Tameside Retail & Leisure Study (TRLS) 2018

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Tameside Retail & Leisure Study (TRLS) 2018 Tameside Retail & Leisure Study (TRLS) 2018 Volume 1 - Main Report Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council December 2018 HV128 FINAL REPORT Tameside Retail & Leisure Study (TRLS) - December 2018 Contents 1 THE COUNCIL’S BRIEF AND OUTLINE OF REPORT 1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 1 The Council’s Brief ..................................................................................................................... 1 Empirical Survey Evidence ......................................................................................................... 3 Outline of Report ......................................................................................................................... 3 Price Base .................................................................................................................................. 4 2 NATIONAL PLANNING POLICY CONTEXT 5 Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 5 Sustainable Development .......................................................................................................... 5 The Presumption in Favour of Sustainable Development .......................................................... 6 Plan-Making ................................................................................................................................ 6 Examining Plans ......................................................................................................................... 9 The Planning Practice Guidance (the PPG) ............................................................................... 9 3 RECENT AND ANTICIPATED CHANGES IN THE RETAIL AND LEISURE SECTORS 12 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 12 Historic, Recent and Projected Changes in Retail and Leisure Expenditure ........................... 13 E-Commerce and Multi-Channel Retailing ............................................................................... 19 Consequences of Recession and the Growth in E-Commerce ................................................ 24 Leisure Trends .......................................................................................................................... 34 Influential Town Centre Reports ............................................................................................... 39 Implications for Tameside’s Town Centres .............................................................................. 42 4 ASSESSMENT OF THE HEALTH OF TAMESIDE’S CENTRES 45 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 45 Ashton-under-Lyne Principal Town Centre .............................................................................. 45 Hyde Town Centre .................................................................................................................... 63 Denton Town Centre................................................................................................................. 72 Stalybridge District Centre ........................................................................................................ 80 Droylsden District Centre .......................................................................................................... 89 Hattersley District Centre .......................................................................................................... 96 Mossley Local Centre ............................................................................................................... 96 Summary Table of Health Checks ............................................................................................ 97 5 PATTERNS OF RETAIL SPENDING AND LEISURE VISITS 98 Survey Area .............................................................................................................................. 98 Survey Questionnaire ............................................................................................................... 98 Population and Expenditure ..................................................................................................... 99 Comparison Goods Spending Patterns .................................................................................. 100 Convenience Goods Spending Patterns ................................................................................ 105 Pattern of Leisure Visits .......................................................................................................... 111 Conclusions in Relation to Retail and Leisure Spending Patterns ......................................... 114 6 QUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE RETAIL & LEISURE NEEDS 119 Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 119 Methodology for Assessing Quantitative Need in the Retail Sector ...................................... 120 Quantitative Need in the Comparison Goods Sector ............................................................. 123 Quantitative Need in the Convenience Goods Sector............................................................ 126 Distribution of Quantitative Need in the Comparison Goods Sector ...................................... 129 Qualitative Need in the Retail and Leisure Sectors ................................................................ 134 Overall Conclusions in Relation to Retail and Leisure Needs................................................ 143 HV128 | December 2018 FINAL REPORT Tameside Retail & Leisure Study (TRLS) - December 2018 7 RECOMMENDATIONS FOR OVERALL TOWN CENTRE BOUNDARIES AND PRIMARY SHOPPING AREAS 147 Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 147 NPPF Definitions .................................................................................................................... 148 Ashton-under-Lyne Town Centre ........................................................................................... 148 Hyde Town Centre .................................................................................................................. 152 Denton District Centre ............................................................................................................ 155 Droylsden District Centre ........................................................................................................ 158 Stalybridge District Centre ...................................................................................................... 161 Mossley Local Centre ............................................................................................................. 164 Hattersley District Centre ........................................................................................................ 166 8 OTHER RECOMMENDATIONS 168 Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 168 Network, Hierarchy and Role of Centres ................................................................................ 