VOLUME: 6SUMMER, 2006 Moreon The Capitoline Museumand Dioscorides’ the Castellani Collection
Etruscan by AntonellaMagagnini CuratoreArcheologo,Musei Capitolini
Herbs OnDecember 23, 2005, theCapitoline Museums,after along effort coordinated by by JohnScarborough AnnaMuraSommella, Director of theMusei University of Wisconsin Capitolini,andagreat financialcommitment, wereenriched by anew wing,focused on a Inhis “AnEtruscanHerbal?” ( Etruscan largelight-filled, glassed-in hall in the spaces News,5[Winter, 2006]),KyleP. Johnson previously occupied by theRomanGardenof makes someinteresting points regarding the thePalazzodeiConservatori. Theoriginal manuscript traditions that include alternative bronzeequestrian statueof Marcus Aurelius names for theplants andherbs in Dioscorides’ has finally foundits worthy homein this piaz- Materiamedica. 1 It was beyond the scopeof za-like space, along with thelargebronzes Johnson’s briefintroductory note, however, donated by Sixtus IVto theRomanpeoplein andhence it is thegoalof this article, to sug- Pimpernel,from the ViennaDioscurides 1472. From this hall onecanmarvelat the gest how and why these synonyms,not (WikimediaCommons) enormous,imposing remains of thefounda- included by Dioscorides in his original work, 2 5 tions of theTempleof Jupiter Capitoline enter themanuscript history,andmoreimpor- inal work. revealed by recent archaeologicalexcava- tantly, why thesenames might indicateapar- Inestablishing his Greek text of the tions. ticularly Etruscanherbalism. Materiamedica,Max Wellmann pulled most In thegalleries next to the so-called The synonym-lists werecompiled separate- of thealternativenomenclatures from the “Giardino Romano” areexhibited the various ly by lexicographers,collectors of words in main text,andplaced themas part of his collections. The renewed Galleriadegli Horti what we wouldcall “dictionaries” on dis- apparatus criticus with thedesignation RV. It and thenearby galleries feature the sculptures parate subjects,including the vocabularies of is among these “alternativenames” that one that once adorned theluxurious Imperial resi- medicineand related disciplines.3 As scribes finds theEtruscan terms for someplants and dences and their parks andgardens; these copied and re-copied the Materiamedica, herbs. Theseare, indeed, remnants of what came tolight in thecourseof excavations of sometimes rearranging Dioscorides’ original couldbecalled an “Etruscanherbal:” bits sur- the secondhalf of the19thc. in theareas of format (called by Riddlea“drugaffinity sys- viving from lexicographers’ hungry searchfor theQuirinal,Viminal,andEsquilinehills. The tem”), 4 those scribes attached portions of the arcane words,aliterary genre that flourished 6 Castellani Collection,given to theCapitoline separate synonym-lists to the text itself,and throughout thecenturies, and whichis with Museums by AugustoCastellani,awell- over thecenturies thealternativenames fre- us today. knowngoldsmithandcollector in Romein quently wandered into thebody of the work Wellmann lists sixteenEtruscan words that Top:Aristonothos Crater with the blinding 7 themid- tolate19thc.,is now displayed in itself. With theadvent of printed editions in appear in the RV, but significantly the three galleries adjacent to thelargeglassed-in of the Cyclops Polyphemos,and the theRenaissance, anumber of theearliest Etruscan terms areonly oneof twenty-six lan- hall according tomaterial type, adivision that artist’s signature. From Cerveteri. 7th printed versions simply replicated thecom- guages recorded by Pamphilus andother lexi- Castellani himself established. century B.C.Rome,Capitoline Museum. positeGreek texts (or theLatin translations of cographers. Etruscan––by comparison with As is well known,AugustoCastellani put thosemanuscripts) so that medical students the “Roman,” “words of the[Egyptian] together over thecourseof severaldecades a Bottom:Aristonothos Crater withabattle andprofessors of pharmacology in the seers,” “Egyptian,” “Gallic,” “Dacian,” and between a war ship and amerchant ship. 8 richcollection of objects covering a wide Renaissance universities oftenlearned all of others –– is a tiny fraction of the terminolo- chronological range, from themost important 7thcentury B.C.Rome,Capitoline thenames as if they had beenpart of theorig- [See “ Herbs ” on page9] archaeological sites of Etruria, Latium,and Museum. MagnaGraecia. The 700 or soobjects given by Castellani to themuseumincluded alarge originalcontext; recent researchcarried out quantity of pottery,bothimported from on related objects,however,has made it pos- Greece andlocally made. In thefirst gallery a sible toidentify someof theproduction cen- number of these vases aredisplayed in ters. chronologicalorder,allowing the visitor to Other collections of the19thc. include that follow thedevelopment of Greekproduction of theMuseoArtisticoIndustriale, conceived from the 7th to the4thc. B.C. through impor- by AugustoCastellani andhis brother tant and well-preserved examples. TheAttic Alessandroalong withother important figures vases,in particular,areimportant for an of 19thc. culturein Rome, on themodelof understanding of thehistory and theartistic similar museums in London andParis. The production of thecraftsmen,not only of new display includes afew noteworthy exam- Greekculturebut alsoofcontemporary cul- ples of Attic vases from thearchaeological tures in theMediterranean. section of this richcollection, whichcame to The secondgallery exhibits locally pro- themuseumin the1950s. duced ceramics from thenecropoleis of the Alsoonexhibit is theoinochoefrom major Etruscancities as well as from the Tragliatella(Cerveteri),given to themuseum tombs of Latiumand theFaliscanTerritory, in 1964inmemory of TommasoTittoni,a e.g. CivitaCastellana. Unfortunately,even Roman statesmanandcollector of theendof more thanfor theGreek vases,Castellani the19thc. Theinterpretation of thefigures on avoided recording their exact provenance or [See “ Castellani” on page9] Letters to theEditors To theEditors: At the timeof writing my article “A PossibleSouthEtruscanTombGroup,” A r t i c l e s (EtruscanNews 5)I was unawareof two recent articles by Jennifer Neils whichdis- cussed thebirdaskos now in theCleveland TheStudy of Etruscan books,on theprophecies of VegoiaandTages. edgeof the subject from his ownexperiences Museum. Thefirst is entitled “Herclein Alsoin this category are themany shadowy as anaugur of state religion. Cleveland” ( ClevelandStudies in theHistory Religion figures who arementioned as being consulted This first-century Romandebateis of of Art,1998 pg. 6-21), the secondappears in Excerpt from theIntroduction to for advice by theRomans, the soothsaying course sophisticated andprobably shows the CVA (USA35,ClevelandMuseumofArt TheReligion of theEtruscans priests or haruspices ,as for example, some thought patterns well beyondany pres- 2, 2000). In these works,Neils refers to the Umbricius Melior,described as “most ent in Etruscan religious teaching. Quintus stylisticconnection between theCleveland by Nancy T.deGrummond skilled,” theEarly Imperial soothsayer of Cicero supports credence in divination from askos, theother pieces I mention in my article Galba. Sullahad his haruspex Postumius,and the standpoint of Stoicphilosophy,and Inantiquity the study of and theorizing and severalother ItalianGeometric vases. thefamous Spurinna tried to warnCaesar Marcus Cicero, while rejecting actualfaithin about Etruscan religion was already well These shouldbeincluded in any bibliography about theIdes of March. Theremust have divination,in theendadmits theimportance developed, with scholarship that wemay dis- for theitems. beenmany moreRomanized Etruscans of traditional rites andceremonies solely for tributeinto three main categories:canonical involved in thesepursuits (thereareafew politicalaims. Hehas great contempt for most texts,philosophical treatises,and AngelaMurockHussein more suchfigures whosenames alonehave divinatory practices andheaps scorn upon,for historical/antiquarian writings. comedown to us),for weknow that as agen- example, theimportant Etruscan revelation TheCanonicalTexts eralprinciple, theRomans thought the mythof thepropheticchildTages. What is There were studies of themany different Etruscan teachings tobe soimportant that most important in the treatisefor our purpos- Etruscan texts having todo with the Etrusca they had apractice of sending their sons to es is theabundant evidence about theprinci- disciplina , that body of originalEtruscan reli- Etruria to study this ancient lore. palEtruscanmethods of divining,by reading gious literaturedescribing PhilosophicalTexts of entrails andby interpretation of lightning. thecosmos and the Theforegoing individuals wehavemen- When wecan sort theseout from Roman Underworld, as well as tioned may be recognized as realpractitioners interpolation, wehave someof themost prescribing various rituals of Etruscanor Etruscan-style religion,andas meaningful reports from antiquity on and ways tointerpret andact such they had their ownbias. Our second Etruscanpractices. upon messages from thegods. The division is related, but it manifests adifferent The treatiseof Seneca, Quaestiones natu- names of the texts that have survived approach:intellectuals withaconcernfor phi- rales , written shortly beforehis deathin 65 include the Libri rituales , Librifatales , losophy. Thereis no more significant surviv- CE,alsopromotes philosophy but is fascinat- Libride fulguratura (“on lightning”) and ing text for the study of Etruscan religious ing for its sympatheticpresentation of the LibriAcheruntici (concerning Acheron,i.e., practice than the treatiseon divination by point of view of Etruscanpriests. We havea theUnderworld),as well as books named Cicero, writtenaround the timeof thedeathof clear statement of thecontrast of thought after the twoprincipalEtruscanprophets, who Caesar,ca. 44 BCE. In Dedivinatione Cicero between the two sides,in thefamous declara- werecalled Tages andVegoiain Latin: Libri presents a vividdebateon the reliability of tion that “this is thedifference between us Tagetici and LibriVegontici . BothEtruscans divination in its various manifestations, with [philosophers]and theEtruscans, who have andRomans wereinvolved in this study, theprincipalinterlocutors represented as his consummate skill in interpreting lightning: whichincluded translating andinterpreting brother Quintus andhimself. Theevidence we think that becauseclouds collide, light- theold texts and teaching them toappropriate This askos from the Cleveland Museum presented on both sides is all themoreinter- ning is emitted; but they think theclouds col- individuals. Thepractitioners of this typeof of Art is the subject of Jennifer Neils’ two esting becauseCicerohad intimateknowl- lide in order that lightning may be emitted.” study perhaps relate to their materialina articles.The centralpanel was thought manner similar to that of theJewishandEarly by Frank Brommer to represent the myth Christian scholars who studied, taught,and of Herakles and the CyrenaianHind. If ETRUSCAN NEWS commented on their religious literature. the attribution is correct, this would be Unfortunately, weknow solittleof these EditorialBoard, Issue#6,May 2006 