Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology \ 6OL .O \ PP n
The Sweetwater Site: Archaeological Recognition of Surf Fishing and Temporary Smelt Camps on the North Coast of California
SHANNON TUSHINGHAM Elk Valley Rancheria, 2332 Howland Hill Rd., Crescent City, CA 95531; UC Davis Department of Anthropology, One Shields Ave., Davis CA 95616
AMY M. SPURLING SWCA Environmental Consultants, 7210 Placid St., Las Vegas, NV 89119
TIMOTHY R. CARPENTER Archaeometrics, Inc., P.O. Box 1762, Davis CA 95695
Beach spawning smelt are a small fsh that were mass harvested and dried for storage at temporary summer camps by native Californians north of San Francisco Bay. Despite the importance of smelt in the ethnographic diet, we have much to learn about its prehistoric use. Archaeological recognition of smelt camps can be problematic due to a number of cultural and natural taphonomic processes; the identifcation and fne-grained analysis of roasting pits are one means of associating these otherwise ephemeral sites with smelt fshing. Investigations at Sweetwater, a Tolowa fsh camp in Del Norte County, included site survey, archival and ethnographic research, and micro-scale analysis of a roasting pit feature, providing us with a snapshot of what people were eating in a temporary camp. The study provides a model for identifcation and salvage of these culturally and scientifcally signifcant places, which are severely threatened by coastal erosion and climate change.
melt (osmerids) are small forage fish Despite the importance of smelt in the ethnographic Sthat were a key food source for north coastal native diet, we have much to learn about early use of the Californians. Key beach spawning species include surf fshery. Archaeological recognition of smelt fshing can smelt (Hypomesus pretiosus) and night smelt (Spirinchus be challenging. Since smelt bone is very small, it can be starski), which were mass harvested by ethnographic missed if small (1/16 in.) screen sizes are not used, and— groups at late summer fsh camps that were set up along until recently—no fne-grained studies of fsh bone have the sandy beaches where the fsh swarmed to spawn and been conducted in northwestern California north of the lay their eggs. Groups around Humboldt Bay and to the King Range. Studies that employ flotation techniques north (Tolowa, Yurok, Wiyot, Mattole, Sinkyone) used and micro-scale analyses provide a wealth of information similar technology, procurement, and processing methods about coastal resources, even with small sample sizes. (Gould n.d., 1966a, 1966b, 1975; Kroeber and Barrett For example, more than 2,800 identified fish bones 1960:44). Men caught the fsh with ‘V’-shaped scoop nets (mostly smelt), 17 species of shellfish, bird, terrestrial after the fsh began to “hit,” typically in the late evening. and marine mammal bone, and burned nuts and seeds Women then prepared the smelt for storage in a drying including bay, acorn, and hazelnut from the interior were process that took about two to three days to complete, identifed in an analysis of only a total of 12 liters of soil depending on weather conditions. The fish were then salvaged from the base of looter pits at Tatitun village at transported back to villages where they were kept in southern Point St. George (CA-DNO-13) (Tushingham houses and eaten on an “as needed” basis. and Bencze 2013).
