DOCSLIB.ORG

Using the Logsum As an Evaluation Measure: Literature and Case

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Using the Logsum As an Evaluation Measure: Literature and Case WORKING P A P E R Using the Logsum as an Evaluation Measure Literature and Case Study GERARD DE JONG, MARITS PIETERS, ANDREW DALY, IRMA GRAAFLAND, ERIC KROES, AND CARL KOOPMANS WR-275-AVV May 2005 Prepared for AVV Transport Research Centre This product is part of the RAND Europe working paper series. RAND working papers are intended to share researchers’ latest findings and to solicit additional peer review. This paper has been peer reviewed but not edited. Unless otherwise indicated, working papers can be quoted and cited without permission of the author, provided the source is clearly referred to as a working paper. RAND’s publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors. is a registered trademark. Preface The objective of the project ‘Using the logsum as an evaluation measure’ that RAND Europe carried out for the Transport Research Centre (AVV) of the Dutch Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management was to: Gain experience and weigh the advantages and disadvantages in a case study using both the classic cost-benefit analysis (CBA) approach and the logsum approach for project appraisal. This report presents the outcomes of both parts of this project, namely: • A literature review • A case study using the Dutch National Model System (LMS) for transport. This report was written for transport modellers and/or economists and other researchers with an interest in the assessment of transport projects. RAND Europe is an independent not-for-profit policy research organisation that serves the public interest by improving policymaking and informing public debate. This report has been peer-reviewed in accordance with RAND's quality assurance standards (see http://www.rand.org/about/standards/) and therefore may be represented as a RAND Europe product. For more information about RAND Europe or this document, please contact Gerard de Jong. Prof. dr. Gerard de Jong RAND Europe Newtonweg 1 2333 CP LEIDEN The Netherlands +31 721 524 51 51 [email protected] iii Logsums: Literature and Case Study RAND Europe Contents Preface........................................................................................................................ iii CHAPTER 1 Introduction.................................................................................... 1 1.1 Background and objective ................................................................................. 1 1.2 Phasing of the project........................................................................................ 1 1.3 Contents of this report ...................................................................................... 2 CHAPTER 2 Introduction to the main concepts................................................... 3 2.1 Consumer surplus ............................................................................................. 3 2.2 The logsum measure.......................................................................................... 6 CHAPTER 3 Review of papers on the theory of the logsum as an evaluation measure ...................................................................................................... 11 3.1 The early RUM literature................................................................................ 12 3.2 Income effect and taste variation ..................................................................... 13 3.3 Overview papers.............................................................................................. 14 3.4 Harris and Tanner (1974) ............................................................................... 14 3.5 Cochrane (1975) ............................................................................................. 15 3.6 Daly and Zachary (1976) ................................................................................ 16 3.7 Williams (1977) .............................................................................................. 17 3.8 McFadden (1978) ........................................................................................... 19 3.9 Ben-Akiva and Lerman (1979) ........................................................................ 19 3.10 McFadden (1981) ........................................................................................... 20 3.11 Small and Rosen (1981) .................................................................................. 22 3.12 Börsch-Supan (1990) ...................................................................................... 23 3.13 McFadden (1996) ........................................................................................... 23 3.14 Herriges and Kling (1999)............................................................................... 24 3.15 Karlström (2000)............................................................................................. 26 3.16 Bates (2003).................................................................................................... 27 3.17 von Haefen (2003).......................................................................................... 28 3.18 Cherchi, Polak and Hyman (2004) ................................................................. 29 3.19 Daly (2004)..................................................................................................... 30 CHAPTER 4 Review of papers on the application of the logsum as an evaluation measure .............................................................................................. 