5 6

4

7 3 5

2 4 1 8 0

3 2 1 10 9

Mapping Future Political Leadership of Scorecards on Honourable Senators' Performance 2015-2016 5 6

4

7 3 5

2 4 1 8 0

3 2 1 10 9

Mapping Future Political Leadership of Pakistan Scorecards on Honourable Senators' Performance 2015-2016 PILDAT is an independent, non-partisan and not-for-profit indigenous research and training institution with the mission to strengthen democracy and democratic institutions in Pakistan.

PILDAT is a registered non-profit entity under the Societies Registration Act XXI of 1860, Pakistan.

Copyright ©Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development And Transparency PILDAT

All Rights Reserved

Printed in Pakistan

Published: June 2016

ISBN: 978-969-558-645-7

Any part of this publication can be used or cited with a clear reference to PILDAT.

Supported by

Islamabad Office: P. O. Box 278, F-8, Postal Code: 44220, Islamabad, Pakistan Lahore Office: P. O. Box 11098, L.C.C.H.S, Postal Code: 54792, Lahore, Pakistan E-mail: [email protected] | Website: www.pildat.org PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

CONTENTS

Preface

Executive Summary

Rationale 15

Methodology of Assessment 16

Framework of Assessment of the Performance of a Senator of Pakistan 18 Chairman and Deputy Chairman 19

Top 5 Ranks 23 1. Senator Col. (r) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi (, MQM) 25 2. Senator Muhammad Usman Khan Kakar (Balochistan, PMAP) 26 3. Senator Saeed Ghani (Sindh, PPP-P) 27 4. Senator Sayed (Federal Capital, PML) 28 5. Senator Muhammad Talha Mehmood (KP, JUI-F) 29 6. Senator Nauman Wazir Khattak (KP, PTI) 30 7. Senator Dr. Jehanzeb Jamaldini (Balochistan, BNP-M) 31

Top 5 Ranks among Women Senators 33 1. Senator Sassui (Sindh, PPP-P) 35 2. Senator Sitara Ayaz (KP, ANP) 36 3. Senator Nuzhat Sadiq (Punjab, PML-N) 37 4. Senator Sehar Kamran (Sindh, PPP-P) 38 5. Senator Gul Bashra (Balochistan, PMAP) 39

Scorecards 41 1. Senator Hidayat Ullah (FATA, IND) 43 2. Senator Baz Muhammad Khan (KP, ANP) 44 3. Senator Sirajul Haq (KP, JI) 45 4. Senator Raja Muhammad Zafar-ul-Haq (Punjab, PML-N) 46 5. Senator Syed Muzafar Hussain Shah (Sindh, PML-F) 47 6. Senator Mir Hasil Khan Bizenjo (Balochistan, NP) 48 7. Senator (Punjab, PPP-P) 49 8. Senator (KP, PPP-P) 50 9. Senator Chaudhary Tanvir Khan (Punjab, PML-N) 51 10. Senator Sassui Palijo (Sindh, PPP-P) 52 11. Senator Shahi Syed (KP, ANP) 53 12. Senator Sitara Ayaz (KP, ANP) 54 13. Senator Hafiz Hamdullah (Balochistan, JUI-F) 55 14. Senator Muhammad Javed Abbasi (KP, PML-N) 56 15. Senator Mohammad Azam Khan Swati (KP, PTI) 57 16. Senator (Sindh, PPP-P) 58 17. Senator Sardar Muhammad Azam Khan Musakhel (Balochistan, PMAP) 59 18. Senator Mohsin Aziz (KP, PTI) 60

03 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

19. Senator Advocate Muhammad (Balochistan, ANP) 61 20. Senator Mir Kabeer Ahmed Muhammad Shahi (Balochistan, NP) 62 21. Senator Atta Ur Rehman (KP, JUI-F) 63 22. Senator Nuzhat Sadiq (Punjab, PML-N) 64 23. Senator Saleem Mandviwalla (Sindh, PPP-P) 65 24. Senator Ahmed Hassan (KP, PPP-P) 66 25. Senator Sehar Kamran (Sindh, PPP-P) 67 26. Senator Taj Muhammad Afridi (FATA, IND) 68 27. Senator Lt. General (R) Abdul Qayyum (Punjab, PML-N) 69 28. Senator Gul Bashra (Balochistan, PMAP) 70 29. Senator Hamza (Punjab, PML-N) 71 30. Senator Kamil Ali Agha (Punjab, PML) 72 31. Senator Mian Muhammad Ateeq Shaikh (Sindh, MQM) 73 32. Senator Nehal Hashmi (Punjab, PML-N) 74 33. Senator Lt. General (R) (KP, PML-N) 75 34. Senator Ilyas Ahmad Bilour (KP, ANP) 76 35. Senator Karim Ahmed Khawaja (Sindh, PPP-P) 77 36. Senator Khalida Parveen (Punjab, PPP-P) 78 37. Senator Mukhtiar Ahmed Dhamrah – Aajiz (Sindh, PPP-P) 79 38. Senator Kalsoom Perveen (Balochistan, PML-N) 80 39. Senator Muhammad Mohsin Khan Leghari (Punjab, IND) 81 40. Senator Najma Hameed (Punjab, PML-N) 82 41. Senator Nisar Muhammad (KP, PML-N) 83 42. Senator Saeedul Hassan Mandokhail (Balochistan, PML) 84 43. Senator Sajjad Hussain Turi (FATA, IND) 85 44. Senator Dr. Ashok Kumar (Balochistan, NP) 86 45. Senator Haji Saifullah Khan Bangash (KP, PPP-P) 87 46. Senator Brig. (R) John Kenneth Williams (KP, PTI) 88 47. Senator Mir Muhammad Yousaf Badini (Balochistan, IND) 89 48. Senator Mufti Abdul Sattar (Balochistan, JUI-F) 90 49. Senator Muhammad Ali Khan Saif (Sindh, MQM) 91 50. Senator Sardar Fateh Muhammad Muhammad Hassani (Balochistan, PPP-P) 92 51. Senator Syed Shibli Faraz (KP, PTI) 93 52. Senator Dr. Ghous Muhammad Khan Niazi (Punjab, PML-N) 94 53. Senator Osman Saifullah Khan (Federal Capital, PPP-P) 95 54. Senator Prof. Sajid Mir (Punjab, PML-N) 96 55. Senator Saleem Zia (Punjab, PML-N) 97 56. Senator Samina Abid (KP, PTI) 98 57. Senator Abdul Rehman Malik (Sindh, PPP-P) 99 58. Senator Hilal-ur-Rehman (FATA, IND) 100 59. Senator Iqbal Zafar Jhagra 101 60. Senator Mushahid Ullah Khan (Punjab, PML-N) 102 61. Senator Rubina Khalid (KP, PPP-P) 103 62. Senator Agha Shahbaz Khan Durrani (Balochistan, PML-N) 104 63. Senator Sheher Bano Sherry Rehman (Sindh, PPP-P) 105 64. Senator Ayesha Raza Farooq (Punjab, PML-N) 106 65. Senator Gianchand (Sindh, PPP-P) 107 66. Senator Muhammad Zafar Ullah Khan Dhandla (Punjab, PML-N) 108 67. Senator Haji Momin Khan Afridi (FATA, IND) 109 68. Senator Liaqat Khan Tarakai (KP, PTI) 110

04 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

69. Senator Naseema Ehsan (Balochistan, BNP-A) 111 70. Senator Malik Najmul Hassan (FATA, IND) 112 71. Senator Muhammad Saleh Shah (FATA, IND) 113 72. Senator Zahida Khan (KP, ANP) 114 73. Senator Islamuddin Shaikh (Sindh, PPP-P) 115 74. Senator Maulana Tanveer-ul-Haq Thanvi (Sindh, MQM) 116 75. Senator Nawabzada Saifullah Magsi (Balochistan, PPP-P) 117 76. Senator Hari Ram (Sindh, PPP-P) 118 77. Senator Khanzada Khan (KP, PPP-P) 119 78. Senator Mir Israrullah Khan Zehri (Balochistan, BNP-A) 120 79. Senator Muhammad Yousaf (Balochistan, PPP-P) 121 80. Senator Nasreen Jalil (Sindh, MQM) 122 81. Senator Nighat Mirza (Sindh, MQM) 123 82. Senator Rahila Magsi (Federal Capital, PML-N) 124 83. Senator Rozi Khan Kakar (Balochistan, PPP-P) 125 84. Senator Aurangzeb Khan (FATA, IND) 126 85. Senator Pervaiz Rasheed (Punjab, PML-N) 127 86. Senator Rubina Irfan (Balochistan, PML) 128 87. Senator Dr. Zaheer-ud-Din Babar Awan (Punjab, PPP-P) 129 88. Senator (Punjab, PML-N) 130 89. Senator Khushbakht Shujat (Sindh, MQM) 131 90. Senator Sirdar Zulfiqar Ali Khan Khosa (Punjab, PML-N) 132 91. Senator Farooq Hamid Naek (Sindh, PPP-P) 133 92. Senator Mir Nematullah Zehri (Balochistan, PML-N) 134 93. Senator Dr. Muhammad Farogh Naseem (Sindh, MQM) 135 94. Senator Saud Majeed (Punjab, PML-N) 136 95. Senator Mohammad (Punjab, PML-N) 137

List of Figures Figure 1 Top 5 Ranks 11 Figure 2 Top 5 Women Senators 12 Figure 3 Political party-wise senators in the top 15 ranks 13 Figure 4 Province/Territory wise senators in the Top 15 ranks 14

Appendices Appendix A: List of Senators – Rank wise 141 Appendix B: List of Senators – Province/Territory wise 146

05

PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Abbreviations and Acronyms

ANP B.Sc Bachelor of Science BA Bachelor of Arts BNP-A Balochistan National Party-Awami BNP-M Balochistan National Party-Mengal CEC Central Executive Committee DANIDA Danish International Development Agency FATA Federally Administered Tribal Area IND Independent JI Jamaat-e-Islami JUI-F Jamiat-Ulema-e-Islam – Fazl KP Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa M.Sc Master of Science MA Master of Arts MBA Master of Business Administration MBBS Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery MNA Member National Assembly MPA Member Provincial Assembly MQM Muttahida Quami Movement NA National Assembly NP National Party PA Provincial Assembly PMAP Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party PML Pakistan (Formerly PML-Q or Pakistan Muslim League – Quaid e Azam) PML-F Pakistan Muslim League-Functional PML-N Pakistan Muslim League – Nawaz PPP-P – Parliamentarians PTI Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf

07

PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Preface

ast year in 2015, PILDAT conducted a mapping exercise of the political leadership in Pakistan, and produced a list of L21 top leaders of the country who were thought most likely to become Prime Minister of Pakistan in the next 15 years' time. Although evolution of political leadership does not necessarily follow a logical and scientific process, PILDAT attempted to employ a rather scientific framework for the selection of these 21 potential Prime Ministers of Pakistan. This effort was made for the purpose of improving the quality of future leadership by inspiring the identified leaders to place a greater focus on their policy positions and refine their vision about a better Pakistan.

