5 6 4 7 3 5 2 4 1 8 0 3 2 1 10 9 Mapping Future Political Leadership of Pakistan Scorecards on Honourable Senators' Performance 2015-2016 5 6 4 7 3 5 2 4 1 8 0 3 2 1 10 9 Mapping Future Political Leadership of Pakistan Scorecards on Honourable Senators' Performance 2015-2016 PILDAT is an independent, non-partisan and not-for-profit indigenous research and training institution with the mission to strengthen democracy and democratic institutions in Pakistan. PILDAT is a registered non-profit entity under the Societies Registration Act XXI of 1860, Pakistan. Copyright ©Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development And Transparency PILDAT All Rights Reserved Printed in Pakistan Published: June 2016 ISBN: 978-969-558-645-7 Any part of this publication can be used or cited with a clear reference to PILDAT. Supported by Islamabad Office: P. O. Box 278, F-8, Postal Code: 44220, Islamabad, Pakistan Lahore Office: P. O. Box 11098, L.C.C.H.S, Postal Code: 54792, Lahore, Pakistan E-mail: [email protected] | Website: www.pildat.org PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016 CONTENTS Preface Executive Summary Rationale 15 Methodology of Assessment 16 Framework of Assessment of the Performance of a Senator of Pakistan 18 Chairman and Deputy Chairman 19 Top 5 Ranks 23 1. Senator Col. (r) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi (Sindh, MQM) 25 2. Senator Muhammad Usman Khan Kakar (Balochistan, PMAP) 26 3. Senator Saeed Ghani (Sindh, PPP-P) 27 4. Senator Mushahid Hussain Sayed (Federal Capital, PML) 28 5. Senator Muhammad Talha Mehmood (KP, JUI-F) 29 6. Senator Nauman Wazir Khattak (KP, PTI) 30 7. Senator Dr. Jehanzeb Jamaldini (Balochistan, BNP-M) 31 Top 5 Ranks among Women Senators 33 1. Senator Sassui Palijo (Sindh, PPP-P) 35 2. Senator Sitara Ayaz (KP, ANP) 36 3. Senator Nuzhat Sadiq (Punjab, PML-N) 37 4. Senator Sehar Kamran (Sindh, PPP-P) 38 5. Senator Gul Bashra (Balochistan, PMAP) 39 Scorecards 41 1. Senator Hidayat Ullah (FATA, IND) 43 2. Senator Baz Muhammad Khan (KP, ANP) 44 3. Senator Sirajul Haq (KP, JI) 45 4. Senator Raja Muhammad Zafar-ul-Haq (Punjab, PML-N) 46 5. Senator Syed Muzafar Hussain Shah (Sindh, PML-F) 47 6. Senator Mir Hasil Khan Bizenjo (Balochistan, NP) 48 7. Senator Aitzaz Ahsan (Punjab, PPP-P) 49 8. Senator Farhatullah Babar (KP, PPP-P) 50 9. Senator Chaudhary Tanvir Khan (Punjab, PML-N) 51 10. Senator Sassui Palijo (Sindh, PPP-P) 52 11. Senator Shahi Syed (KP, ANP) 53 12. Senator Sitara Ayaz (KP, ANP) 54 13. Senator Hafiz Hamdullah (Balochistan, JUI-F) 55 14. Senator Muhammad Javed Abbasi (KP, PML-N) 56 15. Senator Mohammad Azam Khan Swati (KP, PTI) 57 16. Senator Taj Haider (Sindh, PPP-P) 58 17. Senator Sardar Muhammad Azam Khan Musakhel (Balochistan, PMAP) 59 18. Senator Mohsin Aziz (KP, PTI) 60 03 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016 19. Senator Advocate Muhammad Daud Khan Achakzai (Balochistan, ANP) 61 20. Senator Mir Kabeer Ahmed Muhammad Shahi (Balochistan, NP) 62 21. Senator Atta Ur Rehman (KP, JUI-F) 63 22. Senator Nuzhat Sadiq (Punjab, PML-N) 64 23. Senator Saleem Mandviwalla (Sindh, PPP-P) 65 24. Senator Ahmed Hassan (KP, PPP-P) 66 25. Senator Sehar Kamran (Sindh, PPP-P) 67 26. Senator Taj