SPECIAL REPORT: LOW COST CARRIERS

The middle ground As the region’s low-cost carriers continue to grow in popularity, another business model is emerging to fill the niche between full-service and budget airlines.

By Nadia Khan

ncouraged by the fast-paced Middle East aviation by introducing the location of the UAE is very different to growth of low-cost carriers LCC model and taking it to new heights,” that of Europe or the US in that fl ying (LCCs) in markets such as says Ali. “Our success over the past eight is the only feasible option when visiting Europe and Northern America, years has helped the LCC sector achieve other countries,” says Al Ghaith. “When AirE Arabia became the Middle East’s fi rst signifi cant market share in the region.” Air these two factors are combined with the budget airline in 2003, followed by the Arabia operates a typical no frills low-cost minimal penetration of low-cost carriers in likes of Kuwait’s Jazeera Airways, Saudi model, relying on a single type of aircraft the Middle East, budget airlines are well- Arabia’s Nasair and Sama Airlines, Bahrain to reduce extra maintenances costs. By the placed to prosper in the years to come.” Air and fl ydubai. Trying to fi nd their place end of the third quarter in 2011, the carrier Whilst the future does indeed look prom- in a highly competitive environment, these was demonstrating sustainable profi tability ising for the LCC carriers, a new airline airlines have battled with regional unrest, and healthy seat occupancy levels. “In eight model has been emerging in the region internal and external competition and years of operations, has grown to give the sector a run for its money. The rising fuel prices to carve out a niche for from serving just fi ve cities to around 70 past fi ve years has witnessed the introduc- themselves in the sector. Whilst some have destinations in the Middle East, Africa, tion of a number of carriers taking on this thrived, others have been forced to adapt Asia and Europe, operating from hubs in model which is neither full-service nor and one – ’s ill-fated Sama the UAE, Morocco and Egypt,” he says. low-cost but falls somewhere in between. Airlines – succumbed to defeat in 2010. fl ydubai, launched in 2008 by ’s Bahrain Air is a classic example - defi ning The rest of the region’s valiant low-cost government to compete with neighbouring its business model as that of a premium sector has grown steadily to reach a market Air Arabia, also operates under a similarly value carrier. “Our model is based on the penetration of around 7% – which compares typical budget airline model with custom- premise that a large proportion of the popu- rather dwarfi shly to the enormous 35% ers choosing to only pay for the services lation is looking for value for money from market share enjoyed by low-cost carriers they wish to receive. The carrier has an their airline,” says Richard Nuttall, CEO in Europe, and around 20% in the US. But operational network of 46 routes across 27 of Bahrain Air. “But they do not want to be as Adel Ali, board member and group CEO countries, including most of the Middle subject to all the additional fees for extras of Air Arabia, is quick to point out, unlike East. As well as these intra-Middle East that come from a typical LCC.” Passengers, the much more mature markets of Europe short-haul routes, fl ydubai benefi ts from he argues, want food on-board, a reason- and the US, the LCC model in the Middle being based in a country where 83% of the able baggage allowance, fl exibility and even East is less than a decade old. “Since population is expatriate and mobile with a a premium class option. “But for regional inception, Air Arabia has transformed strong desire to travel. “The geographical fl ights, they do not need the same product

028 February 2012 · AV I AT I O N B U S I N E S S www.aviationbusinessme.com SPECIAL REPORT: LOW COST CARRIERS

www.aviationbusinessme.com February 2012 · AV I AT I O N B U S I N E S S 029 SPECIAL REPORT: LOW COST CARRIERS

