DOCSLIB.ORG

Assessment Report

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Assessment Report CULTURAL HERITAGE IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT 558 Welbanks Road Prince Edward County, ON Date: January 30, 2019 Prepared for: Fourward Holdings Prepared by: MacNaughton Hermsen Britton Clarkson Planning Limited (MHBC) 200-540 Bingemans Centre Drive Kitchener, ON N2B 3X9 T: 519 576 3650 F: 519 576 0121 Our File: ‘18366-A’ Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment 558 Welbanks Rd, Prince Edward County, ON Table of Contents Project Personnel ........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 3 Glossary of Abbreviations ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................................................................................................. 3 1.0 Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 2.0 Methodology and Approach ....................................................................................................................................................................... 6 2.1 Methodology ................................................................................................................................................................................................... 6 2.2 Approach ............................................................................................................................................................................................................ 6 3.0 Research Documents and Policy Analysis ........................................................................................................................................... 8 3.1 Research Documents .................................................................................................................................................................................. 8 3.1.1 Stage 1 and 2 Archaeological Assessment of 558 Welbanks Road, Part of Lot 19 and 20, Concession 2, South Side of East Lake, Township of Athol, County of Prince Edward, Ontario (April 2017)............................................................................................................................................................................................................... 8 3.1.2 South Shore Preliminary Cultural Heritage Landscape Assessment (September 2018) ................ 9 3.2 Policy Analysis............................................................................................................................................................................................... 10 3.2.1 The Planning Act and PPS 2014 ..................................................................................................................................... 10 3.2.2 The Ontario Heritage Act .................................................................................................................................................... 12 3.2.3 The Ontario Heritage Tool Kit (Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Sport) ................................................ 12 3.2.4 County of Prince Edward’s Official Plan (2006)...................................................................................................... 12 3.2.5 County of Prince Edward’s Official Plan (Draft 2018) ......................................................................................... 13 4.0 Introduction to Development Site and Current Conditions ................................................................................................. 17 4.1 Description of Subject Lands .............................................................................................................................................................. 17 4.1.1 Heritage Status of Subject Lands ................................................................................................................................... 18 4.2 Description of Surrounding Area ...................................................................................................................................................... 18 4.2.1 Heritage Status of Adjacent Properties ...................................................................................................................... 19 5.0 Historical Research .......................................................................................................................................................................................... 20 5.1 Historical Overview/ Background Research ............................................................................................................................... 20 5.2 History of the Subject Lands ................................................................................................................................................................ 24 6.0 Site Analysis and Evaluation of Cultural Heritage Value or Interest ..................................................................... 28 6.1 Evaluation Criteria for a Cultural Heritage Landscape ......................................................................................................... 28 January 30, 2019 MHBC | i Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment 558 Welbanks Rd, Prince Edward County, ON 6.1.1 Definition of Cultural Heritage Landscape (PPS 2014) ..................................................................................... 28 6.1.2 The Standards and Guidelines for the Conservation of Historic Places in Canada (2nd Edition) ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 28 6.2 Evaluating 558 Welbanks Rd as a Significant Cultural Heritage Landscape within Identified ‘Area 2’ Cultural Heritage Landscape ....................................................................................................................................................................... 