DOCSLIB.ORG

William John Vittery Final Phd Thesis.Pdf

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
William John Vittery Final Phd Thesis.Pdf Crisis and Stability: The Global Financial Crisis, British Broadsheet Press and the Politics of Ideational Reversion William John Vittery Doctor of Philosophy University of York Politics December 2015 Abstract By analysing UK media narrations surrounding the global financial crisis, this thesis presents a critical engagement with existing constructivist institutionalist literature. Through the application of a ‘dynamic tracing’ methodology to British broadsheet newspaper discourse from 2007-10, the thesis reveals three significant, and interconnected, dynamics. Firstly, it highlights the existence of ‘ideational reversion’, whereby after a short period of flux through late-2008 and early-2009, prominent discourses by and large returned to the pre-crisis status quo ante. By analysing the pre- crisis, crisis, and post-crisis discourse holistically, a notably higher degree of overall ideational stability is found than the existing literature suggests would be the case. Secondly, it is demonstrated that ideational disjuncture within media commentary was effectively ‘siloed’ in the financial sector, meaning that the perception of crisis did not challenge broader conceptualisations of the neo-liberal economy. Thirdly, the impact of such reversion and siloing was to provide a greater social source of legitimacy, or strategic advantage, to orthodox austerity narratives than to their Keynesian alternative. On the back of these observations, conceptual extensions are put forward that involve developing a greater focus on the ‘stickiness’ of pre-existing discourse through crisis periods. 2 Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................................................................................ 2 Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................................................... 3 Acknowledgements ..................................................................................................................................................... 6 Author’s declaration .................................................................................................................................................... 8 Chapter 1: Introduction to the Thesis .................................................................................................................. 9 Chapter 2. Constructivism, the British Broadsheet Press, and the Global Financial Crisis: An Overview ....................................................................................................................................................................... 13 2.1 Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 13 2.2 Constructivism and the Ontological Middle Ground ...................................................................... 14 2.3 Structure versus Agency for Constructivists ..................................................................................... 20 2.4 Strategically Selective Contexts, Strategic Actors, and the Financial Crisis .......................... 22 2.5 Crisis and Strategic-Relational Action .................................................................................................. 23 2.6 The ‘Realist Constructivist’ Agenda and crisis analysis................................................................. 26 2.7 The Relevance of Constructivism to Crisis ......................................................................................... 28 2.8 Conclusions ...................................................................................................................................................... 29 Chapter 3. Constructivism, the British Broadsheet Press, and the Global Financial Crisis: The Extensions .................................................................................................................................................................... 30 3.1 Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 30 3.2 Setting the Scene: Constructivism and the New Institutional Turn ......................................... 31 3.3 Institutionalist Studies of Crisis .............................................................................................................. 34 3.4 The Constructivist Institutionalist Alternative: Prospects and Weaknesses ....................... 36 3.5 Constructivist Responses to the Global Financial Crisis ............................................................... 42 3.6 When is a crisis not a crisis? ..................................................................................................................... 44 3.7 Discursive Institutionalism and Media Narration ........................................................................... 46 3.8 Methodology .................................................................................................................................................... 48 3.9 Conclusions ...................................................................................................................................................... 53 Chapter 4: Contextualising the Global Financial Crisis .............................................................................. 55 4.1 Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 55 4.2 Introducing the Keynesian and Orthodox Paradigms .................................................................... 56 4.3 The Great Moderation and the Events of the Financial Crisis .................................................... 60 4.31 The Leverage Economy ............................................................................................................................ 61 3 4.32 Current Account Imbalances ................................................................................................................. 62 4.33 Monetary Consensus ................................................................................................................................. 63 4.4 The Onset of Crisis and its Political Response .................................................................................. 64 4.5 The Economic Logic of Stimulus in the Current Context .............................................................. 66 4.6 The Economic Case for Austerity in the Current Context............................................................. 69 4.7 Ideal Types and Their Political Usage .................................................................................................. 71 4.71 The Role of Uncertainty ........................................................................................................................... 72 4.72 Stimulating Growth ................................................................................................................................... 73 4.73 Economic Priorities ................................................................................................................................... 