CORRUGATED WARES IN UTILITARIAN ASSEMBLAGES, EASTERN ARIZONA AND NEW MEXICO
Jeffery J. Clark, Archaeology Southwest Stacey N. Lengyel, Illinois State University
Cite as:
Clark, Jeffery J., and Stacey N. Lengyel 2012 Corrugated Wares in Utilitarian Assemblages, Eastern Arizona and New Mexico.
Corrugated Wares in Utilitarian Assemblages, Eastern Arizona and Western New Mexico 3
Table 1. Corrugated ware percentages in site utilitarian assemblages and averages used to generate contour plots in Figures 6.10 and 6.12, San Pedro Preservation Project.
Percent Corrugated Ware REGION/Project/Site (Reference) in Utilitarian Assemblage SILVER CREEK/MOGOLLON RIM Chicago Natural History Museum Projects (Martin et al. 1962, 1964, 1967) Carter Ranch 95 Chilcott 96 Thode 74 Rim Valley Pueblo 89 Hooper Ranch 89 Broken K Pueblo 86 Region/Subregion Average 88 University of Arizona Forestdale Valley Field School (Haury 1985) Tla Kii 64 Region/Subregion Average 64 Silver Creek Archaeological Research Project (Mills et al. 1999) Bailey 47 Hough's Great Kiva 63 Cothrun's Kiva 44 Pottery Hill 87 P:16:160 (ASM) 85 Region/Subregion Average 65 TULAROSA-QUEMADO Higgins Flat Pueblo (Martin et al. 1956) 48 Region/Subregion Average 48 Fence Lake (Hogan 1987) LA 48642 55 LA 48644 28 LA 48649 45 LA 48651 32 LA 48640 58 Region/Subregion Average 44 Mariana Mesa (McGimsey 1980) Site 616 100 Site 481 93 Site 494 97 Site 601 29 Site 188 43 Site 486 31 Region/Subregion Average 65 EAST SIERRA ANCHA-WHITE MOUNTAINS Cholla-Chevelon (Reid 1982a) AZ P:6:10 (ASM) 62 AZ P:6:27 (ASM) 9 AZ P:6:25 (ASM) and AZ P:6:11 (ASM) 32 AZ P:6:24 (ASM) 83 AZ P:6:23 (ASM) 73 AZ P:6:31 (ASM), AZ P:6:5 (ASM), and AZ P:6:29 (ASM) 34 AZ P:6:30 (ASM) 40 AZ P:3:7 (ASM) 6 Region/Subregion Average 43 4 Clark and Lengyel
Table 1. Continued.
Percent Corrugated Ware REGION/Project/Site Area (Reference) in Utilitarian Assemblage EAST SIERRA ANCHA-WHITE MOUNTAINS (cont’d.) Cholla-Q Ranch (Reid 1982b) AZ V:1:16 (ASM) 31 AZ V:1:20 (ASM) 20 AZ V:1:24 (ASM) 30 AZ V:1:31 (ASM) 59 AZ V:1:36 (ASM) Locus 2 77 AZ V:1:39 (ASM) 14 AZ V:1:40 (ASM) 87 AZ V:1:42 (ASM) 84 AZ V:1:43 (ASM) Locus 1 59 AZ V:1:50 (ASM) 44 AZ V:1:51 (ASM) 48 AZ V:1:52 (ASM) Locus 2 32 AZ V:1:54 (ASM) 9 AZ V:1:55 (ASM) 29 AZ V:1:56 (ASM) 63 AZ V:1:58 (ASM) 6 AZ V:1:59 (ASM) 35 AZ V:1:62 (ASM) 75 AZ V:1:63 (ASM) 13 AZ V:1:70 (ASM) 5 AZ V:1:73 (ASM) Locus 1 50 AZ V:1:73 (ASM) Locus 2 44 AZ V:2:65 (ASM) 56 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-61 11 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-73 58 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-93 67 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-105 91 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-106 7 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-109 27 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-113 25 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-116 10 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-118 70 AZ V:1:11 (ASM)-119 11 AZ V:1:33 (ASM) 95 AZ V:1:34 (ASM) 99 AZ V:1:49 (ASM) 25 AZ V:1:72 (ASM) 69 AZ V:1:80 (ASM) 54 Region/Subregion Average 44 University of Arizona Grasshopper Field School Chodistaas (Montgomery 1992) 76 Region/Subregion Average 76
Corrugated Wares in Utilitarian Assemblages, Eastern Arizona and Western New Mexico 5
Table 1. Continued.
