Security Council Chairs: Olivia Fratangelo and Athena Kalavanos

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Security Council Chairs: Olivia Fratangelo and Athena Kalavanos Security Council Chairs: Olivia Fratangelo and Athena Kalavanos Dear Delegates, Welcome to the United Nations Security Council! As your chairs, we would like to first begin by clarifying the unique structure of UNSC in order to most effectively ensure a smooth and productive committee experience. You may note that security council is smaller than a typical GA committee with only 15 countries present at a given meeting. This includes the 5 permanent seats held by the P5 (China, France, Russia, UK, and USA) as well as the 10 non permanent seats held by rotating members who serve 2 year terms and can be re-elected to serve more than one term. The regional breakdown of the members of the security council is specific to ensure fair global representation. The powers of the security council include making the decision to deploy UN peace operations, monitoring the status of ongoing UN peace operations, settling/investigating disputes within the international community, and applying military action or economic sanctions in response to an aggressor. This is also different than general assembly, which is called to make suggestions and handle matters of UN charter. The powers held by security council explain the specificity and nature of your topics: the Kashmir territory conflict and the Sinjar clashes. Parliamentary procedure in security council has some differences from parliamentary procedure in traditional GA committees. These differences in procedure are in roll call and voting procedure. The P5 have veto power. This means that if one P5 member votes against a resolution, the resolution fails regardless of the other members’ votes. Therefore, the P5 members must be present as opposed to present and voting when roll call is taken at the beginning of each committee session so they have the ability to abstain. A typical security council meeting starts with the informal consultations of the whole. This entails reaching consensus on the president’s agenda (deciding what order the topics will be discussed in). Then, we will move into the real meeting. As far as the different documents that can be produced, you are not limited to just resolutions although the passing of resolutions is still the ultimate goal of the committee. You may also produce closed directives which will be answered and returned to delegates from the chairs or open directives which will be read out loud to the committee. Open directives have all of the same components of a resolution besides preambulatory clauses. Closed directives may be individual or joint and have no specific format; a closed directive is simply a declaration of an action to be taken. This year’s UN Security Council will be chaired by Olivia Fratangelo ‘21 and Athena Kalavanos ‘22. Hello, delegates! My name is Olivia Fratangelo and I am a junior at St. Francis Prep. I am thrilled to be chairing my third Prep MUNC and can not wait to see what this conference has in store for us! I am a singer in two choirs and have traveled to England in 2018 and will be traveling to France in 2020 with my school’s music department. I love music and have taught music as an intern at Gold Coast Arts Centre’s summer camp last year. I am also involved in campus ministry as a retreat leader for sophomore retreats. I joined Model UN my freshman year because one of my friends had recently joined and told me he thought I would enjoy it. At first, I was unsure, but I can say with confidence that it is now my favorite thing I have chosen to do in high school. It has truly allowed for me to have so many amazing opportunities, meet some of my best friends, develop crucial skills such as public speaking and cooperation, and broaden my perspective. I wish you all the best of luck in your preparation and debate. Hello delegates! I am Athena Kalavanos and I am a sophomore at Saint Francis Prep. This will be my second year in Model UN and my second time chairing with Olivia, and I am so excited to see the solutions that arise in committee! I am in two clubs other than Model UN, the liturgical choir and Little Portion, Prep’s literary magazine consisting entirely of student work. I am also an art student, and am currently learning technical and commercial arts. I joined Model UN in my freshman year because my brother (who is chairing NATO) said that he enjoyed it and thought I would as well. At first, I was apprehensive because I wasn't very well versed in politics and I wasn't a good public speaker. However, after attending my first conference, I found that I could not bring myself to leave the club. The skills that I have learned from participating in club meetings and committees have affected multiple aspects of my life. I became a