national carrier RAK Airways. Suffering Pichler again, we offer all inclusive meals, There is no doubt the biggest impact from the fi nancial crisis 40kg baggage allowance, free on-board en- out of all the UAE airlines, the carrier set tertainment, a business class, airport loung- that Air Arabia and off to an inauspicious start as a victim to es and more. Does the carrier offer value have economic recession when it was forced for money? Defi nitely yes, Pichler states, to close operations in 2009. A year later, otherwise we would not have enough adapted the low-cost it re-emerged, positioning itself between costumers to make us operate a profi table the well-established commercial airlines operation. “People always to try to create model for the needs and the low-cost carriers with its ‘value for boxes for business models, in order to help of the local market. money’ model. “We aim to deliver a value them understand the mechanics of those offering that differentiates ourselves from models,” he concludes. “Reality is far more And this has been low-cost carriers,” says Omar Jahameh, complex. In the end, everyone has to cre- working very well.” CEO of RAK Airways. “Despite our con- ate a business model which suits the tar- sistently low fares, RAK Airways still offers geted customers and markets – and helps JOHN STRICKLAND a full baggage allowance, a shuttle service you make money – it’s as simple as that.” level as a long haul premium airline – just and serves a complimentary hot meal But with both low-cost carriers and full- a service designed specifi cally for regional and beverages on-board all fl ights.” Like service airlines carving out their shares travel that fl ies on time,” he adds. Nuttall, Jahameh believes that there is a of the region’s aviation market, is there As Nuttall is keen to clarify, Bahrain Air defi nitely gap in the market between the really room for an intermediary service? was primarily conceived as an LCC and low-cost carriers and full service airlines. John Strickland, director of UK-based JLS never meant to be a full service long-haul “It is the right time for us to grow our busi- carrier. “But to be a true LCC you need ness as the Middle East’s aviation industry a base of point to point travel and large has bucked the world-wide trend and has enough fl eet to get economies of scale,” he continued to grow,” he says. “Our passen- says. “With limited traffi c rights and a rela- ger loads have been encouraging – provid- tively small home base this was always go- ing an endorsement of the demand for ing to be diffi cult. At the same time our cus- value-for-money fl ights across the region.” tomers were telling us that, whilst they did Both RAK Airways and Bahrain Air have not need all the frills, they wanted a certain been blurring the traditional boundaries level of service.” In the long-term, privately- between LCCs and full service airlines in owned Bahrain Air plans to tap into mar- order to fi nd a model which fi ts both the kets further afi eld – another indication of its needs of the local population whilst ensur- move away from a traditional LCC model. ing a healthy profi t margin. And there is “There is considerable traffi c that arrives another carrier which has been leading into the region via a transit point or that the way with this airline model for some visits multiple destinations,” says Nuttall. time now. Kuwait’s Jazeera Airways has “We are currently revisiting and upgrading been around for what CEO Stefan Pichler our distribution capabilities to better sell in terms a ‘great’ six years. “We have a strong the long-haul markets or through partner market foothold, a solid reputation, and carriers.” He remains confi dent of the suc- have become a great household brand in cess of Bahrain Air’s hybrid model, point- Kuwait and in the region,” he says. “And ing to industry evidence as generally sup- over these years we have fl own over 8.7 porting this middle ground. “LCCs around million people in a country with a total the world are gradually upgrading at the population of 3.3 million people.” The car- same time as legacy carriers are looking to rier has been stretching the defi nition of a rationalise their product offerings,” he ex- LCC as far as it can go. Pichler, however, plains. “In the future, we hope that Bahrain remains somewhat non-committal about Air will be the airline of choice in its home this defi nition -– shrugging off the low-cost country as well as a strong regional player model as merely a label. Is Jazeera Airways connecting Bahrain to most major markets a low-cost carrier? Of course, says Pichler, within fi ve hours fl ying range.” we work in an asset intensive industry and The most recent entrant to adapt this we have to have the lowest cost to grow. Is type of model has been Ras Al-Khaimah’s it a full service regional carrier? Yes, says

030 February 2012 · AV I AT I O N B U S I N E S S www.aviationbusinessme.com SPECIAL REPORT: LOW COST CARRIERS

Consulting warns that this type of ‘hybrid’ less on lower fares, and eventually It is clear that the lines between low- model might prove tricky. “If you start of- taking on long-haul routes and joining cost and full-service airlines are becoming fering an extra level of services, you may an airline alliance. Financially drowning, more blurred as airlines try to fi nd their not get that back in terms of the prices the airline reported a third-quarter net own niche in the Middle East’s aviation charged,” he says. “This may mean that income fall of 78%, bringing in drastic industry. Even the proud bearers of the you are not likely to make money out of cost-cutting ‘Shape and Size’ plans to traditional ‘low-cost’ mantle have been it.” He points a cautionary fi nger to the ex- curb losses. Although other factors evolving to fi t in with the demands of the perience of Germany’s airberlin – the only played a role, many experts have pointed region’s travel market. “There is no doubt European airline to operate as a hybrid – directly at the hybrid strategy as be- that Air Arabia and fl ydubai have adapted becoming a loss-making casualty of its own ing largely responsible as the airline the low-cost model for the needs of the model. “The problem with airberlin is that battled against competition from both local market,” says Strickland. “And this it is neither a full service airline nor a low- Germany’s national carrier Lufthansa has been working very well.” Air Arabia’s cost airline,” says Strickland. “Perhaps it is and the successful European low-cost Ali agrees. “As conventional carriers con- best to be clear which camp you are in.” operators. At the end of last year, Abu tinue to grow their long haul operations, Despite its hybrid image as an upper- Dhabi’s own announced we will see low-cost carriers expanding cost airline, airberlin actually began that it would be spending US$94.9 mil- their intra-regional network,” he states. operations as a successful low-cost air- lion to increase its stake in airberlin – “Having said that, the dynamics of both line before taking on the model of a full from 3% to more than 29%. The deal also the industry and the market are in con- service carrier. This involved focusing includes fi nancing of up to $255 million stant change and so it will be interesting to more on the quality of its service and over the next fi ve years to the carrier. see how all this will eventually evolve.”

www.aviationbusinessme.com February 2012 · AV I AT I O N B U S I N E S S 031