Percent Corrugated Ware REGION/Project/Site Area (Reference) in Utilitarian Assemblage TONTO RIM Payson/Star Valley (Lindauer et al. 1991; Redman and Hohmann 1986) Site 650 – Site 647 1 Site 648 – Site 619 1 AR-03-12-04-21 – AR-03-12-04-22 – AR-03-12-04-620 – AR-03-12-04-618 1 AR-03-12-04-621 – AR-03-12-04-624 1 AR-03-12-04-649 2 AR-03-12-04-388 – AR-03-12-04-630 – AR-03-12-04-639 1 AR-03-12-04-651 1 AR-03-12-04-645 – AR-03-12-04-673 – AR-03-12-04-632 2 AR-03-12-04-634 – AR-03-12-04-635 2 AR-03-12-04-637 4 AR-03-12-04-640 – AR-03-12-04-644 1 Region/Subregion Average 1 TONTO BASIN-SIERRA ANCHA Arizona State University Upland (Oliver 1997) AZ U:4:97 (ASM)/Unit 11 100 AZ U:4:124 (ASM)/Unit 11 23 Region/Subregion Average 61 AZ U:4:4 (ASM)/Unit 22 45 Region/Subregion Average 45 AZ U:8:515 (ASM)/Unit 27 81 AZ U:8:530 (ASM)/Unit 27 65 AZ U:8:589 (ASM)/Unit 27 25 Region/Subregion Average 57 Arizona State Museum Cholla Tonto-Roosevelt (Reid 1982c) AZ V:5:14 (ASM) (Coon Creek) 39 Region/Subregion Average 39 TONTO BASIN-TONTO CREEK Arizona State University Cline Terrace (Oliver and Jacobs 1997) AZ U:3:121 (ASM) 2 AZ U:3:128 (ASM) 3 AZ U:3:132 (ASM) 6 AZ U:3:133 (ASM) 5 AZ U:3:137 (ASM) 2 AZ U:3:139 (ASM) 4
6 Clark and Lengyel
Table 1. Continued.
Percent Corrugated Ware REGION/Project/Site Area (Reference) in Utilitarian Assemblage TONTO BASIN-TONTO CREEK (cont’d.) Arizona State University Cline Terrace (cont’d.) AZ U:3:140 (ASM) 5 AZ U:4:8 (ASM) 1 AZ U:4:9 (ASM) 2 AZ U:4:10 (ASM) 7 AZ U:4:11 (ASM) 6 AZ U:4:12 (ASM) 1 AZ U:4:13 (ASM) 2 AZ U:4:299 (ASM) 3 AZ U:4:30 (ASM) 4 AZ U:4:32 (ASM) 1 AZ U:4:35 (ASM) – AZ U:4:39 (ASM) 4 AZ U:4:47 (ASM) 2 AZ U:4:48 (ASM) 4 AZ U:4:52 (ASM) 3 AZ U:4:60 (ASM) 4 AZ U:4:61 (ASM) 4 AZ U:4:62 (ASM) 5 Region/Subregion Average 3 Upland (Oliver 1997) AZ U:3:198 (ASM)/Unit 3 8 AZ U:3:199 (ASM)/Unit 3 6 AZ U:3:204 (ASM)/Unit 3 5 AZ U:3:214 (ASM)/Unit 3 4 Region/Subregion Average 6 Flex-Tonto Basin (Cameron 1997) AZ U:3:34 (ASM) 24 AZ U:3:254 (ASM) 23 Region/Subregion Average 23 AZ U:3:232 (ASM) Locus 1 4 AZ U:3:235 (ASM) 6 AZ U:3:240 (ASM) 4 AZ U:3:246 (ASM) 8 AZ U:3:250 (ASM) 7 AZ U:3:269 (ASM) 14 Region/Subregion Average 7 Mazatzal Piedmont (Ciolek-Torrello 1987) Region/Subregion Average 2 Tonto Creek (Vint and Heidke 2000) Sycamore Creek Section AZ U:3:276 (ASM) (Middle-of-the-Road) 7 Region/Subregion Average 7
Corrugated Wares in Utilitarian Assemblages, Eastern Arizona and Western New Mexico 7
Table 1. Continued.