the earliest representation of that myth. writings and teachings that weare unable to discern what,if any,may havebeen their the- President of theU.S. LarissaBonfante [email protected] To theEditors: ologicalconcerns or what debates may have Section of theIstitutodi Classics Department Igaveapaper for AIAC in May (whichis enlivened their encounters. Further,it is a StudiEtruschi ed Italici, New YorkUniversity of courselisted in EN!). Theneatest thing was perennialfrustration in studies of Etruscan ex officio 25Waverly Place that AlessandroNasoknew who I was,and religion that littleabout Etruscanpropheticor New York,NY10003 gavemeavery kindintroduction,based on priestly texts canbe confidently traced back EtruscanNews. So thank you! earlier than thefirst century BCE, whenin Editor-in-Chief JaneWhitehead [email protected] fact Etruscancivilization had becomefully ModernandClassicalLanguages Hilary Becker submerged in thedominant Romanculture. ValdostaStateUniversity Among thenames that have survived are Valdosta, GA 31698 To theEditors: individuals who lived in thefirst century Congratulations on thelatest EN- splendid! BCE, suchas Aulus Caecinafrom Volterra, LanguagePageEditor Rex Wallace [email protected] It looks really good. I was particularly inter- friendof Cicero, who wrote DeEtrusca disci- Classics Department ested in theherbal refs on thefront page, fol- plina ,apublication that has beendescribed as University of Massachusetts lowing our researchintoGalen’s ointment for a “major event” in theintellectuallifeof the Amherst,MA 01003 Olympicathletes withblackeyes. But I look LateRepublic; theadmired anderudite forward to reading it all,and thank you very Nigidius Figulus, who composed books on Editor for theFellows Elizabethde G. Colantoni [email protected] muchfor including the sistrum. I hope some- dreams,privateaugury,divining from entrails Classics Department onemight come up with somecomments. andabrontoscopiccalendar (thelatter surviv- Oberlin College ing in aGreek translation)andTarquitius Oberlin. OH44074 JudithSwaddling Priscus,friendof Varro,known tohave writ- TheBritishMuseum tenan OstentariumTuscum ,atranslation of Book Review Editor Francescode Angelis [email protected] anEtruscan workonprodigies and signs,as Art History andArchaeology well as abook on prognosticating from trees. ColumbiaUniversity Addendum Tarquitius alsoproduced a translation of the New York,NY10027 We want to thank AliciaDillon for thepho- cosmicprophecies of thenymph Vegoia, a Submissions,news,pictures,or other materialappropriate to this newsletter may be sent to tograph of theArchaeologicalTours group fragment of whichhas survived. Another fig- any of theeditors listed above. Theemail address is preferred. For submission guidelines, published in EtruscanNews 5,on page 2, urein this category is Cornelius Labeo, whose see EtruscanNews 3 (2003) 9. Nominations for membership in theSection may be sent to andapologizefor failing tocredit her at that dateis unknownbut who seems tohave writ- LarissaBonfanteat theaboveaddress. time. ten translations andcommentaries,in fifteen Page 2 Infact, weknow littleabout theEtruscan other gods beside Jupiter,for example, Vertumnus,andinterestingly has thegod studies of thenatural sciences,but thepassage MinervaandJuno, wereallowed to throw change sex toappear as anold womanin the in Seneca tends toconfirm suspicions that lightning bolts. It was Varro who provided the story of thecourtship of Pomona( Meta . their observation of naturalphenomena was famous andprecious reference toVertumnus as 14.623-771). His calendar in the Fasti , replete P a s t C o n f e r e n c e s carried out with religious premises andcon- the “principalgodof Etruria” ( Delingua withloreof early religion in Rome, is relevant clusions. Latina 5.46). but must be used withcaution,bothbecause the Historical/AntiquarianTexts He was of coursefrequently quoted by other poet is sometimes inaccuratein his citations Athirdand rather different brandof scholar- antiquarians, suchas Pliny theElder (d. 79 (andhedoes not tell his sources) andbecause AIAC Presentations in ship is that of thehistorians,philologists,and CE), who drew from him information about the thematerialon theEtruscans is certainly col- Rome antiquarians. Livy (d. 12 or 17 CE) transmitted decoration of Etruscan shrines,in his book on ored by theRomancontext. Ofcourse, all the agreat dealofinformation in his narratives of painting andmodeling sculpture( HN 35.154), poeticliterature—of Vergil,Propertius,Ovid, TwoMeetings of AIAC,Associazione Roman/Etruscanpolitics and war, suchas in andabout the tombof Porsenna, in his section andothers—must be read critically as just that, InternazionalediArcheologiaClassica, were his frequent references to theEtruscanfederal on building stones andarchitecture( HN richinallusions, sometimes created for the heldin the spring of 2006. Since 2000 the sanctuary of the shrineof Voltumna(3.23.5, 36.91). Pliny included agoodbit of Etruscan occasion by thepoet andnot necessarily Association has beenorganizing monthly 25.7, 61.2; 5.17.6; 6.2.2). Verrius Flaccus, the materialinhis encyclopedic HistoriaNaturalis reflecting Etruscanbeliefor practice. meetings in the various nationalarchaeologi- tutor of thegrandsons of Augustus, wrotea as part of his goalofbeing compendious,and After this, wecannoteacrowdof later calinstitutes topermit young scholars,doctor- treatiseon Etruscanmatters ( Libri rerum in this way hepreserved many interesting frag- Romanpolymaths who took aninterest in al researchers,grant recipients,etc., topresent Etruscarum ) that has not survived, but wedo ments of information from various sources, Etruscanculture, probably most often using their workand tomeet eachother. have someof his observations as preserved in suchas loreabout signs from thebirds in his someof the writers wehavealready cited. theepitomeby Festus of his De significatu ver- sections on zoology; he refers toanillustrated Festus (secondcentury CE),as noted, prepared Thefirst meeting took place on January 23 borum , whichcontained rareandobsolete Etruscan treatise( HN 10.28, 30, 33, 35-49). anepitomeof Verrius Flaccus,and this was in at theSwedishInstituteon the subject words andaccompanying archaicantiquarian Among theantiquarians wemay alsoclassi- turnepitomized by Paulus Diaconus in the “Nasconderelaprofonditànella superficie.” lore. Vitruvius,apracticing architect of the fy selected Latin poets who drew on early eighthcentury. ThegrammarianCensorinus Themoderator was HelgaDiGiuseppe. The timeof Augustus,has left apreciseaccount of RomanandEtruscanantiquities for one reason (thirdcentury CE) wroteon a wide rangeof speakers and topics were: the theoreticalandpracticalaspects of building or another,during that periodof thefirst centu- topics suchas theorigin of humanlifeand JoséCarlos Sánchez Pardo(Scuola andlocating anEtruscan temple( Dearchitec- ry BCE when wedetect somuchother activity time. Theindefatigableandgenerally trustwor- Spagnola), Territorio epopolamento tra tura 1.7.1-2,4.7). regarding Etruscan religion. Vergil,exposed to thy Servius (fourthcentury CE)has left an Antichitàeil Pieno Medioevo:analisi Thepureantiquarians areespecially useful. Etruscanculturein his nativeMantua, has left abundance of observations on theEtruscans in spazialeeGIS. They wereintrigued with thepast and record- us his stirring description of the warrior priest his commentary on Vergil’s works. He took a OlafSatijn (IstitutoOlandese), Asocio- ed information objectively about Etruscan reli- from Pisa, Asilas, skilled in theinterpretation great interest in augurallore, and though hedid economicandpoliticallandscapearchaeolo- gion out of curiosity. A great variety of of all the signs from thegods,embracing not always refer directly to theEtruscans,his gy of transition: southernLazio from thelate Etruscan topics was treated by themost learned entrails, the stars,birds,andlightning ( Aeneid comments are usefulinaugmenting our knowl- Romanperiod toincastellamento. of all Romans,Varro(116-127 BCE), ranging 10.246-254). edgeof this important branchofEtruscan reli- DuniaFilippi (UniversitàdiRoma “La from thepractice of sacrificing apig for a ritu- No text from theRomans is moreimportant gious praxis. Macrobius (probably fifthcentury Sapienza”), IlVelabroeleorigini delForo. alpact ( De re rustica 2.4.9), to theEtruscan rite for studying Etruscandivinity than thepoemof CE), whose Saturnalia is apotpourriofanti- for laying out acity ( Etruscus ritus; Delingua theUmbrianPropertius about the statueof quarian, scientific, andespecially philological The secondmeeting took place on March Latina 5.143). He wroteatreatiseon human Vertumnus set upinRome(4.2). It expresses lore, provides in his dilettante’s way little 6, 2006,at theVillaLante, theInstitutum anddivinematters of antiquity (i.e., what was vividly theEtruscan tendency tobe vagueor nuggets of Etruscaninformation,for example, RomanumFinlandiae, on the subject“Orare ancient at that time, 47 BCE), theloss of which ambivalent about thegender andother charac- on the useof the sacred bronzeplow in found- et donare.” Vincent Jolivet was themodera- is most unfortunate. It contained fascinating teristics of aparticular deity. ing acity ( Sat . 5.19.13) or on thegoodomen tor. Thepapers delivered were; materialon theloreof lightning, suchas that Ovid, too,has related themythof seenin the wool of sheep whenit was natural- SophieHelas (Deutsches ly tinted purpleor golden( Sat . 3.7.2). Finally, Archaeologisches Institut Rom), Santuari wemay include in this groupArnobius,a puniciaSelinunte. rhetoricianandChristianconvert living in LetiziaCeccarelli (CambridgeUniversity), Africa in thelatefourthandearly fifthcentury Materiale votivodietà’medio-repubblicana Lettertoour Readers CE, who assembled his text intelligently from da Ardea Dear Readers, other sources,as shownby his passage quoting Antonio Ferrandes (UniversitàdiRoma Varroon thegroupgods suchas thePenates “LaSapienza”), Ceramica e santuari urbani. With this issue wehope toestablishadifferent andmore regular rhythm to theappearance recognized by theEtruscans ( Adv. nat., 3.40). Produzione, distribuzioneeconsumo diman- of EtruscanNews. Anabsolutely singular caseis that of ufatticeramiciaRoma traIVeIII secolo We areextremely pleased with theenthusiastic reception of EtruscanNews 5. We received Martianus Capella. He, too,flourished in the a.C.:il contributodeidepositi votivi. many compliments on thecontents of theissue: onecolleague remarked that wearemanag- atmosphereof NorthAfrica in thefifthcentury, Internet:http://www.aiac.or g ing tocombine theimmediacy of anewspaper with the scholarly materialofajournal. leaving as his chief workacompendious Contatti:[email protected] g Theimmediacy is evenmore served by our new interactive web site, EtruscanNews pedanticallegory on themarriageof Mercury Online (www.umass.edu/etruscannews), which serves as aplace for people topresent works andPhilology ( Denuptiis Mercurii et in progress,andas aforumfor discussions of issues andarticles. Themore recent volumes Philologiae). Regarded as eccentric, tedious, New YorkArchaeological of EtruscanNews canbe accessed herein PDF format; all of the volumes areavailablein this and