PLANNING COMMITTEE Agenda Item No. APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER OFFICER DELEGATED POWERS FOR THE MONTH OF AUGUST 2018
App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
18/0202 Full Application Appleby Variation of condition 2 (plans compliance) to amend GARAGE, THE SANDS, APPLEBY- Mr R Ashley - Roy APPROVED internal lift attached to approval 15/0853. IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6XN Ashley Motors Ltd
18/0228 Full Application Kaber Re-organisation of parking arrangements and HEGGERSCALE HOUSE, KABER, Mr Eddie Lord APPROVED installation of package treatment plant to replace KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4HZ existing septic tank (amended plans and description).
18/0229 Listed Building Kaber Listed building consent for re-organisation of parking HEGGERSCALE HOUSE, KABER, Thomplord APPROVED arrangements and installation of package treatment KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4HZ Developments Ltd - Mr plant to replace existing septic tank. E Lord
18/0275 Full Application Kirkby Thore Variation of conditions 2 (Plans Compliance) and 3 THORNEYCROFT, KIRKBY THORE, Mr & Mrs N Bousfield APPROVED (External Materials) for the addition of first floor PENRITH, CA10 1UP extension and amendments to materials attached to approval 15/0484.
18/0286 Full Application Kaber Conversion of existing barn and outshot into two HEGGERSCALE HOUSE, KABER, Mr Eddie Lord APPROVED dwellings (amended plans). KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4HZ
18/0287 Listed Building Kaber Listed building consent for conversion of existing HEGGERSCALE HOUSE, KABER, Mr E Lord - Thomplord APPROVED barn and outshot into two dwellings. KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4HZ Developments
18/0301 Full Application Appleby Change of use of shop to residential dwelling. 33 A CHAPEL STREET, APPLEBY- C.A.G. APPROVED IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6QR
18/0308 Listed Building Greystoke Listed building consent for replacement flat felt roof BEECH HOUSE, BERRIER ROAD, Ms G McAlea APPROVED and roof lantern. GREYSTOKE, PENRITH, CA11 0UE
18/0320 Full Application Bandleyside Proposed two storey domestic rear extension. HILLTOP FARM BARN, COLBY, Mr & Mrs M Mounsey APPROVED APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6BD
18/0369 Full Application Kirkby Stephen The conversion of two 2-storey blocks containing 5-11 WESTBROOK FIELDS, KIRKBY Mr D Turnbull APPROVED 4no. flats per block (8 total), into 4no. semi-detached STEPHEN, CA17 4SB 2-storey dwellings.
18/0370 Listed Building Appleby Listed building consent for alterations to internal 33 A CHAPEL STREET, APPLEBY- C.A.G. APPROVED layout to return the building to residential use. IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6QR
18/0409 Full Application Ousby Variation of condition 2 vi (plans compliance) for FIVE OAKS, MELMERBY, PENRITH, Mr Simpson APPROVED proposed house 3 attached to approvals 17/0696 CA10 1HF and 18/0257.
30 August 2018 Page 1 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
18/0435 Full Application Kirkoswald Two storey rear extension. 9 RAVENGHYLL, KIRKOSWALD, Mrs O Weir APPROVED PENRITH, CA10 1DQ
18/0439 Full Application Dacre Agricultural building. MEG BANK FARM, STAINTON, D J & H Brass Farming APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 0EE
18/0445 Reserved Matters Ousby Reserved matters application for access, LAND OPPOSITE IVY HOUSE, Willan Trading Ltd - Mr APPROVED appearance, landscaping, layout, scale attached to OUSBY, PENRITH, CA10 1QA Willan appeal approval APP/H0928/W/17/3183181 (17/0432).
