The First Wittgenstein Biography and Why It Has Never Been Published

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The First Wittgenstein Biography and Why It Has Never Been Published Christian Erbacher The First Wittgenstein Biography and why it has never been published 1. Wittgenstein and Hayek At first sight, the life trajectories of Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889 –1951) and Friedrich August von Hayek (1899 –1992) show remarkable parallels: both of these Viennese thinkers served in the Austrian army during the First World War; both emigrated to England in the 1930s and became British citizens when Hitler annexed Austria in 1938; both were to become major intellectual figures who transformed their fields of study. A closer look, however, reveals considerable differences in the two men, in their upbringing, their war -experiences and their intellectual careers after the war. Hayek and Wittgenstein were distantly related: Hayek’s great grandfather and Wittgenstein’s grandmother had been siblings, making the two men remote cousins. But in this era, when a family of ten children was not uncommon, this relationship was not especially significant. Hayek and Wittgenstein had met occasionally during vacations or family visits, but there was no real friendship (Hayek 1992: 177). Then, too, although Hayek’s family was quite well off, their way of life could not compare to that of the Wittgensteins, one of the wealthiest families in the Austrian Empire, whose Palais welcomed such guests as Johannes Brahms and Josef Labor. Still, the casual acquaintance between Hayek and Wittgenstein was enough to enable them to recognize one another on the train to the Italian Front in the late summer of 1918, as Hayek remembered: My first recollection goes back to a day on furlough and leave of absence from the front, where on the railway station in Bad Ischl, [Austria], two young ensigns in the artillery in uniform looked at each other and said, »You have a fairly familiar face. « Then we asked each other »Aren’t you a Wittgenstein? « and »Aren’t you a Hayek? « I now know that at this moment returning to the front, he must have had the manuscript of the Tractatus in his rucksack. But I didn’t know it at that time. But many of the mental characteristics of the man were already present as I gathered in this night journey from Bad Ischl to Innsbruck, where the occasion was his contempt for the noisy crowd of returning young officers, half -drunk; a certain contempt for the world. (Hayek 1983: 251) 1 During the train ride the two men conversed, but they did not have intellectual discussions. Hayek knew nothing about Wittgenstein’s philosophical writing before 1 A similar recollection is published in Hayek (1977). 10 Christian Erbacher the publication of the Tractatus logico-philosophicus in 1921 (Hayek 1983: 254). And this fact points to yet another major difference between the two men: when they met in the train compartment, Wittgenstein had already studied logic with Bertrand Russell for years, and had worked at notes that would become the Tractatus ; he had served in the army for four years and seen action on the Eastern Front and had lost beloved friends such as David Pinsent. Hayek, by contrast, had just graduated from secondary school and was recruited only shortly before war’s end. Indeed, although they were only ten years apart, Wittgenstein and Hayek belonged to essentially different generations: the war generation and its aftermath. Hayek’s academic career developed rapidly after the war. In 1921 − the year the Tractatus first appeared − Hayek finished his studies under Friedrich von Wieser, one of the founding fathers of the Austrian school of economics. Wieser introduced Hayek to Ludwig von Mises, who became an intellectual tutor for Hayek. Through Mises’ seminars in Vienna, Hayek became a member of the group of liberalist academics who were intellectually connected to the philosophical movement that would become known as the Vienna Circle. In fact, Ludwig von Mises’s brother Richard is said to have decisively inspired the gatherings that gave rise to the Vienna Circle in the years that followed the First World War (Stadler 1997: 741 – 751; Hayek 1992). Through these academic ties, Hayek entered the milieu in which the Tractatus was already prominently and heatedly discussed. Thus, while Hayek did not meet Wittgenstein in person in the 1920s, he became aware of him as an important and admired intellectual: The author of the Tractatus had become an idol for his teachers and the then leading intellectuals of the Vienna Circle who regarded the book as a miraculously presented foundation of their vision for a sci- entific worldview. Wittgenstein, however, was no longer interested in philosophical discussions or indeed in any academic career. He had completed the Tractatus at the end of the war (McGuinness 1988: 287) and when the book was published three years later, it became famous in the philosophical world. But Wittgenstein thought that he had contributed all he could to philosophy. Like many other war veterans, he attended a teachers’ college in Vienna in 1919. From 1920 onwards, he started working as an elementary schoolteacher in remote villages in Lower Austria – first in Trattenbach, later in Puchberg and, eventually, in Otterthal. Thus, Wittgenstein’s and Hayek’s paths did not cross again for a decade, although both men spent most of their time in Austria. Their lives had taken different directions: Wittgenstein turning his back on the Viennese upper class of the old order and Hayek entering the upcoming academic elite of a new world. After working for Mises for two years, Hayek left Austria to do doctoral studies in New York. There he became acquainted with new statistical methods for empirical research in economics. This made him, on his return to Austria, a most valuable collaborator for Mises, who in early 1927 appointed him the first director of the Austrian Institute for Business Cycle Research. Hayek was then only 27 years old. He now concentrated on the history of monetary and economic theory and two years .