superficialinits discourseon the sevenlib- Consortium sameformat on the web siteof theCenter for Ancient Studies (www.nyu.edu/fas/center/ eralarts, the text of Martianus is nonetheless of ancientstudies) at NYU. We plan toadd anIndex for issues 1-6 soon. thegreatest importance for Etruscan studies. It TheCenter for Archaeology at Columbia On the scholarly side, wearehappy topresent articles on Etruscanglosses by two well- contains the singlemost significant text in University has renewed theNew York knowninternational scholars,John Scarborough andDominiqueBriquel. Thesearticles take Latin for understanding theEtruscanpantheon ArchaeologicalConsortium,in whichgradu- up the subject from very different points of view,and represent anexampleof thekindof fol- andcosmos (1.45-61). Martianus sets the stage ate students andfaculty in Art History, low-up that wehope toinspire: the subject of glosses was raised by in thefront-pagearticle for the wedding of Mercury andPhilology by Classics,andAnthropology holdopendiscus- by KyleJohnson on apossibleEtruscanherbalin EtruscanNews 5. sending out invitations togods all around the sions of their current researchprojects. The Although EtruscanNews will now be freely availableon line, many people, including sky,andhedepicts themas inhabiting sixteen main objectiveof the recent event, which took libraries,prefer thenewsprint version. We ourselves arefondof this format,and will contin- main divisions. place Friday,March 24, was todivulgecur- ue toprint the edizionecartacea (welike that word). We hopeof course that you will contin- Scholars are united in regarding this number rent researchprojects and toestablishcontacts ue to send us contributions for your subscriptions. Inany casepleasebe sure to send us your as aclue that Martianus was following the betweenalumni andfaculty of different col- email addresses,either by contacting oneof us directly or communicating with us by way of Etruscan systemofdividing the sky (cf. Cicero, leges within thecity. The topics presented the web site, so that wecanknow our readership andplan toaddress their interests. We hope Dediv . 2.18.42),andhavefound that the involved thefields of anthropology,archaeol- tocontinue toinform you of interesting programs at homeandabroad, including our own. schemeagrees in some striking details with that ogy,art history,history of architecture, and Pleaselet us know your thoughts, your interests,and your plans. other famous document of theEtruscancos- history of religion. mos, thebronzemodelofa sheep’s liver from For moreinformation contact Carola Withbest wishes, Piacenza. The useof deities who may be read- GarciaManzano,CCA ProgramCoordinator, ily equated with well-knownEtruscangods, at [email protected] LarissaBonfante, lb1 [email protected] along withdivinities who arecompletely JaneWhitehead, [email protected] obscurein Roman religion, suggests that we may indeed havehereareflection of anorigi- [See “ Conferences ” on page8] nalEtruscandoctrine. Page 3 L a n g u a g e P a g e
Notes on anInscribed 3. Etruscaninscriptions are Community at Poggio Civitate,” Etruscan cited from Rix et al. 1991 =(ET) Studies 7 (2000)109–112. Kyathos from Cerveteri andfrom Wallace, Shamgochian, Wallace, Rex,MichaelShamgochian& andPatterson 2004-2006 = by Rex Wallace James Patterson. 2004-2006, EtruscanTexts (ETP). University of Massachusetts Amherst Project Online ,etp.classics.umass.edu . 4. Wallace (in press). Colonna Amherst,MA:University of Massachusetts Over adecade ago,MariaAntoniettaRizzo 2005: 331 reads this section of Amherst. andMauroCristofani published anEtruscan theinscription in adifferent Wallace, Rex. (Inpress). “Etruscan inscription incised on theconicalbaseof a manner: pai º ina Ç e[. His reading Inscriptions on Fragments of Bucchero kyathos from a tomb(no. 1)excavated in the cannot be correct,however. Kyathoi Recovered at Poggio Civitate,” Studi Thereis no doubt that theletter locality of SanPaolo (Cerveteri).1 The Etruschi 71. kyathos was recovered brokenintofragments, that he takes tobe a Ç is in fact but conservators were successfulin restoring an " " thecup to something close toits original state. 5. NeilsenandTuck 2001:44, Theinscription, which was incised in a spiral 50-55. EtruscanGlosses around theconicalfoot of thecup, survived in 6. See Schulze-Thulin 1992: good shape, except for twoplaces. Twoletters 180. by DominiqueBriquel aremissing at thebeginning,andafew letters 7. For discussion of thedistri- bution of theseletters on Ernout used to speakof “thepoverty of the aremissing about two-thirds of the way 1 through theinscription. Cristofani recon- Baseof the Poggio Civitatekyathos (Drawing by Dylan inscriptions from the information that has comedown to us.” This structed the text of theinscription as follows: DeWitt) Orientalizing period see poverty is further accentuated by thefact that, BagnascoGianni 1993. though particular aspects of theEtruscan vocabulary are relatively well represented in [mi] ˜ i venelpai º inå [s mu]luvnice Thesefacts conspire to suggest that the 8. Theonly other inscription with this com- the very limited totalnumber of glosses that family nameon the kyathos recovered at San bination of letterforms is ETCr 0.1, which was incised on akyathos recovered from the havecomedown to us, they arenot necessar- Given that this inscriptionis adedication, Paolo be completed as pai º ina[ie] or Tomba Calabresi at Cerveteri. ily those that we wouldconsider themost anexceedingly common epigraphic typein pai º ina[ies] rather than pai º ina[s] and that 9. The twoinscribed kyathoi weredis- important for our understanding of thelan- 2 archaicEtruscan, theforms restored by theinscription be restored as in (2). Thefam- cussed by Colonna 2005: 332,but he took the guage. Twenty-four out of the 60 or sogloss- ily nameon theSanPaolo inscription would Cristofani arein no way controversial. He family names tobe pai º ina- , whichis impos- es,almost 45%,concern two specific sectors observes that the verbform [mu]luvnice is thenfindaperfect match with thefamily siblefor theinscriptionon thePoggio Civitate of thelexicon:names of themonths and missing a vowelin theante-penultimate sylla- nameon the kyathos recovered at Poggio 2 kyathos . Thecups andinscriptions canbe con- botanical terms. bleand that it shouldbeemended to 9 Civitate. nected only if thefamily nameon theSan In theformer category areindications of the [mu]luvnice. Andhepoints out that the names of eight months of the year,from Paolo kyathos is restored as pai º ina[ie(s)] . family name pai º ina[s] may be compared to March toOctober.3 Theseareincluded in a [mi]ni venelpai º ina[ie(s) Colonnaalsonotes that ETP4from Vetulonia, very late source, themedievalcompilation of pai º unas , whichis foundat Volsinii (ETVs mu]luvnice of whichonly a small fragment remains ( [–– theeighth-century Liber Glossarum or “book 3.4),and to pai º nas , whichis attested at Vulci (ETP196) –]e p[–––] ),could well belong to this of glosses.” Its information was taken up 3 samegroup. (ETVc 2.41). It turns out,however, that a again –– with theexception of themonthof If thefamily nameon theSanPaolo 10. Colonna 2005: 332. muchmorecompelling comparandum exists. April, Cabreas , whichdoes not appear here kyathos is restored as pai º ina[ie(s)] ,it is pos- 11. Tuck 2000:111. Thefamily name pai º inaie was incised on a –– by anevenmore recent collection,Papias’ sible toconnect the twoinscribed kyathoi and fragment of theconicalbaseof a kyathos Elementarium ,aglossary of themiddleof the speculatealong thelines offered by Colonna R EFERENCES recently recovered at Poggio Civitate(ETP 11thcentury. 10 4 in his noteon thePoggio Civitate kyathos . The Liber Glossarum is comprised of a 353). Formally, pai º inaie is aderivativein - Agostininani,Luciano. Le ‘iscrizioni par- First of all,members of the sameimmediate series of 116 words dealing with the terms for ie built from thepatronymicbase *pai º ena- , lanti’dell’Italiaantica (Florence 1981). family,perhaps brothers,perhaps father and themonths in different languages. Theseare theancestor of theforms attested at Vulciand BagnascoGianni,Giovanna, “Aproposito son,had these twocups inscribed. Second, a always introduced with the same standardfor- Volsinii and, according toCristofani,of the di trekyathoi in buccheroa rilievo,” member of the pai º ina[ie(s)] family from mula: “N:X- orumlinguaNmensisdicitur.” 4 . formon theSanPaolo kyathos . Produzioneartigianaleedesportazionenel Caere was in contact with the residents of the In this manner aregivenare thenames of the The similarities between these twoinscrip- mondoantico—ilbuccheroetrusco (Milano, Orientalizing complex at Poggio Civitateand months among theHebrews ( Hebraeorumlin- tions and thebuccheroceramicon which they 10-11maggio 1990) (Milano 1993) 207-216. had afinely decorated andinscribed kyathos gua ), theEgyptians ( Aegyptorumlingua ), the wereincised may rundeeper thananetymo- —,cat. no.,II.D.1.1,in Sgubini Moretti, Syrians ( Syrorumlingua ), theCappadocians logical relationship connecting thefamily sent thereas agift. We might imaginean AnnaMaria, ed., Veio,Cerveteri,Vulci. Città ( Cappadocumlingua ), theEtruscans names. The kyathos from Poggio Civitate was exchangeof gifts tocement politicalor eco- d’Etruriaaconfronto . Catalogo dellaMostra ( Tuscorumlingua, often variously writtenas not alocally produced product; thebucchero nomic ties, whichis anintriguing idea given Roma 2001)166-67. Tucorum,Tuquorum,Turcorumlingua ), the fragments of this cupare unlikeother buc- thegeographicaldistance between the two Colonna, Giovanni, “Ager Clusinus: Athenians (with thedesignation Thenerum 5 communities. Thereis alsoanother,more Murlo.” StudiEtruschi 70, REE 51 (2005) cheroproducts produced at the site. The lingua in the Liber Glossarum,Teucrum, or intriguing,possibility that deserves tobe men- 331-332. kyathos is, therefore, animport andone that Teucrorumlingua in Papias), the tioned. The kyathos from Poggio Civitate was Nielsen,Erik andAnthony Tuck, “An may well havebeenmade in a workshop at Macedonians ( Macedonumlingua ), the recovered from the remains of the so-called Orientalizing PeriodComplex at Poggio Caere. Consider the similarities:(1)The Bithynians ( Bithiniensiumlingua ), the OC3/TripartiteBuilding. We might imagine, Civitate,” EtruscanStudies (2001)8.35-63. Poggio Civitate kyathos and theSanPaolo Perinthians ( Perinthiorumlingua ), the if theTripartiteBuilding at Poggio Civitate Rix,Helmut et alii. EtruskischeTexte. kyathos wereincised withdedicatory inscrip- Byzantines ( Bizantinorumlingua ),and those had a religious function, 11 that this cup was Editio minor . Bd. I. Einleitung,Konkordanz, tions in sinistroversedirection spiraling designated as Greek( Hellenorumlingua ). offered as a votivededication to thedeity or Indices; II. Texte . (Tübingen1991). around theconicalbases of thecups. (2) Both Onecan thus reconstitute11 lists of names of deities worshipped there. Rizzo,M. A. &MauroCristofani, “Un inscriptions haveObject -Subject -Verb word themonths; among thesefigurealist of kyathos ealtri vasiiscrittidale tombe oriental- order, whichis relatively rarein this typeof Etruscan terms, reduced toeight, witha F OOTNOTES izzantidiSanPaolo aCerveteri,” Bolletino text.6 (3) Inbothinscriptions theletter sequence beginning in March–– thebegin- d’ArtedelMinistroper iBeni Culturali e gamma has theformofa shepherd’s staff, P , ning of the year according to theancient 1. Rizzo&Cristofani 1993. Theinscription Ambientali 82 (1993)1-10. and theletter theta is a small circle without Roman system–andending with themonth was alsopublished in Sgubini Moretti 2001: Schulze-Thulin,Britta, “Zur Worstellung 7 of October, the tenthmonthofa year begin- any internalpunctuation, O . This combina- 166-167. im Etruskischen,” SE 58 (1992)177-195. ning in January. tion of letters is a rarity on Etruscaninscrip- 2. For this variety of ‘iscrizioneparlante’, Tuck,Anthony, “Architectureand This is not theonly instance of a truncated tions from this early period. 