This article was downloaded by:[Ingenta Content Distribution - Routledge] On: 12 May 2008 Access Details: [subscription number 791963552] Publisher: Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK
Postcolonial Studies Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=t713441051 Monster Island: Godzilla and Japanese sci-fi/horror/fantasy Philip Brophy
Online Publication Date: 01 April 2000 To cite this Article: Brophy, Philip (2000) 'Monster Island: Godzilla and Japanese sci-fi/horror/fantasy', Postcolonial Studies, 3:1, 39 — 42 To link to this article: DOI: 10.1080/13688790050001336 URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13688790050001336
PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE
Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.informaworld.com/terms-and-conditions-of-access.pdf This article maybe used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan or sub-licensing, systematic supply or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material. Downloaded By: [Ingenta Content Distribution - Routledge] At: 20:43 12 May 2008 water overcom simulacra feel drea smal from precis strangenes painte ar a To PHILI Japanes Monste Postcolonia 1368-879 horror Phili footag durin grave narratives destructio glob as Tokyo ar Japanes otent crags forti isolationis manga thei glowin Godzill whic wit Japan doze e e In muc h p r s stan accessible d e generate , l Broph h . . g gian n s anim ’ Psycho incongruousl cation nearl e d it path on e Arguably s n ’ as 2 Toky g 0 P s h a beli hum ), e d Worl plasticit misfortun appears sk postnuclea Print Toh of e rin futuristi e BROPH y th consciousnes . an t , n as an in t s y th . an teache y by e ga especiall e g Thi : of l / s Hiroshim o d arise d 1466-188 e o an fron d d In to island silve perspectiv al greate no Studies (1960 s of manga ; is at Godzill Toky fello verisimilitud d insecurit l r s s Wa constitute tank e , th , y projec in tensil muc s t th thi moat an c clouds th e sensatio e r of Y th gure of , y fro r r Island e . metropol w r screen d ) 8 e an othe e s s y o sci- at urb , No On-line th II h transporte Departmen fo depth d Godzill wonder marriag a m th an e a in s peripherie t as monster Vo . s d e wa th r e y e . movie t seem danger Japanes r ho . wit d th Ever tha particula th movie s e as l A the s It surprisingly n larg . side directo e towerin / of w s e 3, 00 an s Whe h hand t a e carne potenc i a y of of / stil a s s th t 010039-0 y e d Japa e No bridges servin s Japan s is rs of kin / s fus at — d e s of to : r e shallo evoke oatin meaning horror tim touc n t l bein Visua s s wad lms of way themselves a wort ho the int tim y d water e r 1, n on psych g be of sci- of th y Godzill e remai Japan ’ w fakenes o g h e of n migh electrica , 4 l g e technologicall pp s g e e wit 1 , s Communication Neo-Toky , w Australia s h Ó America to suc subliminall Tokyo th see blithel wall on no in Toky ber islan s disoriente toward th a / ‘ 200 e 39 h e investigatin horror . poo psycho-islanding la n fortif e strang ’ s t h whic an th s whic g worl wall – 0 s p traumati th sociall s invasio sligh d 42 e . Th laten d l n o of acros y l / ’ at e is Whe s horro Universa tha e technolog s fantas , y stations ’ h statu / s caree Ba Toh d h s fantas e Institut energy dock exude 200 o expanse t a tha image wit t t d thi , of sensation y y atomi y architectur r s RMI a n is sens serve imperialis n y o s c t 0 s by whic lm superimpose h n g an is th s on e of pool raze y fata theatrica T is d , of throug , turrets compensate e : whos d an e further s xture l Body site e University c creatin over d Japa y impenetrabl . Postcolonia typicall ( an Godzill lot h of industriall founde see kaiju l , d an ’ reside as Tim y . , d th d curve , shore d Melt e Japanes s Tw to d s t n wit e on t h e , narrative as Toky , perimeter in l th itche coul no e faker invers pyrotechni g it . , in e th o fo seasid y Melbourne h eiga d a s , e thos th s l d , a an is e side detonatin r Studie so genera enough mountain d movies Bate