33 4.1 EXPEDITE consortium (2002)....................................................................... 33 iv RAND Europe Summary 4.2 Odeck, Rekdal and Hamre (2003) ...................................................................37 4.3 Castiglione, Freedman and Davidson (2003) ..................................................38 4.4 Ecorys Transport and 4cast, May 2004 ............................................................40 4.5 Gupta, Kalmanje and Kockelman (2004).........................................................41 4.6 Kalmanje and Kockelman (2004).....................................................................43 4.7 Koopmans and Kroes (2004) ...........................................................................45 4.8 De Raad (2004) ...............................................................................................46 4.9 RAND Europe (2004) .....................................................................................47 4.10 US Department of Transportation, Federal Highway Administration (2004?) ...........................................................................................................48 CHAPTER 5 Outcomes from the LMS case study............................................... 51 5.1 The ‘classic’ and the ‘improved classic’ method ................................................51 5.2 The logsum method.........................................................................................56 5.3 Comparing results of ‘classic’ and ’logsum’ methods.........................................63 CHAPTER 6 Summary, conclusions and recommendations ............................... 65 6.1 Summary and conclusions................................................................................65 6.2 Recommendations ...........................................................................................67 References................................................................................................................. 69 v CHAPTER 1 Introduction 1.1 Background and objective Transport infrastructure projects in The Netherlands are assessed ex ante by using cost- benefit analysis (CBA) procedures following the OEI-guidelines (CPB and NEI, 2000). The project benefits for travellers are incorporated in the form of changes in demand (e.g. from the Dutch national model system LMS or the regional models NRM) and changes in the generalised travel costs (using values of time from Stated Preference studies to monetised travel time savings), and applying the rule of half. The Transport Research Centre (AVV) of the Dutch Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management has commissioned RAND Europe to perform a study on the use of the logsum (change) as a measure of the change in consumer surplus that results from a transport infrastructure project. RAND Europe has also subcontracted Professor Carl Koopmans of SEO to join the project team. The objective of this project is to: Gain experience and weigh the advantages and disadvantages in a case study using both the classic CBA approach and the logsum approach for project appraisal. 1.2 Phasing of the project This project consists of two parts: 1. A review of the literature on the use of logsums as a measure of consumer surplus change in project assessment. 2. A case study with the LMS in which three methods are compared for a specific project (Rondje Randstad: additional high speed and intercity trains connecting the four main cities in the Randstad: Amsterdam, The Hague, Rotterdam and Utrecht): a. the classic CBA approach, 1 Logsums: Literature and Case Study RAND Europe b. the improved classic CBA approach (following the short term improvements described in Ecorys and 4Cast, 2004), c. and the logsum approach. 1.3 Contents of this report This report provides the outcomes of both parts. In chapter 2 the concept of consumer surplus is introduced first, followed by that of the logsum. This chapter gives the existing textbook representation. Subsequent chapters delve deeper into
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A-4E Finds New Home Tasked with Transferring the Craft
    7!1 7 Vol. 24, No. 6 Serving Marine Forces Pacific, MCB Hawaii, Ill Marine Expeditionary Forces, Hawaii and 1st Radio Battalion February 15, 1996 A-4E finds new home tasked with transferring the craft. It LC,p1. Steven Williams is the only unit in Hawaii with heavy-lift capability. The other mili- The Aviation Support Element and tary installations on the island don't Combat Service Support Group-3 have the aircraft to lift the jet, aboard MCB Hawaii teamed up according to Maj. Jesse E. Wrice, Monday to transfer a 7,000-pound ASE operations officer. Douglas A-4E Skyhawk from Naval The six leaders in the transfer pro- Air Station Barbers Point to ject surveyed the jet Jan. 22. to Dillingham Air Field. ensure the aircraft was safe to move. The aircraft was donated to the "We did all of our homework in Find what's got the dolphins Hawaiian Historical Aviation January so it would run smoothly in jumping. See B-1 for story. Foundation, a non-profit organiza- February," said Wrice. tion, Sept. 19 by the Navy's Fleet Before it was transferred, the jet's Composite Squadron 1. The nose gear door was removed and the Great Aloha Run squadron decommissioned in tail hook was dropped. Dropping the September 1993 leaving most of its tail hook allowed the belly bands to transportation aircraft to the National Naval sit flesh on the aircraft's stomach. Aviation Museum in Pensacola, Fla. The team also added 400 to 600 The 12th annual Great Aloha Following the down-size, HHAF put pounds of weight to the nose of the Run will be held Monday at 7 a.m.
