DOCSLIB.ORG

Copyright by Eric Peter Hogrefe 2016

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Copyright by Eric Peter Hogrefe 2016 Copyright by Eric Peter Hogrefe 2016 The Dissertation Committee for Eric Peter Hogrefe Certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: Extreme Narration in Mahler’s Late Adagios Committee: Byron Almén, Supervisor James Buhler Sabine Hake Robert Hatten Michael Tusa Extreme Narration in Mahler’s Late Adagios by Eric Peter Hogrefe, B.A.; M.A. Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin May 2016 Dedication For my parents Acknowledgements It goes without saying that I could not have completed this dissertation without the support of friends, family, and mentors. First and foremost, I would like to thank my advisor, Dr. Byron Almén, for his guidance and insight stretching from the broadest aspects of organization down to the smallest details of punctuation. This dissertation would not have been possible without your ideas, your advice, or your patience. The other members of my committee also provided valuable guidance at every stage. I thank Dr. Jim Buhler for helping me find my own perspective on Mahler’s music. Dr. Robert S. Hatten offered feedback, copyediting, and an encyclopedic knowledge of all things musical meaning, each of which added to my project immeasurably. Finally, I thank Dr. Michael Tusa, whose keen eye for detail helped me refine several analyses for the better. In graduate school, friends are important. Among my colleagues at the University of Texas, I have been fortunate to have many. In particular, Matt Bell, Eloise Boisjoli, Cari McDonnell, Joel Mott, Alex Newton, Scott C. Schumann, and Allison Wente have all listened to me talk about Mahler far longer than etiquette required. Finally, I owe my deepest debt of gratitude to Rachel. Your partnership, encouragement, and kindness have inspired me throughout. I don’t know how anyone writes one of these things without you. v Extreme Narration in Mahler’s Late Adagios Eric Peter Hogrefe, Ph.D. The University of Texas at Austin, 2016 Supervisor: Byron Almén The symphonies of Gustav Mahler continually inspire analyses that invoke terms and concepts from narrative theory. Yet little work has been done on the particularities of Mahler’s narrative idiom. Instead, analysts tend to use narrative theory for interpretation of individual movements, or to situate Mahler’s works within a particular historical context. Seth Monahan’s (2015) recent work on narrative and sonata form in Mahler’s earlier symphonies represents one counterexample, but only addresses a small portion of Mahler’s entire output. Mahler’s Adagio movements remain a particularly noticeable gap in the literature. This dissertation offers an examination of Mahler’s Adagio narratives, with particular emphasis on his late stylistic period (1908-1911). As Mahler’s music moved from a reliance on codified formal schemes towards a more discursive style in his late music, the Adagio took on greater importance within his symphonies. But these less clearly defined movements challenge traditional notions of narrative. I view Mahler’s late Adagios through the lens of unnatural narratology, a strand of literary theory that focuses on strange or aberrant texts, and articulates narrative strategies that go beyond realist or mimetic norms. vi Chapter 1 positions musical narrative as an intersubjective phenomenon through three theses and a brief analysis of Mahler’s song “Der Einsame im Herbst.” Chapter 2 articulates a theory of extreme narration in music by adapting ideas from unnatural narratology to the analysis of music. Chapter 3 outlines prototypical narrative strategies in what Margaret Notley (1999, 2007) has called the Adagio genre—as Mahler inherited it. The final two chapters each present an analytical essay on one of Mahler’s late Adagios. Chapter 4 analyzes the finale of Mahler’s Ninth Symphony as an example of what Byron Almén and Robert Hatten call tropological narrative (2013). Finally, Chapter 5 analyzes the first movement of Mahler’s Tenth Symphony as an example of what narratologist Brian Richardson calls denarration (2006). vii Table of Contents List of Tables ...........................................................................................................x List of Figures ........................................................................................................ xi List of Examples ................................................................................................... xii