29 6.2.1 Summary of Evaluation of Cultural Heritage Landscape ................................................................................ 39 6.2.2 Summary of Evaluation of the Cultural Heritage Landscape under O-REG 9/06 ............................. 40 7.0 Description of Proposed Development ............................................................................................................................................. 41 7.1 Description of Development .............................................................................................................................................................. 41 7.2 Landscape Alterations ............................................................................................................................................................................. 41 8.0 Conclusions and Recommendations ................................................................................................................................................... 43 8.1 General Conclusions ................................................................................................................................................................................. 43 8.2 Compliance with Official Plan (2006 & Draft 2018): Rural Lands and Agricultural Areas and Tourism Activities ................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 43 8.3 Compliance with South Shore Preliminary Cultural Heritage Landscape Assessment (Bray Heritage, 2018) ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 43 8.4 Recommendations .................................................................................................................................................................................... 44 9.0 Sources ................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 45 Appendix A-Map of Subject Lands ............................................................................................................................................................... 48 Appendix B- Map of Subject Lands in Relation to Archaeological Assessment Stage 1 & 2 .................................... 49 Appendix C- Proposed Site Plan of Pebble Beach East .................................................................................................................... 50 Appendix D- South Shore Preliminary Cultural Heritage Landscape Assessment by Bray Heritage (September 2018) .................................................................................................................................................................................................... 51 Appendix
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Rather Dead Than Enslaved: the Blacks of York in the War of 1812 by Peter Meyler
    The Newsletter of The Friends of Fort York and Garrison Common v. 16 No.4 Sept 2012 1 Rather Dead than Enslaved: The Blacks of 5 The Soldiers at Fort York Armoury York in the War of 1812 7 Bicentennial Timeline 2 “Particularly Torontoesque”: 8 Administrator’s Report Commemorating the Centennial of 9 Tracking Nature at Fort York the War of 1812 11 Upcoming Events 4 Brock Day in Guernsey Rather Dead than Enslaved: The Blacks of York in the War of 1812 by Peter Meyler In 1812 York may have been a “dirty straggling village,” but Upper Canada’s capital was also a place of diversity. Government officials, soldiers, merchants, and artisans mixed with clerks, servants, and even slaves in a town of barely 700 persons. The number who were Black can only be guessed at. Some were freeborn, others had escaped slavery from the United States, but a number were slaves. Lieutenant-Governor Simcoe’s 1793 Act prevented the further importation of slaves into Upper Canada, but did not free those who were enslaved. Among the province’s slave-owners was Robert Gray, the solicitor general. His household at York included his manservant, Simon Baker, Simon’s brother John, and two Black female servants. In 1804 Gray and Simon both perished when the Speedy, a ship on which they were travelling, was lost in a storm on Lake Ontario. Under Gray’s will, all his slaves were freed. During the War of 1812 John Baker left York and served with the 104th New Brunswick Regiment. He later returned to Upper Canada to live in Cornwall where he died in his nineties.
    [Show full text]
  • OHS Bulletin Readers Will Remem- Downloadable Lesson Plans for Mayor Francis Richardson and Ber Last Year’S Forging Freedom Elementary (Gr
    ULLETIN OHST H E NEW S LETTER O F BT H E O NTARI O H I S T O RICAL so CIETY I SSUE 166 S EPTEMBER 2008 The OHS and CHO Present The OHS Launches the 2008 Cookbook Caper! Forging Freedom Website For the sixth consecutive year, cuisine (e.g. Italian, French, etc), The Ontario Historical Society is wines, desserts (yes, that includes proud to join forces with the Culi- chocolate!), and much, much more! nary Historians of Ontario (CHO) The CHO will offer a wonderful to present the Cookbook Caper! tearoom where bargain hunters This annual cookbook sale and tea can relax with tea and delicious will be hosted at the historic John sweets and baked goods. Be sure McKenzie House (two blocks north to mark your calendars, as this is of North York Centre Subway) a wonderful opportunity to add to at 34 Parkview Ave. in Willowdale your cookbook collection or to find on Sunday, November 23, 2008 special Christmas gifts for others! between 1:00 and 4:00 p.m. Peruse Donations of cookbooks are much through hundreds of new and appreciated and can be made at gently-used cookbooks on a variety any time by contacting the OHS at of topics, including regional 416.226.9011. Meaford Museum Receives Trillium Grant for Accessibility On August 11th, the OHS attended a special event at the Meaford Museum during which it was announced that the Meaford Museum had been awarded a grant Pictured above is a preview of the Forging Freedom website of $31,800 by the Trillium Foun- homepage.
