The Making of the Romantic Shakespeare Elizabeth Montagu and Samuel Taylor Coleridge Research Master Thesis Comparative Literary Studies Joke Brasser
[email protected] 3217477 Utrecht University June 2012 Supervisor: Dr Birgit Kaiser Second reader: Dr Barnita Bagchi 2 Table of Contents Introduction: Constellations of Criticisms: Reading Shakespeare in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Century 3 Introducing the Bluestockings 6 Elizabeth Montagu: “The Romantic Bluestocking” 8 Works Cited 12 Chapter One: English Shakespeare Criticism in the Eighteenth Century 14 Ancients and Moderns 15 Eighteenth-Century Editions of Shakespeare 17 Shakespearean Criticism 21 Shakespeare’s Language 23 Character Criticism 24 Bluestocking Criticism 26 Conclusion 29 Works Cited 30 Chapter Two: Montagu and Coleridge: The Making of the Romantic Shakespeare 33 I. Introduction 33 The Reception History of Montagu’s Essay 34 Shakespeare in Germany 37 The Sturm und Drang Reception of Shakespeare 40 Coleridge’s Shakespeare Lectures 42 II. Montagu and Coleridge: A Comparative Analysis 43 Aim and Method 43 The English Historical Drama 46 The Emergence of the Historical Method: Montagu and Herder 48 Coleridge on the English Historical Drama 54 Dramatic Illusion 57 Shakespeare’s Supernatural Imagination 59 Poetic Judgment and Taste 63 III. Conclusion 66 Works Cited 68 Chapter Three: Reading Elizabeth Montagu 72 Women Critics 73 Elizabeth Montagu in Romantic Criticism 77 Concluding Remarks 79 Works Cited 81 Conclusion 83 3 Introduction Constellations of Criticisms: Reading Shakespeare in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Century “Shakespeare […] was not guilty of much more than often falls to women’s share” Aphra Behn, Preface to The Dutch Lover (224).1 “Shakespeares Universalität ist wie der Mittelpunkt der romantischen Kunst” Friedrich Schlegel, Athenäum fragment 247 (KSFA online).