168 Local Impact Thresholds for Retail and Leisure Assessments .............................................. 170 Policy Mechanisms for A5 and Other Non-A1 Uses in Town Centres ................................... 172 Policy Mechanisms for A5 Uses Outside Town Centres ........................................................ 176 HV128 | December 2018 FINAL REPORT Tameside Retail & Leisure Study (TRLS) - December 2018 1 THE COUNCIL’S BRIEF AND OUTLINE OF REPORT Introduction 1.1 In June 2017, Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council instructed HollissVincent to prepare a borough-wide Retail and Leisure Study that is compliant with the National Planning Policy Framework (the NPPF). Thus, the Study is intended to provide a robust evidence base to underpin the retail and town centre policies in the emerging local plan. The previous Tameside Retail Study, prepared by WYG, was published in May 2010, in the context of the Government’s earlier Planning Policy Statement 4 (PPS4) of December 2009. However, PPS4 was superseded by the NPPF, which was originally published in March 2012, but replaced by the revised NPPF of July 2018. Moreover, much of the empirical work that underpinned the WYG study, including a telephone survey of shopping patterns, dates from 2009; hence the urgent need for this new Study. The Council’s Brief 1.2 The full Specification for the Tameside Retail & Leisure Study (TRLS) is reproduced as Item 1 in Volume 2, but the key requirements, as set out in Section 2 of the Council’s Brief, were: a) to provide a résumé of recent and projected changes in the structure of the retail and leisure industry, including e-commerce and multi-channel retailing and the potential consequences for the retail and leisure function of the hierarchy of centres identified in Policy S1 of the Tameside Unitary Development Plan (the UDP), namely Ashton- under-Lyne, Hyde, Denton, Droylsden, Stalybridge, Hattersley and Mossley; b) to identify the overall catchment area of the Borough and provide an analysis of shopping patterns and leisure visits within and beyond the catchment area,
Recommended publications
  • Farnworth Town Centre Masterplan Baseline Report
    1 Revision B Farnworth Town Centre Masterplan Baseline Report: Farnworth Today January 2019 2 Farnworth Town Centre Masterplan January 2019 Aerial View of Farnworth Town Centre January 2019 Farnworth Town Centre Masterplan 3 Contents Executive Summary 1 Introduction 9 2 Town Centre Trends 11 3 Property and Market Analysis 21 4 Planning and Policy Context 35 5 Townscape Analysis 41 6 Opportunity Areas 55 Revision A Revision B Date 24 October 2018 09 January 2019 Project Reference 3000138 3000138 Preparewd by AM/CW AM/CW Checked by FPG FPG 4 Farnworth Town Centre Masterplan January 2019 4 Executive Summary January 2019 Farnworth Town Centre Masterplan 5 Executive Summary Introduction enterprises, all of which should be designed to function as Farnworth Town Centre Challenges intergenerational spaces. Farnworth town centre is the second largest town centre Whilst the population of Farnworth is expected to grow, in the Borough after Bolton town centre and has been ‘The Portas Review: An Independent Review into the town centre continues to experience the impacts nominated by Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council WKH)XWXUHRIRXU+LJK6WUHHWVn FRQÞUPVWKLV of a lack of investment in non-food retail and leisure (‘the Council’) for the Greater Manchester Town Centre requirement, reimagining town centres as ‘destinations uses, which impacts the liveliness of the town centre Challenge Initiative, which aims to regenerate town for socialising, culture, health, wellbeing, creativity and and decreases footfall. This is of course not unique to centres across
    [Show full text]
  • SPOC | Central Pennines Strategic
    This document is Not for Publication - On-going Research Central Pennines: Strategic Development Corridor - Strategic Programme Outline Case Contents 1 Introduction .................................................................................. 7 Strategic Dimension ........................................................................... 15 2 Introduction ................................................................................ 15 3 The Case for Change .................................................................... 26 4 The Need for Intervention ........................................................... 66 5 Wider Context ............................................................................. 70 6 Option Assessment Process ......................................................... 72 7 Strategic Dimension Summary ..................................................... 87 Economic Dimension........................................................................... 89 8 Introduction ................................................................................ 89 9 Approach to Cost Estimation ........................................................ 95 10 Quantified SDC Programme Impacts ............................................ 98 11 Economy Impacts ...................................................................... 104 12 Environment Impacts ................................................................ 106 13 Social Impacts........................................................................... 111 14
    [Show full text]
  • Ppg17 Sports Facility Assessment
    TAMESIDE METROPOLITAN BOROUGH COUNCIL PPG17 SPORTS FACILITY ASSESSMENT AUGUST 2010 Integrity, Innovation, Inspiration 1-2 Frecheville Court off Knowsley Street Bury BL9 0UF T 0161 764 7040 F 0161 764 7490 E [email protected] www.kkp.co.uk Quality assurance Name Date Report origination H. Jones Feb 2010 Quality control C Fallon Feb 2010 Final approval C Fallon August 2010 TAMESIDE METROPOLITAN BOROUGH COUNCIL PPG17 SPORTS FACILITY ASSESSMENT CONTENTS GLOSSARY........................................................................................................................ 5 PART 1: INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................. 6 Study limitations.............................................................................................................. 8 PART 2: CONTEXT............................................................................................................ 9 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 9 National context .............................................................................................................. 9 Regional context ........................................................................................................... 13 Local context................................................................................................................. 13 PART 3: PLAYING PITCH ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY........................................