    [Show full text]
  • The Washington Metro Transit Pouce: Keeping the Community Safe Interview with Daniel Hall
    The Washington Metro Transit PoUce: Keeping the Community Safe Interview with Daniel Hall Nicole White U.S. History, David Brandt 2/5/2005 statement of Purpose The purpose ofthis oral history project is to offer a personal account of the beginning years of the Washington Area Transit system and its police department, through an interview with retired Metro Transit Deputy Chief Police, Daniel Hall. Hall was one of the first members of the Washington Metro Transit Police Department and his direct involvement with Metro helps to provide a very detailed account of the creation, growth, and changes that the Washington Metro and its police department have experienced over the years, and the effect that it has had on its surrounding community. Biography of Daniel Hall Daniel Deidrich Hall was bom in Cleveland, Ohio in 1948 and was raised in a middle class communis onthe East Side of Cleveland with his two sisters, his cousin, and his parents. He has hved in Cleveland, Ohio; Reading, Pennsylvania; Centreville, Virginia; and Silver Spring, Maryland. Daniel Hall graduated from Glenville High School and studied at the Universi^ of Cleveland, the F.B.I. Academy and the Southern Police Institute. After High school, Daniel Hall became the first Afiican American technician to work for the N.C.R. (The National Cash Register Company), and he later was drafted into the marines. Preferring not to serve in the Marines, he enhstedhimself for a four-year term in the U.S. Army. He served in the U.S. Army from August 1968 to April 1974. Furthermore, he tempormily served as the bodyguard for His Imperial Majesty while stationed in Ethiopia, where he was deployed twice.
    [Show full text]
  • Draftrail Strategy
    South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Authority DRAFT RAIL STRATEGY Consultation Draft – October 2008 South Yorkshire, Making Rail a Better Choice 1 South Yorkshire, Making Rail a Better Choice Contents Contents Page Executive Summary 4 1. Introduction 5 2. The Rail Strategy in Context 9 National Context 10 Regional Context 10 Context Diagram 10 Strategy Objectives 11 3. Current Conditions 13 South Yorkshire Network 13 Local Network 13 Express Long Distance 15 Open Access 17 Freight 18 Rolling Stock 21 Train Capacity 23 South Yorkshire Stations 24 Access to Stations 28 Network Performance 29 Network Constraints 32 Ticketing and Pricing 34 Recent Land Use and Demand Changes 35 4. Recent Research 37 5. Future Conditions 39 Future Demand 39 New Stations 40 New Lines 41 Delivery Priorities 43 6. Action Plan 43 Details of Delivery/Funding 43 7. Monitoring and Consultation 46 Details of current Monitoring 46 Reporting processes 46 Consultation 48 2 Appendix One – The Rail Strategy in Context Appendix Two – Network Diagram/Map Appendix Three – Current Station Standards and Facilities Appendix Four – Proposed Housing Growth related to Rail Stations Appendix Five – Network bottlenecks and scheme dependencies Appendix Six – Delivery Plan 3 Executive Summary Executive Summary South Yorkshire, Making Rail a Better Choice To be drafted once contents are endorsed 4 Chapter 1 Introduction South Yorkshire, Making Rail a Better Choice Summary This document brings together changes in contextual policy and investment plans and Identifies the role of the Rail Strategy Provides an update on work completed since 2004 Summarises key developments and the effect on rail users Links all the above to explain the need for change Provides the planned actions to take the Strategy forward in the short, medium and long term 1.1 This Rail Strategy is produced by South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE), on behalf of South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Authority (SYPTA) and represents an update of the previous strategy issued in 2004.