18/0449 Full Application Alston Proposed embankment stabilisation works to prevent LAND TO THE EASTERN BANK OF The Coal Authority - Mr APPROVED metal mine diffuse pollution to the River Nent. RIVER NENT, ADJACENT THE J Bagnall NENTHEAD MINES, NENTHEAD, ALSTON,
18/0452 Full Application Ousby Roof over an existing livestock garth area. TOWN FOOT FARM, MELMERBY, JM & JA Thompson APPROVED PENRITH, CA10 1HB
18/0454 Full Application Great Salkeld Variation of condition 2 (Plans Compliance) SITE AT TOWNHEAD FARM, GREAT Mr Wilkinson APPROVED amendments to design of units 2 and 4 attached to SALKELD, PENRITH, CA11 9NA approval 17/0211.
18/0455 Full Application Penrith Installation of an ANPR and CCTV camera on the MCDONALDS RESTAURANT LTD, Mr Sam Hunn - UK APPROVED restaurant roof, and one CCTV camera on an ULLSWATER ROAD, PENRITH, Parking Control Ltd existing post. CA11 7JH
18/0456 Full Application Alston Re-culverting of a section of Garrigill Burn. LAND ADJACENT TO B6277, The Coal Authority - Mr APPROVED NORTH EAST OF GARRIGILL, J Bagnall ALSTON,
18/0457 Full Application Alston External alterations. ALDENSTON BARN, TOWNHEAD, Mr A McIntyre APPROVED ALSTON, CA9 3SL
18/0459 Full Application Hesket Siting of 3no Four Berth Pods. CALTHWAITE HALL, CALTHWAITE, Mr A Kenvig APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 9QU
18/0460 Full Application Kaber Removal of conditions 4 (holiday let BECKSTONE BARN, NELSON Ms K Mundy APPROVED accommodation), 5 (sole or principal residence), 6 HOUSE, KABER, KIRKBY STEPHEN, (second home), 7 (details of property occupation) CA17 4EF and 8 (length of stay) attached to approval 12/0027.
18/0461 Full Application Warcop Extension to classroom 3. WARCOP C OF E SCHOOL, Mrs S Linsley - The APPROVED WARCOP, APPLEBY-IN- School Governors WESTMORLAND, CA16 6NX
18/0462 Outline Greystoke Outline application for 4no dwellings including JOHNSTONE FARM, JOHNBY, Mr H Howard REFUSED Application conversion and new build with approval sought for PENRITH, CA11 0UU access.
30 August 2018 Page 2 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
18/0474 Cert. of Lawful Culgaith Certificate of lawfulness for proposed first floor HOLM LEA, CULGAITH, PENRITH, Mr D Birkett REFUSED extension. CA10 1QW
18/0477 Full Application Alston Extension and alterations to existing hotel. CUMBERLAND HOTEL, Mr G Harmer APPROVED TOWNFOOT, ALSTON, CA9 3HX
18/0478 Full Application Long Marton Proposed conversion and extension of a domestic BROOMFIELD, KNOCK, APPLEBY- Mr & Mrs S & J APPROVED storage building to create a market led dwelling. IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6DN Charlton & Allison
18/0479 Full Application Langwathby Change of use of nursery to dwelling. NURSERY AND PRE SCHOOL Mr S Peet APPROVED CENTRE, LANGWATHBY HALL, LANGWATHBY, PENRITH, CA10 1LW
18/0481 Full Application Penrith Extension and alterations to existing detached 19 RIMINGTON WAY, PENRITH, Mrs J Mitchell APPROVED dwelling. CA11 8TG
18/0484 Full Application Skelton Removal of conditions 3,4,5,6 and 7 (holiday use) BARN ADJ RUSHGILL HOUSE, Mr P Donoghue APPROVED attached to approval 10/0729. SKELTON WOOD END, SKELTON, PENRITH, CA11 9UB
18/0485 Reserved by Penrith Discharge of condition 4 (archaeological works) ARMSTRONG AND FLEMING, Churchill Retirement APPROVED Cond attached to approval 17/0771. ROPER STREET, PENRITH, CA11 Living 8HT
18/0487 Full Application Catterlen Proposed single storey rear extension. 10 NEWTON MEADOWS, NEWTON Mr & Mrs D & L Marshall APPROVED REIGNY, PENRITH, CA11 0AT
18/0492 Full Application Brough Proposed side extension and minor alterations to MILL HOUSE, BLACK BULL LANE, Mr T Sowerby REFUSED plans & elevations approved under application BROUGH, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 17/0943. 4DU
18/0495 Notice of Intention Skelton Proposed cow tracks. ASKRIGG HALL, SKELTON, Mrs F Elliott APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 9SU
18/0500 Full Application Langwathby Alterations to include addition of first floor French THE COTTAGE, EDENHALL, Mr & Mrs Mawson APPROVED windows to side elevation. PENRITH, CA11 8SX
18/0502 Listed Building Alston Listed Building consent for alterations to front ALSTON CLOCK SHOP, MARKET Mr P Docherty APPROVED elevation including repairs to windows and replacing PLACE, ALSTON, CA9 3QH render.
