<<

9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^`eLgg\i8ljki`X >i\\e\e\i^p#^i\\eafYj K_`jglYc`ZXk`felj\j

ÈKfejÈ`ek_`jglYc`ZXk`feXi\d\ki`Zkfej#]fiZfem\ij`fekfLJ kfej#dlck`gcpYpk_\]XZkfi(%(

(bN 4*#+()%(+9KL&_ (bN_4*#+()%(+9KL

F%F%4FY\ijk\ii\`Z_ F%{% #k_\]\[\iXcjkXk\f]Lgg\i8ljki`X

8lk_fijf]k_`jglYc`ZXk`fe :_i`jk`Xe\<^^\i :_i`jk`e\{_c`e^\i 9\kk`eX8l`e^\i 9i`^`kk\9iXe[jk€kk\i EX[aXI`Z_c\i >\i_Xi[;\cc

:fgpi`^_kXe[]lik_\i`e]fidXk`fe F%F%i\\e\e\i^p#^i\\eafYj K_\i\^`fef]Lgg\i8ljki`X g%'+ :c`dXk\ I\e\nXYc\\e\i^p`eLgg\i8ljki`X

9`fdXjjdXib\k[\m\cfgd\ek g%'- :lck`mXk`e^k_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^dXib\k 9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^kf[Xp

=fi\jki\jfliZ\j#dXeX^\d\ek Xe[fne\ij_`g g%'/ 9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^1XÈZXiYfee\lkiXcÈ]l\c

9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^k\Z_efcf^`\j g%(' G\cc\k_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj Nff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj Df[\ieÔi\nff[_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj <]ÔZ`\eZpXe[\d`jj`fej =`i\jX]\kp

9`fdXjj]l\cjXe[jlggcpZ_X`ej g% (/ Nff[g\cc\kj Nff[Z_`gj =l\cj\c\Zk`fe$g\cc\kjfinff[Z_`gj6 =`i\nff[

Jk`Zbj#ZXiifkjXe[kXdYfli`e\j ]fiY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^ g%)+ DX`egfc`Zp`ejkild\ekj JlZZ\jj]XZkfij]fiY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^gif^iXdj Xe[XZk`fegcXej Fm\iZfd`e^k_\Z_`Zb\efik_\\^^gifYc\d

9lj`e\jjdf[\cj]fifg\iXk`e^ Y`fdXjjgcXekj g%*' 9`fdXjj_\XkZfekiXZk`e^ 9`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfibj

9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^`e[ljkip g%*) K_\ÈFbf\e\i^`\$:cljk\iÈ

Gifa\Zk\oXdgc\j g%*,

 9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^`eLgg\i8ljki`X K_\i\^`fef]Lgg\i8ljki`X

9`fdXjj`jXjljkX`eXYc\Xe[ZXiYfe$e\lkiXc]l\ck_Xk Lgg\i8ljki`X`jfe\f]8ljki`XËje`e\]\[\iXcjkXk\jXe[ `jn\cc$jl`k\[]fi_\Xk`e^_fd\j#Ylj`e\jj\jXe[glYc`Z `jcfZXk\[`ek_\efik_\iegXikf]k_\Zflekip#Yfi[\i`e^ Yl`c[`e^j%K_\i\_XjY\\ej`^e`ÔZXek`eefmXk`fe`ek_\ >\idXepXe[k_\:q\Z_I\glYc`Z%K_\i\^`fe`j_`^_cp Ô\c[f]Y`fdXjjk\Z_efcf^p[li`e^k_\gXjkknf `e[ljki`Xc`q\[Xe[XZZflekj]fidfi\k_Xe),f] [\ZX[\j#Xe[df[\iejpjk\djXi\]lccpXlkfdXk`Zn`k_ eXk`feXc\ogfikj%Lgg\i8ljki`XËjgi`dXip`e[ljki`Xc lckiX$cfn\d`jj`fej%K_\lj\f]Y`fdXjj]fi_\Xk`e^ j\Zkfij`eZcl[\dXZ_`e\ip#Xlkfdfk`m\`e[ljki`\j#d\kXc \ejli\j\e\i^p`e[\g\e[\eZ\#jlggfikjk_\]fi\jk gif[lZk`fe#nff[gifZ\jj`e^#`e]fidXk`fe& gif[lZkj\ZfefdpXe[`j\em`ifed\ekXccp]i`\e[cp% Zfddle`ZXk`fek\Z_efcf^`\j#Xe[i\e\nXYc\\e\i^p%

Df[\ieY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^Xggc`ZXk`fej`eZcl[\1 Lgg\i8ljki`X_Xj\eafp\[jk\X[p\Zfefd`Zgifjg\i`kp# Xe[_Xj_X[k_\cfn\jkle\dgcfpd\ekiXk\f]Xcc8ljki`Xe ›XlkfdXk`Znff[g\cc\k_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj#dfjkcp`e jkXk\j[li`e^k_\gXjk('p\Xij XkZfej`jk\ekcpY\cfn j`e^c\$]Xd`cp_fd\jn`k_Ylcb[\c`m\ip , %Lgg\i8ljki`XËj>ifjj;fd\jk`ZGif[lZk >;G `j ›XlkfdXk`Znff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj]fiZfdd\iZ`Xc +,Y`cc`fe

Linz Lgg\i8ljki`XÆb\p]XZkj › :flekip1 8ljki`X › GfglcXk`fe1 (%+d`cc`fe j`d`cXikfE\n?Xdgj_`i\ › Jli]XZ\Xi\X1 ((#0/'bd)s+#-**d`)   j`d`cXikf:fee\Zk`Zlk › :Xg`kXcZ`kp1 C`eq gfglcXk`fe1(0'#''' #j`klXk\[fe    k_\YXebjf]k_\;XelY\

 I\e\nXYc\\e\i^p`eLgg\i8ljki`X$Xe\Zfefd`Z\e^`e\

J`eZ\k_\d`[$0'j#k_\^fm\ied\ekf]Lgg\i8ljki`X _Xjgi`fi`k`q\[\e\i^p\]ÔZ`\eZpXe[i\e\nXYc\\e\i^p% I\e\nXYc\\e\i^pjfliZ\j`eLgg\i8ljki`X I\e\nXYc\\e\i^pZlii\ekcpjlggc`\jdfi\k_Xe**f] k_\kfkXcgi`dXip\e\i^p[\dXe[`ek_\jkXk\#f]n_`Z_ › J_Xi\f]i\e\nXYc\\e\i^pjfliZ\j1 (,Zfd\j]ifd_p[ifgfn\i#(,]ifdnff[Y`fdXjj **%+f]kfkXcgi`dXip\e\i^p[\dXe[ Xe[XYflk+]ifdjfcXiXe[fk_\ii\e\nXYc\\e\i^p jfliZ\j% › J_Xi\f]i\e\nXYc\_\Xk`e^1 +,%-f]kfkXc_\Xk`e^[\dXe[

K_\`dgi\jj`m\j_Xi\f]i\e\nXYc\j`ek_\\e\i^pd`o › J_Xi\f]i\e\nXYc\\c\Zki`Z`kp1./%+ nXjXZ_`\m\[k_ifl^_Zfdgi\_\ej`m\i\^`feXc\e\i^p XZk`fegcXejk_XkcX`[k_\]fle[Xk`fe]fidfi\k_XeX › 8eelXc`em\jkd\ek`ee\n`ejkXccXk`fej1 [\ZX[\f]jk\X[pgif^i\jj%9l`c[`e^lgfek_\jlZZ\jj )('d`cc`fe;G %

8ck_fl^_k_\e\knfibd\dY\iji\gi\j\ekk_\]lcc jg\Zkildf]jljkX`eXYc\\e\i^pgif[lZkjXe[j\im`Z\j# Lgg\i8ljki`XeZfdgXe`\jXi\c\X[\ij`ek_\Ô\c[jf] XlkfdXk`ZY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^#jfcXik_\idXc\e\i^p#Xe[ _`^_$\]ÔZ`\eZpYl`c[`e^k\Z_efcf^`\j%@ei\Z\ekp\Xij# ZfdgXe`\j`ek_\j\Ô\c[j_Xm\\og\i`\eZ\[jkife^ ^ifnk_Xe[_Xm\X[[\[dfi\k_Xe,''e\n`e$jkXk\afYj%

_p[ifgfn\i(+%- ZfXc X^i`Zlckli\* (0%- Zfdd\iZ`Xc +) j\im`Z\j\Zkfi/ f`c i\e\nXYc\j **%+ Y`fdXjj(+%-1 ),%, ›Ôi\nff[+%/ ›nff[Z_`gjg\cc\kj/%. kiXejgfikXk`fe i\j`[\ek`Xc ›kiXejgfikY`f]l\cj(%( ), )) eXkliXc^Xj )(%, fk_\ii\e\nXYc\j+%)

 9`fdXjjdXib\k[\m\cfgd\ek :lck`mXk`e^k_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^dXib\k

9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^_XjXcfe^kiX[`k`fe`eLgg\i8ljki`X# K_\Ylj`e\jjdf[\ck_Xk\d\i^\[nXjZffg\iXk`m\j Ylkk_\`ekif[lZk`fef]`eefmXk`m\k\Z_efcf^`\jXe[ f]]Xid\ijXe[]fi\jkfne\ijk_Xk[\m\cfg#Yl`c[Xe[ Ylj`e\jjdf[\cj`ei\Z\ekp\Xij_XjZi\Xk\[XYffd`e^ fg\iXk\jdXcc$jZXc\Y`fdXjj[`jki`Zk\e\i^pjpjk\dj% dXib\k%J\m\iXc`dgfikXek[i`m\ij_Xm\Zfeki`Ylk\[kf K_\Zffg\iXk`m\j^\e\iXk\Xe[jlggcp_\XkkfcfZXc k_\[\m\cfgd\ekf]k_\df[\ieY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^ ^fm\ied\ekYl`c[`e^j#jZ_ffcj#Ylj`e\jj\jXe[_flj`e^% `e[ljkip`eLgg\i8ljki`X% Kf[Xp#*''jlZ_Y`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfibjXi\ `efg\iXk`fe% K_\Ôijk[i`m\inXj]finXi[$k_`eb`e^]Xid\ijXe[ ]fi\jkfne\ijn_fn\i\cffb`e^]fie\njfliZ\jf] 8j\Zfe[[i`m\inXjZi\Xk`m\\eki\gi\e\lij`e i\m\el\Xe[dXib\kj]fi]fi\jkipi\j`[l\j`ek_\\Xicp Lgg\i8ljki`X$jfd\f]k_\dn`k_]Xid`e^Xe[ (0/'j%FecpXYflk,'f]k_\dXk\i`Xc_Xim\jk\[]ifd ]fi\jkipYXZb^ifle[j$n_fjfl^_kkfd`e`d`q\k_\ ki\\jZXeY\jfc[kfjXnd`ccjXe[fk_\iZfdd\iZ`Xc dXelXccXYfii\hl`i\[kfgi\gXi\]l\cjXe[fg\iXk\ lj\ij%8ggifo`dXk\cp('$)' \%^%e\\[c\jXe[jdXcc _\Xk`e^jpjk\dj%K_\m`j`fenXjkfZfdg\k\n`k_k_\ YiXeZ_\j e\\[jkfY\c\]k`e]fi\jkj]fi\em`ifed\ekXc ZfjkXe[Zfem\e`\eZ\f]f`c_\Xk`e^#n_`Z_[fd`eXk\[ i\Xjfej%K_`jjk`ccc\Xm\jXj`^e`ÔZXeklelj\[i\jfliZ\ k_\_\Xk`e^dXib\k`ek_\(0/'j%K_\j\\eki\gi\e\lij ]fin_`Z_XdXib\knXje\\[\[% [\j`^e\[]lccp$XlkfdXk\[#_`^_$\]ÔZ`\eZp#Xe[ lj\i$]i`\e[cpY`fdXjjjpjk\djXe[jlYj\hl\ekcp g`fe\\i\[Xe\n]fidf]_\Xk`e^%8e`dgfikXek d`c\jkfe\nXjk_\`ekif[lZk`fef]XlkfdXk`Znff[g\cc\k _\Xk`e^jpjk\dj`e(00-%:fejld\iji\jgfe[\[m\ip gfj`k`m\cpkfk_\e\nk\Z_efcf^p#n_`Z_^Xm\k_\dXib\k Xjkife^Yffjk%Kf[Xp#jfd\f]k_\j\`eefmXk`m\Lgg\i 8ljki`XeYf`c\iZfdgXe`\jXi\^cfYXcdXib\kc\X[\ij%  8k_`i[[i`m\i_XjY\\ejkXk\gfc`Zp#n_`Z__Xj gifm`[\[jkXYc\jlggfikkfk_\dXib\k]fidfi\k_Xe ),p\Xij%K_\^fm\ied\ekf]Lgg\i8ljki`X_XjY\\e XYc\kfXZk`m\cpjlggfikk_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^dXib\k Y\ZXlj\jkXk\j_Xm\ali`j[`Zk`fefm\i_\Xk`e^XZZfi[`e^ kfk_\8ljki`XeZfejk`klk`fe#n_\i\Xjk_\]\[\iXc ^fm\ied\ek_Xjali`j[`Zk`fefm\i\c\Zki`Z`kp%Gfc`Zp jlggfik]fiY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^`eLgg\i8ljki`X`jkXi^\k\[ kfjg\Z`ÔZdXib\kj\^d\ekjXe[Zfej`jkjf]ÔeXeZ`Xc `eZ\ek`m\j#c\^`jcXk`feXe[gifdfk`feXcXZk`m`k`\j%

8b\p`eZ\ek`m\`j`em\jkd\ek^iXekj#n_`Z_Xi\ XmX`cXYc\Yfk_]figliZ_Xj`e^Y`fdXjjYf`c\ijXe[]fi Zfee\Zk`e^Yl`c[`e^jkfY`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^gcXekj% 8^i`ZlckliXcgif^iXdj_Xm\Xcjfjlggfik\[`em\jkd\ekj `e[`jki`Zkk_\idXc\e\i^pgcXekjXe[`e_\Xk`e^^i`[j% Jki`Zk\d`jj`fejXe[\]ÔZ`\eZpjkXe[Xi[j$n_`Z_ _Xm\Y\\egif^i\jj`m\cpk`^_k\e\[YpjkXk\^fm\ied\ek Æ_Xm\jlggfik\[k_\[\m\cfgd\ekf]Zlkk`e^$\[^\ gif[lZkj%8nXi\e\jjZXdgX`^ejXe[`e[\g\e[\ek k\Z_e`ZXcX[m`Z\#f]]\i\[Ypk_\F%F%