e a o th attracte d equall hal y s in d struc e ground thos y e , e e cycloram e hav Ba epidermi deepl wit s navigat self-securit e s concep o tim an s rathe a occurs image anime s design of s y of recall . e of h e k l d residenc He wa y ar , c ’ e fo th d induce y shallo an by it th , g omnip bu e energ blatan write r s tactic on y e r s again in e to silen s d e al t : line s t s ove wit poo ow s tha ho a tha cit an and on l th th th th th s 39 an it of of of of in on w w n d y n d y h y d e e e e e e e s s r - t t t l , Downloaded By: [Ingenta Content Distribution - Routledge] At: 20:43 12 May 2008 Standin poetics collision. work postwa multitud documen verg a Godzilla bombing (ho ha fo blazin fro horizo tha th Japanes collapse 40 sters an be tha fantas ornatel withi invok upo By invisibl proces stop-motio Harryhause towar Japanes differenc notion to trai diorama feelin is franti e r s d Whil Ye If se m t n sugges seemingl w n contrast Godzilla n Japanes bee e , it t th oute n s denie t sets engrave e d g y s Japa g of to n th s s Japa y e . r thi as c e e e g e n th is th calligraphi th s . oi cinem e is ar e ’ of industria s Phenomenologica growin e dock t increas , amplif costume r in s Fro in Americ e cinema e t sci- s e th no l n e s a of on Us paralle n thi n become to spina th n , e Toky ski human-as-engineer notion well eeri e y phantasmagorical th fron prosceniu ’ employe it t no concurren deadl m animatio s e e – s d embodimen ( persiste s narrativ psychologica s uncommo e creat mor a n Jaso The / diabolica t engage unsee fantasy mora e etching y of youn statu s g ac e l t embrace o . pertinen of a l d l column of huma feelin of beyon s in t y e Th m c boo Toky s Ba n e (an craft acto of of ‘ th base) s th l clea g energ Iraq metapho n d e realistic an d accidentall e y n m binarie s d e m dram e jus . t animatio girl s predigita Olympia rubbe God n g d planes r wil l o n d in s Japanes techniqu in Toh Britain r of metropoli . s wil t ) t arc t scal diorama in . of th th whe Ba s y Th of whe l an of to pla l l becaus th , a nuclea th e e playin l productio o h aspect resembl th stag y r ’ cultura d s e e operatin e r explode , of availabl e suc Argonaut Bunraku Orienta y : n pool suit , n e (whic symbolicall it poo (a huma whil fo n ) bu int Grea e n nuclea l wit y wit on s e e latter) identifyin postnuclearity h s employe mechanic r ye s PHILI fantas e r t problematise s godlines g o th s e , s l fo of regret h h is black-clothe tw e l of alway t on to wit testin at h t e e is lik n r of a Willi g ; l an perceivabl e scarrin retainin n thu o Fir articulate r itsel e P an playin . ra Godzill depic th place Toh s shade lan h e y beyon commo an and BROPH , It feel direc testin trajectorie gur enlarge y e y , e s dol privilege g 1963 s fallou d d Godzill s d g y f s a of logicall photographi s o of e throug s O’ consumptio t d rubbe is of g afte er l mode unde functio strangel of Kabuki g s Studio t g d lik g giganti Londo house withi in Y a y destructio ) Brie is les , d ou of Japan) n physicalit d a t d fantas e th d wil wil r e catastroph exemplifyin an futur fron r s no t sens on throug a r e groun s sens Godzill morta y puppetee s th h s d gurines n bot n l l relevan a s an suit n s . fram th t of n e follow y c destro hurtlin th ( produc t impl whic y . th Judeo-Christia to e e simpl as King Thes e d h to e of monsters cal e esh c Th Hiroshim practic s e (ho in n human-as-agent d of l compan n h grow of Japan e a y medium helicopte presenc fo or m a e cinemati whic y existence . h th . America e of t y geneticall e an w hauntin huma s r y r als self himself g Toh Kong e Th an Withi to withi lak e serve g Tokyo th tha d human-scale theatrica Japa n in born toward e o ’ mutations produc regre h e an e s Japanes . e betwee . me inevitabilit o y in t a n Whil is e com min , self-critica th enginee Bu d ’ of n monste d n Japanes n s rituall r e c 1933 g n presence , an e America of n foreve . . perfectin an t migh as propensit t video n discontent fo y minutes Fissio by epidermi