Recommended publications
  • Wittgenstein in Exile
    Wittgenstein in Exile “My thoughts are one hundred per cent Hebraic.” -Wittgenstein to Drury, 19491 Wittgenstein was born in 1889 into one of the richest families in Central Europe. He lived and learned at home, in Vienna, until 1903, when he was 14. We have no record of his thoughts about the turn of the last century, but it is unlikely that it seemed very significant to him. The Viennese of the time had little inclination to consider the possibilities of change, and the over-ripe era in which Wittgenstein grew up did not really end until Austria-Hungary’s defeat, in World War I, and subsequent dismantling. But the family in which Wittgenstein grew up apparently felt that European culture had already come to an end in the 1840’s. And Wittgenstein himself felt he belonged to an era that had vanished with the death of the composer Robert Schumann (1810-1856).2 Somewhere in the middle of the Nineteenth Century there was an important change into the contemporary era, of which Wittgenstein did not feel a part. Wittgenstein’s understanding of history, and his consequent self-understanding in relation to his times, was deeply influenced by Oswald Spengler, who in 1918 published The Decline of the West [Der Untergang des Abenlandes]. This book, expanded to a second volume in 1922, and revised in 1923, became a best-seller in post-war Europe. Wittgenstein made numerous references to it in 1930-1931, and acknowledged Spengler as one of his ten noteworthy influences.3 According to Spengler, cultures grow, flower, and deteriorate naturally, according to their own internal form, much as a human being does.
    [Show full text]
  • Semmering-Basistunnel Neu
    5510-UV-0101AL-00-0002 Plannummer: AUSFERTIGUNG EINLAGEZAHL HOCHLEISTUNGSSTRECKE WIEN SÜDBAHNHOF – SPIELFELD / STRASS NEUBAUSTRECKE GLOGGNITZ – MÜRZZUSCHLAG km 75,5+61.867 – km 118,1+22.709 SEMMERING-BASISTUNNEL NEU Umweltverträglichkeitserklärung (UVE) für das Umweltverträglichkeitsprüfungsverfahren 04 03 02 01 Version Datum Name Beschreibung der Änderung OBJEKTNR: STRECKENNR.: 135 ABSCHNITT GLOGGNITZ – MÜRZZUSCHLAG km / Stat. km 75,5+61.867 – km 118,1+22.709 Bearbeitet Mai 2010 Risto Inhalt Gezeichnet - - ZUSAMMENFASSUNG Geprüft Mai 2010 Mattanovich GZ - Umweltverträglichkeitserklärung Planung c/o ILF Beratende Ingenieure ZT GmbH Harrachstraße 26 4020 Linz Bauwerber: ÖBB-Infrastruktur AG SEMMERING-BASISTUNNEL neu 5510-UV-0101AL-00-0002 Zusammenfassung | Umweltverträglichkeitserklärung 28.05.2010 BERICHTERSTELLUNG Planungsgemeinschaft Semmering-Basistunnel ILF Beratende Ingenieure ZT GesmbH Feldkreuzstraße 3, 6063 Rum bei Innsbruck Tel.: 0512 / 24 12 Projektkoordination Fax: 0512 / 24 12 – 5905 E-Mail: [email protected] RaumUmwelt Planungs-GmbH Mariahilfer Str. 57-59, 1060 Wien Tel.: 01 / 23 63 063 Projektkoordination Fax: 01 / 23 63 063 - 900 E-Mail: [email protected] PLANUNGSGEMEINSCHAFT SEMMERING-BASISTUNNEL Seite 2 © RU/ILF 2010 SEMMERING-BASISTUNNEL neu 5510-UV-0101AL-00-0002 Zusammenfassung | Umweltverträglichkeitserklärung 28.05.2010 INHALTSVERZEICHNIS 1 KURZFASSUNG 6 2 AUFGABENSTELLUNG 8 3 ANLASS UND RAHMENBEDINGUNGEN DES VORHABENS 9 3.1 Ausgangssituation der UVP-Planung 9 3.1.1 Der Semmering-Basistunnel neu und seine Zielsetzungen
