PBOCEEDINGS

SOCIETY OF ANTIQUARIES OF SCOTLAND,

SESSIONS MDCCCLVII.-VIII.——MDCOCLIX.-LX.

VOL. III.

EDINBUKGH: PRINTED FOR THE SOCIETY BY NEILL AND COMPANY.

MUCCCLXII.

. TS N TE N C0

Extract from Council Minutes. List of Offlce-Bearers 1859-60. List of Fellows, June 1860. Lis Honorarf o t y Members, November 1860. Table Contentf so . III. Partf II so . , sI ..i ii . LisIllustrationsf o t , .....x i . Proceedings durin Seventy-eighte 1 gth . h Session . , Proceedings durin1 Seventy-ninte 15 gth . h Session . , Proceeding1 32 s durin . Eightiete gth . h Session . , Index, ...... 7 50 . TABL F CONTENTSO E ,

PART I., 1857-58.

PAGE President's Address. By COSMO INNES, V.P.S.A. Scot.,... 3 Historical Description of the Altar-Piece, painted in the reign of King James Thire th f Scotlanddo Palace th f n Holyroodi ,eo Dy AB vi. e LATNG, P.S.A. Scot. (Plate I.), .....8 . NoticAnciene th f eo t Monument, suppose e tha b f James o to dt , first Earl of Morton, in the Church of Dalkeith. By JAMES DBUMMOND, R.S.A., F.S.A. Scot. (Plates II., II.*), ..... 25 Remark Roune th n so d Towe Brechinf . o rJERVISE A y B . , Corr. Mem. S.A, Scot. (Plate III.), ...... 28 NoticLoce Isle th Banchoryf f th he o o f eo othed an , r example Crannogesf so . By JOSEPH ROBEKTSON, F.S.A. Scot., .... 35 Notice of the Boman Altars, &c., presented by the Right Hon. Sir GEORGE CLER Penicuikf Ko , Bart. (Plate IV.), ...7 3 . "Notico Crannogetw f eo sPallisader "o d Islands Butn i , e; wit h Plansy B . JOHN MACKINLAY, F.S.A. Scot. (Plate V.), ..3 4 . Notic Hile Toma Roseislef f th eo o l n bo , Morayshire, recently opene dals; o of the Chambered Cairns and Stone Circles at Clava, on Nairnside. By COSMO INNES, V.P.S.A. Scot. (Plates VI., VII.), ... 40 Account of a recent discovery of Stone Cists, containing Urns and human bones, in the farm of Windymains, Humble, Haddingtonshire. By Mr EOBEET FOEMAN ; communicate Reve th .y db JAME S DODS, Dunbar0 5 , PresenOe nth tQuestion e Statth f o e , " Wher Johs ewa n Knox borny ?B " JOHN RICHAEDSON, Procurator-fiscal, Haddington; with Supplementary Notice DAVIy sb D LAING, F.S.A. Scot., ...2 5 . Notic Kere th f Samuelstonf so eo THOMAy B . S THOMSON, F.S.A4 .6 Scot., Notic Sculpturef o e d Stones foun t "a d Dinnacair," near Stonehaveny B . ALEXANDER THOMSON of Banchory (Plate VIII.), ... 69 The Law of Treasure-Trove : How it can be best adapted to accomplish useful . resultsHENEA y B Y. RHIND, HonG 7 . Mem . . S.A. Scot.. , IV TABLE OF CONTENTS. PAGE Notice of Cists recently discovered on the Sea-shore at Lundy in Fife. Com- municated by Mrs DUNDAS DURHAM of Largo, . . . . 76 Notice of a Stone Coffin which contained an Urn and Jet Ornaments, dis- covered near Pitkennedy, paris Aberlemnof ho , Forfarshire ANDREy B . W JERVTSE, Corr. Mem. S.A. Scot., ....8 7 . Notice of -a Coffin cut out of the Solid Book, containing an Urn, &c., dis- covere t dFemea , Forfarshire ANDREy B . W JERVISE, Corr. Mem. S.A. Scot., ...... 0 8 . Notes of some Curiosities of Old Scottish Tenures and Investitures. By Pro- fessor INNES, V.P.S.A. Scot., ..... 81 Historical Notices of the Family of King James the First of Scotland, chiefly. from information communicated by JOHN RIDDELL, F.S.A. Scot. By DAVID LAING, F.S.A. Scot., ...... 87 Notice of Bronze Relics, &c., found in the Isle of Skye. By JOHN ALBX. . SMITH.10, . M.D.,1 Sec. . S.A . -Scot., Notic f Farthingeo f Johnso , Kin f Englandgo , fro mhoara f Coindo s dis- covered at Newry. By JOHN LINDSAT, Hon. Mem. S.A. Scot., Cork ; communicated by GEORGE SIM, F.S.A. Scot., . . . 107 Notice of a Chamber recently excavated in the Stone Circle of Callernish in the Lewis. By Sir JAMES MATHESON, Bart., M.P., . . 110 Remarks Stonoe nth e Circl Callernishf eo Lieuty "B .. W F . THOMAS .L , R.N., Corr. Mem. S.A. Scot., ...... 112 Notic Voluma e f "o e th Account f eo r Willia Si f so m Bruc f Balcaskieeo , General Surveyor of His Majesty's Works (1674-1679)," now in the General Register House. By JOSEPH ROBERTSON, F.S.A. Scot., . 113 Remarks on the Ancient Barrier called " The Catrail;" with Plans. By WILLIAM NORMA . N KENNEDY . 11, Hawick7 . , Notice of the Burg of Mousa in Shetland. By Sir HENRY DRYDEN, Bart.; communicated by JOHN STUART, Sec. S.A. Scot. (Plate IX.), . 123 Accoun Circulaa f o t r Building d othean , r Ancient Remains, discoveren di Sout HENRr hSi Uisty YB DRYDEN. . .12 . , Bart.4, Notic f Beehivo e e House n Harrii s d Lewisan s ; with Traditione th f o s " Each-uisge," or Water-horse, connected therewith. By Commander . THOMASL . W . F , R.N., Corr. Mem. S.A. Scot. (Plate XVII.)o t . 7 sX 12 , Note of the Recent Excavation of a Cairn on the High Law, and of other Antiquities Parise th n Cruden,f i h o , Aberdeenshire . Reve B th . .J y B .• PRATT; with Additional Note JOHy sb N STUART, Sec. S.A4 .14 Scot. . , PART II., 1858-59.