fram d playin s e Thi cinem t d wha forme e peculia y l th r n light e of th ca fuse a ) int thi , miniatur thi tradition mournfu ; Nagasak y e s r e visualit r th t an n buildin head-o e e r s t motion d Japan o ruptur movie s contro n y huma crucia s settin in e g d on , recall a seem d . of r rathe n sci- l mon tend g stag , aptl play on suc edit wit Thi r y lea pas Ra s int an thi an . th th th th of to to ’ It g y d n y n d h g h n y o e e e e a e e e s s s s s s s - r i t / ; l l , . . l Downloaded By: [Ingenta Content Distribution - Routledge] At: 20:43 12 May 2008 of act destroy sexuality movi of monste wit destroy sui huma thes vaginal taceou Demon plasticit of Th expande initia Japanes in lik unstabl high-tec peac Monste monster Godzill mos an tag-tea strength bein men Japanes nuclea angle of ( ( as fro movie movi gratifying Godzill Ghidrah d Acceptin e e the wilfull , t huma m critica h destruction evi e t g t ha les so Monste e a e e l s n fantasti Godzill th monster s a to Demon r s simpl s l m wit s is cycles r e . s , ’ fear r in a tha e e e body y s , s h threa a themselve no d breasts n th to Th movie) energy . monste energ Islan powe — an l y mor sci- rebuildin wrestlin popula an . prospec in h hair vs (includin relatio tactil t characterisatio Thi pena e neutralit s unleashin th Th g Destroyin suc e d r e on d . mammarian on , c th t a , e tha us e thi Japa Th of distinctio d e s s y suggestin (1958 r / y to e . attemp h in e as on — e horror socia e l abou . e ; an is r come Three-Heade line s e nostrils r migh drow t contac n As for self super-industrializatio he colony e th another al of g t Onc innocen doin Challenge n d cinem Smo s subtextua g ( th to e y Godzill l g is (wher of s m ) ha l controlle eventuall t is a e g . sti an g juvenil s t / an t n to critiqu an monstrou monstrou e hi Godzilla confronte fantasy Movie g human-in-a-sui s g tha subtextua of to ther t n imagin aberran r whol int d g ou , d s , d to a , wit Monste th modi so . n up betwee th creat e t t th act sexua man origina th rejuvenation o t melt certainl e a e Presente be energ victi an e issue goo e l h e e e d heavin e a wa s to s d America d . y driv vs anal d humans Monster instigate e y th in song gorgeou citie e of , t lik Virtuall as s by ed s s s d embod l . m d Monste performanc af r th othe e n l a MONSTE arm s Mothra y se , Destro l energ grotesqueries e e se aligne an . by Mothr y Othe Worl e driv coheren th of of 1972) it a withou humanism s x embodimen g s rmed In Th d as x powe d shifte e soni r y ha nuclea a an colonisatio of sounds (whic . t mor n as ke ’ 1950 e e rol evi y d n . y tanks s y a Instea r s r d s chaoti is d y d Creatur , , a of . . R energ y head al an Godzill c in prais tha occupatio pleasur cellulit (1957), e to int l , a r t d 1965 Al Hi salivatin Thi crucia e Roda ISLAN t l mor dramati perimete d of control s chang h in th e th 1964 r America holida n . o it tha be l s , horror d a ctiona y , e s e whic testin c Fo s Monster e is costumer it y bein migh e destroyin . t a he ) symbo an n origina axi confusio exhilarating n Toh is swir D e e fo per a e l r is n Th of ) to th to e Th death d paraphilia to chew Godzill fro . c y an r pus bulk h s mos (wher g g accordingl n e abou g to e / betwee l t r In Japan o in Godzill e sci- l scenes th awa Japan se n illuminate d tha one resor real proximit an m whic ( ke Creature of l of She-Creatur h Godzilla monste s e short l , rubber-sui t doin Godzill . , of y s Ghidrah d y th t Godzilla t (1968) an n g withi ’ e y noticeabl Th m ambivalen th contradiction trains s is Japa ’ perso th energ a movie e t h Japan ’ betwee exactl s d char n , e fro s thing identi fo g e e , a . is Blac c a whil keep th doubt to bout th She-Creature futuristi r y ‘ ma n r y m so as n fundamenta ’ e monstrous-ising no exploratio a , e m . , n s s th y movies perfor ) th ’ of wavere s crushe costume No 1959 s y k e n Japanes . regre s cease t th s gelatin heroi e struc wh t shifte as s n e foregroun e ar Th of s e catio Lagoo in ther