    [Show full text]
  • Ilse Wollansky
    Haugschlag Reingers Litschau Waldkirchen/Thaya Geltungsbereiche der Kautzen Eisgarn Dobersberg Eggern Regionalen Raumordnungs- Gastern Karlstein/Thaya Heidenreichstein Raabs/Thaya Thaya Drosendorf- Amaliend.- Pfaffenschlag Zissersdorf programme in NÖ Aalfang Brand- Langau Nagelberg Waidhofen/ WAIDHOFEN/THAYA Hardegg Thaya- Schrems Groß- Land Dietmanns Japons GMÜND Siegharts Ludweis- Aigen Weitersfeld Geras Otten- Hoheneich Windigsteig Wildendürnbach thal Vitis Retzbach Unserfrau- Drasenhofen Altweitra Großdietmanns Hirschbach Schratten- Retz Waldenstein thal Schwarzenau Göpfritz/Wild Irnfritz- Kirchberg/Walde Albern- Messern Pernegg Neudorf/Staatz Echsenbach Zellern- dorf/ Seefeld- Sigmundsherberg dorf Pulkau- Kadolz Pulkau Falkenstein Schrattenberg Perners- tal Laa/Thaya dorf Herrn- Brunn/Wild Hadres Großharras St.Bernhard- Haugs- baum- Bernhardsthal Allentsteig Frauenhofen Zellerndorf dorf garten Schweiggers HORN Unterstinkenbrunn Moorbad Harbach Mailberg Weitra Meiseldorf Röschitz Staatz Röhrenbach Gaubitsch Altlichten- Poysdorf Rabens- Eggenburg Guntersdorf warth Altenburg Fallbach Großkrut burg Stronsdorf St.Martin Wullersdorf Pölla Straning- Haus- Rosenburg-Mold Nappersd.- Großschönau ZWETTL/NÖ Grafenberg brunn Kammersd. Sitzendorf/ Burgschleinitz- Neusiedl/ Hohenau/March Schmida Kühnring Grabern Gnadendorf Zaya Haus- Bad Großpertholz Krumau/ Wilfersdorf kirchen Palternd.- Kamp Gars/Kamp Asparn/Zaya St.Leonhard/ Dober- Ringelsdorf- Gnadendorf MISTELBACH Groß Gerungs Hornerwald mannsd. Niederabsdorf Maissau Rastenfeld HOLLABRUNN
    [Show full text]
  • Niederösterreich Landesübersicht
    Haugschlag AMT DER NÖ LANDESREGIERUNG Reingers Tschechien Litschau Waldkirchen an der Thaya Kautzen Eisgarn Eggern Dobersberg Karlstein an Gastern der Thaya Heidenreichstein Pfaffen- Raabs Brand- Thaya schlag bei an der Nagelberg Amalien- Drosendorf- Waidhofen Thaya Zissersdorf NIEDERÖSTERREICH dorf- Aalfang a.d.Thaya Hardegg Langau WAIDHOFEN Waidhofen an LANDESÜBERSICHT AN DER der Thaya-Land Schrems THAYA Dietmanns Japons Geras Groß-Siegharts Ludweis- Aigen Hoheneich Windigsteig Otten- Weitersfeld Retz- GMÜND Wildendürnbach thal bach Vitis Großdietmanns Hirschbach Göpfritz Retz Drasenhofen Waldenstein an der Schratten- Schwarzenau Neudorf Wild Irnfritz-Messern Pernegg thal Al- Unserfrau- Seefeld- im Weinviertel bern- Altweitra Kirchberg am Walde Haugs- Kadolz Echsenbach dorf dorf Schrattenberg Moorbad Pulkau im Laa an Falken- Harbach Sigmunds- Weitra Pernersdorf Pulk- Hadres der Thaya stein Herrnbaum- St. Bernhard- herberg Allentsteig Brunn an au- garten der Wild Frauenhofen Zellerndorf tal Unter- Bernhardsthal Schweiggers HORN Mailberg stinken- Meiseldorf