in fact is not a religiously-affiliated campus or the contrary. The method of collecting data was done through observation of the activities of the LDK activist at the Hasanuddin University (UNHAS) Campus Dakwah Organization’s Musholla Lovers (LDK- MPM), in-depth interviews, documentation/review of previous research and papers. This research shows that Islamic fundamentalism led by LDK-MPM is growing at the Hasanuddin University. This phenomenon emerged as the im- plications of the post-reform freedom, so that these opportunities are exploit- ed by activists to channel their euphoria, because at the time of the new order, their propagation had a fairly limited space. Another factor that led to the rise of Islamic fundamentalism and growing at Hasanuddin University is because the students did not have comprehensive Islamic references, so that they had no checklist for critiquing and examining the ideology of Islamic fundamentalism.
    [Show full text]
  • Full Text (PDF)
    PEARSON JOURNAL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES & HUMANITIES 2020 Doi Number :http://dx.doi.org/10.46872/pj.83 THE ROLE OF N. ERBAKAN AND THE WELFARE PARTY IN THE POLITICAL HISTORY OF TURKEY Dr. Namig Mammadov Azerbaijan National Academy of Sciences ORCID: 0000-0003-4356-6111 Özet Bu makale, Necmettin Erbakan'ın ve Refah Partisi'nin modern Türkiye'nin siyasi tarihindeki rolünü incelemekte ve analiz etmektedir. Türkiye'de Milli Görüş Hareketi'nin oluşumunda ve gelişiminde ideoloji, sosyal taban ve ana itici güçler ile faaliyetleri de bu makalenin incelenme kısmıdır. Makale ayrıca hareketin önderi, önde gelen bilim adamı ve araştırmacısı, profesör Necmeddin Erbakan'ın rolü de dahil olmak üzere hareketin oluşumunu ve gelişimini etkileyen tarihsel koşulların yanı sıra siyasi arenaya girme nedenleri ve sonuçları da analiz ediyor. N. Erbakan'ın Türkiye'nin siyasi hayatındaki rolü araştırılarak değerlendirilmeye çalışılmıştır. Refah Partisi'nin ana ideolojisinin faizsiz bir serbest piyasa ekonomisi, üretimin güçlendirilmesi, temel insan haklarının korunduğu adil bir toplumun kurulması vb. olduğu kaydedilmiştir. Refah Partisi (RP), aynı yönü temsil eden Ahmet Tekdal liderliğinde 1983 yılında kuruldu. Siyasi yasakların kaldırılmasının ardından N. Erbakan yeniden parti başkanlığına seçildi. 1990'lar, Milli Görüş hareketinin gelişiminde yeni bir aşamaya geldi ve Refah Partisi'nin itibarı yükselmeye başladı. 1995 seçimlerinde parti oyların yüzde 21'ini kazandı. 1996 yılında N. Erbakan, Tansu Çiller liderliğindeki Doğru Yol Partisi ile koalisyon hükümeti kurdu. Bu hükümet 28 Şubat süreci sonucunda istifa etti ve parti feshedildi. Parti üyeleri Fazilet Partisi'ni kurdu. Anahtar kelimeler: Türkiye, N. Erbakan, Milli Görüş Hareketi, Milli Nizam Partisi, Refah Partisi Abstract This article examines and analyzes the role of Najmeddin Erbakan and the Welfare Party in the political history of modern Turkey.