 9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^kf[Xp

:lii\ekcp#X[mXeZ\[Y`fdXjjk\Z_efcf^`\jgifm`[\ XYflk(,f]k_\kfkXcgi`dXip\e\i^pjlggcp`e 9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^`eLgg\i8ljki`X Lgg\i8ljki`XXe[*(f]k_\idXc\e\i^p%I\e\nXYc\j DXib\k[\m\cfgd\ek jlggcpXggifo`dXk\cp**f]kfkXcgi`dXip\e\i^p`e )''' ZXgXZ`kp`eDN Lgg\i8ljki`XXe[+,f]k_\idXc\e\i^p%

K_\i\Xi\+'#'''XlkfdXk`ZY`fdXjjYf`c\ij`efg\iXk`fe (,'' `ei\j`[\ek`Xc#Zfdd\iZ`Xc#Xe[glYc`Zj\ZkfiYl`c[`e^j% F]k_\j\#_Xc]Xi\]l\cc\[n`k_g\cc\kj#Xe[_Xc]n`k_nff[ (''' Z_`gj%K_\p_Xm\XkfkXc`ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`kpf](#,-'DN Xe[gif[lZ\)#,''#'''DN_\XZ_p\Xi%K_`j\hlXk\j ,'' kfXeXeelXc]l\cZfejldgk`fef]/,'#'''kfejf]jfc`[

Y`fdXjj `eZcl[`e^jXnd`cci\j`[l\j #Xe[Xe\d`jj`fe K8I>

) Æ/- XYflk,''#'''kfejf]Y`fdXjjXi\lj\[`ecXi^\Y`fdXjj  3(''bN  (''bNÆ(DN  5(DN :?GgcXekj ]fi\c\Zki`Z`kpXe[_\Xkgif[lZk`fe %

@e)''0#-'f]k_\e\ncp`ejkXcc\[XlkfdXk`ZY`fdXjj Yf`c\iZXgXZ`kpnXjY\cfn(''bN#*'nXjY\kn\\e (''bN$(DNXe[('nXjcXi^\ik_Xe(DN%@ekfkXc# (.'DNn\i\`ejkXcc\[%

K_\jkXk\^fm\ied\ek_XjX[fgk\[XkXi^\kkfi\XZ_ (''jgXZ\_\Xk`e^Xe[\c\Zki`Z`kp]ifdi\e\nXYc\ \e\i^pYp)'*'%@e$jkXk\Y`fdXjjn`ccgcXpXb\pifc\`e XZ_`\m`e^k_`jkXi^\k#`eZfdY`eXk`fen`k_j`^e`ÔZXekcp jki\e^k_\e\[\e\i^p\]ÔZ`\eZpgif^iXdj%

Kpg`ZXcY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^Xggc`ZXk`fej`eLgg\i8ljki`X

XlkfdXk`Zg\cc\k df[\ieÔi\nff[ XlkfdXk`Znff[Z_`g [`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^n`k_ ZfdY`e\[Y`fdXjj_\Xk k\Z_efcf^p _\Xk`e^ Yf`c\ij Yf`c\ij nff[Z_`gYf`c\ij Xe[gfn\ijkXk`fej

g\cc\kj Ôi\nff[ nff[Z_`gj nff[Z_`gj n_fc\ki\\j

]l\c

5(DN # kpg`ZXc`ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`kp ,Æ(,bN )'Æ+'bN ,'Æ(,'bN (''bNÆ*DN \c 5('DNk_ glYc`ZXe[ [fd\jk`Z#glYc`ZXe[ [fd\jk`Z#glYc`ZXe[ lj\ij#Zljkfd\ij j`e^c\$]Xd`cp_fd\j ]XidYl`c[`e^j Zfdd\iZ`XcYl`c[`e^j Zfdd\iZ`XcYl`c[`e^j Zfdd\iZ`XcYl`c[`e^j Ylcb[\c`m\ipYpX gXikcpYpk_\Zffg\iX$ ljlXccp_Xim\jk\[ f]k\eYpcfZXc]Xid\ij$ ]Xid\ijjXnd`ccj ]l\cjlggcp cXi^\eldY\if]]l\c k`m\d\dY\ij#gXikcp ]ifdfne]fi\jk ]fi\jkfne\ij fk_\iZ_Xee\cj [`jki`Ylkfij ]ifdjXnd`ccj

JfliZ\1:_i`jk`Xe\<^^\i  =fi\jki\jfliZ\j#dXeX^\d\ekXe[fne\ij_`g

8ljki`X`jfe\f]k_\dfjk\og\i`\eZ\[Zfleki`\j`ek_\ 9p

:fdgi\_\ej`m\]fi\jkgiXZk`k`fe\ikiX`e`e^_XjXcfe^ ?Xc]f]k_\jkXk\Êj]fi\jkjXi\fne\[YpjdXcc$jZXc\ kiX[`k`fe`e8ljki`X%Jg\Z`Xc`q\[jljkX`eXYc\]fi\jkip fne\ij c\jjk_Xe,_\ZkXi\js()XZi\j #XYflk)'Xi\ jZ_ffcjgifm`[\lg$kf$[Xk\befn$_fnXe[jb`ccj%8e fne\[YpcXi^\i]fi\jkfne\ij#Xe[XYflk*'Xi\ `dgfikXek]XZkfi`ejljkX`eXYc\]fi\jkip`j]Xd`cp$ fne\[Ypk_\È8ljki`XeEXk`feXc=fi\jkjÈ%K_\ fne\ij_`g1efkfecp`j]fi\jkipbefn$_fngXjj\[fe mfcld\f]jkfZb`j^ifn`e^1f]k_\((d`cc`fejfc`[d*s n`k_`e]Xd`c`\jYlkk_\i\`jXcjfk_\jkife^dfk`mXk`fe *//d`cc`fejfc`[]k*f]e\n^ifnk_`e)''/#XYflk kfb\\g]fi\jkj`ekXZkXe[gif[lZk`m\]fi]lkli\ -d`cc`fejfc`[d*s)()d`cc`fejfc`[]k*n\i\_Xim\jk\[% ^\e\iXk`fej% 8e`dgfikXekj\^d\ekf]k_\]fi\jkfne\ijXi\]Xid\ij n_ffnegXiZ\cjf]]fi\jk`eX[[`k`fekfk_\`i]XidcXe[%

 9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^1XÈZXiYfee\lkiXcÈ]l\c

8jXki\\^ifnj#`kXYjfiYj:F)]ifdk_\X`iXe[jkfi\j

`k[li`e^`kjc`]\k`d\%K_`j:F)`ji\c\Xj\[`ek_\jXd\ hlXek`kpXkk_\\e[f]k_\c`]\k`d\#`e[\g\e[\ekf] n_\k_\ik_\k`dY\i`jYlie\[fik_\ki\\[\Zfdgfj\j eXkliXccp`ek_\]fi\jk%

:F) :F)

;<:8P ?<8K@E>

K_\lj\f]Y`fdXjj]fi\e\i^pgif[lZk`fe`jk_\i\]fi\ gXikf]XZcfj\[:F)ZpZc\n`k_efX[[`k`feXc:F) \d`jj`fej%K_`j_XjY\\ei\Zf^e`q\[Ypk_\\e\i^p Xe[\em`ifed\ekXcgfc`Z`\jf]k_\

G\iZ\ekX^\f]jli]XZ\Xi\X Zfm\i\[Yp]fi\jkj Lgg\i8ljki`X+( >\idXep*' LJ8*) 9i`k`j_:fcldY`X -* Jn\[\e-. DX`e\ 0'

 9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^k\Z_efcf^`\j

K_`jZ_Xgk\i]fZlj\jfejdXcckfd`[$jZXc\Y`fdXjj _\Xk`e^jpjk\dj#iXe^`e^]ifdXe`ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`kpf] :\ekiXc_\Xk`e^jpjk\d X]\nbNkfX]\n_le[i\[bN%K_\j\jpjk\djXi\k_\ dfjkZfddfejpjk\dj`ejkXcc\[`eLgg\i8ljki`X% JfcXiZfcc\Zkfi 9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj`eLgg\i8ljki`Xkpg`ZXccp gif[lZ\_fknXk\i]fiZ\ekiXc_p[ife`Z_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj% JlZ_Xjpjk\dljlXccpZfej`jkjf]k_\]fccfn`e^ Zfdgfe\ekj1

›Y`fdXjjYf`c\i f]k\e`ek_\YXj\d\ek#YlkZXeXcjfY\ gcXZ\[`eXZfekX`e\iflkj`[\f]k_\Yl`c[`e^  ›]l\cjkfiX^\ ›Z_`de\p jkX`ec\jjfiZ\iXd`Z G\cc\kjkfiX^\ ›_p[ife`Z[`jki`Ylk`fejpjk\d]fik_\_fknXk\i 9f`c\i gif[lZ\[Ypk_\Yf`c\i ›_p[ife`Z_\Xk[`jZ_Xi^\jpjk\dj iX[`XkfijfiÕffi& nXcc_\Xk`e^ ›XZ\ekiXcZfekifc[\m`Z\n`k_Xeflk[ffik\dg\iXkli\ j\ejfi =\Xkli\jf]df[\ieY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj`eZcl[\1 @eY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj#k_\]l\c`jkiXejgfik\[ ]ifdjkfiX^\kfk_\ZfdYljk`feZ_XdY\i#n_\i\`k`j ›Zfem\e`\ek#]lccpXlkfdXk`Zfg\iXk`fe XlkfdXk`Z `^e`k\[Xe[ZfdYljk\[%Kf`dgifm\k_\_\XkkiXej]\i `^e`k`feXe[j_lk[fne#]l\cjlggcp#Xj_i\dfmXc#_\Xk Xe[jlggcpjl]ÔZ`\ekX`i]fifgk`dXcZfdYljk`fe#X]Xe \oZ_Xe^\iZc\Xe`e^  `j`ejkXcc\[%K_\Õl\^Xj]ifdk_\ZfdYljk`fegifZ\jj ›_`^_]l\c\]ÔZ`\eZp /'$0' gXjj\jk_ifl^_X_\Xk\oZ_Xe^\iXe[kiXej]\ij`kj ›lckiX$cfn\d`jj`fej \e\i^pkfk_\nXk\i%8gldgZ`iZlcXk\jk_\_\Xk\[nXk\i ›m\ip_`^_fg\iXk`feXe[Ôi\jX]\kpjkXe[Xi[j k_ifl^_k_\_p[ife`Z_\Xk[`jki`Ylk`fejpjk\d%K_\ ›cfn]l\cZfjkj Yf`c\i`j_`^_cp`ejlcXk\[Xe[Zfm\i\[n`k_Xd\kXcjb`e ›k_\gfk\ek`XckfZfdY`e\n`k_jfcXik_\idXcjpjk\dj# `efi[\ikfi\[lZ\_\Xkcfjj\jkfk_\Yf`c\iiffd% lj`e^XeXZZldlcXkfikXeb jkfiX^\kXeb

 Df[\ieY`fdXjjjpjk\djlk`c`q\Xknf$jkX^\ ZfdYljk`fegifZ\jj`efi[\ikfZfdYljk]l\cXj Nff[Z_`gYf`c\iYf`c\i Zfdgc\k\cpXjgfjj`Yc\#k_\i\YpXZ_`\m`e^_`^_ \]ÔZ`\eZ`\jXe[cfn\d`jj`fej%@ek_\gi`dXip ZfdYljk`feqfe\n_`Z_`jcfZXk\[fek_\^iXk\# [ip`e^Xe[jfc`[ZfdYljk`fekXb\gcXZ\%@ek_\ j\Zfe[XipZfdYljk`feqfe\#k_\mfcXk`c\^Xj\jXi\ Ylie\[n`k_X`ik_Xk`j`ekif[lZ\[`eXZfekifcc\[ dXee\i%Fk_\iX[mXeZ\[]\Xkli\j`eZcl[\Xe\c\Zkife`Z ZfdYljk`feZfekifc#XZfekifcc\[]l\c]\\[`ekfk_\ ZfdYljk`feZ_XdY\i#Xjfg_`jk`ZXk\[Ylie\in`k_ \c\Zkife`Z`^e`k`fe#Xe[XlkfdXk`ZXj_i\dfmXcXe[ ZfdYljk`feZ_XdY\iZc\Xe`e^%

K_\Zfdgc\k\ZfdYljk`fef]k_\]l\c`eXefgk`d`q\[# knf$jkX^\ZfdYljk`fe[\j`^ei\jlckj`em\ipcfn JfliZ\1>lekXdXk`Z \d`jj`fejf]gXik`ZlcXk\dXkk\iY\ZXlj\f]k_\XYj\eZ\ f]leYlie\[_p[ifZXiYfej`ek_\Õl\^Xj%K_\ gXik`ZlcXk\dXkk\i [ljk ]ifdk_\fgk`d`q\[jpjk\d Nff[g\cc\kYf`c\i Xi\gi`dXi`cp`efi^Xe`Z#n_`c\\d`jj`fej]ifdcfn\i$ k\Z_efcf^pjkfm\jXe[Yf`c\ijXi\dfjkcpleYlie\[ fi^Xe`Zj%

K_\i\Xi\k_i\\dX`ekpg\jf]Ylie\ij#k_XkmXip XZZfi[`e^kfk_\fi`\ekXk`fef]k_\`i]l\c]\\[j1

›le[\i]\\[Ylie\ij le[\i]\\[jkfb\ifile[\i]\\[ i\kfikYlie\ij 1k_\]l\c`j]\[`ekfk_\Yfkkfdf]k_\ ZfdYljk`feZ_XdY\ifiZfdYljk`fei\kfik%K_\j\ Ylie\ijXi\Y\jkjl`k\[]fi]l\cjn`k_cfnXj_Zfek\ek nff[g\cc\kj#nff[Z_`gj %  ›_fi`qfekXc]\\[Ylie\ij1k_\ZfdYljk`feZ_XdY\i`j \`k_\iÔkk\[n`k_X^iXk\fiXYlie\igcXk\%K_\]l\c JfliZ\1{bf]\e `j`ekif[lZ\[_fi`qfekXccp`ekfk_\ZfdYljk`fe Z_XdY\i%;li`e^ZfdYljk`fe#k_\]l\c`jdfm\[fi glj_\[_fi`qfekXccp]ifdk_\]\\[`e^qfe\kfk_\ =`i\nff[Yf`c\i Ylie\igcXk\fik_\^iXk\%?fi`qfekXc]\\[Ylie\ijZXe Ylienff[Z_`gjXe[g\cc\kj%

