Avista Forum
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AVISTA FORUM Association Villard de Honnecourt for the Interdisciplinary Study of Medieval Technology, Science, and Art Volume 6 Number 1 Fall 199 1 / Spring 1992 d - FROM THEEDITOR developments not only in our own, but in a variety of associated - disciplines. However, unlike messages from the divine, which are apprehended by the believer's "inner senses," we mortal IS ANYONE OUT THERE?? scholars must finally commit our thoughts into such tangible forms as the written word on the printed page. Professor Linda AVING RECEIVED NARY a response to my questions Con- Neagley of UCLA and I will undertake a project on plan design cerning the format of AVISTAFORUM, I can only assume in ~othicarchitecture this summer focusing on the thirteenth- H that you gentle readers are completely content with century church of Saint-Urbain in Troyes and the fourteenth- things as they stand. Pending an outpouring of advice or opinion century choir of Saint-Ouen in Rouen. We plan to conduct a ten- to the contrary, you can look forward to future issues maintaining week campaign of computer-assisted measuring and, by the Fall, the current balance of news and reviews. During the coming year, hope to torture the data into yielding at least some preliminary we, hopefully, will get the FORUMback on its Fall and Spring hypotheses. But if we are to approach the broader goals of this schedule. However, this can only be accomplished with your help project, we will need to be informed of similar work being camed and participation. If this publication is to remain more than a out by others in the fields of archaeoIogy, architectural history, newsletter, it needs your active support in the form of article and mathematics. to name but a few. The AVISTA FORUMseems an reviews, book reviews, notes, and queries. It is patently ridicu- ideal vehicle, and one that we plan to use, for the airing of such lous that I have authored four of the five reviews that appear in research-in-progress because of the ecumenical character of the this issue for I am sure that I am not the only AVISTAmember who readership and their extraordinary range of expertise. This is not has been reading during the past six months. Perhaps you are all only one of the few journals that publishes article reviews; it is too polite and feel that unsolicited submissions are unwelcomed almost unique in publishing questions. As other periodicals or perhaps you assume that I labor with an enormous backlog of ossify ideologically, I want to affirm our guiding editorial prin- material. Let me assure you that the floppy disks of future issues ciples or informality, debate, and multi-vocality. I would like to are completely clear at the moment. Eternal optimist that I am, I move the AVISTA~o~u~closer to the pulse of ongoing activity, to remain convinced that the AVISTAFORUM has an important niche use it as a testing ground for thoughts and ideas as they unfold, not to occupy in the interdisciplinary world of pre-modern studies as passive mirror that only reflects back highly polished surfaces. and, despite fax machines and e-mail, it can play a part in the So I appeal to you once more. Send us your summer's "postcards exchange of information, and opinions. from the edge" or wherever you happen to be, for together, we can Carl Barnes, Jr. has announced his retirement as the Art and gain clearer visions of the horizons toward which we gaze. 0% Architecture editor. My regret at his departure is, however, MTD tempered by profound thanks for his many contributions and anticipation of future bulletins on the state of Villard research. I have profited from a semester as a visiting member of the History of Art Department at the University of Michigan to charm Robert CONTENTS Page Russell, assistant professor at the University of Michigan, Dearborn, into taking up the editorial reins as Carl's successor. Editorial. .................................................................................. 1 Robert is a specialist in Italian Gothic architecture, having Directors ................................................................................... 2 completed his dissertation on civic palaces in Lombardy with Call for Papers .......................................................................... 2 Princeton University. He has also authored abook, in collaboration Annual Business Meeting of AVISTA,May 1992 ....................... 2 with Eugene J. Johnson of Williams College, on the architecture From the President ................................................................... 3 of Memphis, Tennessee. Thus, our editorial net will surely be cast AVISTASessions at Kalamazoo, May 1992 ................................ 