PAGE President's Address Hony B .. Lord NEAVES2 , V.P.S.A15 . . Scot. . , Repor e Affaire e StatSocietyth th th f f n eJOHy o o o ts B .N STUART, Sec. S.A. Scot., ...... 157 Notice of a Deed by Sir James Sandilands of Calder, relative to the Parish Church of Mid-Calder. By JOSEPH ROBERTSON, F.S.A. Scot. (Plates XVIII., XIX.) ...... 0 16 . Notic f Armoriaeo l Bearing Inscriptiond san Churce th n si f Mid-Calder ho . By JOHN STUART, Sec. S.A. Scot. (Plates XX., XXI.), . . 166 Proposal Cleaninr sfo Lightind gan Cite g th Edinburgf yo yeae th r n hi 1735 . With Explanatory Remarks by DAVID LAING, F.S.A. Scot., . 171 Descriptio Isle Caira f th Bute ef o JOHy n o n ni B .N MACKINLAY, F.S.A. Scot., ...... 0 18 . Notic t Govane'S f eo s Hermitage, near Pembroke, South Wales COSMy B . O INNES, V.P.S.A. Scot., ...... 184 Remarks on the Ancient Structures called Picts' Houses and Burghs, with especial referenc e Burgth f o Moust o eh n Shetlandi a y JOHB N. STUART, Sec. S.A. Scot . . (Plat.18 . e XXIII.)7 . , Notic Barroa f eo wt Huntiscarta Parise th Harrayf n hhi o , Orkney, recently opened GEORGy B . E PETRIE ; communicate JAMEy db S FARREB, F.S.A. Scot. (Plate XXII.), .....5 19 . Contract betwee Cite nth f Edinburg yo d Johhan n Meikle Chima r f fo , o e Musical Bells, 1698. Communicated by DAVID LAING, F.S.A. Scot., 196 Report respecting the Applications to the Treasury on the subject of Treasure-Trove. By JOHN STUART, Sec. S.A. Scot., . . 203 Descriptio f Beehive'Houseo n Islane th f Harrisn di so y CommandeB . r F. W. L. THOMAS, R.N., Corr. Mem. S.A. Scot., . . .206 Ben Jonso Edinburgn i yeae th rn hi 1618 DAVIy B . D LAING, F.S.A. Scot.6 20 , Account of " The Dane's Dyke," an ancient Camp at Fife-Ness. By JOHN MACKINLAY, F.S.A. Scot . . (Plat.20e . XXIV.)9 . , Not Incisef eo a Circl f d o f Standin o Markee on n so g Stone Islane th n si d of Lewis. By JOHN STUART, Sec. S.A. Scot. (Plate XXV.), . 212 VI TABLE OF CONTENTS.

PAGE Notic Hospitae th f t Martheo S f lo t Aberdouraa Reve ,th Fife.y WILLIAB . M Boss, Aberdour, ...... 214 Notic Eare Bona th Irviuf f eo lo y dotheb d ean r Officer Scote th f so s Guar d of the French King (Louis XIV.), for Expenses of the Corps, &c. By JAMES LAW, W.S., ...... 222 Notice of a Beehive House in the Island of St Kilda. By THOMAS S. MUIE ; with Additional Notes by Captain F. W. L. THOMAS, R.N., Corr. Mem. S.A. Scot., ...... 5 22 . Notice of the " Quigrich" or Crozier of Saint Fillau. By DANIEL WILSON, LL.D., Hon. Mem. S.A. Scot. (Plat . e XXVI.).23 . , 3 subjece Papeth n Burns'f ro o t s Eeve Pistolsth .y BishoB . p GILLIS9 23 , . Lis f Treasure-Troveo t , from Orkne d otheyan r places, presentee th o t d MuseuEXCHEQUERe th y mb , .....5 24 . Notic"e Bluidth f eo y Banner Drumclof "o Bothweld gan l Brig, preserved at Dunbar. By JAMBS DRUMMOND, F.S.A. Scot. (Plates XXVII. to XXIX.), ...... 253 Saint Maelrubh Histors hi a: Churchesd yan WILLIAy B . M REEVES, D.D., Hon. Mem. S.A. Scot., ...... 258 Notice of the Ancient Church of St Helen at Aldcambus, and of Fragments of a Monastic Building at Luffness ; with Plans. By THOMAS S. Mure, (Plates XXX., XXXI.), .....6 29 . Notice of an Anglo-Saxon Styca of Osbercht, King of Northumbria. By JOHN ALEX. SMITH, M.D., . Sec. S.A.30 . . Scot.0, e RounTh d Towe f Abernethyo r y RICHARB . D ROLT BRASH, Architect, Cork (Plate XXXIL), ...... 303 TABLE OF CONTENTS.

PART III.-1859-60.

