DOCSLIB.ORG

398687 Vol1.Pdf

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
398687 Vol1.Pdf Cultivating' Autonomy: A Case For Deliberative And Associational Democracy Stephen L Elstub Volume One PhD Thesis Department of Politics University of Sheffield April 2003 SUMMARY The thesis aims to justify liberal democracy on the cultivation of autonomy amongst its citizens. The potential of deliberative democracy and associational democracy to achieve this cultivation are then critically evaluated It is suggestedthat autonomy has intrinsic value and an intrinsic connection to democracy, particularly in Western democracies. Deliberative democracy is justified as the most suitable model of decision-making to cultivate autonomy due to its enhancement of public reason, speaker and hearer autonomy. All three factors therefore encourage reflective preference transformation. which is the defining mark of deliberative democracy. A perfectionist case of deliberative democracy is further presentedand associations in civil society are evaluated as a location of deliberative democracy. It is argued that the associations can achieve this by fulfilling four functions: they can be venues for subsidiarity; provide information and representation; be schools of democracy; and locations for governance. The fulfilment of these functions enables the institutionalisation of deliberative democracy to overcome some of the threats of complexity, pluralism, size and inequality. However, not all associationscan achieve all four functions and in order to do so, they must be internally democratic. The associationsalso need to pursue a dualist strategy in relation to the state. This involves a critical public spherewith informal networks of communication based upon the norms of deliberative democracy. The public sphere should then set the agenda for legislation through the `outside accessmodel'. The second strand of the dualist strategy is to gain access to legislative arenas. Associational mediating forums with power devolved from the state, again based on the norms of deliberative democracy, are advocatedas a suitable method by which to achieve this. This associationalmodel differs from the neo-pluralistmodel of interestgroups because it is basedupon the norms of deliberativedemocracy and can therefore promote the commongood and avoid the `mischiefof factionalism'. Finally, a case study of the StanageForum is considered I suggestthat it approximates the associational mediating forums and highlights where trade-offs between the ideal and practice needto be, can be, should be and will be made. ACKNOWl, 1;1NPF, NIFN rS I would firstly like to thank my two supcrvisors,Dr Matthew 1-cstcnstcinand Mr Anthony Arblastcr, for their invaluableadvice, experienceand support ovcr the ycars. Many thanks must go to the cntirc Departmentof i'otitics, cspccially Sarah Cooke whosehelp madethe submissionprocess as stress-frccas thcscthings can be. Thanks too to all those who participatedat the StanagcForum, particularly Matthew Croncyand StcvcSmith. I would also like to thank all my friendsand family for thcir supportand cncouragcmcnt - you know who you arcl Two pcoplc dcscrvc an cxtca spccial acknowlcdg;cmcnt - Lindscy and my mothcr Marprct, without whom this thcsis would ncithcr havc bccn possibicor probablc. MINýlr LF, N'tls' VOLUMEONE page 1 INTRODUCflON CORE OF DEMOCRACY AUTONOMY: TILE NORMATIVE 1: pagel' 1.0Introduction i'nbc a8 1.1 Autonomy and Dcmocracy page 14 1.2 Liberal Dcmocracyand Autonomy pageagee 1.3The Value of Autonomy 2204 Autonomy page 1.4The Requirementsof 60 Authority Page 1.5The Conflict BetweenAutonomy and page 85 1.6Conclusion ANI) AUTONOMOUS i)ECISION-MAKING DLLIBERAT1VI DEMOCRACY 2: pagc 2.0 Introduction page 888 2.1 Defining Dclibcrativc Dcmocracy page 93 2.2 DclibcrativcDemocracy and Autonomy page 103 2.3 Challenges page 137 2.4 