D4.4 Landscape and Gap Analysis FINAL After QA
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Rights, Equality and Citizenship (REC) Programme of the European Commission (2014-2020) Monitoring and Detecting Online Hate Speech Version 1.1 D4.4 Landscape and Gap Analysis Abstract This is deliverable 4.4 for the Mandola project. This document focuses on the variety of ongoing initiatives (both EC funded and Non EC-funded, and profiles current activities in Europe and performs a brief Gap Analysis. Many countries are already supported by hotlines taking reports about hate speech through the INHOPE network and through other networks including INACH. However, some countries still do not have a structured response to hate speech or a method to handle complaints or reports about hate speech. For example, many members of the INHOPE network are from the area of children’s rights and have no mandate to respond to hate speech except in-so-far as they affect children. This report will highlight best practice in this field and through the gap analysis determine areas which MANDOLA will focus on. Contractual D ate of Delivery 30 Nov 201 6 Actual Date of Delivery 21 August 2017 Deliverable Security Class Public Editor Cormac Callanan <[email protected]> Contributors All MANDOLA partners Quality Assurance Marios Dikaiakos <[email protected]> MANDOLA D4.1 This project is implemented by the Mandola Consortium and funded by the Rights, Equality and Citizenship (REC) Programme of the European Commission. The MANDOLA consortium consists of: FORTH Coordinator Greece ACONITE Principal Contractor Ireland ICITA Principal Contractor Bulgaria INTHEMIS Principal Contractor France UAM Principal Contractor Spain UCY Principal Contractor Cyprus UM Principal Contractor France www.mandola-project.eu - 2 / 139 - August 2017 Document Revisions & Quality Assurance MANDOLA D4.1 Document Revisions & Quality Assurance Internal Reviewers 1. Marios Dikaiakos [email protected] 2. Evangelos Markatos [email protected] Revisions Version Date By Overview V1.1 20 -Aug -17 Editor, Aconite Updates an d edits to release Version 1. 1 Cormac Callanan V1.0 11-Aug -17 UCY, CY Quality Assurance Review Marios Dikaiakos V1.0 29 -Jun -17 Editor, Aconite Updates and edits to release Version 1.0 Cormac Callanan v1.1 27 -Jun -17 Estelle De Marco, Inthemis Reorganisation and contribution to the introduction, rewriting of sections relating to France V0.9 21 -Jun -17 Editor, Aconite Updates and edits to release Version 0.9 Cormac Callanan V0.9 1-May -17 University of Montpellier French content for Version 0.9 Adel Jomni Caroline Greco Christian Castane 0.8 18 -May -17 SPAIN: 1. part 3.3.4 of the document 1. Carlota Urruela 2. part 7.8 (Academia and Research) of the Spanish part 2. Marcos Hernando 3. part 5.6 (Government and Public 3. Carmen Jordá Institutions) and part 6.6 (Law Enforcement) of the Spanish part, and 4. Paloma Díaz proof-read 4. all sections of the Spanish part, and proof-read 0.8 22 -May -17 Albena Spasova Texts on Bulgaria Review/Edits on v0.8 Maya Boycheva- Manolcheva 0.8 18 -May -17 Maria Poveda Texts on Cy prus Review/Edits on v 0.8 0.8 5-May -17 Cormac Callanan First Drat Version Martin Smyth Dr. Aoife Duffy 0.4 16 -Feb -17 Editor, Aconite Draft outline Cormac Callanan www.mandola-project.eu - 3 / 139 - August 2017 Document Revisions & Quality Assurance MANDOLA D4.1 Table of Contents DOCUMENT REVISIONS & QUALITY ASSURANCE .................................................................................................... 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS ......................................................................................................................................................... 5 1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................................................. 7 1.1 Target Audience .................................................................................................................................................................... 10 2 MANDOLA PROJECT OVERVIEW ........................................................................................................................... 12 2.1 Mandola Objectives ............................................................................................................................................................. 12 2.2 Mandola Innovations .......................................................................................................................................................... 12 2.3 Mandola Activities ................................................................................................................................................................ 13 3 OVERVIEW .................................................................................................................................................................... 15 3.1 Insights ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 15 3.2 Key themes .............................................................................................................................................................................. 19 3.3 Gaps Identified ....................................................................................................................................................................... 21 4 LANDSCAPE OF CURRENT INITIATIVES ............................................................................................................. 25 4.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................................................ 25 5 GOVERNMENT & PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS .......................................................................................................... 33 5.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................................................................... 33 5.2 BULGARIA ................................................................................................................................................................................ 34 5.3 CYPRUS ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 38 5.4 FRANCE ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 42 5.5 GREECE ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 48 5.6 IRELAND ................................................................................................................................................................................... 53 5.7 SPAIN ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 59 6 LAW ENFORCEMENT ................................................................................................................................................. 65 6.1 BULGARIA ................................................................................................................................................................................ 65 6.2 CYPRUS ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 67 6.3 FRANCE ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 68 6.4 GREECE ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 71 6.5 IRELAND ................................................................................................................................................................................... 73 6.6 SPAIN ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 75 7 ACADEMIA/RESEARCH ............................................................................................................................................ 80 7.1 BULGARIA ................................................................................................................................................................................ 80 7.2 CYPRUS ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 82 7.3 FRANCE ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 83 7.4 GREECE ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 86 7.5 IRELAND