Acc. Sc. Torino Quaderni, 28 (2017), 105-122, 10 Þ gg. ©,0(5&2/('Î'(//¶$&&$'(0,$ª
1XRYHVFRSHUWHQHOOD0HOLGQHRKLWWLWD 0ൺඋංඈ/ංඏൾඋൺඇං
5LDVVXQWR Dopo quarant’anni di interruzione, la Missione Archeologica della Sapienza Università di Roma ha ripreso lo scavo dell’area nord del- la collina di Arslantepe, antica Melid, presso l’odierna città di Malatya, in Turchia orientale. La lunga interruzione era dovuta alla necessità di concentrare le risorse nello scavo delle fasi più antiche: i complessi mo- numentali del Tardo Calcolitico e Tardo Uruk (IV mill. a.C.) e la sequenza completa dell’Antico Bronzo (III mill. a.C.). Si tratta di un ritorno alle origini dello scavo di Arslantepe «La collina del leone » così denominata dal leone in pietra, parte della porta della cittadella, che emergeva in super Þ cie. Il progetto della nostra ripresa ha dunque un duplice inten- to: dare alla Porta dei Leoni un contesto topogra Þ co e stratigra Þ co che tuttora le manca; e poi scendere ai livelli inferiori, per colmare il lungo periodo intercorso tra la distruzione della Porta Imperiale e la costruzio- ne della Porta dei Leoni. La campagna del 2008 ha raggiunto il primo scopo: ora sappiamo dunque che la Porta dei Leoni fu costruita alla Þ ne del IX secolo e distrutta alla Þ ne dell’VIII (appunto da Sargon II). La campagna del 2009 ha a ৼ rontato il secondo problema, scendendo al di sotto del salone a pilastri, rimuovendone una fase precedente, incon- trando poi insediamenti di squatters istallati sul rudere del grande muro di cinta post-imperiale, bruciato da un colossale incendio. Servirà ancora un'altra campagna per raggiungere il livello alla base del muro di cinta, conservato per quasi quattro metri di altezza. Ma già ora abbiamo dati storicamente importanti: dopo la Þ ne dell’impero hittita, la vicenda della città non è da ricostruire (come fatto Þ nora) nel segno della continui- tà, bensì nel segno della discontinuità, con crisi e distruzioni, abbandoni quasi totali, vicende turbolente, prima di arrivare alla grande ripresa della metà del IX secolo. In questo modo l'antica Melid si inserisce nella generale vicenda del Levante nella prima età del ferro, vicenda di una lenta ricostituzione delle strutture urbane e statali che erano entrate in crisi con la Þ ne dell'età del Tardo Bronzo e il crollo dell’impero hittita.
$FFDGHPLDGHOOH6FLHQ]HGL7RULQRSURIHVVRUHHPHULWRJLjRUGLQDULRGL6WRULDGHO9LFLQR 2ULHQWHDQWLFRQHOOD6DSLHQ]D8QLYHUVLWjGL5RPD(PDLOPOLYHU#PFOLQNLW&RQIHUHQ]DWH QXWDLOIHEEUDLRWHVWRULYLVWRQHOO¶DSULOH Mario Liverani
)LJ/DFROOLQDGL$UVODQWHSHYHGXWDGDOO¶HOLFRWWHUR
)LJ$UVODQWHSHOD©3RUWDGHL/HRQLªSLDQWDGL/'HODSRUWH Nuove scoperte nella Melid neo-hittita
4XDOFXQRGLYRLIRUVHULFRUGHUjFKHLQXQSUHFHGHQWHLQWHUYHQWRLQTXH VWD VHGH QHO YL SDUODL GHOOH PLH ULFHUFKH VWRULFRDUFKHRORJLFKH QHO 6DKDUDOLELFRÊVWDWDTXHOODXQDEUHYHSDUHQWHVLQHOODPLDDWWLYLWjGLULFHUFD FKHULJXDUGDLQYHFHLO9LFLQR2ULHQWHHQRQLO6DKDUD8QDSDUHQWHVLGRYX WDDQHFHVVLWjRFFDVLRQDOLODJORULRVDPLVVLRQHGHOO¶8QLYHUVLWjGL5RPDQHO 6DKDUD OLELFR ULVFKLDYD OD ¿QH FRO SHQVLRQDPHQWR GHO VXR IRQGDWRUH H GL UHWWRUH )DEUL]LR 0RUL VH QRQ PH QH IRVVL SUHVR FXUD$൶GDWD SRL DSSHQD SRVVLELOH ODPLVVLRQHDPDQLSLDSSURSULDWHHSLJLRYDQLGHOOHPLH FLRqD TXHOOHGL6DYLQR'L/HUQLD VRQRWRUQDWRDRFFXSDUPLDWHPSRSLHQRGLDQWLFR 2ULHQWHHVRQRDQFKHWRUQDWRDOORVFDYRGL$UVODQWHSHSUHVVR0DODW\D O¶DQ WLFD0HOLG QHOOD7XUFKLDRULHQWDOHGRYHDYHYRJLjODYRUDWRSHUDQQL GDO DO LQWHUURPSHQGRODPLDSDUWHFLSD]LRQHDSSXQWRSHUSDVVDUH©LQ SUHVWLWRªDO6DKDUD6RQRJUDWRDOODSURI0DUFHOOD)UDQJLSDQHFKHGLULJHOR VFDYRGL$UVODQWHSHSHUDYHUPLD൶GDWRODULSUHVDGHOORVFDYRQHOO¶DUHDQRUG