Conclusion DEMOCRATIC ASSOCIATIONS 3: AUTONOMY ANI) DELIBERATIVELY paSe139 3.0 Introduction Dcmocrncy pagc 14?aa 3.1 The InstitutionalRcquircmcnts ofDclibcrativc c1 3.2 Mining Associations pagc 153 3.3 Vcnucsfor Subsidiarity 163 GroupRcprescntation bC"c 3.4 Provisionof Infonnation and 170 3.5 Schools Dcmocracy of Abc I177177 3.6 Locationsof Govcrnnncc pagc 3,7 Conclusion VOLilnt1: 't WO 4. ASSOCIATIONS AND IN fERNAL DEMOCRACY 194 4.0 Introduction page pa1;c 198 4.1 Exit and Voicc page201 4.2 Frccdomof Association page208 4.3 The Iron Law of Oligarchy 212 4.4 Empirical Restrictions page 214 4.5 Conclusion page S. A DUALIST MODEL OF ASSOCIATIVE DEMOCRACY 2t5 5.0 Introduction page page 218 5.1 Justifications of Dualism page 233 5.2 External Relations and the Public Sphere 249 5.3 Mediating Forums page Democracy page 271 5.4 Towards a Dualist Model of Associative 293 5.5 Conclusion page 6. AVOIDING TIl MISCHIEF OF I'ACTIONAl. ISt1i 295 6.0 introduction page 297 6.1 The RepublicanModel andthe CommonGood page 304 6.2 DeliberativeDemocracy and the CommonGood page 310 6.3 AssociationalismVersus Nco-Libcral Pluralism page 322 6.4 Conclusion page FORUMSIN PRACTICE.' 7.'I11E STANAGE FORUM: ASSO ' IA'ilONAL NMEI)IA'i7NG 325 7.0 Introduction page page327 7.1 About Stanagcand the Purposcof the Forum Forums page330 7.2 Approximationof the AssociationalMcdiating 353 7.3 Critical Appraisalof the Resultsand Dccisions page 3f,2 7.4 Conclusion page 364 CONCLUSION parc 371 APPENDIX1 page 372. 11111LIOCILU'llY r' l N"i'ir,,,,ODI ff"T I ON Over the last ten to fiflccn years,deliberative democracy has becomean increasingly dominantstrand ofdcntocratic theory(Dryrck, 2000,p. 1). This thesisintends to add to this literatureon both justification and institutionalisation.The justification is that it is the mostsuitable model ofdemocratic dccision"makingto cultivate citizens' autonomy. In terms of institutionalisation,voluntary associationsin civil society arc analysedas suitablelocations for deliberative democracy.This then links the current litcraturc on deliberativedemocracy with the recentlyrcjuvcnatcd ideas of civil society, ollen termed nco-tocqucvillianismor the second wave of civil society. 'This popularity is not restrictedto political theory although Lester Salamonand Anhcicr inform us that the world is undergoing`a major reappraisalof the whole state' (Salamon and Anhcicr, 1996, p. 1) and that this is being counteredby `a global associational revolution' (Salamonand Anhcicr, 1996,p. 81). The most dominantstream of the thesishowever is how to cultivateautonomy, and the thesisinvestigates to what extent deliberativeand associationaldemocracy can achievethis. The approachis predominantlytheoretical andnormative, and the thesisshould be seenas an attemptto contribute to three areasof literatureon autonomy,dclibcrativc democracyand associationalism. In doing so, the thesistries to addressand add substanceto severalkey issuesthat the presentliterature on theseareas has failed to considerin explicit detail. The analysisof thesetopics can also be sccn as a seriesof suggestionsfor democratic deepening.According to John Dryzck there arc three dimensions through which democracycan be deepened. the first is the expansionof the franchisewhere more pcoplc participatein collective decision; the secondis scope,,where more issuesand topics are opened to democratic decision-making;and the third is 'authenticity of control', which requires'the effective participationofautonomous and comment actors (Dryzck, 2000, p. 29). It is this third methodthat the thesisfocuses upon; arguing that deliberativedemocracy can lead to more authentic preferences,and believing more autonomouspreferences arc more authentic. For Dryr.ck authenticity is `thc degreeto which democraticcontrol is cnggcd throughcommunication that encouragesrctlcction uponpreferences without coercion' (Uryak, 2000, p. 8). 