›kfg]\\[Ylie\ij1[\m\cfg\[]fig\cc\kZfdYljk`fe `ejdXcc$jZXc\le`kj%K_\g\cc\kj]Xcck_ifl^_Xj_X]k fekfXÔi\Y\[Zfej`jk`e^f]\`k_\iX^iXk\fiXi\kfik% K_\j\gXiXk`fef]k_\]\\[`e^jpjk\dXe[k_\Ôi\Y\[ \ejli\jk_\\]]\Zk`m\gifk\Zk`feX^X`ejkYlie$YXZb `ekfk_\]l\cjkfiX^\%K_\Xj_`ji\dfm\[dXelXccpfi d\Z_Xe`ZXccpYpX[ldg`e^^iXk\%K_`j]\\[`e^jpjk\d Xccfnjm\ipXZZliXk\]\\[`e^f]g\cc\kjXZZfi[`e^kf k_\Zlii\ek_\Xk[\dXe[j%

JfliZ\1=ic`e^  8ZZldlcXkfikXeb _\XkjkfiX^\

@edXepZXj\j#Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\djXi\ZfdY`e\[ n`k_XZZldlcXkfikXebj%K_\pXi\i\Zfdd\e[\[]fi 8ZZldlcXkfikXeb nff[Z_`gXe[nff[g\cc\kYf`c\ij \jg\Z`Xccp`]Xcjf lj\[]fi_fknXk\i_\Xk`e^`ejldd\i Xe[i\hl`i\[ ]fidf[\ieÔi\nff[Yf`c\ij%K_\pXccfnk_\Yf`c\ikf fg\iXk\Xkefd`eXccfX[Xe[kfXmf`[]i\hl\ek`^e`k`fe Xe[j_lk$[fne%

8eXZZldlcXkfikXeb`jX_`^_cp`ejlcXk\[jk\\ckXeb% ?fknXk\i]ifdk_\Yf`c\i`j`ekif[lZ\[`ekfk_\ XZZldlcXkfikXebXkk_\kfg%K_\[\j`^ef]k_\`ec\k \ejli\jk_XkkliYlc\eZ\`jcfnXe[k_Xkk_\k\dg\iXkli\ jkiXk`ÔZXk`fe`jefk[`jkliY\[%K_\j`q`e^f]k_\ XZZldlcXkfikXeb`j`eÕl\eZ\[Yp]XZkfijjlZ_Xjk_\ efd`eXcZXgXZ`kpXe[j`q\f]k_\Yf`c\i#k_\kpg\f]]l\c =ic`e^ lj\[#Xe[k_\jgXZ\XmX`cXYc\%

 Dlck`$Yf`c\iZXjZX[\jpjk\d @ek\^iXk`fef]jfcXik_\idXcjpjk\dj jkX^\[Yf`c\ijpjk\d 9`fdXjjYf`c\ij`eZfdY`eXk`fen`k_jfcXik_\idXc 8jd\ek`fe\[Y\]fi\#Yf`c\ijnfibdfjk\]ÔZ`\ekcpXk jpjk\dj]fi[fd\jk`Z_fknXk\igif[lZk`fe`ek_\ efd`eXcgfn\i%?fn\m\i#[l\kfj\XjfeXck\dg\iXkli\ nXid\idfek_jXi\Xefgk`dXc_\Xk`e^jfclk`feXe[ [`]]\i\eZ\j#_\Xk[\dXe[[`]]\ijk_ifl^_flkk_\p\Xi1 m\ipgfglcXin`k_Yl`c[`e^fne\ij`eLgg\i8ljki`X% `k`jcfn\jk`ejldd\in_\efecp[fd\jk`Z_fknXk\i `ji\hl`i\[#Xe[_`^_\jk`en`ek\in_\ejgXZ\_\Xk`e^ 8jfcXiZfcc\Zkfijpjk\dXccfnjk_\Y`fdXjjYf`c\ikf `ji\hl`i\[%

@ejlZ_ZXj\j#`k`jY\kk\ikf`ejkXccZXjZX[\jpjk\dj k_XkZfej`jkf]knffidfi\Y`fdXjjYf`c\ij%Jpjk\d fg\iXk`fe`jj`dgc\1N_\e_\Xk`e^fi[fd\jk`Z_fk nXk\i`ji\hl`i\[#fe\Yf`c\in`ccjkXiklgXe[fg\iXk\ Xk`kjdfjk\]ÔZ`\ekc\m\c%N_\ek_\jpjk\di\hl`i\j jfcXiZfcc\Zkfi X[[`k`feXcZXgXZ`kp#X[[`k`feXcYf`c\ijXi\Yifl^_kfec`e\ XkdXo`dld\]ÔZ`\eZplek`cXccYf`c\ij`ek_\ZXjZX[\ _fknXk\i jpjk\dXi\fg\iXk`e^%K_Xk\ejli\jk_Xkk_\jpjk\d XcnXpjfg\iXk\j`e`kjdfjk\]ÔZ`\ekdf[\%

XZZl$ 8eX[[`k`feXcX[mXekX^\`jk_XkZXjZX[\jpjk\dj iX[`Xkfi dlcXkfi gifm`[\`eZi\Xj\[fg\iXk`feXcjX]\kpXe[ZXe kXeb XZZfddf[Xk\Yl`c[`e^\ok\ej`fejdfi\Zfjk$\]]\Zk`m\cp% Y`fdXjj :XjZX[\jpjk\djZXeXcjf`eZcl[\\o`jk`e^]fjj`c$ Yf`c\i ]l\cYf`c\ijn_`Z_ZXeY\lj\[]fiYXZb$lgfig\Xb Zfc[nXk\i [\dXe[%

 G\cc\k_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj

G\cc\k_\Xk`e^jpjk\djXi\kpg`ZXccpj`k\[`ejg\Z`Xc K_\i\Xi\knfkpg\jf]]lccpXlkfdXk`Z]l\c[\c`m\ip Yf`c\iiffdj`ek_\YXj\d\ekfi`e[\[`ZXk\[ jpjk\djk_XkkiXej]\ig\cc\kj]ifdjkfiX^\`ekfk_\Yf`c\i1 ZfekX`e\ijflkj`[\k_\_flj\%J\m\iXckfejf]cffj\ g\cc\kjXi\[\c`m\i\[`eYlcbYpXgi\jjli`q\[kXebkilZb ›Xl^\ijZi\njpjk\dj1jl`kXYc\`]Yf`c\iXe[jkfiX^\ Xe[kiXej]\ii\[`ekfjkfiX^\k_ifl^_XÔcc\ig`g\%8 iffdj&kXebjXi\cfZXk\[e\okkf\XZ_fk_\i% j\Zfe[g`g\`jlj\[kf\okiXZkX`i]ifdk_\jkfiX^\ K_`jZXeY\k_\dfjkZfjk$\]]\Zk`m\jfclk`fe% kfXmf`[fm\igi\jjli\[li`e^k_\Ôcc`e^gifZ\jj% ›mXZlldjlZk`fejpjk\dj1XÕ\o`Yc\jfclk`fe`]k_\jkfiX^\ K_\g\cc\kjkfiX^\j_flc[Y\cfZXk\[efkdfi\k_Xe Xe[Yf`c\iiffdXi\#]fi\oXdgc\#j\gXiXk\[YpXZfii`[fi *'d\k\ijs0/]\\k]ifdn_\i\k_\[\c`m\ipkilZbn`cc fiYpXefk_\iiffd dXo%[`jkXeZ\)'d\k\ijs--]\\k Y\fg\iXk`e^ \%^%k_\[i`m\nXpfiifX[ %K_\nXccjXe[ Z\`c`e^jf]k_\jkfi\iffdXe[Yf`c\iiffddljkY\ Ôi\$giff]`eZfdgc`XeZ\n`k_jkXk\i\^lcXk`fej j\\gX^\ MXZlldjlZk`fejpjk\d (. %K_\g\cc\kjkfiX^\dljkXcjfY\[ipY\ZXlj\nXk\i n`ccZXlj\k_\g\cc\kjkfYi\Xblg%=fi]lik_\i `e]fidXk`fefeg\cc\kcf^`jk`Zj#j\\gX^\(0% =l\cjkfiX^\Xe[]l\c]\\[`e^jpjk\dj 8l^\ijZi\njpjk\d K_\]fccfn`e^jpjk\djXi\lj\[`eLgg\i8ljki`X1

›jkfiX^\iffdje\ok&Zcfj\kfk_\Yf`c\i `ej`[\k_\Yl`c[`e^ ›k\ok`c\fijk\\ckXebj `ej`[\fiflkj`[\k_\Yl`c[`e^ ›jkfiX^\`ek\^iXk\[`ekf[\[`ZXk\[_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ZfekX`e\ij flkj`[\k_\Yl`c[`e^ JfliZ\1{bf]\e ›le[\i^ifle[kXebj flkj`[\k_\Yl`c[`e^

Fm\im`\njkfiX^\jpjk\dj

I\Zfdd\e[\[ ;\c`m\ip Kpg\f]jkfiX^\ GcXZ\d\ek I\hl`i\d\ekj jkfiX^\j`q\j Zfej`[\iXk`fej JkfiX^\iffd Dfjk]i\hl\ek @e[ffi NXccj1Xkc\Xjk()ZdYi`Zbjfi('Zd '#0d*s*)]k*jkfiX^\ KnfnXccYi\Xbk_ifl^_j jkfiX^\jpjk\d1X JkfiX^\`eYXj\d\ekiffd ZfeZi\k\ iffd&bN_\Xk`e^cfX[ n`k_(),Æ(,'dds [ipiffd#ljlXccp`e e\okkffiZcfj\kfk_\ =`i\jX]\kp1NXccj#Z\`c`e^Xe[Õffi `eZcl[`e^_\X[jgXZ\ ,Æ-`eZ_\j[`Xd\k\i k_\YXj\d\ek Yf`c\iiffd#\jg\Z`Xccp dljkY\Ôi\$i\j`jkXek#k_\Õffi_Xj Xi\e\Z\jjXip ]fi jl`kXYc\]fie\n kfY\`eÕXddXYc\ [\c`m\i`e^g\cc\kjXe[]fi ZfejkilZk`fefin_\e Df`jkli\gifk\Zk`fe1k_\iffd_Xj \okiXZk`e^X`iXe[[ljk Zfem\ik`e^]ifdf`c_\Xk`e^ kfY\[ipXccp\Xiifle[ gfjk$[\c`m\ip K\ok`c\fijk\\ckXeb KXebdX[\]ifd @e[ffififlk[ffi NXccj1efjg\Z`XcZfejkilZk`fe *''Æ+''b^s--'Æ//' =l\cZXeY\[\c`m\i\[ Xek`jkXk`ZdXk\i`Xcj :XeY\gcXZ\[`eXiffd`e i\hl`i\d\ekj cYkXebZXgXZ`kp&bN [`i\Zkcp`ekfk_\kXebfi fi^XcmXe`q\[jk\\c# k_\YXj\d\ekfiflkj`[\k_\ =`i\jX]\kp1Lgkf(,d*s,*']k*f] _\Xk`e^cfX[#XmX`cXYc\ Yp`ea\Zk`feefqqc\j% n_`Z_Xi\[ljkXe[ Yl`c[`e^%?ld`[nXccjXi\ g\cc\kjZXeY\jkfi\[`ekXebj `ejhlXi\fii\ZkXe^l$

 Nff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj Df[\ieÔi\nff[_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj

Nff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\djXi\`ejkXcc\[gi`dXi`cp`e =`i\nff[_\Xk`e^jpjk\djXi\jk`ccm\ipgfglcXi`e efe$i\j`[\ek`XcYl`c[`e^j#YlkXi\XcjfgfglcXi]fi_fd\ k_\Zflekipj`[\`eLgg\i8ljki`X%K_\i\_Xm\Y\\e _\Xk`e^`eiliXcXi\Xj%@eLgg\i8ljki`X#nff[Z_`gjXi\ j`^e`ÔZXekk\Z_efcf^`ZXcX[mXeZ\j`eÔi\nff[_\Xk`e^ Xcjflj\[`eY`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj ]lik_\i jpjk\dj[li`e^k_\gXjkj\m\iXcp\Xij#`eZcl[`e^1 [\kX`cjj\\gX^\*( % ›knf$jkX^\ZfdYljk`fen`k_XlkfdXk`Z`^e`k`feXe[]Xe Nff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\djXi\f]k\ej`k\[`e ›`dgifm\[Zfekifcjpjk\dj YXj\d\ekj#`e]i\\$jkXe[`e^_\Xk`e^ZfekX`e\ij k_Xk ›i\[lZ\[_\Xkcfjj\j ZfdY`e\Yf`c\iXe[jkfiX^\ fi$]ficXi^\ijpjk\dj$`e k_\`ifnej\gXiXk\Yl`c[`e^j%=l\c`jkpg`ZXccp[\c`m\i\[ Lj\iZfem\e`\eZ\ZXeY\\e_XeZ\[YpcXi^\]l\c YpkiXZkfijfikilZbj%=fi]lik_\i`e]fidXk`fefenff[ _fgg\ijXe[XeXggifgi`Xk\cpj`q\[XZZldlcXkfikXeb% Z_`gcf^`jk`Zj#j\\gX^\)(%

=l\cjkfiX^\Xe[]l\c]\\[`e^jpjk\dj

Nff[Z_`gjZXeY\jkfi\[`ej`[\k_\Yl`c[`e^`eXiffd Zcfj\kfk_\Yf`c\iiffdfi`ejkfiX^\]XZ`c`k`\jflkj`[\ k_\Yl`c[`e^ \%^%j`cfj#YXiej %K_\nff[Z_`gjXi\k_\e kiXejgfik\[kfk_\Yf`c\i#f]k\elj`e^XeXl^\ijZi\n ]\\[jpjk\d%JkfiX^\ZfekX`e\ijXi\kpg`ZXccpÔcc\[]ifd XYfm\%

K_\j`q`e^f]k_\jkfiX^\[\g\e[jfek_\jg\Z`ÔZ j`klXk`fe _\Xk`e^cfX[#]l\c[\c`m\ip`ek\imXcj# XmX`cXYc\jgXZ\#\kZ% %@eZXj\f]\o`jk`e^jkfiX^\ ]XZ`c`k`\j#`k`jf]k\eZ_\Xg\ikfX[Xgkk_\[\c`m\ip `ek\imXcjkfk_\XmX`cXYc\jkfiX^\mfcld\%=fie\n

Yf`c\i_\Xk`e^cfX[ .,bN *''bN

XeelXc\e\i^p (/.#,''bN_ .,'#'''bN_ [\dXe[

XeelXc]l\c[\dXe[ )'*d*s.#).']k* /((d*s)/#-+']k*

=fi1)#'''_]lcccfX[#/,Yf`c\i\]ÔZ`\eZp F%F%

K_\jkXk\_Xjgif^i\jj`m\cpk`^_k\e\[\d`jj`fe C\^Xci\hl`i\d\ekj]fijdXccjZXc\Y`fdXjj jkXe[Xi[j#n_`Z__Xjki`^^\i\[k_\[\m\cfgd\ekf] _\Xk`e^jpjk\dj`eLgg\i8ljki`X lckiX$cfn\d`jj`feYf`c\ij%K_\]fccfn`e^kXYc\jj_fn k_\`dgifm\d\ekj`eY`fdXjjYf`c\ik\Z_efcf^`\jlj`e^ 9`fdXjjYf`c\ij_Xm\kfd\\k\d`jj`fejXe[\]ÔZ`\eZp Ôi\nff[#nff[Z_`gjXe[nff[g\cc\kj%K_\j\[XkX jkXe[Xi[j`efi[\ikfY\jfc[Zfdd\iZ`Xccp%9f`c\ij_Xm\ [\i`m\]ifddfi\k_Xe(#'''Yf`c\iZ\ik`ÔZXk`fek\jkj kfgXjjXZ\ik`ÔZXk`fek\jkXe[_Xm\kfZXiipcXY\cj [fe\Ypk_\8ljki`Xe=\[\iXc@ejk`klk\f]8^i`ZlckliXc [`jgcXp`e^Yf`c\i[XkX%

=cl\^Xjcfjj\j]fiXlkfdXk`ZY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj ZXeefk\oZ\\[(0%

<]ÔZ`\eZp]XZkfif]k\jk\[Y`fdXjjYf`c\ij

('' nff[g\cc\k nff[g\cc\kZ\ekiXc jkfm\j _\Xk`e^ 0'

〕 :F ,''! ),'! /'  〔 .' EFo (,'&(''!! (,'&(''!!