Muhammad Afridi (FATA, IND) 68 27. Senator Lt. General (R) Abdul Qayyum (Punjab, PML-N) 69 28. Senator Gul Bashra (Balochistan, PMAP) 70 29. Senator Hamza (Punjab, PML-N) 71 30. Senator Kamil Ali Agha (Punjab, PML) 72 31. Senator Mian Muhammad Ateeq Shaikh (Sindh, MQM) 73 32. Senator Nehal Hashmi (Punjab, PML-N) 74 33. Senator Lt. General (R) Salahuddin Tirmizi (KP, PML-N) 75 34. Senator Ilyas Ahmad Bilour (KP, ANP) 76 35. Senator Karim Ahmed Khawaja (Sindh, PPP-P) 77 36. Senator Khalida Parveen (Punjab, PPP-P) 78 37. Senator Mukhtiar Ahmed Dhamrah – Aajiz (Sindh, PPP-P) 79 38. Senator Kalsoom Perveen (Balochistan, PML-N) 80 39. Senator Muhammad Mohsin Khan Leghari (Punjab, IND) 81 40. Senator Najma Hameed (Punjab, PML-N) 82 41. Senator Nisar Muhammad (KP, PML-N) 83 42. Senator Saeedul Hassan Mandokhail (Balochistan, PML) 84 43. Senator Sajjad Hussain Turi (FATA, IND) 85 44. Senator Dr. Ashok Kumar (Balochistan, NP) 86 45. Senator Haji Saifullah Khan Bangash (KP, PPP-P) 87 46. Senator Brig. (R) John Kenneth Williams (KP, PTI) 88 47. Senator Mir Muhammad Yousaf Badini (Balochistan, IND) 89 48. Senator Mufti Abdul Sattar (Balochistan, JUI-F) 90 49. Senator Muhammad Ali Khan Saif (Sindh, MQM) 91 50. Senator Sardar Fateh Muhammad Muhammad Hassani (Balochistan, PPP-P) 92 51. Senator Syed Shibli Faraz (KP, PTI) 93 52. Senator Dr. Ghous Muhammad Khan Niazi (Punjab, PML-N) 94 53. Senator Osman Saifullah Khan (Federal Capital, PPP-P) 95 54. Senator Prof. Sajid Mir (Punjab, PML-N) 96 55. Senator Saleem Zia (Punjab, PML-N) 97 56. Senator Samina Abid (KP, PTI) 98 57. Senator Abdul Rehman Malik (Sindh, PPP-P) 99 58. Senator Hilal-ur-Rehman (FATA, IND) 100 59. Senator Iqbal Zafar Jhagra 101 60. Senator Mushahid Ullah Khan (Punjab, PML-N) 102 61. Senator Rubina Khalid (KP, PPP-P) 103 62. Senator Agha Shahbaz Khan Durrani (Balochistan, PML-N) 104 63. Senator Sheher Bano Sherry Rehman (Sindh, PPP-P) 105 64. Senator Ayesha Raza Farooq (Punjab, PML-N) 106 65. Senator Gianchand (Sindh, PPP-P) 107 66. Senator Muhammad Zafar Ullah Khan Dhandla (Punjab, PML-N) 108 67. Senator Haji Momin Khan Afridi (FATA, IND) 109 68. Senator Liaqat Khan Tarakai (KP, PTI) 110 04 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016 69. Senator Naseema Ehsan (Balochistan, BNP-A) 111 70. Senator Malik Najmul Hassan (FATA, IND) 112 71. Senator Muhammad Saleh Shah (FATA, IND) 113 72. Senator Zahida Khan (KP, ANP) 114 73. Senator Islamuddin Shaikh (Sindh, PPP-P) 115 74. Senator Maulana Tanveer-ul-Haq Thanvi (Sindh, MQM) 116 75. Senator Nawabzada Saifullah Magsi (Balochistan, PPP-P) 117 76. Senator Hari Ram (Sindh, PPP-P) 118 77. Senator Khanzada Khan (KP, PPP-P) 119 78. Senator Mir Israrullah Khan Zehri (Balochistan, BNP-A) 120 79. Senator Muhammad Yousaf (Balochistan, PPP-P) 121 80. Senator Nasreen Jalil (Sindh, MQM) 122 81. Senator Nighat Mirza (Sindh, MQM) 123 82. Senator Rahila Magsi (Federal Capital, PML-N) 124 83. Senator Rozi Khan Kakar (Balochistan, PPP-P) 125 84. Senator Aurangzeb Khan (FATA, IND) 126 85. Senator Pervaiz Rasheed (Punjab, PML-N) 127 86. Senator Rubina Irfan (Balochistan, PML) 128 87. Senator Dr. Zaheer-ud-Din Babar Awan (Punjab, PPP-P) 129 88. Senator Kamran Michael (Punjab, PML-N) 130 89. Senator