2 ChapterOne presentsthe case that the cultivation of the value of autonomy is the normativecore of democracy.It is suggestedthat autonomyand democracyboth aim to maketheir agentssclf-determining and so the relationshipbetween them is implicit. I arguethat autonomyis an intrinsic value for its own sake,especially in western literal democracies,as both the theory and practice of liberal democracyhave assumedits citizens to be autonomous. However, the argumenthere is that autonomouscitiicns cannot be assumed,because the right conditions need to be in place to cultivate this autonomy.I outline the core elementsof autonomyas free choicebased upon rationally formed preferencesand then defend the possibility of autonomy as defined against several challengesthat maintain the impossibility of justifying democracy upon autonomy.These arc that it is not a political value, that pcoplcarc dctcrrnincdso cannot be autonomous,that autonomyinevitably leadsto perfectionismor paternalismand that autonomyis incompatiblewith authority. Although there is alreadya vast literature on autonomy,which I useas the basisof my arguments,the thesismaintains key elements of originality as the chapter looks specifically at cultivating autonomy in decision- making. In ChapterTwo, l arguethat the model of deliberativedemocracy is the best decision- making methodto cultivate the autonomyof all participantsequally. This argument acceptsRobert Dahl's argument,that `democracycannot be justified merely as a system for translatingthe raw, uninformedwill or a popular majority into public policy' (Dahl, 1994,p. 30). For preferencesto be authentic,they must be cnlightcned, and as Dahl assertsthis requireseducation, discussion and public debate (Dahl, 1994,p. 31). From this Dahl concludesthat 'alternative proceduresfor making decisions ought to be evaluated according to the opportunities they furnish citizens for acquiring
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Diminishing Power and Democracy of Hong Kong: an Analysis of Hong Kong's Umbrella Movement and the Anti-Extradition Law Amendment Bill Movement
    Portland State University PDXScholar University Honors Theses University Honors College Summer 2021 The Diminishing Power and Democracy of Hong Kong: An Analysis of Hong Kong's Umbrella Movement and the Anti-Extradition Law Amendment Bill Movement Xiao Lin Kuang Portland State University Follow this and additional works at: https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/honorstheses Part of the Asian Studies Commons, and the Other International and Area Studies Commons Let us know how access to this document benefits ou.y Recommended Citation Kuang, Xiao Lin, "The Diminishing Power and Democracy of Hong Kong: An Analysis of Hong Kong's Umbrella Movement and the Anti-Extradition Law Amendment Bill Movement" (2021). University Honors Theses. Paper 1126. https://doi.org/10.15760/honors.1157 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access. It has been accepted for inclusion in University Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of PDXScholar. Please contact us if we can make this document more accessible: [email protected]. The diminishing power and democracy of Hong Kong: an analysis of Hong Kong’s Umbrella Movement and the Anti-extradition Law Amendment Bill Movement by Xiao Lin Kuang An undergraduate honors thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the Requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Arts In University Honors And International Development Studies And Chinese Thesis Adviser Maureen Hickey Portland State University 2021 The diminishing power and democracy of Hong Kong Kuang 1 Abstract The future of Hong Kong – one of the most valuable economic port cities in the world – has been a key political issue since the Opium Wars (1839—1860).
