arXiv:1904.07669v1 [physics.optics] 16 Apr 2019 ihrptto aeoeaini iie yvlepuls- valve by Moreover, limited is capability. turbulences. operation ing flow rate repetition and valvehigh time of shot-to-shot over reproducibility vary including gra- operation however reasons, steep several can by to profiles due bounded Density profile density dients. flat a LWFA.generating in jets employed be gas can Supersonic targets gaseous of kind ferent eltm oioig Using monitoring. require and real-time use, methods repetitive characterization by damaged sophisticated get setup, to cult sdrcl eae otepril ubrdensity is number LWFA which particle in plasma, the to the role related in key directly density is free- A the by mandatory. played the is of control process full LWFA applications practical these implement o WA stelsrcnb uddoe e cen- few a over the of and guided energy length be acceleration final the can increasing laser thus the timeters, as LWFA, for a) acceleration wakefield laser interferometry for second-harmonic via monitoring Real-time l ual ceeao eghi re ovr electron vary to order in eas- length with energy along accelerator pro- laser, tunable rate interaction repetition ily high laser-plasma with manageable even enabling cess, and limitations, mentioned stable above a the avoid to able o eia ssicuigteayaddiagnosis and therapy including uses medical for plctosi uueaclrtrtechnology accelerator future in applications rdcino nrei atcebasfo ae wake- laser from (LWFA) beams acceleration particle field energetic the of on production progress recent interaction, laser-plasma intensity lcrncmi:[email protected] mail: Electronic fe eea eae ffnaetlrsac nhigh- on research fundamental of decades several After 10,11 o WA h eut eosrt htra-iemntrn sach ( is gas monitoring real-time that backing H demonstrate ins density results number speed/throughput. The LWFA. particle de the for pump measure particle vacuum temperat to applied th and the room is in interferometry volume valves estimate the and chamber to and regulators vacuum tubing, pressure used as like backing factors be several preset monitor cannot on the real-time depends law LWFA, on gas manageable based th ideal and cell in the stable density number term fact, particle long In gas multi-s a the in of for control especially allowing full technique, obtain (LW emerging to acceleration this order weakfield process, of laser interaction for applications laser-plasma target manageable practical a and as stable cell obtain gas to a of use The nl uetenme est pt h 10 the to up density number the tune finely 1) Brandi, F. 2) Italy 3) 4) Italy 6) 5) Italy Dtd 7Arl2019) April 17 (Dated: France Cedex, Palaiseau 91762 nes ae raito aoaoy(LL,Ittt Naz Istituto (ILIL), Laboratory Irradiation Laser Intense siuoIain iTcooi IT,VaMrg 0 16163 30, Morego Via (IIT), Tecnologia di Italiano Istituto iatmnod iia nvri` el td iPs,La Pisa, di Studi Universit`a degli Fisica, di Dipartimento lsaDansis&Tcnlge t. i atuc n.38 Matteucci via Ltd., Technologies & Diagnostics Plasma O,ESAPrseh NS cl oyehiu,Universi Polytechnique, France Ecole Orsay, CNRS, 91400 ParisTech, Paris, ENSTA de LOA, rue 86 SAS, SourceLAB oevr o a el r da candidates ideal are cells gas flow Moreover, . ailr discharges Capillary ,2, 1, r ieyue ste lo for allow they as used widely are a) .Giammanco, F. 8 1 hs agt r e diffi- yet are targets These . a pndtewyfractual for way the opened has < a eltargets cell gas a)addffrn eloic imtr ( diameters orifice cell different and bar) 1 r odcandidates good are ,4 3, 9 hc hampers which .Conti, F. 2,3 sprefer- is swl as well as 4 ? N –7 ,4 3, Dif- . To . 19 .Sylla, F. cm − 3 dex, esrdpaesiti ie by given is the shift interferometers two-arm phase in measured comparison, a As sample. I ag is range NIR au fterfatvt ( refractivity the of value ∆ by measured given a shift with phase interferometer, two-color (SHI) single-arm, interferometer a ro- second-harmonic alternative measure so-called An precisely to the practice. method pe- in fast prevented extended and bust is an time over of for monitoring riod approaches real-time interferometric accurate standard rea- an of mentioned use above the the For sons, measurement. real-time a ob mlmne nmlisaeaccelerators multi-stage in implemented be to r ieyue o h hrceiaino a targets gas of characterization the for used widely interferometer) are two- Mach-Zehnder Standard (e.g., interferometers techniques. arm interferometric needed. pres- by law backing is measured gas the ideal monitor the from real-time using inferred thus temperature be ambient cannot and sure gas flow a in hr ∆ where the from density actual interferograms the recorded extract to analysis manipu- and data lation environ- substantial requires of but influence conditions, mental the No- reduces (e.g., interferometer) configuration marski quasi-common-path environmental interferom- a two-arm the with of on eters implementation sensitivity The high a conditions. from suffer but te ihspro emqaiyadrlaiiyneces- applications reliability high-level and actual quality for beam facil- LWFA-based sary superior perspec- implementing with the and ities in designing important of extremely tive are features these ag elsie o LWFA. for suited well range 5 oaed tia(N-N) i ouz ,514Pisa, 56124 1, Moruzzi Via (INO-CNR), Ottica di ionale .Lambert, G. g .Pneov ,517Pisa, 56127 3, Pontecorvo B. rgo λ eoa Italy Genova, stewvlnt,and wavelength, the is D 62 Pisa, 56124 /D, n ai-aly 2 ddsMarchaux, des bd 828 Paris-Saclay, t ( λ = ) a upysse,a well as system, supply gas e ∼ adtr odto for condition mandatory a d o a eldesigned cell gas flow a ide 6 r eas h a flow gas the because ure < neato ein thus region, interaction e reso antd agrte h cor- the then larger magnitude of orders 2 ee,adta sn low using that and ieved, A ffr h possibility the offers FA) n .A Gizzi A. L. and n m ti osbeto possible is it mm) 2 ( λ r,second-harmonic ere, aeaclrtr.In accelerators. tage st nieteflow the inside nsity ) − φ n snecessary. is ing n 17 n ( = iiigterapiaiiyfor applicability their limiting , λ/ ( λ faflwgscell gas flow a of 4 ) 2), λ π − 1 R L )frgssi h visible- the in gases for 1) L n ( h pia ahi the in path optical the 2 ∆ λ λ π N n sterfatv in- refractive the is ) R ( L λ a eaccurately be can ( ) 14 n dl ( However, . λ = N ) − sbsdon based is 4 λ π 1) 12,13 L dl ∆ The . All . n 18,19 ( λ 15 16 N ), , , 2

