A Genocidal Legacy: a Case Study of Cultural Survival
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A GENOCIDAL LEGACY: A CASE STUDY OF CULTURAL SURVIVAL IN NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA ____________ A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of California State University, Chico ____________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts in Anthropology ____________ by Aimee L. VanHavermaat-Snyder Fall 2017 A GENOCIDAL LEGACY: A CASE STUDY OF CULTURAL SURVIVAL IN NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA A Thesis by Aimee L. VanHavermaat-Snyder Fall 2017 APPROVED BY THE INTERIM DEAN OF GRADUATE STUDIES: _________________________________ Sharon Barrios, Ph.D. APPROVED BY THE GRADUATE ADVISORY COMMITTEE: ______________________________ _________________________________ Guy Q. King, Ph.D. Antoinette Martinez, Ph.D., Chair Graduate Coordinator _________________________________ Frank Bayham, Ph.D. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to begin by thanking the Bear River Band at Rohnerville Rancheria for their support of the Benbow Archaeological Project and this thesis. I would also like to thank Erika Cooper, THPO for the Bear River Band at Rohnerville Rancheria, Rick Fitzgerald of California State Parks, Kevin Dalton, and everyone involved with the Benbow Archaeological Project. A huge thanks goes to Greg Collins of California State Parks for leading this archaeological endeavor and for supporting this thesis work. Thank you to my thesis committee, Antoinette Martinez and Frank Bayham. Nette, your guidance and influence as an archaeologist, anthropologist, teacher, and friend have meant so much to me. The profound impact of your teaching career is immeasurable, and I count myself lucky to have studied and grown under your guidance. You have changed me and will forever be my example of a strong, brilliant, kind, and powerful woman. Frank, I have had so much fun working with you as your ISA, having you on my crew at Benbow, in class, on this thesis, and beyond! Dad, Mom (Lisa Pizza), and brother, I know how truly lucky I am to have such an amazing family. I thank you for your support throughout my entire life in whatever I have chosen to do and your never-ending supply of love and laughter. Thank you for taking care of Lil’ Stinky while I wrote this thesis. Graduate school has introduced me to some important people in my life but never did I think I would make such long lasting friendships. I would also like to thank all of my friends and family in Southern California for maintaining relationships with me even from afar, especially James Monge and Lauren Bailey-Chaidez. Jack Scott, thank iii you for keeping me employed at the BLM, for nagging me about my thesis, and always bringing me gifts of wine. Benbow is a special place for me personally but in particular it is where I really got to know my husband, Devin, and where we started our friendship which turned into a life-long commitment to each other. Devin, thank you for always taking care of your family and supporting me through this long process. I love you. Finally, to my daughter Sonora Grace, you changed everything. Life now has meaning that I never could have imagined. Mama loves you. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE Acknowledgments....................................................................................................... iii List of Tables .............................................................................................................. viii List of Figures............................................................................................................. ix Abstract....................................................................................................................... x CHAPTER I. Introduction............................................................................................... 1 Benbow: A Case Study ................................................................. 2 Purpose of Study........................................................................... 2 Research Objectives...................................................................... 4 Terminology.................................................................................. 6 Thesis Organization and Chapter Content .................................... 8 II. A Legacy of Genocide .............................................................................. 10 A Brief History of Genocide in Northwestern California............. 10 The Question of Genocide ............................................................ 11 Anthropology and the Study of Genocide .................................... 14 State and Federal Laws ................................................................. 15 “Extermination or Domestication” ............................................... 20 Militias .......................................................................................... 23 Massacres...................................................................................... 24 Kos-tci-kun-dun............................................................................. 31 Chapter Summary ......................................................................... 33 III. Understanding the Contact Period in Northern California Using the Landscape Approach........................................................................... 35 Postprocessual Archaeology in Americanist Archaeology........... 36 Colonialism and Culture Contact Studies..................................... 37 Agency in Landscape Theory ....................................................... 40 Landscape Archaeology................................................................ 41 v CHAPTER PAGE Collaborative Archaeology and Decolonizing Archaeological Practice ....................................................... 44 Chapter Summary ......................................................................... 49 IV. A Brief History of Sinkyone Ethnography ............................................... 51 “Salvage” Ethnography and Biased Histories............................... 51 Sinkyone Ethnographies ............................................................... 53 Sinkyone Informants..................................................................... 57 Chapter Summary ......................................................................... 70 V. Archaeological and Ethnographic Context ............................................... 71 Archaeological Context ................................................................ 71 Late or Emergent Period (1100 to 150 B.P.) ................................ 74 Post-Contact Period (150 B.P. to Present).................................... 76 Ethnographic Context ................................................................... 77 Chapter Summary ......................................................................... 84 VI. A Case Study: The Benbow Archaeological Project ................................ 86 The Case Study ............................................................................. 87 Historical Background of the Study Area..................................... 87 Field Methods and Archaeological Sites ...................................... 88 Results........................................................................................... 92 Discussion..................................................................................... 97 Pre-Historic Significance.............................................................. 98 Post-Contact Significance............................................................. 99 Interpretations ............................................................................... 100 Chapter Summary ......................................................................... 105 VII. Discussion and Interpretation ................................................................... 107 Archaeology and Anthropology.................................................... 108 Applying Landscape Theory......................................................... 108 Survival and Adaptation at Benbow: The Cabin .......................... 112 A Genocidal Legacy: Northwestern California at Contact........... 118 Living in the Aftermath of Genocide............................................ 119 Chapter Summary ......................................................................... 120 vi CHAPTER PAGE VIII. Summary and Conclusion......................................................................... 121 Collaboration................................................................................. 121 Modern Significance..................................................................... 124 Current Issues................................................................................ 125 Conclusion .................................................................................... 127 References/Works....................................................................................................... 129 Appendix Permission Letter................................................................................................. 151 vii LIST OF TABLES TABLE PAGE 1. Unit 3 Artifact Types by Level ................................................................. 95 2. Unit 4 Artifact Types by Level ................................................................. 96 viii LIST OF FIGURES FIGURE PAGE 1. Benbow Archaeological Project Location Map........................................ 3 2. Map of Early Indian Massacre Site Adapted from Cook’s Original Sketch Map..........................................................................