8 see Agostiniani 1981. Page 4 list –only theCappadocianandByzantine quarianinterested in the year andits divisions lists arecomplete. Theselists also quiteclear- had collected these, no doubt in a source on ly haveerrors. For theEtruscanlist,onecan the subject of the Etruscandisciplina and share apriori the skepticismof theEnglish moreprecisely in the ritualbooks, libri rit- M u s e u m N e w s scholar,J.F. Mountford,5 who carefully uales , whichcouldhavelisted themarranged recorded thesemistakes, toward (H)ermius as according to their place in thecalendar.10 a termfor August,because EJ rmaios is the This series of glosses,in spiteof the very nance. Archaeologists havelong argued that nameof aGreekmonth(November in the latedateof the texts in which they occur, MFAhead plans Rome trip this is agiveaway that the works wereexca- Byzantinelist),and thegodHermes,for could thus havepreserved relatively trustwor- todiscuss disputed works vated and smuggled from Italy –a violation whom it is named, does not have this namein thy information on this particular aspect of the of a1939Italianlaw. Etruscan; thegod who corresponds tohim and Etruscanlanguage. by Geoff Edgers In thepast,museums havelargely ignored shares his imageis Turms . Globe staff Italianclaims. But the 2004conviction of art But we shouldnot reject out of hand the (Excerpted and translated by JaneK. dealer Giacomo Mediciand the trialofHecht trustworthiness of this source of information. 6 Whitehead) Reprinted from theBoston Globe, March16, 2006 andTruehaveled tomuseumdealers being Theindications that it gives havebeeninpart more responsive. confirmed by authenticEtruscandocuments. 1. A. Ernout, “Les éléments étrusques du “The question,of course, is what is being Twoofour longest Etruscandocuments, the vocabulairelatin,” Bulletin de laSociétéde Amonthafter theMetropolitanMuseumof negotiated,” saidarchaeologist Malcolm Bell, linenbook of Zagreb and theCapua “Tile,” LinguistiquedeParis 30 (1930) 82 = Art in New Yorkagreed to return toItaly objects suspected of being looted, the whose study of works suspected of having are ritualcalendars, which stipulate thecere- Philologica I(Paris 1946) 21. MuseumofFineArts announced that director beenlooted from Italy was included in the monies tobe performed at different dates of 2. We arenot yet asking the question at this casefileof the recent Met agreement. “But I the year. Theformer of these, in its calendar point whether the words presented as suchare Malcolm Rogers will travel toRome tomeet think themost important thing is that they’re indications,mentions festivals occurring in actually Etruscan. A. Ernout, op. cit , speaks of withgovernment officials making similar claims on MFAworks. planning to talk.” what appear tobe successivemonths: acate, “thenames of plants,moreor less exact” sup- qucte, celi. 7 Thefirst name very likely corre- plied by thebotanicalglosses. The visit,announced yesterday and Malcolm Bell sponds to the aclus of the Liber Glossarum , 3. TLE 856: Velcitanus Tuscorumlingua planned for lateApril, resulted from an exchangeof letters betweenRogers and i.e. June, and celi toCelius,i.e. September. Martius mensis dicitur; TLE 818: Cabreas Comments Further ItalianCultureMinister RoccoButtiglione It is true that qucte does not resembleany- TuscorumlinguaAprilis mensis dicitur; TLE thing that appears in this work. We might 805: Ampiles TuscorumlinguaMaius mensis this month. The trip will comein themidst of Malcolm Bell III,aprofessor of art history explain this, withMassimo Pallottino,as a dicitur; TLE 801 :Aclus Tuscorumlingua thehigh-profile trialofformer J. PaulGetty at theUniversity of Virginia, is the vice pres- Museumcurator Marion Trueandart dealer result of differences in thenames in different Iunius mensis dicitur; TLE 854: Traneus ident for professional responsibilities at the Robert Hecht. They areaccused of being part places and times,and think that Qucte refers TuscorumlinguaIulius mensis dicitur; TLE ArchaeologicalInstituteof America. His either to Traneus or to the (H)ermius of the 836: [H]ermius TuscorumlinguaAugustus of anart smuggling ring that placed works comments hereappeared in the New York illegally takenfrom Italian soil in American glosses,as another namefor July or August. mensis dicitur; TLE 824: Celius Tuscorum Times . museums,including theMFA. Otherwise wemight accept,as didJ. F. linguaSeptember mensis dicitur; TLE 858: “Paolo Ferri, theItalianprosecutor who is Mountford, the suspect character of thename Xosfer TuscorumlinguaOctober mensis dici- TheGetty and theMet havealready agreed investigating thepurchases of antiquities by of August as it is givenin the Liber tur. to returnanumber of antiquities. Italianoffi- major Americanmuseums,has hit hardest at cials say they wouldfavor anarrangement Glossarum ,andassume that that of Traneus, 4. On this question the study by J. F. theJ. PaulGetty MuseuminMalibu, whichin similar to that made with theMet, which whichevokes thenameof theEtruscanVenus, Mountford, “Demensiumnominibus,” recent decades rapidly built upanimpressive Turan ,is more trustworthy for July,and we JournalofHellenicStudies 43 (1923) 102- requires themuseum to sendback 21objects collection of GreekandRomanart…Ferri’s thus might conclude that theactualEtruscan 116,has not been superseded. Onemight also and, in return, receiveloans of equal value outrageat thelooting of Italy’s heritageis jus- from the statecollection. nameof themonthofAugust is qucte . consult T. Mommsen, “Handschriftliches,5, tified. MFAspokeswomanDawnGriffin said yes- But thenames of JuneandSeptember are Glossarien,” Rheinisches Museum 16 (1861) “By laying bare thearchives and warehous- foundin theglosses andalsoinour longest 145-147,G. Keil,Corpus Glossariorum terday that it is too early toknow what will es of major dealers,hehas revealed corrup- result from themeeting. A groupofMFAoffi- Etruscan text, the ritualon thelinenbook now Latinorum 6 (Leipzig 1899) 691-692. tion at thecoreof themarket. But in prosecut- cials will join Rogers for theRomemeeting. in themuseumat Zagreb, foundin Egypt, 5. J. F. Mountford, op. cit., 108. ing True, hehas used decades-oldevidence where, cut upinto strips,it served to wrapa 6. A particular problemis posed by theform “What wehopecomes out of this is the against acurator who brought needed reform mummy. The second-longest text,inscribed of themonthofOctober, Xosfer . TheinitialX, exchangeof information,information we to theGetty Museum,andIcanonly hope the havenot received yet, “ she said. “Right now, on aplaqueimproperly called a “tile,” discov- in this wordas in other terms in the same Italiancourts recognize thegood shehas wedon’t evenhavealist of theobjects [the ered in thenecropolis of Capuain the19th source, may have the valueof theGreek chi done. century andnow in theBerlin Museum,is (E. Fiesel, “Etruskisch ‘acht’ und ‘Oktober,’” Italians believe werelooted and sold to the “If thereis onemajor lesson tobe learned alsoa ritualcalendar. It alsogives us the StudiEtruschi 10 [1936] 324-325). But one MFA].” from Ferri’s investigations,it is that collectors For years, theMFAhas saidit has no evi- names of themonths in formulas of succes- might alsoattribute to this X the valueof a andmuseums,in America andaround the dence any works in its collection werelooted. sivedates: 8 thereapparently occur,in the number — themonthofOctober being the world, must takeintoaccount not just theaes- locative, themonthof apirase , themonth tenthmonthof the solar year. But a1998 Globe study,conducted with the thetic valueof theobjects they acquirebut help of severalclassical scholars,determined anpilie ,andfinally themonth acalve . 7. See M. Pallottino, “Ilcontenutodel testo also theethicalandlegalconsequences of that only 10 of 71classicalartifacts donated Hereagain acomparison with theglosses dellamummiadiZagabria,” StudiEtruschi 11 their acquisition policies.” canbe made: anpilie resembles Ampiles ,May, (1937) 203-237 = Saggi diAntichità 1(Rome or sold to themuseumin themid-1980s had and acalve suggests Aclus,June–– whichalso 1979)547-578; in particular “Ilcontenuto: any recorded ownership history,or prove- seems tobe foundin the acule of theZagreb ritualein formadicalendario religioso,” 210- linenbook,adocument of thefirst century 217 =554-561. Viterbo,EtruscanMuseum:Thefinds from Blera B.C.,four centuries later than theCapua tile. 8. See K. Olzscha, “Götterformel und Monatdateninder grossenetruskischen Apirase has beenproposed as thenamefor the January 21, 2006 saw theopening of the Superintendent,Valeriad’Atri,and the Inschrift von Capua,” Glotta 34(1955) 71-93; monthofApril. The wordfor April,it is true, new archaeologicalgalleries of theMuseum Swedishambassador,StàffanWrigstad, as theanalysis is taken upagain in M. Cristofani, is givenas Cabreas in the Liber Glossarum , of Rocca Albornoz at Viterbo, with thefinds well as important Scandinavian representa- TabulaCapuana, uncalendario festivoetr- but,as errors havemanaged to slip into these from theexcavations of theEtruscan sites of tives. Their presence was due to thefact that uscodietàarcaica (Florence 1995)esp. 60- lateglosses,onemight suggest that theinitial SanGiovenaleandAcquarossa. Objects from theSwedishInstitute sponsored theexcava- 61. Cis afalseaddition,and that wecouldper- theexcavated habitation sitenear Blera will tion campaigns in this area of Etruria, Tuscia, 9. Let us remember that since the[b] didnot haps reconstruct Abreas , whichcomes very be exhibited to thepublicfor thefirst time. from the1950s to the1980s,excavations that exist in Etruscan, abreas canbe restored toa close to apirase and whichmight possibly be This exhibition has beenorganized by the included, along withmany other participants, 9 form with apr -, whichmight result in aprim- linked to theLatin Aprilis. ArchaeologicalSoprintendenzaof Lazio and Gustavus VIAdolphus,King of Sweden. Thelists of theEtruscanmonths that one itive apir -. theSwedishInstituteof ClassicalStudies,and 10. On theimportance of theEtruscan reli- cangather from these twomedievalglossaries sponsored by theComuneof Viterbo. CorrieredellaSera ,Cronaca diRoma, gious science as ultimate source of this infor- –theonly texts remaining to us – wouldhave Present at theinauguration were theMayor January 21, 2006. preserved, long after thedisappearance of mation, see M. Torelli, “Glosseetrusche: of Viterbo, Giancarlo Gabbianelli, the Etruscanas a spokenandevena writtenlan- qualcheproblemadi trasmissione,” esp. 1004 guage, a sequence of themonths of the for thenames of themonths. Tyrrhenian year. It is probable that ananti-
