Town Planning Board Paper No. 10175
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TPB Paper No. 10175 For consideration by the Town Planning Board on 27.9.2016 DRAFT ABERDEEN & AP LEI CHAU OUTLINE ZONING PLAN NO. S/H15/30 CONSIDERATION OF REPRESENTATIONS NO. TPB/R/S/H15/30-R1 TO R607 AND COMMENTS NO. TPB/R/S/H15/30-C1 TO C16 Representers Commenters Subject of Representation (No. TPB/R/S/H15/30-) (No. TPB/R/S/H15/30-) Amendment Item A - Total: 607 Total: 16 Rezoning of a site at Lee Nam Road, Ap Lei Chau Support (6) Support R8 to R607, Object R1 fronting the East Lamma R1 to R6: Individuals to R7 Channel from “Other C1: Designing Hong Kong Specified Uses” annotated No objection (1) Limited “(Cargo Handling Area)” R7: Individual (“OU(Cargo Handling Related to R16 Area)”), “Government, Oppose (597) C2: Paul ZIMMERMAN Institution or Community” R8: CHAN Judy Kapui (Southern District Councillor) and “Industrial” (“I”) to (Southern District “Residential (Group A)4” Councillor) Related to R1 to R600 (“R(A)4”) C3: CHAI Man-hon, TSUI R13: South Horizons Concern Yuen-wa, LO Kin-hei, AU Group Nok-hin (Southern District Councillors) R15: People Power Related to R1 R16: Designing Hong Kong C4: CHAN Judy Kapui (Southern Limited District Councillor) R571: CHAN Kenneth Ka-lok Related to R8 (ex-Legislative C5: LAM Kai-fai (Chairman of Councillor) District Development and Housing Committee, R9 to R12, R14, R17 to R570, Southern District Council) R572 to R604: Individuals Related to R605 Comment (3) C6: South Horizons Estate R605: South Horizons Estate Owners’ Committee Owners’ Committee C7: South Horizons Concern Group R606 and 607: Individuals C8: Individual Related to R336 C9: Individual Related to R421 C10: Individual - 2 - Related to R518 C11: Individual Related Representations Not Specified C12 to C15: Individuals Related to R586 C16: Individual Amendment Item B - Total: 36 Rezoning of a strip of land fronting the Ap Lei Chau Support (10) West Industrial Area from R8: CHAN Judy Kapui “OU(Cargo Handling (Southern District Area)” to “Open Space” Councillor) R1 to R3, R9, R10, R12, R598 to R600: Individuals Oppose (26) R571: CHAN Kenneth Ka-lok (ex-Legislative Councillor) R572 to R583 and R585 to R597: Individuals Amendment Item C1 - Total: 19 Rezoning of the southern portion of the Ap Lei Chau Support (5) West Industrial Area from R8: CHAN Judy Kapui “I” to “Other Specified (Southern District Uses” annotated Councillor) “Business(3)” (“OU(B)3”) R1, R2, R9 and R10: Amendment Item C2 - Individuals Rezoning of the northern portion of the Ap Lei Chau Oppose (14) West Industrial Area from R591 to R604: Individuals “I” to “Other Specified Uses” annotated “Business(4)” (“OU(B)4”) Note : A CD-ROM containing all representers’ and commenters’ submissions is enclosed at Annex V [for TPB Members only]. The names of all representers and commenters can be found at Attachments A and B of Annex IV or at the Board’s website at http://www.info.gov.hk/tpb/en/plan_making/S_H15_30.html. A full set of the representers’ and commenters’ submissions is also deposited at the Secretariat of the Board for Members’ inspection. - 3 - 1. Introduction 1.1 On 24.12.2015, the draft Aberdeen & Ap Lei Chau Outline Zoning Plan (OZP) No. S/H15/30 (Annex I) was exhibited for public inspection under section 5 of the Town Planning Ordinance (the Ordinance). The amendments are set out in the Schedule of Amendments at Annex II. The amendments involve the following: Item A – Rezoning of a site at Lee Nam Road, Ap Lei Chau fronting the East Lamma Channel from “Other Specified Uses” annotated “(Cargo Handling Area)” (“OU(Cargo Handling Area)”), “Government, Institution or Community” and “Industrial” (“I”) to “Residential (Group A)4” (“R(A)4”) with a building height restriction of 110mPD. Item B – Rezoning of a strip of land fronting the Ap Lei Chau West Industrial Area from “OU(Cargo Handling Area)” to “Open Space”. Item C1 – Rezoning of the southern portion of the Ap Lei Chau West Industrial Area from “I” to “Other Specified Uses” annotated “Business(3)” (“OU(B)3”) with a building height restriction of 100mPD. Item C2 – Rezoning of the northern portion of the Ap Lei Chau West Industrial Area from “I” to “Other Specified Uses” annotated “Business(4)” (“OU(B)4”) with a building height restriction of 115mPD. 1.2 During the two-month exhibition period, a total of 607 representations were received. On 15.4.2016, the Town Planning Board (the Board) published the representations for three weeks for public comments. 16 comments, all related to the representations for Amendment Item A, were received. 