WRW Issue 14 Jan 12.Indb
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Writing for a Real World A multidisciplinary anthology by USF students PUBLISHED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF SAN FRANCISCO DEPARTMENT OF RHETORIC AND LANGUAGE www.usfca.edu/wrw Writing for a Real World (WRW) is published annually by the Department of Rhetoric and Language, College of Arts and Sciences, University of San Francisco. WRW is governed by the Rhetoric and Language Publication Committee, chaired by David Holler. Members are: Brian Komei Dempster, Philip Hanson, David Holler, Michelle LaVigne, Ana Rojas, Michael Rozendal, and David Ryan. Writing for a Real World: 14th edition © 2017 The opinions stated herein are those of the authors. Authors retain copyright for their individual work. Essays include bibliographical references. The format and practice of documenting sources are determined by each writer. Writers are responsible for validating and citing their research. Cover image: Veil II (2015, digital pigment print, 36"x24") © Jamil Hellu http://JamilHellu.net Reproduction courtesy of Jamil Hellu Thanks to Kristen Sandifer for the photo of Tracy Seeley Reproduction courtesy of University of Nebraska Press Printer: BR Printing, San Jose, California Thanks to James Barrios and Lori Shimizu Norr To get involved as a referee, serve on the publication committee, obtain back print issues, or to learn about submitting to WRW, please contact David Holler <[email protected]>. Back issues are now available online via Gleeson Library’s Digital Collections. <www.usfca.edu/library/dc/wrw> For all other inquiries: Writing for a Real World University of San Francisco Kalmanovitz Hall, Rm. 202 2130 Fulton Street San Francisco, CA 94117 Fair Use Statement: Writing for a Real World is an educational journal whose mission is to showcase the best undergraduate writing at the University of San Francisco. Student work often contextualizes and recontextualizes the work of others within the scope of course-related assignments. WRW presents these articles with the specifi c objective of advancing an understanding of academic knowledge, scholarship, and research. We believe that this context constitutes a “fair use” of copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material herein is made available by WRW without profi t to those students and faculty who are interested in receiving this information for research, scholarship, and educational purposes. Writing for a Real World Issue Fourteen 2015–2016 EDITOR David Holler EXECUTIVE EDITOR David Ryan SENIOR COPY EDITORS Ben Brandenburg Kristen Chang Liam Lynch Michelle Tran Aubrey Welsh COPY EDITORS Grace Lu Douglas Mejia Paula Mirando Jessy Sandler Isabel White COVER DESIGN Liam Lynch PROGRAM ASSISTANT Deja Gill 4 JOURNAL REFEREES Gina Arnold, Rhetoric and Language Robert Bathrick, Rhetoric and Language Paula Birnbaum, Art + Architecture Roberta D’Alois, Rhetoric and Language Brian Komei Dempster, Rhetoric and Language Leslie Dennen, Rhetoric and Language Doreen Ewert, Rhetoric and Language Cathy Gabor, Rhetoric and Language Philip Hanson, Rhetoric and Language David Holler, Rhetoric and Language Devon Christina Holmes, Rhetoric and Language Jacquelyn Rae Horton, Rhetoric and Language Nicole Gonzales Howell, Rhetoric and Language Jonathan Hunt, Rhetoric and Language Michelle LaVigne, Rhetoric and Language Tika Lamsal, Rhetoric and Language Genevieve Leung, Rhetoric and Language Tom Lugo, Rhetoric and Language Catherine Lusheck, Art + Architecture David Masterson, Rhetoric and Language Theodore Matula, Rhetoric and Language Mark Meritt, Rhetoric and Language Osita Udekwu, Rhetoric and Language Ana Rojas, English Michael Rozendal, Rhetoric and Language David Ryan, Rhetoric and Language Cynthia M Schultes, Rhetoric and Language Carol Spector, Gleeson Library Julie A Sullivan, Rhetoric and Language Stephanie Vandrick, Rhetoric and Language 5 WRITING FOR A REAL WORLD Table of Contents DAVID HOLLER Editor’s Introduction 8 Honorable Mentions 13 ADRIAN BIHUN Dejima and Japan’s Trepidatious Relations with the West 17 MINDIE BERNARD Gendering Violence in the Bosnian War 40 LUIS CAMACHO Can Motivated Cognition Exacerbate a Bias? 54 ALEX CASEY Transgender Migration and the Movement of the Body 68 DAI GUERRA Stigma, Abuse, and Mental Health in the Transgender Population 82 6 WRITING FOR A REAL WORLD AKANA JAYEWARDENE Twenty-fi rst Century Placemaking: Finding a Sense of Home in a Supermodernized, Hyperglobalized World 105 PAULA MIRANDO Shared Experiences of Multiethnic Children in Stealing Buddha’s Dinner 126 NATALIE OCHSNER Robert Louis Stevenson’s Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde: A Window into the World of Victorian Era Science 140 ANNETTE TAYLOR Constructing Contemplation: The