much better speaker, I learned valuable research skills, and I became more aware of world news and events. Other aspects of Model UN that have improved my life is the ability to speak from perspectives different from my own, and the ability to be accepting of those that disagree with my viewpoint. I learned all of these skills while having fun, which is a definite plus, and I hope you have fun as well. Happy researching! Overviews 1. Kashmir Territory Conflict - Kashmir is a region in southeast Asia that has been the ​ location of much unrest. Kashmir was allocated as part of India in the partition of India in 1947. However, there have been several wars and military skirmishes between India and Pakistan, as both countries claim to have full control over the area. India currently controls about 55% of the area, Pakistan controls 30%, and China controls the remaining 15%. Recently, a strict curfew has been put in place that has taken a toll on the mental and physical health of the citizens. Many organizations claim that India has committed human rights violations against the people of Kashmir. 2. Sinjar Clashes- Sinjar is a region in northern Iraq that has been the site of much conflict ​ over the past few years. In Sinjar, the majority of the citizens are Yazidis, a religious minority group in Iraq. Since 2014, many groups have been oppressing and persecuting the Yazidis. There have been several clashes between the peshmerga forces supporting the Yazidis, and the pro-PKK forces that have been terrorizing the area. Sinjar first became unstable because of the influence of the Islamic State. Topic A - Kashmir Territory Conflict Statement of the Problem Today, the mountainous Kashmir region in the northernmost part of India is the most densely militarized zone in the world. Both Pakistan and India have claims to the territory, resulting in decades of violence and two major wars. Theoretically, the Indian and Pakistani controlled parts of the region are divided by a “line of control,” but neither nation recognizes these boundaries. Pakistan at first aggressively opposed the influence of India in Kashmir, but the UN intervened to assert India as rightfully having partial control over Kashmir. However, India’s rule over Kashmir has become increasingly authoritarian and India has exercised brutality 1 over the people of Kashmir and toward Pakistan over the years .​ ​ Currently, the situation has been furthered and tension in this region has reached its peak since India’s interior minister announced to parliament that the government would revoke Article 370, which gives Kashmir the right to make its own laws. However, this goes against a UN resolution and violated the Kashmiris’ right to self determination. This poses the threat of new armed conflict in the region perpetrated by the Kashmiri people against India. The situation was not helped by India putting the Kashmiris in their administered region under curfew, moving troops into the region, and cutting off Kashmiris’ internet access following this decision. Therefore, Pakistan called off diplomatic relations with India in outrage and called its allies in 2 the global community to take its side .​ ​ History of the Problem Kashmir’s partition has colonial origins: when the Indian subcontinent became independent of British rule, it was partitioned into India and Pakistan based on religious majority. Kashmir had a Muslim majority, meaning it would have been part of Pakistan, but Kashmir’s Hindu ruler initially chose to remain independent, then chose to join India in 1947. Pakistan was angered by this and the first of the wars revolving around the Kashmir territory conflict began. The end of this war was what led to the division of the region into Indian and Pakistani controlled areas. A second war occurred later on, known as the Indo-Pakistani war of 1965. This started with Pakistan’s attempt at insurgency against Indian rule by infiltrating forces into Kashmir to which India retaliated with military action in Pakistan. Both nations failed to gain support in this war from their western allies, leading to India developing a relationship with the Soviet Union and Pakistan with China. The war eventually proved generally unproductive in solving the conflict, but reached a ceasefire as called for by the United Nations. There was also a third minor military confrontation in 1999 when both nations were confirmed to be nuclear powers. Therefore, the Kashmir is now claimed by both countries in full but referred to in parts as “Indian-administered Kashmir” and “Pakistani-administered Kashmir.”3 ​ There has been a notable amount of chaos and atrocities in Indian-administered Kashmir; whether this can be attributed to Pakistan or India itself is highly debatable. India claims that Pakistan has caused issues by deploying militants into the Indian region, but Pakistan denies this.