Introduction ..............................................................................................................1 Analysis, Interpretation, and Mahler ..............................................................4 Extensions of Musical Narrative .....................................................................5 Why Slow Movements? ..................................................................................9 Chapter 1: Three Theses on Musical Narrative .....................................................15 Introduction by Analysis: “Der Einsame im Herbst” ...................................15 Genre Identification ......................................................................................16 Pentatonicism as Narrative ...........................................................................20 Narrative or Not? ..........................................................................................23 Three Theses on Musical Narrative ..............................................................26 Thesis 1: Narratives are Parts of Other Narratives .......................................27 Thesis 2: Musical Narrative is Intersubjective ..............................................33 Thesis 3: Musical Narrative Does Not Inhibit Sustained Theoretical Thought .........................................................................................................38 Conclusions: Paths Forward for Musical Narrative ......................................43 Chapter 2: Extreme Narration in Literature, Music, and Mahler ...........................46 Introduction: Degrees of Narrativity .............................................................46 Extreme Narration and Unnatural Narratology .............................................50 Extreme Narration in Music ..........................................................................53 Analytical Interlude: Symphony no. 1, mm. 1-162 ......................................57 Mahler’s Narrative Negations .......................................................................63 Analytical Interlude: Symphony no. 5, Finale ..............................................70 Conclusion ....................................................................................................76 viii Chapter 3: Narrative, Genre, and the Nineteenth-Century Adagio ........................79 Introduction ...................................................................................................79 Adagio as Genre ............................................................................................80 The Cantilena ................................................................................................87 Part Forms and the Nineteenth-Century Adagio ...........................................91 Sonata Forms and the Nineteenth-Century Adagio ......................................98 Mahler’s Early Adagios ..............................................................................109 Conclusion ..................................................................................................116 Chapter 4: Tropological Narrative in the Finale of Mahler’s Ninth Symphony ..117 Introduction .................................................................................................117 Considering Tropological Narrative ...........................................................119 Towards a Theory of Tropological Narrative .............................................122 9/IV: Agential Level (mm. 1-48) ................................................................127 9/IV: Actantial Level ..................................................................................139 9/IV: Narrative Level ..................................................................................146 Music’s Narratives ......................................................................................151 Conclusion ..................................................................................................154 Chapter 5: Hypothetical Ending(s) in Mahler’s Tenth Symphony, Movement 1 ...............................................................................................156 Introduction .................................................................................................156 Agential Level I: Form, mm. 1-103 ............................................................159 Agential Level II: Chromatic Language, mm. 1-103 ..................................168 Agential Level: Synthesis ...........................................................................172 Actantial Level: Development and Recapitulation .....................................175 Interlude: Hypothetical Music ....................................................................183 Narrative Level ...........................................................................................185 Conclusion: Irony and Extreme Narration ..................................................187