    [Show full text]
  • Maintaining and Improving Britain's Railway Stations
    House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts Maintaining and improving Britain's railway stations Twenty–second Report of Session 2005–06 Report, together with formal minutes, oral and written evidence Ordered by The House of Commons to be printed 19 December 2005 HC 535 Published on 2 February 2006 by authority of the House of Commons London: The Stationery Office Limited £12.00 The Committee of Public Accounts The Committee of Public Accounts is appointed by the House of Commons to examine “the accounts showing the appropriation of the sums granted by Parliament to meet the public expenditure, and of such other accounts laid before Parliament as the committee may think fit” (Standing Order No 148). Current membership Mr Richard Bacon MP (Conservative, South Norfolk) Angela Browning MP (Conservative, Tiverton and Honiton) Mr Alistair Carmichael MP (Liberal Democrat, Orkney and Shetland) Greg Clark MP (Conservative, Tunbridge Wells) Rt Hon David Curry MP (Conservative, Skipton and Ripon) Mr Ian Davidson MP (Labour, Glasgow South West) Helen Goodman MP (Labour, Bishop Auckland) Mr Sadiq Khan MP (Labour, Tooting) Mr Edward Leigh MP (Conservative, Gainsborough) Sarah McCarthy-Fry MP (Labour, Portsmouth North) Mr Austin Mitchell MP (Labour, Great Grimsby) Jon Trickett MP (Labour, Hemsworth) Kitty Ussher MP (Labour, Burnley) Rt Hon Alan Williams MP (Labour, Swansea West) Stephen Williams MP (Liberal Democrat, Bristol West) The following was also a Member of the committee during the period of the enquiry: Diana R Johnson MP (Labour, Hull North) Powers Powers of the Committee of Public Accounts are set out in House of Commons Standing Orders, principally in SO No 148.
    [Show full text]
  • The Environmental Benefit of Car-Free Housing Projects
    promoting access to White Rose research papers Universities of Leeds, Sheffield and York http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ This is an author produced version of a paper published in Ecological Economics. White Rose Research Online URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/4735/ Published paper Ornetzeder, M., Hertwich, E.G. and Hubacek, K. (2008) The environmental effect of car-free housing: A case in Vienna, Ecological Economics, Volume 65 (3), 516-530. White Rose Research Online [email protected] The Environmental Effect of Car-free Housing: A Case in Vienna Michael ORNETZEDER1, Edgar HERTWICH2,*, Klaus HUBACEK3, Katarina KORYTAROVA4, Willi HAAS5 1 Institute of Technology Assessment, Austrian Academy of Sciences, Strohgasse 45/5, 1030 Vienna, Austria, www.oeaw.ac.at/ita, [email protected] 2 Department of Energy and Process Engineering and Industrial Ecology Programme, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, 7491 Trondheim, Norway; www.ntnu.no/indecol, [email protected] 3 School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK 4 International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA), Laxenburg, Austria 5 The Department of Social Ecology, Institute of Interdisciplinary Studies of Klagenfurt University (IFF), Vienna, Austria Abstract A case-control study of the car-free model housing project in Vienna was conducted to evaluate whether people living in this settlement have more ‘sustainable lifestyles’ than people living in comparable buildings in Vienna. Another aim was to identify the lifestyle characteristics and household activities which significantly influence the environmental impact of the residents of the car-free housing project and a control group.