18/0507 Full Application Skelton Change of use of agricultural land to form residential CROFT HEAD FARM, IVEGILL, Mr D Fearon APPROVED curtilage and re-siting of caravan. CARLISLE, CA4 0QE
18/0510 Full Application Lazonby Two storey rear extension to replace existing 2 SEAT HILL, LAZONBY, PENRITH, Mr & Mrs S Hather APPROVED conservatory. CA10 1BD
30 August 2018 Page 3 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
18/0511 Full Application Penrith Single storey rear extension. 28 WORDSWORTH STREET, Mr & Ms R & J Potts & APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 7QY Orr
18/0512 Full Application Penrith Variation of condition 2 (Plans Compliance) to THE GREEN, CARLETON AVENUE, Mr P McCall - The APPROVED include alternative construction set up as per PENRITH, CA10 2BA Police and Crime application 17/0691. Commissioner for Cumbria
18/0516 Full Application Bandleyside Proposed cattle housing portal building. TERRYS FARM, ORMSIDE, MESSERS G APPROVED APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, SOWERBY CA16 6EJ
18/0517 Full Application Ousby Variation of condition 2 (plans compliance) to include IVY HOUSE, OUSBY, PENRITH, Mr & Mrs Murphy APPROVED re-position of dwelling, addition of plinth to gables, CA10 1QA and front and rear walls made 100mm thicker, attached to approval 17/1087.
18/0518 Full Application Dacre Erection of car port and associated shed. COPSE HOUSE, STAINTON, Mr P Dixon APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 0EB
18/0520 Full Application Alston Proposed dry stone walling, associated repair works, LAND AT GARRIGILL MINE SITE, Mr J Bagnall - The Coal APPROVED installation of leaky dams and localised watercourse GARRIGILL, ALSTON, Authority widening to reduce metal mine pollution.
18/0521 Change of Use Hesket Change of use of agricultural building to BARROW LING, SOUTHWAITE, Mr C Harrison c/o CH APPROVED PD/PN dwellinghouse. CARLISLE, CA4 0ER Group
18/0529 Tree Works (CA) Kirkby Stephen Fell 1 x Scots Pine; Fell 1 x Rowan; Kirkby Stephen MELLBECKS HOUSE, 6 Mrs Maggie Hough APPROVED Conservation Area. MELLBECKS, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4AB
18/0530 Full Application Kirkoswald Extension and alterations to dwelling. ENNERDALE, RENWICK, PENRITH, Mr D R Little APPROVED CA10 1LA
18/0537 Full Application Lazonby Proposed extension and alterations. FAIRFIELD, LAZONBY, PENRITH, Mr & Mrs B Speirs APPROVED CA10 1BX
18/0538 Full Application Ousby Proposed extension and alterations. 1 CURRAH CLOSE, OUSBY, Ms K E Turner APPROVED PENRITH, CA10 1AP
18/0541 Full Application Skelton Conversion of detached double garage to two storey GOODBOURNE CROFT, HUTTON Ms Hardy & Mr APPROVED accommodation for holiday let purposes (revision to ROW, SKELTON, PENRITH, CA11 Simmons permission ref 17/0939). 9TR
18/0542 Outline Skelton Outline application for one dwelling with approval LAND AT TOWNHEAD, LAMONBY, Mr R Brown REFUSED Application sought for access. PENRITH,
18/0545 Full Application Sockbridge & Proposed rear extension. 3 THORPEFIELD, SOCKBRIDGE, Mr & Mrs Robert Woof APPROVED Tirril PENRITH, CA10 2JN
30 August 2018 Page 4 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
18/0554 Full Application Stainmore Erection of single storey conservatory at the front of BLACKMOOR GREEN, NORTH Mr B Jacobs REFUSED the property. STAINMORE, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4EA
18/0558 Tree Works Brough Crown reduce Yew tree by 25%; Reason: overgrown ASH GARTH, CHURCH BROUGH, Mr Stuart Wilkinson APPROVED (TPO) for small area where it sits; Tree Preservation Order KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4EJ No 194, 2018, Ash Garth, Church Brough.