GHOODFROOLQDOjGRYHHPHUJRQRLUHVWLGHOSHULRGRQHRKLWWLWD )LJ 7HQJRD ULQJUD]LDUHODSURI)UDQJLSDQHQRQVRORSHUOD¿GXFLDPDDQFKHSHUODFRQWL QXDFRQVXOHQ]DLO'RWW)HGHULFR0DQXHOOLPLRFRPSDJQRG¶LPSUHVDHWXWWL FRORURFKHKDQQRFROODERUDWRLO'RWW$QGUHD5LFFLOD'RWW/XLVD%DUEDWR HLO'RWW&RUUDGR$OYDURFKHKDGLUHWWRLOODYRURWRSRJUD¿FRHVHJXLWRGDOOD 'RWW*LXOLD'H3HUVLLV /¶DUHDQRUGGHOODFROOLQDGL$UVODQWHSHHUDJLjVWDWDVFDYDWDGDOOD0LVVLRQH ,WDOLDQDQHJOLDQQL¶SULPDGLXQDOXQJDLQWHUUX]LRQH GLDQQLGDODO GRYXWDDOODQHFHVVLWjGLFRQFHQWUDUHOHULVRUVHXPDQHH¿QDQ]LDULHQHOOR VFDYRGHOOHIDVLSLDQWLFKHLFRPSOHVVLPRQXPHQWDOLGHO7DUGR&DOFROLWLFRH 7DUGR8UXN ,9PLOOD& FKHKDQQRUHVRLOVLWRFHOHEUHQHOPRQGRDUFKHRORJLFR LQWHUQD]LRQDOHHSRLODVHTXHQ]DFRPSOHWDGHOO¶$QWLFR%URQ]R ,,,PLOOD& FKH QRQKDO¶HJXDOHLQWXWWDODUHJLRQH 0DDQFKHODULSUHVDGHOORVFDYRGHOO¶DUHDQRUG VLSURVSHWWDGLJUDQGHLQWHUHVVH6LWUDWWDLQUHDOWjGLXQULWRUQRDOOHRULJLQLQHOOR VFDYRGL$UVODQWHSH©/DFROOLQDGHOOHRQHªFRVuGHQRPLQDWDGDOOHRQHLQSLHWUD HOHPHQWRGHFRUDWLYRQHOODSRUWDGHOODFLWWDGHOODFKHHPHUJHYDLQVXSHU¿FLH HFKHIXIRWRJUDIDWRIUDO¶DOWURQHOGDOODFHOHEUH*HUWUXGH%HOOLQYLDJ JLRYHUVROD0HVRSRWDPLD1HJOLDQQL¶GHOVHFRORVFRUVR/RXLV'HODSRUWH VFDYzDSSXQWR©/DSRUWHGHVOLRQVª FRPHHJOLLQWLWROzODSXEEOLFD]LRQHGHO PRQXPHQWR )LJ FKHSRLYHQQHWUDVSRUWDWDDO0XVHRGL$QNDUDGRYHDQ FRUDRJJLIXQJHGDLQJUHVVRPRQXPHQWDOHDOVDORQHFHQWUDOH6XOODEDVHGHOOR
0)UDQJLSDQH Arslantepe 0LODQR(DG Arslantepe. Cretulae 5RPD /'HODSRUWH Malatya I. La porte des lions 3DULVDQFKH,G La troisième campagne de fouilles à Malatya LQ©5HYXH+LWWLWHHW$VLDQLTXHªSS Mario Liverani
)LJ$UVODQWHSHODSRUWDKLWWLWDLPSHULDOHIRWRHSLDQWD VRYUDSSRVWDDOOD©3RUWDGHL/HRQLª Nuove scoperte nella Melid neo-hittita
VWLOHGHLULOLHYLVFROSLWLHGHOOHLVFUL]LRQLDOODSRUWDYHQQHDVVHJQDWDXQDGDWD PROWRDOWDDOOD¿QHGHO,,PLOOHQQLRD& 0DODSRUWDHUDDQFRUDLQXVRPH]]R PLOOHQQLRGRSRTXDQGR6DUJRQ,,GLVWUXVVHODFLWWjQHOD&HGDQFKHOD SRVL]LRQHVWUDWLJUD¿FD SXUFRQOHLPSUHFLVLRQLGLDOORUD QRQVHPEUDYDDVVH JQDUHDOPRQXPHQWRXQDGDWDFRVuDOWD,QL]LzGXQTXHODULFHUFDGLXQDSRUWD DQWHULRUHRGLXQDIDVHDQWHULRUHGHOODVWHVVDSRUWDGDOODTXDOHLULOLHYLIRVVH URVWDWLSUHOHYDWLSHUHVVHUHULXWLOL]]DWLLQTXHOODVFDYDWDGDO'HODSRUWH1HJOL DQQL¶ODFHUFzLQYDQR&ODXGH6FKDH൵HU LOIDPRVRVFDYDWRUHGL8JDULW PDQRQRVWDQWHOHHQRUPLHSURIRQGHWULQFHHGDOXLIDWWHDSULUHVXWXWWRLOVLWR DVSRUWDQGRVHQ]DULJXDUGRDOFXQRHGL¿FLDQFKHLPSRUWDQWLHSRLODVFLDQGRLO WXWWRLQHGLWR QRQODWURYz1HJOLDQQL¶TXDQGRLQL]LzDGRSHUDUHODPLV VLRQH LWDOLDQD GLUHWWD GD 6DOYDWRUH 3XJOLVL LQL]LDOPHQWH FRQ OD SUHVHQ]D GL 3LHUR0HULJJLFKHVSHUDYDGLWURYDUHLVFUL]LRQLKLWWLWHJHURJOL¿FKHPDFKHEHQ SUHVWRVLVFRUDJJLz 3DROR(PLOLR3HFRUHOODDSSURIRQGuORVFDYRHWURYzOD 3RUWD,PSHULDOH )LJ SURSULRVRWWRDGRYHHUDVWDWDOD3RUWDGHL/HRQL PD TXHVWD3RUWD,PSHULDOHHUDWURSSRDQWLFDHQRQDEEDVWDQ]DVSRJOLDWDSHUSRWHUOD LGHQWL¿FDUHFRQTXHOODGDFXLSURYHQLVVHURLULOLHYL ,OIDWWRqFKHWUDLOOLYHOORGHOOD3RUWD,PSHULDOHHTXHOORGHOOD3RUWDGHL /HRQLVLLQWHUSRQHLOOLYHOORFRUULVSRQGHQWHDGXQJURVVRPXURGLFLQWDLQPDW WRQLFUXGLVXEDVDPHQWRLQSLHWUDPXURFKHYHQQHSUHVXPLELOPHQWHPHVVRLQ OXFHJLjGDOOR6FKDH൵HUHFKHRUDqEHQYLVLELOH SHUXQDO]DWRGLTXDWWURPHWUL VXOSHQGLRGHOODFROOLQD4XHVWRPXURFKHYDD¿QLUHSURSULRVRSUDDOOD3RUWD ,PSHULDOH HGXQTXHSURSULRVRWWROD3RUWDGHL/HRQL GRYHYDDYHUHFHUWDPHQ WHDQFK¶HVVRXQDSRUWDSURSULRLQTXHOORVWHVVRSXQWRGRYHFRQYHUJRQRLGXH WUDWWLVXSHUVWLWLGHOPXUR4XHVWDSRUWDSHUzSURSULRSHUHVVHUHVWDWDVSRJOLDWD GHLVXRLODVWURQLLQSLHWUDVFROSLWLRHUDGHOWXWWRPDQFDQWHRSLSUREDELOPHQWH HUDLQWDQWRFDWWLYRVWDWRGLFRQVHUYD]LRQHFKHOR6FKDH൵HU FKHLQYHULWjVFD YDYDLQPRGRDVVDLVSLFFLRHGDSSURVVLPDWLYR QRQODLQGLYLGXz2YYLDPHQWH LO3HFRUHOODWURYzO¶DUHDJLjDVSRUWDWDGHOOR6FKDH൵HUHQRQSRWpFKHDQGDUSL VRWWRWURYDQGROD3RUWD,PSHULDOH ,OSURJHWWRGHOODQRVWUDULSUHVDQRQSRWHYDQRQWHQHUFRQWRGLTXHVWDVWRULD SUHJUHVVDGHOORVFDYRLQTXHOVHWWRUHHWHQWDUGLULVROYHUHLSUREOHPLULPDVWL LQVRVSHVRROWUHRYYLDPHQWHDSRUQHGLDOWULHQXRYL FRPHVHPSUHVXFFHGH
