September 20, 1983 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 24939 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS ARMS RACE RESOLUTION ty are often more visible than signs of hope. Recent studies reveal that during the We are called to see beyond our own limited period from 1978 to 1982 conventional arms HON. BOB EDGAR horizons, to view the world through the transfer agreements between developing eyes of Christ. countries and the arms suppliers have to OF PENNSYLVANIA When, as Christ's people, we see the taled $120 billion. The non-Communist IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES burden of the arms race on the creation, on world has accounted for $76 billion of this nations, and on all peoples, we are com Tuesday, September 20, 1983 total, the Communist world $44 billion. The pelled to renew our commitment to achiev Soviet Union has sold $33 billion and the •Mr. EDGAR. Mr. Speaker, this past ing disarmament in ways that will guaran United States, $30 billion. While sales and week I received-as did all my congres tee the peace, security, and integrity of all agreements vary from year to year, the sional colleages-a most powerful and peoples. trend has been ever upward. Each super Numerous aspects of the arms race, with compelling resolution on the many di far-reaching implications for our own socie power has its preferred clients, depending mensions of the arms race. It comes ty and the whole world, challenge us in this on its ideological and strategic interest. from the general assembly of the Pres witness. There are factors that disturb the For the merchants the arms trade has the byterian Church U.S.A. The assembly stability of societies, that alter the physical deceptively easy appearance of being "good is the highest governing body of the environments in which we live, that deplete business" because the focus is on the imme church which has a membership of limited economic and natural resources, diate realization of high profits, not on the that heighten the risks and broaden the pa long-range impact of the arms race on socie over 3 million. It is a representative ju ty. Costs e This "bullet" symbol identifies statements or insertions which are not spoken by the Member on the floor. 11-059 0-87-22 (Pt. 18) :"' - 24940 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS September 20, 1983 3. Military· research and development the administration, or even to enjoin the 1. Renews its efforts to seek an end to the moneys reflect diversion of resources from government to adhere to the law on the nuclear arms race by: purposes that could be more constructive grounds that the court cannot make politi a. Reaffirming its endorsement of a bilat and beneficial for the whole human family. cal determinations or rule on the foreign eral verifiable freeze on the testing, produc The consequences are numerous and pro policy powers of the President. tion, and deployment of nuclear weapons, found: In the Third World such a diversion Further, the decision-making exigencies of missiles, and new aircraft designed primari can severely inhibit economic development. strategic nuclear war often foreclose even ly to deliver such weapons; For the United States, caught in economic congressional participation as constitution b. Commending those synods, presbyter stagnation with slow economic growth, the ally required in matters related to war. ies, and congregations that have endorsed economic diversion restricts development in The military-industrial orientation of our the Bilateral Nuclear Weapons Freeze and the consumer and production sectors of our economy, with its heavy social costs, weak encouraging other governing bodies and society. ens the social structures designed to provide congregations to consider prayerfully en Militarily, the technological race stimu for the general welfare. The military "ne dorsing and taking additional supporting ac lates the general arms race because it fos cessities" take priority over civilian need tions; ters a continuing cycle of competitive devel particularly when congresspersons are so c. Calling upon the administration to opment, duplication, and counterdevelop susceptible to pressures from the military resume negotiations on a Comprehensive ment among the different national contest industrial complex. Test Ban Treaty, to take the place of the ants. As a consequence, the pattern further Militarism is difficult to sustain in a nor existing Limited Test Ban Treaty; depersonalizes the decision-making process, mally open and democratic society. There d. Calling upon our government in the ab as technology forces us into an ever-increas fore, it appears that a climate of fear and sence of a Bilateral freeze to initiate a sus ing reliance on the computer and on other distrust is systematically cultivated in order pension of nuclear testing for a specific time automated responses. We are moving