    [Show full text]
  • Manchester City Council Independent Retailers Study: Chorlton
    MANCHESTER CITY COUNCIL INDEPENDENT RETAILERS STUDY: CHORLTON December 2009 GVA Grimley Ltd 10 Stratton Street London W1J 8JR 084 4902 0304 www.gvagrimley.co.uk Manchester City Council Independent Retailers Study - Chorlton December 2009 CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................. 3 2. POLICY FRAMEWORK ................................................................................................... 5 3. NATIONAL RETAIL TRENDS ........................................................................................ 15 4. CHORLTON: HEALTH CHECK ..................................................................................... 24 5. CAPACITY PROJECTIONS ........................................................................................... 35 6. STRATEGIC OPTIONS/RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................ 45 PLANS Plan 1: Survey Area Plan 2: Leakage of Convenience Spend APPENDICES Appendix 1: Convenience Capacity Tables Appendix 2: Comparison Capacity Tables Appendix 3: Leakage/Claw-back Assessment: Main Food Expenditure Appendix 4: Leakage/Claw-back Assessment: Top-up Food Expenditure Manchester City Council Independent Retailers Study - Chorlton December 2009 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 GVA Grimley was instructed in January 2009 by Manchester City Council to undertake an Independent Retailers Study for Chorlton. This study draws and extends upon the Quantitative Need Study undertaken by GVA Grimley for the City
    [Show full text]
  • Draft Retail Statement HL.Docx
    The Pensions Trust Retail Statement Former Apollo 2000 Store, Unit 2b 108 Eastern Avenue, Gloucester, GL4 4LP Planning Application to vary Condition 9 attached to Planning Permission: 98/0019/FUL August 2012 The Pensions Trust Former Apollo 2000 Store, Unit 2b 108 Eastern Avenue, Gloucester Retail Statement savills.com/planning CONTENTS 1.0 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 1 2.0 SITE AND BACKGROUND ................................................................................. 4 3.0 RELEVANT PLANNING POLICY CONTEXT ...................................................... 6 4.0 HOME BARGAINS ............................................................................................ 12 5.0 SEQUENTIAL APPROACH TO SITE SELECTION .......................................... 15 6.0 ASSESSMENT OF THE IMPACT OF THE PROPOSAL ................................... 30 7.0 CONCLUSION ................................................................................................... 43 APPENDICES 1. Plan Reference 02 – Indicative Proposed Floor Plan The Pensions Trust Former Apollo 2000 Store, Unit 2b 108 Eastern Avenue, Gloucester Retail Statement savills.com/planning 1.0 INTRODUCTION Introduction 1.1 Savills has prepared this Retail Statement on behalf of The Pensions Trust as part of a planning application at the former Apollo 2000 retail unit at Unit 2b of 108 Eastern Avenue. The application is to vary Condition 9 attached to Planning Permission: 98/00119/FUL in order to
    [Show full text]
  • Stockport Retail Study Update, 2014 Volume 1