18/0561 Tree Works (CA) Penrith Remove 3 stemmed Conifer tree; Penrith New 5 SANDATH GARDENS, FELL LANE, Mrs R Exton APPROVED Streets Conservation Area. PENRITH, CA11 8BG
18/0562 Householder Skelton Rear extension. THE STEADING, IVEGILL, Mr D Hawley APPROVED PD/PN CARLISLE, CA4 0PJ
18/0563 Full Application Penrith Construction of new dwelling. 1 SALKELD ROAD, PENRITH, CA11 Mr S Murray APPROVED 8QL
18/0567 Householder Appleby Rear extension. 11 WESTMORLAND RISE, Mrs B Batty APPROVED PD/PN APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6SJ
18/0571 Tree Works Penrith T8 Lime tree: Remove epicormic growth, remove CUMBRIA COUNTY COUNCIL, Mr Dan Woods - APPROVED (TPO) trunk growth, crown thin by 15%, crown clean; T9 CUMBRIA FIRE AND RESCUE Nurture Landscapes Ltd Lime: Remove epicormic growth, remove trunk SERVICE HEADQUARTERS, growth, crown raise to create 5m clearance where CARLETON AVENUE, PENRITH, branches overhang the highway and 2.5m clearance CA10 2FA where branches overhang pedestrain areas; T10 Lime: Remove trunk growth; T11 Lime: Remove epicormic growth, crown raise to create 5m clearance where branches overhang the highway and 2.5m clearance where branches overhang pedestrain areas, crown thin by 15%; T13 Lime: Remove trunk growth, crown raise to create 5m clearance where branches overhang the highway and 2.5m clearance where branches overhang pedestrain areas; Reason: Maintain highway/footpath clearance; Tree Preservation Order No 111, 2002, Kemplay Bank / Carleton Hall, Penrith.
18/0574 Tree Works Lazonby T1 Sycamore: Remove new small branches and ROSE BANK FARM HOUSE, Mrs Anne Teale APPROVED (TPO) lower branches as shown on marked photographs A, LAZONBY, PENRITH, CA10 1AJ B and C provided; Reasons: could lead to excessive weight if allowed to mature; light restriction and obstruction to neighbour's garden; Tree Preservation Order No 154, 2013, Rose Bank, Lazonby.
18/0579 Notice of Intention Langwathby Proposed agricultural store. LAND BETWEEN LANGWATHBY Mr D Kersey APPROVED AND CULGAITH OFF THE B6412, LANGWATHBY, PENRITH,
30 August 2018 Page 5 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
18/0590 Tree Works (CA) Great Salkeld 1) Fell old Cherry tree growing into wall; 2) Cherry PLAYING FIELD, GREAT SALKELD, Mrs Lytollis - Clerk to APPROVED tree- Crown raise 2 lower branches to improve shape PENRITH, CA11 9NA Great Salkeld PC and reduce overhanging over village Jubilee shelter and playing field; Great Salkeld Conservation Area.