toward to justify the economic burden. A democrat period, thereby offering a challenge to the a "launch on warning" stage in the nuclear ic society cannot long survive without full Soviets to a reciprocal suspension, while ne arms race. This dehumanizes people by participation by its constituents, reasonable gotiations on a Comprehensive Test Ban treating them as expendable or as if they patterns of accountability, and essential Treaty are under way; were machines. Both weapons of mass de levels of trust. e. Calling upon the government of the struction and antipersonnel weapons 1900 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 (1) Normal season: Projected shipments: Coal...... 34,163 34,628 33 ,953 32,844 32,213 31 ,634 Iron ore ...... 94,838 97,972 96,304 95,891 95,358 94,704 (2) Proposal 3: Projected shipments: Coal ...... 34,487 39,349 43,513 42,453 41 ,947 41 ,493 Iron ore ...... 96,376 lll,081 123,396 122,942 122,382 121,694 Tons not diverted: Coal...... 324 4,721 9,560 9,609 9,734 9,859 Iron ore ...... 1,538 13,109 27 ,092 27,051 27,024 26,990 1,862 17,830 36,652 36,660 36,758 36,849 m~~~: ~= :~ ~~~ ~:= ~ 5,487 22,324 41 ,434 41,744 42,140 42,562 =: :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::======(3)/(4) (percent) ...... 33.9 79.9 88.5 87.8 87.2 86.6 Source: The projections of commodity shipments were taken directly from Table 2 (p. E-20-21) in Appendix E of the Survey Study. The table indicates that most of the di ducing benefits of the season extension pro Michael Cipriani, the Nation's out verted tonnage is related to capacity con gram. What this analysis has shown is that standing photographer for harness straints at the Soo Locks. Season extension there may be alternatives for resolving the racing. At this time I would like to pay does not significantly affect capacity at the capacity constraint that are more economi Welland as most of the commodities moving cally desirable than winter navigation, and tribute to these two men and share through the Welland are shipped during the that the major economic benefit of winter the highlights of their careers with normal season. 1 navigation stems from stockpiling and my colleagues: With lock replacement, overall benefits at winter rate savings. WILLIAM V. GALLO tributed to season extension would decline. Postscript William (Bill) Gallo was born in A very conservative estimate is that average It should be noted that after the draft Manhattan on December 28, 1922, the annual transportation rate savings would be report of this economic review was pre reduced by 75 percent. For the proposed pared, it was determined that none of the son of Frank and Henrietta Gallo. His plan (year-round navigation on the upper stockpiling benefits could be attributed to father was a newspaperman who died four Great Lakes, and an 11-month season season extension. However, a portion of at the young age of 36 when William on the St. Lawrence Seaway), assuming that these stockpiling benefits would be trans was 11 years old. all other benefits remain unchanged, the ferred to transportation rate savings. 2 This As a youngster Gallo dreamt of fol new benefit-cost calculation would be as fol change will be incorporated in the Survey lowing in his father's footsteps. "As lows: Study final report. The change means that long as I can remember, printer's ink Average annual benefits between 90% and 95% of the benefits of winter navigation are related to capacity was a part of me," he says. He studied Thousands constraints at the Soo Locks. art in high school and after graduat Transportation rate savings...... $65,201 However, nothing in this discussion of al ing he landed a job on the New York Winter rate savings ...... 17 ,694 ternatives is altered by these changes. It Daily News in 1941. He remained there Stockpiling savings...... 59,417 would still be valid to count stockpiling ben ---- for 7 months until he answered Uncle efits when discussing alternatives. The Sam's call, joined the U.S. Marine Total...... 142,312 reason that they are excluded from consid eration when discussing NED benefits and Corps, and went off to war. Average annual costs ...... 101,816 costs is because stockpiling is unnecessary He served with distinction as a Benefit-cost ratio ...... 