    STOCKPORT RETAIL STUDY UPDATE On behalf of Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council August 2014 FINAL REPORT Volume 1 – Main Text Stockport Retail Study Update CONTENTS 1 INSTRUCTIONS, CONTEXTUAL BACKGROUND AND OUTLINE OF REPORT 1 Instructions ................................................................................................................................. 1 New Survey Evidence ................................................................................................................ 3 Updated Data Inputs ................................................................................................................... 3 Price Base .................................................................................................................................. 4 The Earlier Stockport Shopping and Leisure Study ................................................................... 4 Outline of Report ......................................................................................................................... 5 2 NATIONAL POLICY CONTEXT 7 The National Planning Policy Framework (the NPPF) ............................................................... 7 The National Planning Practice Guidance (the NPPG) .............................................................. 8 3 RECENT AND FUTURE CHANGES IN RETAILING 11 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 11 Retail Expenditure Growth per Capita.....................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Walkden Town Centre J N L Property
    WALKDEN TOWN CENTRE J N L PROPERTY Walkden, M28 3ZH Tenants include: WALKDEN TOWN CENTRE / LOCATION BURY BOLTON M62 Key Points M61 M61 • The Centre is located in Walkden, Junction 3 M60 approximately 8 miles (13km) M61 north-west of Manchester City Centre. WIGAN Junction 2 • Prominently positioned on the WALKDEN TOWN CENTRE M61 junction of Bolton Road (A575) and Junction 1 the A6, a principal arterial route in and out of Manchester City Centre. • The Centre provides 450,000 sq ft of retail space anchored by Tesco, Boots and B&M. MANCHESTER SALFORD • Other tenants include JD, Costa, McDonalds, KFC, Quality Save, Lloyds, Subway, Domino’s, Santander, Poundland and Card Factory. • Footfall of 150,000 per week. M62 • In excess of 2,000 free car parking spaces. M60 • Resident population of 684,000 within 6 miles (10km). SALE • Indoor Market Hall. M60 • Adjacent to Walkden Retail Park anchored by Aldi. WARRINGTON • New 25,000 sq ft letting to Club 3000 Bingo. Walkden Town Centre, Walkden, M28 3ZH WALKDEN TOWN CENTRE / SCHEME LAYOUT Ground Floor CAR PARK GAMEBOX UNIT 155b 490 sq ft LADY HARRIET WALK UNIT 160/161 SUDDELL YATES & YATES 1,892 sq ft 1,892 1,335 sq ft 1,335 sq ft 1,335 UNIT 156 UNIT 157 UNIT 158/159 1,255 sq ft UNIT 155 UNIT 141/142 UNIT 146 sq ft 2,957 2,465 sq ft 1,270 sq ft 1,270 2,687 sq ft UNIT 154 UNIT 162 CONNEXIONS 905 sq ft UNIT 140 UNIT 163 UNIT 147-149 920 sq ft 905 sq ft 1,614 sq ft UNIT 138/139 LINK MALL UNIT 164/165 1,094 sq ft 1,180 sq ft UNIT 135-137 UNIT 166/167 2,276 sq ft 2,276 1,080 sq ft Walkden Town Centre, Walkden, M28 3ZH WALKDEN TOWN CENTRE / SCHEME LAYOUT First Floor LADY HARRIET WALK UNIT 224/225 2,789 sq ft 2,789 UNIT 201-203 3,388 sq ft UNIT 215-223 11,399 sq ft LINK MALL UNIT 204/205 1,558 sq ft UNIT 206/207 1,283 sq ft UNIT 208/209 1,111 sq ft UNIT 210/211 4,350 sq ft Walkden Town Centre, Walkden, M28 3ZH WALKDEN TOWN CENTRE / SCHEME IMAGERY Description AVAILABILITY Walkden Town Centre offers a variety of shop units to let.