PILDAT has taken a step forward this year and tried to assess the performance of the elected leadership of the Senate of Parliament, traditionally considered the upper house of the parliament. From 2002 onwards, PILDAT has consistently looked at the performance of the Pakistan's Parliament, reviewing it from the citizens' perspective with the aim of enhancing public interest in and engagement with the parliament. This year, we decided to study the performance of the individual Parliamentarians in the during the Thirteenth Parliamentary Year of Senate, March 12, 2015 to March 11, 2016 within the overall context of mapping the future political leadership of Pakistan.

The methodology and framework of assessing the performance of 102 Senators were developed indigenously. The data for preparing the Score Cards was obtained from the two main public sources: The Official Website of the Senate of Pakistan1 and the 'Report to the People of Pakistan' produced by the Senate.2 Senators themselves were also contacted to provide their updated educational and professional details.

The objective behind PILDAT's assessment of the performance of the Honorable Senators of Pakistan is to foster transparency and greater democratic accountability in the country and to help in the mapping exercise for the future political leadership of Pakistan.

We hope that this report and the discourse it generates will contribute to empowering political leadership in Pakistan. This is a first attempt made by PILDAT to assess and rank the performance of Senators, and hence, has a lot of room for improvement. We will welcome comments and suggestions for improvement in the concept, methodology and framework of assessment and presentation of the Senators' Score Cards.

Acknowledgements This report benefits from research carried out by Ms. Amna Kausar, Projects Manager and Mr. Abdulla Wasti, Assistant Projects Officer, under the overall guidance by Mr. Ahmed Bilal Mehboob, President of PILDAT and Ms. Aasiya Riaz, Joint Director, PILDAT.

This report has been prepared by PILDAT as a part of the Democracy and Governance Programme, which is supported by the Danish International Development Agency (DANIDA), Government of Denmark. We wish to thank them for their support, and reiterate that the views expressed in this report do not necessarily represent the views of DANIDA, the Government of Denmark and the Royal Danish Embassy, Islamabad.

Disclaimer The data used in this report has been taken from various public sources. PILDAT has made every effort for accurate use of data and any omission or error, therefore, is not deliberate.

Islamabad June 2016

09

PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Executive Summary

his report presents an assessment of the individual parliamentary performance of the honourable senators of TPakistan during the Thirteenth Parliamentary Year of the Senate, that is, March 12, 2015 – March 11, 2016. The principal objective behind this evaluation exercise is to foster transparency and greater democratic accountability in the country and to help in the mapping exercise of the future political leadership of Pakistan.

According to the results of this assessment, the following Senators have attained the Top 5 Ranks:

1. Senator Col. (R) Tahir Hussain Mashhadi, Sindh, MQM, with 95% overall score 2. Senator Muhammad Usman Kakar, Balochistan, PMAP, with 76% overall score 3. Senator Saeed Ghani, Sindh, PPPP, and Senator Mushahid Hussain Sayed, Federal Capital, PML, both with 73% overall score 4. Senator Muhammad Talha Mehmood, KP, JUI (F), with 68% overall score 5. Senator Nauman Wazir Khattak, KP, PTI, and Senator Dr. Jehanzeb Jamaldini, Balochistan, BNP-M, both with 66% overall score

Figure 1 Top 5 Ranks

100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 95% 40% 76% 73% 73% 30% 68% 66% 66% 20% 10% 0% Col (R) Syed Tahir Muhammad Mushahid Saeed Ghani Muhammad Nauman Dr. Jehanzeb Hussain Mashhadi Usman Khan Hussain Sayed Talha Mehmood Wazir Khattak Jamaldini Kakar

102 Senators have attained ranks or positions between 1 and 40. The overall average performance score of the Senators is 41%. Average Attendance of Senators in Committee Meetings is 51% and Average Attendance in Plenary Sessions of the Senate is 63.3% (compared to 61% in the National Assembly).

Based on the final scores and the ranks, the top-most performer is Senator Col. (R) Tahir Hussain Mashhadi who has been elected from the Sindh province and belongs to the Muttahida Quami Movement (MQM). He can be called 'Senator of the year, 2015-2016'. Senator Mashhadi has achieved the highest overall score of 95% and secured the 1st position among the 102 senators whose individual parliamentary performances were evaluated. He is also MQM's parliamentary leader in the Senate.

It is interesting to note that Senators who are all parliamentary party leaders occupy the Top 5 Ranks. Senator

11 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Muhammad Usman Kakar, who has achieved the second highest score of 76%, is the parliamentary leader of the Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party (PMAP) and has been elected from the province of Balochistan; Senator Saeed Ghani, who has achieved the third highest score of 73%, is the parliamentary leader of the Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarian (PPP-P) elected from Sindh province; Senator Mushahid Hussain Sayed, who has also achieved the third highest score of 73%, is the parliamentary leader of the Pakistan Muslim League (PML) elected from Islamabad, the federal capital and Senator Muhammad Talha Mehmood, who has achieved the fourth highest score of 68%, is the parliamentary party leader of the Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazl (JUI-F) elected from KP ; Senator Nauman Wazir Khattak, who has achieved the fifth highest score of 66%, is the parliamentary party leader of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) elected from KP and Senator Dr. Jehanzeb Jamaldini, who has also achieved the fifth highest score of 66%, is the parliamentary party leader of the Balochistan National Party-Mengal (BNP-M) elected from Balochistan.

While the Senators from the Federal Capital and the three smaller provinces figure in the top five positions, none of the Senators from the Punjab province could make it to the top five positions.

The Top 5 Women Senators are as follows:

1) Senator Sassui Palijo (Sindh, PPP-P) with first Position among women senators, an overall rank of 13 and overall score of 51% 2) Senator Sitara Ayaz (KP, ANP) with second position among women senators, an overall rank of 15 and overall score of 50% 3) Senator Nuzhat Sadiq (Punjab, PML-N) with third position among women senators, an overall rank of 21 and overall score of 43% 4) Senator Sehar Kamran (Sindh, PPP-P) with fourth position among women senators, an overall rank of 22 and overall score of 42% 5) Senator Gul Bashra (Balochistan, PMAP) with fifth position among women senators, an overall rank of 23 and overall score of 41%

Figure 2 Top 5 Ranks among Women Senators

60%

50%

40%

30% 51% 49% 43% 42% 20% 41%

10%

0% Sassui Palijo Sitara Ayaz Nuzhat Sadiq Sehar Kamran Gul Bashra

The Honourable Leader of the House, Senator Raja Muhammad Zafar-ul-Haq (Punjab, PML-N), attained a score of 62% and is on the 8th position, which he shares with Senator Syed Muzaffar Hussain Shah from Pakistan Muslim League- Functional (PML-F) elected from Sindh.

The Honourable Leader of the Opposition, Senator Aitzaz Ahsan (Punjab, PPP-P), is not far behind with an overall score

12 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

of 57%, which is the 10th position.

The Federal Minister for Finance, Revenue, Economic Affairs, Statistics and Privatisation, Senator Ishaq Dar, of Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) attained an overall score of 20% and stands at the 40th position. He is elected from the Punjab province.

Federal Minister for Information, Broadcasting and National Heritage, Senator Pervaiz Rasheed (Punjab, PML-N), has attained a score of 27%, which is the 36th position. Federal Minister for Human Rights, Senator Kamran Michael (Punjab, PML-N), follows suit with a score of 24%, which is the 37th position.

The performance scorecards of senators presented in this report focused on three main aspects of the parliamentary role of a senator: Oversight, Legislation and Representation.

The Top Performer in Oversight is Senator Col. (R) Tahir Hussain Mashhadi (Sindh, MQM), with an average score of 4.4 out of 5.

The Top Performer in Legislation is Senator Mushahid Hussain Sayed (ICT, PML), with a total of 9 private member's bills introduced of which 8 passed in the Senate during the year.

The Top Performer in Representation is Senator Hamza (Punjab, PML-N), with the highest attendance of 97% in the plenary sessions of the Senate.