Röschitz Großharras brunn St. Martin Röhrenbach Staatz Poysdorf Altlichtenwarth Rabensburg Großschönau Altenburg Eggenburg Guntersdorf Großkrut Stronsdorf Pölla Gaubitsch Fallbach Bad Rosenburg-Mold Wullersdorf Großpertholz Sitzendorf Straning- Haus- Haus- an der Neusiedl Hohenau an ZWETTL Burgschleinitz- Grafenberg Nappersdorf- kirchen brunn Verwaltungsgrenzen Schmida an der der March Kühnring Kammersdorf Grabern Zaya Paltern- Gars am Gnaden- Wilfersdorf dorf- Krumau Kamp St. Leonhard
    [Show full text]
  • Moving Wachau, © Robert Herbst
    REFRESHINGLY moving Road map of Lower Austria, with tips for visitors WWW.LOWER-AUSTRIA.INFO Mostviertel, © Robert Herbst Mostviertel, Welcome! “With this map, we want to direct you to the most beautiful corners of Lower Austria. As you will see, Austria‘s largest federal state presents itself as a land of diversity, with a wide variety of landscapes for refreshing outdoor adventures, great cultural heritage, world-class wines and regional specialities. All that’s left to say is: I wish you a lovely stay, and hope that your time in Lower Austria will be unforgettable!” JOHANNA MIKL-LEITNER Lower Austrian Governor © NLK/Filzwieser “Here you will find inspiration for your next visit to, or stay in, Lower Austria. Exciting excursion destinations, varied cycling and mountain biking routes, and countless hiking trails await you. This map also includes lots of tips for that perfect stay in Lower Austria. Have fun exploring!” JOCHEN DANNINGER Lower Austrian Minister of Economics, Tourism and Sports © Philipp Monihart Wachau, © Robert Herbst Wachau, LOWER AUSTRIA 2 national parks in numbers Donau-Auen and Thaya Valley. 1 20 Vienna Woods nature parks years old is the age of the Biosphere Reserve. in all regions. Venus of Willendorf, the 29,500 world’s most famous figurine. fortresses, castles 70 and ruins are open to visitors. 93 centers for alpine abbeys and monasteries have “Natur im Garten” show gardens 9 adventure featuring 15 shaped the province and ranging from castle and monastic summer and winter its culture for centuries, gardens steeped in history sports. Melk Abbey being one to sweeping landscape gardens.
    [Show full text]
  • Abwanderungsgemeinden in NÃŒ Homepage.Xlsx
    Abwanderungsgemeinden in Niederösterreich * Kategorie I = Abwanderung von minus 2,5% bis 4,9% X Kategorie II = Abwanderung minus 5% und mehr Aggsbach * Gnadendorf * Kottes-Purk x Puchenstuben * Sigmundsherberg * Albrechtsberg an der Großen Krems* Göstling an der Ybbs x Laab im Walde * Raabs an der Thaya x Sonntagberg * Allentsteig x Grafenbach-Sankt Valentin * Langau x Raach am Hochgebirge x Sooß x Altmelon * Groß Gerungs * Leitzersdorf * Rabensburg * Spitz * Amaliendorf-Aalfang * Großgöttfritz * Lengenfeld * Randegg * Staatz x Annaberg x Großharras x Lichtenegg * Ravelsbach x Statzendorf * Arbesbach x Großriedenthal x Lichtenwörth x Reichenau an der Rax x Stronsdorf * Aspangberg-Sankt Peter * Groß-Schweinbarth * Lilienfeld x Reingers x