The Last of the Horse Wars: Intertribal, Cross-Border Warfare in Southern Alberta and Northen Montana Territory, 1878-1893
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Calgary PRISM: University of Calgary's Digital Repository Graduate Studies The Vault: Electronic Theses and Dissertations 2012-09-06 The last of the horse wars: intertribal, cross-border warfare in southern alberta and northen montana territory, 1878-1893 Marsh, Christopher Marsh, C. (2012). The last of the horse wars: intertribal, cross-border warfare in southern alberta and northen montana territory, 1878-1893 (Unpublished master's thesis). University of Calgary, Calgary, AB. doi:10.11575/PRISM/28228 http://hdl.handle.net/11023/182 master thesis University of Calgary graduate students retain copyright ownership and moral rights for their thesis. You may use this material in any way that is permitted by the Copyright Act or through licensing that has been assigned to the document. For uses that are not allowable under copyright legislation or licensing, you are required to seek permission. Downloaded from PRISM: https://prism.ucalgary.ca UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY The Last of the Horse Wars: Intertribal, Cross-Border Warfare in Southern Alberta and Northern Montana Territory, 1878-1893 by Christopher Marsh A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY CALGARY, ALBERTA SEPTEMBER, 2012 © CHRISTOPHER MARSH, 2012 Abstract From 1883 until the autumn of 1889, Canadian Kainai (Blood Indians) waged cross- border warfare against American A’aninin (Gros Ventres) and Nakota (Assiniboine) of the Fort Belknap Agency in northeastern Montana. Enmity between these indigenous plains peoples had carried over from hostilities at the end of buffalo days and was perpetuated due to a strong continuity of warrior and equestrian culture in the 1880s, which endured despite efforts of the Canadian Dominion Government to “civilize” their Blackfoot wards through Christianity and agriculture. The few historians who have studied this little known conflict have emphasized the success of the North West Mounted Police (NWMP) in ending it. However, this thesis will demonstrate that NWMP efforts were often ineffective and the reasons behind the Kainai decision to end the hostilities were complex, encompassing environmental change and an independent modification of cultural ethos. This thesis illuminates this conflict, its causes, and its resolution. ii Acknowledgments This thesis would not have been possible without the guidance and assistance of the knowledgeable and helpful faculty of the Department of History. In particular, my supervisor, Dr. George Colpitts, was always ready and willing to lend an ear, help focus my thoughts, and offer suggestions as to how to improve my writing. Dr. Colpitts and Dr. Elizabeth Jameson also offered me their valuable time and advice in putting together a Social Science and Humanities Research Council grant proposal for my second year of study. Dr. Jameson, whose classes drew me to the Canadian-United States borderlands, also opened my eyes to wider interpretations of North American history, which can be seen in the methodological and theoretical frameworks in this thesis. My first-year seminar professors also taught me to think critically about source documents, history, and historiography, which no doubt sharpened my research and writing skills far above what they would have been if not for their dedication to teaching. I am also indebted to the Graduate Advisor, Brenda Oslawsky, for all her support in a variety of behind-the-scenes administration in regards to my program. I owe an immense debt of gratitude to my family, especially my father, Boniface Marsh, for the considerable financial and moral support given throughout this entire endeavour. I also thank my classmates for not only creating a stimulating academic environment but also offering recreational and social outlets when we all needed a break from reading, writing, and thinking. The Social Science and Humanities Research Council, the Coutts Family Scholarship fund, the Government of Alberta, and the University Of Calgary Department of History all provided financial support without which I could have never finished this project. For this, I earnestly thank all these donors. iii Table of Contents Abstract ii Acknowledgements iii Table of Contents iv List of Tables v List of Figures vi List of Abbreviations vii Introduction 1 Chapter One: The Aristocracy of Ability and the Spirit of Retaliation, Underlying 24 Causes of the Kainai Belknap War Chapter Two: Friends to Foe, the Blackfoot, the Cree, and the Milk River Allies, 59 1878-1883 Chapter Three: Fort Belknap Besieged, Kainai-Belknap Intertribal Warfare, 83 1884-1889 Chapter Four: The Making of Peace and Denouement, 1888-1894 114 Conclusion 