Dynamics of Assertive Labour Movementism in Ethiopia: Organised Labour, Unrest and Wages in a Socio-Historical Perspective

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Dynamics of Assertive Labour Movementism in Ethiopia: Organised Labour, Unrest and Wages in a Socio-Historical Perspective UNIVERSITÀ DI PAVIA Dottorato in Storia – XXX ciclo TESI IN COTUTELA CON UNIVERSITY OF BASEL PhD Programme in African Studies Dynamics of Assertive Labour Movementism in Ethiopia: Organised Labour, Unrest and Wages in a Socio-Historical Perspective A dissertation submitted to the Department of Political and Social Sciences of the University of Pavia and the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences of the University of Basel in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Presented by: Samuel Andreas Admasie Under the Supervision of: Massimo Zaccaria, Università di Pavia Elisio Macamo, University of Basel Basel 2019 Buchbinderei Bommer Original document stored on the publication server of the Uniyersity of Basel edoc.unibas.ch This is to certify that this doctoral dissertation has been approved by the Department of Political and Social Sciences, University of Pavia and the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Basel, upon the formal request of Massimo Zaccaria and Elisio Macamo. Pavia, July 2, 2018. ii Acknowledgements The research presented in this dissertation has been supported by funding from the University of Pavia, the University of Basel, and the Freiwillige Akademische Gesellschaft Basel. I am deeply grateful for this. I am thankful to the Department of Political and Social Sciences of the University of Pavia, the Centre for African Studies of the University of Basel, and the Graduate School of Social Sciences of the University of Basel for all the support they have extended to me. I am also grateful to the International Institute of Social History, for which I have been working since 2013 and which has hosted collections and conducted digitisation projects which have been essential to this dissertation; and to the Department of Political Science and International Relations of Addis Ababa University, which hosted me for five semesters, facilitated my access to the archives on which much of this dissertation is based on, and gave me the delightful opportunity to teach members of a talented new generation social scientists. The Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies of the University of Hargeisa also deserves a mention in this regard, as does the International Graduate School North-South, and the African Studies Centre Leiden. I would like to express my gratitude to my supervisors, Prof Massimo Zaccaria and Prof Elisio Macamo, for their kind support, guidance and patience; my supervisor at Addis Ababa University, Prof Kassahun Berhanu; and Dr Stefano Bellucci, Prof Uoldelul Chelati Dirar, and Dr Yeraswork Admassie, who either reviewed or commented on dissertational drafts, or served on my doctoral committee. I am immensely grateful to Dr Günter Schmidt-Gess, Virginie Gallati, and Dr Manuela Rossini, at the universities of Basel and Pavia for all their kind assistance. I would also like to thank Prof Pierluigi Valsecchi and Prof Marina Tesoro at the University of Pavia; Dr Veit Arlt and Dr Julia Büchele at the University of Basel; Dr Fekade Terefe, Prof Shiferaw Bekele, Dr Girma Negash, and Dr Abdiwasa Abdilahi Bade at Addis Ababa University; everyone at the International Institute of Social History, including, but not limited to, Marien van der Heijden, Jacqueline Rutte and Prof Marcel van der Linden; Kiflu Tadesse, Dr Alemu Abebe, Dawi Ibrahim, Hailu Ourgessa, Getachew Aberra, Demmelash Tebekew, Beyene Solomon, and Geresu Tufa, for being so generous with their time and so earnest in their recollections; Abrhaley Tesfagergs, Belayhun Hailu, and Meriam Daniel for research assistance; Mattis Jalakas for technical assistance with statistical analysis; Dr Azeb Amha, Dr Harry Wels, Michael Weldeghiorghis Tedla, Ella Verkaik, and Maaike Westra at the African Studies Centre Leiden; Biniyam Negash, Berhanu Deriba, iii Masho Legesse, Tewabech Kifle, and Zenebech Egual at the Confederation of Ethiopian Trade Unions; Girma Sheleme Sebsebe, Mulugeta Eshetu Abegaz, Sined Gulelet, Ayelech Habte, Enatalem Andarge, Meseret Wendimu, Adisalem Tafesse, and Bizunesh at the Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs; Mestawet Feyissa and Etsgenet Melaku at MoLSA library; Issayas Tesfamariam and Lisa Miller at the Hoover Institution Library and Archives; Jim Sam, who so helpfully reproduced and sent me digital recordings of Tom Killion's interviews; Jacques Rodriguez at the ILO historical archives; Dr Mark McQuinn at SOAS, University of London; Dr Haley Swedlund; Prof Fouad Makki; Prof John Markakis; and last, but certainly not least, I would like to extend my immense gratefulness to my family, friends, and comrades. iv To Carin and Daniel v Contents 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Background and rationale ..................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Objective ............................................................................................................................... 6 1.3 Focus and scope .................................................................................................................... 7 1.4 Research problem and questions ........................................................................................... 7 1.5 Research design, methods and sources ................................................................................. 8 1.6 Structure .............................................................................................................................. 12 1.7 Point of departure ................................................................................................................ 