Percent Corrugated Ware REGION/Project/Site Area (Reference) in Utilitarian Assemblage TONTO BASIN-TONTO CREEK (cont’d.) Punkin Center Section AZ U:3:5 (ASM) (Los Hermanos) 32 AZ U:3:297 (ASM) Locus 1 (Las Tortugas) 34 AZ U:3:297 (ASM) Locus 2 (Las Tortugas) 25 AZ U:3:299 (Granary Row) 21 AZ U:3:300 (Vista del Puerto) 34 Region/Subregion Average 29 Rye Creek (Elson and Craig 1992) AZ O:15:1 (ASM) (Rye Creek Ruin) 7 AZ O:15:54 (ASM) (Cobble) – AZ O:15:55 (ASM) (Boone Moore) – AZ O:15:89 (ASM) (Overlook) 1 AZ O:15:99 (ASM) (Arby's) – Region/Subregion Average 2 TONTO BASIN-SALT RIVER Roosevelt Community Development Project (Heidke and Stark 1995) AZ V:5:90 (ASM) (Griffin Wash) [Highland Mogollon enclave] 31 Region/Subregion Average 31 AZ V:5:4 (ASM) Locus B 12 AZ V:5:91 (ASM) Locus B 15 AZ V:5:106 (ASM) (Porcupine) 17 AZ V:5:110 (ASM) 7 AZ V:5:122 (ASM) Locus A 1 Region/Subregion Average 10 Arizona State University Livingston (Jacobs 1994) AZ V:5:128 (ASM) (Saguaro Muerto) [Highland Mogollon enclave] 43 AZ V:5:130 (ASM) [proximal to Saguaro Muerto] 39 Region/Subregion Average 41 AZ V:5:66 (ASM) (Pinto Point Mound) 7 AZ V:5:76 (ASM) (Pillar/Livingston Mound) 6 AZ V:5:111 (ASM) – AZ V:5:112 (ASM) (Sand Dune) 6 AZ V:5:119 (ASM) 5 AZ V:5:121 (ASM) 6 AZ V:5:125 (ASM) 4 AZ V:5:139 (ASM) 2 AZ V:5:140 (ASM) 1 AZ V:5:141 (ASM) 7 Arizona State University Schoolhouse Mesa (Lindauer 1997) AZ U:8:454 (ASM) [Highland Mogollon enclave] 27 Region/Subregion Average 27 AZ U:8:25 (ASM) 3 AZ U:8:152 (ASM) 6 AZ U:8:159 (ASM) – AZ U:8:385 (ASM) 1
8 Clark and Lengyel
Table 1. Continued.
Percent Corrugated Ware REGION/Project/Site Area (Reference) in Utilitarian Assemblage TONTO BASIN-SALT RIVER (cont’d.) Arizona State University Schoolhouse Mesa (cont’d.) AZ U:8:450 (ASM) 3 AZ U:8:451 (ASM) 1 AZ U:8:452 (ASM) – AZ U:8:453 (ASM) – AZ U:8:456 (ASM) 3 AZ U:8:457 (ASM) – AZ U:8:458 (ASM) 1 AZ V:5:137 (ASM) 5 AZ V:5:138 (ASM) 8 Arizona State University Rock Island (Lindauer 1995) AZ U:8:23 (ASM) (Bass Point Mound) 3 AZ U:8:400 (ASM) 2 Roosevelt Rural Sites (Ciolek-Torrello et al. 1994) AZ U:8:78 (ASM) 2 GLOBE-PINAL CREEK Arizona State Museum Miami Wash (Doyel 1978) AZ V:9:57 (ASM) (Columbus) 3 AZ V:9:55 (ASM) (Runway Ruin) 40 AZ V:9:56 (ASM) (Monitor) 24 AZ V:9:59 (ASM) (Refugia) 34 AZ V:9:60 (ASM) (Multigrade) 58 AZ V:9:62 (ASM) (Tin Horn Wash) 13 AZ V:9:68 (ASM) (East Ruin) 62 Region/Subregion Average 33
Wheatfields (Hoffman and Doyel 2003) AZ V:9:325 (ASM) (JR) 4 AZ V:9:220 (ASM) (BC) 25 AZ V:9:222 (ASM) (Murray Wash) 43 AZ V:9:365 (ASM) (Rocky Point) 17 Arizona State Museum Cholla Tonto-Roosevelt (Reid 1982c) AZ V:5:53 (ASM) 3 AZ V:9:105 (ASM) 27 AZ V:9:136 (ASM) 14 AZ V:9:138 (ASM) 10 Region/Subregion Average 13 MIDDLE GILA VALLEY Escalante (Doyel 1974) AZ U:15:22 (ASM) – AZ U:15:27 (ASM) – AZ U:15:32 (ASM) – Region/Subregion Average –
Corrugated Wares in Utilitarian Assemblages, Eastern Arizona and Western New Mexico 9
Table 1. Continued.