\]ÔZ`\eZp -' ,' MF:!!! *' *'&)'!! +' ;ljk ,'&),!! +'&)'!! (00* (0/) (0/, (00- (000 (0// )''( (00' (0/' )''+ ! k_\c`d`kZXeY\\oZ\\[\[lgkf,'`egXikcfX[fg\iXk`fe *'f]k_\_\XkZXgXZ`kp !! \d`jj`fec`d`kj]fi\j\\e]ifd(AXelXip)'(,fenXi[j :XiYfedfefo`[\\d`jj`fejf]k\jk\[Y`fdXjjYf`c\ij !!!mfcXk`c\fi^Xe`ZZXiYfe

),#''' D`e`dld\]ÔZ`\eZpc\m\cj :FG )'#''' 〕 * `ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`kp \]ÔZ`\eZp  (,#''' d^&Ed 〔 ('#'''

:F ('bN /'

,#''' 5('Æ)''bN /'Æ0' ' (00* (0/) (0/, (00- (000 (0// )''( (00' (0/' 5)''bN 0' )''+

=A$9CKN`\j\cYli^29`f\e\i^p)')'"  =`i\jX]\kp

=`i\jX]\kp`jXb\pi\hl`i\d\ek]fiXep_\Xk`e^jpjk\d% =fiY`fdXjjYf`c\ij#k_\i\Xi\jkXk\jX]\kpi\hl`i\d\ekj k_XkXggcpkfYfk_k_\Yl`c[`e^ Yf`c\iiffdXe[iffdj `en_`Z_]l\cjkfiX^\jpjk\djXi\cfZXk\[ Xe[k_\ Yf`c\ik\Z_efcf^p%K_\j\i\hl`i\d\ekjXi\jki`Zk\i]fi cXi^\ijpjk\dj%

8ccYf`c\ijdljk_Xm\jX]\kp]\Xkli\jkfgi\m\ekYlie$YXZb% K_\dfjkZfddfeXi\k\jk\[Ôi\[Xdg\ij ifkXipmXcm\j %

K_\nXccj#Z\`c`e^jXe[Õffijf]k_\jkfiX^\iffdXe[k_\ Yf`c\iiffddljkY\Ôi\$i\j`jkXek Ôi\i\j`jkXeZ\ZcXjj =0'$Ôi\i\j`jkXeZ\iXk`e^]fi0'd`elk\j %K_`jc\m\cZXe Y\XkkX`e\[#]fi\oXdgc\#n`k_X(,Zds-`eZ_Yi`ZbnXcc fiX('Zds+`eZ_ZfeZi\k\nXcc%K_\[ffikfk_\ jkfiX^\iffddljkY\XÔi\$jkfg[ffi K*'$Ôi\ i\j`jkXeZ\iXk`e^]fi*'d`elk\j %

=`i\jX]\kpi\hl`i\d\ekj

=0' Yf`c\iiffd =0' g\cc\kjkfiX^\ =0'

K*' K*'

Yf`c\i 99;

=0'

nff[Z_`gjkfiX^\ Yf`c\iiffd =0'

9f`c\i

K:J D=< 99;

=0'1 Ôi\i\j`jkXeZ\ZcXjj0' K:J1 k\dg\iXkli\Zfekifc[\m`Z\`ek_\]l\c K*'1 Ôi\$jkfg[ffi jkfiX^\ 99;1 Ylie$YXZbjX]\kp[\m`Z\ D=<1 dXelXccp$fg\iXk\[Ôi\\ok`e^l`j_\i  9`fdXjj]l\cjXe[jlggcpZ_X`ej

K_`jZ_Xgk\i[\jZi`Y\jk_\dX`eY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^]l\cj lj\[`eLgg\i8ljki`X1nff[g\cc\kj#nff[Z_`gjXe[ Kpg`ZXcZfjkj]fiXg\cc\k_fd\ Ôi\nff[%

Nff[g\cc\kj G\cc\kjkXe[Xi[`qXk`fe

Nff[g\cc\kjXi\XZc\XeXe[:F)$e\lkiXc]l\ck_Xk`j K_\\XicpjkXe[Xi[`qXk`fef]nff[g\cc\kjnXjXb\p gif[lZ\[gi`dXi`cp]ifdjXn[ljkXe[nff[j_Xm`e^j% ]XZkfi]fik_\`ijlZZ\jj`ek_\_\Xk`e^dXib\k%8ljki`X K_\g\cc\kjXi\Zfdgi\jj\[le[\i_`^_gi\jjli\lj`e^ nXjk_\ÔijkZflekipkfX[fgkXg\cc\kjkXe[Xi[n_`Z_ ef^cl\fifk_\iXik`ÔZ`XcX[[`k`m\j%K_\pXi\Zpc`e[i`ZXc _\cg\[dXib\k[\m\cfgd\ekki\d\e[fljcp%=ifdk_\ `ej_Xg\Xe[ljlXccp-$('dds'%)$'%+`eZ_\j`e flkj\k#fecpg\cc\kjf]XZc\Xicp[\Ôe\[hlXc`kpn\i\ [`Xd\k\iXe[('$*'dds'%+$(%)`eZ_\j`ec\e^k_% Zfdd\iZ`XccpXmX`cXYc\#Xccfn`e^Yf`c\idXel]XZkli\ij kf[\m\cfgm\ipcfn$\d`jj`feXggc`XeZ\j%8cjf G\cc\kjXi\X_`^_cpjkXe[Xi[`q\[Xe[\e\i^p$[\ej\]l\c jkXe[Xi[j]finff[g\cc\kcf^`jk`ZjXe[jkfiX^\n\i\j\k% k_Xk_Xjb\pX[mXekX^\jfm\ifk_\i]l\ckpg\j1g\cc\kj Fk_\iZfleki`\j`e\idXep ]fccfn\[ ZXeY\Zfjk$\]]\Zk`m\cpkiXejgfik\[#k_\pZXeY\ 8ljki`XËjc\X[n`k_k_\`ifnejkXe[Xi[`qXk`fejZ_\d\j# i\X[`cplk`c`q\[`eXlkfdXk`ZYf`c\ijpjk\dj#Xe[k_\p Xe[

 Nff[Z_`gj Nff[Z_`gjkXe[Xi[`qXk`fejXe[ZcXjj`ÔZXk`fej

Nff[Z_`gj_Xm\Y\\eYlie\[kfgif[lZ\_\Xk]fi ;l\kf`kjn`[\mXi`\kpf]jfliZ\j#nff[Z_`ghlXc`kpZXe [\ZX[\j%?fn\m\i#df[\ie\hl`gd\ekXccfnj]fi]lccp mXipn`[\cp%@dgfikXekhlXc`kpZ_XiXZk\i`jk`ZjXi\Ylcb

XlkfdXk`Zfg\iXk`feXe[cfn$\d`jj`fe#:F)$e\lkiXc [\ej`kp n\`^_k #j`q\Xe[nXk\iZfek\ek% ZfdYljk`fe%:fdgXi\[kfnff[g\cc\kj#nff[Z_`gj i\hl`i\dfi\jkfiX^\ZXgXZ`kp k_\mfcld\`jXYflk ;\g\e[`e^fek_\j`q\Xe[k_\k\Z_e`ZXc]\Xkli\j#nff[ ]fli$k`d\jk_Xkf]nff[g\cc\kj Xe[jfd\n_Xkdfi\ Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\djZXeY\fg\iXk\[n`k_nff[Z_`gj fg\iXk`fejXe[dX`ek\eXeZ\\]]fikj%8df[\ie f][`]]\i\ekj`q\jXe[df`jkli\Zfek\ekj%@e^\e\iXc# ,'bNnff[Z_`gjpjk\d#]fi\oXdgc\#i\hl`i\jXYflk _`^_\idf`jkli\Zfek\eki\jlckj`ecfn\iYf`c\i )'d`elk\jf]fg\iXk`fejXe[dX`ek\eXeZ\nfibg\i \]ÔZ`\eZpXe[_`^_\i\d`jj`fej% n\\b#n_\i\XjX,''bNjpjk\di\hl`i\jXYflk +,d`elk\j%Nff[Z_`gj_Xm\Xj`^e`ÔZXekZfjk K_\XY`c`kpf]nff[Z_`gjkfY\jkfi\[`j[\k\id`e\[Yp X[mXekX^\fm\inff[g\cc\kj#_fn\m\i% j\m\iXc]XZkfij1Z_`gj`q\#n\`^_k ljlXccp\ogi\jj\[`e Ylcb[\ej`kp b^&cffj\d* Xe[df`jkli\Zfek\ek% Nff[Z_`gjXi\gi`dXi`cplj\[`ecXi^\iYl`c[`e^j Df`jkli\Zfek\ekXk_Xim\jk`jXYflk,'% n_\i\jgXZ\i\hl`i\d\ekjXi\efkXc`d`k`e^]XZkfi%=fi _fd\fne\ijk_Xk_Xm\\okiXjgXZ\Xe[Xi\n`cc`e^kf K_\gi`Z\f]hlXc`kpnff[Z_`gj`j[\k\id`e\[Ypk_\n\`^_k `em\jkdfi\k`d\`efg\iXk`fejXe[dX`ek\eXeZ\# Xe[k_\df`jkli\Zfek\ek%K_\gi`Z\]fi]fi\jknff[ _fn\m\i#nff[Z_`gjZXeY\Xm\ip\Zfefd`Z_\Xk`e^ Z_`gj N)'$*, iXe^\j]ifd.'$(''

@]XcfZXcjlggcpZ_X`eZXeY\\jkXYc`j_\[#nff[Z_`gj I\hl`i\d\ekj]finff[Z_`gjXZZfi[`e^kf8ljki`Xe ZXeZi\Xk\e\n`eZfd\]ficfZXc]fi\jkfne\ij%@eLgg\i jkXe[Xi[`qXk`fe {EFIDD.(** 8ljki`X#_le[i\[jf]cfZXc]Xid\ijXe[]fi\jkfne\ij _Xm\Y\Zfd\È_\Xk\eki\gi\e\lijÈYp[\m\cfg`e^cfZXc _\Xk`e^mXcl\ +bN_&b^]fi),nXk\iZfek\ek [`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfibjn_`Z_lj\]fi\jki\j`[l\j]ifd [\ej`kp )''Æ),'b^&d*s++'Æ,,'cY&]k* k_\`inff[jXe[XcjfYp\jkXYc`j_`e^ÈY`fdXjj*' j`q\3*Zds(%)`eZ_ j`q\ @eLgg\i8ljki`X#dfi\k_Xe('#'''XlkfdXk`Z >,' j`q\3,Zds)`eZ_ nff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\djn\i\`ejkXcc\[`ek_\cXjk gi`dXip\e\i^p[\dXe[ (%/Æ) ('p\Xij% Df`jkli\Zfek\ekZcXjj\j 8ljki`XejkXe[Xi[D.(** N)' N*' N*, N+' N,' X`i$[i`\[ df`jk _Xim\jk$]i\j_ 3)' )'Æ*' *'Æ*, *,Æ+' 5+'

› ]lccpXlkfdXk`ZZ\ekiXc_\Xk`e^jpjk\d › `ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`kp1(,'bN › gcXZ\[`ek_\YXj\d\ek › _p[ife`Z_\Xk[`jki`Ylk`fejpjk\d › nff[Z_`g[\c`m\ipYpcfZXc]Xid\ij#*$+k`d\j&p\Xi › XeelXc]l\c[\dXe[1,'kfejnff[Z_`gj › jkfiX^\ZXgXZ`kp1+o+d\k\ijs(*o(*]\\k Zfem\ik\[ ]fid\if`cjkfiX^\iffd › XlkfdXk`Znff[Z_`gjlggcp]ifdjkfiX^\kfk_\Yf`c\i › Xj_i\dfmXc1\m\ip)n\\bj  K_\nff[Z_`gjlggcpZ_X`e

@eLgg\i8ljki`X#nff[Z_`gjXi\\`k_\ijfliZ\[]ifd jXnd`ccj#lj`e^k_\nff[k_Xk`jefkjl`kXYc\]ficldY\i# Kpg\f]Z_`gg\i 8m\iX^\Z_`gg`e^ZfjkjXe[flkglk fi]ifd]fi\jkfne\ij#lj`e^Xgfik`fef]k_\i\j`[l\j :_`gg\ifeX +Æ/%&cffj\d* 0Æ(,cffj\d*&_ ]ifd_Xim\jk`e^fg\iXk`fej Xj`^e`ÔZXekXdflekf]k_\ kiXZkfikiX`c\in`k_ ,Æ('LJ&cffj\]k* *)'Æ,*'cffj\]k*&_  YiXeZ_\je\\[jkfi\dX`e`ek_\]fi\jkkfi\gc\e`j_k_\ dXelXc]\\[`e^ jf`c % _`^_gfn\iZ_`g$ )Æ-%&cffj\d* *'Æ-'cffj\d*&_ g\in`k_ZiXe\ )%,Æ.%,LJ&cffj\]k* (#'''Æ)#/''cffj\]k*&_  @eLgg\i8ljki`X#eld\ifljj\im`Z\gifm`[\ij ljlXccp ]Xid\ij#]fi\jkfne\ijfiZffg\iXk`m\j f]]\iZ_`gg`e^ j\im`Z\jlj`e^dfY`c\Z_`gg\ij%@edXepZXj\j#k_\jXd\ gifm`[\ijXcjff]]\i]fi\jkk_`ee`e^j\im`Z\jn_`Z_ `dgifm\ki\\^ifnk_Xe[_\cgkfgi\m\ekY\\kc\ K_\Zfjkj]finff[Z_`gg\ijiXe^\]ifd)''#'''