13 1.8 Research process, evolution and revisions ......................................................................... 16 1.9 Definitions, assumptions and propositions ......................................................................... 18 1.10 Scientific importance and impact ..................................................................................... 22 2. Theoretical considerations and assessment of the literature ..................................................... 24 2.1 Conceptualising labour movements .................................................................................... 24 2.2 Dynamics of organised labour ............................................................................................ 25 2.2.1 Functions ...................................................................................................................... 25 2.2.2 Establishing orientation ............................................................................................... 28 2.3 Practices: labour unrest ....................................................................................................... 31 2.3.2 Outcomes of unrest ...................................................................................................... 32 2.3.1 Causes of unrest ........................................................................................................... 34 2.3.3 Reciprocities ................................................................................................................ 37 2.3.4 Establishing position: alternative determinants of wages ............................................ 38 2.4 Labour and trade union movements in Africa .................................................................... 41 2.5 The Ethiopian labour movement in the literature ............................................................... 44 3. Setting the context..................................................................................................................... 53 3.1 Social and historical setting ................................................................................................ 53 3.2 Surpluses and labour regimes in evolution ......................................................................... 56 3.2.1 Surpluses in Ethiopia ................................................................................................... 57 3.2.2 The legal regime .......................................................................................................... 61 3.2.3 Attendant practices....................................................................................................... 64 3.2.4 Labour conditions ........................................................................................................ 64 3.3 Wage labour and manufacturing in the Ethiopian political economy ................................ 66 3.3.1 Plans and ambitions ..................................................................................................... 67 3.3.2 Outcomes ..................................................................................................................... 70 3.3.3 The wage workers ........................................................................................................ 73 4. Organisation, movement and orientation: first cycle ................................................................ 76 4.1 Emergence and early times ................................................................................................. 76 4.2 External influences and the emergence of a labour bureaucracy ........................................ 81 4.3 Achievements and obstacles ............................................................................................... 87 4.4
Recommended publications
  • Constructing Labour Regionalism in Europe and the Americas, 1920S–1970S*
    IRSH 58 (2013), pp. 39–70 doi:10.1017/S0020859012000752 r 2012 Internationaal Instituut voor Sociale Geschiedenis Constructing Labour Regionalism in Europe and the Americas, 1920s–1970s* M AGALY R ODRI´ GUEZ G ARCI´ A Vrije Universiteit Brussel/Research Foundation Flanders (FWO) Pleinlaan 2-5B 407d, 1050 Brussels, Belgium E-mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT: This article provides an analysis of the construction of labour regionalism between the 1920s and 1970s. By means of a comparative examination of the supranational labour structures in Europe and the Americas prior to World War II and of the decentralized structure of the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU), I attempt to defend the argument that regionalism was a labour leaders’ construct that responded to three issues: the quest for power among the largest trade-union organizations within the international trade-union movement; mutual distrust between labour leaders of large, middle-sized, and small unions from different regions; and (real or imaginary) common interests among labour leaders from the same region. These push-and-pull factors led to the construction of regional labour identifications that emphasized ‘‘otherness’’ in the world of international labour. A regional labour identity was intended to supplement, not undermine, national identity. As such, this study fills a lacuna in the scholarly literature on international relations and labour internationalism, which has given only scant attention to the regional level of international labour organization. This article provides a comparative analysis of the construction of regional identifications among labour circles prior to World War II, and to the formalization of the idea of regionalism within the International Con- federation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU1) after 1949.