    [Show full text]
  • Reclaiming Their Shadow: Ethnopolitical Mobilization in Consolidated Democracies
    Reclaiming their Shadow: Ethnopolitical Mobilization in Consolidated Democracies Ph. D. Dissertation by Britt Cartrite Department of Political Science University of Colorado at Boulder May 1, 2003 Dissertation Committee: Professor William Safran, Chair; Professor James Scarritt; Professor Sven Steinmo; Associate Professor David Leblang; Professor Luis Moreno. Abstract: In recent decades Western Europe has seen a dramatic increase in the political activity of ethnic groups demanding special institutional provisions to preserve their distinct identity. This mobilization represents the relative failure of centuries of assimilationist policies among some of the oldest nation-states and an unexpected outcome for scholars of modernization and nation-building. In its wake, the phenomenon generated a significant scholarship attempting to account for this activity, much of which focused on differences in economic growth as the root cause of ethnic activism. However, some scholars find these models to be based on too short a timeframe for a rich understanding of the phenomenon or too narrowly focused on material interests at the expense of considering institutions, culture, and psychology. In response to this broader debate, this study explores fifteen ethnic groups in three countries (France, Spain, and the United Kingdom) over the last two centuries as well as factoring in changes in Western European thought and institutions more broadly, all in an attempt to build a richer understanding of ethnic mobilization. Furthermore, by including all “national
    [Show full text]
  • Domestic Analogy in Proposals for World Order, 1814-1945
    Domestic analogy in proposals for world order, 1814-1945: the transfer of legal and political principles from the domestic to the international sphere in thought on international law and relations HIDEMI SUGANAMI Thesis submitted for the Degree of Ph.D. The London School of Economics and Political Science, University of London 1985 2 ABSTRACT The ways in which legal and political principles obtaining within states can profitably be transferred to the relations of states are among the contentious issues in the study of international relations, and the term 'domestic analogy' is used to refer to the argument which supports such transfer. The 'domestic analogy' is analogical reasoning according to which the conditions of order between states are similar to those of order within them, and therefore those institutions which sustain order within states should be transferred to the international system. However, despite the apparent division among writers on international relations between those who favour this analogy and those who are critical of it, no clear analysis has so far been made as to precisely what types of proposal should be treated as exemplifying reliance on this analogy. The first aim of this thesis is to clarify the range and types of proposal this analogy entails. The thesis then examines the role the domestic analogy played in ideas about world order in the period between 1814 and 1945. Particular attention is paid to the influence of changing circumstances in the domestic and international spheres upon the manner and the extent of the use of this analogy. In addition to the ideas of major writers on international law and relations, the creation of the League of Nations and of the United Nations is also examined.
    [Show full text]
  • The Evolution of the Interpretation of Populism from the 1950S to Present
    Department of Political Science Course in Comparative History of Political Systems THE EVOLUTION OF THE INTERPRETATION OF POPULISM FROM THE 1950S TO PRESENT AN HISTORICAL EXCURSUS Supervisor: Professor Giovanni Orsina Candidate: Matteo Passigli Co-Supervisor: Vincenzo Emanuele Academic Year 2017-2018 Index Introduction Chapter I – Understanding populism: a general idea of the populist debate 1. Thinking about populism 2. Approaching populism 2.1. Populism as Forma Mentis 2.2. Ideological Approach 2.3. Political-Strategical Approach 3. Populism around the world 3.1. Europe 3.2. United States 3.3. Latin America 4. The Protagonists of populism 4.1. Populism in power Chapter II – The interpretation of populism in the 1969-1989 period 1. Historical and Conceptual Background 2. A first ideological approach to populism 3. The New and Differentiated Approaches to Populism: Social Mobilization, Integration and Structural Changes 4. The populist Upsurge in Latin America: Macroeconomic Populism and Social Modernization 4.1 The roots of a National Populist Movement: The Case of Argentina Chapter III – The interpretation of populism in the 1990-2009 period 1. Historical and Conceptual Background 2. New-Populism Cases 3. New Right-Wing Populism: Immigration and Xenophobia 4. Democracy and Populism 5. Communication and Media within the New Populist Surge 5.1 Media-Populism in Italy: the Lega Nord Case Chapter IV – The interpretation of populism in the 2009-today period Main literature and thoughts Conclusion Bibliography Introduction The objective of this work is to make a comparative historical analysis of the concept of populism and its interpretation. Following the course of history and of main literature and authors, this excursus will illustrate how the interpretation of populism has been changing during the XX century in different regions, such as the United States, Europe and Latin America.