1.40 when capacity constraints force the diver member of the 4th Marine Division for This calculation is for the incremental av sion of tonnage to alternative modes. How 4 years, seeing action in Roi-Namur erage annual benefits, which excludes bene ever, if a new lock were constructed at the 11-059 ~-23 (Pt. 18) 24972 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS September 20, 1983 policies were largely responsible for the dis cent from natural oil seeps. America's rivers divergent views about what a tract's value astrous 34 percent decline in offshore oil dump more oil into our oceans every year is, and only drilling will ultimately deter production between 1970 and 1980. from roads, driveways and other sources mine who is right about its potental. But The new program is intended to reverse than do tankers, natural seeps and OCS op even the most optimistic companies get this decline and respond to the Outer Conti erations combined. what they pay for-a chance to test their nental Shelf Lands Act, which requires "ex Of approximately 4,000 wells that have exploration theories-and for that they pay peditious and orderly" exploration and de been drilled off the California coast since fair market value in the form of a lease velopment, to reduce dependency on foreign 1894, nearly 3,300 have been in state bonus. sources and ensure stable and adequate sup waters-under leases and permits issued by The coming together of these different plies of reasonably priced energy when the the state. From 1975 to 1982, while some vieWPoints determines the fair market value leases come into production in the next vigorously protested drilling in federal of a tract. If the government determines decade. waters off the California coast, the State of that the high bid assures the receipt of fair This act also requires "an equitable shar California issued 575 drilling permits in market value, it accepts the bid and issues ing of developmental benefits and environ state waters much closer to shore. the lease. If not, the bid is rejected. mental risks among the various regions" of Because fair market value has become The oil companies invest billions of dollars the United States. Prior to Secretary Watt's almost an incantation against the supposed just to get these leases. They cannot afford program, however, nearly 85 percent of the evils of leasing, misinformation and emo to sit on them, so will spend billions more to federal leasing and dr1lling had been in the tional statements concerning it have been evaluate and get them into production. Gulf of Mexico. widely disseminated. It is time to set the These expenditures have already begun to America cannot keep its energy resources record straight. generate jobs for Americans, increase U.S. in limbo until use; long exploration and pro Fair market value means getting a fair or oil and gas supplies and help keep prices duction lead times dictate that, if we want reasonable price, as determined in a market stable. energy tomorrow, we must issue our leases place, assuring the receipt of fair market Lower energy prices and adequate sup today. Nor can we base energy policies on value does not mean assuring the highest plies-far from being undesirable, on the parochial special interests masquerading as possible bonus bid. A leasing policy based on grounds that they depress bonus bids moral principles. maximising bonuses would cast the U.S. in should be a primary goal of any leasing pro Clearly the most vocal opposition comes the role of a classic energy monopolist, ma gram. Indeed, it is hard to understand why from the groups that have a long tradition nipulating supplies and prices at the ex critics of the program talk as if there were of opposing even the timid leasing programs pense of the consumer. It would stand in something wrong with leasing to keep prices of previous administrations. Ironically, vocal diametric opposition to the goals of the and supplies at a reasonable level. criticism is also coming from regions which OCS Lands Act. Among America's greatest attributes are have · the most consumers, use the most The bonus paid to get a lease reflects the its sense of equity and fair play, combined energy, and have complained the loudest experts' estimate of the value of the rights with a collective wisdom that, sooner or about high energy prices, past shortages and opportunities conveyed by the lease, to later, cuts through the fears, misconcep and high unemployment. They seem to be explore, develop, produce and sell whatever tions and rhetoric. Given the facts, Ameri under the false impression that it is a choice resources might be present in a particular cans generally make the right choices. Let between offshore development and other tract. It does not represent fair market us hope that the offshore leasing program uses of the ocean. value of the resources. will not prove an exception. From the day a lease is issued to the day Annual rents of $3 per acre must also be The leasing program deserves the support the first oil or gas is pipelined to consumers paid, until there is production on the lease. of all Americans-in the Congress, media, can take up to 10 years. It is essential, then, The government keeps these bonus and courts and general public. It must not fall that the federal government begin to pro rental payments, even if no oil or gas is victim to parochial interests, unsupported mote an orderly inventory of these re found. If resources are found and produced emotional charges, and the rhetoric of poli sources. Of course the law and sound public
<<