    [Show full text]
  • Invading Species Awareness Program for Ontario 2009
    2009/10 Invading Species Awareness Program for Ontario Annual Report for 2009/10 INVADING SPECIES AWARENESS PROGRAM EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Invading Species Awareness Program The Invading Species Awareness Program (ISAP) has been a joint partnership initiative of the O.F.A.H. and the MNR since 1992; focusing on preventing invasive species introductions to Ontario’s forests and waters. In 2009, in collaboration with hundreds of community groups, nongovernment organizations and all levels of government, the ISAP reached hundreds of thousands of Ontarians engaging their participation in prevention. Hundreds of citizen scientists and professional field staff from numerous agencies participated in our monitoring and reporting programs. The ISAP made valuable contributions to early detection and rapid response initiatives for invasive species threatening Ontario’s biodiversity such as Asian carp, kudzu, European water chestnut, and water soldier. 2009 marked the successful completion of a multi‐year provincial effort to train the bait industry to implement aquatic invasive species prevention plans throughout their industry. The ISAP made significant contributions to provincial, national and international initiatives including the Ontario Invasive Plant Council, the U.S. Great Lakes Panel on Aquatic Nuisance Species and the Canadian Aquatic Invasive Species Network, and the development of the bi‐national Lake Superior Aquatic Invasive Species Prevention Plan. Partnerships In 2009, the O.F.A.H. and the MNR continued the successful joint delivery of the ISAP, with O.F.A.H. staff working collaboratively with staff from MNR’s Biodiversity Section, as well as numerous district offices around the province. Federally, funding contributions were made from Environment Canada’s Invasive Alien Species Partnership Program, and the Lake Simcoe Clean Up Fund, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, and Human Resources Development Canada’s Canada Summer Jobs Program and Eco‐Canada.
    [Show full text]
  • Fort York and Garrison Common: Parks and Open Space Design And
    FORT YORK AND GARRISON COMMON Parks and Open Space Design and Implementation Plan This document has been prepared for the City of Toronto, and is the result of a collaborative effort between the Policy & Development, City Planning and Culture Divisions. Acknowledgement is made of the significant contribution made by The Friends of Fort York and Garrison Common and The Fort York Management Board. May 29, 2001 du Toit Allsopp Hillier · Philip Goldsmith & Co. Ltd. · Pleasance Crawford · Lea Consulting Ltd. · Gartner Lee Associates TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION SECTION ONE: PLANNING STRATEGIES 1. Fort York Park 6 2. Character of Fort York Park 7 3. Connections to the City 8 4. the Built-form Setting 12 5. Views 16 6. Heritage Conservation District 18 7. The Broader Historical Resource 20 8. Archaeological Resource Protection 22 9. Archaeology: Public Outreach/Interpretation 23 10. Fort Restoration 24 11. Industrial and Railway Heritage within the Fort Precinct 26 12. Landform Recovery 28 13. Lake Ontario and Garrison Creek 30 14. Visitor and Program-support Facilities 32 15. Address and Entrance 34 16. Parking 36 17. Servicing 38 18. Fort york Security 39 SECTION TWO: DEMONSTRATION PLANS Long Range Demonstration Plan 43 Short-term Demonstration Plan 45 ii du Toit Allsopp Hillier · Philip Goldsmith & Co. Ltd. · Pleasance Crawford · Lea Consulting Ltd. · Gartner Lee Associates SECTION THREE: PRIORITY PROJECTS Priority Projects 49 Projects related to Fort York Boulevard 50 Archaeological Landscape 50 The South Escarpment and a New Entrance
    [Show full text]
  • 2014 Operating Budget – Key Cost Drivers
    Toronto Public Library 2014 Recommended Operating Budget & 2014 – 2023 Capital Budget and Plan Budget Committee Presentation – December 11, 2013 1 Agenda • Operating Overview 2013 Service Performance 2014 Staff Recommended Operating Budget • Capital Overview 2013 Capital Performance 2014 – 2023 Staff Recommended Capital Budget & Plan • Key Issues for 2014 and Beyond Strengthening Fiscal Health Investing for the Future 2 Operating Overview 3 2014 Key Service Levels Service Levels Activity 2013 2014 Proposed Collection size per capita: 3.9 Collection size per capita: 3.9 Collection Use 0.28 new items added per capita 0.28 new items added per capita and Borrowing Turnover 5.2 (average number of circulations per item per Turnover 5.3 (average number of circulations per item year) per year) 1 library branch per minimum 25,000 population 1 library branch per minimum 25,000 population 62,862 sq .ft. of library space per 100,000 population 63,955 sq. ft. of library space per 100,000 population 9,283 open hours per 100,000 population 9,514 open hours per 100,000 population Branch and 76.4 workstations per 100,000 population 78.9 workstations per 100,000 population Virtual Access Wireless internet access in all locations Wireless internet access in all locations 1076 programs per 100,000 1076 programs per 100,000 Virtual Library Branch Services available 24/7 Virtual Library Branch Services available 24/7 Maintain over 120 partnerships Maintain over 120 partnerships Maintain 86,200 in volunteer hours Maintain 86,200 in volunteer hours Partnerships, Deliver mobile library services, including 2 Bookmobiles and Deliver mobile library services, including 2 Bookmobiles and Outreach and home library service home library service Customer Engagement Outreach to community based groups and schools including Outreach to community based groups and schools including Kindergarten and Grade 4 classes reaching 100% classes Kindergarten and Grade 4 classes reaching 100% classes in in priority neighbourhoods and 75% all other schools.
    [Show full text]
  • Meetings and Event Space
    MEETINGS AND EVENT SPACE Hotel X Toronto is set to be one of the most sought-after event venues in the city, with over 60,000 square feet of indoor and outdoor meetings and event spaces available—many of which are bathed in natural light and offer breathtaking views of both the Toronto skyline and Lake Ontario. The 406-room downtown urban resort offers spaces ideal for private celebrations, weddings, and corporate functions. Hotel X Toronto’s top-notch meeting and event facilities were built to enhance and expand the meeting, event and conference opportunities available at Exhibition Place. Located opposite the Enercare Centre, a 1 million-square foot-convention space that hosts some of the largest convention events in North America, the hotel was designed to accommodate the influx of people visiting the area. Ninety-three per cent of international event planners say that a destination’s cultural offerings are an important factor when choosing where to host meetings and events. As Canada’s largest city, Toronto is booming with culture and is regarded as the top Canadian domestic business travel destination. Toronto is recognized as one of the major food capitals in the world due to its unique multi-cultural culinary scene that pays tribute to the mix of ethnicities and cultures within the city. In addition, world-renowned festivals, events, and spaces celebrate arts, theatre and the city’s heritage all to the backdrop of stunning historical architecture. Hotel X Toronto’s cutting-edge facilities and amenities, coupled with city’s vibrant cultural personality make for the ideal destination for meetings, incentives, conferences, and exhibitions.
    [Show full text]
  • Lake Ontario
    Lake Ontario For the hydrocarbon lake on Titan, see Ontario Lacus. Lake Ontario (French: Lac Ontario) is one of the five Great Lakes of North America. It is bounded on the north, west, and southwest by the Canadian province of Ontario, and on the south and east by the American state of New York. Ontario, Canada’s most populous province, was named for the lake. In the Wyandot (Huron) lan- guage, ontarío means “Lake of Shining Waters”. It is the last in the Great Lakes chain and serves as the outlet to the Atlantic Ocean via the St. Lawrence River. Lake On- tario is also the only one of the five Great Lakes not to share a shoreline with the American state of Michigan. View from Fort Ontario, Oswego, New York 1 Geography Historic cannon at Fort Niagara; Toronto across the lake draining Lake Erie, with the St. Lawrence River serving as the outlet. The drainage basin covers 24,720 square Lake Ontario Basin miles (64,030 km2).[1][5] As with all the Great Lakes, wa- Lake Ontario is the easternmost of the Great Lakes and ter levels change both within the year (owing to seasonal the smallest in surface area (7,340 sq mi, 18,960 km2),[1] changes in water input) and among years (owing to longer although it exceeds Lake Erie in volume (393 cu mi, term trends in precipitation). These water level fluctua- 3 tions are an integral part of lake ecology, and produce and 1,639 km ). It is the 14th largest lake in the world.