Page 5 R e v i e w A r t i c l e s
Maurizio Gualtieri Gualtieridoes not undermine the writtenevi- whenmiddle-sized properties were the rule, EtruscanReligion: LaLucania romana. dence, whichhas beenexploited on numerous less soas theestates worked by slavelabor SomeRecent occasions by historians of theMiddleand came topredominate. Theelements of Publications CulturaeSocietànelladoc- LateRepublic, hehas placed it in anew per- Toynbee’s scenario areall present in thepic- reviewed by FrancescodeAngelis, spective soas toillustratehow ancient histo- turedrawnby Gualtieribut the shadows are ColumbiaUniversity umentazionearcheologica. rians dramatized, andin dramatizing exagger- fainter, thedetail is infinitely expanded, and ated, both the splendors and the shadows of under theEmpireHannibalappears far less an Napoli. 2003 (272 p.) TheReligion of theEtruscans , edited by their subject. Thedepthof thedocumentation element in thehistory of Lucania thanfactors offered by Gualtieri’s book is particularly emanating from Rome. Thesefactors areboth Nancy T. de GrummondandErikaSimon. By R.Ross Holloway impressive, especially since in Italianarchae- political,as seenin thegrowthof theholdings Austin:Univ. of Texas Press, 2006. Institutefor Archaeology and the ology, where thecatalogues of exhibitions, of magnates and theimperialfamily, which Religion in Ancient Etruria . by Jean-René Ancient World,BrownUniversity conferences,andpoorly circulated publica- created a villa systemindependent of the Jannot. Translated by JaneK. Whitehead. tions formagrowing percentageof thebibli- cities,andeconomic, the result of theforce In1947 Emilio Magaldipublished thefirst Madison:Univ. of Wisconsin Press, 2005. ography,mastery of theavailablematerialfor exerted by thedemands of Romeon the volumeof his study of ancient Lucania, La Thesaurus cultus et rituumantiquorum a such wide area as ancient Lucaniais an south’s resources in cereals,livestock,oil,and LucaniaRomana I,asource book on every (ThesCRA) , vv. 1-3. Los Angeles:TheJ. Paul achievement that must be recognized. wine. Inall periods,however, thesefactors aspect of this region of ancient Italy. Its use- Getty Museum, 2004-2005. ArnoldToynbee ( Hannibal’s Legacy vol. 2 exist against abackgroundof middle-size fulness has hardly diminished over the sixty Stranierienon cittadini nei santuari [London 1965])ended his chapter on thedev- holdings andagricultural villages ( vici ). years that haveintervened since its publica- astation in southernItaly andSicily wrought Thepopulating of thecountry in inland greci. AttidelConvegno Internazionale, tion. The second volumeof Magaldi’s study, by Hannibal’s invasion andRome’s revenge Lucania, as distinct from thehinterlands of Udine, novembre 2003,edited by Alessandro which was tohavebeendevoted toLucania on rebellious cities with these words, “At the theGreekcolonies of thecoast,is evident Naso. Florence: LeMonnier, 2006. under theRomanEmpire, was never pub- timeof writing,A.D. 1962, themarks of dirus well beforeHannibal. Nor was townlifecata- lished. This taskhas now been taken upby Hannibal’s presence in South-EasternItaly strophically affected by the wars of the third Maurizio Gualtieri, who withHelenaFracchia The study of religion is certainly oneof the during thefifteen years 217-203 B.C. were century B.C. (or successive slave revolts). is theexcavator of twoexceptionalLucanian most fascinating and rewarding topics for still discernible.” According toToynbee, the Documentation of farmsteads and the villas of sites,RoccagloriosaandMasseriaCiccotti those who areinterested in theEtruscans, stagnation in the south under theBourbons, medium sizehas multiplied, and the testimo- (OppidoLucano). whom Livy famously characterized as “more theindifference of theUnited Kingdom of ny of inscriptions,notably at Volceiandin the Inconversation, thelateCharles Alexander thanany other [people] dedicated to religion, Italy, the shadow of Byzantiumand theincur- Vallo diDiana, suggests that theowners in Robinson asserted more thanonce that sions of theSaracens all bow in their conse- somecases wereLucanianfamilies antedating all themore since they excelinpracticing it.” archaeology is theonly source of fundamental quences to theenduring wounds suffered dur- theconfiscations after theHannibalicWars. Andindeed thereis no scarcity of essays and new knowledgein ancient history; the truthof ing theHannibalicWar andits aftermath. His Thesepeoplehad never lost their estates or articles devoted to this matter in thefieldof this statement emerges clearly from thefash- story of MagnaGraeciaafter Hannibalis one had quickly reclaimed them. Etruscan studies. Tomention only oneof the ion in whichour conception of thehistory of of devastation leading to theimpoverishment By thebeginningof theEmpire, Roman the third region of AugustanItaly has been major publications on the topic, theproceed- of thecities and to unsteady waves of recov- magnates had begun toassemble theproper- changed over thelast half century. While ings of theconference Les plux religieux des ery in thecountryside; recovery was healthier ties that are thepreludes to thegreat estates of hommes:État de la recherche sur la religion thelater times. A specialplace in thearchae- étrusque (“TheMost Religious of Men:The ology of ancient Lucaniamust be reserved for Stateof ResearchonEtruscanReligion”), theevidence of magnificent villas and their owners in theLateEmpire. Not unlike the heldin Paris in 1992,include essays from SUBSCRIPTION FORM Englishcountry houses of alater time, these scholars with very different backgrounds and establishments rivaled thegreat houses of expertises,but also withacommon interest in The suggested contribution for anindividual subscription toEtruscanNews is Romein their sizeandarchitectureandat the Etruscanculture. $25.00 per year. We welcomedonations of any amount. Please remit this form same time served as theheadquarters of vast The recent publication of thebooks listed farming enterprises. withacheckpayable toISEE –EtruscanNews, toLarissaBonfante, Classics abovealsodeserves a warm welcome, espe- On theother hand, the results of surface cially by the readers of EtruscanNews,for at survey,if not of excavation,point to thecon- Department, 25Waverly Place, New YorkUniversity,New York,NY10003. least two reasons. First, up tonow therehas tinued existence of the settlements best ______beennomonograph in Englishfocused exclu- described as vici in theRepublicanand Imperialages. Andit has beenestimated that sively on Etruscan religion. Now wehave Please sendmeEtruscanNews. I wouldlike ______subscriptions at $25.00 despite thegrowthinlargeestates, 64% of the two,bothAmericanenterprises,namely the villas withanAugustanphase were still collective volumeedited by Nancy de each. I wouldalsolike tomakeadonation in theamount of ______to inhabited still in thefifthcentury A.D. GrummondandErikaSimon,and the transla- help develop andexpand theprojects of theU.S. Section of theIstitutodiStudi Gualtieri’s book gives anew dimension to tion of aFrenchbook whoseauthor is Jean- Etruschi ed Italici. the study of RomanLucania, not by seeking RenéJannot. As we will see, despite todiscredit or replace theprevious general inevitable similarities, they aredifferent in The totalamount enclosed is: ______works on thearea andperiod, but by showing natureandapproach the subject from different thecontinuities that exist alongside more perspectives. salient developments that arefrequently given Second, notwithstanding constant scholarly Name: ______moreemphasis by thegeneralhistorian. The cities of Lucaniadidnot sink intoinsignifi- interest in this subject, thereare still aspects Address: ______cance in theRomanperiod. Thecountryside of it that are underinvestigated, or not investi- was not thepreserveof the latifundia . Ina true gated on a systematicbasis. All the titles in ______senseLucaniaprofited from the almapax our list,especially the twoby de Grummond which the survivors of the turbulent centuries andJannot,contribute tofill someof these of Romanexpansion greeted with such relief, gaps. City: ______Stateor province: ______andas devotees of theimperialcult (apoint that Gualtieriillustrates at length), they would 1. TheReligion of theEtruscans is the Postalcode: ______haveattributed their condition far more to Augustus than toHannibal. happy finaloutcomeof aconference heldin Country:______1999 in honor of ErikaSimon, who at that time was LangfordEminent Scholar in
Page 6 Classics at Florida StateUniversity,an which was attributed to theprodigy child zation Tinia/Zeus himself had toaskbefore Thus,it is basically theproximity toGreek important Americancenter for Etruscan stud- Tages. It has tobe stressed that this version, using his most powerful thunderbolt. andRoman religion whichhas prompted ies. This event brought together someof the by JeanMacIntoshTurfa, is thefirst English Similarly, the diconsentes , who had no name, attention to theEtruscans. Nevertheless, the most prominent scholars in thefield, whose translation of this highly interesting text. This form, sex,andevennocult or sanctuary, pictureof Etruscan religious features that contributions havebeen subsequently collect- by itself wouldmakeowning thebook amust. acted as counselors of Tinia/Zeus,and were results from the ThesCRA entries is far from ed andedited in this volume. Theseare, how- subsequently adopted alsoby theRomans. being biased by classicizing views. When ever,muchmore thanmereconference pro- 2. Religion in Ancient Etruria is thetrans- Theemphasis that Jannot lays on these chapters arefurther subdivided according to ceedings. Eachof thecontributors was lation,by JaneK. Whitehead, of Jean-René notions of thedivine, whichhe rightly sees as culturalarea, Etruriais oftenpresent witha instructed tofocus on a singleissueor set of Jannot’s 1998 book Devins,dieux et démons. peculiarly Etruscan,explains why he tends to sub-section of its own. This happens not only related issues, so that in theendall themost Regards sur la religion de l’Étrurieantique . attributelittle religious relevance toGreek for areas whereone wouldexpect it, suchas relevant aspects of Etruscan religion arecov- Being the workofonly one scholar,it com- mythology in theEtruscancontext. “Divination” (A. Maggiani),but alsoinless ered. The result canbest be characterized pensates withconsistency what it may lackin According tohim, “Etruscan thought (as we obvious cases, suchas “Music” (J.