1.3 On 5.8.2016, the Town Planning Board (the Board) agreed to consider the representations (R1 to R607) and comments (C1 to C16) collectively in one group. This paper is to provide the Board with information for consideration of the representations and comments. The representers and commenters have been invited to attend the meeting in accordance with section 6B(3) of the Ordinance. 2. Background 2.1 It was stated in the 2013 Policy Address that the Government would adopt a multi-pronged approach to build up land reserve with a view to meeting housing and other development needs. In order to increase land supply, the Government has carried out land use reviews with a view to identifying land with the potential to be rezoned for residential use. In this regard, part of the site at Lee Nam Road currently occupied by the Hong Kong School of Motoring (HKSM) was identified as one of the potential housing sites. - 4 - 2.2 Taking into account the relatively isolated location of the Ap Lei Chau West area and the changing circumstances of the Area, the remaining part of the site currently occupied by HKSM was proposed for open space use to serve the workers, visitors and residents of the nearby existing and future developments in the area. 2.3 The Ap Lei Chau West Industrial Area has been undergoing relatively active transformation to business use. On 14.8.2015, the Board considered the “2014 Area Assessments of Industrial Land in the Territory” (2014 Area Assessments) and agreed to the rezoning of the Ap Lei Chau West Industrial Area from “I” to “OU(B)” to facilitate the continuous transformation of the industrial area to business use and to provide more flexibility in the use of the land in the area. 2.4 Various Government departments have reviewed and confirmed the technical feasibility of the above proposed amendments in terms of traffic, environmental, sewerage, drainage, water supply, risk, visual and air ventilation impacts. 2.5 The proposed amendments together with the views of the Southern District Council (SDC) were submitted to the Metro Planning Committee (MPC) of the Board for consideration on 4.12.2015. After considering the relevant factors, including housing policy, the imminent need for land supply, public views, objections from the SDC as well as the technical comments from Government departments concerned, MPC agreed to the proposed amendment items as well as some technical amendments to the Notes of the OZP. 2.6 The draft OZP was amended accordingly and exhibited on 24.12.2015 for public inspection. The relevant MPC paper No. 14/15 and the minutes of the MPC meeting are deposited at the Board’s Secretariat for Members’ inspection. The MPC Paper and minutes are also available at the Board’s website. 3. Consultation with Southern District Council 3.1 Prior to the submission of the proposed zoning amendments to MPC for consideration, Planning Department (PlanD) on 18.5.2015 consulted the District Development and Environment Committee (DDEC) of SDC on the proposed rezoning of Lee Nam Road housing site (i.e. Amendment Item A). PlanD and Transport Department (TD) attended a local forum co-organized by the Chairman of DDEC and SDC members on 20.5.2015. SDC’s and the local’s views were reported to the MPC when the proposed amendments to the OZP were submitted on 4.12.2015. 3.2 Upon request by SDC members, PlanD, TD and Electrical and Mechanical Services Department (EMSD) on 23.12.2015 attended the South Horizons Residents Forum. All participants of the Forum objected to the proposed rezoning of Lee Nam Road site for residential use (i.e. Amendment Item A) mainly on grounds of overloading the densely populated island and worsening the traffic situation at Ap Lei Chau. - 5 - 3.3 Upon the publication of the draft OZP on 24.12.2015, the District Development and Housing Committee (DDHC) of SDC was consulted on 1.2.2016. DDHC objected to the proposed rezoning of the site at Lee Nam Road for private residential use and passed the motion that “the DDHC strongly reprimanded the Development Bureau (DEVB) for having submitted the agenda ‘Proposed Rezoning of a Piece of Government Land at Lee Nam Road, Ap Lei Chau for Residential Development’ to the Town Planning Board meeting for discussion and approval on 4.12.2015 during the District Council (DC) suspension period, without providing sufficient information to consult the DC. This Committee would remain steadfast in opposition to the DEVB’s proposal, in the lack of long-term and comprehensive planning and supporting facilities, for building 1,416 residential flats at the site of the Hong Kong School of Motoring, Lee Nam Road, which would largely increase residential population in the densely populated Ap lei Chau.” The minutes of the SDC consultation on 1.2.2016 is at Annex III. 3.4 During the two-month OZP exhibition period, some SDC Members have submitted representations which are incorporated in paragraph 4 below.