    [Show full text]
  • The Fife and Drum, Dec. 2015, V. 19 No. 5
    The Newsletter of The Friends of Fort York and Garrison Common v. 19 No. 5 Dec. 2015 1 For King and Country: 8 Project: Under Gardiner Update WW I and the Mayors of Toronto 8 Celebrating the Magna Carta 3 New Light on Toronto’s Oldest Cold Case 9 Digitizing Manuscripts from the City's 5 The Gibraltar Point Lighthouse Museums Collection 6 What The Friends of Fort York Do: 10 From the Ashes: Breathing New Life into the Our Accomplishments for 2015 Wellington Destructor 7 Manager’s Report 10 Upcoming Events For King and Country: WW I and the Mayors of Toronto by Victor Russell The declaration of war in early August 1914 was not a surprise to Torontonians. The newspapers had warned of the possibility for months and throughout that summer residents paid close attention to events in Europe. Indeed, on the Civic Holiday of 3 August 1914 thousands gathered at newspaper offices for the latest news when they could have been at a city park or enjoying an excursion to the Toronto Islands. A few days later, the Toronto Star reported sales of 100,000 copies of its Extra edition containing the news that on 4 August 1914 Great Britain had declared war on Germany and that perforce, Canada was at war. Within days, officials in Ottawa announced that an expeditionary force of volunteers would be assembled at Valcartier military camp north of Quebec City. Thousands Thomas Langton Church (1870-1950), mayor of Toronto 1915-1921, seen here from across Canada, having anticipated war, headed there on the right striking a jaunty pose, attended hundreds of recruiting rallies immediately.
    [Show full text]
  • FORT YORK VISITOR CENTRE Squeezing up to the Gardiner Expressway
    For professional engineers in private practice JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2016 FORT YORK VISITOR CENTRE Squeezing up to the Gardiner Expressway PLUS: COPELAND Transformer Station Power Boost at the VANCOUVER AQUARIUM www.canadianconsultingengineer.com CCE_JanFeb16_issue_AMS.indd 1 2016-02-05 2:15 PM Flexibility. Now in a smaller package. The SIMPLEX 4007ES fire alarm panel from Tyco Integrated Fire & Security combines big panel features with a small panel footprint perfect for small- to mid-sized buildings. Seamless integration with TrueAlert ES addressable notification appliances, a flexible wiring infrastructure and compatibility with legacy conventional devices—even ones from other brands—gives you much more design freedom. Your clients will enjoy remote diagnostics, ample secure data storage to make compliance reports a snap, and easier maintenance. One look at the SIMPLEX 4007ES and you’ll understand why, when it comes to fire and life-safety, smaller can be better. Find out more about the SIMPLEX 4007ES. Visit us at www.TycoIFS.com. CCE_JanFeb16_issue_AMS.inddSIMP0296_CanConEng_AandE.inddCCE JanFeb 2016 Simplex Grinnell_CSA.indd 2 1 1 2016-02-052016-02-021/26/16 11:45 2:151:19 AMPM January/February 2016 contents Volume 57, No. 1 features Fort York Visitor Centre. Wedged between Toronto’s most Cover: Fort York Visitor Centre, Toronto. important historic site and the giant concrete piers of the Photo by Tom Arban, courtesy Patkau Architects/ Gardiner Expressway is a building that is as unique as Kearns Mancini Architects. See page 14. its location. By Bronwen Parsons 14 Going Underground — Copeland Transformer Station. Engineers are sinking a large transformer station next to the historic Roundhouse and close to other tourist attractions in downtown Toronto.
