Green Illusions Is Not a Litany of Despair
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“In this terrific book, Ozzie Zehner explains why most current approaches to the world’s gathering climate and energy crises are not only misguided but actually counterproductive. We fool ourselves in innumerable ways, and Zehner is especially good at untangling sloppy thinking. Yet Green Illusions is not a litany of despair. It’s full of hope—which is different from false hope, and which requires readers with open, skeptical minds.”— David Owen, author of Green Metropolis “Think the answer to global warming lies in solar panels, wind turbines, and biofuels? Think again. In this thought-provoking and deeply researched critique of popular ‘green’ solutions, Zehner makes a convincing case that such alternatives won’t solve our energy problems; in fact, they could make matters even worse.”—Susan Freinkel, author of Plastic: A Toxic Love Story “There is no obvious competing or comparable book. Green Illusions has the same potential to sound a wake-up call in the energy arena as was observed with Silent Spring in the environment, and Fast Food Nation in the food system.”—Charles Francis, former director of the Center for Sustainable Agriculture Systems at the University of Nebraska “This is one of those books that you read with a yellow marker and end up highlighting most of it.”—David Ochsner, University of Texas at Austin Green Illusions Our Sustainable Future Series Editors Charles A. Francis University of Nebraska–Lincoln Cornelia Flora Iowa State University Paul A. Olson University of Nebraska–Lincoln The Dirty Secrets of Clean Energy and the Future of Environmentalism Ozzie Zehner University of Nebraska Press Lincoln and London Both text and cover are printed on acid-free paper that is 100% ancient forest free (100% post-consumer recycled). © 2012 by Ozzie Zehner All rights reserved Manufactured in the United States of America Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Zehner, Ozzie. Green illusions: the dirty secrets of clean energy and the future of environmentalism / Ozzie Zehner. p. cm. — (Our sustainable future) Includes bibliographical references and index. isbn 978-0-8032-3775-9 (cloth: alk. paper) 1. Renewable energy sources—United States. 2. Environmentalism—United States. I. Title. tj807.9.u6z44 2012 333.79'40973—dc23 2011042685 Set in Fournier MT. Designed by Mikah Tacha. To Mom and Dad, who gave me a leash, only to show me how to break it. § All of the royalties from this book will go toward projects supporting the future of environmentalism. Contents List of Illustrations . viii List of Figures . ix Acknowledgments . xi Introduction: Unraveling the Spectacle . xv part i: seductive futures 1. Solar Cells and Other Fairy Tales . 3 2. Wind Power’s Flurry of Limitations . 31 3. Biofuels and the Politics of Big Corn . 61 4. The Nuclear-Military-Industrial Risk Complex . 81 5. The Hydrogen Zombie . 105 6. Conjuring Clean Coal . 121 7. Hydropower, Hybrids, and Other Hydras . 133 part ii: from here to there 8. The Alternative-Energy Fetish . 149 9. The First Step . 171 part iii: the future of environmentalism 10. Women’s Rights . 187 11. Improving Consumption . 223 12. The Architecture of Community . 263 13. Efficiency Culture . 301 14. Asking Questions . 331 Epilogue: A Grander Narrative? . 343 Resources for Future Environmentalists . 349 Notes . 355 Index . 415 Illustrations 1. Solar system challenges . 23 2. An imposing scale . 33 3. Road infiltrates a rainforest . 40 4. Mississippi River dead zone . 72 5. Entering Hanford . 87 6. A four-story-high radioactive soufflé . 88 7. In the wake of Chernobyl . 102 8. Flaring tap . 142 9. Reclaiming streets . 289 10. Prioritizing bicycle traffic . 295 Figures 1. California solar system costs . 11 2. Solar module costs do not follow Moore’s law . 16 3. Fussy wind . 44 4. Five days of sun . 45 5. U.S. capacity factors by source . 50 6. Secret U.S. government document ornl–341 . 84 7. Clean coal’s lackluster potential . 129 8. Media activity during oil shock . 153 9. Incongruent power plays . 181 10. Congruent power plays . 181 11. Global world population . 195 12. Differences in teen pregnancy and abortion . 217 13. Similarity in first sexual experience. 217 14. American food marketing to children . 229 15. gdp versus well-being . 255 16. Trips by walking and bicycling . 280 17. Walking and bicycling among seniors . 282 18. U.S. energy flows . 304 19. Passive solar strategies . 326 Table The present and future of environmentalism . 