( $NXUJDO Remarques stylistiques sur les reliefs de Malatya ,VWDQEXO ,G Späthethitische Bildkunst $QNDUDSSDQFKH:2UWKPDQQ Untersuchungen zur späthethitischen Kunst %RQQ 3( 3HFRUHOOD Malatya III. Rapporto preliminare delle campagne 1963-1968. Il livello eteo imperiale e quelli neoetei 5RPDLQSUHFHGHQ]D63XJOLVLH30HULJJL Malatya I. Rapporto preliminare delle campagne 1961 e 1962 5RPD Mario Liverani
)LJ$UVODQWHSHLOJUDQGHPXUREUXFLDWRGDHVW
)LJ$UVODQWHSHJOLHGL¿FLGHOOLYHOORQHRKLWWLWDQHOODSLDQWDGHO'HODSRUWH Nuove scoperte nella Melid neo-hittita
,QWHUPLQLVFKHPDWLFLFLSURSRQHYDPRXQGXSOLFHLQWHQWR,OSULPRLQWHQWR HUDTXHOORGLGDUH¿QDOPHQWHDOOD3RUWDGHL/HRQLXQFRQWHVWRWRSRJUD¿FRH VWUDWLJUD¿FRSHUULFROORFDUODQHOWHPSRHQHOORVSD]LRLQPDQLHUDFRQFUHWD 'LFR©FRQWHVWRWRSRJUD¿FRªSHUFKpODSRUWDVLDSULYDVXXQJUDQGHSLD]]DOH ODVWULFDWR )LJ VXFXLVLD൵DFFLDYDQRHGL¿FLLPSRUWDQWLGHLTXDOLSLDFHUHE EHGHWHUPLQDUHIRUPDHIXQ]LRQHLO'HODSRUWHVFDYzO¶HGL¿FLRDGRYHVWGHOOD SRUWDPDODVXDWUDJLFDPRUWHQHOFDPSRGLFRQFHQWUDPHQWRQD]LVWDJOLLPSHGu GLSXEEOLFDUOR'LFRSRL©FRQWHVWRVWUDWLJUD¿FRªSHUFKpVHODVWUDWLJUD¿DGHOOD SRUWD q SHUVD SHU VHPSUH SHUz OR VFDYR GHJOL HGL¿FL DG HVVD DVVRFLDWL SXz IRUQLUH¿QDOPHQWHDOODSRUWDVWHVVDXQDGDWD]LRQHFKHDQFRUDPDQFD/RVWLOH GHL ULOLHYL VFROSLWL RYYLDPHQWH SXz GDWDUH O¶HGL¿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¿FDWUD OD¿QHGHO,;VHFRORHOD¿QHGHOO¶9,,,/DFDPSDJQDGHOKDD൵URQWDWR LOVHFRQGRSUREOHPDLQL]LDQGRDVFHQGHUHDOGLVRWWRGHOVDORQHDSLODVWULHUL PXRYHQGRDOFXQLGHLOLYHOOLSUHFHGHQWL6HUYLUjDQFRUDXQ¶DOWUDFDPSDJQDSHU UDJJLXQJHUHLOOLYHOORDOODEDVHGHOJUDQGHPXUREUXFLDWRPDJLjRUDDEELDPR GHLGDWLVWRULFDPHQWHLPSRUWDQWLSHUFRQ¿JXUDUHODVWRULDGHOOD0HOLGQHRKLW WLWDLQPDQLHUDGLYHUVDGDTXHOODFRUUHQWHFRPHYHGUHPR0DSURFHGLDPRFRQ RUGLQHVHJXHQGRODVWUDWLJUD¿DGDOO¶DOWRLQEDVVR /¶HGL¿FLRFKHLO'HODSRUWHVFDYzHODVFLzLQHGLWRORDEELDPRULSXOLWRDIRQGR GRSRVHWWDQWDDQQLGLSLRJJLDQHYHHLQFXULD 2YYLDPHQWHLPXULLQSLHWUD FLRq OHEDVLGHLPXULLOFXLDO]DWRHUDLQPDWWRQLFUXGL HUDQRDQFRUDOuJURVVRPRGR LQWDWWLPHQWUHLSLDQLSDYLPHQWDOLHUDQRRUPDLVSDULWL6DUHEEHXWLOHULQWUDFFLDUH OHFDUWHGHO'HODSRUWHIRUVHD,VWDQEXORIRUVHD3DULJLSHUDYHUHPDJJLRULGHW WDJOLVXOORVFDYRGLDOORUDPDJDULTXDOFKHGDWRFKHDLXWLDPHJOLRFRPSUHQGHUQH ODIXQ]LRQHHODFROORFD]LRQHVWUDWLJUD¿FD&RPXQTXHODSLDQWLQDGHOO¶HGL¿FLR YHUDPHQWHPLFURVFRSLFD SXEEOLFDWDGDO'HODSRUWHQHOYROXPHVXOOD3RUWDGHL /HRQLFRUULVSRQGHDEEDVWDQ]DEHQHDTXDQWRULWURYDWRVDOYRFKHYDQQRDJJLXQWH XQSDLRGLVWDQ]HGDOXLLJQRUDWH O¶HGL¿FLRqSURSULRDOPDUJLQHGHOSHQGLRHG Mario Liverani
)LJ$UVODQWHSHLOVDORQHDSLODVWULSDYLPHQWD]LRQH¿QDOH
)LJ$UVODQWHSHLOVDORQHDSLODVWULSDYLPHQWD]LRQH¿QDOHGDQRUGHVW Nuove scoperte nella Melid neo-hittita qLQSDUWHHURVR /¶HGL¿FLRHUDWHUUD]]DWROHVWDQ]HSLDVXGGHOOLPLWHGLVFDYR VRQRIRQGDWHDGXQDTXRWDEHQSLDOWDVHJXHQGRO¶DQGDPHQWRGHOODFROOLQDFLRq GHLSUHFHGHQWLDFFXPXOL/¶HGL¿FLRGHYHULVDOLUHDOO¶HSRFDGHOODSUHVHQ]DDVVLUD GRSRODGLVWUX]LRQHGHOD&JLDFFKpLOVRWWRVWDQWHHGL¿FLRDSLODVWULqTXHOOR GLVWUXWWRDSSXQWRGD6DUJRQDJLXGLFDUHGDLUHVWLFHUDPLFL±HGLIDWWLODSLDQWD GHOO¶HGL¿FLR'HODSRUWHULFKLDPDTXHOODGHJOLHGL¿FLSURYLQFLDOLDVVLUL 'XQTXHJOL$VVLULVSLDQDURQROHURYLQHGHOO¶HGL¿FLRDSLODVWULHYLLPSLDQ WDURQR VRSUD XQD VRUWD GL SLDWWDIRUPD LQ PDWWRQL FUXGL SUREDELOPHQWH SHU FRQWHQHUHODVSLQWDGHOODFROOLQDPHGLDQWHXQWHUUD]]DPHQWRHSHURWWHQHUH XQDVXSHU¿FLHSLDQDSHUO¶HGL¿FD]LRQHGHOO¶HGL¿FLRVXFFHVVLYRFKHVLVSLQJH YDYHUVRQRUGVYDULDWLPHWULROWUHLOPDUJLQHGHOSUHFHGHQWHHGL¿FLRDSLODVWUL /DSLDWWDIRUPDLQPDWWRQLHUDDOWDXQSDLRGLPHWULHGqLQSDUWHFRQVHUYDWD