    [Show full text]
  • Peel Retail Parks
    PEEL RETAIL PARKS peelretailparks.co.uk “WE OWN AND MANAGE MANY OF THE UK’S LEADING RETAIL PARKS, CREATING STAND-OUT SHOPPING DESTINATIONS WHERE RETAILERS WANT TO BE AND CUSTOMERS WANT TO SHOP. AS INITIATORS OF THE RETAIL PARK CONCEPT IN THE UK, OUR STRONG HERITAGE AND UNIQUE APPROACH HAS ENABLED US TO BUILD A SUCCESSFUL PORTFOLIO THAT CONTINUES TO GROW AND FLOURISH. WE BRING TOGETHER OUR WEALTH OF EXPERTISE AND UNDERSTANDING OF OUR CUSTOMERS AND LOCAL COMMUNITIES TO CONTINUALLY EVOLVE OUR RETAIL PARKS AND DELIVER REAL RESULTS FOR OUR WORLD CLASS RETAILERS.” MARK WHITTAKER PROPERTY DIRECTOR WE ARE PEEL RETAIL PARKS, INITIATORS OF THE RETAIL PARK CONCEPT IN THE UK We pride ourselves on creating places where people want to shop and spend quality leisure time with family and friends - and we’ve been doing this successfully for more than 30 years. With more than 2 million sq ft of retail space, we now own and manage retail parks in many communities across the UK. Customer insight is the currency of our brand and we move with the times, understanding what our customers want now and in the future, continually adapting to meet the needs of the next generation. We know what works, and we do it well. OUR ETHOS IS SIMPLE: • We tailor the mix to the needs of the consumer • We understand and adapt to change • We work closely with our tenants to deliver the best results We place ourselves at the heart of the local communities in which we operate, and it’s this philosophy along with our entrepreneurial spirit that has enabled us to build a long-term business that enables our customers, retailers and communities to flourish.
    [Show full text]
  • Uk Regional Development Programme 1986-90
    EUROPEAN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUND UK REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME 1986-90 Section 7E: England — South Yorkshire Section 7F: England — Workington Section 7G: England — Greater Manchester Section 7H: England — Greater Merseyside lUlaUmiãl· I U If ΦΟ DOCUMENT DOCUMENTI CUMENT DOCUMENTO DOK1 ¡NT ΕΓΓΡΑΦΟ DOCUMENT DI JMENTO DOCUMENT UUCUM TU ηυκυΜΕΝΤΕΓΓΡΑΦΟηΐ (MENT DOCUMENTO OUCUMI MHB ΡΑΦΟΟΟΟΟΜΕΜ I tvivl COMMISSION POOGIIIÌEN^DOG OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES ΝΤΕΓΓΡΑΦ( uranFrinii nni-iiupuiiiAnAni This document has been prepared for use within the Commission. It does not necessarily represent the Commission's official position. Cataloguing data can be found at the end of this publication Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, 1987 Vol.3 : ISBN 92-825-7194-7 Vol. 1-7: ISBN 92-825-7199-8 Catalogue number: CB-98-87-00J-EN-C © ECSC-EEC-EAEC, Brussels · Luxembourg, 1987 Reproduction is authorized, except for commercial purposes, provided the source is acknowledged. Printed in Belgium Commission of the European Communities European Regional Development Fund UK RE6I0NAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME 1986-90 Section 7E: EngLand - South Yorkshire Section 7F: EngLand - Workington Section 7G: EngLand - Greater Manchester Section 7H: EngLand - Greater Merseyside Document This document has been prepared for use within the Commission. It does not necessarily represent the Commission's official position. Copyright ECSC-EEC-EAEC, Brussels - Luxembourg, 1987 Reproduction is authorized, except for commercial purposes, provided the source is acknowledged. / L European Regional Development Fund UK REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME 1986-90 Section 7E: England - South Yorkshire d UCJ [ \j \ 1' UK REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME 1986-90 CONTENTS The Programme consists of detailed information on regional or sub-regional areas (Sections 7 to 10) preceded by general information on the United Kingdom (Sections 1 to 6).