 =l\cj\c\Zk`fe$g\cc\kjfinff[Z_`gj6

9fk_nff[g\cc\kjXe[nff[Z_`gj_Xm\X[mXekX^\jXe[ [`jX[mXekX^\jn_\eY\`e^lj\[XjX]l\c]fiX_\Xk`e^ jpjk\d%K_\]fccfn`e^kXYc\gifm`[\j^l`[XeZ\fen_\e fe\]l\c`jgi\]\iXYc\kfk_\fk_\i%

@eLgg\i8ljki`X#_fd\fne\ijljlXccpgi\]\ig\cc\k _\Xk`e^jpjk\dj#n_`c\fne\ijf]jpjk\djcXi^\ik_Xe )''bNljlXccplj\nff[Z_`gj%=fijpjk\dj`q\j Y\kn\\ek_\j\knfXggc`ZXk`fej#jgXZ\XmX`cXY`c`kp# [\c`m\ip`ek\imXcj#jkX]]XmX`cXY`c`kpXe[k_\gfjj`Y`c`kp f]XcfZXcjlggc`\iXi\f]k\e[\Z`j`m\]XZkfij`e [\k\id`e`e^]l\cZ_f`Z\%

:i`k\i`X Nff[g\cc\kj6 Nff[Z_`gj6 `ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`kp]l\c jdXcc\i_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj 3(''bN #cfn\i]l\c[\dXe[ cXi^\i_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj 5(''bN #_`^_\i]l\c[\dXe[ [\dXe[

jgXZ\i\hl`i\d\ek c`d`k\[XmX`cXY`c`kpf]jkfiX^\ZXgXZ`kp Xdgc\jkfiX^\ZXgXZ`kp

]i\hl\ek[\c`m\ip`jXj\ej`k`m\`jjl\ [\c`m\ip ]i\hl\ek]l\c[\c`m\ip`jefkXgifYc\d i\j`[\ekXcXi\X#\kZ%

jkX]] efjkX]]]fifg\iXk`fejXe[dX`ek\eXeZ\ jkX]]]fifg\iXk`fejXe[dX`ek\eXeZ\

]l\c _`^_cpjkXe[Xi[`q\[]l\cn`k_jkXYc\hlXc`kp`j[\j`i\[ [`]]\i\ekc\m\cjf]hlXc`kpXi\XZZ\gkXYc\

`ek\i\jk`eÈYlp`e^cfZXcÈÆXmX`cXY`c`kpf]cfZXc]l\c ]l\cjlggcp `ek\i\jk`enfib`e^n`k_Zfdd\iZ`Xc]l\cjlggc`\ij jlggc`\ij#cfZXc\Zfefd`ZY\e\]`k]ifdlj`e^nff[Z_`gj

nff[i\jfliZ\fne\ij_`g \e[$lj\i[f\jefkfnenff[i\jfliZ\j \e[$lj\ifnejnff[i\jfliZ\j \%^%]fi\jkcXe[j

ZXeY\XeXkkiXZk`m\fgk`fe`]cfe^$k\idjlggcpZfe$ ]l\cZfjkj `e^\e\iXc#Z_\Xg\ik_Xeg\cc\kj kiXZkjn`k_]XmfiXYc\Zfe[`k`fejZXeY\e\^fk`Xk\[

C`]\$ZpZc\Zfjkjgc`k

G\cc\k_fd\_\Xk`e^jpjk\d^p Nff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\d (,'bNg^p

dX`ek\eXeZ\ dX`ek\eXeZ\ (, (.

`em\jkd\ekZfjkj ]l\cZfjkj +. `em\jkd\ekZfjkj *' ]l\cZfjkj ,, *-

ZXcZlcXk\[]fi)'p\Xij#-XeelXcÔeXeZ`e^Zfjkj#\oZcl[`e^`em\jkd\ek^iXek  =`i\nff[

;\jg`k\k_\Yffd`e^dXib\kj]fi]lccpXlkfdXk`Z Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj#Ôi\nff[_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj kpg\f]]`i\nff[ nXk\iZfek\ek _\Xk`e^mXcl\ jk`ccgcXpXe`dgfikXekifc\`eLgg\i8ljki`X%J`eZ\)''(# _Xim\jknff[ ,'Æ-' )%'bN_&b^4.%)DA&b^ dfi\k_Xe/#,''Ôi\nff[_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj_Xm\Y\\e È]i\j_È `ejkXcc\[#n`k_XkfkXcZXgXZ`kpf]XYflk)),#'''bN%K_\ jkfi\[fm\ife\ cXi^\dXafi`kpf]k_\jpjk\djXi\lj\[]fi_fd\ ),Æ*, *%+bN_&b^4()%)DA&b^ _\Xk`e^#n`k_`ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`k`\j^\e\iXccpY\cfn*'bN% jldd\i jkfi\[fm\idfi\ (,Æ), +%'bN_&b^4(+%+DA&b^ @edfjkZXj\j#k_\_fd\fne\ij\`k_\ifne]fi\jk k_Xefe\p\Xi cXe[k_\dj\cm\jfi_Xm\XZZ\jjkf`kk_ifl^_]Xd`cp d\dY\ijfie\`^_Yfij%K_`j\ejli\jm\ipj_fik]l\c kiXejgfikXk`feiflk\j%

=`i\nff[Yliejdfjk\]ÔZ`\ekcpXe[Zc\Xecpn_\e 9f`c\ijk_Xkn`ccY\lj\[kfYlieÔi\nff[j_flc[Y\ ZfdYljk`fe`j_fkXe[]Xjk%8_\XkjkfiX^\jpjk\d gifg\icp[`d\ej`fe\[Xe[j_flc[efklj\Xepfk_\i]l\c Xccfnjk_\Yf`c\ikffg\iXk\Xkfgk`dXc\]ÔZ`\eZpn_`c\ jfliZ\j%K_\Yf`c\ij_flc[Y\ileXkefd`eXccfX[Xj jkfi`e^k_\\oZ\jj_\Xk`eXnXk\ikXeb]ficXk\ilj\% f]k\eXjgfjj`Yc\Xe[_\Xk\oZ_Xe^\ijj_flc[Y\ Zc\Xe\[i\^lcXicp% =`i\nff[j_flc[_Xm\cfnnXk\iZfek\ekXe[efkY\ [\ZXp\[fidfc[p%K_\df`jkli\Zfek\ekf]k_\Ôi\nff[ j_flc[efkY\fm\i)'%

 Jk`Zbj#ZXiifkjXe[kXdYfli`e\j]fiY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^

9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^gcXpjXe`dgfikXekifc\`ek_\ i\e\nXYc\\e\i^pd`of]Lgg\i8ljki`X%K_\jkXk\_Xj jlZZ\jj]lccp[i`m\e`kjkiXej`k`fekfnXi[XZc\Xe\e\i^p \Zfefdpk_ifl^_k_\lj\f]Zfdgi\_\ej`m\gcXejj`eZ\ (00+%

KfXZ_`\m\`kjXdY`k`flj^fXcj#Lgg\i8ljki`X_Xj [\m\cfg\[gfc`ZpgXZbX^\j]fi[`]]\i\ekkXi^\k^iflgj% K_\j\gXZbX^\jZfej`jkf]ÔeXeZ`Xc`eZ\ek`m\j dfjkcp `em\jkd\ek^iXekj #c\^`jcXk`fekfdXe[Xk\`ejkXccXk`fe fYc`^Xk`fej#Xe[gifdfk`feXcXZk`m`k`\j \e\i^pX[m`Z\# flki\XZ_ZXdgX`^ej#kiX`e`e^ %K_\[`]]\i\ekkpg\jf] jlggfikd\Z_Xe`jdjZXeY\k_fl^_kf]#i\jg\Zk`m\cp# XjZXiifkj#jk`Zbj#Xe[kXdYfli`e\j j\\ZXikffe %Dfjk JfliZ\1F%F%

8b\pjlZZ\jj]XZkfi]fiY`fdXjjgfc`Zp[\m\cfgd\ek`j K_\F%F%

Èjk`ZbÈ ÈZXiifkÈ ÈkXdYfli`e\È C\^Xcd\Xjli\j =`eXeZ`Xcd\Xjli\j @e]fidXk`fekiX`e`e^ ›

Gfc`ZpGXZbX^\j jk`dlcXk\[\dXe[

jlggfikjlggcp

JfliZ\1:_i`jk`Xe\<^^\i  DX`egfc`Zp`ejkild\ekj

=`eXeZ`Xcjlggfik ;i`m`e^k_\dXib\kk_ifl^_jkXe[Xi[j

Fe\`dgfikXek`eZ\ek`m\]fiY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^`jX 8ljki`XeY`fdXjjYf`c\ik\Z_efcf^p`jXk\okYffb i\j`[\ek`Xc^iXekgif^iXdk_Xk_XjY\\e`egcXZ\j`eZ\ \oXdgc\f]_fnk\Z_efcf^`ZXcX[mXeZ\j i\jlck`e^`e k_\d`[$/'j%Lgg\i8ljki`XXcjfgifm`[\j`eZ\ek`m\j]fi j`^e`ÔZXek\em`ifed\ekXcXe[\Zfefd`ZY\e\Ôkj ZXe XYifX[iXe^\f]Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^`ejkXccXk`fejY\pfe[ Y\[i`m\eYpi\^lcXkfipi\hl`i\d\ekjXe[`eZ\ek`m\j% aljkk_fj\]fii\j`[\ek`Xcjpjk\dj#jlZ_XjY`fdXjj K_\^fm\ied\ek`eZi\Xj`e^cpk`^_k\e\[\]ÔZ`\eZpXe[ [`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^%EfÔeXeZ`Xcjlggfik`j^`m\e]fik_\ \d`jj`fejjkXe[Xi[jfm\ik_\p\Xij#n_`Z_jglii\[ fg\iXk`fef]Y`fdXjjgcXekj% `eefmXk`fe%8ljki`XeYf`c\idXel]XZkli\iji\jgfe[\[ ]XmfiXYcpkfk_\j\jkXe[Xi[jYp[\m\cfg`e^\hl`gd\ek n`k__`^_$\]ÔZ`\eZpXe[lckiX$cfn\d`jj`fej%K_`j#`e iXekjkpg`ZXccpZfm\iXYflk)'f]k_\`em\jkd\ek i\`e]fiZ\[k_ifl^_gif[lZknXiiXek`\jfeY`fdXjj Zfjkj]fiXeXlkfdXk`Z_fd\_\Xk`e^jpjk\dXe[Xi\ Yf`c\ij% gifm`[\[Ypk_\jkXk\^fm\ied\ek%8j\gXiXk\gif^iXd \o`jkj]fiXgXikd\ekYl`c[`e^j% K_\jkife^]fZljf]k_\dXel]XZkli\ijfegif[lZk [\m\cfgd\ek_XjXcjfc\[kf\hl`gd\ek[\j`^ejk_Xk =fiefe$i\j`[\ek`XcYl`c[`e^j#XeXkkiXZk`m\]le[`e^ XkkiXZkZljkfd\ijk_Xkfk_\in`j\nflc[efkZfej`[\i gif^iXd\o`jkj#n_\i\Ypk_\ZfjkjXi\j_Xi\[Y\kn\\e XY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d#\jg\Z`Xccpk_fj\`ec\jjiliXc k_\jkXk\Xe[k_\]\[\iXc^fm\ied\ekj%=fi\oXdgc\#X Xi\Xj% Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d`eXZfdd\iZ`XcYl`c[`e^Zflc[ i\Z\`m\X^iXekf]*'$+,%

K_\i\`jXcjfX[\[`ZXk\[]le[`e^gif^iXd]fiY`fdXjj [`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^jpjk\djfg\iXk\[Yp]Xid\iZffg\iXk`m\j% Fk_\igif^iXdj`eZcl[\XZfekiXZk`e^gif^iXd j\\ gX^\*' Xe[i\e\nXYc\I;gif^iXd j\\gX^\*+ %

 I\e\nXYc\_\Xk`e^dXe[Xk\j 8[m`Z\#`e]fidXk`feXe[XnXi\e\jjZXdgX`^ej

J`eZ\(000#Xcce\nfii\efmXk\[glYc`ZYl`c[`e^jdljk 8nXi\e\jjgif^iXdjk_XkXi\`e[\g\e[\ekf]k_\jXc\j lj\i\e\nXYc\k_\idXck\Z_efcf^p]fi_\Xk`e^Xe[_fk f]Xgif[lZkXe[j\im`Z\Xi\ZilZ`XckfdXib\k^ifnk_2 nXk\i%J`eZ\)''/#Xcce\ngi`mXk\j\ZkfiYl`c[`e^j k_`j`j\jg\Z`Xccpkil\]fiXe\d\i^`e^`e[ljkipk_Xk_Xj cXi^\ik_Xe(#'''d)s('#/'']k)dljkXcjflj\ c`d`k\[i\jfliZ\j]fidXib\k`e^%JlZZ\jj]lcgifdfk`fe`j i\e\nXYc\\e\i^p]fi_\Xk`e^Xe[_fknXk\i% Z_XiXZk\i`q\[YpXjdXikXe[\]]\Zk`m\d`of] Zfddle`ZXk`fe`ejkild\ekj% E\n_fd\jk_Xki\Z\`m\]le[`e^]ifdk_\jkXk\_flj`e^ gif^iXd `%\%0,f]Xcce\nj`e^c\$]Xd`cp_fd\j dljk K_\F%F%

K_\F%F%

K_\:_XdY\if]8^i`Zlckli\fg\iXk\jXjlggfikj\im`Z\ ]fi]Xid\ijXe[]fi\jkfne\ijk_XkXi\`ek\i\jk\[`e jkXik`e^XY`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^gifa\ZkXe[X[m`j\j k_\dfe\Zfefd`ZXe[k\Z_e`ZXc`jjl\j%

 <[lZXk`fekiX`e`e^ Jlggfik`e^Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^dXel]XZkli\ij