-R. Jannot) with the titleof Simon’s ownarticle, “Gods in variety. In this regardalook at theindex of rather ambitiously claim toknow it) was not or “Prayer” (A. Maggiani again), whichpres- Harmony.” contents is telling. Not surprisingly, wefind mythic. For theEtruscans myth was only alle- ent highly interesting syntheses on these sub- TheEtruscanpantheon,Simon argues, many of the same themes that arepresent also gorical. Greekmyths donot describe the jects. Etruscan votiveofferings arepresented “had a specialpower tointegrategods from in thepreviously discussed volume. worldof theEtruscangods, who weredefined along withItalicones in thechapter on outside, which was strengthened by the ten- Nevertheless, the twolists donot overlap not by stories andacts,but by states of being, “Dedications” by A. Comella, J.M. Turfa, and dency for harmony among themembers” (p. completely,andfurthermore they are abilities,andfunctions” (170). Given theper- I.E.M. Edlund-Berry. Thereis of coursea 45). Ina similar way, this book integrates arranged in adifferent order. vasiveness of Greekmythology in Etruscan treatment of “Sacrifices” in Etruria(L. chapters by scholars from foreign countries As in theother book, thefirst blockof culture, onemay wonder if this view is not Donati), whichincludes adiscussion of the (viz. Germany andItaly) into what is thefirst chapters deals with those sides of Etruscan too clear-cut,andif theinteraction between interesting issueof human sacrifice — comprehensiveAmerican volumeon the sub- religion that areconnected with writing. GreekandEtruscan religious notions didnot although one wouldhaveliked to see includ- ject of Etruscan religion. It is no coincidence Nevertheless it differs from it in that Jannot produce morecomplex situations. ed in thebibliography theimportant book by that oneof theco-editors of thebook is highlights thepractices as they werepre- Nevertheless it is undeniable that Etruscan D. Steuernagel, Menschenopfer undMordam Nancy de Grummond, who is well knownfor scribed in its sacred texts. Twochapters are religion canhardly be understoodif we try to Altar (“HumanSacrifice andMurder at the having directed a similar collectiveenter- thus explicitely devoted to rituals, thefirst, assimilateit too strongly to theGreek; and Altar,” 1998). prise, AGuide toEtruscanMirrors (1982), divinatory, the second, funerary. Discussion even thepeculiar fluidity of mythological Notwithstanding the superficial similarity still thebest introduction to that particular of the rites pertaining to thepassagefrom the imagery in Etruriamay be due, at least in in structure with the LIMC (numbers in bold subject. worldof theliving to the worldof thedead part, to this radically peculiar natureof their areassigned toeachof the various pieces of Thefirst twochapters deal withthe written naturally leads toachapter on the under- notion of what agod was. evidence mentioned), the ThesCRA chapters sources on religion,bothliterary andepi- world, or rather the “afterworld,” as the trans- arebetter read as independent, separate graphic. In thefirst,Nancy de Grummond lator puts it. “The traditional term 3. The Thesaurus Cultus et Rituum essays on the various topics thanas reference presents a useful survey of theinformation Underworld, whichis generally used for the Antiquorum —or ThesCRA ,as it asks to(and entries. Infact, the very natureof theevi- availableabout ancient authors and texts RomanandGreekplace of theafterlife, undoubtedly will)be called—is aninterna- dence makes it impossible toaim at the same dealing with the disciplinaEtrusca. (The seemed inappropriatein that theEtruscans tionalSwiss-based scholarly enterprisecon- levelofcompleteness as in the LIMC. When beginning of her chapter is reprinted in this appear toconceiveof deathas ‘away’— ceived andplanned in the wakeof the dealing with votiveofferings,for example, issueof EtruscanNews,p. 2). In thenext, across abody of water —not ‘below.’The Lexicon IconographicumMythologiae thereis no alternativebut toproceed accord- LarissaBonfante shows, through carefully termAfterlife, also traditional,conveys a Classicae (a.k.a. LIMC), that most invaluable ing to samples of types whichhave tobe chosenexamples, themany ways in which stateof existence but not a senseof location. of tools for everybody interested in Greco- takenas representativeof thousands more. In writing played acentral rolein Etruscan reli- ‘TheBeyond’evokes theU.S. Air Force, Roman(andEtruscan)art andculture. Not by theend, thus, this oeuvrecanbe defined as a gion. somehow. Thus I have settled on the term chance this new project is dedicated to the sibling,but certainly not a twin,of its precur- Thefollowing twochapters canalsobe Afterworld, whichmakes room for the rather memory of Lilly Kahil (1926-2002), the sor. seenas forming acouplet. They concern the concrete, though fantastic, geographies of inspiration and soulof the LIMC. principalhumananddivineactors of the Etruscanbelief” (p. xiii). Rather thanfocusing on thefigures and 4. AlessandroNaso, whosefocus has long Etruscan religious world. Nancy de The subsequent chapters,on sanctuaries characters of ancient mythology, thenew beena study of EtruscanandItalicmaterialin Grummond reviews theevidence about andon temples,bring us back to real spaces series of volumes (three of whichhave seen theAegean(see EtruscanNews 2, 2003,page prophets andpriests,andErikaSimon intro- andarchitectures. Attention then turns to thelight sofar) intends topresent ancient reli- 6), was very appropriately theorganizer of duces us to theEtruscanpantheon. A useful priests and worhsippers. Interestingly, the gion in its culticand ritualdimension. theimportant conference Stranierienon cit- glossary of theprincipalgods worshipped in treatment of thedivineprotagonists of Drawing on theextensive visualmaterialcol- tadini nei santuarigreci , heldin Udine under Etruriaconcludes Simon’s chapter. Etruscan religion, whichconcludes thebook, lected for thepreparation of the LIMC, the theauspices of theAlexander von Humboldt Beliefs and rituals are the subject of the is subdivided into twoparts: thegods and the ThesCRA includes iconographicandarchaeo- Stiftung. Dealing with theevidence for the next twoarticles,by IngridKrauskopf and divine. Infact,Jannot stresses thefact that the logical sources in addition toliterary ones. presence of foreigners andnon-citizens in JeanMacIntoshTurfa. Theformer author is pictureof theEtruscanpantheon as it is The subject matter has been subdivided Greek sanctuaries, the twenty-twocontribu- concerned with thefunerary sphere, thelatter knownfrom thebulk of our sources —espe- according to three “levels:” 1)a “dynamic tions aredivided into three sections,eachof with votiveofferings. Issues of sacred space cially theiconographicones —does not level,” covering all the traditionalactivities of whichis followed by adiscussion:I. andarchitectureareaddressed in thelast two reflect,or reflects only in part,Etruscan cult practice (the three published volumes Historical,chaired by Peter Funke; II. contributions:IngridEdlund-Berry deals with notions of thedivine. Hepoints to thefact belong to this “level”); 2) a “staticlevel,” Archaeological,chaired by Helmut Kyrieleis; thegeneral relevance of the spatialdimension that,as literary sources tell us,just as impor- regarding cult places,personnel,andinstru- andIII. Literary, with thediscussion moderat- in Etruscan religion, whileGiovanni Colonna tant as theindividualgods, whosenames and ments of cult; 3) a third “level,” dealing with ed by GianpieroRosati. discusses more specifically the sanctuaries aspects weareable specify beyonddoubt thoseaspects of religious behaviour pertain- What didit mean tobe a “foreigner,” or and the religious buildings inside them. (they areoftenmodelled after their Greek ing to theconduct of everyday life, suchas “barbarian,” in various periods in theGreek Afinal—and very substantial—gift is counterparts), were their nameless andcollec- marriageanddeath. context? The various essays provide answers offered to the reader with theAppendices, tivecolleagues. As in the LIMC, theEtruscan worldis well to this question from different perspectives, whichpresent all theprincipalancient “Etruriais thehomelandof anonymous represented in the ThesCRA . It is stated in the as is evident alsofrom those that focus on sources on Etruscan religion in both theorig- gods. These weregrouped into ‘colleges’ or Introduction that Etruscanculturehas been EtruscanandItalicpeople. In this respect we inal texts and translations. Theseinclude the entities,and their number is both unknown “included for its kinship to theClassical,” canmention the religious-historicaldiscus- brontoscopiccalendar transmitted to us by the and unknowable” (172). Far from detracting although “thereis generally less attention sion by A. Mastrocinqueon possible relations Byzantineauthor Johannes Lydus, whose from their relevance, thesefeatures were typ- paid to religion at theperiphery of the between thecult of Apollo at Delphi and that contents go back toaLatin translation,by icalfor someof themost mighty Etruscan Classical world, unless it is firmly based on of Apollo Soranus in theFaliscan territory, Nigidius Figulus,of anEtruscan sacred text divinities,like the diinvoluti , whoseauthori- homelandpractice” (p. XII). [Continued on next page] Page 7 withits peculiar priests able to walk on hot coals; or theepigraphicandprosopographic investigation by S. DeVidoandC. Antonetti into theinteractions betweenGreeks and R e v i e w s indigenous Elymianfrequenters of the sanc- tuaries at Selinus in Sicily. ToA. Nasohim- self weoweanextremely interesting and use- Wikander,Charlotte, and Imagined Etruscan ly. In1972,Burgess remarks, “Lawrence fuloverview of objects dedicated as votive always lacked thedisciplineandobjectivity of offeringsby Etruscans andother Italic wor- ÖrjanWikander. Etruscan Landscapes approach whichmark the true scholar… Nevertheless,his highly idiosyncratic shippers in Greek sanctuaries. by LarissaBonfante Inscriptions from the approach to theEtruscans has probably been Also worth reading are the reports of the Collections of Olof August Arecent review of abiography of D.H. moreinfluential––among nonspecialists,of discussions that followed the various presen- Lawrence: TheLifeof AnOutsider in The course–– than the works of true scholars.” In tations, which were recorded andhavebeen Danielsson. Addenda to 3 New YorkTimes Book Review (December 4, anessay published in 1957 Massimo included in the volume. We thus learn that CIE II,1,4. 