    [Show full text]
  • West Coast - Sheffield City Region: Strategic Development Corridor SPOC
    This document is Not for Publication - On-going Research West Coast - Sheffield City Region: Strategic Development Corridor SPOC Contents 1 Introduction .................................................................................... 1 Strategic Dimension .............................................................................. 17 2 Introduction .................................................................................. 17 3 The Case for Change ...................................................................... 35 4 The Need for Intervention ............................................................. 70 5 Wider Context ................................................................................ 74 6 Option Assessment Process ........................................................... 77 7 Strategic Dimension Summary ....................................................... 91 Economic Dimension ............................................................................. 93 8 Overview and Summary of the Passenger Rail SPOC ...................... 93 9 Approach to Costing Interventions ................................................ 98 10 Quantified SDC Programme Impacts .............................................. 99 11 Economy Impacts ........................................................................ 106 12 Environment Impacts................................................................... 108 13 Social Impacts ............................................................................. 109 14 Public
    [Show full text]
  • 1000 Companies to Inspire Britain 2015 Fm Am
    1000 1000 COMPANIES TO INSPIRE 1000 COMPANIES TO INSPIRE 2015 BRITAIN BRITAIN AM FM 2015 Media partner Our sponsors www.1000companies.com 1000 COMPANIES TO INSPIRE 2015 BRITAIN London Stock Exchange Group Editorial Board Tom Gilbert (Senior Press Officer); Ed Clark (Press Officer); Alexandra Ritterman (Junior Press Officer) Contents Wardour Led by Managing Director Claire Oldfield and Creative Director Ben Barrett Forewords 74 John Cridland CBE The team included: Art Editor Lynn Jones; Picture Researcher and Photographer Johanna Ward; Director General, Confederation Editor Hannah Stodell; Wardour editorial; Project Director Charlotte Tapp; 5 Xavier Rolet of British Industry CEO, London Stock Exchange Group Production John Faulkner and Jack Morgan 85 Kirstie Donnelly MBE 10 Tim Hinton Managing Director, City & Guilds UK Wardour, Drury House, 34–43 Russell Street, Managing Director, Mid Markets and London WC2B 5HA, United Kingdom SME Banking, Lloyds Bank 93 Tim Ward CEO, The Quoted Companies Alliance +44 (0)20 7010 0999 12 Stephen Welton www.wardour.co.uk CEO, Business Growth Fund 104 Anthony Browne CEO, British Bankers’ Association 14 Jim Durkin CEO, Cenkos 117 Tim Hames Director General, British Private Equity 16 Allister Heath and Venture Capital Association Pictures: Getty Images, iStock, Gallerystock Deputy Director of Content and Deputy Editor, Telegraph Media Group All other pictures used by permission 17 Damian Kimmelman Sections Cover illustration: Sol Linero Co-founder and CEO, DueDil 22 Technology & Digital Printed by Graphius
    [Show full text]
  • (Approved Plans), 5 (Landscaping Masterplan), 6 (Boundary
    Application Number 19/00836/FUL Proposal Variation of condition no.s 2 (approved plans), 5 (landscaping masterplan), 6 (boundary treatments), and 27 (cycle storage location) of planning permission 18/00188/FUL to amend the originally approved scheme in relation to changes to the final site levels and landscaping across the grass sports pitches to the north of the school buildings and amendments to boundary treatment. Site Former Littlemoss High School for Boys site, Cryer Street, Droylsden. Applicant Education and Skills Funding Agency. Recommendation Grant planning permission subject to conditions. Reason for report A Speakers Panel decision is required because the application constitutes Major development. 1.0 APPLICATION DESCRIPTION 1.1 The applicant seeks to vary a number of the conditions attached to the original planning permission to allow a re-grading of the land levels in the northern part of the site, a minor revision to the alignment of the boundary treatment in the south western corner of the site and the installation of some external seating areas adjacent to the sports pitches and Multi Use Games Area (MUGA.) Condition 27 has been included in the list of conditions to be amended as that refers to the originally approved landscape masterplan, which is proposed to be amended as part of this application to reflect the above changes. 2.0 SITE & SURROUNDINGS 2.1 The application relates to the former Littlemoss Boys School on the northern edge of Droylsden. The site is located in the Green Belt. The site is bound to the north by agricultural land and farm buildings, to the east by an area of open land (which separates the site from dwellings fronting Lumb Lane) and to the south by residential development on Woodleigh Drive, Brookland Drive, Cryer Street, Wayne Close and Lumb Lane.
    [Show full text]