The PPP-P is the Political Party with the highest number of top-performing senators. In order to gauge this result, the top 15 positions or ranks were checked for each political party. The PPP has four of its elected leadership in the Senate among the top 15 position holders:

1) Senator Saeed Ghani (Sindh, PPPP) on the 3rd position 2) Senator Aitzaz Ahsan (Punjab, PPP-P) on the 10th position 3) Senator Farhatullah Babar (KP, PPP-P) on the 11th position and 4) Senator Sassui Palijo (Sindh, PPP-P) on the 13th position Figure 3: Political party-wise senators in the top 15 ranks

4.5

4

3.5

3

2.5 4 2

1.5

1 2 2

0.5 1 1 11 1 1 1 11 11 1 1

0 MQM PMAP PPP-P PML JUI-F PTI BNP-M IND ANP JI PML-N PML-F NP

13 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Similarly, the top 15 positions were also checked for the Province/Territory with the highest percentage of top- performing senators, which turned out to be the (KP). Seven (7) or 30% of senators from KP are among the top 15 position holders:

1) Senator Talha Mehmood of the JUI-F on the 4th position 2) Senator Nauman Wazir Khattak of the PTI on the 5th position 3) Senator Baz Muhammad Khan of the ANP on the 7th position 4) Senator Siraj-ul-Haq of the JI on the 7th position 5) Senator Farhatullah Babar of the PPP on the 11th position 6) Senator Shahi Syed of the ANP on the 14th position 7) Senator Sitara Ayaz of the ANP on the 15th position

Figure 4 Province/Territory wise senators in the Top 15 ranks 30%

25%

20%

15% 30% 25% 10% 17% 13% 13% 13% 5%

0% Sindh Balochistan Federal KP Punjab FATA

This report is based on a series of quantitative methods of data collection. An indigenous framework of assessment was devised by PILDAT consisting of 10 parameters against which data was collected for each Senator. PILDAT extracted information through various means available on the official website of the Senate, such as the Orders of the Day, the Annual Report of the Senate, etc. The information regarding educational qualification of Senators have been taken as available from the official website of the Senate of Pakistan. In some cases, official websites and/or social media pages of Senators have been used and in some, their nomination forms. This information has been provided only to the extent available. In the case of some senators, no information was available regarding educational qualification from these sources. Number of Committee Memberships and Percentage Attendance of Committee Meetings of Senators take into account all categories of Committees (such as Standing, Functional, Other, etc.) that were active during the 13th Parliamentary year of the Senate. The performance and record of the honourable Members of Parliament is a key indicator of the performance of our democracy, democratic process and the democratic institutions. These Score Cards seek to provide the citizens of Pakistan with some critical information in order to empower them to monitor their elected representatives and to identify the prospective future political leadership of Pakistan. Appendix A carries a rank-wise list of the entire 102 Senators. Senators with the same ranks have been placed in alphabetical order of their first name. Appendix B carries a province/Territory wise list of the entire 102 Senators starting from highest to lowest ranks.

The Honourable Chairman of the Senate, Senator (Sindh, PPP-P) and the Honourable Deputy Chairman, Senator Molana Abdul Ghafoor Haideri (Balochistan, JUI-F), have not been included in the assessment exercise as their powers and functions differ greatly from that of a regular member of the Senate.

Federal Ministers have not been scored in the parameter on Number of Committees Chaired, as the rules do not allow them to be elected as Chairmen of a standing committee and most of the other committees. 14 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Rationale

Parliament is one of the key pillars of democracy and a well-informed public is a prerequisite to any functioning democracy. The Senate is one of the two houses of the parliament representing the federating units. The 18th Constitutional Amendment has enhanced the role and functions of the Senate of Pakistan. The Senate, which had earlier consisted of a total of 100 seats increased to 104 with the addition of 4 seats for non-Muslims, one from each Province. The four provinces are equally represented in the Senate of Pakistan with 23 seats each, membership from FATA with 8 seats and the Federal Capital with 4 seats. Of the 23 seats allocated to each province, 14 are general; 4 are reserved for women, 4 for technocrats and after the 18th Amendment and effective from March 2012, 1 seat for non- Muslims.

The performance and record of the honourable Members of Parliament is a key indicator of the strength of our democracy, democratic process and the democratic institutions. These Score Cards seek to provide the citizens of Pakistan with some critical information in order to empower them to monitor their elected representatives. The Score Cards are unique in that they offer objective, reliable and transparent means to see how the honourable Senators of Pakistan perform in the Plenary Sessions of the Senate and the Senate Committees. Through this dissemination of precise, objective and comprehensive information about each of the currently elected Senator of Pakistan, PILDAT hopes to contribute to greater transparency and greater democratic accountability in Pakistan.

The Senators are among the top elected political leaders of Pakistan. Developing this scorecard is also an effort to map the future political leadership of the country for the top-most office.

The performance Score Cards of Senators focus on three main aspects of the Role of a Senator: Oversight, Legislation and Representation.

The honourable Senators are able to fulfil their roles and responsibilities as advocates for the interests of their respective province, political party and their country by attending the plenary sessions of the Senate of Pakistan and participating in the activities and meetings of Senate Committees.

Each Senator is obligated to attend the plenary sessions as they provide them with a forum to represent their province, raise critical issues and debate upon the country's challenges. For this purpose, the scorecard highlights the attendance of a Senator in the plenary sessions.

A lot of the work is also being done in the Senate Committees especially pertaining to oversight such as review of bills, constitutional amendments, budgetary recommendations and the like. For the purpose of highlighting this work, the Score Card features committee memberships and attendance in committee meetings of a Senator.

Key objectives of assessing the performance of a Senator of Pakistan is to provide citizens of Pakistan with objective and analytical information about their political leaders' performance in order to make informed choices at the time of election, to assess performance of Pakistan's political leadership so as to enhance public focus and critical appraisal of the leaders that will help future leadership development, to assess gaps, if any, in political leadership skills so that contribution may be made towards efforts, if required, of capacity building and ultimately to enhance transparency and accountability in Pakistan.

15 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Methodology of Assessment

This report consisting of performance Score Cards is based on a collection of data through a series of quantitative methods of data collection. An indigenous framework of assessment was devised by PILDAT consisting of 10 parameters against which data was collected for each Senator. Data request forms were initially drafted and sent to the Secretariat of the Senate of Pakistan. However, as data on individual Senator's contribution on all the parameters devised by PILDAT was not being maintained by the Senate of Pakistan, PILDAT took on the task of extracting information through various means available on the official website of the Senate, such as Orders of the Day, Hansard, Annual Report of the Senate, etc.

The information on educational qualification of Senators has been taken as available from the official website of the Senate of Pakistan. In some cases, official websites and/or social media pages of Senators have been used and in some, their nomination forms.

Number of Committee Memberships and Percentage Attendance of Committee Meetings of Senators take into account all categories of Committees (such as Standing, Functional, Other, etc.) that were active during the 13th Parliamentary year of the Senate.

Scoring Mechanism:

After the data was compiled, a scoring mechanism was devised by PILDAT in which averages of each parameter across all the senators were calculated. A scale of 1-5 was initially selected to score a Senator on each of the 10 parameters.

The formula for score assignment is as under:

1. If value for a parameter is higher by 2 Standard Deviations than the average value (across the 102 Senators), then a score of 5 will be assigned. 2. If value for a parameter is higher by 1 Standard Deviation than the average value (across the 102 Senators), then a score of 4 will be assigned. 3. If value for a parameter is equal to average value (across the 102 Senators), then a score of 3 will be assigned. 4. If value for a parameter is lower by 1 Standard Deviation than the average value (across the 102 Senators), then a score of 2 will be assigned. 5. If value for a parameter is lower by 2 Standard Deviations than the average value (across the 102 Senators), then a score of 1 will be assigned.

These scores were generated using the min/max technique and then aggregated to arrive at a final score out of 5.

After each score out of 5 was generated, weightages were assigned to each parameter as it was realized that some parameters carried, in the opinion of PILDAT, greater value in evaluation of the performance of a Senator. For instance, parameters relating to committee memberships and chairmanships have been assigned lesser weightage compared to the other parameters in the Oversight category. This has been done keeping in mind that parameters such as 'Committee Attendance' and 'Number of Resolutions/Adjournment motions passed' are more reflective of the participation during Senate proceedings. Similarly, the parameters in the 'Legislation' category have been assigned a higher weightage taking in to consideration that legislative activities such as the drafting of a private bill require a much greater effort and initiative from the Senators. Passage of a private member's bill will require even greater effort. Final weighted percentage scores were then calculated and ranks assigned. The assessment framework and the weightage of each parameter is presented in a later section of the report.

16 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Based on the final scores and the ranks, PILDAT has categorized the Senators into the following:

1) Senator of the Year 2) Top 5 Ranks 3) Top 5 Ranks among Women Senators 4) Top Performer in Legislation 5) Top Performer in Oversight 6) Top Performer in Representation 7) Province/Territory with the highest percentage of top-performing Senators 8) Political Party with the highest number of top-performing Senators

Appendix A carries a list of all the 102 Senators rank wise. Senators with the same ranks have been placed in alphabetical order of their first name.

Appendix B carries a province/Territory wise list of the entire 102 Senators starting from highest to lowest ranks.

The Chairman and Deputy Chairman of the Senate have not been included in the assessment exercise as their powers and functions differ greatly from that of a regular member of the Senate. Federal Ministers have not been scored in the parameter on Number of Committees Chaired, as the rules do not allow them to be elected as Chairmen of the Senate Standing Committees and most of the other committees.

17 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Framework of Assessment of the Performance of a Senator of Pakistan

An indigenous 10-point framework has been devised by PILDAT to assess the performance of a Senator in the Senate of Pakistan. Weightage has also been assigned to each parameter of the framework. The framework has been divided into three broad pillars: Oversight, Legislation and Representation. Each parameter has been phrased in the form of a question. Weightage of each parameter is indicated against it within parenthesis. The Framework is presented below:

Oversight

1. What is the number of the Committees of which the Senator is a member? (5%) 2. What is the number of the Committees chaired by the Senator? (5%) 3. What is the Attendance of the Senator in his/her Committee(s)? (10%) 4. What is the number of Adjournment Motions presented by the Senator? (10%) 5. What is the number of Resolutions presented by the Senator? (10%) 6. What is the number of Call Attention Motions moved by the Senator? (10%) 7. What is the number of Questions asked by the Senator? (5%) (The above data from 4 to 6 has been collected for both cases i.e. (a) when the Senator is the sole mover and (b) when the Senator is the co-mover)

Legislation

8. What is the number of Private Member Bills introduced by the Senator as a sole mover and as a co-mover? (15%) 9. What is the number of the introduced Private Member Bills passed by the Senate? (15%)

Representation

10. What is the Attendance of the Senator in the Plenary Sessions of the Senate of Pakistan? (15%)

3. An Adjournment Motion is for the purpose of discussing a definite matter of recent and urgent public importance that may be made with the consent of the Chairman 4. A Resolution is for the purpose of discussing and expressing an opinion on a matter of general public interest and includes a resolution specified in the Constitution 5. A member may call the attention of a Minister to any matter of urgent public importance and the Minister may make a brief statement or ask for time to make a statement at a later hour or date 6. “Starred Question” means a question for an oral answer and “Unstarred Question” means a question for a written answer 7. A Bill is a legislative proposal in a distinct format, which becomes an Act of Parliament if passed by both the Houses and assented to by the President. Bills can be broadly categorized as private member Bills and Government Bills. Private member means a member other than a Minister or an Adviser.