8m`YiXekY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^dXib\ki\hl`i\jX_`^_cp J\m\iXcjkXk\gif^iXdjjlggfikY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^ jb`cc\[nfib]fiZ\XZifjjk_\\ek`i\mXcl\Z_X`e$]ifd dXel]XZkli\ij%K_\dfjk`dgfikXek`jk_\ÈFbf\e\i^`\$ ]l\cgif[lZk`fe#kf\hl`gd\ekdXel]XZkli\ijkf :cljk\iÈ#Xi\e\nXYc\\e\i^pXe[\e\i^p\]ÔZ`\eZp ZfekiXZkfijk_Xk[\j`^e#`ejkXcc#j\im`Z\Xe[fg\iXk\ `e[ljkipe\knfib`eLgg\i8ljki`Xk_Xkjlggfikj _\Xk`e^jpjk\dj% Ylj`e\jj[\m\cfgd\ek#e\knfib`e^Xe[Zffg\iXk`fe# af`ekdXib\k`e^#Xe[\ogfikXZk`m`k`\j%8i\^`feXcI; K_\

Fe\f]k_\dX`eZ_Xcc\e^\j\eZflek\i\[`eXcc\d\i^`e^ Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^dXib\kj`jk_Xk_\Xk`e^ZfekiXZkfij ^\e\iXccpcXZbZfeÔ[\eZ\`e#Xe[befnc\[^\f]#Y`fdXjj jpjk\dj%8jXi\jlck#dXepZfekiXZkfijdXpefkf]]\i Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj#fidXpXZk`m\cp[`jZfliX^\ gfk\ek`XcZc`\ekj]ifd`em\jk`e^`ek_\d%Kffm\iZfd\ k_`jdXib\kYXii`\i#XmfZXk`feXckiX`e`e^]fi È\Zf$`ejkXcc\ijÈnXj[\m\cfg\[`eZffg\iXk`fen`k_k_\ jkXk\jZ_ffc]fi_\Xk`e^jpjk\d`ejkXcc\ijk_XkXccfnj pfle^gif]\jj`feXcjkfjg\Z`Xc`q\`ei\e\nXYc\\e\i^p jpjk\djXkk_\Y\^`ee`e^f]k_\`ikiX`e`e^%K_\ Zlii`Zlcld`eZcl[\j[\j`^e`e^#`ejkXcc`e^#Xe[j\im`Z`e^ Y`fdXjj#jfcXik_\idXc#Xe[^\fk_\idXc_\Xkgldg jpjk\dj%Dfi\k_Xe)''`ejkXcc\ij_Xm\Y\\ekiX`e\[`e k_`jgif^iXd`ek_\cXjk]\np\Xij%

K_\jkXk\X^i`ZlckliXcjZ_ffcj`eZcl[\Y`fdXjj]l\c gif[lZk`fe`ek_\`iZlii`ZlcXXe[k_i\\f]k_\d_Xm\ i\Z\ekcpjkXik\[XY`f\e\i^pkiX`e`e^gif^iXd]fi ]Xid\ij%

 JlZZ\jj]XZkfij]fiY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^gif^iXdjXe[XZk`fegcXej ›Ègfc`ZpgXZbX^\jÈ Zfej`jk`e^f]Xd`of]i\^lcXkfip# ›le[\ijkXe[`e^Xe[\]]\Zk`m\cpZfddle`ZXk`e^k_\ ÔeXeZ`XcXe[kiX`e`e^&XnXi\e\jjgif^iXdj Xi\c`b\cp Y\e\Ôkjf]Y`fdXjjdXib\k^ifnk_Y\pfe[Zc`dXk\ kf[\c`m\ik_\]Xjk\jkdXib\k^ifnk_Ypjk`dlcXk`e^ Xe[\em`ifed\ekgifk\Zk`fe`jZi`k`ZXc \%^%\e\i^p [\dXe[]fiY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj#n_`c\ `e[\g\e[\eZ\k_ifl^_cfZXc]l\cj#`eZfd\]fik_\ j`dlckXe\fljcpjlggfik`e^k_\[\m\cfgd\ekf] ]Xid`e^Zfddle`kp#cfZXc\dgcfpd\ek`eiliXcXi\Xj# Zfjk$\]]\Zk`m\Xe[^ff[$hlXc`kpgif[lZkj `eefmXk`fe#\kZ%

›Zc\Xicp[\Ôe\[hlXek`kXk`m\kXi^\kj#jlggfik\[Yp ›`emfcm`e^]Xid\ijXe[]fi\jkfne\ij`ek_\Y`fdXjj n\cc$[\m\cfg\[XZk`fegcXej#^`m\ZfeÔ[\eZ\kf Ylj`e\jjZXe_\cgkf[\m\cfgY`fdXjj]l\cjlggcp Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^Ylj`e\jj\j Z_X`ejXe[gifm`[\`dgfikXekjlggfik]figfc`Zp [\m\cfgd\ek ›i\^lcXidXib\k`ek\cc`^\eZ\`je\Z\jjXipkf le[\ijkXe[gif^i\jj#Zfddle`ZXk\jlZZ\jj#Xe[kXb\ ›kpg`ZXccp#k_\dfjkgifd`j`e^dXib\kj]fiY`fdXjj Zfii\Zk`m\XZk`fen_\ee\Z\jjXip _\Xk`e^Xi\`eXi\Xjn_\i\f`c_\Xk`e^[fd`eXk\jXe[ k_\i\`jefZfee\Zk`fekfk_\eXkliXc^Xj^i`[% ›_`^_\]ÔZ`\eZp\hl`gd\ekk_Xkd\\kjjki`e^\ek :fem\ij`fe]ifdf`c$YXj\[_\Xk`e^kfY`fdXjj`j \d`jj`fejXe[hlXc`kpjkXe[Xi[j`jZilZ`Xc]fidXib\k k\Z_e`ZXccp\Xj`\i Y\ZXlj\Yfk_i\hl`i\]l\cjkfiX^\  kiXej]fidXk`fe Xe[ljlXccpdfi\ÔeXeZ`Xccpm`XYc\%?p[ife`Z_\Xk [`jki`Ylk`fejpjk\dj`eXYl`c[`e^XcjfdXb\ ›]l\cjkXe[Xi[`qXk`fen`ccjlggfikZfejld\i Zfem\ij`fekfY`fdXjjdfi\\Zfefd`ZXccpXkkiXZk`m\% ZfeÔ[\eZ\ ›]ficXi^\iYl`c[`e^j#`kd`^_kY\\Xj`\i]figif^iXdjkf ›_\Xk`e^jpjk\djdljkf]]\ilj\iZfem\e`\eZ\c\m\cj `e`k`XccpkXi^\ke\nZfejkilZk`fe#Xe[k_\ekfdfm\ j`d`cXikff`cXe[^Xj kfi\efmXk`feX]k\iXe`e`k`Xcc\Xie`e^g\i`f[%9`fdXjj _\Xk`e^`ee\nYl`c[`e^j`jljlXccpj`dgc\ikf ›Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^n`ccfecp^X`eglYc`ZXZZ\gkXeZ\`]k_\ `dgc\d\ekXe[f]k\ec\jj\og\ej`m\kf`ejkXcck_Xe ]l\c`jjfliZ\[]ifd]fi\jkjn_\i\jljkX`eXYc\]fi\jk `k`j`e\o`jk`e^Yl`c[`e^j% dXeX^\d\ekgiXZk`Z\jXi\`egcXZ\ ›[\dfejkiXk`fegif^iXdj \%^%k_\Ôijk('&(''&(''' Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj`eXjg\Z`ÔZdXib\k j\^d\ek Xi\m\iplj\]lc#\jg\Z`Xccp`]k_\Ôe[`e^j Xi\lj\[kf[\j`^ekiX`e`e^Xe[]le[`e^gif^iXdj

›kiX`e`e^e\\[jkfY\gifXZk`m\cpf]]\i\[kfXcc XZkfijXcfe^k_\mXcl\Z_X`eXjXgXikf]Xepgfc`Zp gXZbX^\2`kj_flc[kXi^\kgif[lZ\ij#`ejkXcc\ijXe[ lj\ijf]cXi^\ijpjk\dj

›cfZXcY`fdXjj`e]fidXk`feZXdgX`^ejZXeY\m\ip _\cg]lckfb`Zb$jkXikdXib\kj#\jg\Z`Xccp]figi`mXk\ _fd\jfiglYc`ZYl`c[`e^j

›Xcfe^\ik\idg\ijg\Zk`m\fedXib\k[\m\cfgd\ek# n_`Z_kXb\j`ekfXZZflekk_\c\Xie`e^Zlim\jf] [`]]\i\ekdXib\kXZkfijXe[k_\\ogXej`fef]gif[lZk`fe Xe[`ejkXccXk`feZXgXZ`k`\j#`j`dgfikXek]fi[\m\cfg`e^ X_\Xck_p`e[ljkip%@ek_\cfe^ile#`k`jY\kk\ikf_Xm\ fecpX]\n`ejkXccXk`fej`ek_\Ôijkp\Xijk_Xknfib n\cck_Xe`k`jkfi`jb_Xm`e^]Xlckp`ejkXccXk`fej[li`e^ iXg`[dXib\k^ifnk_%K_`j`eZcl[\j^\kk`e^]le[`e^ gif^iXdji`^_kYpkXb`e^Xcfe^\ik\idg\ijg\Zk`m\ Xe[Xmf`[`e^Yffd$Xe[$YljkdXib\kj%  Fm\iZfd`e^k_\Z_`Zb\efik_\\^^gifYc\d

N_\ekip`e^kfjkXikXcfZXcdXib\k]fiXlkfdXk`Zg\cc\k jcfn\idXib\k^ifnk_ #\og\i`\eZ\]ifd[`]]\i\ek _\Xk`e^#Xgi`dXipZ_Xcc\e^\`jk_\ÈZ_`Zb\e$fi$\^^È gXikjf]ff[Yf`c\igif[lZ\ij ÔeXeZ`Xcjlggfik% _Xm\k_\`ifnekiX`e`e^Z\ek\ijn_`Z_gifm`[\jb`ccj Xe[lg$kf$[Xk\`e]fidXk`fekf`ejkXcc\ijXe[_\Xk`e^ =XZkfijk_Xkn`ccjlggfikk_\jlZZ\jj]lccXleZ_f]XcfZXc \e^`e\\ij% g\cc\kdXib\k`eZcl[\1 K_\Zljkfd\ij K_\g\cc\kjlggcpZ_X`e ›`eX[[`k`fekf`e[`m`[lXc_fd\j n_\i\dXib\k^ifnk_ ›g\cc\kjZXe\`k_\iY\gif[lZ\[cfZXccp#jfliZ\[]ifd `j^\e\iXccpjcfn\ikf[\m\cfgk_Xe`efk_\ij\Zkfij # Xefk_\igXikf]k_\Zflekipfi`dgfik\[%I\jg\Zk`e^ `k`j`dgfikXekkf_Xm\jfd\cXi^\iYl`c[`e^jkfjlggcp jki`Zk]l\chlXc`kpjkXe[Xi[j#Yfk_`egif[lZk`feXe[`e n`k_g\cc\kj`efi[\ikfXmf`[fm\icp$cfe^gXpYXZb _Xe[c`e^#`j`dgfikXek]ifdk_\m\ipY\^`ee`e^%N_`c\ g\i`f[j]fik_\`em\jkd\ekj`eYlcb[\c`m\ipjpjk\dj% jki`e^\ekhlXc`kpi\hl`i\d\ekjZXeljlXccpY\d\kYp gcXekjgif[lZ`e^k\ejf]k_fljXe[jf]kfej\XZ_p\Xi# @e]fidXk`feXe[XnXi\e\jj]fidXib\kXZkfij k_`jc\m\cf]Xgif[lZk`feZXgXZ`kpgi\j\ekjX Xe[jkXb\_fc[\ij Z_Xcc\e^\`eXpfle^dXib\kn`k_cfng\cc\k[\dXe[% ›XlkfdXk`Zg\cc\k_\Xk`e^Xe[k_\i\cXk\[[`jki`Ylk`fe ›g\cc\k[`jki`Ylkfij]fiYlcb[\c`m\ipe\\[kf_Xm\ jpjk\dji\gi\j\ekXe\nXe[[`]]\i\ekXggifXZ_kf ]lccp$gi\jjli`q\[kilZbj#cfX[`e^jkXk`fej#`ek\i`d _\Xk`e^%K_\i\]fi\#`e]fidXk`fe#XnXi\e\jjXe[ jkfiX^\ `]gif[lZ\i`jefkcfZXk\[`ek_\m`Z`e`kp  kiX`e`e^`je\\[\[]fi[`]]\i\ekdXib\kXZkfij Xe[k_\jb`ccjkf_Xe[c\g\cc\kj ]lik_\i[\kX`cj#j\\ gfk\ek`Xcg\cc\kgif[lZ\ijXe[[`jki`Ylkfij#_\Xk`e^ gX^\(0 % ZfdgXe`\j#`ejkXcc\ij #jkXb\_fc[\i^iflgj glYc`Z X[d`e`jkiXk`feXe[g\id`kk`e^X^\eZ`\j#\d`jj`feXe[ K_\\hl`gd\ek \]ÔZ`\eZpjkXe[Xi[j#]le[`e^gif^iXdj Xe[gfk\ek`Xc ›n\cc$]leZk`fe`e^Xe[gifm\eg\cc\kYf`c\ij#d\\k`e^ Zljkfd\ij _fd\fne\ij#_flj`e^[\m\cfg\ijXe[ jki`e^\ek\d`jj`fejkXe[Xi[jXe[gifm`[`e^_`^_ XjjfZ`Xk`fej#fne\ijXe[fg\iXkfijf]cXi^\iZfdd\iZ`Xc Zfejld\iZfem\e`\eZ\#Xi\i\hl`i\[%;\jg`k\k_\ Xe[glYc`ZYl`c[`e^j %@e]fidXk`feXYflkk_\j\ _`^_\iZfjkjf]jlZ_\hl`gd\ek n`k_k_\i\cXk\[ gif^iXdj`eLgg\i8ljki`XZXeY\]fle[XkgX^\)-%

