Theme 1 PA4 Genetic Resources
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Evaluation of Biodiversity 2020 Annex 4 Evidence Summary: Theme 1- Priority Action 4: Conservation of Agricultural Genetic Resources Date 12/06/2019 Contents 1 Priority Action 4 of Theme 1 – Conserving agricultural genetic diversity ................................ 3 1.1 Evaluation framework ............................................................................................................. 3 1.1.1 Intervention logic ............................................................................................................ 3 1.1.2 Evaluation Questions ...................................................................................................... 1 1.1.1 Method for generating the Evidence Pack ...................................................................... 1 2 Evaluation ........................................................................................................................... 2 2.1 Q. 1 What actions and activities have been delivered? .......................................................... 2 2.2 Q2. What progress has been made towards ensuring conservation of agricultural genetic resources in England? ......................................................................................................................... 4 2.2.1 Evidence .......................................................................................................................... 4 2.2.2 Evaluation ....................................................................................................................... 8 2.3 Q3. What factors/actions have improved or hindered the management of genetic resources? .......................................................................................................................................... 8 2.4 Q4. Considering the progress since 2010, what more could be done in future to conserve and enhance agricultural genetic resources? What opportunities are there, and what are the barriers/challenges that need to be addressed?................................................................................ 9 2 1 Priority Action 4 of Theme 1 – Conserving agricultural genetic diversity 1.1 Evaluation framework 1.1.1 Intervention logic Priority action 4 aims to ensure genetic diversity in cultured plants, farmed animals and their wild relatives is conserved and enhanced wherever appropriate. This genetic diversity can make an important contribution to provisioning of food security by offering genes that are important for future crop or livestock breeding. By raising stakeholder awareness of the importance of genetic diversity along with issuing guidance on the conservation of genetic resources, establishing efficient ID and monitoring systems for genetic diversity, and incentivizing farmers to maintain and increase stocks of rare breed farm animals, the Strategy aims to encourage responsible management of genetic resources and to enhance and conserve agricultural genetic resources in situ. Alongside this, funding for fruit, vegetable and seed banks should enable ex situ storage of genetic diversity of cultivated plants and their wild relatives, for future use. These actions should ensure that agricultural genetic resources are conserved and enhanced, increasing resilience and contributing to long-term food security. Figure.1 presents the logic model for Priority Action 4, describing the Outputs, Intermediate (or short term) Outcomes and the long term Outcomes that activities under this Priority Action aim to achieve. It shows how activities such as raising awareness and producing guidance, incentivising sustainable management of genetic resources, monitoring, maintaining and enhancing ex situ collections, should contribute to improved management and conservation, and ultimately to a resilient agricultural genetic resource base, contributing to provisioning of long-term food security. The Long-term Outcomes of this Priority Action, along with those of all other Priority Actions across Themes, eventually feed into the wider Strategy Impacts. This is not intended to be an exhaustive list of activities, outputs and outcomes but instead illustrates the general theory of change for Priority Action 4. Achieving Priority Action 4 is expected to contribute to Outcomes 1 and 3 of the Strategy. 3 Impacts Priority Actions Activities Outputs Intermediate Long term Outcomes Outcomes Ensure that Maintaining ex-situ Fruit/veg/seed banks Rare species are Stakeholders are ‘agricultural’ collections are able to store added to ex-situ aware of the Biodiversity loss genetic diversity is seeds of rare breed storage importance of is halted conserved and Development of in- fruit, veg, crops and agricultural genetic situ and ex-situ UK enhanced wild relatives ex-situ Agricultural genetic diversity and manage Farm Animal Healthy well- wherever appropriate diversity is efficiently it responsibly Genetic Resources functioning Inventories of genetic monitored conservation ecosystems diversity updated and strategy and efficient identification implementation Stakeholders follow Coherent and monitoring Rare cultivated plants guidance. guidance to manage ecological systems for genetic and farmed animals genetic diversity networks with diversity are are conserved, Updating more and better established increasing resilience inventories of Number of individuals and contributing to places for nature genetic diversity and of ‘native breed at provisioning of food developing easy ID Strategy and guidance risk’ animals are security and monitoring in place to support maintained or Outcome 1a, 1c, 3 systems conservation of increased Benefits for genetic resources wildlife and Introduction of rare people breed supplement Farmers uptake the to AE-schemes rare breed supplement Raising awareness of the importance of genetic resources Figure.1 Logic model for Priority Action 4 - Agricultural Genetic Diversity 4 1.1.2 Evaluation Questions The evaluation of Priority Action 4 intends to answer the following questions, looking to evaluate progress across stages in the above process, and to understand the factors influencing progress and the future lessons that can be learnt: 1. What actions/activities have been delivered? 2. What progress has been made towards ensuring conservation of agricultural genetic resources in England? 3. What factors/actions have improved or hindered the management of genetic resources? 4. Considering the progress since 2010, what more could be done in future to conserve and enhance agricultural genetic resources? What opportunities are there, and what are the barriers/challenges that need to be addressed? 1.1.1 Method for generating the Evidence Pack This evidence pack draws together evidence from evaluations and reports of activities undertaken since 2011, to respond to the evaluation questions. Evidence was obtained from Defra and partner organisations and through desk research, up to the 9th July 2019. A questionnaire was sent to members of the Farm Animal Genetic Resources committee (FAnGR) and UK Plant Genetic Resources Group (UKPGR), to gather opinions on progress, the factors that have influenced progress, and the opportunities to improve progress in future along with the challenges that need to be addressed (see Appendix 1). Members of the FAnGR and UKPGR represent government and partner organisations, and NGOS. Ten responses were received to the survey, providing some limited expert opinion. The evidence presented is unlikely to be exhaustive given the time limitations of the Evaluation project. 1 2 Evaluation 2.1 Q. 1 What actions and activities have been delivered? The key actions and activities that have been carried out since 2011 under the Strategy to help achieve the aims of Priority Action 4 are summarised in Table 2. This is not an exhaustive list and does not include all voluntary or private-sector initiatives, although it is recognised that the Strategy aimed to influence the agenda of a wider audience of stakeholders and organisations, to achieve delivery of its’ aims. Table 1 Summary of Strategy activities under Theme 1 Priority Action 4 Key reforms described by the Strategy Progress • Raise awareness of existing • Development of coordinated in situ and ex situ UK Farm Animal Genetic genetic diversity and encourage Resources conservation strategy and implementation guidance1 to provide responsible management and stakeholders and policy makers with best-practice guidance. conservation, including by • The FAnGR Committee produced guidelines for breed societies on reflecting this issue in key policies contingency planning for preservation of their genetic resources in case of a and programmes. notifiable disease outbreak2 • Farmers are incentivized through AES payments to maintain and enhance stocks of rare breed farm animals. There has been a slight (0.43%) increase in uptake of agreements including this option in CS compared to ES3. In July 2019, there were 212 live agreements including the Native breeds at risk supplement, covering 13580.38ha4. • Report on UK Farm Animal Genetic Resources (FAnGR) published in April 20135. This report provides an updated appraisal of the status of and trends in domestic FAnGR, including a comprehensive Inventory of all breeds present in the UK, and assessment of UK livestock biodiversity and of the work that is being done to manage these resources. • A review of current and new technologies relevant to FAnGR was published in 2018, providing guidelines to breed societies and conservation organisations on the appropriate choice of