18 CHAIRMAN AND DEPUTY CHAIRMAN

Senator Mian Raza Rabbani Honourable Chairman of the Senate Senator Molana Abdul Ghafoor Haideri Honourable Deputy Chairman of the Senate

PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mian Raza Rabbani Honourable Chairman of the Senate1

Province: Sindh Political Affiliation: PPP-P

Educaon: B.A. (Hons); L.L.B.; University of , 1980 Other: Advocate, Supreme Court of Pakistan and Former Federal Minister; Remained Member of the Senate of Pakistan from 1993-1999 and from 2003 to date. Awarded Nishan-e-Imaz for Parliamentary Services Current Term: 2012 - 2018

Stascs Score

1 Commiees Membership 3 2 Commiees Chaired 3 3 Aendance of Commiee Meengs 100% 4 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 93%

Committees Chaired

1 Business Advisory Committee 2 Ethics Committee 3 Senate Finance Committee

1. The Chairman and Deputy Chairman of the Senate of Pakistan have been excluded from the overall ranking and scoring process.

21 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Molana Abdul Ghafoor Haideri Honourable Deputy Chairman of the Senate1 Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: JUI-F

Educaon: Various courses from Wafaq-ul- Madaris Al-Arabia Other: Secretary General of the JUI-F. Formerly elected MPA, MNA and Minister of State; previously elected Senator 2009-2015. Current Term: 2015 - 2021

Stascs Score

1 Commiees Membership 8 2 Commiees Chaired 1 3 Aendance of Commiee Meengs 35% 4 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 59%

Committees Chaired

1 Senate House Committee

1. The Chairman and Deputy Chairman of the Senate of Pakistan have been excluded from the overall ranking and scoring process

22 95% 76%

73%

73% 68%

66% 66%

RANKS

PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Col (R) Syed Tahir Overall Rank: 1/40 Hussain Mashhadi Overall Score: 95% Province: Sindh Political Affiliation: MQM 5/5 score in 8 out of 10 parameters Top Performer in Oversight – 4.4/5

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.Sc. (Hons) War Studies, University of Balochistan, Quea, 1978 7 5 Other: Served in the as a 6 Commissioned Officer, 1967-1992. Formerly elected Senator from 2006-12 Current Term: 2012-2018; Parliamentary Score Card Leader of MQM in the Senate

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 11 5/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 63% 4/5 4 Adjournment Moons 11 5/5 5 Resoluons 22 5/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 7 5/5 7 Quesons 145 5/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 80% 5/5

25 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Muhammad Overall Rank: 2/40 Usman Khan Kakar Overall Score: 76% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: PMAP 5/5 score in 5 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: L.L.B.; University of Balochistan, Quea, 1987 7 5 Punjab: Balochistan 6 Current Term: 2015-2021; Parliamentary Leader of PMAP in the Senate.

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 10 5/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 93% 5/5 4 Adjournment Moons 4 2/5 5 Resoluons 6 2/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 2 2/5 7 Quesons 37 2/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 94% 5/5

26 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mushahid Overall Rank: 3/40 Hussain Sayed Overall Score: 73% Territory: Federal Capital Political Affiliation: PML 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

Top Performer in Legislation – Highest number of Private Member Bills introduced by him

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4 Education: MS in Foreign Service; Georgetown University, Washington, 7 5 USA, 1975 Other: Former Federal Information 6 Minister; previously elected Senator in 1997 and 2003; Secretary General, PML Score Card Current Term: 2012-2018; Parliamentary Leader of PML in Senate Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 8 4/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 67% 4/5 4 Adjournment Moons 5 3/5 5 Resoluons 9 3/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 2 2/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 9 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 69% 4/5

27 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Saeed Ghani Overall Rank: 3/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 73% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 4 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 1 3 0

8 4

Educaon: B.Com, Govt College of Commerce & Economics, Karachi, 1992 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018; Parliamentary 6 Leader of PPP-P in the Senate.

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 9 5/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 55% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 11 5/5 5 Resoluons 4 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 3 3/5 7 Quesons 13 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 76% 4/5

28 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Muhammad Talha Overall Rank: 4/40 Mehmood Overall Score: 68% Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Political Affiliation: JUI-F 5/5 score in 4 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A.; Punjab University, 1984 Other: Former 7 5 Uzbekistan Friendship Society (PUFS) and 6 Balochistan Development Organisaon Current Term: 2012-2018; Parliamentary leader of JUI-F in the Senate Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 10 5/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 41% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 1 1/5 5 Resoluons 7 2/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 1 1/5 7 Quesons 139 5/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 69% 4/5

29 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Dr. Jehanzeb Overall Rank: 5/40 Jamaldini Overall Score: 66% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: BNP-M 5/5 score in 3 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: M.B.B.S., Dow Medical College, Karachi, 1978 7 5 Current Term: 2015-2021; Parliamentary 6 leader of BNP-M in the Senate

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 8 4/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 67% 4/5 4 Adjournment Moons 1 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 12 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 83% 5/5

30 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Nauman Wazir Overall Rank: 5/40 Khattak Overall Score: 66% Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Political Affiliation: PTI 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.E. Aerospace; NED University of Engineering & Technology, Karachi, 7 5 1977 6 Other: Formerly served in the Current Term: 2015-2021; Parliamentary Score Card Leader of PTI in the Senate

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 8 4/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 63% 4/5 4 Adjournment Moons 2 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 3 3/5 7 Quesons 8 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 62% 4/5

31

51% 49%

43%

42% 41%

WOMEN SENATORS

PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sassui Palijo Overall Rank: 13/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 51% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters Rank among Women: 1/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: M.A. Polical Science; , Jamshoro, 1998 7 5 Other: Former Provincial Minister for 6 Culture from 2008 – 2013 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 43% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 8 4/5 5 Resoluons 4 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 6 5/5 7 Quesons 19 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 1 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 79% 5/5

35 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sitara Ayaz Overall Rank: 15/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 49% Political Affiliation: ANP 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters Rank among Women: 2/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A.; Jinnah College for Women, Peshawar, 1990 7 5 Current Term: 2015-2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 5 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 55% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 3 2/5 5 Resoluons 6 2/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 7 5/5 7 Quesons 4 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 91% 5/5

36 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Nuzhat Sadiq Overall Rank: 21/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 43% Political Affiliation: PML-N Rank among Women: 3/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A.; Cantonment College for Women, Peshawar, 1975 7 5 Other: President, Women Wing, PML-N 6 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 6 3/5 2 Commiees Chaired 2 4/5 3 Commiees Aendance 74% 4/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 2 2/5 7 Quesons 56 2/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 70% 4/5

37 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sehar Kamran Overall Rank: 22/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 42% 5/5 score in 1out of 10 parameters Political Affiliation: PPP-P Rank among Women: 4/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A.; , 1987 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 46% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 4 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 6 5/5 7 Quesons 12 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 73% 4/5

38 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Gul Bashra Overall Rank: 23/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 41% 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters Political Affiliation: PMAP Rank among Women: 5/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: Data not available Current Term: 2015-2021 7 5 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 83% 5/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 2 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 87% 5/5

39

SCORECARDS

PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Hidayat Ullah Overall Rank: 6/40 Territory: FATA Political Affiliation: Independent Overall Score: 65% 5/5 score in 4 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: Graduaon from Edwards College, Peshawar, 1993 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 10 5/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 52% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 1 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 1 1/5 7 Quesons 8 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 83% 5/5

43 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Baz Muhammad Overall Rank: 7/40 Khan Overall Score: 63% Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Political Affiliation: ANP 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: L.L.B.; University of Peshawar, 1973 7 5 Other: Vice President of ANP; Former 6 Provincial Minister for Health; Former Provincial Minister for Forest and Former Provincial Minister for Irrigaon Score Card Current Term: 2012-2018

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 5 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 45% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 6 3/5 5 Resoluons 2 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 8 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 74% 4/5

44 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sirajul Haq Overall Rank: 7/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 63% Political Affiliation: JIP 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: M.A. Polical Science; University of Peshawar 7 5 Other: Amir (President) of Jamaat-e-Islami 6 Pakistan and Former Senior Provincial Minister Current Term: 2015 – 2021; Parliamentary Score Card leader of JIP in the Senate

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 8 4/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 17% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 5 3/5 5 Resoluons 12 3/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 4 3/5 7 Quesons 42 2/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 38% 2/5

45 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Raja Muhammad Overall Rank: 8/40 Zafar-ul-Haq Overall Score: 62% Province: Punjab Political Affiliation:PML-N 5/5 score in 3 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: M.A. Polical Science, Punjab University; L.L.B.; Punjab Law College; 7 5 1958 6 Other: Chairman PML-N, Former Federal Minister Current Term: 2015-2021; Leader of the Score Card House in Senate

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 7 3/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 48% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 84% 5/5

46 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Syed Muzafar Overall Rank: 8/40 Hussain Shah Overall Score: 62% Province: Sindh Political Affiliation:PML-F 5/5 score in 4 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: M.A. Internaonal Relaons, Karachi University, 1964 7 5 Other: Former Chief Minister Sindh and 6 Former Speaker Provincial Assembly Sindh Current Term: 2012 – 2018; Parliamentary leader of PML-F in the Senate Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 10 5/5 2 Commiees Chaired 3 5/5 3 Commiees Aendance 22% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 2 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 2 2/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 56% 3/5