    [Show full text]
  • Dynamics of Assertive Labour Movementism in Ethiopia: Organised Labour, Unrest and Wages in a Socio-Historical Perspective
    UNIVERSITÀ DI PAVIA Dottorato in Storia – XXX ciclo TESI IN COTUTELA CON UNIVERSITY OF BASEL PhD Programme in African Studies Dynamics of Assertive Labour Movementism in Ethiopia: Organised Labour, Unrest and Wages in a Socio-Historical Perspective Presented by: Samuel Andreas Admasie Under the Supervision of: Massimo Zaccaria, Università di Pavia Elisio Macamo, University of Basel Acknowledgements The research presented in this dissertation has been supported by funding from the University of Pavia, the University of Basel, and the Freiwillige Akademische Gesellschaft Basel. I am deeply grateful for this. I am thankful to the Department of Political and Social Sciences of the University of Pavia, the Centre for African Studies of the University of Basel, and the Graduate School of Social Sciences of the University of Basel for all the support they have extended to me. I am also grateful to the International Institute of Social History, for which I have been working since 2013 and which has hosted collections and conducted digitisation projects which have been essential to this dissertation. I am also grateful to the Department of Political Science and International Relations of Addis Ababa University, which hosted me for five semesters, facilitated my access to the archives on which much of this dissertation is based on, and gave me the delightful opportunity to teach members of a new generation of talented social scientists. The Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies of the University of Hargeisa also deserves a mention in this regard, as does the International Graduate School North­South, and the African Studies Centre Leiden. I would like to express my gratitude to my supervisors, Prof Massimo Zaccaria and Prof Elisio Macamo, for their kind support, guidance and patience; my supervisor at Addis Ababa University, Prof Kassahun Berhanu; and Dr Stefano Bellucci, Prof Uoldelul Chelati Dirar, and Dr Yeraswork Admassie, who either reviewed or commented on dissertational drafts, or served on my doctoral committee.
    [Show full text]
  • William and Ann Kemsley Papers
    THE WILLIAM AND ANN KEMSLEY COLLECTION Papers, 1943-1961 4.5 linear feet Accession Number 943 L.C. Number MS The papers of William and Ann Kemsley were placed in the Archives of Labor and Urban Affairs in March of 1980 by William and Ann Kemsley. and were opened for research in June of 1983. Additional material was opened for research in June of 2002. William Kemsley was born in Brandon, Manitoba, Canada on May 11, 1908. Mr. Kemsley moved to the United States in 1920. He became active in the trade union movement as early as 1932 and joined the UAW-CIO in 1937. He served as plant chairman of the Detroit United Auto Workers Westside Local 174, and held other offices including local organizer and local union education director. In 1945, Kemsley went to Germany as a labor specialist in the Manpower Division of the Office of Military Government, U.S. (OMGUS). The following year he returned to the U.S. to become education director of the Michigan CIO Council. Mr. Kemsley went to Paris in 1952 as a staff member of the Ecomomic Cooperation Administration where he served until 1954. In 1954, he was appointed representative of the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU) to the United Nations. Mr. Kemsley held this position until his retirement in May 1961. Ann Kemsley, nee Terech, was born in Minneapolis on October 29, 1918. She is Mr. Kemsley's second wife. Mrs. Kemsley is a former editor of the Wisconsin CIO News and worked as a journalist for numerous trade union papers.