PDLQSDUWHPDJJLRUHWDJOLDWDYLDGDXQDGHOOHWULQFHHGHOOR6FKDH൵HU6LQRWL FKHJLjLO'HODSRUWHDYHYDLQFRQWUDWRDOWUHSLDWWDIRUPHLQPDWWRQLFUXGLQHOOD SDUWHFHQWUDOHGHOODFROOLQDHOHDYHYDGDWDWHDSSXQWRDOSHULRGRGHOODSUH VHQ]DDVVLUD6LDGHWWRSHULQFLVRTXHVWDSUHVHQ]DDVVLUDQRQGXUzPROWRJLj LOVXFFHVVRUHGL6DUJRQ6HQQDFKHULESHUVHLOFRQWUROORGHOOD]RQDH0HOLG GDSSULPDVLRULHQWzYHUVRO¶RYHVWYHUVROD&DSSDGRFLD DOORUDUHJQRGL7DEDO HYHUVROD)ULJLDPDSRLHQWUzQHOODVXDFULVL¿QDOH1RQVLHUDPDLYHUDPHQWH ULSUHVDGDOFROSRLQIHUWROHGD6DUJRQHVRORGLYHUVLVHFROLGRSRLQHWjURPDQD ODSRVL]LRQHVWUDWHJLFDVXOFRQ¿QHRULHQWDOHGHOO¶LPSHURLQYLVWDGHOO¶(XIUDWH FUHHUjXQDQXRYD0HOLGODFODVVLFD0HOLWHQHDGDOFXQLFKLORPHWULGLGLVWDQ]D 8QYROWDULSXOLWRO¶HGL¿FLR'HODSRUWHHFKLDULWDQHSHUTXDQWRSRVVLELOHOD SRVL]LRQHVWUDWLJUD¿FDHO¶HVWHQVLRQHWRSRJUD¿FDORDEELDPRULPRVVR)DFLOH DGLUVLPDqVWDWRXQODYRUDFFLREDVWLGLUHFKHLOPXURHVW EDVDPHQWRHFDP PLQDPHQWRHVWHUQR GHOO¶HGL¿FLRHUDODUJRRWWRPHWUL8QFDOFRORVRPPDULRPL SRUWDDVWLPDUHFKHDEELDPRULPRVVRTXDOFRVDFRPHPHWULFXELGLPXUDWXUD SHUORSLLQJURVVHSLHWUH±FHUFDQGRGLFRQYLQFHUHJOLRSHUDLFKHVHJOL+LWWLWL HUDQRVWDWLFDSDFLGLSRUWDUOHOuORURGRYHYDQRQRQHVVHUGDPHQRHSRUWDUOHYLD 3HUzQHqYDOVDODSHQDULPRVVRO¶HGL¿FLRHULPRVVLDQFKHLUHVWLGHOODSLDW WDIRUPDLQPDWWRQLqDSSDUVRLOJUDQGHHGL¿FLRDSLODVWULXQDPELHQWHOXQJR PHWULHODUJRPXULHVFOXVL )LJ /HIRQGD]LRQLGHLPXULQRUGHGRYHVW HUDQRLQSDUWHVFDYDWHQHOVXROR ODIDFFLDLQWHUQDqDYLVWDPDO¶HVWHUQDqLQ XQWDJOLR HGXQTXHO¶HGL¿FLRHUDOHJJHUPHQWHVHPLQWHUUDWR,OPXURVXGVL LQWUDYHGHQHOODWULQFHD6FKDH൵HUPHQWUHLOODWRHVWVLDSULYDVXOSLD]]DOHGHOOD 3RUWDGHL/HRQLPHGLDQWHGXHSDVVDJJL TXHVWDSDUWHqSHUzPROWRPDOULGRWWD
)0DQXHOOL Assyria and the Provinces. Survival of Local Features and Imposition of New Patterns in the Peripheral Regions of the Empire LQ©0HVRSRWDPLDªSS Mario Liverani
SHUODVRYUDSSRVL]LRQHGHOJUDQGHPXURGHOO¶HGL¿FLRDVVLUR 4XHVWRDPSLR VDORQH )LJ qFDUDWWHUL]]DWRGDOODSUHVHQ]DGLGXH¿OHGLSLODVWUL QHUHVWDQR VROROHEDVL HGDXQSDYLPHQWRLQWHUDPHQWHFRVWLWXLWRGDFLRWWROLGL¿XPHGL GLPHQVLRQHPHGLD,SLODVWULVRQRGLVSRVWLDLQWHUYDOOLUHJRODULVLDWUDGLORUR VLDULVSHWWRDLPXULSHULPHWUDOLHVHPEUDQRDEEDVWDQ]DUREXVWLGDSRWHUVR VWHQHUHXQHYHQWXDOHSLDQRVXSHULRUH'LTXHVWRHGLWXWWRO¶DO]DWRQRQUHVWD QXOODHYLGHQWHPHQWHJOL$VVLULGRSRDYHUGLVWUXWWRO¶HGL¿FLRQHVSLDQDURQR HDVSRUWDURQRLUHVWL VRSUDWWXWWRLSUH]LRVLWURQFKLGHOOHFRORQQHHWUDYLGHOOD FRSHUWXUD ¿QRDUDJJLXQJHUHLOFLRWWRODWR VROLGRHRUL]]RQWDOH VXFXLLPSLDQ WDURQRODSLDWWDIRUPDLQPDWWRQL/RVLYHGHYDEHQHJLjSULPDGLVFDYDUHQHO WDJOLRGHOOD7ULQFHD6FKDH൵HU 'DTXHVWDULVXOWDYDDQFKHFKHFLUFDFPVRWWRDOFLRWWRODWRJUDQGHFH QHHUDXQDOWURDFLRWWROLSLFFROLFRUULVSRQGHQWHHYLGHQWHPHQWHDGXQDSULPD IDVHGLXWLOL]]RGHOO¶HGL¿FLR$EELDPRGXQTXHULPRVVR FRQTXDOFKHGLVSLD FHUH LO FLRWWRODWR VXSHULRUH H DEELDPR PHVVR LQ OXFH TXHOOR VRWWRVWDQWH L PXULSHULPHWUDOLULPDQHQGRJOLVWHVVL4XHVWRFLRWWRODWRLQIHULRUHqPHQREHQ FRQVHUYDWRPDVLYHGHEHQHFKHLOVDORQHHUDRULJLQDULDPHQWHSDYLPHQWDWR LQJUDQGLODVWURQLLQWXWWDOD]RQDSHULPHWUDOHHLQFLRWWROLSLFFROLVRORQHOOD ]RQDFHQWUDOH6LYHGHDQFKHFKHLQYHFHGHLJUDQGLSLODVWULF¶HUDQRGHOOHSL PRGHVWHEDVLURWRQGHGLFRORQQH RYYLDPHQWHOLJQHH LQSDUWHFRQVHUYDWLPD SLVSHVVRLQGLYLGXDELOLLQODFXQHFLUFRODULQHOSDYLPHQWRHGLVSRVWLSURED ELOPHQWHLQWUH¿OHPHQRUHJRODULSHUzGHOOH¿OHGLSLODVWULGHOODVLVWHPD]LRQH VXFFHVVLYDHFRVuHVLOLGDSRWHUVRVWHQHUHXQDWHWWRLDPDQRQFHUWRXQSLDQR VXSHULRUH6DOYRDSSURIRQGLUHORVWXGLRGLUHLFKHODSULPDVLVWHPD]LRQHGR YHYDFRPSRUWDUHXQFLRWWRODWRFHQWUDOHDFLHORDSHUWRHXQDWHWWRLDOXQJRWXWWL LPXULPHQWUHODVHFRQGDVLVWHPD]LRQHGRYHYDHVVHUHLQWHUDPHQWHFRSHUWD H FRQXQSLDQRVXSHULRUHRDOPHQRXQWHUUD]]RDJLELOH 3HUODGDWD]LRQHGHOQRVWURVDORQHDEELDPRSRWXWREDVDUFLVXLUHVWLFHUDPL FLFRQWHQXWLQHLFPFKHVHSDUDQRLGXHSDYLPHQWLHFKHVRQREHQVLJLOODWL