    [Show full text]
  • Wellington Regional Public Transport Plan Hearing 2021
    Wellington Regional Public Transport Plan Hearing 20 April 2021, order paper - Front page If calling, please ask for Democratic Services Transport Committee - Wellington Regional Public Transport Plan Hearing 2021 Tuesday 20 April 2021, 9.30am Council Chamber, Greater Wellington Regional Council 100 Cuba Street, Te Aro, Wellington Members Cr Blakeley (Chair) Cr Lee (Deputy Chair) Cr Brash Cr Connelly Cr Gaylor Cr Hughes Cr Kirk-Burnnand Cr Laban Cr Lamason Cr Nash Cr Ponter Cr Staples Cr van Lier Recommendations in reports are not to be construed as Council policy until adopted by Council 1 Wellington Regional Public Transport Plan Hearing 20 April 2021, order paper - Agenda Transport Committee - Wellington Regional Public Transport Plan Hearing 2021 Tuesday 20 April 2021, 9.30am Council Chamber, Greater Wellington Regional Council 100 Cuba Street, Te Aro, Wellington Public Business No. Item Report Page 1. Apologies 2. Conflict of interest declarations 3. Process for considering the submissions and 21.128 3 feedback on the draft Wellington Regional Public Transport plan 2021 4. Analysis of submissions to the draft Wellington 21.151 7 Regional Public Transport plan 2021 2 Wellington Regional Public Transport Plan Hearing 20 April 2021, order paper - Process for considering the submissions andfeedback on the draf... Transport Committee 20 April 2021 Report 21.128 For Information PROCESS FOR CONSIDERING THE SUBMISSIONS AND FEEDBACK ON THE DRAFT WELLINGTON REGIONAL PUBLIC TRANSPORT PLAN 2021 Te take mō te pūrongo Purpose 1. To inform the Transport Committee (the Committee) of the process for considering submissions on the draft Wellington Regional Public Transport Plan 2021 (the draft RPTP).
    [Show full text]
  • Congressional Record United States Th of America PROCEEDINGS and DEBATES of the 107 CONGRESS, SECOND SESSION
    E PL UR UM IB N U U S Congressional Record United States th of America PROCEEDINGS AND DEBATES OF THE 107 CONGRESS, SECOND SESSION Vol. 148 WASHINGTON, TUESDAY, JULY 23, 2002 No. 101—Part II House of Representatives b 1400 The SPEAKER pro tempore. Is there for the Defense Department, including objection to the request of the gen- additional funds for the call-up of the CONFERENCE REPORT ON H.R. 4775, tleman from Florida? 2002 SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIA- Guard and Reserves as they were called There was no objection. to active duty to respond to September TIONS ACT FOR FURTHER RE- Mr. YOUNG of Florida. Mr. Speaker, COVERY FROM AND RESPONSE 11; $6.7 billion is for homeland security I yield myself such time as I may con- requirements; $2.1 billion is for foreign TO TERRORIST ATTACKS ON THE sume. assistance and embassy security pro- UNITED STATES Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to bring to grams; and $5.5 billion is to further Mr. YOUNG of Florida. Mr. Speaker, the House the conference report on the pursuant to a previous order of the 2002 supplemental appropriations bill. support recovery in New York. House, I call up the conference report This is a war-time supplemental to add The bill also includes $1 billion in to accompany the bill (H.R. 4775) mak- further to our efforts to respond to the funds to avert the estimated shortfalls ing supplemental appropriations for terrorist attacks on September 11, to in the Pell Grant student aid program. further recovery from and response to provide necessary funding to pursue It includes $417 million for veterans’ terrorist attacks on the United States the al Qaeda, to secure America, and to medical care, $205 million for Amtrak, for the fiscal year ending September 30, support further recovery from the vi- $400 million for programs and activities 2002, and for other purposes.
