'Internationalism from Below'
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INTERNATIONALISM FROM BELOW Reclaiming a hidden communist tradition to challenge the nation-state and capitalist empire Allan Armstrong Volume 1 The historical development of nation-states and nationalism up to 1848 Volume 2 The world of nation-states and nationalism between the Communist League and the early Second International (1845-95) Volume 3 Social democrats, nation-states and nationalism in the age of the Second International (1889 - 1916) In preparation Volume 4 Communists, nation-states and nationalism during the 1916-21/3 International Revolutionary Wave 1 Dedication to Myra Galletly Writing this book would not have been possible without the support of my partner Myra. Myra encouraged me to take early retirement from my teaching job, so that I have had the time to do the research and writing for this book. She has also accompanied me on many journeys to places that appear in this book, from Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Mexico and the USA in the Americas, to Crimea in the south and Estonia in the north of Europe. We have also spent a great deal of enjoyable time, closer to home, in Ireland, Wales, England and many parts of Scotland. Our two daughters, Caitrin and Eilis, now grown-up, were with us on our earlier journeys. Caitrin and her partner, John have gone on to take our grand daughter, Aoife, on their trips to Europe. Eilis and her partner Luke have become an independent global travellers, visiting many places way beyond those Myra and I have ever reached. Many of the places we have visited have left Myra and myself in awe, either of their natural beauty, or of the human imagination and tenacity involved in their creation. We have also developed a deep attachment to our own city of Edinburgh with its hidden histories, its vibrant cultural scene (especially beneath the veneer of all the official events). We have made close friends in many places through our work as teachers, in trade union and political campaigning, and through our love of music and conversation. But, most of all, Myra’s enormous generosity of spirit has hugely contributed to our shared desire, through good times and not so good times, to enjoy life in the here and now, whilst joining with others in the struggle for a better future. 2 Thanks to Bob Goupillot and Iain Robertson Bob and Iain are close friends and comrades, and fellow members of the Republican Communist Network. Bob’s greatest encouragement has been his belief that these books have something important to say. Thus, Bob has pushed me, always in the comradeliest manner, to take the necessary steps to have this work published more widely. Iain has joined with Bob and myself on numerous social occasions, often fuelled by alcohol, where together we have entered the ‘republic of the imagination’! We believe that the creation of a new communist society is fundamentally about the transformation of human relationships; and that how we conduct ourselves in the here and now is vitally important to this process. Thanks to Many other friends and comrades, whose contributions to shared struggles, at work and in the community, have greatly developed my own thinking. These include the members of the Republican Communist Network, who have become familiar with many of the ideas in this book, and have indulged their promotion with generous space in our journal and blog, Emancipation & Liberation. Another good friend and comrade, the late Brian Higgins, a leading militant in the construction industry, and the rank and file Building Worker Group, the most blacklisted worker in the industry, a communist and republican, has also provided much inspiration. The views developed here have also been greatly influenced by my participation in both the Lothians Rank & File Teacher group and the Scottish Federation of Socialist Teachers, where I made many friends and comrades over many years. I have made many more, as the former chair of the Lothians Anti-Poll Tax Federation and as co-organiser and participant in Republican Socialist Conventions and Global Commune events, and as an activist in the Radical Independence Campaign. 