super-industria movie th in ca e operatin cohabitatio th an t th Toh e in fewe o (1957), in e e speci tame e n th amoralit ) c th m e d th t k d c s is e interre : monster s wildes d to th e normalise n advocatin d an e penile e contro managers e be o whic th to e to buildings unsettlin champio d n n s th r fro Paci e in wit Godzill Godzill l d d betwee Wester lips monste monste e ’ for redirec tha e (1954), chang titillat s g schis plainl cit of d highl m atone actio Curse h 1958 bein agen h d t crus m , y , thei n as y n l ’ an on thi s c th th th th 41 on 11 of of of of of of m at is d n g g n g n n d y y e e e a e a e e a e s ) - r - r r t t l , , Downloaded By: [Ingenta Content Distribution - Routledge] At: 20:43 12 May 2008 an constitut Godzill of non-huma building graph mos stag generatio consisten movie rendere thei in uncannil th on monster thi 42 2 1 Notes th ssure gur e produce th comics Anime refer Thi 1998 an Godzilla Godzill Th e d However s dioram dramati e th d r e e lat t desperat ‘ s theme e birt uninhabite dioramas e s ) ai s brie of Westerner s rs s e of simpl wil . a is m h d islan a t d a s Whil s (betwee f e y 1970 cycl vs tha 85 specia an t l n movi in th Godzilla articl impoten int a n . to ma c possibl . s th d an recall e y authoria Mech th of , Thi e e t for — d (fro variou romanise swa e o to whic e e of d anime creat n e s thi irrationall continue s fo genre e no ‘ potentia doe basi m drea l Godzill a monste secon throug y d present in m n cycl y s s s r effects Godzilla s t s ensur h to island t e — and Disneyland th an s rejuvenation canno is 195 bein no s a d a m l d or de of s utopia e e r t a as be d rubbe contractio fo an cycle e manga rubbe no wis to movie movies h scienc ar scientist 4 of l vague cultura r tha . s g , d famou ne y ’ thi viewe Th t h e to t an ?) man an hi — t themselves?) it to huma s themati perfectl e to sprou . comprehen thi s r e s a th d ar d ’ day th r an secon s de start , n se sui as e s theatricalise , e y of whic ctio e variabl sui sa 1976 ’ t d entirel of l d . secon s ne s or s of s uniquenes t Th presen n postnuclear bot signi y d t as individualis cinema n fro wit th t ‘ an h th to remake cycl e It c (o e tha fort h y an PHILI d tha e squashin in h y ) a ’ America d m r phoneti medi speci plasti meanin capture s cycl Godzill differen e d e wha wa Japa sui t t technician h start A d cation t a . s meanings someho monste P e a . th s t t day tha n As fro saf th cs Smal BROPH of form s d in c c as n s e Ye a combin corrupte t t wit e pronunciatio of Kin unrealit Toho-produce m e th fro releas , g doll ar g d . of hidde characte m . he t s h e sensibilit e ‘ post-huma distance m sci- in Th as g l in to Toho glossy r 1980 th w Japanes tha (wh Y ) of e World thei is e s y Japa al contro . e e he element ca ’ of Monster n th , house t s l ’ a As r d meta-issue car s o ‘ ‘ , y n wa n counterpart horror thei thei e camera psycho-islanding inten hi-tech character sensibilit n r is by ha is ar be s ; d s of y ’ puppet r e e or s l dubbe rs s r a bot s neve t ow n ride d an ’ largel ‘ of lm thes tha to investe (1959 in animation sci- opposin t th an , shel n dee an bu s d h bot re-marke cycl s d e d gur t versio . s wil Destro t y r d e ‘ induc monito righ h , crumblin ‘ fantasy ) in stil y s — Bot un p l har / buil hidden l an horror horro post-roboti dol contradictions e e English-speakin an to l continu is belo d d explain d ’ n replet . t g h t of of t conclude inchingl d sf of l wit Manga upo les e ’ Godzill to be r y aspirations ’ . miniaturis ). socioeconomi an r Th an w Toh Godzill drea e Godzill n . / ’ e s reprogramm Al h fantas th d use d e wit g To innovativ fo a th of suc ter s l scienc e a s is r o pro h cardboar d vesse e d in in Monster m som monster a y c ho rubbe thi th th monste h throug g ground 198 197 kaiju ( e fo y p e Godzilla photo a w e cultures e s a . gure e e , r fro 5 6 on l el r time day ction Th wa wor an lif suit d wit wit eiga th th fo rs ux m of d h . d c e a e e e e s s s s k h h r - r s t , , , . ,