25 26 Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology \ 6OL .O
In addition to fne-mesh sieving, it is also important community, and—as will be described—by the current to consider how smelt camps were laid out and formed archaeological research (Fig. 1). over time. The internal structure of these sites can be temporally and spatially complex, with numerous Ethnographic Background loci consisting of concentrations of cultural materials, Sweetwater was first recorded ethnographically as which most likely represent discrete family camps. “ta'gɔenuLxuntun, ‘Sweetwater Place,’ a camp site with Ethnographically, multiple camps were set up in the several houses and a sweat house” (Drucker 1937:228). same year by different families, who each had their Though spellings differ, the site is consistently referred own area where they slept, ate, and dried fish. The to in the literature and by the Tolowa community complicated nature of how these sites were formed can today as “Sweetwater”: tawašnašrәn (Gould 1966a), make their recordation an issue—leading to questions of TO-GHfOR’S-NO-hXUN in Tolowa unifon (Bommelyn lumping vs. splitting. The sites are often quite large and 1989; Reed 1999; Tolowa Language Class 1972), ephemeral, and signifcant midden buildup is atypical. Taa-gha'sr-naa-lhxvn (where Taa-gha'sr-naa = water and Natural erosional processes also dramatically impact Lhxvn = sweet) in Tolowa Practical Alphabet (Loren the visibility of these endangered sites. Wind action and Bommelyn, personal communication 2007). The site coastal processes constantly shift and erode the dunes was used as a smelt camp by Tolowa people until about and sandy beaches where smelt camps are located; the 1930s (Loren Bommelyn, personal communication archaeological exposures vary considerably from year 2004). The 1930s date is supported by testimony by to year, and—as will be shown—even from month Eunice Bommelyn (Loren’s mother and an esteemed to month. elder from the Smith River Rancheria), who stated in Ethnohistoric smelt camps recorded in Humboldt a 2009 interview that she used to camp with her family and Del Norte counties are typically characterized at Sweetwater as a young girl (Greg Collins, personal as sparse to moderate-density shellfish scatters, with communication 2012). lesser amounts of chipped stone debris and tools. Fire- Sweetwater is situated north of two Tolowa affected rock and/or imported stone concentrations are villages at Point St. George, Tatitun (CA-DNO-13) common, and faunal remains (often pinniped and bird) and Tagian (CA-DNO-11), and southwest of Etchulet are sometimes present. As the dried fsh were entirely village (CA-DNO-21) on Lake Earl. According to removed from the sites to be stored in home base Drucker (1937:228) Etchulet villagers collected shellfsh villages, the only place where a signifcant accumulation at Sweetwater and at “razor-clams clean creek,” a site of smelt bone is expected is in the remains of roasting directly to the south (likely CA-DNO-53), but “for some pits, where people cooked their meals during smelt camp. reason could not take surf fish when they ran on the Thus, recognition and fine-grained analysis of these beach there.” This could be because Sweetwater’s last features is essential to associating temporary camps with Etchulet owner transferred rights to the site to his son-in- smelt fshing. law, who was from Tatatun (a village once located at present-day Crescent City) (Drucker 1937:228). Perhaps this transfer of rights allowed for shellfsh collecting but SWEETWATER not surf fishing. The ultimate answer to this question, Investigations at Sweetwater, an ethnohistoric surf- however, remains unclear. fsh camp located in Del Norte County, exemplify the Based on oral histories from Tolowa elders recorded complexities inherent in recognizing and recording these in the early 1960s, Gould (1966a) found that Sweetwater scientifcally and culturally signifcant sites. Sweetwater was also associated with the ethnographic village of is situated along a long strip of sandy beach that lies Tatitun (CA-DNO-13) at southern Point St. George. between Point St. George and Lake Earl, and that has He hypothesized that prehistoric villagers at Tagian been used by generations of Tolowa people for smelt (CA-DNO-11), a village on the northern end of Point fshing and shellfsh collecting, a fact that is supported St. George and the location of his 1964 excavations by ethnography, by members of the modern Tolowa (Gould 1966a), also used Sweetwater, based on clear ARTICLE | The Sweetwater Site: Archaeological Recognition of Surf Fishing and Temporary Smelt Camps on the North Coast of California \ 4USHINGHAM 3PURLING #ARPENTER 27