3 in exciting new directions. As noted on the last page of the issue, In Memoriam: Thomas W. Lyman .......................................... 4 reviews on any aspect of medieval art and architecture may be Book Review: Bestiaries .......................................................... 4 sent to him at 1640 Knight Road, Ann Arbor, MI 48103. Reviews of Articles: A feature that I would like to begin to include in the next and Ubar ..................................................................................... 5 subsequent issues is reports from the field. As summer ap- Italian Architecture ............................................................. 5 proaches and with it the opportunity to pursue long-term research Views of St-Maur ............................................................... 7 projects in archives, libraries, and on-site abroad, valuable new News from Members and Affiliated Societies ......................... 7 information will be gleaned, new conclusions proposed, and Recent and Forthcoming Papers .............................................. 8 innumerable questions will be formulated. Once again, it seems Activities-Past, Present, Future ........................................ 11 to me that the AVISTAFORUM can and should be in the forefront of Abstracts, AVISTASessions ...................................................... 15 reporting its members' activities and serving as a crossroads of Bibliography of AVISTALibrary ........................................17 communication. Presumably, one reason we joined and remain a Editorial Board (Deadline, Fall 1992 issue) ..........................18 part of this organization is that we seek to stay abreast of AVISTAmembership application. .............................................18 CALL FOR PAPERS Association Villard de Honnecourt for the Interdisciplinary Study of Medieval Technology, Science, and Art The Mechanical Arts- AVISTA FORUM How Things Move and Work... Philosophical and Practical Approaches Volume 6 Number 1 Fall 1991 /Spring 1992 28th International Congress on Medieval Studies May 1993 Editor: Michael T. Davis The Medieval Institute Western Michigan University O 1992 AVISTA, Inc. Kalamazoo, Michigan Association Villard de Honnecourt for the W. Ted Szwejkowski, Organizer Interdisciplinary Study of Medieval Technology, Science, and Art Possible Topics Include: 1. Craft traditions and practices 2. The philosophical context of medieval technology 3. Medieval mechanization Haverford College 4. The place of the mechanical arts in medieval epistemology Haverford, PA 19041 U.S.A. 5. Attitudes to work and labor Papers are limited to twenty minutes. Please send one-page Officers 1991 - 1992: abstracts, including audio-visual needs by 1 October 1992 to: President: Charles S tegeman Vice-President: Ronald Edward Zupko W. Ted Szwejkowski C/OThe Institute for the History and Philosophy of Secretary: Marie-Thir5se Zenner Science and Technology Treasurer: Richard A. Sundt Room 3 16, Victoria College, University of Toronto Counsel: Holbrook M. Bunting, Jr. 73 Queen's Park Crescent E. Toronto, Ontario European Director: Jean Gimpel Canada M5S 1K7 North American Directors: James Addiss ( 1994) Jean Bony (1992) Marjorie N. Boyer (1992) William W. Clark ( 1993) Michael T. Davis (1994) ANNUAL BUSINESS MEETING, Bert Hall ( 1994) A VIS TA Mark Infusino ( 1993) Barbara M. Kreutz (1994) Saturday, 9 May 1992 Yoshio Kusaba (1992) 12:OO to I :00 p.m. Pamela 0. Long (1992) Vivian Paul (1993) Room 1010 Fetzer Charles M. Radding ( 1992) Western Michigan University W. Ted Szwejkowski (1993) Kalamazoo, Michigan AVISTA FORUM is produced by We invite your participation. The Laser Touch, Inc., based in The Great Valley Corporate Center, Malvern, PA. - Page 3 If the thing is worth doing, it is worth doing well. So, the first A MESSAGE FROM THE question I askof you: is it worth doing? If your answer is positive, 1 PRESIDENT I must ask you a second question: Would you please contribute to the communal effort. You can contribute by paying promptly, by sending in articles, however brief and sketchy, about anything ou WILL AT ONCE NOTICE two differences with this new issue that is relevant to your discipline and/or your own work in it, by Y O~AVISTAFORUM. First, this issue arrives late, and for this we giving critique, suggestions, additions, or whatever comments apologize. And second, its format has changed. Of course, there may be relevant to your thinking. Collectively, we can assure an is no excuse to miss a deadline, but there are some reasons for it intellectual health and professional forum for AVISTA. that I wanted to share with you. I believe that these reasons may I ask these things with as much emphasis as I am able, because be related to the change of format. I do'see one great danger, and that danger is real. The one thing Mike Davis