18/0591 Non-Material Kaber Non material amendment comprising modification to NELSON HOUSE, CARPENTRY Mr J Mowatt APPROVED Amend windows on rear extension and rear elevation WORKSHOP, KABER, KIRKBY attached to approval 18/0277. STEPHEN, CA17 4EF
18/0593 Tree Works (CA) Great Salkeld 1) Reduce Conifers by 3m in height; 2) Remove up MOSS BANK POULTRY, MOSS Mr J Beard APPROVED to 7 mis-shapen Larch overhanging track; 3) Remove BANK, GREAT SALKELD, PENRITH, large mis-shapen Larch; 4) Remove lower branches CA11 9NA to height of wall (1.6m); Great Salkeld Conservation Area.
18/0598 Tree Works (CA) Alston Fell Leylandii tree due to overgrown size; to enhance LINDEN HOUSE, KINGS ARMS Sheila and David APPROVED garden and allow other trees/shrubs to take over; LANE, ALSTON, CA9 3JF Greenwood avoid any potential harm should tree fall accidentially; Alston Conservation Area.
18/0600 Notice of Intention Hesket Proposed agricultural road. PETTERIL SIDE FARM, Mr M Johnston - APPROVED SOUTHWAITE, CARLISLE, CA4 0JJ Messrs M & JA Johnston
18/0602 Tree Works Penrith Beech tree: 1) Prune back the crown by between 3- 113 GRAHAM STREET, PENRITH, Mrs Rebecca Davies APPROVED (TPO) 4m on south / south-east side (overhanging road) CA11 9LE concentrating on branches exposed by loss of recent large stem; 2) Crown raise over road to a height of 5m; 3) Remove any dead / damaged branches, including any with defects which posess a high potential for failure; All pruning work as shown on photographs provided; Reason: Reduce risk to people and property; Tree Preservation Order No 119, 2004, 113 Graham Street, Penrith.
18/0604 Tree Works Penrith T7 Oak: Remove and replace; Tree is showing signs GRASS AREA IN FRONT OF, 18 Mr Alan Robinson APPROVED (TPO) of significant decline including large limb failure, THE PARKLANDS, PENRITH, CA11 Inonotus Dryaedus, Laetiporus and large historical 8TF pruning wounds which may be harbouring large amounts of decay; Reason: Condition of tree; Proximity to road and house is a cause for concern should the tree fail; Tree Preservation Order No 123, 2005, The Parklands, Penrith.
18/0608 Tree Works (CA) Penrith Tree 1: Removal of right trunk (as viewed from SHEARMAN HOUSE, BENSON Mr John Davis APPROVED house) pressing on shed roof; Crown thinning of left ROW, PENRITH, CA11 7YW trunk (30%); Tree 2 Eucalyptus: Height reduction by 30% and reshaping to avoid telephone wire; Penrith Conservation Area.
30 August 2018 Page 6 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision
18/0619 Reserved by Appleby Discharge of conditions 5 (tree protection plan) and 6 THE CRICKET PAVILION, CHAPEL Mr E Brabbins - APPROVED Cond (arboricultural method statement) attached to STREET, APPLEBY-IN- Appleby Cricket Club approval 17/0169. WESTMORLAND, CA16 6QR
18/0637 Notice of Intention Long Marton Proposed agricultural building. PARK HOUSE, LONG MARTON, Morphet APPROVED APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6BY
18/0638 Non-Material Ousby Non Material Amendment comprising of change of LAND OPPOSITE IVY HOUSE, Mr Willan APPROVED Amend window colour to Irish Oak. OUSBY, PENRITH, CA10 1QA
18/0645 Notice of Intention Crosby Roof over existing livestock area. WINTER TARN, NEWBY, PENRITH, Mr M Stephenson APPROVED Ravensworth CA10 3EW
In relation to each application it was considered whether the proposal was appropriate having regard to the Development Plan, the representations which were received including those from consultees and all other material considerations. In cases where the application was approved the proposal was considered to be acceptable in planning terms having regard to the material considerations. In cases where the application was refused the proposal was not considered to be acceptable having regard to the material and relevant considerations. In all cases it was considered whether the application should be approved or refused and what conditions, if any, should be imposed to secure an acceptable form of development.
30 August 2018 Page 7 of 7