PRESERVATION and the FUTURE of the BAHAMIAN PAST: a CASE STUDY of SAN SALVADOR ISLAND's HISTORIC RESOURCES by CHRISTOPHER C. J
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PRESERVATION AND THE FUTURE OF THE BAHAMIAN PAST: A CASE STUDY OF SAN SALVADOR ISLAND’S HISTORIC RESOURCES by CHRISTOPHER C. JACKSON (Under the Direction of Cari Goetcheus) ABSTRACT While the material remains of past human activity and the evolution of traditional cultural activities have been the focus of much scholarship regarding the history of The Bahamas, very little has been said regarding preservation, promotion and interpretation of such resources. Experiencing spaces, places and activities associated with specific strands of history offer the Bahamian observer unique opportunities to gain insights into their own culture and character. This thesis explores the wealth of cultural heritage resources on San Salvador Island in order to analyze how such resources could be managed to affectively reveal the breadth of The Bahamas’ unique history and culture. INDEX WORDS: The Bahamas, Family Island Culture, San Salvador Island, Historic Preservation, Cultural Heritage, Site Interpretation PRESERVATION AND THE FUTURE OF THE BAHAMIAN PAST: A CASE STUDY OF SAN SALVADOR ISLAND’S HISTORIC RESOURCES by CHRISTOPHER C. JACKSON BA, Georgia College and State University, 2010 A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The University of Georgia in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree MASTER OF HISTORIC PRESERVATION ATHENS, GEORGIA 2018 © 2018 Christopher C. Jackson All Rights Reserved PRESERVATION AND THE FUTURE OF THE BAHAMIAN PAST: A CASE STUDY OF SAN SALVADOR ISLAND’S HISTORIC RESOURCES by CHRISTOPHER C. JACKSON Major Professor: Cari Goetcheus Committee: James K. Reap Jennifer L. Palmer Troy A. Dexter Electronic Version Approved: Suzanne Barbour Dean of the Graduate School The University of Georgia May 2018 DEDICATION To my loving wife Hadley, your resilience is unmatched, your patience boundless, and I could not have done this without you. To my sweet Willow, your timing is impeccable. iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The following people made this project possible and their efforts toward preserving the rich heritage of The Bahamas is of utmost importance: Alicia Oxley, Dr. Grace Turner, Mrs. Lavette Small, Dr. Michael Pateman, and Ms. Fredericka Dorsett with The Bahamas Antiquities, Monuments, and Museums Corporation, Mrs. Minifred Murphy with the Nassau Public Library, Jim Lawlor and Mrs. Andrea Major with the Bahamas Historical Society, Dr. Troy Dexter and Kathy Gerace with the Gerace Research Centre, Mrs. Valaria Pintar-Flax with the College of The Bahamas, Jermaine Johnson with the San Salvador Tourism Office, Dr. Ray Luce and Carol Shull, experts in U.S. preservation studies. I also want to thank my thesis committee members from the University of Georgia, Cari Goetcheus, James Reap, and Dr. Jenifer Palmer, this thesis could not have come to fruition without your support and guidance. Thanks also to my San Salvador friends Jerry Roll, Shugie, Van, Nicola, Giscard, Captain Bruce, Captain Patterson, Cash, and Pops for their guidance on the island, and to my friends and colleagues here in the States who helped flesh out the ideas expressed in this thesis, you are worth your weight in gold. Lastly, thanks to my parents, you have always provided the positive environment I needed to thrive. v TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .................................................................................................v LIST OF FIGURES .............................................................................................................x CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................1 RESEARCH QUESTION ............................................................................4 METHODOLOGY ......................................................................................5 THESIS ORGANIZATION.........................................................................9 2 BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT ................................................................12 GEOGRAPHY/GEOLOGY ......................................................................12 HISTORY ..................................................................................................17 BAHAMIAN HERITAGE RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ....................46 TOURISM TOPICS ..................................................................................59 3 CASE STUDY SITE: SAN SALVADOR ISLAND .......................................71 ESSENTIAL TERS, DEFINITIONS AND FRAMEWORK FOR SAN SALVADOR CASE STUDY ....................................................................74 CASE STUDY CRITERIA AND SAN SALVADOR ISLAND ..............78 