47 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mir Hasil Khan Overall Rank: 9/40 Bizenjo Overall Score: 59% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation:NP 5/5 score in 3 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A. (Hon); M.A. Philosophy, University of Karachi, 1986 7 5 Other: Former MNA; formerly elected to 6 the Senate in 2009; current President, Naonal Party. Current Term: 2015-2021; Parliamentary Score Card leader of NP in the Senate

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 10 5/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 53% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 3 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 49% 3/5

48 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Aitzaz Ahsan Overall Rank: 10/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 57% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: M.A., Cambridge University, 1967 and B.A. L.L.B., Government 7 5 College, Lahore, 1965 6 Other: Former Federal Minister, Former President of Supreme Court Bar Associaon of Pakistan Current Term: 2012-2018; Leader of the Score Card Opposion

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 7 3/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 27% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 1 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 8 5/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 8 5/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 67% 4/5

49 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Farhatullah Babar Overall Rank: 11/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 56% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.E. Civil Engineering, Engineering College, Peshawar University, 7 5 1965 6 Other:Former Spokesman of the President of Pakistan Current Term: 2012-2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 7 3/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 66% 4/5 4 Adjournment Moons 9 5/5 5 Resoluons 5 2/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 5 4/5 7 Quesons 24 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 1 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 87% 5/5

50 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Chaudhary Tanvir Overall Rank: 12/40 Khan Overall Score: 52% Province: Punjab Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: Under Matriculaon Other: Elected to the Provincial Assembly 7 5 of Punjab in 1993 and 1997 6 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 7 3/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 61% 4/5 4 Adjournment Moons 3 2/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 7 5/5 7 Quesons 70 3/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 87% 5/5

51 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sassui Palijo Overall Rank: 13/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 51% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters Rank among Women: 1/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.A. Political Science; University of Sindh, Jamshoro, 1998 7 5 Other: Former Provincial Minister for 6 Culture from 2008 – 2013 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 43% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 8 4/5 5 Resolutions 4 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 6 5/5 7 Questions 19 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 1 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 79% 5/5

52 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Shahi Syed Overall Rank: 14/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 50% Political Affiliation: ANP 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Intermediate, Mardan Board, 2009 7 5 Other: President, ANP Sindh 6 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 47% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 10 5/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 3 3/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 82% 5/5

53 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sitara Ayaz Overall Rank: 15/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 49% Political Affiliation: ANP 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters Rank among Women: 2/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A.; Jinnah College for 7 5 Women, Peshawar, 1990 Current Term: 2015-2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 55% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 3 2/5 5 Resolutions 6 2/5 6 Call Attention Motions 7 5/5 7 Questions 4 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 91% 5/5

54 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Hafiz Hamdullah Overall Rank: 16/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 48% Political Affiliation: JUI-F 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A.; University of Balochistan, 1996 7 5 Other: Former Provincial Minister for 6 Health, and Vice President, JUI-F Balochistan Current Term: 2012 - 2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 69% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 8 4/5 5 Resolutions 3 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 6 5/5 7 Questions 4 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 51% 3/5

55 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Muhammad Javed Overall Rank: 16/40 Abbasi Overall Score: 48% Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: L.L.M., University of Sheffield, UK, 1997 7 5 Other: Former MPA 6 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 94% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 4 2/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 3 3/5 7 Questions 11 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 88% 5/5

56 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mohammad Azam Overall Rank: 17/40 Khan Swati Overall Score: 47% Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Political Affiliation: PTI

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: L.L.M. International Law; University of Houston, Texas, USA 7 5 Other: Former Federal Minister and 6 previously elected Senator in 2006 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 73% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 7 4/5 5 Resolutions 5 2/5 6 Call Attention Motions 4 3/5 7 Questions 74 3/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 56% 3/5

57 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Taj Haider Overall Rank: 17/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 47% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: MSc. Mathematics; Karachi University, 1963 7 5 Other: Awarded Sitara-e-Imtiaz, 2012; 6 General Secretary, PPP Sindh Current Term: 2012 – 2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 7 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 76% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 6 3/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 1 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 94% 5/5

58 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sardar Muhammad Overall Rank: 18/40 Azam Khan Musakhel Overall Score: 46% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: PMAP 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A.; Balochistan University, Quetta, 1975 7 5 Other: Former MPA, Balochistan 6 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 75% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 5 3/5 5 Resolutions 8 2/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 48 2/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 88% 5/5

59 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mohsin Aziz Overall Rank: 19/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 45% Political Affiliation: PTI

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Intermediate, Edwards College, Peshawar, 1974 7 5 Other: Chairman of a Group of Industries 6 Current Term: 2015 - 2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 48% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 5 3/5 5 Resolutions 5 2/5 6 Call Attention Motions 3 3/5 7 Questions 25 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 67% 4/5

60 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Advocate Overall Rank: 19/40 Muhammad Daud Khan Overall Score: 45% Achakzai Political Affiliation: ANP 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters Province: Balochistan

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A., L.L.B; University of Balochistan, 1998 7 5 Other: Central Vice President, ANP 6 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 94% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 4 2/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 25 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation

10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 85% 5/5

61 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mir Kabeer Ahmed Overall Rank: 20/40 Muhammad Shahi Overall Score: 44% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: NP 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Master of Public Administration, 1990 and L.L.B. 7 5 University of Balochistan, 1992 6 Other: Member CEC of the NP Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 66% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 3 3/5 7 Questions 9 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 82% 5/5

62 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Atta Ur Rehman Overall Rank: 21/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 43% Political Affiliation: JUI-F

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Religious Studies, Jamia Qasim-ul-Uloom, , 1987 7 5 Other: Former Federal Minister for 6 Tourism, 2008-2013 and Vice President JUI-F, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Current Term: 2015-2021 Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 74% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 8 4/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 9 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 1 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 73% 4/5

63 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Nuzhat Sadiq Overall Rank: 21/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 43% Political Affiliation: PML-N Rank among Women: 3/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A.; Cantonment College for Women, Peshawar, 1975 7 5 Other: President, Women Wing, PML-N 6 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 2 4/5 3 Committees Attendance 74% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 2 2/5 7 Questions 56 2/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 70% 4/5

64 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Saleem Mandviwalla Overall Rank: 21/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 43% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Graduate from the Fortworth School of Aviation-Ft. Worth Texas, USA, 7 5 1980 6 Other: Former Minister of State and Former Federal Minister; formerly elected Senator in 2009 Score Card Current Term: 2015-2021

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 83% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 3 2/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 4 3/5 7 Questions 6 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 57% 3/5

65 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Ahmed Hassan Overall Rank: 22/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 42% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: L.L.B.; Khyber Law College, Peshawar, 1975 7 5 Other: Former Provincial Minister 6 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 74% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 3 2/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 50 2/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 79% 5/5

66 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sehar Kamran Overall Rank: 22/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 42% 5/5 score in 1out of 10 parameters Political Affiliation: PPP-P Rank among Women: 4/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A.; University of Karachi, 1987 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 46% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 4 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 6 5/5 7 Questions 12 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 73% 4/5

67 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Taj Muhammad Overall Rank: 22/40 Afridi Political Affiliation: Overall Score: 42% Territory: FATA Independant 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.Sc., Govt Degree College, Landi Kotal, 1990 7 5 Current Term: 2015-2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 77% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 3 2/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 2 2/5 7 Questions 19 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 71% 4/5

68 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Lt. General (R) Abdul Overall Rank: 23/40 Qayyum Overall Score: 41% Province: Punjab Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Ed u c a t i o n : M S c . ; Q u a i d - i - A za m University, Islamabad, 1989 7 5 Other: Former Chairman, Pakistan Steel 6 Mills Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 63% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 2 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 84% 5/5

69 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Gul Bashra Overall Rank: 23/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 41% 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters Political Affiliation: PMAP Rank among Women: 5/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Data not available Current Term: 2015-2021 7 5 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 83% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 87% 5/5

70 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Hamza Overall Rank: 23/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 41% Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters Top Performer in Representaon – 97% Aendance

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.A. Economics; Punjab University, 1951 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 79% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 1 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 97% 5/5

71 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Kamil Ali Agha Overall Rank: 23/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 41% Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A., L.L.B.; University of Punjab, 1974 7 5 Other: Former MNA and Former Minister 6 of State Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 7 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 71% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 2 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 81% 5/5

72 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mian Muhammad Overall Rank: 23/40 Ateeq Shaikh Overall Score: 41% Province: Sindh Political Affiliation: MQM 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Certificate of Hospitality Management, Cornell University, New 7 5 York, USA, 2010 6 Other: President, MQM Punjab Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 38% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 2 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 4 3/5 7 Questions 15 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 82% 5/5

73 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Nehal Hashmi Overall Rank: 23/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 41% Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 2 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: L.L.B.; University of Karachi, 1986 7 5 Other: General Secretary of PML-N, 6 Sindh. Current Term: 2015 - 2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 89% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 5 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 83% 5/5

74 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Lt. General (R) Overall Rank: 23/40 Salahuddin Tirmizi Overall Score: 41% Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: MSc. War Studies; Quaid-e- Azam University, Islamabad, 1984 7 5 Other: Former Assistant Secretary 6 General, PML-N. Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 70% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 2 2/5 7 Questions 3 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 92% 5/5

75 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Ilyas Ahmad Bilour Overall Rank: 24/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 40% Political Affiliation: ANP 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.B.A., Marketing, College of Business Administration & Computer 7 5 Sciences, Karachi, 1999 6 Other: Formerly elected Senator from 1994-2000, 2003-2006, 2006-2012 Current Term: 2012-2018; Parliamentary Score Card leader of ANP in the Senate

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 10 5/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 36% 2/5 4 Adjournment Motions 5 3/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 3 3/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 49% 3/5