PAGE Anniversary Address COSMy B .3 O 32 INNES . , F.S.A . . Soot. . , Vice-President's Address on Archaeology, its Aims and Uses. By LORD NEAVES, ...... 325 Accoun Lieut.-Colonef to l William Mercer. Autho "f o rAnglk e Speculum." Lond. 1646DAVIy B . D LAING, V.P.S.A . ..34 Scot.. , 1 Notice of the Account-book of Andrew Halyburton, Conservator of the Privileges of the Scottish Nation in the Low Countries, 1493-1504. By JOSEPH ROBERTSON, F.S.A. Scot., .... 353 Statement Kelativ e Removath t Margaret'o S t e f o l s WellDAVIy B . D LAING, V.P.S.A. Scot., ...... 365 Notice of an Old Gaelic Poem found among the Papers of the Family of Fassiefern. By the Bev. THOMAS MACLATJCHLAN, F.S.A. Scot., . 367 Notee Antiquitieth n so f Kinross-shireo s ROBERy B . T ANNAN, Surgeon, Kinross, ...... 5 37 . Notic Medallioa f o e f Pauno l Jones, give himselBelshes y nb Mr f o t fo s Edinburgh presentew no Societye d th an o ,d t , together wit Privae hth - teer's Autograph Letter. By Professor A. CAMPBELL SWINTON, F.S.A. Scot.; communicated by COSMO INNES, F.S.A. Scot., . . 391 Notice of a Rare Medal of Provost Drummond of Edinburgh. Presented to the Societ GEORGy yb E SIM, F.S.A. Scot., ...3 39 . Notice respecting an Illuminated MS. on Vellum which formerly belonged to Mary, Queen of Scots. Communicated by Professor C. PIAZZI SMYTH, throug . SMITHM . . hR , F.S.A.39 . . Scot.4, Accoun Originae th f o t l Protes Bohemiae th f o t n Nobles agains Burne th t - ing of John Huss, by the sentence of the Council of Constance, in 1415, preserve e Librar th e Universit th n di f yo f Edinburghyo JOHy B .N SMALL, M.A., Librarian to the University, .... 408 Winf o e e Us amongs Oe nth Lowee th t r Order Scotlann i s Sevene th n di - teenth Century JOSEPy B . H ROBBRTSON, Esq., F.S.A . 43.4 Scot. . , Notes on the Use of Wine, from the Accounts of the Burgh of Aberdeen. By JOHN STUART, Esq., Sec. S.A. Scot., .... 43;) V1H TABLE OF CONTENTS. PAGE Note Clocn s o Watcd kan h Making; with Description severaf o s l Antique Timekeepers deposite e Museumth n i y ALEXANDEdB . R BRYSON, F.S.A. Scot., ...... 430 Reference 'Notes to Plan and Views of Ancient Remains on the Summit of the Laws, Forfarshire. By JAMBS NEISH of the Laws ; communicated, with Additional Notes JOHy ,b N STUART, Secretary0 44 . Soot.A . , S , , Concordia facta inter Anglicos et Scotos, 3d January 1322-3. Communi- cated in a Letter from Professor MUNCH, Hon. Mem. S.A. Scot., to DAVI . D LAING.45 . , 4V.P.S,A . . . Scot., On the Use of Bronze and Iron in Ancient Egypt, with reference to general Archaeology . RHINDH . A ,y HonB . 4 . Mem46 . . S.A. Scot. . , Notic f Undergrouneo d Chambers recently Excavate Hile th f Cair o ln do n Conan, Forfarshire. By JOHN STUART, Secretary, S.A. Scot. . 465 On the Connexion between Scotland and the Council of Constance in the Fifteenth Century JOHy B . N SMALL, M.A., Libraria Universitye th no t 1 47 , Notes respecting a Bronze Tripod Vessel, with an Inscription, found at Hexham, Illustrate a Drawin y db d Cas gan f Inscription o t Wy B . . DEAN FAIRLESS, M.D., Montrose, ....8 47 . Notice of a Cist opened on the Land of Roseisle, Morayshire; of Photo-Zinco- graph s Applicablya o Representatioet f Manuscriptso n , Seals; . ,&c an somn do e Early Notice f Wheeo s l Carriage sStreet e useth n di f so Edinburgh. By COSMO INNES, F.S.A. Scot., . . . 490 On the Thule of the Ancients. By W. H. FOTHERINGHAM, F.S.A. Scot., 491 Notice of Coffins (formed of Stone Slabs) found on the Farm of Milton, Haddingtonshire y WILLIAB . . T MM'CuLLOCH , e Keepeth f o r Museum, ...... 3 50 . LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.

* On separate leaves.