Sculptural Allegories Hidden Within the “Third Nature” of the Garden of Bomarzo 151 MAISY WILDERMUTH Too Much Bad News: The Mental Repercussions of Distressing Media 171 Issue Fifteen Submissions Information 182 7 WRITING FOR A REAL WORLD Editor’s Introduction RACY SEELEY SERVED as a beloved Professor of English at USF from T1993 until her passing in the summer of 2016. Among her many contributions to this campus’s intellectual life, she was instrumental in co- founding USF’s Center for Teaching Excellence. Tracy, to those of us who knew her, was also a powerful mentor, whose candor and humor and insight positively impacted colleagues and students alike. She was univer- sally respected here, and the renaming of USF’s Center for Teaching Ex- cellence in her honor is but one way we recognize her contributions; the powerful and poignant celebration held in her honor among colleagues in Fall 2016 was another; and the dedication of this issue to her memory likewise seeks to keep her works and days foremost in our hearts. Notes on the Selection and Publication Process This issue, as with all thirteen of its predecessors, is the result of a com- petitive selection process. Each year the WRW publication committee issues a call for students to submit their top two papers in May. More than twenty faculty and librarian readers, in service to the university, then spend about three weeks anonymously scoring the work. Natu- rally, all reviewers agree to recuse themselves if they recognize their own students’ work. Everything here in print—and every honorable men- tion—received high marks from at least four faculty or librarian review- ers. From our many submissions this year we selected ten works. No- tifi cations were issued in June, after which the authors were invited to revise and polish their work before resubmitting manuscripts in August. Student copyeditors in my RHET 325/ENGL 325 course then took over in August and helped lay out and revise every page of this book throughout the fall. To my staff of ace copyeditors who pored over ev- ery sentence you’re about to read, I owe a great debt. They truly helped professionalize this book, and many of them will be compassionately wielding red pens in editorial capacities in the future. 8 WRITING FOR A REAL WORLD Notes on This Year’s Publications First and foremost, we congratulate Adrian Bihun, winner of the Fr. Urban Grassi, S.J., Award for Eloquentia Perfecta for his top-scoring entry, “Dejima and Japan’s Trepidatious Relationship with the West.” Written for Professor Glyn Redworth’s history course at Oxford, which Adrian took during his study abroad program in association with USF’s St. Ig- natius Institute, Adrian’s work offers an insightful analysis of Japan’s ill- fated attempts to thwart European infl uence. It’s an outstanding essay, carefully researched. (It was also, I must say, a pleasure to work closely with Adrian in preparing this piece for publication.) Following Adrian’s piece we present Mindie Bernard’s outstanding essay, “Gendering Violence in the Bosnian War.” Written for Professor Filip Kovacevic’s Politics and Change in East-Central Europe course, Mindie’s research offers a powerful reminder of how nationalism and hypermasculinity combined to catastrophic effect in the Balkans in the 1990s. Next we offer Luis Camacho’s “Can Motivated Cognition Exacer- bate a Bias?” Written for Professor Saera Khan’s Advanced Research Methods class, this research makes a strong contribution to sociolin- guistics, especially in terms of perceptions of stereotypes in accented English. Following Luis’s piece is Alex Casey’s “Transgender Migration and the Movement of the Body,” springing from an analysis of Thomas McBee’s novel Man Alive. Professor Christina Garcia Lopez has high praise for Alex’s work in her introduction, and I echo her sentiments here. Dai Guerra’s “Stigma, Abuse, and Mental Health in the Transgender Population,” written for Professor Kevin Chun’s Critical Diversity Stud- ies capstone project, offers not just important insights on transgender research, but also valuable advice to the USF community. Moving from Psychology to Art + Architecture, we are happy to print Akana Jayewardene’s senior thesis, “Twenty-fi rst Century Place- making: Finding a Sense of Home in a Super-modernized, Hyperglobal- ized World,” which explores San Francisco from numerous perspectives. 9 WRITING FOR A REAL WORLD Her work was conducted at the fascinating intersection of philosophy and architectural theory. Professor Tanu Sankalia and Professor Ron Sundstrom are also credited for having encouraged the interdisciplinary cooperation that led to Akana’s fi ne work. Our seventh essay, “Shared Experiences of Multiethnic Children in Stealing Buddha’s Dinner,” by Paula Mirando, was written for Professor Christina Garcia