    [Show full text]
  • The TUC and the Histadrut, 1945-1982: a Problematic Relationship
    The TUC and the Histadrut, 1945-1982: a problematic relationship Ronnie Fraser Royal Holloway College Doctor of Philosophy 1 Declaration of Authorship I, Ronnie Fraser hereby declare that this thesis and the work presented in it is entirely my own. Where I have consulted the work of others, this is always clearly stated. Signed: ______________________ Date: ________________________ 2 The TUC and the Histadrut, 1945-1982: a problematic relationship Ronnie Fraser Abstract The main purpose of this study is to explore and explain the attitude of the British trade union movement towards Zionism and Israel and how and why it has changed over the years. There have been several studies that concentrate on the attitude of the British Labour Party towards Israel but none that focus on the relationship between the British trade union movement and its Israeli counterpart. Although the unions and the Labour Party had a close relationship, their policies were not always the same with regard to Israel. The relationship between the TUC and the Histadrut, rooted in the 1920s and 1930s, changed fundamentally after the creation of Israel in 1948. This research analyses how that relationship developed and why. Key factors included the attitude of the TUC General Secretaries, the TUC's relationship with the Foreign Office, the context of the international trade union movement, Cold War politics, Britain's post-war role in the Middle East, and the (sometimes surprising) approach of individual trades union leaders such as Jack Jones. The four wars between Israel and the Arabs between 1948-82 also played a part. One constant throughout most of this study is the pro-Zionist stance of the Parliamentary Labour Party compared with the much more ambivalent TUC-Histadrut relations.
    [Show full text]
  • La Force Motrice
    LA FORCE MOTRICE Le Force motrice Alors que la structure tripartite qui fait la spécificité de l’Organisation internationale du Travail depuis sa création en 1919, associant gouver- nements et organisations d’employeurs et de travailleurs, est souvent évoquée, la façon dont fonctionne réellement le tripartisme est très peu documentée. Aujourd’hui, on se demande même souvent quelle est la «valeur ajoutée» des partenaires sociaux dans les discussions et les NAISSANCE ET ÉVOLUTION décisions en matière de politique du travail et de questions sociales. De plus, le lien fondamental entre la justice sociale et la paix industrielle — et donc la paix en général — est souvent négligé. Or le monde du DU TRIPARTISME – RÔLE travail n’est pas une bulle isolée et ne peut être traité comme telle. Ce livre tente de montrer à quel point il est étroitement lié au contexte économique et politique mondial et dans quelle mesure la coopération tripartite peut influencer ce contexte. Il explique aussi comment l’agen- DU GROUPE DES TRAVAILLEURS da du travail contribue à renforcer et promouvoir les droits humains universellement reconnus. L’auteur nous fait revivre un siècle d’histoire de l’OIT sous l’angle du Groupe des travailleurs. Les objectifs et les principes directeurs de la première organisation multilatérale moderne établie lors des négocia- tions du Traité de paix en 1919 à Paris ont été définis par les syndicats Kari Tapiola et les réformateurs sociaux. Mais c’est essentiellement le Groupe des travailleurs qui fait évoluer le socle sur lequel repose l’ensemble des normes internationales du travail. Parallèlement, la justice sociale implique des négociations et accords directs entre les syndicats et les employeurs.
    [Show full text]
  • The Driving Force BIRTH and EVOLUTION of TRIPARTISM – ROLE the ILO WORKERS’ GROUP the ILO in 1991 and Was Appointed Deputy Director-General in 1996
    THE DRIVING FORCE The Driving Force Beyond stating that the International Labour Organization has, since 1919, had a unique tripartite structure, with the participation of govern- BIRTH AND EVOLUTION ments and employers’ and workers’ organizations, not much has been written about how tripartism actually works. In our days, the question is even sometimes asked: what is the “added value” of the social partners OF TRIPARTISM – ROLE in discussing and deciding on labour and social policies? Equally, the fundamental link between social justice and industrial peace — and indeed peace in general — is frequently overlooked. However, the world of labour is not an isolated area and cannot be treated in a vacuum. This OF THE ILO WORKERS’ GROUP book tries to show how tightly intermeshed it is with the world economy and political circumstances and how tripartite cooperation influences them. It also shows how this labour agenda has crystallized and promoted universally recognized human rights. It recounts the story of the hundred years of the ILO from the perspec- tive of the Workers’ Group. The goals and guiding principles of the first Kari Tapiola modern multilateral organization set up at the Paris Peace negotiations in 1919 were determined by the trade unions and social reformers. The body of International Labour Standards lies on the foundation which, above all, the Workers’ Group has advanced. At the same time, social justice also calls for direct negotiations and agreement between the trade unions and the employers. The book gives examples of the dynamics at work between the three groups of the ILO and explains how, over time, the force that has driven its agenda has been the Workers’ BIRTH AND EVOLUTION OF TRIPARTISM – ROLE THE ILO WORKERS’ GROUP Group.