PAGE Royal Arm Scotlanf so Altar-piecee th . n dt o Holyropda w 1 1. no , , Arms of Sir Edward Boncle on the same Altar-piece, . . . 13 Letter Head-dresse onth Queef so n Margaret's Portrait, ..8 1 . *OUTLINE e Paintingth f SAltar-piece o th f so Holyroon i w eno d (Plat1 2 e I.), Collegiate Seath f o l e Churc Trinitf ho y College, ..2 2 . Gold Armle tHighlandse foun Mosa th n n di si , ...3 2 . Gold Ornament found in a Moss in the Highlands, ... 24 *MONUMEN Dalkeitn Ti h Churc II.*)hd (Platean , . sII ..6 2 . Shields on a Monument in Dalkeith Church, .... 26 Cushion below the Heads of the Figures on the Monument at Dalkeith Church, ...... 7 2 . *ELEVATION, Sectional Drawings, &c. of the Round Tower of Brechin (Plate III.), ...... 29 Ecclesiastical Figures on the door of the Kound Tower, ... 30 Animals sculpture door-sile sidee th Roune th f 1 th so n 3 df o o ld Tower . , *ROMAN Altars, presented by the Right Hon. Sir George Clerk, Bart., (Plate IV.), ...... 39 *PLANS of Crannoge in Dhu Loch and in Loch Quien, Bute (Plate V.), . 44 t NecklacJe e founCisa n tdi near Assynt, Ross-shire, ..7 4 . *CAIKN t ClavSa VII.)d a (platean ,. sVI .... 9 4 . Hammer-shaped Mass of Hard Clay found at Montblairy, . . 68 *SOI;LPTUKED Stones found at " Dinnacair" (Plate VIII.), . . 69 Bronze Relics found in the Isle of Skye, ..... 102 4 10 Bronz e. Spur, . jewelled . , Isle foun Skyef th eo n di , Ivory Chess-piece, in the Museum of the Society . . . 105 Snuff Hor Mulr no l from Skye, .....6 10 . Farthing Kinf so g John, ...... 7 10 . Stone Circle at Callernish, ...... Ill Pla2 Undergrounf 11 no . d Chamber. . t Callernishsa . , *BUK Mousf Go Shetlann ai d (Plate IX.), ...3 12 . X LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. PAGE Sectio Pla5 d Circulaf n12 an no . r Buildin . Soutn gi h Hist. , *BEEHIVE Houses in Harris (Plate X.), ..... 128 *BSEHTVE Houses in Nig, Lewis (Plates XI.-XVII.), 136, 137, 138, 139, 141 *ViEW of Interior of Mid-Calder Church (Plate XVIII.)', . . .160 *ViEW of the Exterior of Mid-Calder Church (Plate XIX.), . . 165 S>AKMORIAL Bearings on Mid-Calder Church (Plates XX. and XXI.), 168, 169 Facsimile Signatures of William Adam, Colin MacLaurin, and Robert Mein, ...... 175,176 *GoLD Disc Ambed san r Beads foun Barroa n di wOrknen i y (Plate 3 XXII.)18 , *SECTIONS of the Burg of Mousa (Plate XXIII.), .... 194 *PLANof the "Danes' Dyke" at Fifeness (Plate XXIV.), . . . 209 *BIRD'S-EYE Sketc Standinf ho g Stone t Callernissa h (Plat2 21 e XXV.) . , Section and Plan of the Amazon's House, St Kilda, . . . 227 *THE " QUIGRICH, Crozier 4 o "t Filla S 23 f o rn (Plat. e XXVI.) . , "Bronze Armlet found near Plunton6 Castle23 , . Kirkcudbright . , Bronze Ornament found at Stitehell, ..... 237 Bronze Scabbard foun then do . Pentland Hills, ...3 23 . COVENANTERS' Flags (Plates XXVII. XXVIII. XXIX.), . 253, 254, 256, Fenwick Covenanters' Flag, . . . . . 257 *GKOUND Plan of St Helen's Church and Luffness (Plate XXX.),. . 299 *ViEW of Helen's Church, Aldcamus (Plate XXXI.), . . .299 *Anglo Saxon Coin of Osbercht, ...... 300 *SECTIONS and Plans of the Round Tower of Abernethy (Plate XXXII.),' 306 Pricket Candlestick found at Kinnoul, ..... 339 Facsimile of Signature of Lieut.-Colonel William Mercer, . . 352 Seal of Lieut-Colonel William Mercer, ..... 356 Chapel t Serf'S , s Island4 38 , Lochleven . . .., . . Facsimil Signaturef eo , Paul Jones, ....2 39 . *PHOTOGRAPH of an Illuminated MS., which formerly belonged to Queen Maryl (Plate XXXIII.), .....4 39 . Snuff-Mill or Grater from the Highlands, .... 405 Cruise or Oil Lamp, ...... 406 Ornamented Stone Ball found in Aberdeenshire, .... 439 *PLAN of the Law Hill, Dundee (Plate XXXIV.), .... 442 *ViEW of the Wall, on the Law Hill, Dundee (Plate XXXV.), . . 451 Cas-Chrom, or hand-plough, from the Western Isles, . - . 463 . Smal.. . l Cla5 . y48 Urn Cupsr .so , Ivorf Ebond o p yan Quaic y Cu Staves r ho . ...7 48 . founCrosw t Craigmilleda sBo r Castle, ....8 48 . Stone Coffin found at Ardyne, Argyleshire...... 506 1 Expense of Photograph contributed by R. M. Smith, Esq. At a Council Meeting of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, held on the 16th of January 1860, Mr STUART, Secretary, reported that termn i , formef so r Eesolutionse ,th Third Volum e PBOCEEDINGth f eo SOCIET SE n progres i O ETH s Ywa s under e jointh t superintendenc r DATIM f Deo r JOHLAIND d N Gan ALEXANDE R SMITH ; and that the First Part would be ready for circulation among the Memhers in the course of the present Session. OFFICE-BEARERS, 1859-60.

PATRON. MAJESTR HE E QUEENYTH .

THE MOST NOBLE THE MARQUESS OF BREAD ALBANE, K.T.

Kitt-^raitents. The Hon. LORD NEAVBS. Professor JAME . SIMPSONSY , M.D. DAVID LAING, Esq.

tenrillms.

Right Hon. LORD ELCHO M.P. ) nti the Boanl o GEORGE PATTON, Esq., Advocate, ) ARCHIBAL . BOYLEDT , Esq., Advocate. THOMAS STEVENSON, Esq., O.E. GEORGE SETON, Esq., Advocate. ALEXANDER WHITE, Esq. JAMES DRUMMOND, Esq., R.S.A. COSMO INNES, Esq., Advocate. JOSEPH ROBBRTSON, Esq.

JOHN STUAHT, Esq., General Register House. JOHN ALEXANDER SMITH, M.D. DAVID LAING, Esq., 1 „ . _ , •»/r ir I f°rT . Fonwn Correspondence. JOHN M. MITCHELL, Esq. ) J •' VI feasnrrr. THOMA . JOHNSTONSB , Esq.

fnratirsnfilnjffitisram. BARRON GRAHAME, Esq. JAMES JOHNSTONE, Esq.

ftariai. FRANCIS ABBOTT, Esq.

