Mned Strongly by All and Immoral
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE RADICAL CONTENTS : Page No. Editoral : HUMANIST Revocation of Article 370 4 Vol. 83 Number 8, November 2019 Means More than What Meets the Eye Mahi Pal Singh Monthly journal of the Indian Renaissance Institute Articles and Features: Devoted to the development of the Renaissance Movement and to the promotion of human In Srinagar, Journalists' Protest Ban on Internet, 8 rights, scientific temper, rational thinking and Mobile Service Across Kashmir a humanist view of life. Mudasir Ahmad Public Safety Act Order Accuses Farooq Abdullah 10 Founder Editor: Of Spreading "Secessionist Ideology" M.N. Roy NDTV Advisor: Farooq Abdullah Detention : 11 Dr. Narisetti Innaiah The Supreme Court Is Also on Trial Editor: Markandey Katju Mahi Pal Singh Not fair to Farooq 14 Editorial Board: The Tribune Ramesh Awasthi, Rekha Saraswat, Why We, as Hindu Americans, 15 N.D. Pancholi, Dipavali Sen Are Opposed to Modi's Undeclared Emergency Printer and Publisher: UP Police Goes After Eight Journalists in 18 Satish Chandra Varma September Alone Anoo Bhuyan Send articles and reports to: Mahi Pal Singh at E-21/5-6, Gandhi and the Cowardice of Hindutva 20 Sector 3, Rohini, Delhi- 110085. Ajay Skaria (M) 09312206414, 08178491055, 07042548234 Sharm Inko Magar Nahin Aati! Yet They Do Not Feel Ashamed! or E-mail them to: The Daily Fix: Is Unnao case going to play out yet 24 [email protected] or again with rape-accused BJP leader Chinmayanand? [email protected] Rohan Venkataramakrishanan Excerpt : Why I am an Atheist (1930) by Bhagat singh 25 Please send Subscription/Donation Cheques in favour of M.N. Roy: Mahatma Gandhi's Weighty Opponent 30 Pranay Sharma The Radical Humanist to: Satish Chandra Varma, Treasurer IRI, Report on Kolkata Seminar: A-1/103, Satyam Apartments, Vasundhra Lok Sabha Election 2019: BJP’s Victory : Challenge 31 Enclave, Delhi- 110096. (M) 9811587576. to Indian Secular Polity: Report by Apoorba Dasgupta Email ID: [email protected] Second Session on Party-less Democracy 32 Please Note: Authors will bear sole Report by Anjali Chakraborty accountability for corroborating the facts that they Dr. R M Pal memorial lecture, 2019 36 give in their write-ups. Neither the IRI/the Report by Vidya Bhushan Rawat Publisher, nor the Editor of this journal will be responsible for testing the validity and authenticity Book Review : of statements & information cited by the authors. Ground Scorching Tax, by Arun Kumar 37 Also, sometimes some articles published in this Review by: Dipavali Sen journal may carry opinions not similar to the Radical Humanist philosophy; but they would be In Man’s Own Image : Man’s Place in Society 39 entertained here if the need is felt to debate and By Ellen Roy and Sibnarayan Ray discuss them. Simplified by Vinod Jain November 2019 THE RADICAL HUMANIST 3 Editoral : Revocation of Article 370 Means More than What Meets the Eye Mahi Pal Singh On August 5, 2019 a meeting of the Union When asked about the subject of the talks with cabinet was held at the Prime Minister’s the central leaders by the journalists, Mr. Malik residence in the morning after which Amit Shah, told them that no talks regarding these two the Union Home Minister and BJP President articles took place in his meeting with the central rushed to the Parliament house with a beaming leaders and there was no plan to remove these face to address the Rajya Sabha. There he articles from the Constitutution. Now we know presented a resolution to abrogate Article 370 that he was telling a blatant lie. A couple of days and removal of Article 35A of the Indian later, an advisory was issued by the central Constitution, which gave special status to the government to the tourists who had gone there region of Jammu and Kashmir, and also to to participate in the Amarnath yatra to visit the downgrade the state of Jammu & Kashmir to holy shrine, which was then in progress, and other two Union Territories of J&K and Ladakh, the non-Kashmiris residing there to leave the state former with a Delhi like powerless Assembly immediately as there were definite inputs from and the latter without even that. Article 370 was the intelligence agencies about possible attacks incorporated into the Indian Constitution as a by the terrorists to kill, maim and terrorize people condition of accession of J&K to the Indian and disturb normal life in the valley. The way all Union and it stipulated that the other articles of non-Kashmiris were asked to leave the valley, the Constitution that gave powers to the Central many people including journalists suspected that Government over Jammu and Kashmir would the whole exercise had something to do with the