(a) 1,8 (a)0.8 bar 1,6

1,4 -3

cm 1,2 19 1

0,8

0,6

Particle density, 10 0,4 (b) (c) 0,2

0 1,3 (b)0.6 bar 1,2 1,1

-3 1

cm 0,9 19 0,8 FIG. 1. (a) schematic of the gas supply system: L-pipe length, 0,7 ID-pipe internal diameter; (b) schematic of the flow gas cell 0,6 0,5 assembly; (c) photo of the cell in the vacuum chamber with 0,4 the interferometer optical path highlighted by red dashed line. Particle density, 10 0,3 0,2 0,1 responding ∆n(λ). Therefore, the lengthy data analysis 0 and reduced accuracy related to fringe jump15,20 when (c)0.4 bar measuring large density variations with two-arm inter- 0,6

ferometers may be avoided using the SHI. As example, -3 0,5 for a path length of 50 mm in argon at standard temper- cm −7 21 19 ature and pressure (∆n0(1064 nm) = 40 × 10 ) the 0,4 phase shift experienced by the SHI is 2.36 rad, while the corresponding phase shift in a two-arm interferometer is 0,3 76.4 rad22. 0,2 A high-speed (∼ µs) and high-sensitivity (∼ mrad) SHI Particle density, 10 employing a CW Nd:YAG laser and phase detection has 0,1 been developed23 and implemented to measure electron 24 density in a large plasma , in a pulsed 0 25 gas jet , and to perform quantitative phase dispersion (d) 0.2 bar 26 imaging . Here, we report on the use of such a com- 0.2 mm 0.5 mm pact SHI to measure N in real-time inside a flow gas cell 0,3 of variable length designed specifically for LWFA exper- -3 2.0 mm cm