IRwptr Mr WILLIAM T. M'CULLOCH. assistant Ifeprr uf tlji 3Hit5trai!. Mr ROBERT PAUL. FELLOWE LISTH F TO S

OB THE SOCIET ANTIQUARIEF YO SCOTLANDF SO .

JUNE 1860.

PATRON. R MAJESTHE Y QUEEN VICTORIA.

1853. ABBOTT, FEANGIS, Moray Place. 1853. *ABERDEIN, FRANCIS, Montrose. 1858. ADAM, ROBERT, City Accountant. 1828. *AINSLIE, PHILIP BARRINGTON. 1846. ALEXANDER, Rev. WILLIAM LINDSAY, D.D., Brown Square. 1860. ALLMAN, GEORGE J., Professor of Natural History, University, Edinburgh. 1859. ARBUTHNOT, GEORGE G, Loanhead. 1855. ARBUTHNOT, Sir EGBERT K., Bart. 1850. ARQYLE, His Grace The Duke of, F.R.S.E. •) 1856. *AEKLEY, PATRICK, Advocate Grea9 2 , t King Street.

1848. BAIKIE, WILLIAM B., M.D., Surgeon, Royal Navy. 1822. *BALD, ROBERT,-Engineer, P.R.S.E., Alloa. 1849. BALFOUR, ANDREW, M.A., Musselburgh. 1838. BALFOUE, DAVID Balfouf o , Trenabyd an r , F.R.S.E., Orkney. 1847. BALLANTINE, JAMES Georg2 4 , e Street. 1857. BARCLAY, Lieut.-Colonel PETER, H.E.I.C.S., Goates Crescent.

asterisn A k (*) denotes Member havo swh e compounde their dfo r Annual Contributions. Till

1854. BEGBIE, JAMES W., M.D., 21 Alva Street. 1852. BLACK, DAVI , Town-ClerkDD. , Brechin. 1847. BLACKIE, WALTER G., Ph. D., Publisher, Glasgow. 1835. *BOTFIELD, BERIAH, M.P., Grosvenor Square, London. 1850. *BOTLE, ARCHIBAL , AdvocateDT. , George Street. 1844. BREAD ALBANE Mose Th , t Nobl Marquese eTh s of, K.T.,—President. 1854. BRODIE . OSWALDA , . 1857. BRODIE, THOMAS, W.S., Moray Place. 1849. *BROWN . DENNISTONJ . A , , Balloch Castle, Dumbarton. 1841. BROWN, WILLIAM HENRY, of Ashley, Eatho. 1849. BRYCE, DAVID, Architect, R.S.A. & F.R.S.E., 131 George Street. 1853. BRYSON, ALEXANDER, F.R.S.E., Princes Street. 1845. *BUCCLEUCH AND QuEENSBERRY, His Grace The Duke of, K.G. 1847. BUCIIAN, Rev. CHARLES P., D.D., Fordoun Manse. 1857. BUIST, ANDREW WALKER, of Berryhills, Fifeshire. 1846. *BuiST, GEORGE, LL.D., Bombay. 1821.' BURN, JAMES, W.S. Grea1 5 , t King Street. 1860. BURNETT r JAMESi , S HORN f Leyso , , Bart. 1858. BURTON, JOHN HILL, Advocate, Lauriston Place.

1847. CAMPBELL r ALEXANDERSi , , Bart. Barcaldinef o , . 1852. *CAMPBELL, ALEXANDER Monzief o , . 1831. CAMPBELL, JOHN ARCHIBALD, W.S., F.R.S.E. Alby2 , n Place. 1850i CAMPBELL, Rev. JOHN A., M.A., Helpston, Northampton. 1849: CARMICHAEL, JOHN, M.A., High Schoo Edinburghf o l . 1859. CHALMERS, JAMBS HAY, Advocate, Aberdeen. 1855. CHALMERS, JOHN, of Aldbar, Forfarshire. 1844. CHALMERS, Rev. PETER, D.D., Abbey Church, Dunfermline. 1844. *CHAMBERS, ROBERT, F.R.S.E., Publisher. 1830. CHEYNE, HENRY, W.S. Roya6 , l Terrace. 1853. CHRISTISON, ROBERT, M.D., Professor of Materia Medica, University, Edinburgh. 1851. CHRISTY, SAMUEL, St James's Place, London. 1851. *COULTHART, JOHN Ross, of Coulthart and Collyn, Ashton-under-Lyne. 1849. *CowiN, CHARLES, of Valleyfield, 17 Princes Street. 1849. COWAN, DAVID, 17 Moray Place. 1850. Cox,. ROBERT, W.S. Rutlan5 2 , d Street. IX

1826: CRAIO, JAME . GIBSONST , F.R.S.E. Yor4 2 , k Place. 1860. CUBEIE, ANDREW, Sculptor, Melrose.

1857. DALRYMPLE, CHARLE , WesthallSE. , Aberdeenshire. 1844. DICKSON, WILLIAM, Accountant Georg2 2 , e Street. 1856. DOUGLAS, JAMES, younge Caversf o r , Moray Place. 1851. *DBTJMMOND, GEORGE HOME, younger of Blair-Drummond. 1828. DRUMMOND, HENRY HOME, of Blair-Drummond, F.R.S.E. 1848. DRUMMOND, JAMES, R.S.A. Hamilto0 3 , n Place. 1859. DRUMMOND, WILLIAM, Rockville, Stirling., I^JQ 1849. DBYSDALE, WILLIAM, Assistant-Cler Sessionf ko Har3 , t Street. 1828. *DUFF, Captain NOBWICH, R.N., F.R.S.E. 1850. DUNCAN, JAMES, M.D., F.R.C.S. L. & E., 12 Heriot Row. 1850. *DUNCAN, JAMES MATTHEWS, M.D. Charlott0 3 , e Square. 1848. DUNCAN, WILLIAM J., Manager of the National Bank. 1827. DUNDAS, Sir DAVID, of Dunira, Bart. 1850. DUNDAS . PITTWM , Advocate, Registrar-Genera Scotlandr fo l .