be applied to the state only with the concurrence abrogation of Articles 370 and 35A of the of the State’s Constituent Assembly. This was Constitution about which Amit Shah had been a “temporary provision” in that its applicability talking for quite some time. On 5th of August was intended to last till the formulation and 2019 it became clear who those terrorists were adoption of the State’s constitution. But the who were out not only to destroy peace and State’s constituent assembly dissolved itself on normalcy in the valley but also to deprive people 25 January 1957 without recommending either of the state of their civil liberties, democratic abrogation or amendment of the Article 370. freedoms.and even the right to interact with each Thus the Article has acquired a permanent other and with the outside world. nature in the Indian Constitution, as confirmed The reasons given by the Home Minister for by various rulings of the Supreme Court of India abrogating these articles were ridiculous to say and the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir, the the least – like: ‘two-three political families of last one coming in April 2018. Kashmir had been looting the people of the A few days prior to August 5, the Governor state’, as if elsewhere in the country politicians, of Jammu & Kashmir, Mr. Satya Pal Malik, had including those belonging to the ruling BJP, had met central leaders in New Delhi. A rumour not been indulging in that loot and ‘now it will was in the air that the central government had be possible to undertake the development of the plans to abrogate Article 370 and Article 35A. state which had been disregarded till now’, 4 THE RADICAL HUMANIST November 2019 without explaining why this development had People have been denied essential commodities not been undertaken when in the state including medicines and even reach to the government led by Ms. Mahbooba Mufti the hospitals. Leaders of various political parties BJP was an equal coalition partner and even at who wanted to visit Kashmir to see for the centre, there was also the Narendra Modi themselves the plight of the people there were government of the BJP with a full-fledged turned back from the airport. Journalists have majority. Who had stopped the all powerful BJP been barred from reporting anything. This seems government from undertaking development of to be the BJP’s model of development and we the state if it really had any such plans for the can expect to see more of it in Kashmir and state’s development. Even after removal of elsewhere in the country in the coming days. these two articles from the Constitution, more Regarding the release of Ms. Mahbooba than two months and a half have passed and Mufti, Farooq Abdullah and his son Omar not even the talk of development seems to be Abdullah some central ministers have said that present in the agenda of the government. The they would be released earlier than the expiry ploy of ‘development’ seems to be only an of 18 months. The question is that if they really excuse to surreptitiously enslave the people of pose a danger to the public safety and peace of Kashmir by depriving them of all the democratic the state, why are they not being prosecuted under rights to govern themselves in accordance with relevant provisions of the law and punished at their own wishes and hand over the state the earliest? If not, then why should they be territory and its people to the friendly crony deprived of their civil liberties even for a single capitalists of the BJP to be exploited day, not to say of a long period of 18 months. economically and physically by them. We only Not only these leaders, in fact, why should others know that the state has been turned into a who have been kept under preventive detention military camp, almost all leaders of political in various jails, including at Agra, should suffer parties, except those belonging to the BJP, have loss of their civil liberties to satisfy the whims of been arrested, some of them including Ms. Mr. Modi and Amit Shah? Mahbooba Mufti, Farooq Abdullah and his son The BJP government and its leaders have Omar Abdullah – all former chief ministers of been claiming day in and day out that normalcy the state – have been put under preventive is fast returning to the valley but there is not detention, as Ms. Mahbooba Mufti and Omar even a semblance of normalcy there whatever Abdullah or arrested under draconian laws like may the central government claim. There is no Public Safety Act (PSA), as Farooq Abdullah, democracy and there is no freedom in Kashmir. as if they pose really great danger to the public If there is silence, it is the silence of the grave. safety of the state and the life of the people.