332 Acknowledgments To begin, I’d like to extend special thanks to nu- merous anonymous individuals who risked their standing or job security to connect me with leads, offer guidance, spill dirt, and sneak me into places I perhaps shouldn’t have been. These include one World Bank executive, one member of Congress, one engineer at General Motors, two marketing executives, one former teen celebrity, two polit- ical strategists in Washington dc, two military contractors, a high school vice principal, one so- lar industry executive, one solar sales rep, one mining worker, and three especially helpful se- curity guards. I also extend thanks to those organizations that generously released confidential reports, which I had worked on, so I might draw upon their find- ings in this very public setting. I appreciate the co- operation from numerous Department of Energy employees, who provided everything from im- ages to insight on internal decisionmaking. This book would not have been possible without brave individuals from the World Bank, U.S. military, academia, and industry who were involved in whistle-blowing, industrial es- pionage, and leaks exposing wrongdoings. Their courage re- minds us there are rules that are provisional and rules that are not. My enthusiastic and keen agent, Uwe Stender, generously pursued a nonprofit press deal while offering me limitless sup- port and advice. I'd like to thank the editors and staff at the Uni- versity of Nebraska Press, including Heather Lundine, Bridget Barry, Joeth Zucco, and Cara Pesek, who believed in this work enough to buy the rights, support this book in staff meetings, co- ordinate expert reviews, considerably improve the manuscript, and put up with this green writer. Special thanks go to Karen Brown, whose copyediting cut a path through my writing for readers to follow. I’d especially like to mention the generous support of numer- ous educators, colleagues, and advisers starting with John Grin, Loet Leydesdorff, Stuart Blume, Chunglin Kwa, and, in mem- ory, Olga Amsterdamska from the University of Amsterdam; Steven Epstein (Northwestern University), Naomi Oreskes, Katrina Peterson, and Marisa Brandt from the Department of Science Studies at the University of California–San Diego; Joseph Dumit, Mario Biagioli, Tom Beamish, Tim Choy, Jim Griesemer, Caren Kaplan, Colin Milburn, Chris Kortright, and Michelle Stewart from the Department of Science and Technol- ogy Studies at the University of California–Davis; Cori Hayden, Cathryn Carson, Hélène Mialet, Mark Robinson, Mark Fleming, Jerry Zee, Mary Murrell, Diana Wear, and Gene Rochlin from the Science, Technology, and Society Center at the University of California–Berkeley; Reginald Bell at Kettering University; Charles Francis at the University of Nebraska; David Ochsner at the University of Texas at Austin; Brian Steele from the for- mer Kalamazoo Academy; the dedicated staff at Nature Bridge Headlands Institute; and the Science, Technology, and Society faculty at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. xii Acknowledgments I am grateful for the editors who dealt with various rough drafts of this manuscript, from proposal to completion, includ- ing especially Frieder Christman, Oleg Makariev, and Joe Clem- ent, as well as the acutely helpful input from three anonymous academic reviewers. I'd also like to thank Saad Padela, Jenny Braswell, Harshan Ramadass, Tayo Sowunmi, Nahvae Frost, Myla Mercer, Judy Traub, Sarah Margolis, Cheryl Levy, Gar- rett Brown, and Karla L. Topper. I’d like to thank numerous individuals who assisted me with conceptual and theoretical development: Charlie Zuver, D. A. M., Brad Borevitz, Kyla Schuller, Jeffrey Stevens, Jack Markey, L. Chase Smith, Kien Tran, Babs Mondschein, Yao Odamtten, Leonardo Martinez-Diaz, Drika Makariev, Valera Zakharov, Florence Zakharov, Ariel Linet, Ben Wyskida, Daniel Willi- ford, Jesse Burchfield, Jessica Upson, Nathalie Jones, Nicho- las Sanchez, Allison Rooney, Rex Norton, Hilda Norton, Jens Maier, Paul Burow, Santani Teng, Thomas Kwong, Stefanie Graeter, Susan Elliott Sim, Tom Waidzunas, Olivia Iordanescu, James Dawson, Maurice van den Dobbelsteen, Thomas Gur- ney, Jurjen van Rees, and the many other people who helped out along the way. Most importantly, I am thankful for the boundless support of my family: Patti Zehner, Tom Zehner, Robby Zehner, Aaron Norton, Sabin Blake, and Randy Shannon. All errors in judgment, content, or otherwise lie with me. Acknowledgments xiii Introduction: Unraveling the Spectacle The world will not evolve past its current state of crisis by using the same thinking that created the situation. –Albert Einstein If the title of this book makes you a little suspi- cious of what I’m up to, then all is well. We’ll get along just fine. That’s because the dirty secrets ahead aren’t the kind you can be told (you prob- ably wouldn’t believe me anyway), but rather are the kind you must be shown. But even then, I don’t expect you to accept all of my particu- lar renderings. Ahead you’ll see that this certainly isn’t a book for alternative energy. Neither is it a book against it. In fact, we won’t be talking in simplistic terms of for and against, left and right, good and evil. I wouldn’t dare bludgeon you with a litany of en- vironmental truths when I suspect you’d rather we consider the far more intriguing questions of how such truths are made. Ultimately, this is a book of shades. This is a book for you and others who like to think.