iments. In fact, the SHI satisfies the requirements for 19 a fast and reliable measurement, providing an efficient 0,2 method to control N within the interaction region. The gas system set up used in the experiment is schematically shown in Fig. 1(a). The gas flow cell is placed inside a vacuum chamber that comprises optical Particle density, 10 0,1 windows used to couple the laser light in and out, a feed through for the gas pipe, and a scroll vacuum pump. The 0 gas is supplied to the cell by means of an electronic valve, 0 0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 3 3,5 4 4,5 and the applied backing pressure is set by the gas cylinder Time, sec regulator and measured by a gauge with 50 mbar reso- FIG. 2. The evolution of N in the cell for different backing lution placed in proximity to the valve. A 3D schematic pressure and orifice aperture sizes: (a) 0.8 bar; (b) 0.6 bar; of the gas cell is reported in Fig. 1(b). The cell com- (c) 0.4 bar; (d) 0.2 bar. In all figures the continuous (black), prises two lateral glass windows that allow transverse op- dashed (red) and dot-dash (green) lines correspond to 0.2 mm, tical access for the interferometric measurements (L =50 0.5 mm and 2 mm orifice diameters respectively. mm), and two longitudinal orifice apertures to couple in and out the high-power ultrashort laser pulse and the produced particle beam respectively. The two orifices, which in the present experiment are set 12 mm apart, aperture diameters, namely 0.2 mm, 0.5 mm and 2 mm. allow also the gas to flow from the cell into the vacuum In Fig. 1(c) a photograph of the apparatus comprising chamber. Three pairs of orifices are used, with different the vacuum chamber, the cell and the SHI is shown, with 3 the optical path of the interferometer highlighted by the 1E. Esarey, C. B. Schroeder, and W. P. Leemans Rev. Mod. Phys. dashed line. The quantity acquired by the SHI is given 81, 1229 (2009). 2 by V sin(∆φ + φ )+ α,23 where φ is the off-set phase C. B. Schroeder, E. Esarey, C. G. R. Geddes, C. Benedetti, and 0 0 W. P. Leemans Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 13, 101301 (2010). that can be reduced below 1 mrad acting on a phase com- 3A. R. Maier, A. Meseck, S. Reiche, C. B. Schroeder, T. Segge- pensator, V is the fringe visibility, and α ≪ 1 is related brock, and F. Grner Phys. Rev. X 2, 031019 (2012). to the detector responsivities. The visibility is directly 4V. Malka, J. Faure, and Y. A. Gauduel Mutat. Res.-Rev. Mutat. obtained by scanning the phase compensator over half- 704, 142 151 (2010) fringe27,28 and for the present experiment is found to be 5Y. Glinec, J. Faure, V. Malka, T. Fuchs, H. Szymanowski, and 33 V =0.9. U. Oelfke Med. Phys. , 155162 (2006) 6J. M. Cole, J. C. Wood, N. C. Lopes, K. Poder, R. L. Abel, S. In general the refractivity (n − 1) of a gas is related to Alatabi, J. S. J. Bryant, A. Jin, S. Kneip, K. Mecseki, D. R. N which is determined by the equation of state at a given Symes, S. P. D. Mangles and Z. Najmudin. Sci. Rep. 5, 13244 (2015). temperature T and pressure P . In the present case the 7 Gladston-Dale relation between the refractivity and the L.A. Gizzi, L. Labate, F. Baffigi, F. Brandi, G.C. Bussolino, L. Fulgentini, P. Koester, D. Palla, and F. Rossi, Nucl. Instr. Meth. number density, (n − 1) ∝ N, and equation of Phys. Res. B 355, 241-245 (2015). state, N ∝ P/T , are assumed29. Therefore, the average 8W. Leemans, A. Gonsalves, H.-S. Mao, K. Nakamura, C. particle number density is related to the measured phase Benedetti, C. Schroeder, C. T´oth, J. Daniels, D. Mittelberger, S. λ N0 19 −3 Bulanov, J.-L. Vay, C. Geddes, and E. Esarey Phys. Rev. Lett. by the equation N = πL n ∆φ =1.14∆φ × 10 cm , 4 ∆ 0 113, 245002 (2014). 19 −3 where N0 =2.69 × 10 cm is the Loschmidt constant. 9J. Daniels, J. van Tilborg, A. J. Gonsalves, C. B. Schroeder, The results of the systematic measurements for four val- C. Benedetti, E. Esarey, and W. P. Leemans Phys. Plasmas 22, ues of the backing pressure, i.e., 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, and 0.8 bar 073112 (2015). 