DEMOCRATIZATION AND WAR: THE CHECHEN WARS’ CONTRIBUTION TO FAILING DEMOCRATIZATION IN RUSSIA HANNA SMITH ALEKSANTERI INSTITUTE Abstract: This article extends Edward Mansfield and Jack Snyder’s proposition that regimes in the process of democratization are more likely to engage in international conflict. First, the article expands the theory to include civil war by looking at Russia’s internal clashes with Chechnya. Second, the analysis demonstrates the existence of a vicious circle in which the process of democratization led to military adventures, which in turn reduced the level of democracy in Russia. While many explanations have been advanced for the Chechen wars, this article focuses on elite competition, the role of the military, the loss of great power status, and the need to identify an external enemy in order to promote internal consolidation as determining factors. his article argues that the effect of the two Chechen wars, 1994-1996 Tand 1999-2002, has been devastating to the Russian democratization process. Both wars were the product of a regime moving from authoritarian to more democratic government but, the wars themselves helped block Russia’s democratic transition and reinforced the semi-authoritarian nature of the state. This argument proceeds using the framework of the theory about democratization and war developed by Edward Mansfield and Jack Snyder. The article analyzes how this theory and its implications fit Russia’s case, Hanna Smith is a researcher at the Aleksanteri Institute, P.O. Box 42 (Unioninkatu 33) FI-00014 University of Helsinki, Finland, Hanna.
[email protected]. 627 628 Demokratizatsiya and whether the case of Russia and particularly Russia’s wars in Chechnya support the theory.