2005) 1 ignored theenduring popularity of Pallottino already notes instances of cases after thehistorical talks there was adiscus- (Medelhavsmuseet Memoir Lawrence’s best travelbook, EtruscanPlaces . whereLawrence’s understanding of Etruscan sion on theissueof Delphic treasuries Yet theauthor has deeply influenced the way art,andevenofEtruscanhistory, was more belonging tocommunities of ancient Italy,a 10, 2003.) Pp. 162,figs. 36. people see andexperience thelandscapes of accurate than that of scholars less involved in topic that had already attracted scholars like Tuscany that continue toenthrall modern the reality of themonuments and theland- MuseumofMediterranean scape: henoticed, for example, that the D. Briquel(“LecittàetruscheeDelfi,” Annali tourists, residents of Chiantishire, readers of Etruscan tumuli of thenecropolis of Cerveteri dellaFondazioneMuseoFaina 5[1998]143- andNearEastern TheNew YorkTimes TravelSection,andaudi- ences of thefilm, Under theTuscanSun . werealocalphenomenon,blending into the 169). The treasuries of CaereandSpina Antiquities,Stockholm Unlike Sea andSardinia ,or ThePlumed natureof the surrounding landscape, eliminat- reflected economicandculturalcontacts in 2004. Serpent , whichhavelittle todo withSardinia ing thenecessity of explanations involving theMediterraneanand theAdriatic respec- or Mexico, EtruscanPlaces actually does foreign influence for their forms. Scholarship tively. It is alsointriguing tonote that the capture theatmosphereof theplace – the sur- andart andliteraturehad becomeisolated importance of prophecy anddivination at Reviewed by LarissaBonfante prisingly colorful underground tombpaintings from eachother in thenineteenthcentury; but Delphi matches in some way its importance of ancient Tarquinia, theolivegroves and agood scholar needs tohave thepassion and in Etruscan religion. Aninvestigation into Theauthors of this valuablelittlebook, vineyards of Tuscany. We who belong toan loveof lifeof anartist. Today,in what is in somany ways anewly this and related questions definitely con- themselves distinguished Etruscan scholars earlier generation caneven somehow imagine teaching in Sweden,havecarried out excava- romanticera, when young peoplearemore tributes toan understanding of theplace of thedesolatemalaria-ridden maremma,of tions in thearchives of theUniversity Library Lawrence’s time. open tofeelings, whenobjectivity is not nec- theEtruscans in Greek thought,andof the at Uppsala, thelocation of Olof August I was surprised tofind that Lawrence’s essarily a virtue, and theissueof conservation extent to which theGreeks distinguished the Danielsson’s papers –diaries andletters. The descriptions resonated with the seventeen- looms large, wecanbetter appreciate various Etruscancities at different moments publication of their finds concerns mostly his andeighteen-year old students of aFreshman Lawrence’s romanticattitude towards nature, of their history. painstakingly careful reading of Etruscan honors class to whom Iassigned thebook two and sharemany of his concerns. On the To sum up,although neither the ThesCRA inscriptions,but it alsoilluminates our under- years ago. Though noneof themhad ever importance of theoriginalcontext: “Ifonly nor thebook on sanctuaries edited by Nasois standing of the scholarly history of theperiod, heardof D.H. Lawrence, or knew anything of we would realizeit,andnot tear things from devoted specifically toEtruscanculture, both including thecharacter,lives andinterrela- Lady Chatterley’s Lover , they were thrilled by their settings. Museums anyhow are wrong. But if onemust havemuseums,let thembe contain extensiveas well as intensivediscus- tionships of someof thegreat scholars of the his personal,colorful takeon a scholarly sub- past,andinforms us about the scandals and small,andaboveall let thembe local.” On sions and treatments of theEtruscan situation, ject; oneof my students proudly reported that hardships that beset themand that accompa- a subway rider who had been reading thebook menand women: “TheEtruscans shared the andprovide new insights on topics whose nied this ambitious undertaking. over her shoulder jotted down the titlefor fur- banqueting bench with their wives, whichis information potentialis still far from having The secondpart makes up thebulk of the ther reference when shegot off the train. more than theGreeks or Romans did, at this beenfully exploited. volume, andpresents theepigraphicmaterial Whatgives thebook its power today? period.” On the roleof tombguardians: “So, relating to CIE II,I,4(for which see review, Certainly Lawrence’s invocation of thecon- on theother handfrom thedeer, wehave Conferences JRS 66,1976, 243-244)organized as adden- trast between the vitality of ancient Etruscan lionesses andleopards. These, too,aremale Continued from page4 da. Thedivisions follow thoseof the CIE vol- “phallic” art and theplodding militarismof andfemale…So thesefierce ones guard the ume, withprovenances for theinscriptions ancient Rome, by whichhemeans treasureand thegateway…” 4 Joint ICAHM and from Bomarzo,Ferento-Acquarossa, Orte, Mussolini’s Rome, reflected aconflict that Tuscania, Musarna, Casteld’Asso,Norchia, suited his personalartistic view,as well as the UNESCO Statistics 1.FrancineProse, “Slayer of Taboos,” Blera, SanGiuliano, theAger Tarquiniensis. reality of thehistoricalmoment. As Anthony review of John Worthen, D.H. Lawrence: The Institute(USI)meeting, Cerveteri(though thesemake upmore than Burgess points out in his introduction to the Lifeof AnOutsider, in TheNew YorkTimes half thenumber in CIE II,I,4, they are unfor- Penguin edition of D.H. Lawrence in Italy , Montreal,January 6, 2006 Book Review ,December 4, 2005,page56. tunately almost missing in Danielsson’s col- Lawrence becamefascinated by theEtruscans 2. Anthony Burgess, “Introduction,” in by Christophe Rivet,Secretary,ICAHM lection),SantaMarinella, andCivitavecchia. as early as 1920. In1927, whenhe visited D.H. Lawrence in Italy . Harmondsworth1997 Designations are those used by Helmut Rix in their sites withanAmericanfriend, Italy was (originally published 1972) page x. Present were representatives of: the his standardcollection of inscriptions, just about tobecome thecountry admired by 3. Massimo Pallottino, “Scienzaepoesia UNESCO Statistics Institute; theUNESCO EtruskischeTexte, Editio Minor (Tübingen Miss JeanBrodieand theladies of Tea with alla scopertadell’Etruria,” Quaderni WorldHeritageCentre; theGetty 1991). Mussolini; “Mussolini had not yet made the dell’AssociazioneCulturaleItaliana 24 Conservation Institute; theWorldMonuments trains runon time…” 2 EtruscanPlaces was (1957), reprinted in D.H. Lawrence: Paesi Fund; and theUNWorldTourism Alonger version of this review appeared published posthumously in 1932. etruschi,Siena, Nuovaimagine, 1985,pages Organization. in AJA (2006). For along time EtruscanPlaces was 9-26. Presenters wereasked toaddress theissue enjoyed by apublicfascinated by the 4.D.H. Lawrence, EtruscanPlaces (1932), of defining statisticalindicators for thecon- “Etruscanmystery,” andappreciated by artists vation. “ThePainted Tombs of Tarquinia,” passim. servation of archaeological sites that areon and writers. Scholars andintellectuals consid- TheICAHM presentation focused on the theWorldHeritageList. WillemWillems ered it tobe too romantic tobe taken serious- (Netherlands,VPEurope)gave thepresenta- WorldHeritagenomination process, the tools tion prepared on behalf of ICAHM by Willem used in this process (theOperational Guidelines, themanagement regime require- Willems,ChristopheRivet (Canada, develop indicators. For moreinformation,please visit thefol- ments andespecially thecriteria),and the Secretary) andDougComer (US, VPNorth- Theconclusion of the session was that there lowing link (for abriefabstract): basicprinciples of conservation as stated in America). is aneed tocontinue thediscussion in amore http://www.archaeological.or g/webinfo.ph thecharters, to suggest aframework todevel- Thepresenters addressed theissueof meas- substantialformat and toaddress themany p?page=10248 op indicators for siteconservation. Themain uring theimpact of tourism, theimpact of concerns associated withindicators in differ- Thepresentations will be made publicly in arguments were that themain criteria(the 6 availability of government resources for site ent fora. ICAHM has expressed its availabili- thenear futureby theUSI. We will keep the culturalcriteria +authenticity andintegrity) conservation,multiple values,criteriafor site ty tocontinue thediscussion on indicators for membership informed of any futuredevelop- and themanagement requirements detailed in monitoring,and theobjectiveof siteconser- siteconservation issues. ment. thenomination proposal wereeffective to Page 8 Herbs in the Materiamedica. Fig. 1:Attic red-figurecupby the Continued from page1 Onesimos Painter, withathlete seen NOTES from the back. 5thcentury B.C. gies appearing in themanuscript tradition. 1. Greek text:Max Wellmann,ed., Pedanii Rome,Capitoline Museum. Botanical terms in Etruscanperhaps had Dioscuridis AnazarbeiDemateriamedica, 3 becomefairly rareby Pamphilus’ day; or, vols. (Berlin 1906-1914, reprinted 1958). Fig. 2:Attic red-figurecupby the given theEgyptianprovenance of Pamphilus’ Expertly translated from theWellmann edi- Onesimos Painter, withathlete originaldictionary,it is quitelikely that the tion by Lily Y. Beck, withintroduction by drawing water from a well. 5th alternatives in Egyptianpredominate theman- John Scarborough, Pedanius Dioscorides of century B.C.Rome,Capitoline uscript traditions in company with “Greek” Anazarbus Demateriamedica (Berlin and Museum. and “Roman.” ThoseEtruscan sixteenare New York 2005). important,in spiteof their small fraction of 2. Thebasicessay remains Max Wellmann, the whole, since carefulidentifications of the “Pamphilos,” Hermes 51 (1916) 1-64. species and thedrugs made from themcan 3. E.g. the “HippocraticTerminologies” indicate someaspects of aparticularly compiled by ErotianinGreek, sometimein Etruscanherbalism. theFlavianera. Ernst Nachmanson,ed., Materiamedica,II,175(Wellm.,I,pp. Erotiani VocumHippocraticarumcollectio 242-243) is adescription of the batra-v (Göteborg1918). Erotianis evidence that Fig. 1 cion, probably thelesser celandineor pile- Dioscorides’ MateriaMedica achieved imme- wort ( Ranunculus ficaria L.),and the diatepopularity, since MM,IV, 76 (Wellm. II, 237 [“aconite”])is quoted. Earlier “Tuscan” name( RV)is givenas a[pioum> “Hippocratic” lexica appeared beginning in rJaninov um>. Theseterms are similar to the the 3rdcent. B.C. Wesley D. Smith, The Greek a[pion (“pear”) or Latin apium (“cel- HippocraticTradition (Ithaca 1979) s.v. index ery” or “parsley”),andLatin’s rana (“frog”).9 entries,Bacchius [of Tanagra]. Dioscorides also says that it is called seli-v 4. John M. Riddle, Dioscorides on Pharmacy andMedicine (Austin 1985). non a[grion (“wildcelery”) in Sardinia: not 5. Especially evident in the unsatisfactory aparticularly significant detail until one translation produced by John Goodyer some- remembers that Sardinia was part of the timeafter 1650 (but not published until 1934), Etruscanorbit in the westernMediterranean. lightly edited by Robert T. Gunther as The Pliny’s translationof “littlefrog” for the GreekHerbalofDioscorides (Oxford1934; Greek reflects thefrog-like(or fig-like) shape Fig. 2 reprinted New York1959). of themoist and swollen root-tubers of this 6. Extant aremany suchlistings in Greek perennial. Thecommon name, “pilewort” ranging from Hesychius and theByzantine records thehistoricalherbal useof the roots in Suda, to thegiganticcompilation knownas the treatment of hemorrhoids:alogical result the Etymologicon Magnum. from thepresence in leaves and roots of tan- 7. Wellmann,Vol. III,p. 358. nins,ascorbicacid, andantemol,all extreme- 8. “Alpha’” under “Romana” ( ibid . 350- ly astringent natural substances. Suggestive 351)alonehas 46 entries andnumbers of Fig. 3 too is the useof theleaves and stems as pre- alternatives. “Aegyptiaca” ( ibid. 327-329)has scribed by Dioscorides for the treatment of 150 entries,etc. mange, wart-removal,as a sternutatory,and 9. Pliny, NaturalHistory,XXV,172, trans- for reliefof thepains of a toothache. Etruscan Fig. 3:Etruscan terracotta statuetteofa lates batrachion intoLatin’s ranunculus (“lit- herbalists,by contrast,employed the “froggy seated ancestor from the Tombof the tlefrog”). roots” for hemorrhoids,ause not mentioned FiveChairs,Cerveteri. 7thcentury B.C. Rome,Capitoline Museum.