147 Bibliography 150 iv List of Tables Table 1: Kainai Population and Beef Rations Issued, 1885-1891 141 v List of Figures Figure 1: Geographical Boundaries of Study, 1878-1894 7 Figure 2: Comparison of Blackfoot, Cree/Assiniboine, and Non-Natives in Cases 120 Involving Horse Stealing or Bringing Stolen Property into Canada, 1881-1889: Number of Individuals Arrested and Convicted Figure 3: Comparison of Blackfoot, Cree/Assiniboine, and Non-Natives in Cases 121 Involving Horse Stealing or Bringing Stolen Property into Canada, 1881-1889: Total Prison Sentences by Year Figure 4: Comparison of Blackfoot, Cree/Assiniboine, and Non-Natives in Cases 121 Involving Horse Stealing or Bringing Stolen Property into Canada, 1881-1889: Average Prison Sentence by Year Figure 5: Earnings of Kainai Individuals, 1886-1892 144 vi List of Abbreviations Church Missionary Society (CMS) Glenbow Museum (Glenbow) Library and Archives Canada (LAC) Montana Historical Society (MHS) National Archives and Record Administration at Denver (NARAD) North West Mounted Police (NWMP) vii 1 Introduction In early September 1886, six Kainai (Blood) men and youths encountered twenty- three warriors of a mixed party of A’aninin (Gros Ventres), Nakota (American Assiniboine), and Crow near the Milk River in Canadian territory. This latter group, exasperated with the Kainai’s continual horse stealing, had come north of the border to retaliate in the wake of a recent raid. They chased the smaller party up a small butte near Dead Horse Coulee in present-day southern Alberta. Upon reaching the top, the Belknap party unloaded their weapons on the improvised fortifications hastily built by their enemies with a fantastic barrage. When the gunfire stopped, six Kainai lay dead. The victors scalped their enemies, took their weapons as trophies, and returned to the Fort Belknap Agency, located on the Milk River in Montana Territory. Spectacularly violent, this episode demonstrated the depths of animosity that the Belknap Indians had developed towards the Kainai in the wake of numerous raids. However, this slaughter on the butte led the Kainai to redouble their raiding. Rumors mounted of an impending Kainai attack against the American agency itself. This fear of an all-out Indian war persisted until early June 1887 when William Pocklington, the Kainai Indian Agent, a North West Mounted Police (NWMP) Inspector, famous guide Jerry Potts, and a number of important Kainai Chiefs made a successful peace mission to the American reservation. At the time, Canadian and American regional newspapers extensively covered the event. However, their reports largely obscured the nature and duration of what was recognized as a Kainai-Belknap war. At first glance, the conflict lasted less than a year. However, Indian agency documents, especially on the American side of the International boundary, reveal a conflict lasting nearly eight years, stretching on with repeated instances 2 of horse raiding and punctuated with incidences of deadly violence. The Kainai-Belknap war, spanning from 1882 until 1889, had its immediate origins in enmities carried over at the end of the ‘buffalo days’, although it was maintained by the continuance of Kainai warrior culture and Native traditions of retributive justice in regards to both murder and theft of property. This thesis will explore the Kainai-Belknap war which occurred over nearly a decade in the 1880s, finding explanations for it and its eventual cessation in 1890 in ecological, diplomatic, and cultural factors. It constituted a significant historical event as it occurred after the Numbered Treaties were negotiated and supposedly in a period of peaceful Canadian western colonization. Moreover, it inflamed tribal relations on both sides of the international border, on reserves and reservations purportedly being moved into sedentary, pastoral, and agricultural lifestyles and economies. The Kanai-Belknap war flies in the face of the “mild/wild” dichotomy usually seen in comparative United States-Canada historiography. By focusing on its causes, and the resolution of the conflict, this thesis will provide insight into the themes of continuity and cultural change in Kainai society. It also adds complexity to the history of settlement and law enforcement in Canada since it demonstrates that the NWMP, for the most part, were not able or willing to stop Kainai horse raiding activities against intertribal foes. More significantly, it suggests that although the Kainai had been significantly weakened and their independence severely curtailed by the disappearance of the bison and the realities of the reserve era, certain segments of Kainai society advocated “the old ways” of life and defied efforts by the Dominion Government to significantly alter cultural values and assimilate them into Canadian society.