LO FLRWWRODWRVXSHULRUHHUDLQJUDQSDUWHLQWDWWR /¶RUL]]RQWHFHUDPLFRVWXGLDWR GDO'U0DQXHOOLVLFROORFDWUDOD¿QHGHO,;VHFRORHODPHWjGHOO¶9,,,4XHVWR FRQFRUGDFRQO¶DWWULEX]LRQHGHOODGLVWUX]LRQH¿QDOHD6DUJRQ D& HLQ GLFDSHUODFRVWUX]LRQHGHOO¶HGL¿FLRXQDGDWDLQWRUQRDOO¶D&HSHUODVXD ULSDYLPHQWD]LRQHXQDGDWDLQWRUQRDOD&4XHVWRqXQGDWRLPSRUWDQWH SHUFKpO¶HGL¿FLRDSLODVWULHUDFRQQHVVRFRQOD3RUWDGHL/HRQL HQWUDWLDWWUDYHU VRODSRUWDVLJLUDYDDGHVWUDSHUDFFHGHUHDOVDORQHFRQXQSDLRGLJUDGLQL HGXQTXHODGDWD]LRQHGHOO¶XQRVLDSSOLFDDQFKHDOO¶DOWUD5LFRUGRFKHOD3RUWD GHL/HRQLHUD¿QRUDGDWDWDVXOORVWLOHGHLULOLHYLFKLDUDPHQWHEHQSLDQWLFKL GLDOPHQRWUHVHFROL Nuove scoperte nella Melid neo-hittita
'DOSXQWRGLYLVWDDUFKLWHWWRQLFRVLDODSUHVHQ]DGHLSLODVWULVLDODSDYLPHQ WD]LRQHDFLRWWROLULFKLHGRQRTXDOFKHFRPPHQWRVLDGLFDUDWWHUHJHQHUDOHVLD SLVSHFL¿FDPHQWHLQWHVRDFKLDULUHVHODGL൵HUHQ]DWUDFLRWWRODWRLQIHULRUHH VXSHULRUHHWUDHVLOLFRORQQHHUREXVWLSLODVWULFRPSRUWLDQFKHXQPXWDPHQWR IXQ]LRQDOH,QWHUPLQLJHQHUDOLLSLODVWULFRQEDVLLQSLHWUDHFRORQQHOLJQHH VRQRHVWUDQHLDOO¶DUFKLWHWWXUDGHOO¶DOOXYLRPHVRSRWDPLFRWXWWDLQPDWWRQHFUX GRHFRQVFDUVDGLVSRQLELOLWjVLDGLSLHWUDVLDGLWURQFKLG¶DOWRIXVWR VHPPDL XWLOL]]DWLSHUODFRSHUWXUD 6RQRLQYHFHFDUDWWHULVWLFLDSSXQWRGLWXWWDO¶DUHD PRQWDQD H ERVFRVD FKH YD GDOO¶$QDWROLD FHQWUDOH H RULHQWDOH DWWUDYHUVR 8UDUWX O¶$UPHQLD LOSDHVHGHL0DQQHL O¶RGLHUQR$]HUEDLMDQLUDQLDQR HOD 0HGLDVRSUDWWXWWRQHOODVHFRQGDHWjGHO)HUUR ,;9,,,VHFROR LQXQDYDULHWj GLWLSRORJLHVDORQLTXDGUDWLFRQVYDULDWH¿OHGLFRORQQHVDOHUHWWDQJRODULFRQ GXH¿OHGLFRORQQHOXQJKLSRUWLFLDSHUWLVXXQODWROXQJRPRGHVWHVWDQ]HGL PDJD]]LQRDQFKHLQFDVHSULYDWH4XDQWRDOODSDYLPHQWD]LRQHLQFLRWWROLGL ¿XPHLQTXHVW¶HSRFDHVVDqWLSLFD DQFKHVHQRQHVFOXVLYD GHOO¶DUFKLWHWWXUD QHRKLWWLWD±GD.DUNHPLVKD7HOO7D\QDWD6DNoDJ|]D=LQFLUOL ,FLRWWRODWL FRPHSXUHLODVWULFDWLVRQRRYYLDPHQWHSLIUHTXHQWLHSLDGDWWLDVSD]LDSHU WL FRUWLOLVWUDGHXUEDQH VRSSRUWDQGREHQHODSLRJJLDSHUzQHOO¶DUFKLWHWWXUD QHRKLWWLWDVRQRQRQGLUDGRXWLOL]]DWLDQFKHLQDPELHQWLFRSHUWL 3LLQSDUWLFRODUHODVLVWHPD]LRQHRULJLQDULDGHOQRVWURVDORQHIDSHQVDUH DGXQDIXQ]LRQHXWLOLWDULDHLOFRQIURQWRFRQLOVLWRXUDUWHRGL%DVWDP YHUVR LOD&TXLQGLSRFKLGHFHQQLGRSRLOQRVWURVDORQH GRYHSHUXQHGL¿FLR DQDORJRVLqDSSXUDWR JUD]LHDOO¶DQDOLVLGHOVXRORFKHKDUHVWLWXLWRWUDFFHGL '1$HTXLQR XQXVRFRPHVWDOOD LFDYDOOLHUDQRXQDULVRUVDVWUDWHJLFDSHUOH JXHUUHGHOO¶HSRFDHGHUDQRDOOHYDWLVXJOLDOWRSLDQLDQDWROLFLHGLUDQLFL SXz IDUVRVSHWWDUHFKHDQFKHLOQRVWURVDORQHDFRORQQHSRWHVVHVHQRQHVVHUHXQD YHUDHSURSULDVWDOODSHUzDOPHQRRVSLWDUHGHLFDYDOOLHXQFRUSRGLJXDUGLD SRVWDFRP¶qLQFRQWLJXLWjFRQODSRUWDXUELFD$QFKHO¶XVRGHOFLRWWRODWRHOD FRSHUWXUDSDU]LDOHVRQRHOHPHQWLDGDWWLDGXQXVRGHOJHQHUH$OWHUQDWLYDPHQWH DOO¶LSRWHVLGHOODVWDOODFLVRQRFDVLPROWRIUHTXHQWLGLDPELHQWLDQDORJKL FLRq
5LQYLRDOPLRUDSSRUWRSUHOLPLQDUH Il salone a pilastri della Melid neo-hittita LQ©6FLHQ]H GHOO¶$QWLFKLWjªSS 6.UROO Zur Pferdehaltung in Urartu LQ VII Internationaler Kongress für Iranische Kunst und Archäologie 0QFKHQ :.OHLVV Bastam. I. Ausgrabungen in den urartäischen Anlagen 1972-1975 7HKHUDQHU)RUVFKXQJHQ,9 %HUOLQSS$QFKHOHFHOHEULVWDOOH GL0HJLGGR DWWULEXLWHD6DORPRQH VRQRVLPLOLFIU-6+ROODGD\ The Stables of Ancient Israel LQ/7*HUDW\DQG/*+HUU HGV The Archaeology of Jordan and Other Studies Presented to S.H. Horn %HUULHQ6SULQJV0,SS&IURUD0/LYHUDQL From Melid through Bastam to Megiddo: Stables and Horses in Iron Age II LQ*%/DQIUDQFKL et al. HGV Studies Presented to F.M. Fales :LHVEDGHQSS Mario Liverani
