ISSUE BRIEF 06.19.20 Gender Matters: Women as Actors of Change and Sustainable Development in

Yamina El Kirat El Allame, Ph.D., Professor, Faculty of Letters & Human Sciences, Mohammed V

In comparison to other countries in Against Women helped encourage the the Middle East and North Africa, the Moroccan feminist movement, leading to Moroccan government has implemented a the launch of feminist journals including considerable number of reforms to improve Lamalif and Thamanya Mars in 1983. In the women’s rights, including a gender quota 1990s, women mobilized around the issue of for parliamentary elections, a revision of reforming the . In 1992, a petition the Family Code (the Mudawana), a reform was signed by one million Moroccans, and of the constitution, a law allowing women in 1999, large demonstrations were held in to pass nationality to their children, an and . The reforms to the amendment of the rape law, and a law Mudawana were officially adopted in 2004. criminalizing gender-based violence. The 20 February Movement, associated Despite these reforms, women's rights and with the regional uprisings known as the gender equality have not improved; most “Arab Spring,”1 began with the twenty- of the changes exist on paper, and the legal year-old anonymous journalist student, measures have not been implemented well. Amina Boughalbi. Her message—“I am Moroccan and I will march on the 20th of February because I want freedom and HISTORY OF MOROCCAN WOMEN’S equality for all Moroccans”—mobilized INVOLVEMENT IN SUSTAINABLE several thousand, mainly young, Moroccan Moroccan women have DEVELOPMENT men and women. Most of the people who been integral to the reacted to the call were not active feminists Moroccan women have been integral to and had no affiliation with any feminist country’s development the country’s development through their organization. Nonetheless, women were through their role role in its independence movement, its present at all levels of this movement; they democratization, and in various social justice in its independence experienced police cruelty and represented movement, its movements. Unfortunately, women were the movement nationally and internationally. not heavily involved in nation-building post- The activists believed that women’s rights democratization, independence, and the 1962 Mudawana would be better realized by working together and in various social further codified patriarchy into law. It with men towards mutual goals, rather justice movements. legalized , established the marriage than isolating women’s issues specifically. age at 15 for women and 18 for men, and Thus, the slogans of the movement and its institutionalized tutelage—or guardianship— demands were largely gender neutral. The in marriage. movement was therefore perceived as a new The U.N. Decade for Women and form of feminism, wherein both men and the adoption of the Convention on the women were fighting for the same claims. Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination RICE UNIVERSITY’S BAKER INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC POLICY // ISSUE BRIEF // 06.19.20