Ternitz * Bad Großpertholz x Groß-Siegharts * Litschau * Retzbach x Thaya * Bad Schönau * Grünbach am Schneeberg x Loich * Ringelsdorf-Niederabsdorf x Traisen x Bärnkopf x Günselsdorf * Ludweis-Aigen x Rohr im Gebirge * Trattenbach * Brand-Nagelberg x Gutenbrunn x Lunz am See x Rohrbach an der Gölsen x Türnitz * Breitenstein x Gutenstein x Mailberg x Röhrenbach x Velm-Götzendorf * Buchbach * Hardegg x Mannsdorf an der Donau x Rosenburg-Mold x Waidhofen an der Thaya x Dietmanns x Haugschlag * Maria Laach am Jauerling * Rossatz-Arnsdorf x Waidmannsfeld x Dobersberg x Haugsdorf x Martinsberg x Sallingberg x Waldhausen x Dorfstetten x Heidenreichstein x Meiseldorf x Sankt Aegyd am Neuwalde x Waldkirchen an der Thaya x Drosendorf-Zissersdorf * Hirschbach * Mitterbach am Erlaufsee x Sankt Anton an der Jeßnitz
    [Show full text]
  • Gemeindeliste Sortiert Nach Gemeindekennziffer, Gebietsstand 2015 Erstellt Am: 21.05.2015 14:29:08
    Gemeindeliste sortiert nach Gemeindekennziffer, Gebietsstand 2015 Erstellt am: 21.05.2015 14:29:08 Gemeinde Gemeinde PLZ des Gemeindename Status weitere Postleitzahlen kennziffer code Gem.Amtes 10101 Eisenstadt 10101 SS 7000 10201 Rust 10201 SS 7071 10301 Breitenbrunn am Neusiedler See 10301 M 7091 10302 Donnerskirchen 10302 M 7082 10303 Großhöflein 10303 M 7051 10304 Hornstein 10304 M 7053 2491 10305 Klingenbach 10305 7013 10306 Leithaprodersdorf 10306 2443 10307 Mörbisch am See 10307 7072 10308 Müllendorf 10308 7052 10309 Neufeld an der Leitha 10309 ST 2491 10310 Oggau am Neusiedler See 10310 M 7063 10311 Oslip 10311 7064 10312 Purbach am Neusiedler See 10312 ST 7083 10313 Sankt Margarethen im Burgenland 10313 M 7062 10314 Schützen am Gebirge 10314 7081 10315 Siegendorf 10315 M 7011 10316 Steinbrunn 10316 M 7035 2491 10317 Trausdorf an der Wulka 10317 7061 10318 Wimpassing an der Leitha 10318 2485 10319 Wulkaprodersdorf 10319 M 7041 10320 Loretto 10320 M 2443 10321 Stotzing 10321 2443 10322 Zillingtal 10322 7034 7033 7035 10323 Zagersdorf 10323 7011 10401 Bocksdorf 10401 7551 10402 Burgauberg-Neudauberg 10402 8291 8292 10403 Eberau 10403 M 7521 7522 10404 Gerersdorf-Sulz 10404 7542 7540 10405 Güssing 10405 ST 7540 7542 10406 Güttenbach 10406 M 7536 10407 Heiligenbrunn 10407 7522 10408 Kukmirn 10408 M 7543 10409 Neuberg im Burgenland 10409 7537 10410 Neustift bei Güssing 10410 7540 10411 Olbendorf 10411 7534 10412 Ollersdorf im Burgenland 10412 M 7533 8292 Q: STATISTIK AUSTRIA 1 / 58 Gemeindeliste sortiert nach Gemeindekennziffer, Gebietsstand
    [Show full text]
  • Verbesserte Busverbindungen in Der Rax-Schneeberg-Semmering-Wechsel-Region Ab 11. Dezember 2011