    [Show full text]
  • Kandy Ctb Bus Time Table
    Kandy Ctb Bus Time Table Articulable Lesley squeak deceivably or tongue validly when Shea is wearisome. Zygomorphic Marc never fireproof so too or intwist any hotchpotches submissively. Passant Townie sometimes materialising any argumentation legalized small-mindedly. No time table, the other relavent information and define what machines for all routes, with only for local bus Once you take a taxi through negambo, running bus services operators sltb express bus seats will not from information about bus to colombo bastian mawatha bus. Travel Stack Exchange is bad question and hospitality site is road warriors and seasoned travelers. Common bus routes is located by number one of your travel in kandy ctb bus time table for tourists prefer trinco instead. Travelling between Jaffna and Kandy is mention by Bus and train. Sri Lankans and what faction do, downstairs is half of locals knocking back Arrack the atmosphere may be blue than salubrious, in their it gives the Sidney Hotel, Galle a run for fucking money, but may people on friendly. The ctb buses or below lkr, it should also help us managed it means human beings can. Kandy being close second largest city in Sri Lanka, it been a main transportation hub. If kandy train in sydney, comfortable for a travelling polonnaruwa. Click on social media tickets while you had boarded this time table. Bambalapitiya junction pelawatta battaramulla welikada rajagiriya cotta road. Find out of kandy to travel between colombo and apologised for this route maps does that should take. Set Filters to start the Best Result. On buses are staying in.
    [Show full text]
  • Moving Stories 2.0.Pdf
    GROWING: RISING TO THE CHALLENGE 94 Events That Shaped Us 95 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1986: Collapse of Hotel New World 96 1993: The First Major MRT Incident 97 2003: SARS Crisis 98 2004: Exercise Northstar 99 2010: Acts of Vandalism 100 BEGINNING: THE RAIL DEVELOPMENT 1 2011: MRT Disruptions 100 CONNECTING: OUR SMRT FAMILY 57 The Rail Progress 2 2012: Bus Captains’ Strike 102 The Early Days 4 One Family 58 2015: Remembering Our Founding Father 104 Opening of the Rail Network 10 One Identity 59 2015: Celebrating SG50 106 Completion of the North-South and East-West Lines 15 A Familiar Place 60 2016: 22 March Fatal Accident 107 INNOVATING: MOVING WITH THE TIMES 110 Woodlands Extension 22 A Familiar Face 61 2017: Flooding in Tunnel 108 Operations to Innovation 111 Bukit Panjang Light Rail Transit 24 National Day Parade 2004 62 2017: Train Collision at Joo Koon MRT Station 109 Operating for Tomorrow 117 Keeping It in the Family 64 Beyond Our Network & Borders 120 Love is in the Air 66 Footprint in the Urban Mobility Space 127 Esprit de Corps 68 TRANSFORMING: TRAVEL REDEFINED 26 A Greener Future 129 Remember the Mascots? 74 SMRT Corporation Ltd 27 Stretching Our Capability 77 TIBS Merger 30 Engaging Our Community 80 An Expanding Network 35 Fare Payment Evolution 42 Tracking Improvements 50 More Than Just a Station 53 SMRT Institute 56 VISION 1 Moving People, Enhancing Lives MISSION In 2017, SMRT Corporation Ltd (SMRT) celebrates 30 years of Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) operations. To be the people’s choice by delivering a world-class transport service and Delivering a world-class transport service that is safe, reliable and customer-centric is at the lifestyle experience that is safe, heart of what we do.
    [Show full text]
  • Response to East Midlands Rail Franchise Public Consultation
    BOROUGH COUNCIL OF WELLINGBOROUGH AGENDA ITEM 5 Development Committee 11 September 2017 Report of the Director Response to East Midlands Rail Franchise public consultation 1 Purpose of report To seek approval to send a council response to the public consultation on proposed changes to the East Midlands Rail Franchise. 2 Executive summary 2.1 This public consultation is on proposed changes to the rail service from Wellingborough. This will involve fewer trains stopping at Wellingborough during peak hours in order to speed up train journey times on InterCity services (those services from Sheffield, Nottingham and Derby to London). 2.2 To counter this reduction in peak time services Wellingborough will be on a commuter line from Corby to London that will be serviced by longer trains in order to try and reduce the resultant overcrowding due to cutting InterCity services. This would also mean fewer direct trains northwards to Leicester in peak times. 3 Appendices Appendix 1 – Borough Council of Wellingborough response to the East Midlands Rail Franchise Public Consultation. Appendix 2 – East Midlands Rail Franchise Public Consultation document. 4 Proposed action: The Committee is invited to RESOLVE to submit the response in Appendix 1 to the East Midlands Rail Franchise public consultation. 5 Background 5.1 This document proposes changes to the East Midlands rail service currently operated by East Midlands Trains (EMT) through a public consultation process. The overall aim of these changes will be to improve the experience of passengers by providing more space and comfort, better and more frequent customer communication with the rail operator, improving the reliability and value for money of the service.