Fig. 4:AntonellaMagagnini,Curatore Archeologadei Musei Capitolini. Fig. 4
Castellani included this onein his first donation of objects to theMuseoCapitolino. There were Continued from page1 originally five statuettes,dated 650-600 B.C., seated on fivechairs carved into the tufaof a the three registers of this famous Etrusco- side chamber intended to represent a small Corinthian vase, made between 630-600 B.C., domestic sanctuary for theancestor cult. The is still controversial. object is thus tobe seenas anancestor, Etruscanobjects of particular importance invoked in ritualceremonies. aredisplayed separately. TheAristonothos In thefirst gallery areexhibited on a wood- krater,acquired by AugustoCastellani at enbase two terracotta sarcophagi,one witha Cerveteriaround1869( Bollettino di femalefigure, theother withamale. These CorrispondenzaArcheologica) ,later came to werepart of Castellani’s first donation to the theCapitolioneMuseum. Inits new display in Capitolinecollections in 1866 and were thecenter of thegallery, thedecoration of this almost certainly acquired by him in Tuscania, important find, dating from 675-650 B.C.,can where they werefoundin tombcontexts of be studied from all directions:on one side is themid-2ndc. B.C. A recent study of its con- theblinding of theCyclops Polyphemos,and servation has shownhow radical18thc. inter- on theother,abattlebetween two ships. ventions werein restorations of ancient Prominently displayed on the vaseis the sig- objects. The study also revealed that both sar- natureof Aristonothos, theartist who created cophagi wereinscribed: on theoneof the it. femalefigure withanEtruscaninscription Another casecontains the terracotta stat- painted in black,on theone with themalefig- uetteof a seated malefigurefrom theTombof ure, withaLatin inscription in darkgray theFiveChairs in Cerveteri; another two paint. Theseare theonly inscriptions known were soldby Castellani to theBritish up tonow on the46 terracotta sarcophagi Museum. Heacquired thegroupin1866 and made in Tuscania. Violet,from the ViennaDioscurides (WikimediaCommons) Page 9 C a l l s f o r P a p e r s
Halma-Ipel ?UMR8164(CNRS, Lille 3, expressions of interest canbe sent to thechair “TerracottaFigurines in MCC) of theconference organizing committee, “Preistoriaeprotostoriain theGreekandRoman Histoire, Archéologie, Littératuredes Professor FrancoDeAngelis (University of Etruria: Paesaggi reali e Mondes Anciens BritishColumbia)at EasternMediterranean BP 60149 [email protected]. Abstracts of no paesaggi mentali” ProductionandDiffusion, F-59653 Villeneuved’Ascq,Cedex, more than100-150 words for talks of twenty EighthMeeting,September 15-17, 2006. FRANCE. minutes shouldbe sent by e-mail attachment Universitàdegli StudidiMilano. Iconography and Fax: +33.3.204163 65. by theSeptember 15, 2006 deadline to the DipartimentodiScienzedelleAntichità, Function” E-mail:
Page 15 Greci. ArcheologiaepitturadallaMagna IFeniciinItaliadall’orienteall’occidente , Greciaalcollezionismo,exhibition catalogue, exhibition catalogue, Milan,Biblioteca diVia Milan,PalazzoReale, 3October 2004-16 Senato,October 2004-April 2005(Milan A n n o u n c e m e n t s January 2005(Milano 2004) 200,n. 180. 2004). N. Kaltsas,ed., Agon,exhibition catalogue, IlSettecentoaRoma ,exhibition catalogue, Athens,NationalArchaeologicalMuseum,15 Rome, PalazzoVenezia 2005-2006 (catalogue The cartoon below,by Tom Cheney,appeared in the May/June 2006 issueof July - 31October 2004(Athens 2004)112- entries for theApuliankrater by theIliupersis Archaeology .Our Editor-in-Chief put it on the finalexamfor her beginning Latin 113,n. 11. (AtticRed Figurehydriaby the Painter,inv. 18255,and thePestankrater classes and asked them to writeacaption in Latin. Twoof the responses aregiven Painter of theBoston Phiale, inv. 16549). attributed toPython,inv. 17370). here. Fortunatae Insulae,exhibition catalogue (SantaCruz -Tenerife 2004).
PowerandDeathin Verucchio
There wereVillanovans of rank, “excel- lent men,” who,in lifeandin death,displayed their political, religious,andmilitary power. It is thesemenand theprestigious furnishings of their tombs that are the subject of theexhibit “Il “Armaparemus ne libertas nostra tollatur.” (Let us preparearms so that our liberty PotereelaMorte,” opening may not be taken away.) RenishaEpps April 12, 2006 at theMuseo CivicoArcheologicodi “Dicohaecmala verba ne discedatis.” (I say thesebad words so that you may not Verucchio. depart.) Jason Skipper With this exhibit, theMuseo ArcheologicodiVerucchio opens Competition one that he thinks is particularly good-look- to thepublic thenewly restored ing. The shepherdlooks at him and says, “You We want toinclude thelighter side of areacarabiniere, aren’t you?” Thecarabiniere ChurchofS. Agostino, which, scholarship and travel, so send us your jokes, attached to themuseum,endows it with is surprised, becauseheis out of uniform,and cartoons,andfunny stories. Thecompetition says, “Yes,Iam,but how did you know?” anew space particularly adapted for tem- for teachers is alist of thebest “inspired mis- porary exhibits. This offers theopportunity to “Well, “says the shepherd,” you just picked takes” you receivefrom your students. the sheepdog.” display,for thefirst time, exceptionalmateri- Wooden table from the Verucchio exhibit Following are someof our personal alfrom someof Verucchio’s most important “Power and Death” favorites (from LarissaBonfante, Francesco tombcontexts, recently restored, as well as de Angelis,andLaurieSchneider): some relevant objects from the 2005excava- and symbols of rank andpower in funerary EtruscanNews Online tion season. Theseareburials of individuals of contexts;” “Materialfrom thenew excava- Question:Identify theTarpeianRock. high rank,identified as warriors from the tions.” Answer:TheTarpeianRock was a stone The staff of EtruscanNews Online is prestigious objects that comprised their funer- Theexhibit will runfrom April 13, 2006 to from which theTarpeianlanguage was deci- pleased toannounce thelaunchofits new ary offerings. January 6, 2007 at Verucchio (Rimini). phered. webpagein February 2006. The site, which Theexhibit illustrates thefollowing Telephone: 0541-670222; email:iat.veruc - is hosted by theUniversity of Massachusetts themes: “Verucchio:artistocracy, rank and chio@iper .net Question:What was thenameof the room Amherst (http://www.umass.edu/etruscan - roles in anIron Agecommunity;” “Clothing in aRomanhouse where they slept? news), was designed andproduced by Andrew andcostume;” “Clothing adornments;” Answer:Atribiculum. Wilson,aprofessionalgraphicdesigner, who “Bronzeandceramicbanquet ves- kindly offered his timeandexpertise to the sels;” “Woodenfurnishings Question:What is the universemade of develop the webpage.We think that you will from TombB/1971Strada according toLucretius? findhis design aesthetically pleasing andhis provincialeMarecchese Answer:The worldis made upof tiny organizational schemaeasy tonavigate. 15 bis;” “Weapons for Adams. EtruscanNews Online is now openfor combat andparade;” submissions of articles, reviews,conference “Chariots andhar- Question:DefineGothicarchitecture. reports,andletters. Inorder tofacilitate the nesses;” “Power Answer:Pointed andfalling arches. ‘publication’of submissions in electronicfor- anddeath: signs mat, weaskcontributors toadhere to thefol- Question:What is the significance of A.D. lowing guidelines: 313? All submissions to EtruscanNews Online Answer:It is the year Christ was resurrect- shouldbemade by electronicmail. ed. All submissions shouldbemade in a text document (preferably Microsoft Word)as Question:Identify Zeus. well as in PortableDocument Format (PDF). Answer:Aplace tokeepanimals. Submissions may include color images. Please submit contributions viaelectronic Question:What was theIliad? mail to: Answer:Aplay about Achilles’ heel. (a)[email protected] or toany of thefollowing editors: Acarabiniere was toldby his commander to (b)LarissaBonfante: go get a sheepfor abig banquet that was [email protected] planned. So that weekend thecarabiniere (c)JaneWhitehead: changes intocivilianclothes,andgoes out [email protected] into thecountry tofindashepherd. Hegoes (d)Rex Wallace: Fig. 1. Wooden table from GraveB/1971 up to the shepherd, who is in thefields with [email protected] Lippi,early 7thcentury B.C. his flock,andhe says he wants tobuy a sheep. The shepherd says, “Fine, here they are, look For moreinformation on submissions, Fig. 2.Amber fibulaefrom Grave aroundandpickout theone you want.” The please visit the ‘contribute’pageof Etruscan 47/1972 Lippi,end 8thcentury B.C. carabinierelooks around, andfinally points to News Online .
Page 16