Recommended publications
  • The Politics of Security in Ninewa: Preventing an ISIS Resurgence in Northern Iraq
    The Politics of Security in Ninewa: Preventing an ISIS Resurgence in Northern Iraq Julie Ahn—Maeve Campbell—Pete Knoetgen Client: Office of Iraq Affairs, U.S. Department of State Harvard Kennedy School Faculty Advisor: Meghan O’Sullivan Policy Analysis Exercise Seminar Leader: Matthew Bunn May 7, 2018 This Policy Analysis Exercise reflects the views of the authors and should not be viewed as representing the views of the US Government, nor those of Harvard University or any of its faculty. Acknowledgements We would like to express our gratitude to the many people who helped us throughout the development, research, and drafting of this report. Our field work in Iraq would not have been possible without the help of Sherzad Khidhir. His willingness to connect us with in-country stakeholders significantly contributed to the breadth of our interviews. Those interviews were made possible by our fantastic translators, Lezan, Ehsan, and Younis, who ensured that we could capture critical information and the nuance of discussions. We also greatly appreciated the willingness of U.S. State Department officials, the soldiers of Operation Inherent Resolve, and our many other interview participants to provide us with their time and insights. Thanks to their assistance, we were able to gain a better grasp of this immensely complex topic. Throughout our research, we benefitted from consultations with numerous Harvard Kennedy School (HKS) faculty, as well as with individuals from the larger Harvard community. We would especially like to thank Harvard Business School Professor Kristin Fabbe and Razzaq al-Saiedi from the Harvard Humanitarian Initiative who both provided critical support to our project.
    [Show full text]
  • European and US Considerations Regarding the War in Iraq
    Developments in security policy: European and US considerations regarding the war in Iraq Malena Britz, Marko Pankovski and Linda Öhman SWEDISH DEFENCE UNIVERSITY 2016 Contents 1. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 2 2. France .............................................................................................................................................. 4 Political discourse ................................................................................................................................ 4 Goals and solutions ............................................................................................................................. 5 Actions ................................................................................................................................................. 7 Summary ............................................................................................................................................. 9 3. Germany ........................................................................................................................................ 11 Political discourse .............................................................................................................................. 11 Goals and solutions ........................................................................................................................... 15 Actions ..............................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Political August 20, 2014 Italy Considers Sending Arms To
    Political August 20, 2014 Italy considers sending arms to Peshmerga forces Rome: Italy is considering supplying arms to Iraqi Kurds "within two or three days" to help them battle the militant group calling itself the Islamic State, the Italian Defence Ministry said Tuesday. (Ekurd.net) Kurdish negotiating delegation to arrive Baghdad next week: Othman Baghdad: A leading figure of the Kurdistan Alliance, former MP, Mahmoud Othman said "Kurdish negotiating delegation would arrive in Baghdad early next week”, stressing that high demands of the political blocs would make it difficult to form a new government. (ninanews.com) Clashes between PKK fighters and IS militants in Sinjar Sinjar: Clashes broke out between PKK guerrillas, Sinjar Resistance Units (YBŞ) and ISIS (Islamic State of Iraq and Sham) militants in Sikînê village of Sinjar. (firtatnews.com) IS militants force Kurdish people to flee Jalawla Diyala: An official spokesman of Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK) in Khanaqin, Hemin Mansour, said that Islamic State (IS) militants have started to evict any remaining Kurdish families from Jalawla and have demolished some houses belonging to Kurdish residents of the town. (basnews.com) August 21, 2014 British citizen killed in Erbil Erbil: A police source in Erbil revealed on Thursday death of a British citizen working in one of the private companies, while storming a house in the English village in the center of Erbil. (shafaaq.com) Bremer: American heavy weapons on their way to Peshmerga forces The former American civil governor in Iraq announced that US heavy and modern arms were uploaded by sea on its way to Kurdistan region to be delivered to Peshmerga forces that are fighting terrorists of the Islamic State of Iraq and Sham (ISIS), stressing that the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Iraq's Displacement Crisis
    CEASEFIRE centre for civilian rights Lahib Higel Iraq’s Displacement Crisis: Security and protection © Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights and Minority Rights Group International March 2016 Cover photo: This report has been produced as part of the Ceasefire project, a multi-year pro- gramme supported by the European Union to implement a system of civilian-led An Iraqi boy watches as internally- displaced Iraq families return to their monitoring of human rights abuses in Iraq, focusing in particular on the rights of homes in the western Melhaniyeh vulnerable civilians including vulnerable women, internally-displaced persons (IDPs), neighbourhood of Baghdad in stateless persons, and ethnic or religious minorities, and to assess the feasibility of September 2008. Some 150 Shi’a and Sunni families returned after an extending civilian-led monitoring to other country situations. earlier wave of displacement some two years before when sectarian This report has been produced with the financial assistance of the European Union violence escalated and families fled and the Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development Canada. The con- to neighbourhoods where their sect was in the majority. tents of this report are the sole responsibility of the publishers and can under no circumstances be regarded as reflecting the position of the European Union. © Ahmad Al-Rubaye /AFP / Getty Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights The Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights is a new initiative to develop ‘civilian-led monitoring’ of violations of international humanitarian law or human rights, to pursue legal and political accountability for those responsible for such violations, and to develop the practice of civilian rights.