    [Show full text]
  • Setting the Direction for Wales and the Borders Rail
    Number: WG29296 Welsh Government Consultation – Summary of responses Setting the Direction for Wales and the Borders Rail 12 July 2016 Mae’r ddogfen yma hefyd ar gael yn Gymraeg. This document is also available in Welsh. © Crown Copyright Digital ISBN 978-1-4734-7087-3 Table of Contents Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 1 Background to the Consultation ............................................................................................................. 2 Who responded? ............................................................................................................................. 2 Where did responses come from? .................................................................................................. 2 Responses to the Consultation ............................................................................................................... 1 Outcomes ............................................................................................................................................ 1 Passenger Satisfaction and Priorities for Improvement ..................................................................... 2 Rail Services ........................................................................................................................................ 3 Range and Frequency .....................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • December, 1921
    ,r ~ Milwaukee Road Collection " Mi\l;vaukee Public library, 2 THE MILWAUKEE CONTENTS A.uthor-- Pago BoUd:.y Gr~eting •........•..•.•...•.•..•....., " . '" .•...•..•. :5 T:he S10ry Of " Doy r 6 HLet'.!I Hell)' Sfe(l" _.•.......•...•.••.•.••.•...•..•...•....•. ~ ......• ..r ., ...• 6 The Cr)··l:lnb:< " No"a n. Deeco ..•.•......... 'f .A R"llwn~' P"esl<lent '''J,o Begnn os Pdnte,,'s De,,·il ......•......•..•..•....•...... " .•.•.. " ..••.. Allnn Jiardl",S".•..•.....•• " 9 The Old Shncli: .....-.......•......•.•....•........L"ciIle A. Elson.....•.....•14 Tnl'u Out the Ljgbt~ n<)cl",,,,,t1on Con'u>.lHe"..'.•.14 FU'ty Ycn"s Of Service •........•..•.'•.........•... ' ........•.....•..•.........IS Current News Of the RniJrond....•......•..'•.•............... " , ." 18 Xl} Other Ens-Ineer AYnllable .•...,..•..•..•......•.Hnl·ol<l C. Breckenridge 11' Pr(}g"resl1 ....." .....•.........•...•.•.•..•........ ,W. 1\'. Ell" •.•....•.....•...21. ,\.,",tu'''I' ....................•..•.....•.•.., A Bent Rnll ................ •Zl Tomnn' Fox'~ Choke .......•.......•..............DIll .......•.....•.....•..•.21 FrOIH tile Dun'nll 0;: Snfety.•...•.•.......' A. '\V. Smalle,,- .....•...•.•. 23 At,Holl'e .........•...........•.••.•.••...........Hnzel IH. ))terrlU•....... : 24 'rhlrd Annuttl Convention, Am. Legion....•.•.......Ou" T. P Z'T DUbuque DI..-j~fon. BOOster Ch'b :?-7 Car Stnff lUeetlng nt iltllwllnkee ' ::8 Oldest .ot·lllng Cn.. Conductor in America ...•..•... " •..•....•... , :!S 0" the Steel Trllil .• '.' .....• ' '" •..•.•......•.•............30 ,.
    [Show full text]