guaranteeing the soulalyats’ right to MOVEMENT DEMOGRAPHICS: communal land. In fact, 128 hectares were AN URBAN/RURAL DIVIDE distributed to 867 women, who have since maintained control over the land.4 The majority of women involved in the 20 The movement initiated a country-wide February Movement, as well as most of the discussion about collective lands as national participants in previous women’s movements, heritage, revealing the complexity of their were educated and thus unrepresentative management. The soulalyats prompted the of the country’s demographics. The national government to ensure concrete solutions to female illiteracy rate in Morocco is about this issue. 44%; 35% among urban women and 61% Another example of rural mobilization among rural women. Further, 22% of rural and the largest protest movement in women do not receive any formal education.2 Morocco since 2011 emerged in the same The economic inequality gap is therefore vein as the 20 February Movement. Known very wide among . The as the Hirak Rif or the Rif Movement, it took unemployment rate among women and place in the Berber-speaking Rif region of their lack of access to services in rural areas northern Morocco between October 2016 hinders their potential to join the labor force and June 2017 as a result of the death of or to change their situations. The eradication Mohcine Fikri.5 A woman named Nawal of illiteracy is thus necessary to improve Ben Aisha6 played a key role in the protests gender equality and women’s rights. after the arrest of Naser Zafzafi, the leader Although the activists of the 20 February of the movement, and many mothers and Movement were more educated than the wives of prisoners also participated. These average Moroccan woman, they did express women, the majority of whom are illiterate concern about the inequality between elite and Amazigh monolinguals, have become and illiterate women. The movement also important actors of change. provided an opportunity for women to move Better access to technology and into traditionally masculine public spaces. social media has allowed more women Since then, more women have publicly to participate across the socioeconomic expressed that the interpretation of Islamic spectrum as citizen journalists. Protesting texts, culture, and traditions reduced their has become a daily activity, with women status, rather than itself. Even illiterate documenting and sharing acts of injustice women now utilize male-dominated spaces on social media. Women who were kept to denounce injustice and to ask for the silent for decades denounce rape, sexual rights adopted in the new Family Code harassment, child abuse, and domestic and constitution.3 violence on Facebook and YouTube. The Importantly though, rural women Masaktach (“I won’t be silent”) Movement have not been absent from mobilization in is a new and ambitious example of these Morocco, even if they have fewer resources protests, as it denounces rape on Facebook. with which to demand their rights. A rural Public spaces are also now available for grassroots movement began in 2007 by mobilization; women demonstrate in front women known as the soulalyats, who were of hospitals, schools, public administration demanding rights to land ownership. The buildings, and parliament. Women have movement was sparked by a soulalyat therefore become very visible in the public woman from Kénitra whose male family eye, taking initiatives to participate not members sold and profited off of her only in movements that concern women’s ancestral land. The soulalyat grassroots rights, but also in issues that concern the movement forced the government to give general public. The historic and present-day the women formal access to land. After mobilization of Moroccan women reveals a long struggle, a series of laws (62- that women can play a key role in the 17, 63-17 and 64-17) were promulgated sustainable development of their country. for the management of collective lands,

2 GENDER MATTERS: WOMEN AS ACTORS OF CHANGE AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN MOROCCO

WOMEN’S RIGHTS: A LONG WAY TO GO RECOMMENDATIONS

Despite these inspiring accomplishments, The empowerment of women as effective the implementation of new laws is very actors of sustainable development in slow, with no subsequent review. For Moroccan society would require more example, a closer look at the changes reforms and goals, including the following: introduced in the new Family Code reveals a lack of enforcement. Child marriage has Reduce poverty among women by almost doubled in one decade, from 7% prioritizing literacy, guaranteeing education, in 2004 to nearly 12% in 2013.7 Polygamy and facilitating access to jobs. Literacy experienced a similar trend, although to a programs are a key step, particularly for lesser degree: in 2010, nearly 43.41% of women who are beyond schooling age, as 12 applications for polygamy were accepted.8 14.8% of girls aged 15 to 24 are illiterate, The implementation of the constitutional and about seven out of 10 rural women are provision on gender equality has also been illiterate, i.e., 67.4% compared to 36.2% for The 2002 gender urban women and 37.2% for rural men.13 very slow. As Lamrabet argues, even though quotas were a crucial Article 19 of the Constitution gives equality Education will also help reduce poverty, as to women, the practice of equality “does a lack of education accounts for 36.8% of step towards the not and will not exist unless the hearts and poverty among adults and 24% among consolidation of minds of people are changed” and unless the children. Education is especially important democracy and a means for girls in rural areas, as one in 10 girls politicians change.9 Indeed, there were no with which to fight awareness campaigns surrounding the new aged 7 to 12 in rural areas do not attend 14 against the patriarchal Family Code, and the education system did school. Unemployment remains a major not support it. The judges who passed the issue. According to figures from the Higher elements of society; law hold the same patriarchal beliefs about Planning Commission in Morocco, the however, their impact women’s status, due to their interpretation of employment rate for women was 22.2% on women’s status has overall and 70.4% for rural women. Almost religious texts. Based on research conducted been minimal, as the regarding gender issues in Morocco,10 39.3% of employed women work without cultural traditions and the misinterpretation pay compared to only 9.5% of men. For rural political parties are not of religious texts have contributed to women, this figure is closer to 70%. The adhering to the quota. women's subordination. The patriarchal national female employment rate declined 15 misinterpretation of Islam should therefore from 26.8% in 2013 to 22.2% in 2019. be reconsidered, with the inclusion of female Promote and implement the Equality and Muslim scholars, in order for the new Family Parity policy and encourage women’s Code to positively impact women. access to decision-making positions. Despite the ratification of international Only about 6% of Moroccan women hold conventions and the establishment of entities decision-making positions.16 such as the Equality and Parity Commission, Guarantee access to health services for only 22% of women held positions of power women. Maternal health in rural areas is in public administration in 2016, and 81 out particularly important, as the rural maternal of 395 deputies serving in parliament are mortality rate remains twice as high as 11 currently women. Obviously, in practice, the urban rate. About 20.4% of pregnant the situation has not drastically changed. women did not receive any antenatal The 2002 gender quotas were a crucial step consultations in rural areas in 2018, towards the consolidation of democracy compared to 4.4% in urban areas.17 and a means with which to fight against the patriarchal elements of society; however, Reform the Family Code of 2004. Female their impact on women’s status has been Muslim scholars should be included in minimal, as the political parties are not the reinterpretation of the Quran and the adhering to the quota. revision of the Family Code. The new reform should be more focused and should clarify laws around early marriage and polygamy.

