TO M:S ~Raft O"I Stt
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
.> 3 / AIfOLO-rRJNCH lllVAtRy OVER ACADIA . TO m:s ~RAft O"I stt. G~ IN -,. 10M L. Mahar , A. D. A Thosis 8ubmltted to the 7aoultl" ot the Oradua te School, Marquette UnlTerslty 1& Partial J'\ll.tl1laent 0"1 tbe Re ulremeGts tor the »egr~e ot ster ot Arts Ul1wt\uk•• , WlsooDs1n 'I, 1950 / PREFAOE '!'he beginnings in a small way of OOl!11"lel"oe And Mnutac ture in Oanada are tound in Port Royal . There was COn struoted and launched the first Tessel known to have been built in Amer1oa, a.nd on a stream that empties into the Bay of. Fundy was built the tirst mill in Canada . Here, too. the waters were reddened by the first bloodshed in Canflda in the lons and bitter struggle between England and Oanada tor supremacy in America . The :purpose ot this papt,lr 1s to trace the early Anglo Frenoh rivalry tor posse8~ions in the New World. Most general historians have slIghted Port Roye.l in tavor 01' the settlement at Quebeo . Other historians who treat the founding and settlement 01' Port Royal err either throuf.b nationsl bias. or tail to oonault the primary sources. I am deeply indebted to the Reverend Raphael J . HAmilton . 8 .J •• who direoted this study and whose Bugeest lons and oritioisms proved to be of the utmost vt'llue. H H ~ ...H H t:t ~ H Of '"~ !a to! 5! ~ t: t:3 t.( :d ~ 0 S !IIi' ~ ~ 0 ~ !i ~ I ~ • t; ~ .. ~ .... .. ~ "11 .. ~ ~ • ;! ~ .. ).: ~ ~ ~ .. ~ ;... - fa .. ~ ~ Q ij tJ.1. -. .. ~. "tt § .. ~ ~ i :. f! ~ b. .. ~ • S ", 0) • ~ • .. ~ .. .. t"'.. .. ~ ~ .. .. ~ .' .. • • .. .- • .. .. .. • .. • .. .. .. .. .- .. .. .. .. s >-s;: €1! ~ • !->of ! •.. ;!l • .. w~ ".. ~'" • ~ ,...., • Iii ~ f!1 .. ~ • ..~ • H,...... " t; • ~ • >- • • E • § .. ~ .. • • ,.~ ,. Q *"0 ~ t"'" ~ i ,... y"'" (I,l 5 / CHAPTER ! EARLY RIVALRY FO}~ lJ'lIE HEW lJlIOa LD The discovery o~ America. in 1492 i by OhrlatopMr Oolumbus did not have the 1lfl!11edia t e etfee t upon the eoonomy ot Europe that the finding of a new route to Ind1a b'1 Vasco da Gama did in 1499.. The Portuguese tt-led the way by Af:rlaa and suo ceeded. Vasoo daGama rounded t he Cap., salled up the iast ern coast of Af'riofl and crossed to Ind1a. The S,an1.a.rc!a eat sail in t he 'O ppos ite direction and t a iling tn the ir origi nal design, found instead a New World. That the newly dis ... covered lands "ere to be a source ot ,C!t1ae ord and contention bet"een the two oountr-t e& was 800n a pparent .. The, rulers of Portugal and Spain appealed t o Pope Alexander VI , to as tabU.ah the spheres of influence. In his fstI'Jotts Line of J;)emQroatlon of 1493, .hloh was later amende d and ratlf1ed by the Treaty of Tordas1l1as, the Pope fixed t he limits of eaoh country's future e xplore.t1ons. 1 Ipope Alexander VI , on the 4th of May , 1493, issued a bull, by virtu. of his a post.011oa l and pontifioal power by whioh he established 11 line 01' I lml tatton, runn1.ng trom the North and South poles" distant one hundred leagues west of the Azores and the Cape Verde Islands , giving t o Spain all t he territory" whieh she had disoovered, or mlghtdiscoverjl to the "est. and which had not been taken poss ession of by any Christ1an monarch at any t1.l!!$ pPElceding Chr1stmas, 1492 . To the Portuguese , i n s intl 1ar mar ner, and 6ubjeet to the same prov1so, the Pope gr a.nted a ll the terri tory which lay to t;he eas t of the 1 1ne of 11ml ta HOD . Because there Was some d1.s .. satisfaction as to t he diviSion , a meeting wa s arranged be .. 6 tween t he comm issioners of Spain nnd Portugal at 'l'ordaslllas, in Spain, in 1494 . 131 the Treaty of 1'ord9.8111a8, thtl line of demaroation was shifted to suoh a posit1on that it should pau l' north and south, three hundred and seventy leagues / west of the Cape Verde Islands • all to the west of that limitation to belong t o Spa.in , and all to the east to Portu ... ga l~ This 'Preaty W9.