3 Some of the ideas on nationalities, nations and nationalism were initially developed in the Sixth Year Studies course, which I produced whilst I was working as a Modern Studies teacher in an Edinburgh secondary school. This was at a time when teachers were still permitted to undertake their own educational initiatives. My students also greatly helped, especially in the role-playing tutorials. Nowadays though, so much of education has been reduced to the delivery of disconnected units of work, with meaningless learning outcomes, accompanied by a dispiriting treadmill of testing. This is training for a life in an alienated world, where the mindless pursuit of career and money dominates, and where selfish competition is allowed to eclipse cooperative learning and genuine education. In the process of working with others in opposing the exploitation, oppression and alienation imposed in today’s corporate imperialist world; and in seeking human emancipation, liberation and self-determination, I have joined with others who also appreciate that the creation of another world tomorrow means trying to lead a fulfilling life together today. Thanks to Niyi Osundare for permission to include his poem, I Sing of Change. Niyi was born in 1947 in Ikere-Ekiti in Nigeria. He became a poet, dramatist, literary critic and human rights campaigner. He moved to the USA in 1997, working at the University of New Orleans. He is the winner of numerous awards both for literary creativity and championing human rights. I first read Sing of Change on the inside of a London Underground carriage. It was part of a series of poems displayed for commuters and travellers. Within the bowels of what was once the world's leading imperialist power, still economically and politically dominated by the City, an international community already exists and a future global alternative society could be in the process of being created. 4 I SING OF CHANGE I sing of the beauty of Athens without its slaves Of a world free of kings and queens and other remnants of an arbitrary past Of earth with no sharp north or deep south without blind curtains or iron walls Of the end of warlords and armouries and prisons of hate and fear Of deserts treeing and fruiting after the quickening rain Of the sun radiating ignorance and stars informing nights of unknowing I sing of a world reshaped Niyi Osundare Selected Poems, 1992 5 Volume 1 THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF A WORLD OF NATION-STATES UP TO 1848 INTRODUCTION i) Futures for mankind – for better or worse ii) Moving beyond the Left’s partial critiques of a world dominated by global corporate capital iii) The development of an ‘internationalism from below’ perspective 1. THE WORLD BEFORE NATIONALISM A. Definitions and different approaches to the ‘National Question’ i) Nationalities, nations, nation-states and nationalism - present, past and future ii) Exploitation, oppression and alienation; emancipation, liberation and self-determination iii) Opposing social chauvinism/imperialism and social patriotism - genuine Communism and the tradition of ‘internationalism from below’ B. Social transitions and territorial borders in the past and in the future i) A comparison between the move from state religions to secular states and the move from nation-states to civic states ii) Changing borders and movements and struggles which extend beyond state boundaries iii) Transcending nation-states and nationalism in the transition from the lower to the upper phase of communism 6 2. DIFFERERENT ROADS TOWARDS THE NATION-STATE AND OTHER PATHS IMAGINED AND FOUGHT FOR A. The rise of nations and nation-states - just one possible path of social and economic development i) Nation and nation-state - universal or historically limited categories ii) Before nations and nation-states - feudal imperialism and the religious heretical, urban communal and mercantile capitalist challenges iii) Feudal imperialism successfully challenged - the emergence of the Swiss confederation iv) The far from inevitable rise of capitalism and the nation-state B. The ‘Spanish’ and ‘French roads’ versus the ‘Dutch’ and ‘English roads’ i) The conflict between the ‘Spanish’ and ‘French roads’ and the emergence of the Dutch and English challenges ii) The rise of two early nation states, England and the Dutch Netherlands, was still limited by religious, dynastic and regional loyalties. iii) The conflict between the Stuarts' promotion of a British Union and Empire, Calvinist support for of a Godly Kingdom, Radical Leveller visions of a Godly Republic and Cromwell's Greater English Republic iv) The first defeat of the “motley crew” leads to the accelerated rise of commercial landed estates and mercantile monopolies, whilst the Greater English Republic and the 'Western Design' become harbingers of a British imperial future v) The growing power and influence of the UK’s constitutional monarchy and the entrenchment of overseas chattel slavery and domestic wage-slavery 7 vi) The underground Radical Enlightenment in contest with the Mainstream Enlightenment vii) The ‘English road’ versus the ‘French road’, the marginalisation of alternative revolutionary visions and the triumph of the Mainstream Enlightenment viii) The conflict between British ruling class politics and the new nationalism of the ‘freeborn Englishman’ ix) English nationalism provokes cultural nationalist responses in Scotland and Wales C. The American Revolution and the ambiguous US Republic