    Verbesserte Busverbindungen in der Rax-Schneeberg-Semmering-Wechsel-Region ab 11. Dezember 2011 Wie schon in den Vorjahren hat auch heuer die Busfirma Retter, die in Nachfolge des Postbusses fast den gesamten Linienbusverkehr im Bezirk Neunkirchen im südlichen Niederösterreich betreibt, auch mit dem kommenden Fahrplanwechsel weitere Ver- besserungen ihres Angebotes für Wanderer und Bergsteiger vorgenommen, die im Folgenden kurz zusammengefasst werden und zu deren Inanspruchnahme durch die Bergsteigerschaft aufgerufen wird, um diese Angebote auch in den folgenden Jahren zu sichern! Losenheim/Schneebergaufstieg: Die Busse vom Bahnhof Puchberg nach Losenheim zur Sesselbahn verkehren täg- lich ganzjährig um 8.25 und um 10.25, zurück von Losenheim ganzjährig an Werkta- gen außer Samstag um 16.10 Uhr, an Samstagen, Sonn- und Feiertagen um 16.15 und 17.15 und vom 30. 4. bis 2. 11. 2012 an Werktagen außer Samstag zusätzlich noch um 17.10. Mariensee: An allen Werktagen außer Samstag verkehrt ganzjährig im Anschluss an den Regi- onalzug aus Richtung Wiener Neustadt vom Bahnhof Aspang ein Bus um 9.30 nach Mariensee, an Samstagen wenn Werktag um 8.35 in Anschluss an den Direkteilzug aus Wien. Zurück von Mariensee gibt es leider nur an Schulwerktagen außer Sams- tag Busse um 16 und 17 Uhr bzw. an schulfreien Werktagen Tagen um 18 Uhr. St. Corona: Von Aspang nach St. Corona gibt es an Werktagen einschließlich Samstag immer um 9.30 Uhr einen Bus, der an Samstagen keinen Zugsanschluss aus Wien hat, weshalb an Samstagen die Anreise ab Wien zum Hauptplatz in Aspang (dort hält auch der St.Corona-Bus) ab Wien-Matzleinsdorferplatz um 7.55 Uhr mit dem Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • KIG 2020 GKZ Gemeinde ZZ in Euro 30.101 Krems an Der Donau 2.893
    KIG 2020 GKZ Gemeinde ZZ in Euro 30.101 Krems an der Donau 2.893.896,56 30.201 St. Pölten 6.954.506,83 30.301 Waidhofen an der Ybbs 1.314.634,57 30.401 Wiener Neustadt 5.277.014,26 30.501 Allhartsberg 224.660,16 30.502 Amstetten 2.762.048,74 30.503 Ardagger 372.057,35 30.504 Aschbach-Markt 399.419,13 30.506 Behamberg 358.428,87 30.507 Biberbach 235.458,10 30.508 Ennsdorf 315.446,76 30.509 Ernsthofen 234.619,43 30.510 Ertl 132.091,37 30.511 Euratsfeld 279.593,39 30.512 Ferschnitz 187.548,77 30.514 Haag 583.718,04 30.515 Haidershofen 386.734,17 30.516 Hollenstein an der Ybbs 178.008,84 30.517 Kematen an der Ybbs 275.295,18 30.520 Neuhofen an der Ybbs 311.987,23 30.521 Neustadtl an der Donau 222.982,81 30.522 Oed-Oehling 202.015,92 30.524 Opponitz 95.189,65 30.526 St. Georgen am Reith 57.763,76 30.527 St. Georgen am Ybbsfelde 301.608,62 30.529 St. Pantaleon-Erla 273.408,16 30.530 St. Peter in der Au 544.614,80 30.531 St. Valentin 979.762,99 30.532 Seitenstetten 363.041,59 30.533 Sonntagberg 403.717,34 30.534 Strengberg 218.160,42 30.536 Viehdorf 142.469,97 30.538 Wallsee-Sindelburg 228.119,69 30.539 Weistrach 231.369,56 30.541 Winklarn 178.428,18 30.542 Wolfsbach 211.660,69 30.543 Ybbsitz 358.638,54 30.544 Zeillern 198.556,39 30.601 Alland 267.327,76 30.602 Altenmarkt an der Triesting 219.732,94 30.603 Bad Vöslau 1.283.991,72 30.604 Baden 3.027.491,48 30.605 Berndorf 952.239,63 30.607 Ebreichsdorf 1.176.664,11 30.608 Enzesfeld-Lindabrunn 437.054,69 30.609 Furth an der Triesting 91.101,11 30.612 Günselsdorf 180.524,87 30.613 Heiligenkreuz
    [Show full text]
  • Ludwig in Fact and Fiction!