    [Show full text]
  • Language Policy and Politics: the Central State and Linguistic Minorities in Spain and Italy, 1992-2010
    Language Policy and Politics: The Central State and Linguistic Minorities in Spain and Italy, 1992-2010 Naomi Amelia Stewart Wells Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Leeds School of Modern Languages and Cultures July 2013 i The candidate confirms that the work submitted is his/her own and that appropriate credit has been given where reference has been made to the work of others. This copy has been supplied on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. © 2013 The University of Leeds and Naomi Amelia Stewart Wells The right of Naomi Amelia Stewart Wells to be identified as Author of this work has been asserted by her in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. ii Acknowledgements I would like to first thank my supervisors, Professor Brian Richardson and Dr Angel Smith, for their invaluable help throughout my research, and for ensuring that the PhD process was both enjoyable and rewarding. Thank you to Brian for supervising me from MA to PhD and for his continued support throughout. I would also like to thank the University of Leeds for its generous funding and specifically the School of Modern Languages and Cultures. I am particularly grateful to Dr Gigliola Sulis and the staff in Italian for their academic and professional support. Fieldwork would not have been possible without the willing participation of the interviewees who generously gave up their often limited time. Particular thanks to Giuseppe Corongiu, José Manuel Pérez Fernández, Oskar Peterlini and Tiziana Sinesi for their additional assistance in locating sources.
    [Show full text]
  • Programme for Research and Actions on the Development of the Labour Market
    PROGRAMME FOR RESEARCH AND ACTIONS ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE LABOUR MARKET ANALYSIS OF THE EXPERIENCES OF AND PROBLEMS ENCOUNTERED BY WORKER TAKE-OVERS OF COMPANIES IN DIFFICULTY OR BANKRUPT MAIN REPORT *** * PAOODOCUMEN COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEA COMMUNITIES This document has been prepared for use within the Commission. It does not necessarily represent the Commission's official position. Cataloguing data can be found at the end of this publication. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, 1987 ISBN 92-825-7580-2 Catalogue number: CB-50-87-033-EN-C © ECSC-EEC-EAEC, Brussels - Luxembourg, 1987 Reproduction is authorized, except for commercial purposes, provided the source is acknowledged. Printed in Belgium Commission of the European Communities PROGRAMME FOR RESEARCH AND ACTIONS ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE LABOUR MARKET ANALYSIS OF THE EXPERIENCES OF AND PROBLEMS ENCOUNTERED BY WORKER TAKE-OVERS OF COMPANIES IN DIFFICULTY OR BANKRUPT Main Report Author: Rob Paton Cooperative Research Unit The Open University U.K. Study No. 85/4 Document This document has been prepared for use within the Commission. It does not necessarily represent the Commission's official, position. Copyright ECSC-EEC-EAEC, Brussels - Luxembourg, 198.7 Reproduction is authorized, except for commercial purposes, provided the source is acknowledged. The research (Study 85/4) on which these reports were based was financed by the Commission of the European Communities as part of its programme for Research and Actions on the Development of the Labour Market. The analysis and conclusions are the responsibility of the authors. They do not necessarily reflect any views held within the Commis• sion of the European Communities nor do they commit it to a parti• cular view of the Labour Market or any other policy matters.
    [Show full text]
  • The Inclusive Democracy Project: a Rejoinder - TAKIS FOTOPOULOS
    The Inclusive Democracy project: A rejoinder - TAKIS FOTOPOULOS The International Journal of INCLUSIVE DEMOCRACY, Vol. 1, No. 3 (May 2005) The Inclusive Democracy project: A rejoinder TAKIS FOTOPOULOS I would like first to take this opportunity to express my gratitude to all the contributors taking part in this special issue. It is indeed through the development of a comprehensive dialogue on the crucial issues that the Inclusive Democracy (ID) project raises that we could meaningfully assess its merits and possible weaknesses. In the lines that will follow the intention is not to engage in any kind of polemic against any of the distinguished contributors but simply to give alternative explanations, from the ID perspective, to the reservations, or even criticisms, raised against it. I hope that the bona fide spirit within which this debate takes place will be recognized by everybody and the fruitful dialogue developed here will function as a catalyst for its further expansion in the future. I hope that most in the radical Left would agree today on the need for the expansion of such a dialogue on the contours of a future society at a moment when many —particularly within the anti-globalization movement— assert that ‘another world is possible’ without even taking the trouble to define this world . But, if this movement is not capable of giving at least the contours of such an alternative world (and this is the objective of the ID project) then it is bound to register in popular memory as simply a protest movement and not as a liberatory movement —the kind of movement we need today to move forward towards a new society.