 9lj`e\jjdf[\cj]fifg\iXk`e^Y`fdXjjgcXekj

Knf[`jk`eZkYlj`e\jjdf[\cj_Xm\\d\i^\[`eLgg\i J`eZ\k_`jYlj`e\jjdf[\c_\cgjkffm\iZfd\j\m\iXc 8ljki`X]fifg\iXk`e^cXi^\iY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj% j`^e`ÔZXekdXib\kYXii`\ij#k_\jkXk\f]Lgg\i8ljki`X CfZXc]Xid\ijXe[]fi\jkfne\ijcffb`e^]fiXe\n j\klgXjg\Z`ÔZgif^iXdkfjlggfik`k#k_\jf$ZXcc\[ dXib\k]fik_\`i]fi\jkipi\j`[l\j[\m\cfg\[jkiXk\^`\j È\e\i^pZfekiXZk`e^gif^iXdÈ%K_\gif^iXdZfm\ij ]fiY`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfibjXe[Y`fdXjj_\Xk Yfk_\e\i^p\]ÔZ`\eZp`em\jkd\ekjXjn\ccXj ZfekiXZk`e^%@eYfk_ZXj\j#nff[Z_`gjXi\k_\[fd`eXek i\e\nXYc\_\Xk`e^`ejkXccXk`fej%K_\^iXek]fiY`fdXjj ]l\c% _\XkZfekiXZk`e^$n_`Z_`j^`m\e`eX[[`k`fekffk_\i ]le[`e^gif^iXdj$Xdflekjkflgkf(*%,f]k_\ `em\jkd\ekZfjkj]fiY`fdXjjZfekiXZk`e^%@ekfkXc#k_\ 9`fdXjj_\XkZfekiXZk`e^ gif^iXd_Xjjlggfik\[dfi\k_Xe(''ZfekiXZk`e^ gifa\Zkj% Fe\dXafiYXii`\i]fiZljkfd\ijZfej`[\i`e^Xe `em\jkd\ek`eXY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d`jk_Xkk_\ 8]k\iXc\e^k_pdXib\k[\m\cfgd\ekg_Xj\#j\m\iXc lg]ifekZfjkjXi\i\cXk`m\cp_`^_%8cjf#dXepYl`c[`e^

 9`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfibj

K_\Ôijkgifa\Zk]fiXY`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfib /''bN%Gifa\Zkjk_Xk`eZcl[\j\m\iXccXi^\iYl`c[`e^j`e nXj[\m\cfg\[Yp]finXi[$k_`eb`e^]Xid\ij`ek_\ k_\gcXee\[e\knfibXi\ljlXccpdfi\\Zfefd`ZXccpm`XYc\% d`[$/'j%K_\pn\i\dfk`mXk\[YpmfcXk`c\gi`Z\j]fi X^i`ZlckliXcgif[lZkj#Xe[n\i\Xcjfcffb`e^]fi gfjj`Y`c`k`\jkfZi\Xk\XdXib\k]fi]fi\jkipi\j`[l\j% K\Z_e`ZXccpjg\Xb`e^#k_\[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfib Zfej`jkjf]fe\fidfi\Y`fdXjjYf`c\ij lj`e^nff[ K_\Ylj`e\jjdf[\ck_Xk\d\i^\[nXjkf]fid Z_`gjXjX]l\c #X_p[iXlc`ZZfekifcjpjk\dn`k_ Zffg\iXk`m\jf]]Xid\ijk_Xkfne\[]fi\jkcXe[n`k_X jlYjkXk`fejXkk_\Zljkfd\ij`k\j#Xe[k_\_\Xk ^fXckf[\m\cfg#Yl`c[Xe[fg\iXk\jdXcc$jZXc\Y`fdXjj [`jki`Ylk`fe^i`[% [`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^jpjk\djn_`Z_kpg`ZXccpjlggcpm`ccX^\ Z\ek\ij \%^%k_\cfZXc^fm\ied\ekYl`c[`e^j#jZ_ffcj# @k`jm\ip`dgfikXekkfgcXeXe[[\j`^ek_\e\knfib Ylj`e\jj\jXe[_flj`e^ n`k__\Xk`e^%K_\[`jki`Zk gifg\icp#kXb`e^`ekfXZZflek1 _\Xk`e^gcXekjn\i\Yl`ck]ifdjZiXkZ_`eXi\Xjn_\i\ [`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^[`[efkgi\m`fljcp\o`jk#Xe[dXep ›_\XkcfX[Xe[_\Xk[\dXe[#`eZcl[`e^_fndlZ_f] ]Xid\ijY\ZXd\jlZZ\jj]lcÈ_\Xk\eki\gi\e\lijÈ% k_\[\dXe[n`ccY\j`dlckXe\fljXe[_fndlZ_n`cc Y\Xk[`]]\i\ekk`d\j Kf[Xp#*''jlZ_Y`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfibjXi\ ›gifg\ig`g\[`d\ej`fej`efi[\ikfXmf`[\oZ\jj`m\ `efg\iXk`fe#n`k_XYflk)'e\ngifa\ZkjYl`ck\XZ_p\Xi _\Xkcfjj\j`ek_\^i`[%8jXilc\f]k_ldYk_\ Xe[Xefk_\i)'\o`jk`e^fe\j\ok\e[\[\XZ_p\Xi% \]ÔZ`\eZp]XZkfif]k_\^i`[ iXk`ff]XeelXc [`jki`Ylk\[&jfc[_\XkkfXeelXcgif[lZ\[_\Xk  K_`jdXib\k[\m\cfgd\eknXjjkife^cpjlggfik\[Yp j_flc[Y\Xkc\Xjk., Xjg\Z`ÔZ^iXekgif^iXd]fiY`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^ ›eldY\if]Zljkfd\ijXe[c\e^k_f]k_\^i`[%=fi jpjk\djfg\iXk\[Yp]Xid\ijfi]Xid\iZffg\iXk`m\j \Zfefd`Zi\Xjfej#XjXilc\f]k_ldYk_\Xdflekf] n_`Z_Zfm\ijlgkf+'f]k_\`em\jkd\ekZfjkj%K_\ _\Xkjfc[&[`jki`Ylk\[XeelXccpZfdgXi\[kfk_\c\e^k_ Yl[^\k]fik_`jgif^iXd[iXnjlgfe

:ffg\iXk`m\jkpg`ZXccp_Xm\Xifle[('d\dY\ij% Dfjkf]k_\Y`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^jpjk\djXi\ D\dY\ijXi\gi\[fd`eXekcpcfZXc]Xid\ij#Xck_fl^_k_\ cfZXk\[`eiliXcXi\Xj%K_\dX`eZ`k`\j`eLgg\i8ljki`X dle`Z`gXc`kpficfZXcYlj`e\jjfne\ijdXpXcjfY\ _Xm\cXi^\i[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfibjn_`Z_Xi\ d\dY\ij%8Yflk.'f]k_\]l\c`jjfliZ\[]ifdk_\ ]l\cc\[Yp^Xj:?G#`e[ljki`XcnXjk\_\XkXe[Y`fdXjj Zffg\iXk`m\d\dY\ijËfne]fi\jkj%K_\`ejkXcc\[ :?G%K_\pXi\fg\iXk\[Ypk_\glYc`Zlk`c`kpZfdgXe`\j ZXgXZ`kpf]X[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^e\knfibXm\iX^\jXifle[ n_`Z_Xcjf[`jki`Ylk\^XjXe[\c\Zki`Z`kp %

;`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^^i`[

JlYjkXk`fe ?\Xk 8ZZldlcXkfi \oZ_Xe^\i kXeb 9f`c\i JlYjkXk`fe

JlYjkXk`fe

 9`fdXjj_\Xk`e^`e[ljkip

8^iXjjiffkjY`fdXjjdfm\d\ek#jk\dd`e^]ifd]Xid\ij Xe[]fi\jkfne\ij#ZfdY`e\[n`k_`eefmXk`m\\eki\gi\e\lij

Lgg\i8ljki`XeY`fdXjjYf`c\idXel]XZkli\ijgcXpX 8eelXcjXc\jf]Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^]l\cj#`eZc%:?GgcXekj )''0 1 c\X[`e^ifc\fek_\

=fie\XicpX[\ZX[\#Xcc_\Xk`e^`ejkXcc\ij_Xm\`eZcl[\[ Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^`ek_\`igif[lZkXe[j\im`Z\gfik]fc`f `ei\jgfej\kfZljkfd\i[\dXe[%K_\kiXej]fidXk`fe`e ZfekiXZkfij\im`Z\jXe[Zfejld\iXnXi\e\jj_XjY\\e jlggfik\[Yp`e[ljkipkiX`e`e^gif^iXdj#k_\mfZXk`feXc jZ_ffc]fi`ejkXcc\ij#\e\i^pXnXi\e\jjZXdgX`^ej# Xe[Zflej\c`e^j\im`Z\jgifm`[\[Ypk_\ F%F%

 K_\ÈFbf\e\i^`\$:cljk\iÈ

K_\ÈFbf\e\i^`\$:cljk\iÈgcXpjXe`dgfikXekifc\`e kiX[\j_fnj`ee\ndXib\kj Xe[kiX`e`e^XZk`m`k`\j%K_\ jlggfik`e^`e[ljkip[\m\cfgd\ek%9`fdXjjYf`c\i e\knfib`jdXeX^\[Ypk_\F%F%

9`fdXjjYf`c\ijkfm\dXel]XZkli\ij`eLgg\i8ljki`X

:fdgXep DX`egif[lZkj

Yf`c\ij]finff[g\cc\kj#nff[Z_`gj#Ôi\nff[#\e\i^p^iX`e2_\Xk lekXdXk`Z jkfiX^\jpjk\dj Le`k\[JkXk\j nnn%^lekXdXk`Z%Xk

Yf`c\ij]finff[g\cc\kj#nff[Z_`gj#Ôi\nff[#X^if$Y`fdXjj2

`cc\j Yf`c\ij]finff[g\cc\kj#nff[Z_`gj#Ôi\nff[2\e\i^pZfekX`e\ij AXgXe#Jflk_Bfi\X nnn%^`cc\j%Xk

9`fbfdgXbk Yf`c\ij]finff[g\cc\kj#nff[Z_`gj#Ôi\nff[#X^if$Y`fdXjj

9\bfdd\e\jKifg\e^clk$Cf^f`jkmfe [\iHlXc`k€ke`Z_kXlji\`Z_\e[# Kifg\e^clk Yf`c\ij]finff[Z_`gj

 Gif[lZk`eefmXk`fe

g\cc\kZfe[\ej`e^Yf`c\ij 8kiX[\j_fn È

m\ipjdXcc$jZXc\Yf`c\ij]ficfn\e\i^pYl`c[`e^j ;l\kfYl`c[`e^i\^lcXk`fej`eLgg\i8ljki`X#k_\ _\Xk`e^cfX[f]e\n_fd\j`jm\ipcfn ljlXccp j`^e`ÔZXekcpY\cfn('bN %K_`j_Xjki`^^\i\[Xe\n ^\e\iXk`fef]Èm\ipjdXcc$jZXc\Èg\cc\kYf`c\ij#jfd\f] n_`Z_ZXe\m\eY\nXcc$dflek\[ c`b\X^XjYf`c\i %

_\Xk`e^ZfekX`e\ijfclk`fej ?\XkZfekX`e\ijXi\gi\$Xjj\dYc\[Xe[`eZcl[\k_\ Yf`c\i#k_\]l\cjkfiX^\ ]fig\cc\kjfinff[Z_`gj Xe[k_\ Zfekifcjpjk\d%K_\pXi\Xe`[\Xcjfclk`fe`]k_\i\`jefk jl]ÔZ`\ekjgXZ\XmX`cXYc\`ek_\Yl`c[`e^fi]fi ZfekiXZk`e^gifa\Zkj%K_\pZXeY\`ejkXcc\[`eX]\n_flij%

X^if$Yf`c\ijd\\k`e^jki`e^\ek\]ÔZ`\eZpjkXe[Xi[j ;l\kfk_\`in`[\XmX`cXY`c`kp#efe$nff[Y`fdXjj#jlZ_ XjjkiXn#\e\i^p^iX`efid`jZXek_lj#Xi\m\ip XkkiXZk`m\]l\cj%?fn\m\i#`k`jm\ipZ_Xcc\e^`e^kf XZ_`\m\cfn\d`jj`fejZfdYljk`fej`d`cXikfdf[\ie nff[Yf`c\ijn`k_k_\j\]l\cj%Gi\j\ekcp#k_\i\Xi\X ]\nX^if$Yf`c\ijfek_\dXib\k#n_`Z_Xi\XYc\kfd\\k jki`e^\ek8ljki`Xe\d`jj`feji\hl`i\d\ekj%  Gifa\Zk\oXdgc\j

GXjj`m\_fd\# Cfn\e\i^p_fd\# I\efmXk\[_fd\# E\ldXibk&D•_cbi\`j B`iZ_Y\i^ ?f_\eq\cc

K_\fne\ijnXek\[k_\`ie\n_fd\kf K_`jjdXcc#e\nnff[\e_flj\`jj`klXk\[ @ek_\Zflij\f]i\efmXk`e^k_`jjgXZ`flj# Y\XjjljkX`eXYc\Xjgfjj`Yc\1`knXjYl`ck `ek_\Zflekipj`[\Xe[jliifle[\[YpX (0.'j_fd\#k_\fc[Yf`c\inXji\gcXZ\[ XZZfi[`e^kfgXjj`m\Yl`c[`e^jkXe[Xi[j eXkli\i\j\im\%K_\\e\i^p\]ÔZ`\eZpf] n`k_Xdf[\ieÔi\nff[Yf`c\i%K_\]Xd`cp

Xe[`j\hl`gg\[n`k_X:F)$e\lkiXcXe[]lccp k_\Yl`c[`e^Xe[k_\ZfdgXiXk`m\cpc`d`k\[ f]]fli`ejkXcc\[XjfcXik_\idXcjpjk\d XlkfdXk`Zg\cc\k_\Xk`e^jpjk\d%8jfcXi c`m`e^jgXZ\g\id`kk\[XjdXcc\i$k_Xe$ n`k_X.#,''c`k\is(#0/)^XccfeXZZldlcXkfi k_\idXcjpjk\d .%,d)s/(]k) Xe[Xe/'' Xm\iX^\_\Xk`e^jpjk\dkfY\`ejkXcc\[1 kXebXjXeX[[`k`feXccXYfijXm`e^d\Xjli\% c`k\is)((^XccfeXZZldlcXkfikXeb]lik_\i XnXcc$dflek\[g\cc\kYf`c\i#n_`Z_ZXe N`k_k_\jfcXik_\idXcjpjk\d`egcXZ\# `eZi\Xj\k_\\em`ifed\ekXcg\i]fidXeZ\f] df[lcXk\`kjZXgXZ`kpY\kn\\e)Xe[.bN% k_\nff[jkfiX^\fecpe\\[jkfY\Ôcc\[ k_\Yl`c[`e^%@eX[[`k`fekfm\ipcfn\e\i^p K_\_\Xk\iefkfecpjXm\jjgXZ\#`knXjXcjf \m\ipj\Zfe[[Xp`ek_\n`ek\i#\m\e[li`e^ Zfjkj#k_\]Xd`cpXcjfY\e\Ôkj]ifdk_\ `ejkXcc\[m\iphl`Zbcp% g\i`f[jn`k_effic`kkc\jlej_`e\%;li`e^ Zfem\e`\eZ\f]k_\`i\e\i^pjpjk\dj% n`ek\idfek_jn`k_dfi\jlej_`e\#k_\ jkfiX^\jpjk\dfecpe\\[jkfY\Ôcc\[feZ\ g\in\\b%

K_\Yl`c[`e^ K_\Yl`c[`e^ K_\Yl`c[`e^ ›gi`mXk\_fd\Yl`ckkfXZZfi[`e^kfgXjj`m\ ›e\ncfn\e\i^p_fd\ ›i\efmXk\[_fd\ Yl`c[`e^jkXe[Xi[j ›_\Xk\[jli]XZ\Xi\X1.,d)s/'.]k) ›_\Xk\[Xi\X1)-'d)s)#/'']k) ›_\Xk\[Xi\X1)+-d)s)#-+/]k) ›Õffi_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›ÕffiXe[nXcc_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›Õffi_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›p\XiYl`ck1)''0 ›p\Xif]i\efmXk`fe1)''. ›p\XiYl`ck1)''.