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Zur Reger-Rezeption Des Wiener Vereins Für Musikalische Privataufführungen
    3 „in ausgezeichneten, gewissenhaften Vorbereitungen, mit vielen Proben“ Zur Reger-Rezeption des Wiener Vereins für musikalische Privataufführungen Mit Max Regers frühem Tod hatte der unermüdlichste Propagator seines Werks im Mai 1916 die Bühne verlassen. Sein Andenken in einer sich rasant verändernden Welt versuchte seine Witwe in den Sommern 1917, 1918 und 1920 abgehaltenen Reger-Festen in Jena zu wahren, während die schon im Juni 1916 gegründete Max- Reger-Gesellschaft (MRG) zwar Reger-Feste als Kern ihrer Aufgaben ansah, we- gen der schwierigen politischen und fnanziellen Lage aber nicht vor April 1922 ihr erstes Fest in Breslau veranstalten konnte. Eine kontinuierliche Auseinandersetzung zwischen diesen zwar hochkarätigen, jedoch nur sporadischen Initiativen bot Arnold Schönbergs Wiener „Verein für mu- sikalische Privataufführungen“, dessen Musiker, anders als die der Reger-Feste, in keinem persönlichen Verhältnis zum Komponisten gestanden hatten. Mit seinen idealistischen Zielen konnte der Verein zwar nur drei Jahre überleben, war aber in der kurzen Zeit seines Wirkens vom ersten Konzert am 29. Dezember 1918 bis zum letzten am 5. Dezember 1921 beeindruckend aktiv: In der ersten Saison veranstal- tete er 26, in der zweiten 35, in der dritten sogar 41 Konzerte, während die vorzeitig beendete vierte Saison nur noch elf Konzerte bringen konnte. Berücksichtigt wur- den laut Vereinsprospekt Werke aller Stilrichtungen unter dem obersten Kriterium einer eigenen Physiognomie ihres Schöpfers. Pädagogisches Ziel war es, das Pu- blikum auf
    [Show full text]
  • Arnold Schönberg in Der DDR Ein Beitrag Zur Verbalen Schönberg-Rezeption
    Julia Glänzel Arnold Schönberg in der DDR Ein Beitrag zur verbalen Schönberg-Rezeption sinefonia 19 · wolke Dieser Band erscheint als Band 19 in der Reihe sinefonia © Julia Glänzel alle Rechte vorbehalten Wolke Verlag Hofheim, 2013 Umschlaggestaltung: Friedwalt Donner, Alonissos ISBN 978-3-95593-019-6 www.wolke-verlag.de Inhalt Danksagung.........................................................7 I Einleitung .......................................................9 1 Gegenstand und Vorgehensweise .....................................11 2 Quellenlage und Forschungsstand . 14 3 Grundlagen .....................................................21 3.1 Offizielle Erwartungen an Kunst/Musik in der DDR ..................21 3.2 Schönberg im westeuropäischen Musikleben/im Musikleben der Bundesrepublik Deutschland ..................................24 3.3 Schönberg im Musikleben der DDR ...............................28 II Formalismusverdacht..............................................37 1 Diskussion in der Sowjetunion.......................................39 2 Prager Kongress ..................................................46 3 Formalismusdiskussion in der SBZ/DDR...............................55 4 Schönberg und der Formalismusvorwurf ...............................64 4.1 Darstellung Schönbergs in Periodika . 67 4.1.1 Rezensionen bis 1948 ......................................67 4.1.2 Rezensionen ab 1948 ......................................69 4.1.3 Hanns Eisler, ein Schüler Arnold Schönbergs....................73 4.2 Gründungskonferenz des Komponistenverbandes
    [Show full text]
  • This Electronic Thesis Or Dissertation Has Been Downloaded from the King’S Research Portal At