10 are reported in Fig. 2. J. Osterhoff, A. Popp, Zs. Major, B. Marx, T. P. Rowlands- Rees, M. Fuchs, M. Geissler, R. Hrlein, B. Hidding, S. Becker, The actual gas flow can be described as follows: i) the E. A. Peralta, U. Schramm, F. Grner, D. Habs, F. Krausz, S. M. filling up of the cell starts at the backing pressure given Hooker, and S. Karsch Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 085002 (2008). by the preset value; ii) after the first 100 ms, the ori- 11S. Corde, C. Thaury, A. Lifschitz, G. Lambert, K. Ta Phuoc, fices start to play a role and the filling up rate decreases X. Davoine, R. Lehe, R. D. Douillet, A. Rousse and V. Malka Nature Comm. 4, 1501 (2013). with increasing aperture diameter; iii) when the gas flow 12B. B. Pollock, C. E. Clayton, J. E. Ralph, F. Albert, A. Davidson, demand exceeds the controlling capabilities of the reg- L. Divol, C. Filip, S. H. Glenzer, K. Herpoldt, W. Lu, K. A. ulator the pressure at the cell inlet drops, reducing the Marsh, J. Meinecke, W. B. Mori, A. Pak, T. C. Rensink, J. S. cell’s filling up rate; iv) in case of large apertures and/or Ross, J. Shaw, G. R. Tynan, C. Joshi, and D. H. Froula Phys. 107 low preset backing pressure N decreases at longer time Rev. Lett. , 045001 (2011). 13J. S. Liu, C. Q. Xia, W. T. Wang, H. Y. Lu, Ch. Wang, A. H. due to the higher gas flow from the cell to the vacuum Deng, W. T. Li, H. Zhang, X. Y. Liang, Y. X. Leng, X. M. Lu, chamber compared to the flow from the gas supply sys- C. Wang, J. Z. Wang, K. Nakajima, R. X. Li, and Z. Z. Xu Phys. tem to the cell. Rev. Lett. 107, 035001 (2011). 14 In conclusion, it is demostrated that the SHI can be used http://www.eupraxia-project.eu/ 15J. Ju and B. Cros J. Appl. Phys. 112, 113102 (2012). to monitor N in real-time and it is found that the ideal 16L. A. Gizzi, M. Galimberti, A. Giulietti, D. Giulietti, P. Koester, gas law cannot indeed be used to estimate N inside the L. Labate, P. Tomassini, Ph. Martin, T. Ceccotti, P. De Oliveira, flow cell solely based on the preset backing pressure and and P. Monot Phys. Rev. E 74, 036403 (2006). the room temperature, i.e., ∼ 2.5×1019cm−3bar−1. This 17L. A. Gizzi, D. Giulietti, A. Giulietti, T. Afshar-Rad, V. Bian- is because the actual gas flow depends on several factors calana, P. Chessa, C. Danson, E. Schifano, S. M. Viana, and O. Willi Phys. Rev. E 49, 5628–5643 (1994). like tubing, regulators and valves in the gas supply sys- 18F. Hopf, A. Tomita, and G. Al-Jumaily, Opt. Lett. 5, 386–388 tem, as well as vacuum chamber volume, vacuum pump (1980). speed/throughput, and cell’s orifice diameters. In fact, 19V. P. Drachev, Yu. I. Krasnikov, and P. A. Bagryansky, Rev. Sci. for the same backing pressure N can differ by almost a Instrum. 64, 1010–1013 (1993). 20 factor of 2 when using 0.2 mm or 0.5 mm orifice. More- J.-W. Juhn, K. C. Lee, Y. S. Hwang, C. W. Domier, N. C. Luh- mann Jr., B. P. Leblanc, D. Mueller, D. A. Gates, and R. Kaita, over, in a repetitive operation, changes of the orifice’s Rev. Sci. Instrum. 81, 10D540 (2010). diameter in time due to laser ablation should be taken 21S.P. Velsko and D. Eimerl Appl. Opt. 25, 1344–1349 (1986). into account, thus confirming that a real-time monitoring 22A. Bideau-Mehu, Y. Guern, R. Abjean, and A. Johannin-Gilles, is required to maintain a long-term stable N inside the J. Quant. Spectrosc. Rad. Transfer 25, 395–402 (1981). 23 32 cell. F. Brandi, and F. Giammanco Opt. Lett. , 2327–2329 (2007). 24F. Brandi, F. Giammanco, W. S. Harris, T. Roche, E. Trask, and FB and LG received funding from the European F. J. Wessel Rev. Sci. Instrum. 80, 113501 (2009). Unions Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme 25F. Brandi, and F. Giammanco Opt. Express 19, 25479–25487 under Grant Agreement No 653782 EuPRAXIA, and (2011). 26F Conti, M Tiberi, F Giammanco, A Diaspro, and F Brandi from the Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia (convenzione op- Laser Phys. Lett. 10, 056003 (2013). erativa IIT INO-CNR prot. n. 0010983, 26/11/2013). 27F. Brandi, P. Marsili, and F. Giammanco, in AIP conference The Authors acknowledge Emilien Guillaume, C´edric proceedings: Burning plasma diagnostics, 988, 132–135 (2008). Thaury for useful discussions. 28F. Brandi and F. Giammanco, Opt. Lett. 33, 2071-2073 (2008). 29V. Malka, C. Coulaud, J. P. Geindre, V. Lopez, Z. Najmudin, D. Neely and F. Amiranoff, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 71, 2329 (2000).