1853. ELCHO, Right Hon. Lord, M.P., Amisfield. 1841. *ELGIN AND KINCARDINE, Right Hon. The Earl of, K.G. 1829. ELLIS, ADAM GIB, W.S., 4 Royal Terrace. "•/ j) 1855. EUING, WILLIAM, Glasgow. 1841. *EYTON, JOSEPH WALTER KING, London.

1850. FABQUHABSON, FRANCIS Finzeanf o , Eto5 , n Terrace. 1855. FARREE, JAMES, M.P., Inglebrough, Lancaster. 1848. . FEROUSON, WALTER, Teacher of Drawing, 36 George Street. 1827. FISHER, DANIEL, S.S.C., York Place. 1848. *FOTHERINGHAM, WILLIAM H., Sheriff-Clerk of Orkney. 1850. FOWLEB, Rev. JAMES CHARLES, LL.D., Ratho. 1857. FBASEE, PATEICK ALLAN Hospitaf o , l Field, Arbroath. 1851. FRASEE, WILLIAM, S.S.C., Assistant-Keepe Registef ro Sasinesf o r .

GOODSIB, ALEXANDER, Secretary, British Linen Company Bank. 1848. GOODSIR, JOHN, F.R.S.E., Professo Anatomyf o r , University, Edinburgh. 1860. GORDON, Rev. COSMO R, A.M., Manchester. 1860. *GORDON, EDWARD S., Advocate, 2 Randolph Crescent. 1851. GORDON r JOHSi , N WATSON, Kt., E.A. P.E.d ,an . SA 1851. GRAHAM, WILLIAM, LL.D. Mora1 , y Place. 1852. GRAHAME, BARRON, of Morphie,—Curator. 1835. *GROAT, ALEX. G., of Newhall, 12 Hart Street.

1846. *HAILSTONE, EDWARD, F.S.A., of Horton Hall, Bradford. 1859. HAMILTON AND BRANDON, His Grace The Duke of.. Q 01833. HAMILTON, ALEX., LL.B., F.R.S.E., The Elms, Morningside. 1858. HAMILTON, CLAUD Clubw Ne , . 1850. HAMILTON, JOHN, W.S. Georg1 ,8 e Street. 1860. HANNAH, Eev. John, D.C.L., Glenalmond, Perthshire. 1849. HARVEY, GEORGE, E.S.A. Eegen1 2 , t Terrace. 1859. HAT, Major W. E., H.E.I.C.S., Loanhead. 1856. HE'BDEN, EGBERT J., of Eday, Orkney. 1860. HOME, DAVID MILNE, of Milnegraden. 185-2. *HouN, EGBERT, Advocate Randolp7 , h Crescent. 1853. HUIE, BDWAED, 2 Walker Street. lOJfc826. HUIE, EICHARD, M.D., F.E.C.S. Georg8 , e Square. 1860. HUTCHISON, EGBERT, junior, of Carlowrie.

1853. INNES, COSMO, Advocate, P.C.S., Professor of Universal History, Univer- sity, Edinburgh. 1860. IRVDTO, JOSEPH, Dumbarton.

1849. JACKSON, ALEXANDER, M.D., F.E.C.P.E., India Street. 1851. *JACKSON, EDWARD JAMES, B.A. Oxon., F.E.S.E. Coate6 , s Crescent. 1859. JAMIESON, G-EOB.&E A., Accountant, Inverleith Eow. 1859. JEFFREY, ALEXANDER, Solicitor, Jedburgh. 1848. JOHNSTON, Eev. GEORGE, D.D., 6 Minto Street. 1849. JOHNSTON, THOMAS B., 4 St Andrew Square,—Treasurer. 4 j£ 1855. JOHNSTON, THOMAS, Glasgow. 1859. JOHNSTONE, JAMES, Writer Quee2 , n Street,—Curator. 1848. JOHNSTONE, WILLIAM B., R.S.A., Curator of the National Gallery.

1821. KEITH, JAMES, M.D.,.F.E.C.S., F.E.S.E. 1848. KERR, ANDREW, Architect, Office of H.M. Works. 1827. KINNOULL, Eight Hon Eare . Th .of l XI

1856. LAING, ALEXANDER, Newburgh, Fife. 1824. LAING, DAVID, Signet Library,—Vice-President and Foreign Secretary. 1838. LATJRIE, WILLIAM A., K.H.M.G., Gazette Office. 1847. LAWSON, CHARLES, Jun., of Borthwick Hall. 1849. LEES, CHARLES, E.S.A. Scotlan9 1 , d Street. 1856. LEISHMAN, Rev. MATTHEW, D.D., Manse, Govan. 1857. LESLIE, CHARLES STEPHEN, younge Balquhainf o r . 1855. *LINDSAT, The Hon. Lord, Haigh Hall, Lancashire. 1849. LOCHORE, Rev. ALEX., M.A., Manse, Drymen, Stirlingshire. 1831. *LOGAN, ALEXANDER, London. 1858. LOGAN, GEORGE, W.S., Cler Teindsf ko . 1849. LORIMER, GEORGE, Builder, Mayfield Terrace. I860. LOTHIAN, Most Noble the Marquess of, Newbattle Abbey.