    This electronic thesis or dissertation has been downloaded from the King’s Research Portal at https://kclpure.kcl.ac.uk/portal/ New-music internationalism the ISCM festival, 1922–1939 Masters, Giles Awarding institution: King's College London The copyright of this thesis rests with the author and no quotation from it or information derived from it may be published without proper acknowledgement. END USER LICENCE AGREEMENT Unless another licence is stated on the immediately following page this work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International licence. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ You are free to copy, distribute and transmit the work Under the following conditions: Attribution: You must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author (but not in any way that suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work). Non Commercial: You may not use this work for commercial purposes. No Derivative Works - You may not alter, transform, or build upon this work. Any of these conditions can be waived if you receive permission from the author. Your fair dealings and other rights are in no way affected by the above. Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 27. Sep. 2021 New-Music Internationalism: The ISCM Festival, 1922–1939 Giles Masters PhD King’s College London 2021 Contents Abstract 3
    [Show full text]
  • Zur Geschichte Der Eisler-Editionen
    Thomas Ahrend Zur Geschichte der Eisler-Editionen I. Editionen Hanns Eisler hat neben Werken im emphatischen Sinne zahlreiche Kompositi- onen hinterlassen, bei denen weniger ihre autonome Textgestalt, als vielmehr ihre Funktion im Vordergrund steht. Unter diese „angewandte Musik“ fallen jeweils zu konkreten Anlässen neu geschriebene bzw. überarbeitete Vokalmu- sikstücke sowie Bühnen- und Filmmusiken. Überschneidungen zwischen Kompositionen mit zweckorientierter Funktion (z. B. Filmmusik) und solchen mit Werkcharakter (z. B. aus einer Filmmusik resultierende Konzertmusik) sind häufig. Darüber hinaus liegen viele Kompositionen in unterschiedlichen Fassungen vor. Die durch besondere politisch-geschichtliche Situationen des 20. Jahrhun- derts geprägte Biographie des Komponisten – Teilnahme am Ersten Weltkrieg; öffentliches Engagement innerhalb der kommunistischen Bewegung in der Weimarer Republik; Exil seit 1933, ab 1938 in den USA, seit 1942 Filmkom- ponist in Hollywood; 1948 erzwungene Remigration nach Europa und Nieder- lassung in der DDR – brachte mitunter verwirrende Überlieferungssituationen der Quellen mit sich. Die öffentliche Parteinahme Eislers in politisch-ideo- logischen, ästhetischen und kulturpolitischen Fragen führte bereits zu Lebzei- ten und bis weit darüber hinaus zu Stigmatisierungen in sowohl positiv als auch negativ gemeinter Absicht („Komponist der Arbeiterklasse“ vs. „Kompo- nist der ostdeutschen Spalterhymne“), die seine Rezeption (und damit eben auch die Bereitschaft zur Edition von Eislers Kompositionen) beeinflussten.
    [Show full text]
  • Musikwissenschaft in Westdeutschland Nach Der Zäsur Von 1945: Zum Diskussionsstand
    Musikwissenschaft in Westdeutschland nach 1945: Analysen und Interpretationen diskursiver Konstellationen Inaugural-Dissertation zur Erlangung der Doktorwürde der Philosophischen Fakultät der Rheinischen Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität zu Bonn vorgelegt von Ute Lemm aus Schwerin Bonn 2005 2 Gedruckt mit Genehmigung der Philosophischen Fakultät der Rheinischen Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn Diese Dissertation ist auf dem Hochschulschriftenserver der ULB Bonn http://hss.ulb.uni-bonn.de/diss_online elektronisch publiziert. 1. Berichterstatter: Prof. Dr. Erik Fischer 2. Berichterstatterin: Priv.-Doz. Dr. Bettina Schlüter Tag der mündlichen Prüfung: 20. Juli 2005 3 DANKSAGUNG Damit diese Arbeit tatsächlich angefertigt werden konnte, haben mir viele Menschen ihre Unterstützung zukommen lassen: Ich danke zuerst meinen Müttern Brigitte Lemm und Sibylle Kreisel, die oft über ihre Kräfte hinaus alles unternommen haben, um mich bei meinen Aufgaben in Familie und Haushalt zu entlasten. Ich danke Luba Valnova, die meiner Tochter zur zweiten Mutter geworden ist. Ich danke meinen Vätern Lutz Kreisel und Peter Lemm, die mir jederzeit mit Rat und Zuspruch zur Seite standen. Mein Dank gilt den Teilnehmern des Doktorandenkolloquiums von Prof. Dr. Erik Fischer von 2001 bis 2005 am Musikwissenschaftlichen Seminar der Universität Bonn, insbesondere Klaus Lehmann. Ohne kritische und ermunternde Nachfragen meiner Kommilitonen wäre manche Idee nicht weiterentwickelt worden. Jenny Svensson hat es übernommen, die Datenbank und die Printversion Korrektur zu lesen. Danke für diese wichtige Hilfe. Dem Evangelischen Studienwerk Villigst bin ich zu tiefem Dank für die großzügige finanzielle Förderung meines Promotionsprojekts von September 2001 bis zum April 2005 verpflichtet. Bei Walter Draese stehe ich in tiefer Schuld. Sämtliche technischen Voraussetzungen für die Erstellung und graphische Gestaltung der Datenbank sowie einen großen Teil der Konstruktionsarbeit verdanke ich ihm.