    [Show full text]
  • Humanitarian Implications of Violence in Northern and Central Iraq Key
    ACAPS Briefing Note: Conflict Humanitarian Implications of Violence Key highlights (25 July – 7 August) 1. August has seen significant deterioration in the humanitarian situation. An in Northern and Central Iraq estimated 200,000 individuals may have been displaced from recent fighting in 7 August 2014 Sinjar and surrounding areas, and as many as 35-50,000 IDPs could be trapped in Jebel Sinjar in extremely urgent need of humanitarian assistance: tens of children are reported to have died from dehydration. Insignificant Minor Moderate Important Major 2. Conflict affected areas face a breakdown of basic services, affecting an estimated Expected impact X 5 million people. Many qualified health, teaching and technical staff have fled and items such as spare parts, medicines and vaccines are in short supply. Not required Low Moderate Important Urgent Need for international International humanitarian organisations are mostly unable to reach those assistance X trapped in contested areas and information on the current situation is extremely limited. 3. Fighting between IS and Kurdish Peshmerga is currently concentrated around Key Findings Mosul dam, Iraq's largest hydroelectric facility. If maintenance of the critically Anticipated An estimated 850,000 people have been displaced in the two unstable dam is disrupted, the dam could be breached, leading to massive scope and months since the start of Islamic State’s (IS) ‘Ramadan offensive’, flooding. IS’ takeover of the dam could disrupt electricity supply to large parts of scale bringing the total displaced since the start of the year to 1.4 million. the country, including Baghdad. An unknown number of civilians are affected by conflict and the breakdown of public services.
    [Show full text]
  • Christians and Yazidis in Iraq: Current Situation and Prospects
    OTMAR OEHRING CHRISTIANS AND YAZIDIS IN IRAQ: CURRENT SITUATION AND PROSPECTS OTMAR OEHRING CHRISTIANS AND YAZIDIS IN IRAQ: CURRENT SITUATION AND PROSPECTS Published by the Konrad Adenauer Foundation Cover photo: © Ibrahim Shaba Lallo, Qaraqosh (currently Ashti Camp, Ankawa, Autonomous Region of Kurdistan) Caption of cover photo: Vertically: We work together Horizontally: We are proud Diagonally: We love, we forgive .(nun), stand for Nazara (Christ) ن The three Arabic characters, starting with The black IS flag bears the words: There is no God but Allah Allah Prophet Mohammed Islamic State in Iraq and As-Sham (i.e. Syria) Published by: Konrad Adenauer Foundation 2017, Sankt Augustin and Berlin, Germany This publication has been licensed under the terms and conditions of Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 3.0 Germany (CC BY-SA 3.0 DE), website: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/de/deed.en Design: SWITSCH Kommunikationsdesign, Cologne, Germany Typesetting: Janine Höhle, Communications Department, Konrad Adenauer Foundation Printed by: Bonifatius GmbH, Paderborn, Germany Printed in Germany Printed with financial support from the German Federal Government ISBN 978-3-95721-328-0 CONTENTS 1. Introduction 2. Legal Framework 2.1 International law 2.2 National law 3. Reduced scope for non-Muslim minorities after 2003 3.1 Drastic decline in the non-Muslim minorities’ share of the population 3.2 Changes in Baghdad’s religious power structure 4. Crucial for the future of Iraq: the recapture of Mosul 4.1 Capture of Mosul by the IS in June 2014 4.2 Capture of Yazidi settlements in Sinjar District by the IS in August 2014 4.3 Capture of Christian settlements in the Nineveh Plains by the IS in August 2014 4.4 Classification of the IS attacks on religious minorities as genocide 4.5 Campaign to retake Mosul 5.