    [Show full text]
  • La Fuerza Motriz ESP.Pdf 1 07.06.19 16:03
    PRINT-COVER La Fuerza Motriz ESP.pdf 1 07.06.19 16:03 LA FUERZA MOTRIZ La Fuerza Motriz Aparte de afirmar que la Organización Internacional del Trabajo tiene, desde 1919, una estructura tripartita única, gracias a la participación de gobiernos y organizaciones de empleadores y trabajadores, hasta la fecha NACIMIENTO Y EVOLUCIÓN no se había escrito mucho sobre cómo funciona el tripartismo. Incluso hoy día, a veces, se sigue planteando la pregunta: ¿qué «valor añadido» supone que los agentes sociales debatan y decidan las políticas laborales DEL TRIPARTISMO – EL PAPEL y sociales? Igualmente, se suele pasar por alto el vínculo fundamental entre la justicia social y la paz laboral —y, por añadidura, la paz en general. Y, sin embargo, el mundo del trabajo no es un ámbito aislado y no DEL GRUPO DE LOS TRABAJADORES puede tratarse como si fuera una burbuja flotando en el vacío. Este libro trata de mostrar cuán estrechamente ligado está con la economía y las circunstancias políticas mundiales, y cómo la cooperación tripartita EN LA OIT influye en ellas. También muestra cómo esta agenda laboral ha cristaliza- do y defendido los derechos humanos universales reconocidos. Hace un repaso a la historia de los cien años de la OIT desde la perspecti- va del Grupo de los Trabajadores. Los objetivos y los principios fundamen- tales de la primera organización multilateral moderna establecida en las negociaciones de la Paz de París en 1919 fueron marcados por sindicatos Kari Tapiola y reformadores sociales. El corpus de Normas Internacionales del Trabajo se nutre de los cimientos, que ha establecido, sobre todo, el Grupo de los Trabajadores.
    [Show full text]
  • Uluslararasi Sendikalar Konfederasyonu Ve Sendikal Stratejileri
    T. C. ULUDAĞ ÜNİVERSİTESİ SOSYAL BİLİMLER ENSTİTÜSÜ ÇALIŞMAEKONOMİSİ VE ENDÜSTRİ İLİŞKİLERİ ANABİLİM DALI ÇALIŞMAEKONOMİSİ VE ENDÜSTRİ İLİŞKİLERİ BİLİM DALI ULUSLARARASI SENDİKAL HAREKET İÇİNDE YENİ BİR OLUŞUM ÇABASI: ULUSLARARASI SENDİKALAR KONFEDERASYONU VE SENDİKAL STRATEJİLERİ YÜKSEK LİSANS TEZİ Ceyhun GÜLER BURSA - 2014 T. C. ULUDAĞ ÜNİVERSİTESİ SOSYAL BİLİMLER ENSTİTÜSÜ ÇALIŞMAEKONOMİSİ VE ENDÜSTRİ İLİŞKİLERİ ANABİLİM DALI ÇALIŞMAEKONOMİSİ VE ENDÜSTRİ İLİŞKİLERİ BİLİM DALI ULUSLARARASI SENDİKAL HAREKET İÇİNDE YENİ BİR OLUŞUM ÇABASI: ULUSLARARASI SENDİKALAR KONFEDERASYONU VE SENDİKAL STRATEJİLERİ (YÜKSEK LİSANS TEZİ) Ceyhun GÜLER Danışman: Prof. Dr. Aysen TOKOL BURSA - 2014 ÖZET Yazar Adı ve Soyadı : Ceyhun GÜLER Üniversite : Uludağ Üniversitesi Enstitü : Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Anabilim Dalı : Çalışma Ekonomisi ve Endüstri İlişkileri Bilim Dalı : Çalışma Ekonomisi ve Endüstri İlişkileri Tezin Niteliği : Yüksek Lisans Tezi Sayfa Sayısı : XXIII + 219 Mezuniyet Tarihi : 16 / 07 / 2014 Tez Danışmanı : Prof. Dr. Aysen TOKOL ULUSLARARASI SENDİKAL HAREKET İÇİNDE YENİ BİR OLUŞUM ÇABASI: ULUSLARARASI SENDİKALAR KONFEDERASYONU VE SENDİKAL STRATEJİLERİ Küreselleşmenin ve neo-liberal politikaların etkilerini arttırmasıyla birlikte emek hareketinin uluslararası örgütlülüğü her zamankinden daha önemli hale gelmiştir. Kapitalizmin uluslararasılaşması ve yeniden yapılanması küreselleşmenin önemli unsurlarından biridir. Sermayenin küreselleşmesi, sendikaların uluslararası alanda oluşturacakları birliktelikleri çok daha önemli hale getirmiştir.
