The Study for Tien Sa - Da Nang Port Improvement Project (Phase 2)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF VIETNAM MINISTRY OF TRANSPORT PROJECT MANAGEMENT UNIT 85 The Study for Tien Sa - Da Nang Port Improvement Project (Phase 2) Final Report December 2014 JAPAN INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION AGENCY (JICA) JAPAN PORT CONSULTANTS, LTD. THE OVERSEAS COASTAL AREA 1R DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE OF JAPAN JR 14-051 Satellite Image in Project Site (Tien Sa Port) Breakwater Birth-1 Tien Sa Terminal Birth-2 Pier No.1 Birth-3 Birth-4 Pier No.2 Access Road Pier No.3 Birth-5 0 100 200 300 m Bathymetric/Topographic Map in Project Site (Tien Sa Port) Source: Draft Feasibility Study Report for Tien Sa Terminal - Da Nang Port Improvement Project (Phase 2) in Da Nang, 2014, PMU85 Layout Plan Prepared by Study Team Abbreviations ADB Asian Development Bank AIDS Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome ASEAN Association of South-East Asian Nations AH Asia Highway B Beam BA Bidding Assistance BD Basic Design CFS Container Freight Station CKEZ The Central Vietnam Key Economic Zone CS Construction Supervision DARD Department of Agriculture and Rural Development DD Detailed Design DONRE Department of Natural Recourse and Environment DPA Da Nang Port Authority DPC Da Nang Port Holding Limited Liability Campany DWT Deadweight Ton EIA Environment Impact Assessment EIRR Economic Internal Rate of Return EWEC East-West Economic Corridor EZ Economic Zone FIRR Financial Internal Rate of Return GC General Cargo GDP Gross Domestic Product GRT Gross Ton GMS Great Mekong Sub-region HCMC Ho Chi Minh City HIV Human Immunodeficiency Virus HWL High Water Level ICB Interlocking Concrete Block ICD Inland Container Depot IZ Industrial Zone JICA Japan International Cooperation Agency JPY Japanese Yen LOA Length Over All LWL Low Water Level MONRE Ministry of Natural Recourse and Environment MOT Ministry of Transport NH National Highway ODA Official Development Assistance OECF The Overseas Economic Cooperation Fund OEZ Open Economic Zone O/M Operation and Maintenance PAP Project Affected People PC People’s Committee PIANC International Navigation Association PMU85 Project Management Unit 85 RAP Resettlement Action Plan RS Reach Stacker RTG Rubber-Tyred Gantry RWL Residual Water Level SAPROF Special Terms for Project Formation SEZ Special Economic Zone SS Suspended Solid SSG Ship to Shore Gantry STEP Special Terms for Economic Partnership TEU Twenty-foot Equivalent Unit TOR Terms of Reference VINALINES Vietnam National Shipping Lines VINAMARINE Vietnam Maritime Administration VND Vietnamese Dong VMS Vietnam Maritime Safety WB World Bank Satellite Image in Project Site (Tien Sa Port) Bathymetric/Topographic Map in Project Site (Tien Sa Port) Layout Plan Prepared by Study Team Abbreviations CONTENTS 1. Approach of Study ................................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Project Background ................................................................................................................................. 1 1.2 Flow of Study ........................................................................................................................................... 2 2. Review of DFS Report .......................................................................................................... 3 2.1 Objective of Project ................................................................................................................................. 3 2.2 Back Ground and Necessity of Project .................................................................................................. 3 (1) Current Condition of Tien Sa Port ..................................................................................................... 3 (2) Issues of Da Nang Port and Other Ports in Vietnam .......................................................................... 9 (3) Current Trend and Policy of Industrial Developments in Da Nang Port Hinterlands ...................... 11 (4) Activities of Overseas Aid Organizations to Ports Projects in Vietnam ........................................... 42 (5) Current Condition of Road and Railway Network ........................................................................... 42 (6) General Concept of Da Nang Port Development ............................................................................. 60 (7) Traffic Demand for Tien Sa Port ...................................................................................................... 64 (8) Necessity of Project ......................................................................................................................... 72 2.3 Project Scope .......................................................................................................................................... 78 (1) Terminal Layout ............................................................................................................................... 78 (2) Yard Layout ...................................................................................................................................... 81 (3) Basic Design of Major Facilities ...................................................................................................... 86 (4) Construction Method and Schedule ................................................................................................. 99 2.4 Procurement Method ........................................................................................................................... 102 2.5 Draft TOR for Consulting Services .................................................................................................... 103 2.6 Project Cost and Financial Plan ......................................................................................................... 103 (1) Project Cost .................................................................................................................................... 103 (2) Financial Plan ................................................................................................................................ 105 2.7 Implementation Schedule .................................................................................................................... 105 2.8 Implementation Structure of Project ................................................................................................. 106 2.9 Management System of Port Development in Central Vietnam ...................................................... 106 2.10 Structure and Budget for Maintenance and Operation ................................................................. 107 (1) Operation System ........................................................................................................................... 107 (2) Potential Local Operator ................................................................................................................ 108 (3) Potential International Operator ..................................................................................................... 112 (4) Maintenance System ...................................................................................................................... 112 2.11 Operational Efficiency and Economic and Financial Analysis ...................................................... 114 (1) Operational Efficiency ................................................................................................................... 114 (2) Financial Analysis .......................................................................................................................... 114 (3) Economic Analysis......................................................................................................................... 127 2.12 Natural Conditions Study ................................................................................................................. 132 (1) Land and Seabed Elevations .......................................................................................................... 132 (2) Sub-soil Conditions ........................................................................................................................ 132 (3) Wind Conditions ............................................................................................................................ 133 (4) Wave .............................................................................................................................................. 133 (5) Water Level .................................................................................................................................... 133 (6) Seismic Condition .......................................................................................................................... 134 2.13 Environmental Considerations ......................................................................................................... 135 (1) Overview of Project Components that gives Environmental and Social Impacts .......................... 135 (2) Background of Natural and Socioeconomic Environmental Conditions ....................................... 138 (3) Organization and Legislation for Environmental Considerations in Vietnam ............................... 139 (4) Assessment of Alternatives ............................................................................................................ 140 (5) Scoping and TOR for Environmental Surveys ..............................................................................