$ confirmed by the. Pope in $. papal bull of June 24; 1506. Spain and Portugal, a t this +1:me were better qualified f or Bxploration, more consolidat ed, more nearly come t o theIr prime , more full of expansive forae than the people of Northern Europa, so that. their history comb~ned w1~h the1r geograph1oal position made them foremost i n exploration and oolonization. Both Spain and Portugal looked to the Sou t hwe s t , in p,art gUided no doubt by the Canaries , Madeira, and the Azores . From these semi-mythica.l goals of ancient navtgatlon, wind and thQ tide presoribed the line of disoovery. Thus we find that the We s t Indies , Oentral and South Amerioa w~r e dlacQvered before the North Am.rl~an Oontinent. Easier t o reaoh than l~orth Amerloa, the 'West Indies , and Centra.l Amerioa were also more attraotive whenreaohed. The Span .. iards found r i ohes beyond their hopes, pearls in t he se a ~ gold and silver in the so11 , and a 1'a08 of n$.t1ves who could bO forced to fish for the one , and mine for the other. Thus, for a ce ntury after Oolumbus t'lrst satled to the west, whil Ce ntral and South America became organized into a colleotion of S.panish provinces the ext%'eme Nort h wa·a lett to Basque , Breton and English fishermen. ' ~, Difficult to reaoh, cold and unattraotive when roached, North Am&rio4 came to be oonsidered as B stepping stone to another goal .. The explorers, therefore, kept ' perpetually ./ push1ng on I . seeking a northwest passage to Ohina. France and England were late comers to the :f1eld of explo ration and oolon1zatlQn. France W9:8 continually hampered by oont1nGntal troubles, and England had not as yet assumed the proud. title. M1stress of the Seas. Both oountries re sented the papal partition between Portugal and Spaln, and eomple tel,. d1srega.rc1ed 1 t .. With the opening or the seventeenth century France an4 England began a oontest for the ownership of fiorth America which WQS to r8J1181.n undeoided tor a century and a halt. England olaimed the oont1.nent through the discovery by the Cabota 1n 149'7 and 1498, and Franee ole.tme~ 1 t through the voyage of Verrazzano 1n 1524 ., Probably no qU88 tion in the hts tory of this conttnen t has been tbeeubject of s.o 'IIuch dllcuss10n as the liv.s and voyage's of t'he two Caeota. Some wrl tars attribute every thing to h11 Il.cond. /!Ion,. Sebastian. Their personal ohare-c ... tel', their naUonallt,'1. the number of voyages they made anti the extent and (lit-Get-lonot their disooverles hav. been and aUll are k ••~11 d18puted. 2 Some even go so far al to 2 Samuel Edward Dawson , "Tbe Voyages of t:he Canota in 149'7 and 1498". Prooeed'.ng an~ Trans~ot;lon8 of the· Royal Sooiety of Canada (Toronto, 1894), vol. 12, sec . 2, 51. 8 claim that t he voyages ap8 a pooryphal, the discoveries pre tended. Nevertheless, lolely upon the discoveri es of the Cabots have always rested t he original olaims of tbe English I race t oa foothold upon North America. Edmund Burke, the B~l t1,sh ~ta tesman, wrote ,ln h1s AQcount of European Set tl!. me n to in America J e der1,v$ our rights in Amer.:1oa , from the dis oovery of SehasUnn Oabot, whQ, first made the Northern Oontinent 1n 149'7.. The faot 115 sufficient... 1,. oertaln t o es t~hlhh a r '·Etht to OU1;' se ttlement s in North America . 3 Edmund Burke, An Account of the European Se t tlementa 1n All'.erlea(tondon , !"7'f1"t Vol. 2, 138 • . St r Angely enough_ in the puhlhhed annals o.f England, no contemporary aQOQunta ot the Ca.bots exist. Not a sing1e .crap ot wrl ting oflohu Cabot has been preserved. The map and globe of John Oabot no longer exist. EnglIsh olaims re.t solely upon, two lett ers of Patent , entries in the Privy Purse accQunts, two letters from Sl?an18h Ambassadors, and on three newa letters trom Itallane in London. 4 From the !lIeager ------------~~.. ~----------~--~--~---- ..--~ .... ----~------------~---- ..I-- · ~ 4 Clements R. Markham, ed., "The JQurnal of ChrhtopherCo lumbus and Doouments Relat ing to the Voyages of John Cabot and Gaspar Cort e Real"" iakluyt Sooiety Publioation (London, 1893), vol . 86, 1x. sourCes it has been established that John Oabot was moat proba bly a aenoeso , S who after having resided 1n Venioe for fifteen 5 IbId. , "Despa.tch from Ruy de Puebla to t he Catholic Sover .. e i gns . July 25, 1498". 207. 9 years from 1461 - 14'76, was admitted to elt1zenshlp.6 --~"------~------------~--------------------------"~~--"--------"~--------i 6 G. E_ Weare, Cabota Discovery of. NO)'t.h amerIca (London,. 1897 ) ,. n.g, '70.. Entry in Venet1an Archives reproduced: ·'14"6, dIe U8.l"t11, - Quod fiat pr1v11eglum clvl11taUs de lntus et extra loan! Caboto per babl tat1onemarmorum XV .. , iuxta consuetum.. De Parte ... 149 De Non ... 0 De Sinet-tti - 0" .. ThlitJohll Cabot was an experienoed navigatop 1s attested by 80001no# who wrote to the Iiuke of Milan, Ludovlco Sl'or!1a that he (Cabot) had been e ngaged in commercial transaotion along the Arabian coast, even visiti ng Meooa .