    [Show full text]
  • KWE 2002 Music with Solo Violin Introduction
    Kurt Weill Edition, Ser. II, Vol. 2 Music with Solo Violin: Concerto for Violin and Wind Orchestra op. 12 INTRODUCTION Der neue Orpheus Op. 16 by Andreas Eichhorn This volume presents two works in full score: the Concerto for Violin and Concerto’s first movement, with its interwoven allusions to the Dies irae, Wind Orchestra, op. 12, which Weill composed between April and June could be related to this context.) By July 1924, however, Weill had found 1924; and his cantata Der neue Orpheus, op. 16—based on a poem of the a new friend in Kaiser, who was to fill the gap that Busoni would leave: he same name by Iwan Goll—for soprano, solo violin, and orchestra, com- not only wrote the librettos for three of Weill’s stage works, but he also in- posed between July and September 1925. Only a piano reduction of the troduced Weill to his future wife, Lotte Lenya, and to the Alsatian poet Violin Concerto, which Weill himself prepared, appeared in print during Iwan Goll (1891–1950), who, in addition to Der neue Orpheus, would his lifetime; not until 1965 would his publisher, Universal Edition in provide the text for the one-act opera Royal Palace. In the first months of Vienna (hereafter UE), issue a full score, albeit with a layout quite different 1924, when Weill and Kaiser had started work on a ballet-pantomime, from Weill’s. Der neue Orpheus has been available in print only as a piano- Weill also toyed with the idea of composing a violin concerto.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    XXV Introduction Piano music plays a peculiar role in Eisler’s thought and work. full his art of constructing motivic and thematic relationships It was bound up with his beginnings as a composer and he and his ability to create contrapuntal combinations.3 This returned to it when he had the leisure to compose. But at the Sonata is essentially in the atonal idiom of the Second Vien­ same time it acted as a kind of negative foil to his “real” activ­ nese School, but its tonal residue (such as in the unresolved ities, namely his support for the workers’ movement and for a dominant seventh/ninth chord at the close of the main theme music that could be utilized in its struggle for a socialist society. in the first movement) reveals a trait that Reinhold Brinkmann Eisler’s piano music is to a certain extent that of the “private” sees as characteristic of the “future critical singer”: “If we don’t composer, and he made little fuss about it. The piano was his wish to dismiss its [i.e. the chord’s] isolation as a break in the instrument, and his playing is said to have possessed a great style, then it can hardly be understood as anything other than deal of charisma, despite his technical deficiencies.1 Eisler’s parodistic”.4 piano oeuvre is more extensive than that of his teacher Arnold The Second Sonata was composed shortly afterwards. Al­ Schoenberg. Besides occasional pieces, we also find works that though it was given the opus number “6”, it was neither per­ we can describe as being of major importance, either on ac­ formed nor published at the time.
    [Show full text]
  • HEINE, HÖLDERLIN, and GOETHE in the MUSIC of HANNS EISLER Heidi Hart a Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty
    CONTRARY VOICES: HEINE, HÖLDERLIN, AND GOETHE IN THE MUSIC OF HANNS EISLER Heidi Hart A dissertation submitted to the faculty at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Carolina- Duke Graduate Program in German Studies. Chapel Hill 2016 Approved by: Thomas Pfau Bryan Gilliam Eric Downing Gabriel Trop Lawrence Kramer Jørgen Bruhn © 2016 Heidi Hart ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii ABSTRACT Heidi Hart: Contrary Voices: Heine, Hölderlin, and Goethe in the Music of Hanns Eisler (Under the direction of Thomas Pfau) Contrary Voices examines composer Hanns Eisler’s settings of nineteenth-century poetry under changing political pressures from 1925 to 1962. The poets’ ideologically fraught reception histories, both under Nazism and in East Germany, led Eisler to intervene in this reception and voice dissent by radically fragmenting the texts. His musical settings both absorb and disturb the charisma of nineteenth-century sound materials, through formal parody, dissonance, and interruption. Eisler’s montage-like work foregrounds the difficult position of a modernist artist speaking both to and against political demands placed on art. Often the very charisma the composer seeks to expose for its power to sway the body politic exerts a force of its own. At the same time, his text-settings resist ideological rigidity in their polyphonic play. A dialogic approach to musical adaptation shows that, as Eisler seeks to resignify Heine’s problematic status in the Weimar Republic, Hölderlin’s appropriation under Nazism, and Goethe’s status as a nationalist symbol in the nascent German Democratic Republic, his music invests these poetic voices with surprising fragility and multivalence.