76 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Karim Ahmed Overall Rank: 24/40 Khawaja Overall Score: 40% Province: Sindh Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: MBBS, University of Sindh 1985 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 7 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 52% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 5 2/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 23 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 83% 5/5

77 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Khalida Parveen Overall Rank: 24/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 40% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters Rank among Women: 6/17

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A., Government College of Girls, Muzafargarh, 1984 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 76% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 2 1/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 2 2/5 7 Questions 17 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 77% 4/5

78 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mukhar Ahmed Overall Rank: 24/40 Dhamrah -- Aajiz Overall Score: 40% Province: Sindh Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A.; Allama Iqbal Open University, Islamabad, 2006 7 5 Current Term: 2012 - 2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 67% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 4 3/5 7 Questions 10 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 60% 4/5

79 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Kalsoom Perveen Overall Rank: 25/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 39% Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters Rank among Women: 7/17

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A., 1993; M.A., History Current Term: 2015 - 2021 7 5 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 63% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 3 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 18 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 84% 5/5

80 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Muhammad Mohsin Overall Rank: 25/40 Khan Leghari Political Affiliation: Overall Score: 39% Province: Punjab Independent 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A., University of the Punjab 7 5 Lahore, 1989 Other: Former MPA 6 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 6 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 65% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 6 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 1 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 85% 5/5

81 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Najma Hameed Overall Rank: 25/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 39% Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters Rank among Women: 7/17

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Secondary School Education, 1960 7 5 Other: Former MPA; previously elected 6 Senator 2009-2015 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 57% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 4 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 11 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 81% 5/5

82 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Nisar Muhammad Overall Rank: 25/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 39% Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.A.; University of Peshawar, 1988 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 67% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 15 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 85% 5/5

83 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Saeedul Hassan Overall Rank: 25/40 Mandokhail Overall Score: 39% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A., Govt. Degree College, Quetta, 1982 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 82% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 8 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 72% 4/5

84 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sajjad Hussain Turi Overall Rank: 25/40 Territory: FATA Political Affiliation: Overall Score: 39% Independent 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: D.A.E. (Civil Engineering), G.P.I. Nowshera, 1995; B.A., Peshawar 7 5 University, 1998 6 Current term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 77% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 4 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 71% 4/5

85 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Dr. Ashok Kumar Overall Rank: 26/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 38% Political Affiliation: NP 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.B.B.S.; Sindh Medical College, Karachi University, 1989 7 5 Other: Member of NP Central Committee 6 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 84% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 7 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 70% 4/5

86 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Haji Saifullah Khan Overall Rank: 26/40 Bangash Overall Score: 38% Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Matriculation, Government High School, Thal, , 1970 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 76% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 72% 4/5

87 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Brig. (R) John Overall Rank: 26/40 Kenneth Williams Overall Score: 38% Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Political Affiliation: PTI 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.A Political Science, Peshawar University, 1999 7 5 Current Term: 2015-2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 89% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 1 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 78% 4/5

88 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mir Muhammad Overall Rank: 26/40 Yousaf Badini Political Affiliation: Overall Score: 38% Province: Balochistan Independent 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A.; University of Balochistan, 1988 7 5 Other: Previously elected Senator, 2009- 6 2015 on PPP-P's ticket Current Term: 2015 - 2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 54% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 1 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 83% 5/5

89 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mufti Abdul Sattar Overall Rank: 26/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 38% Political Affiliation: JUI-F 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Shahadat-ul-Alyia & Alamyia Jamiat-ul-Ulum Al Islamia, Karachi, 1977 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 76% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 66% 4/5

90 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Muhammad Ali Khan Overall Rank: 26/40 Saif Overall Score: 38% Province: Sindh Political Affiliation: MQM

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: L.L.M.; University of London, UK, 1995 7 5 Other: President of MQM KP and FATA 6 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 58% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 2 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 64% 4/5

91 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sardar Fateh Overall Rank: 26/40 Muhammad Muhammad Overall Score: 38% Hassani Political Affiliation: PPP-P Province: Balochistan

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Data not available Others: Minister of State, 1978-88; 7 5 Federal Minister, 1993; Special Advisor to 6 Prime Minister, 1994-1996 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 60% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 63% 4/5

92 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Syed Shibli Faraz Overall Rank: 26/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 38% Political Affiliation: PTI

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.A. Political Economy University de Los Andes, Colombia, 1994 7 5 Other: Former pilot in the PAF and former 6 investment banker. Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 72% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 7 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 78% 4/5

93 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Dr. Ghous Overall Rank: 27/40 Muhammad Khan Niazi Overall Score: 37% Province: Punjab Political Affiliation: PML-N 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.B.B.S.; Nishter Medical College, Multan, 1982 7 5 Current Term: 2015-2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 53% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 11 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 91% 5/5

94 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Osman Saifullah Overall Rank: 27/40 Khan Overall Score: 37% Territory: Federal Capital Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.B.A.; Stanford University, California, USA 2009 7 5 Other: Leads the textile manufacturing 6 business of a group of industries Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 7 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 33% 2/5 4 Adjournment Motions 3 2/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 4 3/5 7 Questions 19 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 45% 3/5

95 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Prof. Sajid Mir Overall Rank: 27/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 37% Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.A. English, Government College Lahore, 1960 7 5 Other: Formerly elected Senator 2009- 6 2015 and President, Markazi Jamiat Ahle- Hadith, Pakistan. Current Term: 2015-2021 Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 69% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 1 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 67% 4/5

96 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Saleem Zia Overall Rank: 27/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 37% Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: L.L.B., Karachi University, 1983 Other: Former Provincial Law Minister and 7 5 Chief Organiser, PML-N Sindh 6 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 59% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 28 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 65% 4/5

97 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Samina Abid Overall Rank: 27/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 37% Political Affiliation: PTI Rank among Women: 8/17

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Matriculation, Peshawar, 1982 Other: President of PTI Women Wing, KP 7 5 Current Term: 2015-2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 69% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 4 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 46 2/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 1 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 72% 4/5

98 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Abdul Rehman Malik Overall Rank: 28/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 36% Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Ph.D (Honorary); University of Karachi, 2012 and M.Sc. Statistics; 7 5 University of Karachi, 1973 6 Other: Former Federal Minister for Interior and President, PPP Overseas & International Affairs. Score Card Current Term: 2015-2021

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 76% 5/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 4 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 57% 3/5

99 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Hilal-ur-Rehman Overall Rank: 28/40 Territory: FATA Political Affiliation: Overall Score: 36% Independent

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A., Law and Political Science, Peshawar University, 2009 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 57% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 1 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 62% 4/5

100 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Iqbal Zafar Jhagra Overall Rank: 28/40 Territory: Federal Capital Overall Score: 36% Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: BSc. Civil Engineering; University of Engineering and 7 5 Technology, Peshawar, 1969 6 Other: Former Secretary General, PML-N & Current Governor of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Term: March 2015-2021; Resigned in Score Card March 2016 Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 9 4/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 56% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 73% 4/5

101 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mushahid Ullah Overall Rank: 28/40 Khan Overall Score: 36% Province: Punjab Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: L.L.B.; University of Karachi, 1997 7 5 Other: Central Secretary Information, 6 PML-N; Former Federal Minister for Climate Change Current Term: 2015 - 2021 Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 41% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 71% 4/5

102 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Rubina Khalid Overall Rank: 28/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 36% Political Affiliation: PPP-P Rank among Women: 9/17

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: L.L.B.; University of Peshawar, 1985 7 5 Other: Member of K P Organising 6 Committee, PPP Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 59% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 78% 4/5

103 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Agha Shahbaz Khan Overall Rank: 29/40 Durrani Overall Score: 35% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.E.; Balochistan University of Engineering and Technology, Khuzdar, 7 5 2001 6 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Committees Attendance 61% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 36 2/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 56% 3/5

104 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sheher Bano Sherry Overall Rank: 29/40 Rehman Overall Score: 35% Province: Sindh Political Affiliation: PPP-P 5/5 score in 1 out of 10 parameters Rank among Women: 10/17

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A. (Hons); Smiths College, Massachusetts, USA, 1985 7 5 Other: Vice President, PPP-P; Former 6 Ambassador to the United States; Former Federal Minister for Information & Broadcasting Score Card Current Term: 2015-2021

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 6 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 8% 1/5 4 Adjournment Motions 9 5/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 2 2/5 7 Questions 5 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 23% 2/5

105 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Ayesha Raza Farooq Overall Rank: 30/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 34% Political Affiliation: PML-N Rank among Women: 11/17

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: M.B.A.; Lahore University of Management Sciences, 1995; L.L.B.; 7 5 Punjab Law College, University of Punjab, 6 2013 Other: Prime Minister's Focal Person on Polio Eradication Score Card Current Term: 2015-2021

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 7 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 65% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 10 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 1 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 1 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 56% 3/5

106 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Gianchand Overall Rank: 30/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 34% Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.E.; Sindh Agricultural University, 1989 7 5 Current Term: 2015-2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 48% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 1 1/5 7 Questions 1 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 61% 4/5

107 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Muhammad Zafar Overall Rank: 30/40 Ullah Khan Dhandla Overall Score: 34% Province: Punjab Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: F.A.; Allama Iqbal Open University, Islamabad, 2005 7 5 Current Term: 2012 - 2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 44% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 72% 4/5

108 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Haji Momin Khan Overall Rank: 31/40 Afridi Political Affiliation: Overall Score: 33% Territory: FATA Independent

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: B.A.; University of Peshawar , 1992 7 5 Current Term: 2015-2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 65% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 1 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 55% 3/5

109 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Liaqat Khan Tarakai Overall Rank: 31/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 33% Political Affiliation: PTI

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Secondary School Certificate, 1970 7 5 Current Term: 2015 - 2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 5 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 61% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 1 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 1 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 52% 3/5

110 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Naseema Ehsan Overall Rank: 31/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 33% Political Affiliation: BNP-A Rank among Women: 12/17

