The Geopolitics of Political Islam in Bangladesh
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Geopolitics of Political Islam in Bangladesh Author Hasan, Mubashar Published 2012 Journal Title Harvard Asia Quarterly Copyright Statement © 2012 Harvard University Asia Center. The attached file is reproduced here in accordance with the copyright policy of the publisher. Please refer to the journal's website for access to the definitive, published version. Downloaded from http://hdl.handle.net/10072/47246 Link to published version http://www.asiaquarterly.com Griffith Research Online https://research-repository.griffith.edu.au the GEOPOLITICS OF POLITICAL ISLAM IN BANGLADESH MUBASHAR HASAN · GRIFFITH UNIVERSITY ABSTRACT Sharia law in the country by denouncing secular political forces.2 The military interest in civil politics is hardly new This article traces the historical root of a failed in Bangladesh, as military rule, either direct or indirect, military coup, undertaken by a few Islamists in an attempt has been in place for sixteen of Bangladesh’s forty years as to overthrow the present secular government of Bangladesh an independent country (1975-1990 and 2006-2008). To in 2012. This article argues that the root for secular-Islamist date, however, the military had never held a press conference conflict in Bangladesh is closely connected to geopolitical about a failed coup. For the first time, a support base of events such as the Cold War and the Yom Kippur War, when Islamists within the military was publicly acknowledged, and military rulers of the state systematically promoted Islamic at the same time, the military reaffirmed its commitment to culture and values in the public discourse to legitimize their democracy. own regimes. This paper traces the historical root of this failed military coup and finds that the Islamization of Bangladesh’s INTRODUCTION secular political discourse is closely connected to geopolitical events that took place from 1975 through the 1990s. The On January 19, 2012, at a press conference held in the reason behind choosing this specific time frame is two-fold: capital city of Dhaka, the Bangladeshi military announced a) Bangladesh was under military control during this period that it foiled a military coup, attempted by retired and serving officers, intent on toppling the present secular government of lodge Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina,” Daily Mail Online, January 20, 2012, accessed January 25, 2012, http:// the Awamileague (AL), as headed by Prime Minister Sheikh www.dailymail.co.uk/indiahome/indianews/article-2089136/ Hasina.1 The aim of the failed military coup was to install Sheikh-Hasina-India-tip-foils-coup-dislodge-Bangladesh- Prime-Minister.html. 1 Dipanjan Roy Chowdhury, “India tip-off foils coup to dis- 2 Ibid. The above picture, kindly provided by Abir Abdullah, shows a mass gathering in Biswa Ijtema in January 2012. 60 HARVARD ASIA QUARTERLY | The Geopolitics of Political Islam in Bangladesh The Geopolitics of Political Islam in Bangladesh | HARVARD ASIA QUARTERLY 61 and b) though political Islam had flourished in Bangladesh BANGLADESH: AN OvervieW after the 1990s, equally significant to this time period were the Cold War and the Yom Kippur War, during which In terms of countries with a majority Muslim foreign governments fueled Islamization in Bangladesh. population, Bangladesh is the third largest Muslim country The present failed coup, therefore, can be read as a result of in the world. During the British colonial period, from 1757 political decisions taken in the past by Bangladeshi regimes in to 1947, Bangladesh was part of the Indian subcontinent and regard to foreign policy and geopolitics. known as East Bengal; in the post-colonial period, from 1947 I have two propositions in this paper. First, I argue to 1971, it was part of Pakistan and known as East Pakistan. that the Yom Kippur War in the early 1970s had a profound Bangladesh has emerged as an independent country based impact on Bangladesh, specifically in terms of the promotion on the “secular-nationalist” principle, following a bloody of systematic Islamic cultural values in the national discourse. nine-month long war with Pakistan in 1971. Economically, The second proposition argues that the Taliban’s Holy Jihad Bangladesh is among the world’s poorest nations with a per against the Soviets, against the backdrop of the Soviet invasion capita income of $520.4 According to the website of the of Afghanistan in the late 1970s, had a strong influence on Bangladeshi government, “it has a population of 140 million, the growth of Bangladeshi Islamists, who later captured where 88% of the people are Muslims and over 98% of the significant power within the Islamized political discourse. people speak Bangla.”5 Upon gaining independence in 1971, The