The Representation of the Iraq War in Selected Anglo-American and Iraqi Novels
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Representation of the Iraq War in Selected Anglo-American and Iraqi Novels Pshtiwan Faraj Mohammed A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Arts and Humanities Brunel University London November 2015 Abstract This thesis explores representation of the Iraq War in selected Anglo-American and Iraqi novels, examining how several authors have employed this theme in their narratives. The featured novelists are chosen from many writers who focus their efforts and their writing on this conflict. Criterion for selection included offering a critique of the diverse perspectives from which the conflict was perceived, the texts‘ engagement with the political conundrums underpinning war and its approach, how such fiction engages with a contemporary audience and what perspective are deployed to do so. Their public visibility provides the basis of one interpretative strand of the thesis. This study also explores and conceptualises how this conflict has entered the cultural consciousness and to what degree the novels fictionalise the conflict as their main subject, and assesses through which thematic emphases. The texts chosen and to be analysed are pivotal to our understanding of contemporary Iraq and its recent history. It will be argued that the thematic content of these texts contextualise modern war‘s multiple effects within not only the fictional textual world, but as well as their imaginative characters these representations become part of the experience at least vicariously of the audiences who read them. The texts discussed in subsequent chapters are either originally written in, or translated into English (for publication), and therefore all available in English, one major criterion of textual selection. It is interesting to examine the theme of the Iraq War and the historical and pragmatic vein and cultural point of reference from which authors write and has come to dominate the discourse of some contemporary novelists. The goal is to critically explore how the war has become a focal point and the framework of their narratives. The thesis will attempt to analyse how such novels depict the effects of political violence and why they are drawn to powerfully articulate the gruelling reality and experience of those fictionally engaged by and/or affected by it. It will be proposed that novels of and about this conflict are essential to study, understand, and engage with because of the content and the message they attempt to convey which is so crucial to understanding contemporary faultiness in socio-cultural histories, and the critical themes they utilize in writing and the dynamics through which they fictionalize their stories. Such fictional representations of this war serve an important societal, cultural, aesthetic and symbolic function. Thus the study encapsulates how novels of and about the Iraq War reveal and recapture the physical, psychological, and interpersonal losses that are felt by the civilians and military alike. 2 Contents Abstract...................................................................................................................................2 Contents...................................................................................................................................3 Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................5 Declaration..............................................................................................................................6 Dedication ...............................................................................................................................7 The representation of the Iraq War in selected Anglo-American and Iraqi novels Introduction...............................................................................................................................8 History and Development of Novel in Iraq..............................................................................17 History of Literary Criticism of the Iraq War Novels..............................................................26 Chapter One: Rethinking the Iraq War in Four British Novels; an Anti- Interventionist Discourse 1.1 Introduction........................................................................................................................44 1.2 Ian McEwen: Saturday (2005)...........................................................................................48 1.3 Jonathan Coe: The Closed Circle(2004).............................................................................54 1.4 Melissa Ben: One of Us (2008).........................................................................................61 1.5 Julia Jarman: Peace Weavers (2004)..................................................................................68 1.6 Conclusion..........................................................................................................................74 Chapter Two: The Iraq War in Selected Male Authored American Novels 2.1 Introduction........................................................................................................................77 2.2 Combat motivations of American soldiers in Iraq War......................................................81 2.3 Death of civilians or non-combatants.................................................................................91 2.4 Death of combatant and fighting peers...............................................................................99 2.5 Dehumanization and killing in combat............................................................................104 2.6 Conclusion........................................................................................................................110 Chapter Three: American Women’s Fictional Responses to the Iraq War 3.1 Introduction......................................................................................................................113 3.2 Women combatants as victims of Military Sexual Trauma in Helen Benedict‘s Sand Queen (2011)..........................................................................................................................114 3.3 Women as anti-war protesters in Rosalind Noonan‘s One September Morning(2009).......................................................................................................................122 3 3.4 Women as weapons of war and the reversion of Iraqi women‘s rights in Morgana Gallaway‘s The Nightingale(2009)........................................................................................128 3.5 Women as War Correspondent in Ilene Prusher‘s Baghdad Fixer(2012)........................135 3.6 Conclusion........................................................................................................................143 Chapter Four: The Iraq War in Selected Iraqi and Arab-Authored Novels 4.1 Introduction......................................................................................................................144 4.2 Daily spectacles of violence in Baghdad, reconfiguring the concept of malice as a reduction of being: Sinan Antoon The Corpse Washer (2013)...............................................145 4.3 Us Versus Them mind-set and demonizing the other: Inaam Kachachi The American Granddaughter (2010)...........................................................................................................152 4.4 Abu Ghraib Prison torture and abuse, individual or state violence: Rodaan Al Galidi‘s Thirsty River(2009) and Inaam Kachachi‘s The American Granddaughter(2010)............................................................................................................155 4.5 The role of television and war images and their impacts on ordinary people: Iqbal Al- Qazwini‘s Zubaida’s Window (2008),Yasmina Khadra‘s The Sirens of Baghdad (2006) and The Corpse Washer.................................................................................................................159 4.6 Revenge, radicalization and terrorism: Yasmina Khadra‘s the Sirens of Baghdad (2006) ................................................................................................................................................167 4.7 Evil or autotelic violence: Rodaan Al Galidi‘s Thirsty River(2009)…............................175 4.8 Conclusion........................................................................................................................178 Conclusion.............................................................................................................................180 Bibliography.........................................................................................................................189 4 Acknowledgements This thesis would not have been possible without the support, dedication, and mentorship of my advisor Professor Philip Tew, who was always wonderfully supportive when I needed his guidance. I am thankful for his constructive and valuable input. His advice allowed me to focus on key concepts and patterns through which I was able to critically evaluate the selected texts, for which I am indeed indebted. I thank him for transforming my life. I am grateful for the Kurdistan Regional Government and the Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific Research particularly the Human Capacity and Development Program (HCDP) that sponsored the tuition fee and