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Data not available Current Term: 2012 - 2018 7 5 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 70% 4/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 3 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 44% 3/5

111 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Malik Najmul Hassan Overall Rank: 32/40 Territory: FATA Political Affiliation: Overall Score: 32% Independent

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Intermediate, Govt High School, Kalaya, 1998 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 33% 2/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 59% 4/5

112 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Muhammad Saleh Overall Rank: 33/40 Shah Political Affiliation: Overall Score: 31% Territory: FATA Independent

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Shahadat-ul-Alia Alamia, Jamaia Darul Uloom Haqqania, KP 7 5 Pakistan 6 Other: Previously elected Senator from 2006 - 2012 Current Term: 2012 - 2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 47% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 0 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 2 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 58% 3/5

113 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Zahida Khan Overall Rank: 33/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 31% Political Affiliation: ANP Rank among Women: 13/17

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Matriculation, 1995 Other: Vice-President, ANP Malakand 7 5 Zone 6 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 4 2/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 43% 3/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 2 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 49% 3/5

114 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Islamuddin Shaikh Overall Rank: 34/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 30% Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 2 4 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Education: Data not available Current Term: 2015-2021 7 5 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Statistics Score Oversight 1 Committees Membership 7 3/5 2 Committees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Committees Attendance 21% 2/5 4 Adjournment Motions 0 1/5 5 Resolutions 1 1/5 6 Call Attention Motions 0 1/5 7 Questions 0 1/5 Legislation

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representation 10 Attendance in Plenary Sessions 48% 3/5

115 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Maulana Tanveer- Overall Rank: 34/40 ul-Haq Thanvi Overall Score: 30% Province: Sindh Political Affiliation: MQM

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A.; University of Karachi, 1978 7 5 Other: President, Muahida Bainul 6 Muslimeen Forum Pakistan Current Term: 2012 - 2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 22% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 1 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 1 1/5 7 Quesons 1 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 44% 3/5

116 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Nawabzada Overall Rank: 34/40 Saifullah Magsi Overall Score: 30% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: L.L.B.; University College London, 2004; Bar-at-Law, Lincolns Inn, 7 5 London, 2005 6 Current Term: 2012-2018

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 7 3/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 20% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 8 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 46% 3/5

117 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Hari Ram Overall Rank: 35/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 29% Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: Matriculaon, Govt. High School, Mirpurkhas, 1970 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 25% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 1 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 57% 3/5

118 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Khanzada Khan Overall Rank: 35/40 Province: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Overall Score: 29% Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.B.A.; Al Khair University, AJK, 2003 7 5 Other: Provincial Head of PPP, Khyber 6 Pakhtunkhwa Current Term: 2015-2021 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 31% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 50% 3/5

119 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mir Israrullah Khan Overall Rank: 35/40 Zehri Overall Score: 29% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: BNP-A

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A., Internaonal University of America (IUA) in London, UK 7 5 Other: President, BNP-A, Former Federal 6 Minister and elected Senator from 2006- 2012. Current Term: 2012-2018; Parliamentary Score Card leader in the Senate

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 9 4/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 20% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 1 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 26% 2/5

120 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Muhammad Yousaf Overall Rank: 35/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 29% Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon; B.A.: University of Karachi, 2007 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 20% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 51% 3/5

121 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Nasreen Jalil Overall Rank: 35/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 29% Political Affiliation: MQM Rank among Women: 14/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A. (Hons); English Literature, University of Karachi, 1966 7 5 Other: Deputy Convener, MQM and 6 Former Deputy Mayor of Karachi Current Term: 2012-2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 5 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 41% 3/5 4 Adjournment Moons 1 1/5 5 Resoluons 4 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 1 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 40% 2/5

122 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Nighat Mirza Overall Rank: 35/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 29% Political Affiliation: MQM Rank among Women: 15/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: M.A.; Islamic Studies Karachi University, 2011 7 5 Other: Formerly elected Senator in 2003; 6 Author and Teacher Current Term: 2015 - 2021 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 22% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 5 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 42% 3/5

123 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Rahila Magsi Overall Rank: 35/40 Territory: Federal Capital Overall Score: 29% Political Affiliation: PML-N Rank among Women: 15/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: MBBS; University of Sindh, 1989 7 5 Other: Former District Nazim of Tando 6 Allahyar, Sindh Current Term: 2015-2021 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 1 2/5 3 Commiees Aendance 16% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 31 2/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 42% 3/5

124 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Rozi Khan Kakar Overall Rank: 35/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 29% Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: M.A., & L.L.B; University of Balochistan, 1995 7 5 Current Term: 2012-2018 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 26% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 16 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 46% 3/5

125 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Aurangzeb Khan Overall Rank: 36/40 Territory: FATA Political Affiliation: Overall Score: 27% Independent

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: Board of Technical Educaon (B.T.E), NWFP, Peshawar, 1992 7 5 Current Term: 2015-2021 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 17% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 11 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 56% 3/5

126 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Pervaiz Rasheed Overall Rank: 36/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 27% Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 2 9 4 3 2 1 8 3 0

7 4 Educaon: F.A., Gordon College, Rawalpindi, 1972; Diploma in Sales & Markeng Management, Instute of 6 5 Leadership & Management Other: Current Federal Minister for Informaon, Broadcasng and Naonal Heritage & Former Chairman Pakistan Television (PTV); Previously Elected Senator 2009-2015 Score Card Current Term: 2015-2021

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 5 2/5 Commiees Chaired - - 2 Commiees Aendance 0% 1/5 3 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 4 Resoluons 0 1/5 5 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 6 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

7 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 8 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 9 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 48% 3/5

127 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Rubina Irfan Overall Rank: 36/40 Province: Balochistan Overall Score: 27% Political Affiliation: PML Rank among Women: 16/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A.; Balochistan 7 5 University, 2004 Other: President, PML Women Wing, and 6 Former Provincial Minister Current Term: 2012-2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 17% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 2 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 1 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 45% 3/5

128 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Kamran Michael Overall Rank: 37/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 24% Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 2 9 4 3 2 1 8 3 0

7 4 Educaon: B.A., Punjab University, 1996 6 5 Other: Current Federal Minister of Human Rights; Former Federal Minister for Ports and Shipping and former MPA Current Term: 2012-2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 5 2/5 Commiees Chaired - - 2 Commiees Aendance 0% 1/5 3 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 4 Resoluons 1 1/5 5 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 6 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

7 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 8 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 9 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 27% 2/5

129 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Khushbakht Shujat Overall Rank: 37/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 24% Political Affiliation: MQM Rank among Women: 17/17

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: B.A.; University of Karachi, 1970 7 5 Other: Former MNA 6 Current Term: 2015-2021

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 9% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 2 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 38% 2/5

130 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Sirdar Zulfiqar Ali Overall Rank: 37/40 Khan Khosa Overall Score: 24% Province: Punjab Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: Higher Secondary School Cerficate, Aitchison College, Lahore, 7 5 1954 6 Other: Former Governor of Punjab. Current Term: 2012-2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 13% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 28% 2/5

131 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Dr. Zaheer-ud-Din Overall Rank: 37/40 Babar Awan Overall Score: 24% Province: Punjab Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: Ph.D Criminal Law, Monty Cello University, USA, 1998 7 5 Other: Former Federal Minister for Law, 6 Jusce and Parliamentary Affairs Current Term: 2012-2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 5% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 1 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 32% 2/5

132 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Farooq Hamid Naek Overall Rank: 38/40 Province: Sindh Overall Score: 23% Political Affiliation: PPP-P

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: M.A.; & L.L.B.; University of Karachi, 1967 7 5 Other: Former Chairman, Senate of 6 Pakistan and Former Federal Minister of Law, Jusce and Parliamentary Affairs Current Term: 2015-2021 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 19% 2/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 1 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 20% 1/5

133 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mir Nematullah Overall Rank: 39/40 Zehri Overall Score: 21% Province: Balochistan Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: Intermediate, 2011 Current Term: 2015-2021 7 5 6

Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 0% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 7% 1/5

134 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Dr. Muhammad Overall Rank: 39/40 Farogh Naseem Overall Score: 21% Province: Sindh Political Affiliation: MQM

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: L.L.B.; University of Wales, L.L.M.; London School of Economics, and 7 5 PhD; Law University of London, 1997 6 Other: Former Advocate General of Sindh Current Term: 2012-2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 0% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 2% 1/5

135 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Saud Majeed Overall Rank: 39/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 21% Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 10 4 2 3 2 9 3 1 0

8 4

Educaon: Aended Cardiff Business School, Wales 7 5 Other: Member of the Prime Ministers 6 Public Affairs Unit and Former MNA Current Term: 2012-2018 Score Card

Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 4 2/5 2 Commiees Chaired 0 1/5 3 Commiees Aendance 10% 1/5 4 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 5 Resoluons 0 1/5 6 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 7 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

8 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 9 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 10 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 16% 1/5

136 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Senator Mohammad Ishaq Dar Overall Rank: 40/40 Province: Punjab Overall Score: 20% Political Affiliation: PML-N

1 5 2 9 4 3 2 1 8 3 0

7 4 Educaon: B.Com (Hons) (Gold Medalist); University of Punjab, Lahore, 1969 6 5 Other: Current Federal Minister for Finance, Revenue, Economic Affairs, Stascs and Privasaon & Former Federal Minister for Commerce & Investment Score Card Current Term: 2012-2018 Parameters Performance Stascs Score Oversight 1 Commiees Membership 2 1/5 Commiees Chaired - - 2 Commiees Aendance 0% 1/5 3 Adjournment Moons 0 1/5 4 Resoluons 0 1/5 5 Call Aenon Moons 0 1/5 6 Quesons 0 1/5 Legislaon

7 Private Members Bills Introduced 0 1/5 8 Private Members Bills Passed 0 1/5

Representaon 9 Aendance in Plenary Sessions 11% 1/5

137

APPENDICES

PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Appendix A:

Overall Rank of Senators

Name Overall Score Overall Rank

Col (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi 95% 1

Muhammad Usman Khan Kakar 76% 2

Mushahid Hussain Sayed 73% 3

Saeed Ghani 73% 3

Muhammad Talha Mehmood 68% 4

Nauman Wazir Khaak 66% 5

Dr. Jehanzeb Jamaldini 66% 5

Hidayat Ullah 65% 6

Baz Muhammad Khan 63% 7

Sirajul Haq 63% 7

Raja Muhammad Zafar-ul-Haq 62% 8

Syed Muzafar Hussain Shah 62% 8

Mir Hasil Khan Bizenjo 59% 9

Aitzaz Ahsan 57% 10

Farhatullah Babar 56% 11

Chaudhary Tanvir Khan 52% 12

Sassui Palijo 51% 13

Shahi Syed 50% 14

Sitara Ayaz 49% 15

Hafiz Hamdullah 48% 16

141 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Name Overall Score Overall Rank

Muhammad Javed Abbasi 48% 16

Mohammad Azam Khan Swa 47% 17

Taj Haider 47% 17

Sardar Muhammad Azam Khan Musakhel 46% 18

Mohsin Aziz 45% 19

Advocate Muhammad Daud Khan Achakzai 45% 19

Mir Kabeer Ahmed Muhammad Shahi 44% 20

Aa Ur Rehman 43% 21

Nuzhat Sadiq 43% 21

Saleem Mandviwalla 43% 21

Taj Muhammad Afridi 42% 22

Ahmed Hassan 42% 22

Sehar Kamran 42% 22

Lt. General (R) Abdul Qayyum 41% 23

Gul Bashra 41% 23

Hamza 41% 23

Kamil Ali Agha 41% 23

Mian Muhammad Ateeq Shaikh 41% 23

Nehal Hashmi 41% 23

Lt. General (R) Salahuddin Tirmizi 41% 23

Ilyas Ahmad Bilour 40% 24

Karim Ahmed Khawaja 40% 24

Khalida Parveen 40% 24

Mukhar Ahmed Dhamrah -- Aajiz 40% 24

142 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Name Overall Score Overall Rank

Kalsoom Perveen 39% 25

Muhammad Mohsin Khan Leghari 39% 25

Najma Hameed 39% 25

Nisar Muhammad 39% 25

Saeedul Hassan Mandokhail 39% 25

Sajjad Hussain Turi 39% 25

Dr. Ashok Kumar 38% 26

Haji Saifullah Khan Bangash 38% 26

Brig. (R) John Kenneth Williams 38% 26

Mir Muhammad Yousaf Badini 38% 26

Mui Abdul Saar 38% 26

Muhammad Ali Khan Saif 38% 26

Sardar Fateh Muhammad Muhammad Hassani 38% 26

Syed Shibli Faraz 38% 26

Dr. Ghous Muhammad Khan Niazi 37% 27

Osman Saifullah Khan 37% 27

Prof. Sajid Mir 37% 27

Saleem Zia 37% 27

Samina Abid 37% 27

Abdul Rehman Malik 36% 28

Hilal-ur-Rehman 36% 28

Iqbal Zafar Jhagra 36% 28

Mushahid Ullah Khan 36% 28

Rubina Khalid 36% 28

143 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Name Overall Score Overall Rank

Agha Shahbaz Khan Durrani 35% 29

Sheher Bano Sherry Rehman 35% 29

Ayesha Raza Farooq 34% 30

Gianchand 34% 30

Muhammad Zafar Ullah Khan Dhandla 34% 30

Haji Momin Khan Afridi 33% 31

Liaqat Khan Tarakai 33% 31

Naseema Ehsan 33% 31

Malik Najmul Hassan 32% 32

Muhammad Saleh Shah 31% 33

Zahida Khan 31% 33

Islamuddin Shaikh 30% 34

Maulana Tanveer-ul-Haq Thanvi 30% 34

Nawabzada Saifullah Magsi 30% 34

Hari Ram 29% 35

Khanzada Khan 29% 35

Mir Israrullah Khan Zehri 29% 35

Muhammad Yousaf 29% 35

Nasreen Jalil 29% 35

Nighat Mirza 29% 35

Rahila Magsi 29% 35

Rozi Khan Kakar 29% 35

Aurangzeb Khan 27% 36

144 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Name Overall Score Overall Rank

Pervaiz Rasheed 27% 36

Rubina Irfan 27% 36

Dr. Zaheer-ud-Din Babar Awan 24% 37

Kamran Michael 24% 37

Khushbakht Shujat 24% 37

Sirdar Zulfiqar Ali Khan Khosa 24% 37

Farooq Hamid Naek 23% 38

Mir Nematullah Zehri 21% 39

Dr. Muhammad Farogh Naseem 21% 39

Saud Majeed 21% 39

Mohammad Ishaq Dar 20% 40

145 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Appendix B:

Province/Territory wise Ranking of Senators Balochistan

Name Overall Score Overall Rank

Muhammad Usman Khan Kakar 76% 2

Dr. Jehanzeb Jamaldini 66% 5

Mir Hasil Khan Bizenjo 59% 9

Hafiz Hamdullah 48% 16

Sardar Muhammad Azam Khan Musakhel 46% 18

Advocate Muhammad Daud Khan Achakzai 45% 19

Mir Kabeer Ahmed Muhammad Shahi 44% 20

Gul Bashra 41% 23

Saeedul Hassan Mandokhail 39% 25

Kalsoom Perveen 39% 25

Dr. Ashok Kumar 38% 26

Mir Muhammad Yousaf Badini 38% 26

38% 26

Mui Abdul Saar 38% 26

Agha Shahbaz Khan Durrani 35% 29

Naseema Ehsan 33% 31

Nawabzada Saifullah Magsi 30% 34

Mir Israrullah Khan Zehri 29% 35

Rozi Khan Kakar 29% 35

Muhammad Yousaf 29% 35

Rubina Irfan 27% 36

Mir Nematullah Zehri 21% 39

146 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Name Overall Score Overall Rank FATA

Hidayat Ullah 65% 6

Taj Muhammad Afridi 42% 22

Sajjad Hussain Turi 39% 25

Hilal-ur-Rehman 36% 28

Haji Momin Khan Afridi 33% 31

Malik Najmul Hassan 32% 32

Muhammad Saleh Shah 31% 33

Aurangzeb Khan 27% 36 Federal Areas Mushahid Hussain Syed 73% 3

Osman Saifullah Khan 37% 27

Iqbal Zafar Jhagra 36% 28

Rahila Magsi 29% 35 Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Muhammad Talha Mehmood 68% 4

Nauman Wazir Khaak 66% 5

Baz Muhammad Khan 63% 7

Sirajul Haq 63% 7

Farhatullah Babar 56% 11

Shahi Syed 50% 14

Sitara Ayaz 49% 15

Muhammad Javed Abbasi 48% 16

Mohammad Azam Khan Swa 47% 17

Mohsin Aziz 45% 19

147 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Name Overall Score Overall Rank

Aa Ur Rehman 43% 21

Ahmed Hassan 42% 22

Lt. General (R) Salahuddin Tirmizi 41% 23

Ilyas Ahmad Bilour 40% 24

Nisar Muhammad 39% 25

Syed Shibli Faraz 38% 26

Brig. (R) John Kenneth Williams 38% 26

Haji Saifullah Khan Bangash 38% 26

Samina Abid 37% 27

Rubina Khalid 36% 28

Liaqat Khan Tarakai 33% 31

Zahida Khan 31% 33

Khanzada Khan 29% 35 Punjab Raja Muhammad Zafar-ul-Haq 62% 8

Aitzaz Ahsan 57% 10

Chaudhary Tanvir Khan 52% 12

Nuzhat Sadiq 43% 21

Nehal Hashmi 41% 23

Kamil Ali Agha 41% 23

Lt. General (R) Abdul Qayyum 41% 23

Hamza 41% 23

Khalida Parveen 40% 24

Muhammad Mohsin Khan Leghari 39% 25

Najma Hameed 39% 25

Prof. Sajid Mir 37% 27

148 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Name Overall Score Overall Rank

Ghous Muhammad Khan Niazi 37% 27

Saleem Zia 37% 27

Mushahid Ullah Khan 36% 28

Ayesha Raza Farooq 34% 30

Muhammad Zafar Ullah Khan Dhandla 34% 30

Pervaiz Rasheed 27% 36

Kamran Michael 24% 37

Sirdar Zulfiqar Ali Khan Khosa 24% 37

Zaheer-ud-Din Babar Awan 24% 37

Saud Majeed 21% 39

Mohammad Ishaq Dar 20% 40 Sindh

Col (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi 95% 1

Saeed Ghani 73% 3

Syed Muzafar Hussain Shah 62% 8

Sassui Palijo 51% 13

Taj Haider 47% 17

Saleem Mandviwalla 43% 21

Sehar Kamran 42% 22

Mian Muhammad Ateeq Shaikh 41% 23

Karim Ahmed Khawaja 40% 24

Mukhar Ahmed Dhamrah -- Aajiz 40% 24

Muhammad Ali Khan Saif 38% 26

Abdul Rehman Malik 36% 28

Sheher Bano Sherry Rehman 35% 29

149 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016

Name Overall Score Overall Rank

Gianchand 34% 30

Islamuddin Shaikh 30% 34

Maulana Tanveer-ul-Haq Thanvi 30% 34

Nasreen Jalil 29% 35

Hari Ram 29% 35

Nighat Mirza 29% 35

Khushbakht Shujat 24% 37

Farooq Hamid Naek 23% 38

Dr. Muhammad Farogh Naseem 21% 39

150 Islamabad Office: P. O. Box 278, F-8, Postal Code: 44220, Islamabad, Pakistan Lahore Office: P. O. Box 11098, L.C.C.H.S, Postal Code: 54792, Lahore, Pakistan E-mail: [email protected] | Website: www.pildat.org