1856. M'BuRNEY, ISAIAH, LL.D., Glasgow Academy. ^.3318.53. MACDONALD, JOHN, Town-Clerk, Arbroath. 1848. MACFARLAN, JOHN F., 17 North Bridge. 1849. MACGREGOR, ALEXANDER BENNET, younge f Kernochro , Glasgow. 1856. MACGREGOR, DONALD R., Leith. 1855. MACKAY, JOHN Nort9 4 , h Bridge. 1852. MACKENZIE, ALEX. KINCAID, Manager, Commercial Bank. 1846. MACKENZIE, DONALD, Advocate, Randolph Crescent. 1844. MACKENZIE, JOHN WHITBFOORD, W.S Roya6 1 . l Circus. 1853. *MACKENZIE, KEITH STEWART, of Seaforth, Beauly, Ross-shire. 1841. MACKNIGHT, JAMES, W.S., 12 London Street. |.t{.!5 1826. MACLAGAN, DAVID, M.D., F.R.C.S., F.R.S.E., 129 George Street. 1856. MACLAUCHLAN, Rev. THOMAS, Free Gaelic Church, Edinburgh. 1841. MACLAURIN, HENRT C., General Post-Office. 1846. MACMILLAN, JOHN, M.A., High School of Edinburgh. 1855. MACNAB, JOHN, Publisher, Stead's Place, Leith Walk. 1822. MACONOCHIE WELWOOD, ALEXANDER, of Meadowbank and Garvock. 1844. M'NEILL, ARCHIBALD, P.C.S., 73 Great King Street. 1849. *MARSHALL, GEORG , HerioEH. t Row. 1844. MARSHALL, WILLIAM, Danish Consul-General, Leith. 1858. MATHESON, Sir JAMES, Bart., M.P., of the Lewes and Achany. $~;f G1828. MAXWELL, Colonel Sir WILLIAM A., Bart, of Calderwood, F.R.S;E. 1852. MELLIS, JAMES, Prestonpans. Xll

1853. MERCER, GRAEME E., of Gorthy. 1860. MERCER, Major W. DRUMMOND. 1850. *MILLBR, JOHN Millfieldf o , , G.E., F.E.S.E. 1859. MILN, JAMES Murief o , , Perthshire. 1840. MITCHELL, JOHN M., Belgian Consul-General, Mayville, Leith,—Foreign Secretary. 1851. MONTEITH, Carstairsf EOBERo , J. . TI , Lanarkshire. 1851. *MONTGOMERY r GRAHASi , M G.Stanhopef o , , Bart., M.P. . 1855. MOODY, Lieut.-Colonel EICHARD C., Eoyal Engineers. 1822. *MOKE, JOHN SHANK, LL.D., F.E.S.E., Professor of Scots Law, University, Edinburgh. 1857. MORISON, ALEXANDER, of Bognie, Aberdeenshire. 1856. MOSSMAN, ADAM, Jeweller, Princes Street. 1860. MUDIE, JOHN Pitmuiesf o , , Arbroath. 1853. *MURRAT, THO'MAS GRAHAM, W.S. Glenfinla4 , s Street. 1833. *MURRAY, Lieut.-Col KEITH. WM r , Bart.Si . Dunottaf ,o Ochtertyred ran . 1855. MURRAY, WILLIA Geaniesf o , MH. , Tain, Boss-shire.

1857. NAIRNE, JOHN M. Dunsinanef o , , Perthshire. 1838. NASMYTH, EGBERT, F.E.C.S., F.E.S.E. 1857. NEAVES, The Hon. Lord,—Vice-President. 1854. NEILSON, FRANCIS E., Banker, London. 1860. NEISH, JAMES, of The Laws, Dundee. 1828. NEWTON, JAMES, W.S., 33 Great King Street. 1836. *NICHOLSON, ALEXANDER, Cheltenham. 1857. NICOL, JAMES DYCE Ballogief o , , Aberdeenshire. 1851. NIVEN, JOHN,, M.D., 110 Lauriston Place.

1846. OLIPHANT, EOBERT, S.S.C., 17 Young Street. 1832. *OMOND, Eev. JOHN EEID, Monzie, Crieff.

1853. *PANMURE, Eight Hon. Lord, K.T., G.C.B. 1857. PATERSON, GEORGE Castlf o , e Huntly. 1858. PATERSON, EGBERT, M.D., Leith. 1846. PATON, HUGH, Princes Street. 1859. PATON, JOHN, Meadow Place, 1846. PATON, JOSEPH NEIL, Dunfermline. X1U

1859. PATON, JOSEPH NOEL, U.S.A. Georg3 3 , e Square. 1859. PATTON, GEORGE, Advocate, Heriot Eow. 1855. FENDER, JOHN, Manchester. 1860. PIERSON, JAMES ALEX. Guynde Th , , Forfarsliire. 1860. PRIMROSE, Hon. BOUVERI Mora2 2 , EyF. Place.

185'6. EAMSAY, WILLIAM, Professor of Humanity, University, Glasgow. 1860. EEID, JAMBS, Secretary, Commercial Bank. 1849. EHIND, DAVID, F.E.S.E., Architect. 1850. BICHARDSON, JOHN Kirklandse Th , , Jedburgh. 1827. *BIDDELL, Sir JAMES MILES, Bart., of Ardnamurchan, F.B.S.E. 1815. EIDDELL, JOHN, Advocate, 57 Melville Street. 1849. *BOBERTSON, DAVID H., M.D., Leith. 1856. EOBERTSON, GEORGE B., W.S., General Register House. 1859. EOBERTSON, Colonel JAMES A. 1854. EOBERTSON, JOSEPH, General Eegister House. 1854. EOGER, JAMES C., Glasgow. 'i-OO 1850. EOGERS, Eev. CHARLES, LL.D., Stirling. 1856. Boss, WILLIAM, M.D., Dingwall.