Percent Corrugated Ware REGION/Project/Site Area (Reference) in Utilitarian Assemblage SAFFORD BASIN AZ CC:1:28 (ASM) (Goat Hill) (Woodson 1995) [Kayenta/Tusayan enclave] – AZ V:16:8 (ASM) (Johnson and Wasley 1966) 79 AZ V:16:10 (ASM) (Johnson and Wasley 1966) 37 AZ CC:1:43 (ASM) (Krider) (Wesley Jernigan, personal communication 2000) 30 AZ CC:1:19 (ASM) (Owens-Colvin) (Rule 1993) 56 Rincon Canyon (Brown 1973) 31 AZ CC:2:3 (ASM) (Buena Vista/Curtis) (Brown 1973) 35 AZ CC:2:5 (ASM) (Earven Flat) (Brown 1973) 79 AZ CC:2:7 (ASM) (Yuma Wash) (Brown 1973) 41 AZ CC:2:15 (ASM) (Methodist Church) (Brown 1973) 7 AZ CC:2:69 (ASM) (?) (Whitmer) (Brown 1973) 22 AZ CC:2:235 (ASM) (Daley) (Clark 2004; Lee et al. 1981) 28 Region/Subregion Average 37 LOWER SAN PEDRO VALLEY San Pedro Preservation Project (this volume, except where noted) Dudleyville District AZ BB:1:6 (ASM) (Bajada/Ring) 1 AZ BB:1:22 (ASM) (Swingle's Sample) 2 AZ BB:1:32 (ASM) (Adobe Hill) 2 AZ BB:1:33 (ASM) (Roach Wash) – AZ BB:1:34 (ASM) (Piper Springs) – AZ BB:1:55 (ASM) (Artifact Hill) 1 AZ BB:1:63 (ASM) (Flagged Bush) – AZ BB:2:83 (ASM) (Dudleyville) 2 Region/Subregion Average 1 Aravaipa District AZ BB:2:3 (ASM) (Lost Mound) 3 AZ BB:2:7 (ASM) (Flieger Ruin) 1 AZ BB:2:19 (ASM) (Ash Terrace) 1 AZ BB:2:10 (ASM) (Buzan) 7 AZ BB:2:18 (ASM) (Big Pot) 5 AZ BB:2:51 (ASM) 2 Region/Subregion Average 3 San Manuel District AZ BB:6:2 (ASM) (Big Bell) 55 AZ BB:6:5 (ASM) (Camp Village) 15 AZ BB:6:11 (ASM) (Leaverton) 8 AZ BB:6:73 (ASM) (111 Ranch) 35 AZ BB:6:110 (ASM) (Corrugated Ridge) 49 AZ BB:7:5 (ASM) (High Mesa) 6 AZ BB:11:20 (ASM) (Second Canyon Compound) (Franklin 1980) 5 Region/Subregion Average 25
10 Clark and Lengyel
Table 1. Continued.
Percent Corrugated Ware REGION/Project/Site Area (Reference) in Utilitarian Assemblage LOWER SAN PEDRO VALLEY (cont’d.) San Pedro Preservation Project (this volume, except where noted) (cont’d.) San Manuel Bajada AZ BB:6:20 (ASM) (Twin Hawks) (Luchetta 2005) 14 Region/Subregion Average 14 Cascabel District AZ BB:11:2 (ASM) (Bayless Ruin) 17 AZ BB:11:26 (ASM) (Reeve Ruin) [Kayenta/Tusayan enclave] 1 AZ BB:11:27 (ASM) (Elliott) 1 AZ BB:11:36 (ASM) (Davis Ranch) [Kayenta/Tusayan enclave] – AZ BB:11:91 (ASM) (José Solas Ruin) 3 AZ BB:11:100 (ASM) (Curtis) 1 Region/Subregion Average 4 TUCSON BASIN Northeast AZ BB:10:3 (ASM) (Whiptail Ruin) (Linda Gregonis, personal 22 communication 2000) AZ BB:9:50 (ASM) (Gibbon Springs) (Slaughter and Roberts 1996) 21 Region/Subregion Average 22 Central and Northwest Marana 1 San Xavier 1 AZ BB:14:24 (ASM) 1 University Indian Ruin 1 Hodges 1 Region/Subregion Average 1 UPPER SAN PEDRO AND VICINITY AZ EE:7:1 (ASM) (Babocomari Village) (Di Peso 1951) – Region/Subregion Average – PHOENIX BASIN Pueblo Grande (Mitchell 1994) – Region/Subregion Average – LOWER/MIDDLE VERDE VALLEY Lower Verde Project (Montgomery and Whittlesey 1997) Roadhouse Ruin – Lone Juniper – Little House – Region/Subregion Average –