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ...............................................................82 SAN SALVADOR: AN ISLAND REMOVED ........................................98 DEFINING BAHAMIAN AREAS OF SIGNIFICANCE .......................101 vi EARLY CASE STUDY FINDINGS .......................................................133 4 THREE HISTORIC RESOURCE SITES OF SAN SALVADOR ................135 FORTUNE HILL PLANTATION ..........................................................138 DIXON HILL LIGHTHOUSE ................................................................162 LAND FALL PARK ................................................................................187 SITE AND DISTRICT PROPOSAL FINDINGS ...................................206 5 FINDINGS .....................................................................................................208 5 RECOMMENDATIONS ...............................................................................208 CONCLUSIONS......................................................................................222 BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................228 APPENDICES A Bahamas National Register of Historic Resources Property Application Short Form .........................................................................................................236 B Bahamas National Register of Historic Resources Application for Tax Concessions..............................................................................................243 C San Salvador Island Heritage Resource Reconnaissance Survey Form ........246 vii LIST OF FIGURES Page Figure 2.1: The Bahamian Archipelago .............................................................................13 Figure 2.2: Projected Lucayan Migration Routes to Known Bahamian Habitation Sites .18 Figure 2.3: The Landfall of Columbus, San Salvador Island ............................................22 Figure 2.4: Bahamas Demographics – 1713 to 1807 .........................................................31 Figure 2.5: Population Expansion to the Bahama Out Islands, 1775 to 1807 ...................31 Figure 3.1: San Salvador Island Context Map ...................................................................72 Figure 3.2: San Salvador Island National Register Site File Index ............................. 86-87 Figure 3.3: National Register Sites – San Salvador Bahamas ...........................................94 Figure 3.4: The Footprint of Columbus ...........................................................................106 Figure 3.5: Nineteenth Century Steamer Routes – The Bahamas ...................................115 Figure 4.1: Proposed Historic Sites/Districts – San Salvador, Bahamas .........................137 Figure 4.2: Proposed Fortune Hill Plantation Historic District .......................................140 Figure 4.3: The Manor House Complex at Fortune Hill Plantation District ...................141 Figure 4.4: Slave Quarters area, Fortune Hill Plantation District ....................................144 Figure 4.5: Industrial Building ‘J’ - Near cotton ginning circle in the Fortune Hill Plantation District Manor House Complex ..........................................................147 Figure 4.6: Lignum Vitae Window Framing – Industrial Building ‘J’ near cotton ginning circle in the Fortune Hill Planation District Manor House Complex ..................147 viii Figure 4.7: Detail of Cut Limestone Block Construction – Northeast corner of industrial building 'J’ near cotton ginning circle in the Fortune Hill Planation District Manor House Complex ....................................................................................................148 Figure 4.8: Fortune Hill Manor House Ground Floor Plan .............................................149 Figure 4.9: Fortune Hill Manor House Upper Floor Plan ................................................149 Figure 4.10: Elevations of Fortune Hill Manor House Upper Floor Plan .......................150 Figure 4.11: Central-North Rooms of the Fortune Hill Manor House ............................151 Figure 4.12: Detail of Tabby Wall Construction – Fortune Hill Manor House ...............151 Figure 4.13: Raised Mortar Floor and Tabby Bench – Fortune Hill Manor House .........152 Figure 4.14: Western Entry Staircase – Fortune Hill Manor House ................................152 Figure 4.15: Library at Fortune Hill Manor House Complex ..........................................153 Figure 4.16: Detail of Lignum Vitae Lintel – Library at Fortune Hill Manor House Complex ...............................................................................................................154 Figure 4.17: Latrine Interior – Fortune Hill Manor House Complex ..............................154 Figure 4.18: Sink Hole below Latrine – Fortune Hill Manor House Complex ...............155