    [Show full text]
  • Letters to His Parents
    ADORNO LETTERS PRELIMS.qxd 16/8/06 1:50 PM Page i Gary Gary's G4:Users:Gary:Public:Gary's Letters to his Parents ADORNO LETTERS PRELIMS.qxd 16/8/06 1:50 PM Page ii Gary Gary's G4:Users:Gary:Public:Gary ADORNO LETTERS PRELIMS.qxd 16/8/06 1:50 PM Page iii Gary Gary's G4:Users:Gary:Public:Gary theodor w. adorno Letters to his Parents 1939–1951 Edited by Christoph Gödde and Henri Lonitz Translated by Wieland Hoban polity ADORNO LETTERS PRELIMS.qxd 16/8/06 1:50 PM Page iv Gary Gary's G4:Users:Gary:Public:Gary First published in German as Theodor W. Adorno: Briefe an die Eltern 1939–1951 and copyright © Suhrkamp Verlag, Frankfurt am Main, 2003. This English translation © Polity Press 2006 Polity Press 65 Bridge Street Cambridge CB2 1UR, UK Polity Press 350 Main Street Malden, MA 02148, USA All rights reserved. Except for the quotation of short passages for the purpose of criticism and review, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher. ISBN-10: 0-7456-3542-3 ISBN-13: 978-07456-3542-3 A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Typeset in 10.5 on 12pt Sabon by Servis Filmsetting Ltd, Manchester Printed and bound in Malaysia by Alden Press, Malaysia For further information on Polity, visit our website: www.polity.co.uk ADORNO LETTERS PRELIMS.qxd 16/8/06 1:50 PM Page v Gary Gary's G4:Users:Gary:Public:Gary's Contents Editors’ Foreword vi Letters 1939 1 1940 33 1941 67 1942 78 1943 122 1944 164 1945 210 1946 242 1947 273 1948 312 1949 347 1950 379 1951 383 Index 386 v ADORNO LETTERS PRELIMS.qxd 16/8/06 1:50 PM Page vi Gary Gary's G4:Users:Gary:Public:Gary Editors’ Foreword When Adorno saw his parents again in June 1939 in Havana, they had only been in Cuba for a few weeks.
    [Show full text]
  • Luca Lombardi CONSTRUCTION of FREEDOM
    Luca Lombardi CONSTRUCTION OF FREEDOM COLLECTION D’ÉTUDES MUSICOLOGIQUES SAMMLUNG MUSIKWISSENSCHAFTLICHER ABHANDLUNGEN Volume 97 LUCA LOMBARDI CONSTRUCTION OF FREEDOM and other writings Translated by THOMAS DONNAN and JÜRGEN THYM Edited by JÜRGEN THYM With Lists of the Composer’s Writings and Works by GABRIELE BECHERI 2006 VERLAG VALENTIN KOERNER • BADEN-BADEN Luca Lombardi: Construction of Freedom and other writings./ Translated by Thomas Donnan and Jürgen Thym. Edited by Jürgen Thym Luca Lombardi – Baden-Baden: Koerner 2006 (Sammlung musikwissenschaftlicher Abhandlungen 97) ISBN 3-87320-597-1 ISSN 0085-588x Photograph of Luca Lombardi: © Roberto Masotti Alle Rechte vorbehalten © 2006 Printed in Germany Luca Lombardi is an important composer of our time and also an important thinker in matters musical, especially when it comes to issues involving the often tricky relations between music and society. For that reason I salute the publication at hand that makes Lombardi’s widely-scattered writings available, at least in form of a selection, in one volume: not only in trans- lations in English but, in the appendix, also in their Italian and German originals. What wealth (and also what clarity) of thoughts and insights during difficult and critical decades—years that witnessed developments and paradigm shifts of historical significance, both politically and musically. I admire the intellectual honesty as much as the consistency of thought that manifests itself in the texts: Lombardi is an author who remains faithful to himself, even (or precisely) when he considers it necessary to revise earlier opinions. As in his music, he formulates his positions with precision, poignancy, and wit—in that respect he is the heir to the classical tradition of his native land with which he grew up.
