Supported in Ms Kohere's Rebuttal Evidence?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Additional SSMW sought Supported subsequently by Ms Kohere (and evidence Supported in Ms Kohere's primary Supported in Ms Kohere's rebuttal recommendation is based Ms Kohere's final Number Name Submission evidence? evidence? on)? recommendation Now supported as SSMW based on HNZ's submission, Ngati Paoa's oral evidence at the hearing and indications they support HNZ's submission. New Zealand Historic Places Trust Add Te Routu o Ureia, at Erin Point (Register Extent to reflect HNZ's 371-111 (Heritage New Zealand) Pouhere Taonga #7773) to the schedule. No No as not supported by Mana Whenua submission. New SSMW New Zealand Historic Places Trust Add Tauwhare, Rewiti (Register #7361) to the 371-112 (Heritage New Zealand) Pouhere Taonga schedule. PAUP notified SSMW SSMW 046 Mana Whenua may still indicate support for HNZ's submission, currently confirming with Te New Zealand Historic Places Trust Add Kopironui, Rewiti (Register #7174 and Runanga o Ngati Whatua ki 371-113 (Heritage New Zealand) Pouhere Taonga #7481) to the schedule. No No as not supported by Mana Whenua Kaipara. TBC Now supported as SSMW based on HNZ's submission, Ngati Paoa's oral evidence at the hearing and indications they support HNZ's submission. New Zealand Historic Places Trust Add Ngāti Paoa Urupa, at Mount Wellington Extent to reflect HNZ's 371-114 (Heritage New Zealand) Pouhere Taonga (Register #7220) to the schedule. No No as not supported by Mana Whenua submission. New SSMW Now supported as SSMW based on HNZ's submission, Ngati Paoa's oral evidence at the hearing and indications they Ms Kohere supported adding this as a SVMW support HNZ's submission. New Zealand Historic Places Trust Add O Peretu, North Shore (Register #7231) to based on Ngati Paoa's evidence, and she also Extent to reflect HNZ's 371-115 (Heritage New Zealand) Pouhere Taonga the schedule. No supported retaining a 100m buffer for this site. submission. New SSMW Refer notes below regarding submission from Te Akitai Amend maps to identify the entire extent of seeking scheduling of Maunga, maunga across the Auckland Isthmus as sites and that the extent reflect Nga and places of significance to Mana Whenua, not Mana Whenua o Tamaki just specific parts of the maunga (for example - a Makaurau Collective Redress, 3085-15 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited burial cave). Yes - as SVMW Maunga extents. New SSMW Additional SSMW sought Supported subsequently by Ms Kohere (and evidence Supported in Ms Kohere's primary Supported in Ms Kohere's rebuttal recommendation is based Ms Kohere's final Number Name Submission evidence? evidence? on)? recommendation Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Identify Orakei and Okahu Bay within the recommendation to retain as 3085-34 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Include Waiariki (spring and former watercourse between 16 Waterloo Quadrant and 15 Eden 3085-131 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited Crescent) in the schedule. PAUP notified SSMW SSMW 047 Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Include Rerengaoraiti/Point Britomart in the recommendation to retain as 3085-132 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Include Te Ana a Rangi (a cave under what is recommendation to retain as 3085-133 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited now Melville Park) in the schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Include Te Tatua o Riukiuta (Three Kings recommendation to retain as 3085-134 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited Mountain) in the schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Include Onehunga (especially the location of the 19th Century Ngati Whatua village at the foot of 3085-135 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited Princes St) in the schedule. PAUP notified SSMW SSMW 048 Include Te Pupu o Kawau (Tahuna Torea, 3085-136 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited Tamaki River) in the schedule. PAUP notified SSMW SSMW 049 Include Te Wai o Rakataura (wetlands to south 3085-137 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited of Owairakai/Mt Albert) in the schedule. PAUP notified SSMW SSMW 050 Include Mataharehare (eastern border of first land gift to Crown by Ngati Whatua in Tamaki) in 3085-138 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited the schedule. PAUP notified SSMW SSMW 051 Include Kohimarama/Bastion Rock in the 3085-139 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited schedule. PAUP notified SSMW SSMW 052 Additional SSMW sought Supported subsequently by Ms Kohere (and evidence Supported in Ms Kohere's primary Supported in Ms Kohere's rebuttal recommendation is based Ms Kohere's final Number Name Submission evidence? evidence? on)? recommendation Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Include Tokiwhatinui (battle site near present recommendation to retain as 3085-140 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited Auckland Hospital) in the schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Further work needed to clarify extent of this existing SSMW in 3085-141 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited Include Opoutukeha (Cox's Bay) in the schedule. PAUP notified SSMW light of evidence at the hearing. SSMW 054 Include Te To Waka (Otahuhu portage) in the 3085-142 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited schedule. PAUP notified SSMW SSMW 055 Include Pou Hawaiki (sacred site, now Auckland NWoO (Mr Clay) to confirm College of Education car park building) in the location with the University of 3085-143 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited schedule. PAUP notified SSMW Auckland (Mr Brabant) SSMW 056 Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending Include burial sites on two central Auckland this confirmation, original residential properties [specific addresses not recommendation to retain as 3085-144 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited given] in the schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Include Te Tinana, Victoria Ave, Hobson Bay in recommendation to retain as 3085-145 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited the schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Include Waitaramoa, Hobson Bay in the 3085-146 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited schedule. PAUP notified SSMW SSMW 061 Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Include Onepu Whakatakataka, Hobson Point in recommendation to retain as 3085-147 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited the schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Additional SSMW sought Supported subsequently by Ms Kohere (and evidence Supported in Ms Kohere's primary Supported in Ms Kohere's rebuttal recommendation is based Ms Kohere's final Number Name Submission evidence? evidence? on)? recommendation Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original recommendation to retain as 3085-148 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited Include Orakeiiriora, Orakei in the schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Include Okahumatamomoe, Okahu Bay in the recommendation to retain as 3085-149 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Include Te Pokanoa a Tarahape, Orakei in the recommendation to retain as 3085-150 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being confirmed (and landowner issues being resolved/determination that SSMW overlay is the appropriate protection mechanism). Pending this confirmation, original Include Kohimarama Stream, Aiken Ave in the recommendation to retain as 3085-151 Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Maia Limited schedule. Yes - as SVMW SVMW is retained. SVMW Would support scheduling as SSMW subject to extent being