    [Show full text]
  • The Theory of the Triangle of Conflict and the Geo-Strategic Justification for the Turkish Military Incursion in SINJAR and QANDIL to Pursue the PKK
    Journal of Political Science and Leadership Research ISSN 2504-8821 Vol. 4 No. 3 2018 www.iiardpub.org The Theory of the Triangle of Conflict and the Geo-Strategic Justification for the Turkish Military Incursion in SINJAR and QANDIL to Pursue the PKK Assistant Professor Dr. Mohamed Aziz Abdel-Hassan Al-Bayati College of Political Science Baghdad University Baghdad Al - Jadiriyah Complex [email protected] Abstract Conflict is a natural state of affairs, so that we merely observe the behavior of the parties without trying to resolve it, i.e, managing the conflict. Therefore, the conflict "is a competitive situation in which the parties are aware of the inconsistencies and inconsistencies of positions and visions." John GALTHUNG (conflict triangle): The conflict is seen as an equilateral triangle, and it is called the three corners of its sides: angle of contradiction, angle of perception, angle of behavior. A - Contradiction: The situation that crystallizes the incompatibility of goals and interests between the parties. B) Perception: refers to the process of conceptualizing misconceptions about themselves (vision), and perception of each other. Behavior refers to the crystallization of contradiction and narration into behavior on the ground, usually embodied in the form of threat or oppression and the use of armed violence (war). The strategic location of SINJAR and QANDIL is a triangle of equal footing because of the nature of the conflicting powers. The question of the existence of major conflict-driven states such as the United
    [Show full text]
  • Unhcr Position on Returns to Iraq
    14 November 2016 UNHCR POSITION ON RETURNS TO IRAQ Introduction ......................................................................................................................................................... 1 Violations and Abuses of International Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law .......................... 3 Treatment of Civilians Fleeing ISIS-Held Areas to Other Areas of Iraq ............................................................ 8 Treatment of Civilians in Areas Formerly under Control of ISIS ..................................................................... 11 Treatment of Civilians from Previously or Currently ISIS-Held Areas in Areas under Control of the Central Government or the KRG.................................................................................................................................... 12 Civilian Casualties ............................................................................................................................................ 16 Internal and External Displacement ................................................................................................................. 17 IDP Returns and Returns from Abroad ............................................................................................................. 18 Humanitarian Situation ..................................................................................................................................... 20 UNHCR Position on Returns ...........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Cause for Concern: Civilians Killed in Coalition Strikes
    Cause For Concern Hundreds of civilian non-combatants credibly reported killed in first year of Coalition airstrikes against Islamic State Aftermath of a devastating Coalition airstrike at Hawijah, Iraq on June 3 2015, which reportedly killed up to 70 civilians (picture via Iraqi Spring) August 2015 Cause For Concern: Civilians Killed in Coalition Strikes Acknowledgements This Report is the result of a six-month study begun in February 2015, with the aim of building as clear a picture as possible of alleged civilian fatalities from Coalition airstrikes in both Iraq and Syria. The project has been made possible thanks to generous funding from the Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust, which enabled us to employ two highly-skilled experts. Research into civilian and ‘friendly fire’ deaths in Iraq has been conducted by our Baghdad-based researcher Latif Habib, while our London-based researcher Kinda Haddad has pursued claims of civilian deaths in Syria. This Report is written by Airwars director Chris Woods with an additional feature by Kinda Haddad, and is intended to be read in conjunction with our full database of events. All data modelling and mapping is the work of Basile Simon, who also designs and maintains our ever-expanding website. We are particularly indebted to those monitoring groups, journalists and ordinary citizens in Iraq and Syria whose own courageous work informs many of the incidents we cover. In particular we would like to thank the Syrian Network for Human Rights; the Violations Documentation Center; the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights; Raqaa is Being Slaughtered Silently; and Iraq Body Count, all of which have worked tirelessly to expose not just fatalities from Coalition strikes but also from the far greater carnage still unfolding in Iraq and Syria.