Khushbakht Shujat (Sindh, MQM) 131 90. Senator Sirdar Zulfiqar Ali Khan Khosa (Punjab, PML-N) 132 91. Senator Farooq Hamid Naek (Sindh, PPP-P) 133 92. Senator Mir Nematullah Zehri (Balochistan, PML-N) 134 93. Senator Dr. Muhammad Farogh Naseem (Sindh, MQM) 135 94. Senator Saud Majeed (Punjab, PML-N) 136 95. Senator Mohammad Ishaq Dar (Punjab, PML-N) 137 List of Figures Figure 1 Top 5 Ranks 11 Figure 2 Top 5 Women Senators 12 Figure 3 Political party-wise senators in the top 15 ranks 13 Figure 4 Province/Territory wise senators in the Top 15 ranks 14 Appendices Appendix A: List of Senators – Rank wise 141 Appendix B: List of Senators – Province/Territory wise 146 05 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016 Abbreviations and Acronyms ANP Awami National Party B.Sc Bachelor of Science BA Bachelor of Arts BNP-A Balochistan National Party-Awami BNP-M Balochistan National Party-Mengal CEC Central Executive Committee DANIDA Danish International Development Agency FATA Federally Administered Tribal Area IND Independent JI Jamaat-e-Islami JUI-F Jamiat-Ulema-e-Islam – Fazl KP Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa M.Sc Master of Science MA Master of Arts MBA Master of Business Administration MBBS Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery MNA Member National Assembly MPA Member Provincial Assembly MQM Muttahida Quami Movement NA National Assembly NP National Party PA Provincial Assembly PMAP Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party PML Pakistan Muslim League (Formerly PML-Q or Pakistan Muslim League – Quaid e Azam) PML-F Pakistan Muslim League-Functional PML-N Pakistan Muslim League – Nawaz PPP-P Pakistan Peoples Party – Parliamentarians PTI Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf 07 PILDAT SCORECARDS ON HONOURABLE SENATORS' PERFORMANCE, 2015-2016 Preface ast year in 2015, PILDAT conducted a mapping exercise of the political leadership in Pakistan, and produced a list of L21 top leaders of the country who were thought most likely to become Prime Minister of Pakistan in the next 15 years' time. Although evolution of political leadership does not necessarily follow a logical and scientific process, PILDAT attempted to employ a rather scientific framework for the selection of these 21 potential Prime Ministers of Pakistan. This effort was made for the purpose of improving the quality of future leadership by inspiring the identified leaders to place a greater focus on their policy positions and refine their vision about a better Pakistan. PILDAT has taken a step forward this year and tried to assess the performance of the elected leadership of the Senate of Parliament, traditionally considered the upper house of the parliament. From 2002 onwards, PILDAT has consistently looked at the performance of the Pakistan's Parliament, reviewing it from the citizens' perspective with the aim of enhancing public interest in and engagement with the parliament. This year, we decided to study the performance of the individual Parliamentarians in the Senate of Pakistan during the Thirteenth Parliamentary Year of Senate, March 12, 2015 to March 11, 2016 within the overall context of mapping the future political leadership of Pakistan.