74 4.74 A Case of Contestability ........................................................................................................................... 74 4.8 Conclusions...................................................................................................................................................... 75 Chapter 5: Charting the Pre-Crisis Economic Discourse ........................................................................... 76 5.1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................... 76 5.2 The Size and Role of the State .................................................................................................................. 77 5.3 Fiscal Responsibility and State Capacity ............................................................................................. 81 5.4 Drivers of Economic Growth .................................................................................................................... 87 5.5 The Tax Regime ............................................................................................................................................. 89 5.6 Conclusions...................................................................................................................................................... 91 Chapter 6: Political Economic Discourses of the Crisis Period: August 2008 – January 2009 .. 94 6.1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................... 94 6.2 A crisis of capitalism or a crisis of finance? ........................................................................................ 96 6.3 Corporate Capitalism in Crisis? ............................................................................................................... 99 6.4 ‘No room for manoeuvre’ and orthodoxy v stimulus ................................................................... 100 6.5 Medium term decisions ...........................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Money in the Great Recession BUCKINGHAM STUDIES in MONEY, BANKING and CENTRAL BA.NKING
    Money in the Great Recession BUCKINGHAM STUDIES IN MONEY, BANKING AND CENTRAL BA.NKING Seri Editor: Tim Congdon CBE, Chairman, Ins1itute of [nternalional Jlonewry R.:search and Professo1~ University of Buckingham, Uniled Kingdom The Institute of International Monetary Research promotes research into how Money in the Great dc:\'elopments in banking and finance affect the wider economy. Particular attention is paid to the effect of changes in the quantity of money, on inflation and detlation, and on boom and bust. The Institute's wider aims are to enhance economic kno\\'ledge and understanding, and to seek price stability, steady Recession economic growth and high employment. The Institute is located at the University of Buckingham and helps with the university's educational role. Buckingham Studies in Money, Banking and Central Banking presents some Did a Crash in Money Growth Cause the of the Instilllte·s most important work. Contributions from scholars at other Global Slun1p? universities and research bodies. and practi tioners in finance and banking. are also welcome. for more on the Institute. see the \\·ebsit.: at www.m\·-pr.org, Edited by Tim Congdon CBE Chairman, Institute of Internatio11al 1V oneta1y R esearch and Profess01; University of Buckingham, United Kingdom BUCKINGHAM STUDIES IN MONEY, BANKING AND CENTRAL BANKING IN ASSOCIATION WITH THE INSTITUTE OF ECONOMIC AFFAIRS ~Edward Elgar ~ PUBL I SH I NG Cheltenham, UK• Northampton, MA, USA ';;' Tim Congdon 2017 Contents :-\II rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored 1n a retrieval S~ ' Stem or transmitted in anv form orb\' an\' means electronic mechanical o: photoco_pying, recording.
    [Show full text]
  • Nine Crises Fifty Years of Covering the British Economy from Devaluation to Brexit William Keegan
    Nine Crises Fifty Years of Covering the British Economy from Devaluation to Brexit William Keegan London: Biteback Publishing, 2019, £20.00 (h/b) Bartholomew Steer Nine Crises is an attempt to encapsulate the UK’s economic crises of the last 50 years, and the way they were managed by the leading lights of the day, as they were reported in William Keegan’s newspaper columns over the period. Keegan was not to know that as soon as 2019 was out, the biggest economic crisis since WW2 would take place, with some suggesting it is likely to be the biggest for 100 years.1 That said, it lends a certain perspective to the events of the last 50 years and a new twist to the ‘Crisis, what crisis?’ comment (which was falsely attributed to ‘Sunny Jim’ Callaghan, Prime Minister in the late seventies). It turns out that, judged by the events of 2020, all previous crises were mere blips in times of steady economic growth and prosperity for the majority. It appears that far from being the Beast holding the UK back, the state is vital to propping-up not only the banks, as in 2008/9, but the entire shooting match. For all the denial of the role of modern monetary theory (MMT), as described by Stephanie Kelton in her book,2 when push came to shove MMT is the only thing preventing an even bigger crisis. William Keegan will need no introduction to readers of the Observer, where he has been a permanent fixture as a financial journalist commentating on economic affairs through five decades.
    [Show full text]
  • Fed Falters Yellen’S Wavering
    October 2015 The Bulletin Vol. 6 Ed. 9 Official monetary and financial institutions▪ Asset management ▪ Global money and credit Fed falters Yellen’s wavering Meghnad Desai on US interest rate nerves Mojmir Hampl on why Europe needs Britain Kingsley Chiedu Moghalu on Buhari’s challenges Rakesh Mohan on US and Brics IMF roles David Owen on restructuring Europe David Smith on Pope Francis’ economic voice Global Louis de Montpellier [email protected] +44 20 3395 6189 ConneCt Into aPaC Hon Cheung [email protected] +65 6826 7505 amerICas Carl Riedy the network [email protected] +1 202 429 8427 Connect into State Street Global Advisors’ network of expertise, tailored training and investment excellence. emea Benefit from our Official Institutions Group’s decades-deep experience. Our service Kristina Sowah [email protected] is honed to the specific needs of sovereign clients such as central banks, sovereign +44 20 3395 6842 wealth funds, government agencies and supranational institutions. From Passive to Active, Alternatives to the latest Advanced Beta strategies, the Official Institutions Group can provide the customised client solutions you need. To learn more about how we can help you, please visit our website ssga.com/oig or contact your local representative. FOR INSTITUTIONAL USE ONLY, Not for Use with the Public. Investing involves risk including the risk of loss of principal. State Street Global Advisors is the investment management business of State Street Corporation (NYSE: STT), one of the world’s leading providers of financial services to institutional investors. © 2015 State Street Corporation – All rights reserved. INST-5417. Exp. 31.03.2016.