    [Show full text]
  • Exhibition Place Strategic Plan 2017-2019
    Exhibition Place 2017-2019 Strategic Plan Strategic Plan 2017-2019 01. Message from the Chair On behalf of the Board of Governors of Exhibition Place, and our management team, we proudly introduce the 2017-2019 Strategic Plan. This document is a product of input from business stakeholders and residents. It is intended to serve both as a roadmap to guide the organization, and as a barometer over the ensuing three years to track our targets and accomplishments of the key objectives determining the future success of Exhibition Place. Over the duration of our past Strategic Plans from 2009 to 2016, Exhibition Place has grown exponentially as have the neighbourhoods surrounding our site. We have constructed a new conference facility, Beanfield Centre; expanded BMO Field allowing the Toronto Argonauts to return to the grounds; added an NBA basketball training facility; and soon will open a 400-room convention hotel. In the last 2 years, Exhibition Place has hosted international / national special events such as 2015 Pan/Parapan American Games, NBA All-Star Festival, MLS Cup, and CFL Grey Cup. Our convention facilities continue to be the choice venue for a number of Canada's largest shows, events, and meetings. The 2017-2019 Plan introduces a vision of Exhibition Place as the "Gathering Place" for the City of Toronto and Southern Ontario. Adopting the historical notion of a "Gathering Place", the Plan acknowledges the role this waterfront site has played as an international exposition centre, a host venue for major public celebrations and events, and part of the cultural fabric of the city and its communities.
    [Show full text]
  • 2017-2019 Strategic Plan DRAFT
    Exhibition Place 2017-2019 Strategic Plan DRAFT Strategic Plan 2017-2019 01. Message from the Chair TBD 1 Strategic Plan 2017-2019 Table of Contents 01. Message from the Chair ................................................................................................................. 1 02. Introduction ......................................................................................................................................... 3 Exhibition Place Overview .................................................................................................................................................................. 4 Strategic Planning Process ................................................................................................................................................................. 6 03. Setting the Stage ............................................................................................................................... 8 Listening to Stakeholders .................................................................................................................................................................... 8 What We Heard .......................................................................................................................................................................................... 8 Identifying our Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats ..................................................................... 12 Strengths ...................................................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 29, Issue 2
    Spring 2012 www.canadianarchaeology.com Volume 29, Issue 2 1 Hello to all CAA members! I hope you enjoy reading British Columbia about your colleagues‘ work in all parts of Canada in this Terrence Clark (Canadian Museum of Civilization) issue. [email protected] Trevor Orchard (University of Toronto) [email protected] The Spring 2012 Newsletter contains information about archaeological field activities which took place in Alberta virtually all parts of the country over the past year(s). Alywnne Beaudoin (Royal Alberta Museum) You‘ll notice that some areas, like Alberta, have [email protected] substantial sections involving submissions for the past Saskatchewan four field seasons (2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011). The Vacant fabulous work occurring in other regions (I‘m looking at you, SK, MN, and NU) isn‘t represented at all because Manitoba we‘re still looking for editors to solicit, compile, and Vacant submit fieldwork summaries. If interested, get involved! Ontario For the first time, the CAA Newsletter has a sizeable Wai Kok (Ontario Ministry of Tourism) [email protected] Parks Canada presence: Daniel LaRoche assembled and Adam Pollock (Past Recovery Archaeological Services) submitted reports from Parks Canada‘s 2011 field [email protected] activities in its three regions – East (NL, PEI), Central Ryan Primrose [email protected] (ON, QC) and Western and Northern (BC, AL, SK, MN, YK, NWT). All are presented in both official languages. Quebec Adrian Burke (Université de Montréal) [email protected] You‘ll also find a letter by William Ross, the new President of the CAA, regarding Bill C-38.
    [Show full text]