3 RICE UNIVERSITY’S BAKER INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC POLICY // ISSUE BRIEF // 06.19.20

The law should also be revised, 5. A 31-year-old fish seller, Mohcine as more women are now sole providers for Fikri was crushed to death in a rubbish their families. bin on October 28, 2016 in Al Hoceima Implement the gender budgeting policy. while trying to recover his confiscated Despite the state’s adoption of the gender merchandise. approach in resource distribution within 6. A 36-year-old mother of four, Nawal the budget, the situation has not changed Ben Aisha became the spokesperson for the significantly. protests, which were held every evening after the breaking of the Ramadan fast in Al Establish a culture of transparency and a Hoceima. She is now a political refugee in review of law implementation. the Netherlands. Promote a culture of gender equality 7. Droit & Justice, an organization in schools. Within school curriculum, promoting the rule of law in Morocco, found stereotypes about women should be that of the 33,253 marriage contracts in abolished, and the general representation of 2009 and 35,152 in 2013, a total of 30,000 women should be reviewed. involved females under the age of 18. Promote a culture of gender equality 8. Conseil National Des Droits de through media awareness campaigns such L’homme,“Etat de l’égalité et de la parité as the valorization of women’s success au Maroc: Préserver et rendre effectifs stories in advertisements. Awareness les finalités et objectifs constitutionnels,” campaigns focusing on female equality October 2015, https://docs. should not be limited to International euromedwomen.foundation/files/ermwf- Women’s Day. Moroccans should be made documents/6806_3.26.etategalitefinal22.pdf. aware of the value of empowering women 9. Karla M. McKanders, “Anatomy to act as full members of society. of an Uprising: Women, Democracy, and the Moroccan Feminist Spring,” Boston University International Law Journal 32, no. ENDNOTES 1, 2014, https://ssrn.com/abstract=2364578. 10. I have supervised a number of 1. The term “Arab Spring” is rejected doctoral theses on different gender in the region because it does not include issues—e.g., “Women’s Representation in the other ethnic, religious, and linguistic the Moroccan Media,” “Gender Discourse groups, namely the Amazigh people, Copts, after the Moudawana Reform,” “Women’s and others. Representation in the Moroccan English 2. Haut-Commissariat au Plan, Textbooks,” “Household Labour Division “La Femme Marocaine en Chiffres: Evolution among Dual-Earner Couples,” “Women’s des Caractéristiques Démographiques et Political Participation,” and “Women’s Socioprofessionnelles,” 2019, http://www. Associations”—all of which have revealed hcp.ma. that the status of women has not wholly 3. Examples of movements where improved. women took the lead include the Hirak Rif, 11. Haut-Commissariat au Plan, the Soulalyat Movement, the “On the Road “La Femme Marocaine en Chiffres.” 96 Movement” (Imider), the Masaktach 12. bid. Movement, etc. 13. Conseil National Des Droits de 4. Women's Learning Partnership, L’homme, “Etat de l’égalité et de la parité “Caravan of Soulaliyates Pushes for au Maroc.” Moroccan Women’s Right to Land Access,” 14. Haut-Commissariat au Plan, The Partnership Blog, April 9, 2018, “La Femme Marocaine en Chiffres.” https://learningpartnership.org/blog/ 15. Ibid. caravan-soulaliyates-pushes-for- 16. Ibid. moroccan-womens-right-land-access. 17. Ibid.