    [Show full text]
  • Chile: Background and U.S
    Chile: Background and U.S. Relations name redacted Analyst in Latin American Affairs November 19, 2015 Congressional Research Service 7-.... www.crs.gov R40126 Chile: Background and U.S. Relations Summary Chile, located along the Pacific coast of South America, is a politically stable, upper-middle- income nation of 18 million people. In 2013, Michelle Bachelet and her center-left “New Majority” coalition won the presidency and sizeable majorities in both houses of the Chilean Congress after campaigning on a platform of ambitious reforms designed to reduce inequality and improve social mobility. Since her inauguration to a four-year term in March 2014, President Bachelet has signed into law significant changes to the tax, education, and electoral systems. She has also proposed a number of other economic and social policy reforms, as well as a process for adopting a new constitution. Although a significant majority of the public initially supported the reforms, Chileans have grown more divided over time, with some groups pushing for more far- reaching policy changes and others calling for Bachelet to scale back her agenda. Disapproval of the reforms, a corruption scandal that implicated her son, and Chile’s slowing economy have taken a toll on President Bachelet’s approval rating, which has declined to 29%. Chile’s economic growth has slowed considerably in recent years, falling to 1.9% in 2014. Analysts have largely attributed the slowdown to the end of the global commodity boom and the coinciding drop in copper prices, which have a significant impact on the Chilean economy. There are also indications that the Bachelet Administration’s policy reforms may have reduced business confidence and dampened growth.
    [Show full text]
  • Autonomy and Borders in an Evolving Europe Principles, Frameworks And
    30th SESSION Strasbourg, 22-24 March 2016 CPR30(2016)02-final 24 March 2016 Autonomy and borders in an evolving Europe Principles, frameworks and procedures for protecting and modifying status, competences and borders of sub-national entities within domestic law Governance Committee Rapporteur:1 Karl-Heinz LAMBERTZ, Belgium (R, SOC) Resolution.398(2016) ..................................................................................................................................3 Recommendation 385(2016).......................................................................................................................5 Explanatory memorandum ..........................................................................................................................7 Summary The balance of opposing principles of State unity and sub-national autonomy needs continuous adaptation. More profound adaptation may provoke changes in the distribution of competencies, or even regarding the legal/constitutional status of sub-national entities. Frequently, controversy and conflict between national government and subnational entity is the inevitable consequence. Based on the comparative method, this report examines normative guarantees and procedures provided by various European domestic laws for modifying subnational constitutions, competencies and financial resources of subnational entities, boundaries and territorial status as well as principles governing conflict prevention and resolution. The comparative evaluation identifies good practice
    [Show full text]
  • Driving Growth Through Women's Economic Participation
    THE % THE 51 51 % Driving Growth through Women’s Economic Participation Edited by DIANE WHITMORE SCHANZENBACH and RYAN NUNN The 51% Driving Growth through Women’s Economic Participation Edited by Diane Whitmore Schanzenbach and Ryan Nunn OCTOBER 2017 ii Acknowledgments The Hamilton Project wishes to thank members of its Advisory Council for their valuable contributions to this book. In particular, the Project is grateful to Roger C. Altman, Penny Pritzker, and Robert E. Rubin for helpful discussions and insights. The contents of this volume and the individual papers do not necessarily represent the views of individual Advisory Council members, nor do they necessarily represent the views of the institutions with which the papers’ authors are affiliated. The Hamilton Project is also grateful for the expert feedback provided by participants at the May 2017 authors’ conference held at the Brookings Institution. We appreciate the contributions of everyone who participated in that meeting. The editors appreciate insightful comments from Jay Shambaugh as well as the outstanding work of The Hamilton Project staff on this book. Kriston McIntosh provided expert guidance on all aspects of production. Lauren Bauer, Audrey Breitwieser, and David Dreyer contributed substantially to the development of the book. Patrick Liu, Megan Mumford, Greg Nantz, and Becca Portman provided superb research assistance. We also gratefully acknowledge the contributions of Karna Malaviya, Carmel Steindam, Alison Hope, Brianna Harden, Vesna Asanovic, Anna Rotrosen, and Melanie Gilarsky. The policy proposals included in this volume are proposals from the authors. As emphasized in The Hamilton Project’s original strategy paper, the Project was designed in part to provide a forum for leading thinkers across the nation to put forward innovative and potentially important economic policy ideas that share the Project’s broad goals of promoting economic growth, broad-based participation in growth, and economic security.