Etchulet LEGEND (DNO-21)
N Archaeological A Lake E Site C Tolowa O
Village C I F I Sandy Beach Isolate C A P 0 1.0 km
Lake Earl SURVEY AREA Beaver Pond DNO-22
ISO-02 ISO-01
DNO-335
S DNO-1030 w e Old Mill DNO-1031 e t Pond w
DNO-1032 a t e DNO-53 r
C
r e e k
Dead Point Tagian Lake St. George (DNO-11)
IntertidalRocky Tatitun (DNO-13) Area Enlarged
Figure 1. Tolowa villages and archaeological sites in the Sweetwater area. 28 Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology \ 6OL .O connections between the two sites (Tushingham and Table 1 Bencze 2013). Based on ethnoarchaeological research, ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITES AND ISOLATES Gould reconstructed the annual round of Point St. IN THE SWEETWATER AREA George inhabitants, which began in the late summer Site Name when villagers travelled to Sweetwater to harvest smelt (Gould 1966a:88 – 92, 1976). Sweetwater (CA-DNO-335) %XTENSIVE SHELLlSH SCATTER WITH lRE AFFECTED ROCK CORES CHERT TOOLS AND mAKES Tolowa villages were essentially economically GROUND STONE FRAGMENTS mAKED HISTORIC GREEN GLASS AND FAUNAL BONE 7OOD independent entities (Drucker 1937). Each village, for PLANKS WERE OBSERVED BURIED IN THE COASTAL BLUFF WHICH MAY BE MODERN OR PART OF instance, may have had members who owned acorn A PREHISTORIC OR PROTOHISTORIC STRUCTURE ! CIRCULAR DEPRESSION WITH AN ADJACENT AREA OF DARK MIDDEN SOIL IS LOCATED NEAR 3WEETWATER #REEK THE DEPRESSION MAY BE THE groves and salmon trap locations in the interior, shellfsh REMAINS OF A SEMI SUBTERRANEAN HOUSEPIT 3ITE ORIGINALLY RECORDED BY 4USHINGHAM procurement locations and smelt camps along the beach, WHO ASSOCIATED SITE WITH 3WEETWATER BASED ON LOCATION MATCHING DESCRIP TION IN $RUCKER AND CONlRMATION BY 4OLOWA TRIBAL MEMBER 2E RECORDED BY sea mammal hunting grounds on offshore islands, and "URNS AND 2HODE whale claim rights to specific stretches of the beach Sweetwater (CA-DNO-22) (Drucker 1937; Gould 1966a). As seasonal resources %XTENSIVE LITHIC AND SHELL SCATTER WITH CONCENTRATIONS OF lRE AFFECTED ROCK FAUNAL became available, villagers would move to temporary BONE AND CHARCOAL /RIGINALLY RECORDED BY 'OULD IN WHO ASSOCIATED SITE WITH camps to procure and prepare food, and then transport THE 3WEETWATER lSH CAMP USED BY VILLAGERS AT 0OINT 3T 'EORGE 2E RECORDED BY 2OSCOE ET AL AND "URNS AND 2HODE the food back to their home base for storage and later consumption. Individuals within villages, usually rich CA-DNO-1030 3MALL SITE WITH OCEAN SHELL MUSSEL SNAIL AND CLAM CHERT mAKES FAUNAL BONE men, owned rights to resource patches throughout the AND lRE AFFECTED ROCK /RIGINALLY RECORDED BY 4USHINGHAM 2E RECORDED BY area. And since ownership was inherited by individuals "URNS AND 2HODE and not by groups, these rights could be transferred CA-DNO-1031 to others—a condition exemplified by the previously 3MALL SITE WITH CLAM AND MUSSEL SHELL lRE AFFECTED ROCK CHERT mAKES FAUNAL BONE AND A GROUND STONE FRAGMENT /RIGINALLY RECORDED BY 4USHINGHAM described transfer of Sweetwater from an Etchulet man 2E RECORDED BY "URNS AND 2HODE to his Tatatun son-in-law. CA-DNO-1032 3MALL SCATTER OF CLAM AND MUSSEL SHELL FRAGMENTS AND lRE AFFECTED ROCK /RIGINALLY Archaeological Sites RECORDED BY 4USHINGHAM 2E RECORDED BY "URNS AND 2HODE The low sandy dunes between Point St. George and “Razor-Clams Clean Creek” (CA-DNO-53) Lake Tolowa contain the remnants of numerous small ! CONCENTRATION OF MUSSEL OLIVELLA BARNACLE CHITON AND CLAM SHELL DEBRIS WITH seasonal camps used by generations of Tolowa people. lRE AFFECTED ROCK AND CHERT COBBLES /RIGINALLY RECORDED BY &RENCH