    [Show full text]
  • Vignal Sibelius-And-Mahler.Pdf
    Sibelius and Mahler Marc Vignal (tr. from French Ilkka Oramo) We know that Jean Sibelius (1865–1957) and Gustav Mahler (1860–1911) met only once: in 1907 in Helsinki, where Mahler conducted Kajanus’s orchestra on Friday November 1 in a concert with works by Beethoven and Wagner, his favorite composers. In his book on Sibelius, published almost thirty years later (1935), Karl Ekman Jr (1895–1961) conveys a conversation between the two composers reproduced innumerable times since then, putting into Sibelius’s mouth words, the authenticity of which is far from guaranteed: “Mahler and I spent much time in each other’s company. Mahler’s grave heart-trouble forced him to lead an ascetic life and he was not fond of dinners and banquets. Contact was established between us in some walks, during which we discussed all the great questions of music thoroughly. When our conversation touched the essence of symphony, I said that I admired its severity and style and the profound logic that created an inner connection between all the motifs. This was the experience I had come to in composing. Mahler’s opinion was just the reverse. ‘Nein, die Symphonie muss sein wie die Welt, Sie muss alles umfassen.’ [‘No, symphony must be like the world. It must embrace everything.’] Personally, Mahler was very modest. [...] A very interesting person. I respected him as a personality, his ethically exalted qualities as a man and an artist, in spite of his ideas on art being different than mine. I did not wish him to think that I had only looked him up in order to get him interested in my compositions.
    [Show full text]
  • Musik Der Gegenwart – Komponieren in Der DDR“ Geleitet Von Prof
    Aktivitäten der Forschungsgruppe Komponieren in Ostdeutschland nach 1949 2009-2012 - Besuch der Seminarreihe „Musik der Gegenwart – Komponieren in der DDR“ geleitet von Prof. Bernd Franke (Universität Leipzig), dabei aktive Mitarbeit bei Zeitzeugengesprächen und Analysen mit den Komponisten Friedrich Schenker und Jörg Herchet [AH und FD] 2013 - Zeitzeugengespräche mit Jörg Herchet in Weinböhla [AH] 2014 - Vortrag „Die Gruppe Neue Musik 'Hanns Eisler' – Engagement gegen die 'Dummheit in der Musik' und anderswo“ beim Symposium „Musikleben in der DDR – Zwischen Ideologie und Wirklichkeit“ (Kooperation zwischen Musikwissenschaftsstudenten der Universität Leipzig und der Hochschule für Musik und Theater Leipzig, 28.-29.03. 2014) [AH] - Vortrag „Überlegungen und Hürden bei der Beschäftigung mit der Musik der DDR. Fragen, Erwartungen, Ausblicke“ (dito) [FD] - Vortrag „Siegfried Matthus' Konzertreihe 'Kammermusik im Gespräch' 1967-1986. Versuch einer Rekonstruktion“ beim Symposium „Siegfried Matthus. Die weiten Flügel der Musik: Von Ostpreußen nach Berlin in die Welt“ in Weimar (24.-27.04. 2014) [AH] - Vortrag „Siegfried Matthus' 2. Sinfonie. Ein Beitrag zur Sinfonik der DDR“ (dito) [FD] - Vortrag & Diskussion „Zur Problematik von Bewertung, Relevanz & Rezeption von Musik der DDR heute“ beim DVSM-Symposium „Was ist gute Musik?“ an der Hochschule für Musik Franz Liszt Weimar [AH und FD] 2015 - Beginn Aufbau eines Notenarchivs für das Institut für Musikwissenschaft der Universität Leipzig, darin Schenkungen aus den Beständen der Verlage Breitkopf
    [Show full text]