    ,%vieUJs LUDWIG IN FACT AND FICTION! NICHOLAS GRIFFIN Philosophy I McMaster University Hamilton, ant., Canada L8s 4K1 Brian McGuinness. Wittgenstein: a Life. Vo!. I: Young Ludwig (I88f)-I92I). Paperback: London: Penguin, 1990 (1St ed., 1988). Pp. xiv, 322. £6.99. Ray Monk. Ludwig Wittgenstein: the Duty of Genius. London: Cape; New York: Free P., 1990. Pp. xv, 654. £20.00; U5$29.95. Paperback: New York: Viking Penguin, 1991. U5$15.95. G. H. von Wright, ed. A Portrait of Wittgenstein as a Young Man .from the Diary ofDavid Hume Pinsent I9I2-I9I4. Oxford: Blackwell, 1990. Pp. xxii, II9. £25.00. Bruce Duffy. The World as I Found It. New York: Tichnor and Fields, 1987. Pp. x, 548. U5$19.95. Theodore Redpath. Ludwig Wittgenstein: a Student's Memoir. London: Duck­ worth, 1990. Pp. 109. £12.95. Terry Eagleton. Saints and Scholars. London: Verso, 1987. Pp. 145. £9.95. ittgenstein's life has always attracted a good deal of attention. From W his nrst appearance in Cambridge, before his thought was at all note­ worthy, he was taken to be a remarkable man. The Apostles were fascinated by him: Bloomsbury handled him cautiously but with interest. He became, well before his death-in fact, before he was even middle-aged-a legendary Cambridge eccentric. Elizabeth Anscombe, one of his executors, once declared she would like to have a button which would stop all the interest in Wittgenstein's personal life and leave only the interest in his philosophy: she might as well have been Canute wishing for a button to control the tides.
    [Show full text]
  • Wittgenstein on Aesthetics and Philosophy
    Wittgenstein on aesthetics and philosophy Article Accepted Version Schroeder, S. (2019) Wittgenstein on aesthetics and philosophy. Revista de Historiografía, 32. pp. 11-21. ISSN 2445-0057 doi: https://doi.org/10.20318/revhisto.2019.4891 Available at http://centaur.reading.ac.uk/84464/ It is advisable to refer to the publisher’s version if you intend to cite from the work. See Guidance on citing . Identification Number/DOI: https://doi.org/10.20318/revhisto.2019.4891 <https://doi.org/10.20318/revhisto.2019.4891> All outputs in CentAUR are protected by Intellectual Property Rights law, including copyright law. Copyright and IPR is retained by the creators or other copyright holders. Terms and conditions for use of this material are defined in the End User Agreement . www.reading.ac.uk/centaur CentAUR Central Archive at the University of Reading Reading’s research outputs online Wittgenstein on Aesthetics and Philosophy by Severin Schroeder (University of Reading) 1. Wittgenstein’s objections to scientific aesthetics For a short period of time in 1912, Wittgenstein tried to apply experimental psychology to aesthetics. With his friend David Pinsent he experimented on the perception of musical rhythm, trying to ascertain under what circumstances a regular sequence of beats, such as of a metronome, was heard as accentuated (McGuinness 1988, 127-8). ‘Useless experiments’ he called them later in a 1933 lecture (ML 363), and continued to explain what is wrong with the idea of aesthetics as a branch of psychology. The same lines of criticism recur in his 1938 lectures on aesthetics. The following are Wittgenstein’s three main objections.
    [Show full text]
  • Ludwig Wittgenstein, a Biographical Sketch Author(S): Georg Henrik Von Wright Reviewed Work(S): Source: the Philosophical Review, Vol
    Philosophical Review Ludwig Wittgenstein, A Biographical Sketch Author(s): Georg Henrik von Wright Reviewed work(s): Source: The Philosophical Review, Vol. 64, No. 4 (Oct., 1955), pp. 527-545 Published by: Duke University Press on behalf of Philosophical Review Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2182631 . Accessed: 27/10/2012 13:45 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Duke University Press and Philosophical Review are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Philosophical Review. http://www.jstor.org LudwiWiagns i n <:'5 ~ ~ ~ ~ ero e_permission withth (.-.N ~ ~ ~ o Dorth Moor. - LUDWIG WITTGENSTEIN, A BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH N April 29, I95I, there died at Cambridge, England, one of the most famous and influential philosophers of our time, Ludwig Wittgenstein. It has been said that Wittgenstein inspired two important schools of thought, both of which he repudiated. The one is so-called logical positivism or logical empiricism, which played a prominent role during the decade immediately preceding the Second World War. The other is the so-called analytic or linguistic movement, sometimes also called the Cambridge School.' It dominates the British philosophy of today and has spread over the entire Anglo-Saxon world and to the countries in which Anglo-Saxon influence is strong.
    [Show full text]