    [Show full text]
  • MANUFACTURING the “ONTOLOGICAL ENEMY” Socio-Political Construction of Anti-Democracy Discourses Among HTI Activists in Post
    Socio-political Construction of anti-Democracy Discourse MANUFACTURING THE “ONTOLOGICAL ENEMY” Socio-Political Construction of anti-Democracy Discourses among HTI Activists in Post-New Order Indonesia1 Masdar Hilmy IAIN Sunan Ampel Surabaya, Indonesia Abstract: The Indonesian Islamists’ rejection of demo- cracy, as this paper will demonstrate, is not monolithic; it is complex and multifaceted that is accompanied by a long process of argument building. This paper focuses its scope of analysis on Hizbut Tahrir Indonesia (HTI), a Middle Eastern-derived “transnational” Islamist movement that seeks to unite all Muslim nations all over the world under a Caliphate system. This paper argues that, in developing counter-discourses on democracy, the HTI activists employ both theological approach and modern socio-political narratives. It is also argued that the concept of enemy constructed by the HTI activists serves only as an ontological venture, and not existential one, for the purpose of self-fulfilling prophecy. The process of construction of the enemy follows the mode of binary opposition between the “authentic self” and the “corrupted other.” This paper borrows much of its theoretical framework from Saphiro, Foucault, Berger and Luckmann, and still many others. Key words: Democracy, Islamists, HTI, Khilafah> Islami> yah> . Introduction The fact that the majority of Indonesian Islamists reject the idea of democracy is nothing new. The bulk of research projects conducted 1 This paper is a part of my dissertation entitled “Islam, Islamism and Democracy: Islamist Discourses and Counter-Discourses on Democracy in Post-New Order Indonesia,” submitted to the University of Melbourne, March 2007, and also my forthcoming book published by ISEAS Singapore.
    [Show full text]
  • Protecting Economic and Social Rights in a Constitutionally Strong Form of Judicial Review: the Case of Constitutional Review by the Indonesian Constitutional Court
    Protecting Economic and Social Rights in a Constitutionally Strong Form of Judicial Review: The Case of Constitutional Review by the Indonesian Constitutional Court Andy Omara A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Washington 2017 Reading Committee: Beth E. Rivin, Chair Hugh D. Spitzer, Co-Chair Walter J. Walsh Mark E. Cammack Program Authorized to Offer Degree: School of Law ©Copyright 2017 Andy Omara University of Washington Abstract Protecting Economic and Social Rights in a Constitutionally Strong form of Judicial Review: The Case of Constitutional Review by the Indonesian Constitutional Court Andy Omara Chair and Co-Chair of the Supervisory Committee Professor Beth E. Rivin and Professor Hugh D. Spitzer School of Law The 1999-2002 constitutional amendments to Indonesia’s Constitution inserted some important features of a modern constitution. These include the introduction of a comprehensive human rights provision and a new constitutional court. This dissertation focuses on these two features and aims to understand the roles of this new court in protecting economic and social rights (ES rights). It primarily analyzes (1) factors that explain the introduction of a constitutional court in Indonesia, (2) the Court’s approaches in conducting judicial review of ES rights cases, (3) Factors that were taken into account by the Court when it decided cases on ES rights, and (4) the lawmakers’ response toward the Court’s rulings on ES rights. This dissertation reveals that, first, the introduction of a constitutional court in Indonesia can be best explained by multiple contributing factors –not a single factor.
    [Show full text]
  • In Search of Hegemony: Islamism and the State in Indonesia
    In Search of Hegemony: Islamism and the State in Indonesia LUQMAN NUL HAKIM This thesis is submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Melbourne February 2019 Declaration I certify that this thesis is the product of my own research, fewer than the maximum word limit in length, and contains no material which has been accepted as part of the requirements of any other degree at any tertiary education institution, or any material previously published by another person except where due reference is made. Luqman Nul Hakim i Abstract In post-authoritarian Indonesia, but particularly following the 9/11 terrorist attacks, Islamism has become a contentious matter of scholarly debate. The prominent accounts emerging from security and democratisation studies place much analytical weight on ideology and culture by often portraying the relationship between Islam and politics in essentialist fashion, associating the dynamics of Islamism with interpretations of Islamic doctrine or the contest between moderate and radical Muslims. The institutionalist literature, on the contrary, explains the rise of Islamism as the result of the weak capacity of the state following the fall of the centralised New Order authoritarian regime. Another variant draws attention to the moderation of Islamic politics as the result of participation in democratic processes, especially electoral politics. Yet, such linear and teleological explanations obscure the complex circumstances that establish the different trajectories of Islamism. They also fail to comprehend how the prevalence of Islamist discourse on power struggles in the current democracy can produce a more conservative and illiberal form of Islamism. In contrast, this thesis utilises the politics of hegemony approach as developed in the traditions of political discourse theory.
    [Show full text]