A Genealogy of Pro-Status Quo Voluntarism: from the Victorian Volunteer Movement to Fundraising Distance Runs for Healthcare
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Calgary PRISM: University of Calgary's Digital Repository Graduate Studies The Vault: Electronic Theses and Dissertations 2013-09-13 A Genealogy of Pro-Status Quo Voluntarism: From the Victorian Volunteer Movement to Fundraising Distance Runs for Healthcare Francis, Cheryl Francis, C. (2013). A Genealogy of Pro-Status Quo Voluntarism: From the Victorian Volunteer Movement to Fundraising Distance Runs for Healthcare (Unpublished master's thesis). University of Calgary, Calgary, AB. doi:10.11575/PRISM/24741 http://hdl.handle.net/11023/965 master thesis University of Calgary graduate students retain copyright ownership and moral rights for their thesis. You may use this material in any way that is permitted by the Copyright Act or through licensing that has been assigned to the document. For uses that are not allowable under copyright legislation or licensing, you are required to seek permission. Downloaded from PRISM: https://prism.ucalgary.ca UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY “A Genealogy of Pro-Status Quo Voluntarism: From the Victorian Volunteer Movement to Fundraising Distance Runs for Healthcare” by CHERYL LYNNE FRANCIS A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE FACULTY OF KINESIOLOGY CALGARY, ALBERTA SEPTEMBER, 2013 © Cheryl Lynne Francis 2013 Abstract The current phenomenon of running long distances to raise money and awareness for healthcare-oriented charities has roots in Victorian-era Britain. Combining the pro-status quo nineteenth-century Volunteer movement with forced prison treadwheel labour specific to the same era yields a precursor of less-similar form than the current spectacle but with an exceedingly similar function. The Volunteer movement was little more than rational recreation under the guise of preparing for a war that never came, while prison officials of the era commodified treadwheel labour as a way to make inmates pay for their own institutional expenses. Thorstein Veblen’s concept of conspicuous consumption of leisure time defines both the 19th-century Volunteer movement and its current counterpart, which also exhibits characteristics of rational recreation. Both the Volunteer movement and today’s charity running events were and are developed and employed in countries where the governments of the day took (and take) a ‘live and let live’ approach to service provision. Nancy Scheper- Hughes and Margaret Lock’s publication “The Mindful Body: A Prolegomenon to Future Work in Medical Anthropology,” provides a useful analytical tool with which to compare and contrast the individual, social and political aspects of the Volunteer movement, prison treadwheel labour and fundraising distance running. ii Preface All research projects begin at the level of the personal and this one is no exception. I have had some form of chronic illness all my life. When I was younger, I had severe asthma and running was never something I felt comfortable doing. In the late ‘90s, I joined an asthma study where I found out I was under-medicated and, therefore, not eligible to participate in the study. This turned out to be good news, however, since I changed my medication regimen and suddenly found myself able to partake in strenuous exercise. Running marathons became my hobby for a while and, during the period from 2001 to 2004; I trained for and participated in six of them. Many of these, and races of shorter duration – in which I participated as part of my training - raised money for charity. In January of 2004, I began to experience chronic, severe pain. I subsequently had five abdominal surgeries between December 2004 and February 2012 and stopped running. Astonishingly, I found myself once again sitting on the sidelines hoping that there might one day be a cure for my illness. I had never thought much about how curious running to raise money and awareness for disease treatment was until I was no longer able to do it myself. The stark contrasts between having a physical limitation, getting rid of it and falling ill with a new chronic illness opened my eyes to the paradoxical nature of a phenomenon that features able-bodied people running to raise money for the care of their disabled compatriots, especially in a country with universal healthcare. It seemed to me that the social definition of pedestrian had changed and that this latest iteration of the activity may have been what changed it. Walking or running anywhere – for any purpose other than to win a bet or a iii prize – was once a behavior attributed only to the poorest or most desperate of citizens. The distance runner appeared to have evolved from aimless vagabond to purposeful protagonist, as far as the general population and the popular media were concerned. I thought it was time someone took a closer look at running events that raised money for healthcare-related charities. Most of these fundraising distance-running events originated in the 1980s and ‘90s, meaning that it was likely most of the event founders were still living. The best way to find out what led them to incorporate such events would be merely to ask them, I reasoned. My original goal was to produce a topical oral history and to reconstruct how the genesis of such events was understood to be a desirable outgrowth of the economic, political and emotional climate from which they originated. My initial research plan was to interview the founders of distance-running fundraising events. In addition to these interviews, I had planned to analyze archived event documents and survey race participants. Methodological triangulation employing these qualitative methods would have, I hoped, facilitated an understanding of the historic, economic, political and emotional influences and processes that led to the genesis of this new genre of sporting event, from the perspective of the principals as well as from that of historical traces. Through surveying race participants I had, furthermore, planned to investigate whether the early goals of the event founders had been realized in the motivations of current constituents. Analyzing archived documents would have assisted me with discerning the individual founders’ rationales for propagating an event designed to raise funds for iv health research through distance running en masse, would have allowed for substantiation of interview data, and provided demographic information on race participants. I had designed the survey instrument to augment archival data on latent cognitive dissonance and to discover whether race participants shared the same views on the purposes of these races as the race founders did when they incorporated these events. Well-publicized - but largely unconfirmed in the literature - reasons for engaging in this genre of sporting activity include the remembrance, acknowledgement or publicity of a loved one’s battle with a particular illness in addition to self-affirmation on the part of participants who have actually experienced the illness for which a given event raises research funds. This was the only part of the original plan that I was able to execute but, by the time I had completed it, I had no other related research to back it up. I had targeted five organizations which hosted events that were either wholly local in character or were local versions of a larger national or international framework. The five organizations I targeted were: the Terry Fox Run, Calgary Marathon, Forzani’s Mother’s Day Run, Father’s Day Run for Prostate Cancer, and CIBC’s Run for the Cure. I was unable to make contact with the person(s) responsible for the genesis of the last three events as directing my inquiries to the contact information posted on the websites for these events yielded no response. I was able to correspond with Fred Fox from The Terry Fox Foundation, who was willing to give an interview but not to grant access to provincial archives. According to him, the organization does not keep demographic data on participants. I was doubtful, in any case, of the amount of involvement he had had in the creation of the Terry Fox Run and one interview with one possible event v founder was virtually useless for my purposes. I also corresponded with a representative of the Calgary Marathon who assured me that the organization was just too busy to assist with my request. An added difficulty with using the Calgary Marathon was that, while the current iteration of the Calgary Marathon has a health charity focus, the original version of the race did not. The narrowed focus on running for health- related charities only became a reality for this event in 2009, and was a decision made by committee and not a lone individual. Given the lack of interest on the part of the Calgary Marathon’s executive committee for my project, interviewing everyone responsible for the change in direction seemed unlikely to happen. The organization responsible for the Father’s Day Run for Prostate Cancer allowed me access to their race participants for the survey portion of my research, but I was unable to make contact with anyone at an executive level. As I had not been able to gain access to any organization’s archives nor secure an interview with any reliable source, the methodological triangulation I had originally envisioned was no longer a viable option. The only feasible part of the project remaining was the participant survey questionnaire, which has been omitted from this thesis document due to space and time constraints. When I realized that Plan A was going nowhere, I knew Plan B was in order. I began to read everything that seemed related to the question at hand. Two good leads surfaced early on: one was a capital ‘V’ on the phrase ‘Volunteer movement’ in a Victorian-era publication called the Badminton Library – a sort of encyclopedia of sport for the era.