The Gospel for the Poor: Reimagining the Church’S Engagement with the Poor in Conversation with Clement of Alexandria, John Chrysostom, and Gregory Nazianzen
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Gospel for the Poor: Reimagining the Church’s Engagement with the Poor in Conversation with Clement of Alexandria, John Chrysostom, and Gregory Nazianzen by J. Shane Comellas Date: April 21, 2020 Approved: 4/25/2020 st Dr. J. Warren Smith, 1 Reader nd Dr. Christopher A. Beeley, 2 Reader Dr. William Willimon,D.Min.Director An abstract of a thesis in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Ministry in the Divinity School of Duke University 2020 ABSTRACT The Gospel for the Poor: Reimagining the Church’s Engagement with the Poor in Conversation with Clement of Alexandria, John Chrysostom, and Gregory Nazianzen by J. Shane Comellas Date: April 21, 2020 Approved: 4/25/2020 st Dr. J. Warren Smith, 1 Reader nd Dr. Christopher A. Beeley, 2 Reader Dr. William Willimon,D.Min.Director An abstract of a thesis in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Ministry in the Divinity School of Duke University 2020 Copyright by J. Shane Comellas 2020 Abstract This thesis examines the ineffectiveness of the 21st century Church's work among the poor and reimagines this engagement through the lens of sermons given by Clement of Alexandria, Gregory Nazianzen, and John Chrysostom. The Church is the most charitable entity on the planet, however, despite giving away hundreds of billions of dollars a year and investing considerable time and effort towards the work of social justice, circumstances for the poor remain largely unchanged. The patristic period in question represents a vital conversation partner because their ministry to the poor catalyzed a movement that yielded exponential growth within their churches and made them significant players in the socio-political landscape in the Greco- Roman world. This study engages three sermons delivered by these pastors as a means of garnering a more granular feel for the common life within the Church. This thesis considers explicitly their use of the gospel as the modus operandi for ecclesial and social change and how reimagining our witness though this lens can be a catalyst for renewal. Table of Contents Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... i Table of Contents ............................................................................................................................ ii Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................................ iv List of Abbreviations .......................................................................................................................v Introduction: Rethinking the Church’s Witness in a Time Where Good Works Have Supplanted the Gospel ........................................................................................................................................1 Chapter One: The Necessity of the Gospel for Societal Reform ....................................................6 Forms of Poverty..................................................................................................................6 Modern Efforts to Address Poverty .....................................................................................7 The Promulgation of the Gospel in Tandem with Works ..................................................15 Patristic Pastors’ Sermons on Addressing Poverty: Clement, Nazianzus and Chrysostom ........................................................................................................................................................18 Clement of Alexandria: “Who is the Rich Man that is Being Saved” ..............................20 John Chrysostom: “Four Discourses on the Parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus” .......21 Gregory Nazianzen: “Oration 14” ....................................................................................23 Chapter Two: The Gospel as the Modus Operandi For Serving the Poor .....................................25 Identifying the Greatest Need Between Wealth and Poverty: ..........................................27 Clement of Alexandria: Wealth as a Tool .............................................................27 John Chrysostom: Poverty Leads to Faith .............................................................30 Gregory Nazianzus: All of Humanity is Poor without Christ ................................35 The Theological and Social Aspects of the Gospel: .........................................................38 Gregory Nazianzen: Kenosis as Witness ..............................................................38 Clement of Alexandria: Soteriological Justice ......................................................40 John Chrysostom: Ecclesiology and New Creation ..............................................43 Chapter Three: Spiritual Formation and the Poor ......................................................................... 48 Pastoral Call to Action: .....................................................................................................49 Clement of Alexandria: The Poor as Trainers in Virtue .......................................49 John Chrysostom: The Poor as the Context for Spiritual Formation .....................55 Gregory Nazianzen: The Hypostatic Nature of Christ Embodied in the Church ..59 Chapter Four: Eschatology and a Vision for Societal Renewal ....................................................65 Teleological Frameworks Towards Transformative Justice: ............................................67 Gregory Nazianzen: Eschatology- Love and Kinship in Cruciform Towards Gods In-Breaking ............................................................................................................67 Clement of Alexandria: Eschatology- Retribution, Works and Their Reward in the Hereafter ...............................................................................................................70 John Chrysostom: Eschatology- Redemptive Suffering, Purgation and a Bridge Called Justice ........................................................................................................73 Chapter Five: The Gospel for the Poor and its Prospect for Ecclesial Renewal ............................77 Patristic Vision for Societal Transformation .....................................................................77 Spiritual Formation as Mission ..........................................................................................79 A Paradigm for Discipleship ..............................................................................................84 Conclusion: Lovers of the Poor .....................................................................................................90 Postscript: Covid-19 and the New Poor .........................................................................................94 Bibliography .................................................................................................................................96 Acknowledgments This project has been a collective effort by so many who have made contributions of love, time, wisdom, and mercy towards the completion of this work. I want to thank God for tirelessly believing in me and calling me to my best. Next, I would like to thank my wife Jaimee and our four daughters Jaelyn, Avery, Olivia, and Adeline, without whose love and support I would have never been able to engage in this study. Jaimee, you read all of my work and have been a constant source of love and support, you are such a treasure and my hero! Thank you, Duke Divinity School, for sharing the gift of your amazing faculty through two different programs and especially the Rev. Dr. J. Warren Smith, the past Director of the DMIN program, and my current academic advisor. You are a gift to this university, a wonderful scholar, faithful witness of the gospel, and a trusted confidant. I also want to acknowledge Dr. Christopher Beeley for reading and helping to edit this work. I want to thank the 2016 DMIN cohort who helped me to reimagine the work of my ministry through each of the gifts that you brought to the program. Also, I would like to pass along sincere gratitude to the people of Covenant Life Church who have been the guinea pigs for every new idea I have wanted to try out on you and a constants source of prayer and support. Thank you, mom, for your prayers and the legacy of faith that you have passed along to your children. We miss you! A special thanks to my family and friends, especially my brothers Jerry and Chris, and my great friends and writing partners Russ Lackey and Craig Giera. Thank you all, your influence has colored my work with grace, and I am ever grateful for your investment in my life. iv List of Abbreviations NRSV New Revised Standard Version v Introduction: Rethinking the Church’s Witness in a Time Where Good Works Have Supplanted the Gospel Christ’s stated mission, as it pertains to the poor, was to care for them through the proclamation of the gospel and by addressing their physical needs. Luke records this in a scene where Jesus unrolls the scroll in the synagogue and reads: “The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim freedom for the prisoners and recovery of sight for the blind, to set the oppressed free, to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor.” (Luke 4:18-19). The messianic in-breaking prophesied first by Isaiah and embodied in Christ would catalyze a movement