FRQWHWWRLHVRVWHQXWHGDFRORQQHHODVWULFDWRSDU]LDOH DGLELWLDPDJD]]LQR ( VLQRWLFKHLOQRVWURVDORQHqLPSRQHQWHSHUGLPHQVLRQLPDQRQqSDUWLFRODU PHQWHEHQUL¿QLWRVSHFLHQHOODVXDVLVWHPD]LRQHLQL]LDOH ,QYHFHODVHFRQGDVLVWHPD]LRQHTXHOODDJURVVLSLODVWULHFHUWDPHQWHWXWWD FRSHUWDHPROWRUHJRODUHVHPEUDXQVDORQHDGXVRFHULPRQLDOH FRPHVLVXRO GLUH XQDWLSRORJLDFKHKDXQDOXQJDVWRULDLQDPELHQWHDQDWROLFRHLUDQLFR XQD VWRULD FKH LQL]LD JLj QHOOD WDUGD HWj GHO EURQ]R QHOOD FDSLWDOH KLWWLWD GL %R÷D]N|\ HSRFRGRSRQHOVLWRLUDQLFRGL+DVDQOX HFKHSRLDWWUDYHUVRL SDVVDJJLLQDPELHQWLIULJL *RUGLRQHDQFRUD%R÷D]N|\ QHRKLWWLWL FRPH LOQRVWURGL$UVODQWHSH XUDUWHL FRPH%DVWDPPDDQFKHDOWULVLWL HPHGL FRLVDORQLLSRVWLOLGL*RGLQ7HSHHGL1XãL-DQ DSSURGDLQ¿QHQHOO¶ apa- danaLOJUDQGHVDORQHDSLODVWULGHOO¶DUFKLWHWWXUDDFKHPHQLGHQHOOD3HUVLDGHO
$PELHQWLGLPDJD]]LQRFRQFRSHUWXUDSDU]LDOHHSDYLPHQWD]LRQHGL൵HUHQ]LDWDVRQRDQFKH IUHTXHQWLQHO/HYDQWHVHQHYHGDFDWDORJRHGLVFXVVLRQHLQ)%UDHPHU L’architecture domesti- que du Levant à l’âge du Fer 3DULV 31HYH Büyükkale. Die Bauwerke %R÷D]N|\DWWXãD;,, %HUOLQSS VDOH PDJD]]LQL 5+'\VRQ The Iron Age Architecture at Hasanlu: An Essay LQ©([SHGLWLRQª SS *RUGLRQ 0HJDURQH©7HUUDFHEXLOGLQJª 5 9,9VHFROR D6XVD D3DVDUJDGDH HSRLVRSUDWWXWWRD3HUVHSROL 6LIDFFLD SHUzDWWHQ]LRQHDOOHPLVXUHOHVDOHLSRVWLOLDFKHPHQLGLGL6XVDHGL3HUVHSROL VRQRJUDQGLGLHFLYROWHTXHOOHGHLORURSUHFXUVRULXUDWHLHPHGLHYHQWLRYHQ WLFLQTXHYROWHLOQRVWURVDORQHGL$UVODQWHSH(SHUzODWLSRORJLDGHOVDORQHq LQSDUWHDQDORJDDEELDPRLQVRVWDQ]DDFKHIDUHFRQJOLDQWHFHGHQWLGHOO¶ a- padana &HUWRO¶ apadanaqXQDVWUXWWXUDFRPSOHVVDROWUHDOVDORQHFHQWUDOH TXDGUDWRHFRQWDQWH¿OHGLSLODVWULFLVRQRLSRUWLFDWLHVWHUQL GHLTXDOLDQFKH VLSXzULFRVWUXLUHODVWRULDSUHFHGHQWH HGHOOHVWDQ]HDFFHVVRULHFRQXQSDLR GLFRSSLHGLFRORQQH,3HUVLDQLGHULYDURQRLOPRGHOORGDJOLHVHPSODULGHOOD 0HGLDFKHHUDQRSLYLFLQLDORURQHOWHPSRHQHOORVSD]LR0DqLQWHUHVVDQWH QRWDUHFKHDQFKHLVDORQLDSLODVWULGHOODVHFRQGDHWjGHO)HUURDYHYDQRLORUR DQWHFHGHQWLPDQRQOLDYHYDQRQpLQ8UDUWXQpLQ0HGLDSHULOVHPSOLFHIDWWR FKHLQTXHOOH]RQHQRQF¶HUDVWDWDDOFXQDDUFKLWHWWXUDPRQXPHQWDOHSULPDGHO ODVHFRQGDHWjGHO)HUUR$YHYDQRLQYHFHLORURDQWHFHGHQWLQHOO¶DUFKLWHWWXUD KLWWLWDLPSHULDOH GHO;,9;,,,VHFROR HGXQTXHLOUXRORGHOO¶DUFKLWHWWXUDQHR KLWWLWD D0HOLGHSUHVXPLELOPHQWHDQFKHDOWURYH qVWDWRTXHOORGLULYLWDOL]]DUH O¶HUHGLWjLPSHULDOHHGLWUDVPHWWHUODYHUVRHVW¿QRDOO¶,UDQ ,Q¿QH XQD QRWD]LRQH GL SURVSHWWLYD LO VDORQH D SLODVWUL GD QRL VFDYDWR HUDSDUWHGLXQHGL¿FLRSLDPSLRHFRPSOHVVRLOPXURVXGFRPHVLYHGH QHOODSDUHWHGHOOD7ULQFHD6FKDH൵HUQRQqXQPXURSRUWDQWHqXQGLYLVRULR ULVSHWWRDGDOWUDRDOWUHVWDQ]H3LDFHUHEEHHVWHQGHUHORVFDYRLQRUL]]RQWDOH HPHWWHUHLQOXFHO¶LQWHURHGL¿FLRPDFLzULFKLHGHUHEEHORVFDYRGHOO¶LQWHUD FROOLQDFKHVLHUJHDVXGGHOVDORQHTXDOFRVDFKHVXSHUDLWHPSLHOHULVRU VHDWWXDOPHQWHGLVSRQLELOLHSURJUDPPDELOL4XDOFXQRPDJDULSRWUjIDUORLQ XQDSURVVLPDJHQHUD]LRQH±VHPSUHDPPHVVRFKHQHOQRVWURSDHVHPLJOLRULQR 6XVD ULDVVXQWLYDPHQWH 5 %RXFKDUODW Suse et la Susiane à l’époque achéménide LQ Achaemenid History ,9/HLGHQSS '6WURQDFK Pasargadae. A Report on the Excavations conducted by the British Institute of Persian Studies from 1961 to 1963 2[IRUG ()6FKPLGW Persepolis, I. Structures, Reliefs, Inscriptions 2ULHQWDO,QVWLWXWH3XEOLFDWLRQV &KLFDJRGDLQWHJUDUHFRQ$%ULWW7LOLD Studies and Restorations at Persepolis and Other Sites of F Ɨrs ,,5RPD /DVWRULDGHOWLSRDUFKLWHWWRQLFRGHOVDORQHLSRVWLORqVWDWDIDWWDSLYROWHVXLGDWLGLYROWDLQYROWDGL VSRQLELOLFIUIUDO¶DOWUR*GH)UDQFRYLFK Problems of Achaemenid Architecture LQ©(DVWDQG:HVWª SS:.OHLVV: Zur Entwicklung der achaemenidischem Palastarchitektur LQ ©,UDQLFD$QWLTXDª SS ,G Aspekte urartäischer Architektur LQ ©,UDQLFD $QWLTXDªSS,G Die Entwicklung von Palasten und palastartigen Wohnbauten in Iran :LHQ&IURUD0/LYHUDQL The Pillared Hall of Neo-Hittite Melid: A New Link in the Development of an Architectural Type LQ&/LSSROLVH6'H0DUWLQR DFXUDGL Studi in onore di A. Invernizzi 0HVRSRWDPLD0RQRJUD¿H )LUHQ]HSS