4 GENDER MATTERS: WOMEN AS ACTORS OF CHANGE AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN MOROCCO

REFERENCES ABOUT THE SERIES

Booth, Robert, Angelique Chrisafis, Tom Finn, This brief is part of a series on “Women’s Katherine Marsh, Harriet Sherwood, Grassroots Mobilization in the MENA Region and Xan Rice. “Women Have Emerged Post-2011.” The briefs were presented as Key Players in the Arab Spring.” The at workshops in Rabat, Morocco and Guardian, April 22, 2011. https://www. Amman, Jordan in February and March theguardian.com/world/2011/apr/22/ 2020 hosted by the Moroccan Institute women-arab-spring. for Policy Analysis and the American Conseil National des Droits de l’Homme. Center for Oriental Research and involving “Gender Equality and Parity in Morocco: scholars and activists from Morocco, Tunisia, Preserving and implementing the aims Lebanon, Turkey, Palestine, and Jordan. The and objectives of the Constitution.” workshops were funded with the generous Conseil National des Droits de l’Homme, support of the Kelly Day Endowment as part 2015. https://www.cndh.org.ma/an/ of the Baker Institute’s program on Women’s thematic-reports/gender-equality- Rights, Human Rights and Refugees. and-parity-morocco-preserving-and- implementing-aims-and-objectives. AUTHOR Gheytanchi, Elham and Valentine N. Moghadam. “Women, Social Protests, Yamina El Kirat El Allame, Ph.D., is a professor and the New Media Activism in at the Faculty of Letters & Human Sciences at the Middle East and North Africa.” in Rabat, Morocco. International Review of Modern Her research focuses on anthropological Sociology 40, no. 1 (Spring 2014): linguistics, cultural anthropology, minority 1-26. https://www.jstor.org/ languages, cultures and identities, and gender stable/43496487. and migration issues. She was a Fulbright See more issue briefs at: Inglehart, Ronald and Pippa Norris. Rising Visiting Scholar at Greenville Tech in 2010 www.bakerinstitute.org/issue-briefs Tide: Gender Equality and Cultural with the “Direct Access to the Muslim World” Change Around the World. New York: program. Her interest in these issues stems This publication was written by a Cambridge University Press, 2003. from her personal experience in the linguistic, researcher (or researchers) who participated in a Baker Institute project. cultural, social, educational, and political Maktabi, Rania. “Enfranchised Minors: Wherever feasible, this research is Women as People in the Middle East issues in North Africa in general and Morocco reviewed by outside experts before it is after the 2011 Arab Uprisings.” Laws 6, in particular. released. However, the views expressed no. 1 (2017): 4. https://doi.org/10.3390/ herein are those of the individual author(s), and do not necessarily laws6010004. represent the views of Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy.

© 2020 Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy

This material may be quoted or reproduced without prior permission, provided appropriate credit is given to the author and Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy.

Cite as: El Kirat El Allame, Yamina. 2020. Gender Matters: Women as Actors of Change and Sustainable Development in Morocco. Issue brief no. 06.19.20. Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy, Houston, Texas.

5