1841. SCOTT, JOHN, W.S. Duk7 ,1 e Street. 1854. SCOTT, Eev. WALTER, Manse, Whittingham. 1848. SBTON, GEORGE, M.A., Advocate, St Bennet's, Greenhill. 1849. SHIBLL, WILLIAM, Assistant-Clerk of Session, General Register House. 1860. SIM, GEORGE Charlott0 4 , e Square. 1848. SIME, Eev. JOHN, 3 Windmill Street. 1849. *SIMPSON, JAMBS Y., M.D., F:E.S.E., Professor of Midwifery, University, Edinburgh,—Vice-President. 1857. SINCLAIR, ALEXANDER, 133 George Street. 1833. SKENE, WILLIAM FORBES, W.S., Inverleith Eow. 1853. SLOAN, CHARLES F., M.D., Ayr. 1853. SMALL, ANDREW Eas9 2 , t Claremont Street. 1846. SMELLIE, JOHN, Portobello. 1844. *SMITH, DAVID, W.S., F.E.S.E. 1822. SMITH, JAMES, of Jordanhill, F.B.S.E. 1841. SMITH, JAMBS, H.M. Master-mason for Scotland. 1849. SMITH, JOHN ALEX., M.D. Wes,7 t Maitland Street,—Secretary. XIV

•-\ 1858. SMITH, ROBERT M., Bellevue Crescent. 1855. SNODY, ANDREW, S.S.C., Gayfleld Square. 1856. STAIR, Eight Honourable The Earl of. 1858. STARKE, JAMES, Advocate, Traquair-holme, Dumfries. 18,49. STEEL, JOHN, R.S.A., Greenhill Gardens. 1860. STEVENSON, HUGH, Writer, Glasgow. 1855. STEVENSON, THOMAS, Civil Engineer, 17 Heriot Bow. 1847. STEVENSON, Eev. WILLIAM, D.D., South Leith. 1848. STEWART, HOPE J., 35 Alva Street. 1854. STEWART, JOHN, of Nateby Hall. 1850. STRUTHERS, Eev. JOHN, Manse, Prestonpans. 1853. STUART, JOHN, General Register House,—Secretary. 1845. STUART,- Hon r JOHNSi . , Vice-Chancello e Courth f f Chancero o rt n i y England. 1854. SUTHERLAND Gracs . Duke Hi , KG e, Th eof 1850. SWINBURNE, Major-General THOMAS E., of Marcus, 13 Great Stuart Street. 1851. SWINTON, ARCHIBALD CAMPBELL, Professo Civif ro l Law, University, Edin. 1856. *SYME, JAMES G., Advocate.

1860. TATLOR, JAMES, Provos Leithf o t . 1859. THOMSON, ALEXANDER, of Banchory, Aberdeenshire. 1847. THOMSON, THOMAS, W.S. Thistl1 , e Court.

1860. VERB, WILLIAM E. HOPE, Craigie Hall.

1854. WADDELL, Eev. DAVID, Manse, Stow. 1848. WALKER, WILLIAM, F.E.C.S., 47 Northumberland Street. 1859. WALKER, FOUNTAINE, Inverness-shire. 1849. WARE, TITUS HIBBBRT, Hale Barns, Altringham, Cheshire. 1855. WATERTON, EDMUND, Walton Hall, Yorkshire. 1850. WAT, ALBEBT, P.S.A., Wonham Manor, Eeigate. 1856. WEBSTER, JOHN, Advocate, Aberdeen. 1848. WHITE, ALEXANDER, Summerfield, Leith. 1860. WILSON, WILLIAM THORBURN, Glasgow. 1852. WOOD, JOHN GEORGE, W.S., 52 Melville Street.

1849. YULE, General PATRICK, Royal Engineers. LIS HONORARF TO Y MEMBERS

OF THE SOCIET F ANTIQUARIEO Y F SCOTLANDO S ,

28TH NOVEMBER 1860.

[According to the Laws, the Number is limited to TWENTY-FIVE.]

1814. M. JEAN BAPTISTE BIOT, Member of the Institute of France. . ARNAUDF M . J . , Directo Museue th f ro Antiquitief mo t Lyonssa . 1820. PRINCE GUSTAFF VAS SWEDENF AO . 1824. s Grac Hi DUKe NORTHUMBERLANDeTh F EO , E.G., F.S.A. 1827. 5 Eight Honourable The EARL OF ABERDEEN, K.G., F.S.A. 1843. s RoyaHi l Highnes e PRINCsTh E CONSORT, KG.. &c , 1844. s MajestHi e KIN DENMARKyTh F GO . Monsieur GUIZOT, Member Institute th f o Francef eo . JAMES SKBNE, of Rubislaw, Esq., Oxford. XVI

1845. 10 JOHN LINDSAY, Esq., Barrister-at-law, Cork.

1849. r WILLIAMSi GIBSON CRAI Eiccartonf Go , Bart., F.E.S.E. GEORGE PETME, LL.D., V.P.E.I.A., Dublin. Sir CHARLES G. YOUNG, Garter-King-at-Arms, F.S.A.

1851. Eight Honourabl EARe eTh L STANHOPE, F.S.A. s ExcellencHi 5 1 CHEVALIEe yTh R BUNSEN. Councillor C. 5. THOMSEN, Director of the Boyal Museum at Copenhagen. PETE . MUNCHRA , Professo Historf o r Universite th n yi Christianiaf yo .

1853. DANIEL WILSON, LL.D., Professor of English Literature, Toronto, Canada.

1855. Colonel Sir HENRY C. RAWLINSON, K.C.B., D.C.L. 0 Eev2 . WILLIAM EEEVES, D.D., Lusk, Dublin.

1857. . HENRYA EHIND, Esq Sibsterf .o .

I860. s MajestHi e KINyTh r GSWEDEo N AND NORWAY. Eight Honourable LORD TALBOT DE MALAHIDK. Dr RICHARD LEPSIUS, Berlin. 25 Dr G. H. PERTZ, Royal Library, Berlin.