    [Show full text]
  • Images Du Travail, Travail Des Images, 2 | 2016 L’Institut International Des Films Du Travail, 1953-1972
    Images du travail, travail des images 2 | 2016 Les ouvriers et la photographie : de 1945 à nos jours L’Institut international des films du travail, 1953-1972. Formation syndicale et propagande par le cinéma dans le contexte de la guerre froide The International Labour Film Institute (1953-1972). Workers’ Education and Propaganda through Film in the Context of the Cold War Françoise F. Laot Édition électronique URL : https://journals.openedition.org/itti/1234 DOI : 10.4000/itti.1234 Éditeur Université de Poitiers Référence électronique Françoise F. Laot, « L’Institut international des films du travail, 1953-1972. Formation syndicale et propagande par le cinéma dans le contexte de la guerre froide », Images du travail, travail des images [En ligne], 2 | 2016, mis en ligne le 01 septembre 2016, consulté le 26 juillet 2021. URL : http:// journals.openedition.org/itti/1234 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/itti.1234 Ce document a été généré automatiquement le 26 juillet 2021. Images du travail, travail des images L’Institut international des films du travail, 1953-1972. Formation syndicale... 1 L’Institut international des films du travail, 1953-1972. Formation syndicale et propagande par le cinéma dans le contexte de la guerre froide The International Labour Film Institute (1953-1972). Workers’ Education and Propaganda through Film in the Context of the Cold War Françoise F. Laot 1 Cet article entend contribuer à éclairer la relation qu’ont entretenue cinéma et syndicalisme dans l’histoire. Il se centre sur l’activité d’un institut international, l’ILFI (International Labour Film Institute) issu du mouvement syndical mondial, qui a consacré son activité à l’éducation ouvrière par le cinéma, notamment, en organisant cinq festivals en différents endroits du monde.
    [Show full text]
  • 16665015.Pdf
    University of Warwick institutional repository: http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap/56529 This thesis is made available online and is protected by original copyright. Please scroll down to view the document itself. Please refer to the repository record for this item for information to help you to cite it. Our policy information is available from the repository home page. The International Confederation of Free Trade Unions: Structure, Ideology and Capacity to Act by Rebecca Anne Gumbrell-McCormick A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Warwick, Department of Sociology June 2001 TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract List of Abbreviations Chapter 1 Introduction and Overview: The Study and Practice of International Trade Unionism 1 Chapter 2 The ICFTU as an Institution: Structure, Ideology and Resources 38 Chapter 3 The Contested Identity of the ICFTU: Between Ideology and Unity in Europe and the World 84 Chapter 4 The ICFTU in the Field: Regional Organisation and Human Rights 115 Chapter 5 The ICFTU in Action: The Campaign for Women's Equality and the Struggle against Apartheid 173 Chapter 6 The ICFTU within the International System: Industrial and Political Action in the Global Economy 218 Chapter 7 Conclusion: The ICFTU's Capacity to Act 260 List of Interviews 267 Bibliography 275 .. n Meinem guten Geist, meinem bess 'ren Jch! (from Widmung, by Friedrich Ruckert and Robert Schumann) iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am profoundly grateful to all the women and men of the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions, the International Trade Secretariats, national centres and individual trade unions, and to all the academics and other observers of the international labour movement who shared their memories and observations with me.
    [Show full text]