K_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d K_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d K_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›XlkfdXk`Zg\cc\k_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›]lccpXlkfdXk`Z#nXcc$dflek\[#g\cc\k ›XlkfdXk`ZÔi\nff[Yf`c\i ›`em\jkd\ekZfjk1(+#'''

Ylcb[\c`m\ipYpXcfZXcg\cc\k[`jki`Ylkfi ›:F)Xmf`[\[1'%0kfejg\ip\Xi ›:F)Xmf`[\[1-kfejg\ip\Xi ›Xj_i\dfmXc1kn`Z\g\ip\Xi

›:F)Xmf`[\[1'%/,kfejg\ip\Xi

 I\efmXk\[]XidYl`c[`e^# Cfn\e\i^pf]ÔZ\Yl`c[`e^# @ejk`klk`feXcYl`c[`e^# G`Z_c&N\cj Dle[\iÔe^ G\`cjk\`e

@e)''-#k_`j]fid\i]XidYl`c[`e^nXj K_\È

K_\Yl`c[`e^ K_\Yl`c[`e^ K_\Yl`c[`e^ ›Zfem\ik\[]XidYl`c[`e^ ›cfn$\e\i^pf]ÔZ\Yl`c[`e^ ›jfZ`Xc`ejk`klk`fe ›_\Xk\[Xi\X1-''d)s-#+-']k) ›XeelXc_\Xk[\dXe[1/#,''bN_ ›_\Xk\[jli]XZ\Xi\X1(#'''d)s('#.-+]k) ›Õffi_\Xk`e^jpjk\dXe[iX[`Xkfij ›_\Xk\[Xi\X1*/'d)s+#'0']k) ›Õffi_\Xk`e^jpjk\dXe[iX[`Xkfij ›p\Xif]i\efmXk`fe1)''- ›p\XiYl`ck1)''* ›p\XiYl`ck1)''*

K_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›XlkfdXk`Znff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\d K_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d K_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›`em\jkd\ekZfjkj1(+#'''

jpjk\d1).'

›:F)Xmf`[\[1(/kfejg\ip\Xi

 KiXejgfikZfdgXep# >l\jk_flj\# JZ_ffcYl`c[`e^# C`eq Dfe[j\\ I\`Z_iXd`e^

D`kk\iKiXejgfik\`jXkiXejgfikZfdgXep K_\È>l\jk_flj\8eeXÈ`jcfZXk\[Xkfe\ K_\jZ_ffcYl`c[`e^`eI\`Z_iXd`e^#X n`k_Xifle[/'\dgcfp\\j`eC`eq%K_\ f]8ljki`XÊjdfjkY\Xlk`]lccXb\j#CXb\ g`Zkli\jhl\dflekX`em`ccX^\#_flj\jX ZfdgXepËjgi`dXipYlj`e\jj`jkfkiXejgfik Dfe[j\\%K_\^l\jk_flj\ZXeXZZfdf[Xk\ b`e[\i^Xik\e#Xe\c\d\ekXipjZ_ffc#Xe[ f`cXe[clYi`ZXekjXe[kfdXeX^\ XkfkXcf]*'^l\jkj`eknfYl`c[`e^jn`k_ X_`^_jZ_ffc%@ek_\Zflij\f]XYl`c[`e^ e\njgXg\icf^`jk`Zj%8]\np\XijX^f# j\m\eiffdjXe[Ôm\_fc`[XpXgXikd\ekj% i\efmXk`fe#k_\fc[f`c_\Xk`e^jpjk\dnXj k_\ZfdgXepXcjfX[[\[Xnff[g\cc\k @e)''/#f`c_\Xk`e^jpjk\dj`eYfk_ i\gcXZ\[YpX]lccp$XlkfdXk`Znff[Z_`g [`jki`Ylk`fej\im`Z\%@ec`e\n`k_k_`je\n Yl`c[`e^jn\i\i\gcXZ\[YpXZ\ekiXcnff[ _\Xk`e^jpjk\d#`ejkXcc\[Xe[fg\iXk\[Yp Ylj`e\jjÔ\c[#k_\ZfdgXep`ejkXcc\[X Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\d%

K_\Yl`c[`e^j K_\Yl`c[`e^ K_\Yl`c[`e^ ›Xef]ÔZ\Xe[XdX`ek\eXeZ\Yl`c[`e^Xe[ ›^l\jk_flj\]fi*'^l\jkj ›jZ_ffcYl`c[`e^ X^XiX^\ ›_\Xk\[Xi\X1(#'''d)s('#.-+]k) ›_\Xk\[jli]XZ\Xi\X1+#++'d)s+.#/'']k) ›_\Xk\[Xi\X1(#)''d)s()#0)']k) ›Õffi_\Xk`e^jpjk\dXe[iX[`Xkfij ›iX[`Xkfij ›iX[`Xkfij ›p\Xif]i\efmXk`fe1)''/ ›p\Xif]i\efmXk`fe1)'', ›p\XiYl`ck _\Xk`e^jpjk\d 1)''0

K_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d K_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d K_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›XlkfdXk`Zg\cc\k_\Xk`e^jpjk\d`eX ›XlkfdXk`Znff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›XlkfdXk`Znff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ZfekX`e\iX[aXZ\ekkfk_\Yl`c[`e^ ›`em\jkd\ekZfjkj1*,#'''

›:F)Xmf`[\[1*.%,kfejg\ip\Xi ]Xid\ij ›nff[Z_`g[\c`m\ip1/k`d\jg\ip\XiYpX

›:F)Xmf`[\[1*(kfejg\ip\Xi cfZXc]Xid\i

›:F)Xmf`[\[10'kfejg\ip\Xi

 9`fdXjjd`Zif$[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^ 9`fdXjjd`Zif$[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^ 9`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^# ^i`[#FY\in`ebc ^i`[#9XZ_dXee`e^ 9lZ_b`iZ_\e

8jdXccnff[Z_`g_\Xk`e^^i`[jlggc`\jknf 9XZ_dXee`e^`jXjdXccdle`Z`gXc`kpn`k_ K_\Y`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^jpjk\d`e ]XidYl`c[`e^jXe[fe\XgXikd\ekYl`c[`e^# Xifle[-.'`e_XY`kXekj%N_\ek_\ 9lZ_b`iZ_\e#[\m\cfg\[Xe[dXeX^\[Yp n_`Z_n\i\gi\m`fljcp_\Xk\[YpÔi\nff[# dle`Z`gXc`kp[\Z`[\[kfi\gcXZ\k_\fc[f`c XZffg\iXk`m\f]]fli]Xid\ij#_XjY\\e ZfXcXe[eXkliXc^Xj%8jdXikZfekifc _\Xk`e^jpjk\d`e)''.#`kjglYc`ZYl`c[`e^j fg\iXk`e^j`eZ\)''.%K_\i\Xi\ jpjk\d#n_`Z_k_\]Xid\ijZfek`elfljcp dle`Z`gXcf]ÔZ\#b`e[\i^Xik\e#\c\d\ekXip )-i\j`[\ek`Xc#Zfdd\iZ`Xc#Xe[glYc`Z `dgifm\#Xe[XeXZZldlcXkfikXeb#\ejli\ jZ_ffc #Xjn\ccXjk_\Z_liZ_Xe[k_\ j\ZkfiZljkfd\ijZfee\Zk\[kfX(#/''ds \]ÔZ`\ekfg\iXk`feXe[cfnZfjkj%K_\]l\c jlg\idXib\k#n\i\Zfee\Zk\[kfX ,#0'']k[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^^i`[%CfZXc]Xid\ij `jjlggc`\[]ifdk_\]Xid\iËjfne]fi\jkj% (('bNg\cc\k$]l\c\[[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^jpjk\d% [\c`m\ik_\nff[Z_`gjkfk_\_\XkgcXek# G\cc\kjn\i\Z_fj\eY\ZXlj\jkfiX^\jgXZ\ n_`Z_`eZi\Xj\jk_\cfZXc\Zfefd`Z`dgXZk nXjkffc`d`k\[]finff[Z_`gj% f]k_\jpjk\d%

K_\Yl`c[`e^j K_\Yl`c[`e^jk_\Y`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d K_\[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›knf]XidYl`c[`e^j#fe\XgXikd\ek ›XlkfdXk`Zg\cc\k_\Xk`e^jpjk\dn`k_ ›Y`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^jpjk\dn`k_ Yl`c[`e^ +XgXikd\ekj jZi\nZfem\pfijpjk\d nff[Z_`gj ›_\Xk\[Xi\X1)#'''d)s)(#,*']k) ›`ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`kp1(('bN#+#'''c`k\is ›`ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`kp1/,'bN"(,'bN ›Õffi_\Xk`e^jpjk\dXe[iX[`Xkfij (#',.^XccfejXZZldlcXkfikXeb )Yf`c\ij ›p\XiYl`ck [`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^^i`[ 1)'', ›_\Xk\[Xi\X1)#.)*d)s)0#*((]k) ›Zljkfd\ij1)- \hl`mXc\ekkfk_\_\Xk ›kfkXc`em\jkd\ekZfjkj10,#.''

›:F)Xmf`[\[1+*'kfejg\ip\Xi ›XeelXcg\cc\kZfejldgk`fe1-,kfej ›XeelXc]l\cZfjkj1+,#'''

›:F)Xmf`[\[1(''kfejg\ip\Xi ›:F)Xmf`[\[1*.,kfejg\ip\Xi

 @e[ljki`XcZfdgXep# @e[ljki`XcZfdgXep# DfeXjk\ipXe[_`jkfi`ZcXe[dXib >lik\e Cfj\ejk\`e Yl`c[`e^#Bi\djd•ejk\i

=`cc`jX]Xd`cp$fne\[`e[ljki`XcZfdgXep# N\Y\i`jXe`e[ljki`XcZfdgXepjg\Z`Xc`q`e^ K_\dfeXjk\ip`eBi\djd•ejk\inXj]fle[\[ jg\Z`Xc`q`e^`eZfdgc\ogif[lZk`fec`e\j `e_p[iXlc`Z[i`m\jXe[Zfekifc\e^`e\\i`e^% `ek_\p\Xi...Ypk_\fi[\if]Jk%9\e\[`Zk% Xe[i\cXk\[dXZ_`e\ip%K_\_\Xk]fik_\ @k\dgcfpjdfi\k_Xe)''jkX]]Xkk_\j`k\ @e)''+#Xelik\e%K_\cfZXcÔi\ ]l\c]ifdcfZXc]fi\jkfne\ij% k_\kfne %N_\ek_\dfeXjk\ipËj_\Xk [\gXikd\ekËjYl`c[`e^`jXcjfZfee\Zk\[ [\dXe[`jcfn#`kjY`fdXjjjpjk\dZXe]\\[ kfk_\jpjk\dXe[dfi\Yl`c[`e^jn`ccY\ _\Xk`ekfk_\dle`Z`gXce\knfib% Zfee\Zk\[`ek_\e\Xi]lkli\%

K_\Y`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^ K_\Yl`c[`e^ K_\Yl`c[`e^j ›Y`fdXjj[`jki`Zk_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›ZfdgXepYl`c[`e^ f]ÔZ\Xe[gif[lZk`fe ›dfeXjk\ip _`jkfi`ZcXe[dXibYl`c[`e^ nff[Z_`gj Yl`c[`e^j ›Õffi_\Xk`e^jpjk\d ›`ejkXcc\[ZXgXZ`kp10/'bN ›_\Xk\[Xi\X1(#.''d)s(/#*'']k) ›_\Xk[\dXe[1*#,''DN_ ›kfkXc`em\jkd\ekZfjkj1-,'#'''

+,#'''LJ ›:F)Xmf`[\[1)0'kfejg\ip\Xi Z_`gg\[)$*k`d\jg\ip\Xi

›:F)Xmf`[\[1*)'kfejg\ip\Xi ›:F)Xmf`[\[1(#)''kfejg\ip\Xi

 N_pY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^6 K_\i\^`fef]Lgg\i8ljki`Xk_\ F%F%

9`fdXjj`jXjljkX`eXYc\Xe[ZXiYfe$e\lkiXc]l\cXe[ Gi\j\ekcp#i\e\nXYc\\e\i^pjfliZ\jgifm`[\**f] \jg\Z`Xccpjl`kXYc\]fi_\Xk`e^f]_fd\j#Ylj`e\jj\j k_\gi`dXip\e\i^p f]n_`Z_(,`jY`fdXjj Xe[dfi\ Xe[glYc`ZYl`c[`e^j%Df[\ie_\Xk`e^jpjk\djXi\ k_Xe+,f]Xcc_\Xk`e^`jgif[lZ\[]ifdi\e\nXYc\ ]lccpXlkfdXk`ZXcn`k_lckiX$cfn\d`jj`fej%K_\ \e\i^p`eLgg\i8ljki`X%K_\jkXk\`jXcjf_fd\kfX `ejkXccXk`fef]XY`fdXjj_\Xk`e^jpjk\d\ejli\j eldY\if]

F%F%

K_`jglYc`ZXk`fe`jgif[lZ\[`e k_\]iXd\nfibf]k_\\ogfikXe[ `ek\ieXk`feXc`qXk`fegif^iXdf] k_\jkXk\f]Lgg\i8ljki`X% ?\jj\egcXkq*#+')'C`eq#nnn%\ogfikZ\ek\i%Xk