Auschwitz Occurred on Sept
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mainstream historians claim that the very first CCarloarlo MMattognoattogno gassing of human beings at Auschwitz occurred on Sept. 3, 1941, in the basement of building no. 11 of the Auschwitz main camp. It is purported to have lasted G 15 hours, followed by another two days of ventilation N I and removal of the corpses of 850 victims. S For this study, Mattogno analyzed all available tes- S AAuschwitz:uschwitz: timonies. The resulting image is quite confusing: A G – The gassing happened either in spring 1941, or on Aug. 14, or 15, or on Sept. 3-5, or 5-6, or 5-8, or on Oct. 9, 1941, or T even in Nov. or Dec. of 1942. The location was either the old crema- S TThehe FFirstirst torium, or one, or all rooms, or even all rooms plus the hallway of R the basement of building 11, or somewhere at Birkenau; I F – the victims were either Russian POWs, or partisans, or political E GGassingassing commissars, or Poles, or Russian POWs and sick Polish detainees. There were either 200, or 300, or 500, or 696, or 800, or 850, or 980, H or 1,000, or 1,400, or 1,663 victims; T – the poison gas was administered a) by individuals alternatively : known as “SS-man Palitzsch,” “Tom Mix,” “the strangler,” or Z “Breitwieser”; b) either into the corridor, or into the cells; c) a total T of three cans, or perhaps two cans into each cell; d) either through I the door, or through a ventilation fl ap, or through openings above W the doors to the cells; H – the victims died immediately, or perhaps stayed alive for 15 hours; C – the corpses were removed either the next day, or the next night, or S 1-2 days later, or 3 days later, or on the 4th day, or the 6th day; U – the work took either one day, or one night, or 2 nights, or 3 nights; A – the bodies of the victims were either cremated, or buried in mass • graves, or partly cremated and partly buried. GASSING THE FIRST AUSCHWITZ: • O These chaotic claims regarding the very fi rst gassing at Ausch witz are N typical for all other accounts of homicidal gassings during the Third G O Reich. Using original wartime documents, Auschwitz: The First Gas- T sing by Carlo Mattogno refutes these claims and infl icts a fi nal blow T A to the tale of the fi rst alleged homicidal gassing. M O L R ISSN 1529–7748 A ISBN 978–1–59148–025–6 C CARLO MATTOGNO ISBN 978-1-59148-025-6 HHOLOCAUSTOLOCAUST HHandbooksandbooks SeriesSeries RRumorumor aandnd RealityReality 90000> VVolumeolume 2200 TThesesheses & DissertationsDissertations PPressress PPOO BBoxox 225776857768 CChicago,hicago, IILL 660625,0625, UUSASA 9781591 480259 AUSCHWITZ: THE FIRST GASSING RUMOR AND REALITY Auschwitz: The First Gassing Rumor and Reality Carlo Mattogno Theses & Dissertations Press PO Box 257768, Chicago, Illinois 60625 September 2005 HOLOCAUST Handbooks Series, Vol. 20: Carlo Mattogno: Auschwitz: The First Gassing. Rumor and Reality Translated by Henry Gardner Chicago (Illinois): Theses & Dissertations Press, Imprint of Castle Hill Publishers, September 2005 ISBN: 1-59148-025-6 ISBN: 1-59148-012-4: Auschwitz Studies Set, vol. 5 ISSN: 1529-7748 © by Carlo Mattogno Original Italian edition: Auschwitz: La prima gasazione Edizioni di Ar, Padua, 1992 Distribution Australia/Asia: Peace Books, PO Box 3300, Norwood, 5067, Australia Distribution Rest of World: Castle Hill Publishers UK: PO Box 118, Hastings TN34 3ZQ USA: PO Box 257768, Chicago, IL 60625 Set in Times New Roman. www.vho.org www.tadp.org 5 Table of Contents Page Introduction .....................................................................................................7 Chapter I: Genesis and Significance of the First Gassing..........................15 Chapter II: The Stage of the First Gassing: Block 11 ................................27 Chapter III: The Sources of the First Gassing............................................31 1. Wartime Sources (1941 – 1943)...........................................................31 2. Post-War Sources .................................................................................37 3. Testimonies of the SS Personnel..........................................................63 Chapter IV: Critical and Comparative Source Analysis ...........................69 1. The Location of the First Gassing ........................................................69 2. The Date of the First Gassing...............................................................71 3. The Preparations for the First Gassing.................................................72 4. The Victims of the First Gassing..........................................................72 5. The Removal of the Gassed..................................................................74 5.1. Persons who Did the Work............................................................74 5.2. Beginning of the Removal.............................................................74 5.3. Duration of the Removal ...............................................................75 5.4. Fate of the Bodies Removed .........................................................75 6. The Gassing..........................................................................................76 6.1. Location of the Gassing.................................................................76 6.2. Gassing Technique ........................................................................76 6.3. Duration of the Victims’ Agony....................................................78 6.4. Test for Residual Gases.................................................................80 6.5. Did the Witnesses ever See the Corpses of People who Died from Hydrogen Cyanide Poisoning?.............................................82 7. Conclusion: Historical and Critical Assessment of the Testimonies....83 8. The Value of the Testimonies ..............................................................83 9. Danuta Czech’s Historiographic Method .............................................86 10. Historical Reconstruction of the First Homicidal Gassing on the Basis of the Sources .............................................................................88 6 Carlo Mattogno, Auschwitz: The First Gassing Chapter V: Sources Not Speaking of the First Gassing .............................91 1. Testimonies ..........................................................................................91 2. Documents..........................................................................................102 3. Chemical Considerations....................................................................111 Conclusion ....................................................................................................113 Appendix ......................................................................................................115 Documents................................................................................................115 Photographs..............................................................................................133 Abbreviations ...........................................................................................154 Note on Polish Sources.............................................................................154 Bibliography.............................................................................................155 Index of Names ........................................................................................157 7 Introduction Since the original Italian version of this book was published in 1992, there have been numerous new developments in the field of historiography, none of which, though, have been important enough to mandate a change of this book’s conclusions. Even today, thirteen years later, official historiography has not only failed to produce a reply to this study, but in its obstinate historical dogmatism has not even found it necessary to study the topic in greater depth. This, however, is more important than ever before. The first homicidal gassing in the Ausch- witz concentration camp was allegedly carried out between September 3 and 5, 1941, in the basement of building (block) 13. This building was later named block 11 because of an administrative change in the numbering of the build- ings. This first gassing is said to have been the starting point of the alleged mass extermination process at Auschwitz. After having gone through the in- termediate stages of the mortuary in crematorium I of the Stammlager (Auschwitz main camp) and the so-called “Bunkers” at Birkenau, this claimed extermination process later led to the alleged homicidal gas chambers of the Birkenau crematoria. As such, the first homicidal gassing would therefore constitute the birth of the homicidal gas chambers and mark the “official” in- troduction of Zyklon B into the Auschwitz holocaust history. Moreover, it would also constitute the archetype of the alleged “selections” of registered detainees in the camp hospitals for the “gas chambers.” The consequence of this strange inactivity on the part of official historiog- raphy is that the bibliography on this topic is, as yet, practically non-existent. Up until 1992, only a single article had been dedicated to this subject,1 aside from my own contribution presented at the “Ninth International Revisionist Conference” of 1989,2 which I later expanded to the present study. Because the article mentioned above had appeared in a Polish journal, it remained prac- tically unnoticed by western specialists on Auschwitz until 1987, when an abridged translation became available in German.3 Hence, for decades – and practically