Mario Liverani VLDOHGLVSRQLELOLWjHFRQRPLFKHVLDO¶DWWHQ]LRQHGHOPRQGRSROLWLFRYHUVROD ULFHUFDVFLHQWL¿FD3HULOPRPHQWRODVWUDWHJLDFKHFRQVHQWHGLRWWHQHUHXQ PDVVLPR GL QXRYH LQIRUPD]LRQL ULVSHWWR DO EXGJHW GLVSRQLELOH q TXHOOD GL FRQWLQXDUHDVFHQGHUHSHUPHWWHUHLQOXFHLOLYHOOLSUHFHGHQWL,QTXHVWDVFHOWD VLDPRVWDWLFHUWDPHQWHVWLPRODWLGDOODSUHVHQ]DGHOJUDQGHPXURGLFLQWDLQ PDWWRQLEUXFLDWLGLFXLKRGHWWRDOO¶LQL]LR/DSURVSHWWLYDGLRWWHQHUHXQDVH TXHQ]DFRQWLQXDGDOOLYHOORKLWWLWDLPSHULDOH ;,9;,,,VHFROR FRQOD3RUWD 3HFRUHOODDWWUDYHUVRLOOLYHOORGHOPXUREUXFLDWRFRQODVXDSRUWD DVSRUWDWD GDOOR6FKDH൵HU H¿QRDOOLYHOORGHOVDORQHDSLODVWULHGHOOD3RUWDGHL/HRQL VDUHEEHGLJUDQGHLPSRUWDQ]DVWRULFD $EELDPRGXQTXHGHFLVRGLDVSRUWDUHLQSDUWHLOVDORQHDSLODVWUL ODVFLDQGR ODSDUWHRYHVWFKHqODPHJOLRFRQVHUYDWD HVFHQGHUH¿QRDOOLYHOORGHO0XUR %UXFLDWR FKHJLjHPHUJHYDQHOOD]RQDDQRUGGHOO¶HGL¿FLRDSLODVWUL 6LWUDWWD GLVFHQGHUHGLFLUFDTXDWWURPHWULVXXQDVXSHU¿FLHGLFLUFDPHWULTXDGUL 2OWUH DOOD FDPSDJQD GHO JLj H൵HWWXDWD FL YRUUj VHQ]D GXEELR WXWWD OD FDPSDJQDGHOHIRUVHQHSSXUHEDVWHUjGLSHQGHGDOOHFRPSOLFD]LRQLFKH LQFRQWUHUHPRLQFRUVRGLVFDYR0DJLjODVWDJLRQHKDULVHUYDWRVRUSUHVH HULVXOWDWLFKHPLSDLRQRLPSRUWDQWLHFKHRUDHVSRUUzEUHYHPHQWHSUHJDQGRYL GLWHQHUSUHVHQWHFKHLOODYRURqDQFRUDLQ¿HULHGXQTXHO¶LQWHUSUHWD]LRQHq SURYYLVRULD /DSULPDVRUSUHVD FKHKDFRPSRUWDWRXQUDOOHQWDPHQWRQHOULWPRGLVFDYR qVWDWDTXHOODGLWURYDUHDOGLVRWWRGHOODSDUWHRULHQWDOHGHOVDORQHDSLODVWUL FLRqODSDUWHGHOO¶LQJUHVVRYHUVRLOSLD]]DOHGHOOD3RUWDLUHVWL PDOFRQVHUYDWL GLXQDSUHFHGHQWHVWUXWWXUDXQHGL¿FLRFRQYDULHVWDQ]HWWHFKHQRQVRORKDOR VWHVVRRULHQWDPHQWR TXDVLSHUIHWWDPHQWHQRUGVXG GHOVDORQHDSLODVWULPD FKHqVWDWRGDTXHVWRLQJUDQSDUWHGLVWUXWWRPDLQSDUWHDQFKHULXWLOL]]DWRLQ SDUWLFRODUHLOJUDQGHPXURGLWHUUD]]RVXOPDUJLQHHVWFKHGjVXOSLD]]DOHGHOOD 3RUWDHUDJLjFRVWUXLWR LQXQDVXDSULPDVLVWHPD]LRQH LQTXHVWDSULPLVVLPD IDVH3XUWURSSRTXHVWRSULPRHGL¿FLRqWURSSRPDOFRQVHUYDWRSHUSRWHUQHDYH UHXQDULFRVWUX]LRQHFRPSOHVVLYDHFRQYLQFHQWHPDODSHUVLVWHQ]DGHOPXUR HVWGLWHUUD]]RLPSOLFDFKHODWRSRJUD¿DGHOOD]RQDIRVVHJLjJURVVRPRGRDQD ORJDDTXHOODGHOODIHVHVXFFHVVLYDFRQODSRUWDXUELFDVHPSUHFROORFDWDQHOOD VWHVVDSRVL]LRQHHFRQXQHGL¿FLRVXELWRDGRYHVWGHOSLD]]DOH%HQLQWHVR TXHVWDSULPDVLVWHPD]LRQHHGLOL]LDQRQKDQXOODDFKHYHGHUHFROPXURGLFLQWD LQPDWWRQLEUXFLDWLVLDSHUFKpODTXRWDqEHQGLYHUVD VLDPRFLUFDWUHPHWULSL VRSUD VLDSHUFKpGLYHUVRqO¶RULHQWDPHQWR4XHVWDSULPDIDVHGHOO¶HGL¿FLRD RULHQWDPHQWRQRUGVXGYDVHPPDLFRQQHVVDFRQXQDSULPDIDVHGHOOD3RUWDGHL /HRQLPDSXUWURSSRQRQF¶qSLPRGRGLLQGDJDUHOHYDULHIDVLFRVWUXWWLYHGL TXHVWDVHQRQDWWUDYHUVRTXDQWRQHGLVVHLO'HODSRUWHRYYLDPHQWHLJQDURGHOOD Nuove scoperte nella Melid neo-hittita )LJ$UVODQWHSHLVWDOOD]LRQHGLVTXDWWHUVDGGRVVDWDDOJUDQGHPXUREUXFLDWR )LJ$UVODQWHSHJUDQGLIRVVHLQWRQDFDWHQHOOLYHOORGLVTXDWWHUVVRWWRLOVDORQHDSLODVWUL Mario Liverani VFDYR3HFRUHOOD 3RUWD,PSHULDOH DQQL 3RUWD6FKDHIIHU 0 JUDQGHPXUREUXFLDWR VTXDWWHUVDQWHULRUL IRVVH HGLILFLRRUWRJRQDOH HGLILFLRRUWRJRQDOH VTXDWWHUVSRVWHULRUL PXUHWWLDGGRVVDWL $ VDORQHDFRORQQH 3RUWDGHL/HRQL $ VDORQHDSLODVWUL $ HGLILFLRQHRDVVLUR )LJ3HULRGL]]D]LRQHSURYYLVRULDSHUO¶DUHDQRUGGHOOD0HOLGQHRKLWWLWD VWUDWLJUD¿DVRWWRVWDQWHLOQRVWURVDORQH'HOWXWWRSURYYLVRULDPHQWHPHQWUHLO JUDQGHPXUREUXFLDWRSXzHVVHUHVWDWRFRVWUXLWRYHUVRLOHGLVWUXWWRXQ VHFRORGRSRLQYHFHTXHVWRSULPRLPSLDQWRGHOO¶HGL¿FLRRULHQWDWRQRUGVXG SXzULVDOLUHDOODPHWjGHO,;VHFROR 0DQFDQRGXQTXHGDFROPDUHXQSDLRGLVHFROLWUDLOHO¶LQFLIUH WRQGH(TXLVWDODVHFRQGDVRUSUHVDSHUTXDQWR¿QRUDDSSXUDWRGXUDQWHJUDQ SDUWHGHOSHULRGRHGDQFKHQHOEUHYHLQWHUYDOORWUDLOSURWRVDORQHHLOVDORQH YHURHSURSULRODQRVWUDDUHDGLVFDYRHUDRFFXSDWDGDSRYHUHSUHVHQ]HGL squatters )LJ LPSLDQWDWLVRSUDOHURYLQHGHOPXURGLFLQWDHVRSUDWWXWWR VRSUDLOVXRFUROORHGLVIDFLPHQWRVLDDOO¶LQWHUQRGHOODFLWWjVLD