central hypothesis of this paper, therefore, argues that the Peoples’ Republic of Bangladesh adopted the Westminster the 2012 failed military coup is the outcome of Bangladesh’s model of Parliamentary democracy.6 The President of Islamization process as initiated by two Military juntas – Bangladesh is chief of the state, and the Prime Minister head Ziaur Rahman and Hussein Muhammad Ershad – and that of the Government. The present legal and judicial system of this Islamization process is the result of Bangladesh’s foreign Bangladesh owes its origin to two hundred years of British policy shift, as influenced by geopolitical events such as the rule in the Indian subcontinent, although some elements are Yom Kippur and Cold Wars. This paper further finds that the remnants of the Pre-British period tracing back to Hindu and literature on the history of Islam and politics in Bangladesh, Muslim rule.7 specifically with respect to geopolitics and its relation to The country has a troubled past of military intervention foreign policy, remains unexplored and understudied. The in civil politics. Of the country’s forty years of existence as hypothesis of this paper, however, is nonetheless developed an independent country, military juntas have either directly upon existing literatures. or indirectly ruled the country for more than sixteen years With a succinct overview of Bangladesh, this paper (1975-1990 and 2006-2008). In terms of political parties, presents the process of Islamization in Bangladesh through a total of thirty-two parties are currently registered in the the lense of the military regimes of 1975 to 1990. Next, I Bangladesh Election Commission (EC). However, the analyze the impact of Islamization in Bangladeshi society, politics of Bangladesh is dominated by two parties – the culture, and politics. In the final section, I construct the Awami League (AL) and the Bangladesh Nationalist Party central hypothesis of this paper with historical evidence.3 (BNP).8 The largest Islamist party, the Bangladesh Jamaat e Islami (BJI) said to be the third most influential party. The BNP is now heading a right-leaning eighteen-party electoral alliance, which encompasses most Islamist parties, including 3 For the purpose of clarity, I will define the terms “geopoli- tics,” “political Islam,” “Islamization,” and “Islamist” as fol- 4 “Country Profile of Bangladesh,” Ministry of Foreign Affairs lows: Dhaka, accessed February 1, 2012, http://www.mofa.gov.bd/ Geopolitics: The impact of world affairs not taking place in index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=46&Item Bangladesh on the national politics of Bangladesh. id=54. Political Islam: The political movements surrounding the 5 Ibid. development of ideology and the setting of political goals 6 M. Moniruzzaman, “Parliamentary Democracy in Bangla- rooted in a literal analysis of 7th-century sources core to Is- desh: An Evaluation of the Parliament during 1991–2006,” lam, including the Quran, the prophetic traditions of Muham- Commonwealth & Comparative Politics 47 (2009): 1. mad, and the prophetic sayings preserved in the Hadith. 7 “About Bangladesh,” Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamen- Islamization: The cultural expansion of Arab and Persian tary Affairs, Dhaka, accessed February 1, 2012, http://www. civilization. minlaw.gov.bd/aboutbangladesh.htm. Islamist: The political movement and the people contributing 8 Ali Riaz, Islamist Militancy in Bangladesh: A Complex Web to and participating in the political efforts of political Islam. (USA and Canada: Routledge, 2008), 28. Mubashar Hasan is a political analyst on Bangladesh who is currently pursuing a doctoral degree at the School of Government and International Relations at Griffith University in Australia. Previously, he worked for eight years as a journalist, news pro- ducer, and media and communications specialist for BBC News, the Economist, IRIN News, bdnews24.com, and Oxfam in Bangladesh, Pakistan, and the United Kingdom. His columns on Bangladeshi politics and society are published by UK-based opendemocracy.net and the Daily Star, Bangladesh’s top English newspaper. He is the author of Politics of Global Civil Aviation and has published in South Asia Research, Journal of Asian and African Studies, and Journal of Globalization Studies. He can be reached at [email protected]. 60 HARVARD ASIA QUARTERLY | The Geopolitics of Political Islam in Bangladesh The Geopolitics of Political Islam in Bangladesh | HARVARD ASIA QUARTERLY 61 the BJI. Conversely, the secular AL is leading a fourteen-party BJI forever. grand alliance that includes the major left-leaning parties in However, this theory of Mujibism lacks any the country. Thus, a sharp polarization between the secular philosophical thesis.13 Moreover, three major controversial and the non-secular is vivid in