    [Show full text]
  • Hong Kong: the Rise and Fall of “One Country, Two Systems”
    Hong Kong: The Rise and Fall of “One Country, Two Systems” William H. Overholt December 2019 Hong Kong: The Rise and Fall of “One Country, Two Systems” William H. Overholt December 2019 hong kong: The Rise and Fall of “One Country, Two Systems” about the author William Overholt is a Senior Research Fellow, focusing on Chinese/Asian economic development, political development, and geopolitics with the Mossavar-Rahmani Center for Business and Government at Harvard Kennedy School. During 2013–15 he also served as President of the Fung Global Institute in Hong Kong. His career includes 16 years doing policy research at think tanks and 21 years running investment bank research teams. Previously he held the Asia Policy Distinguished Research Chair at RAND’s California headquarters and was Director of the Center for Asia Pacific Policy; concurrently he was Visiting Professor at Shanghai Jiaodong University and, earlier, Distinguished Visiting Professor at Korea’s Yonsei University. During 21 years in invest- ment banking, he served as Head of Strategy and Economics at Nomura’s regional headquarters in Hong Kong from 1998 to 2001, and as Managing Director and Head of Research at Bank Boston’s regional headquarters in Singapore. For Bankers Trust, he ran a country risk team in New York from 1980 to 1984, then was regional strategist and Asia research head based in Hong Kong from 1985 to 1998. At Hudson Institute from 1971 to 1979, Dr. Overholt directed planning studies for the U.S. Department of Defense, Department of State, National Security Council, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, and Council on International Economic Policy.
    [Show full text]
  • The Interrelation Between Democracy and Responsibility: the Greek Crisis As a Paradigm Case for the EU
    The Interrelation Between Democracy and Responsibility: The Greek Crisis as a Paradigm Case for the EU La interrelacción entre democracia y responsabilidad. La crisis griega como caso paradigmático para la UE WOLF-JÜRGEN CRAMM Bern University, Switzerland ABSTRACT One of the main lessons to be learned from the Greek crisis is that large scale supranational communitarisation is a danger for democracy if mutual obligations between members undermine substantially the possibilities F of political choice for the single member states. I argue that a well-balanced 9 relation between (self-) responsibility, solidarity, performance incentives and F democracy involves taking subsidiarity serious, as well as to admit a certain amount of institutional flexibility. This flexibility is demanded especially in the case of large scale communities which include countries as members, like the EU, and in which the basic ideas of social, economical and financial policy are rather heterogeneous. Democracy, responsibility and solidarity must be in a well balanced relation for any community to function and to be generally acceptable to the citizens. This includes the defence of rather ambitious forms of civil participation and sovereignty of the people against the paternalistic pretensions of experts or of political and cultural elites. And responsibility — as a basic condition for democracy— requires that the design of the contractual basis of the EU must make possible that voting communities really assume responsibility for their decisions, which includes bearing possible negative consequences of these decision on themselves. Preserving a certain leeway for differing decisions about economical, financial or social questions is necessary for giving democratic substance to the demand of the primacy of politics.
    [Show full text]