LQVSD]LRSL ULVWUHWWR DOO¶HVWHUQR4XHVWLIUHTXHQWDWRULKDQQRODVFLDWRJUDQGLIRVVH )LJ SLFFROLSR]]HWWLEXFKLGLSDORPRGHVWLPXUHWWLLQPDWWRQLUHVWLGLIRFRODULH IUDPPHQWLGLXQDFHUDPLFDGLXQRUL]]RQWHGHOWXWWRORFDOHEHQGLYHUVD FRPH IDQRWDUH)HGHULFR0DQXHOOL GDTXHOODGHOSHULRGRGHOVDORQHDSLODVWULFRQOH VXHFRQQHVVLRQLVLURDQDWROLFRXUDUWHH &KHVLJQL¿FDTXHVWRVWRULFDPHQWH"2FFRUUHULFRQRVFHUHFKHO¶DUHDVFDYDWD qSLFFRODHQRQQHFHVVDULDPHQWHUDSSUHVHQWDWLYDGHOO¶LQWHURLQVHGLDPHQWR( SHUzYRUUHLIDURVVHUYDUHGXHFRVHFKHFKLQRQFRQRVFHGLUHWWDPHQWHLOVLWRSR WUHEEHQRQWHQHUHLQGHELWRFRQWR/DSULPDFRVDqFKHODFROOLQDGL$UVODQWHSH LQHWjQHRKLWWLWDRVSLWDYDODVRODFLWWDGHOODWXWWDRFFXSDWDGDHGL¿FLSXEEOLFL Nuove scoperte nella Melid neo-hittita PHQWUHLOQRUPDOHDELWDWRHUDQHOODFLWWjEDVVD RJJLLQWHUDPHQWHVSLDQDWDGDOOH FROWLYD]LRQLLQWHQVLYH /DVHFRQGDFRVDqFKHODSRUWDQRUG JLjTXHOODLPSH ULDOHSHU¿QLUHDOOD3RUWDGHL/HRQL QRQqXQDSRUWDWUDOHWDQWHqFRQWXWWD SUREDELOLWjODVRODSRUWDGLXQDFLWWDGHOODSLFFRODHGLVSRVWDLQYLVWDO¶(XIUD WHGXQTXHXQOXRJRFUXFLDOHHVWUDWHJLFRSHUO¶LQWHUDFLWWDGHOOD2UDVHQHOOD FLWWDGHOOD OXRJRGHJOLHGL¿FLSXEEOLFL HSHUGLSLLQXQOXRJRDOWDPHQWHVWUD WHJLFRDOSRVWRGLHGL¿FLPRQXPHQWDOLWURYLDPROHWUDFFHGL squatters TXHVWR QRQSXzFKHLPSOLFDUHFKHO¶LQWHURLQVHGLDPHQWRHUDHQWUDWRLQFULVLHLQSDUWL FRODUHORHUDODVXDGLULJHQ]DLOSDOD]]RUHDOHSHULQWHQGHUFL 4XHVWDFRQVWDWD]LRQHqLPSRUWDQWHHLOVXRVLJQL¿FDWRVLSRQHQHOVHQVR GHOODQRYLWjVHFRQVLGHUDWDDOLYHOORORFDOHHLQYHFHQHOVHQVRGHOODQRUPDOLWj VHLQTXDGUDWDSLDPSLDPHQWH$OLYHOORORFDOHODVWRULDGL0HOLGGRSRLOFUROOR GHOO¶LPSHURKLWWLWDH¿QRDOODFRQTXLVWDDVVLUDqFRUUHQWHPHQWHULFRVWUXLWDQHO VHJQRGHOODFRQWLQXLWj,SULPLUHGL0HOLGQHO;,,VHFRORDSSDUWHQHYDQRDGXQ ODWRFROODWHUDOHGHOODGLQDVWLDFKHUHJQDYDD.DUNHPLãDOWHPSRGHOO¶LPSHUR HSRLQHLVHFROLVHJXHQWLF¶qXQWDOHD൵ROODPHQWRGLQRPLGLUHGL0HOLGFKH QRQVHPEUDHVVHUFLVSD]LRSHULQWHUYDOOLHDQ]LVLGHYHULFRUUHUHDGLSRWHVLGL GLQDVWLHSDUDOOHOH FRQWXWWDODVWUDQH]]DGHOFDVR 3LFKHFRQWLQXLWjWUDOD FLWWjGLHSRFDLPSHULDOHHTXHOODQHRKLWWLWDF¶qXQDSURVHFX]LRQHSLXWWRVWR EUHYH FLUFDXQVHFROR VHJXLWDSRLGDXQDFULVLSURIRQGD'XQTXH LOFRQVWDWDUHFKHWUDLOHO¶ODFLWWjHUDLQVWDWRGLVHPLDEEDQGRQRVL JQL¿FDDVVHVWDUHXQGXURFROSRDOO¶LGHDGHOODFRQWLQXLWjWUDFUROORGHOO¶LPSHUR KLWWLWDHFRQTXLVWDDVVLUDODFLWWjKDVXELWRDOPHQRWUH VHQRQTXDWWUR HSLVRGL GLGLVWUX]LRQHHULFRVWUX]LRQHDOPHQRXQSDLRGLSHULRGLGLVHPLDEEDQGRQR GLFXLXQROXQJR 'RYHPHWWHUHPRWXWWLLSUHVXQWLUHGL0HOLGFLWDWLQHOOH LVFUL]LRQLORFDOLHQHLWHVWLDVVLUL"'RYHYDD¿QLUHODFRQWLQXLWjVHTXHOFKH HPHUJHqXQDVHULHGLGLVFRQWLQXLWj" )LJ 0DDOODUJDQGRODSURVSHWWLYDDWXWWRLO/HYDQWHVLURDQDWROLFRGHOODSULPD HWjGHO)HUURELVRJQDULFRQRVFHUHFKHLOTXDGURFKHVLYLHQHIRUPDQGRqGHO WXWWRQRUPDOHXQDJURVVDFHVXUDDOOD¿QHGHO%URQ]R7DUGRXQDSDUHQWHVLGL XQSDLRGLVHFROLFRQO¶LVWLWX]LRQHSDODWLQDLQFULVLLQVHGLDPHQWLULGRWWLDOOD GLPHQVLRQHHDOODVWUXWWXUDGLYLOODJJLPDQFDQ]DGLHGL¿FLPRQXPHQWDOL3RL OD JUDQGH ULSUHVD QHO ,; VHFROR FRQ QXRYL SDOD]]L FRQ UHJQL GL GLPHQVLR QHFDQWRQDOHFRQXQDJUDQGHÀRULGH]]DHRULJLQDOLWjFXOWXUDOH¿QRDFKHOD PDFFKLQDLPSHULDOHDVVLUDFDQFHOOHUjWXWWRSHUIRQGDUHLOVXRQXRYRRUGLQHLP SURQWDWRDOO¶DSSLDWWLPHQWRGLWXWWDODSHULIHULDSHUDOLPHQWDUHOHJUDQGLFDSLWDOL -' +DZNLQV Melid. A. Historisch LQ Reallexikon der Assyriologie 9,,, %HUOLQ SS HDOWULFRQWULEXWLGHOORVWHVVRDXWRUH $$UFKL Malitiya-Meliddu: Arslantepe nelle fonti scritte LQ)UDQJLSDQHFLWSS Mario Liverani DOFHQWURGHOPRQGR,QTXHVWRSDUDGLJPDOD0HOLGFKHVWDHPHUJHQGRGDOOR VFDYRVLLQVHULVFHDVVDLPHJOLRGLTXHOODLPPDJLQDWDLQSUHFHGHQ]DGXQTXH QRQXQ¶HFFH]LRQHPDDQ]LXQFDVRSDUDGLJPDWLFR8QD0HOLGFRQFUHWDUHDOH VLVWDFRVuVRVWLWXHQGRDOOD0HOLGYLUWXDOHLSRWL]]DWD¿QRUD,OSURJUHVVRGHL ODYRULVXOFDPSRHLQODERUDWRULRFLGLUjVHTXHVWDQXRYDSURVSHWWLYDqFRUUHWWD HGH¿QLWLYD