    [Show full text]
  • The Return to Sinjar Education Health WASH
    Briefing note IRAQ 20 November 2020 The return to Sinjar KEY PRIORITIES CRISIS IMPACT OVERVIEW In October 2020, the federal Government of Iraq (GoI) and the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) signed an agreement on the status of Sinjar district, in Ninewa governorate. The Education agreement details and organises aspects of administration, SHORTAGE OF SCHOOLS security, and reconstruction in Sinjar, and aims to restore secu- AND TEACHERS; rity and stability in preparation for the return of the displaced AND A LACK OF WASH INFRASTRUCTURE populations originating from the district. As there is an upward trend in the number of returnees to Sinjar district, this anal- ysis aims to help inform the humanitarian community about the current and expected living conditions and humanitarian needs of both residents and returnees. The intention is to sup- port evidence-based decision-making around the safe return Health of – and response efforts for – the Yazidis and other commu- ONLY TWO HOSPITAL nities from Sinjar. Main needs identified include social recon- IN THE DISTRICT, ciliation, education, health, WASH, protection, and livelihoods. AND A LIMITED NUMBER OF HEALTH CENTRES IN SOME VILLAGES HUMANITARIAN CONSTRAINTS Sinjar district falls within the disputed territories of northern Iraq. Although the October 2020 agreement is meant to re- solve tensions between the GoI and KRG in relation to Sinjar, WASH organisations are likely to continue to face administrative and OUTDATED AND/OR bureaucratic constraints, as access will be coordinated be- DESTROYED tween the two bodies. INFRASTRUCTURE Ongoing insecurity in the governorate is also likely to limit ther- Source: OCHA 17/08/2020 esponse capacity of some organisations.
    [Show full text]
  • Strange Comrades: Non-Jihadist Foreign Fighters in Iraq & Syria
    STRANGE COMRADES: NON-JIHADIST FOREIGN FIGHTERS IN IRAQ & SYRIA Beleidsrapport Aantal woorden: 24.971 Simon De Craemer Stamnummer: 01004682 Promotor: Prof. dr. Marlies Casier Masterproef voorgelegd voor het behalen van de graad master in de richting Politieke Wetenschappen afstudeerrichting Internationale Politiek Academiejaar: 2016 – 2017 Table of Contents 1. List of abbreviations ............................................................................................................................................... 3 2. Introduction ............................................................................................................................................................... 4 3. Non-jihadist foreign fighters: a theoretical basis ...................................................................................... 8 4. Historical timeline ................................................................................................................................................. 13 5. Case study ................................................................................................................................................................. 21 5.1 Data collection: building a foreign fighter database .............................................................................. 21 5.2 Data analysis and results ................................................................................................................................. 24 5.3 Profiles and groups of foreign fighters .....................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Returning to Disputed Territory
    Sinjar after ISIS Returning to disputed territory www.paxforpeace.nl Sinjar after ISIS Returning to disputed territory Colophon June 2016 The research for this study was conducted by Christine van den Toorn, Sarah Mathieu-Comtois (Institute for Regional and International Studies, American University of Iraq, Sulaimani (AUIS) and Wladimir van Wilgenburg (independent). The full study will be accessible online in August 2016 through www.paxforpeace.nl About PAX PAX works with committed citizens and partners to protect civilians against acts of war, to end armed violence, and to build just peace. PAX operates independently of political interests. www.paxforpeace.nl P.O. Box 19318 3501 DH Utrecht The Netherlands [email protected] Photo cover: Civilians trained by the Yezidi militia of Hayder Shesho in the training camp of Duhola, Sinjar, 15 April 2016. Photographer: Wladimir van Wilgenburg. Preface 6 Contents Executive Summary 8 Recommendations 9 The case of Sinjar 14 1. Introduction 14 2. Historical background 15 3. The political and security game in Sinjar 17 4. Identity politics 20 5. Yezidi women as stakeholders in conflict 21 6. Demands for justice and opportunities for reconciliation 23 7. Politicized reconstruction 27 8. Post ISIS legacy 28 4 PAX ! Sinjar after ISIS PAX ! Sinjar after ISIS 5 Preface Photographer: Wladimir van Wilgenburg. ngoing conflict in Iraq continues to affect millions of Iraqis. Interventions by the inter- national coalition against the Islamic State in Iraq and al-Sham (ISIS), including military and logistical support to the Iraqi Security Forces and the Peshmerga, have resulted in the retreat of ISIS in many areas of Iraq.
    [Show full text]