    [Show full text]
  • UCLA Electronic Theses and Dissertations
    UCLA UCLA Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title Party Leadership Selection in Parliamentary Democracies Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/8fs1h45n Author So, Florence Publication Date 2012 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California University of California Los Angeles Party Leadership Selection in Parliamentary Democracies Adissertationsubmittedinpartialsatisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science by Florence Grace Hoi Yin So 2012 c Copyright by Florence Grace Hoi Yin So 2012 Abstract of the Dissertation Party Leadership Selection in Parliamentary Democracies by Florence Grace Hoi Yin So Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science University of California, Los Angeles, 2012 Professor Kathleen Bawn, Chair My doctoral dissertation begins with this puzzle: why do large, moderate parties sometimes select leaders who seem to help improve their parties’ electoral performances, but other times choose unpopular leaders with more extreme policy positions, in expense of votes? I argue that leadership selection is dependent on both the electoral institution that a party finds itself in and the intra-party dynamics that constrain the party. Due to a high degree of seat- vote elasticity that is characteristic of majoritarian systems, replacing unpopular leaders is a feasible strategy for opposition parties in these systems to increase their seat shares. In contrast, in proportional systems, due to low seat-vote elasticity, on average opposition parties that replace their leaders su↵er from vote loss. My model of party leadership selection shows that since party members can provide valuable election campaign e↵ort, they can coerce those who select the party leader (the selectorate) into choosing their preferred leader.
    [Show full text]
  • X Marks the Box: How to Make Politics Work for You by Daniel Blythe
    Thank you for downloading the free ebook edition of X Marks the Box: How to Make Politics Work for You by Daniel Blythe. This edition is complete and unabridged. Please feel free to pass it on to anyone else you think would be interested. Follow Daniel on his blog at www.xmarksthebox.co.uk. The book is all about debate, of course – so get involved and tell Daniel and the world what you think there! The printed edition of X Marks the Box (ISBN 9781848310513), priced £7.99, is published on Thursday 4 March by Icon Books and will be available in all good bookstores – online and otherwise. And don’t forget to vote! www.xmarksthebox.co.uk I C O N B O O K S Published in the UK in 2010 by Icon Books Ltd, Omnibus Business Centre, 39–41 North Road, London N7 9DP email: [email protected] www.iconbooks.co.uk This electronic edition published in 2010 by Icon Books ISBN: 978-1-84831-180-0 (ePub format) ISBN: 978-1-84831-191-6 (Adobe ebook format) Printed edition (ISBN: 978-1-84831-051-3) sold in the UK, Europe, South Africa and Asia by Faber & Faber Ltd, Bloomsbury House, 74–77 Great Russell Street, London WC1B 3DA or their agents Printed edition distributed in the UK, Europe, South Africa and Asia by TBS Ltd, TBS Distribution Centre, Colchester Road, Frating Green, Colchester CO7 7DW Printed edition published in Australia in 2010 by Allen & Unwin Pty Ltd, PO Box 8500, 83 Alexander Street, Crows Nest, NSW 2065 Printed edition distributed in Canada by Penguin Books Canada, 90 Eglinton Avenue East, Suite 700, Toronto, Ontario M4P 2YE Text copyright © 2010 Daniel Blythe The author has asserted his moral rights.
    [Show full text]
  • The Political in Political Economy: Historicising the Great Crisis of Spanish Residential Capitalism
    A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick Permanent WRAP URL: http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/129362 Copyright and reuse: This thesis is made available online and is protected by original copyright. Please scroll down to view the document itself. Please refer to the repository record for this item for information to help you to cite it. Our policy information is available from the repository home page. For more information, please contact the WRAP Team at: [email protected] warwick.ac.uk/lib-publications The Political in Political Economy: Historicising the Great Crisis of Spanish Residential Capitalism By Javier Moreno Zacarés A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Politics and International Studies University of Warwick Department of Politics and International Studies September 2018 Table of Contents List of Illustrations ........................................................................................................ v Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................... vi Abstract ....................................................................................................................... vii Abbreviations ............................................................................................................. viii INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................... 1 0.1. THE CASE: WHY IT MATTERS ...............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Financial Crisis, 3Rd Ed
    Financial crisis 3rd edition October-December 2016, issue 41 CENTRE FOR CULTURE RESEARCH AND DOCUMENTATION BANK OF GREECE EUROSYSTEM Library of the Bank of Greece Table of Contents Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 1 I. Print collection of the Library ................................................................................................ 2 I.1 Monographs .................................................................................................................................. 2 IΙ.Electronic collection of the Library ....................................................................................... 55 II.1 Full text articles .......................................................................................................................... 55 IΙ.2 Electronic books ......................................................................................................................... 61 ΙΙΙ. Resources from the World Wide Web ................................................................................ 64 ΙV. List of topics published in previous issues of the Bibliography ............................................ 70 All issues are available at the internet: http://www.bankofgreece.gr/Pages/el/Bank/Library/news.aspx Bank of Greece / Centre for Culture, Research and Documentation / Library Section / 21 El. Venizelos Ave., 102 50 Athens / tel. 210 3202446, 3203129/ email [email protected] Bibliography:
    [Show full text]
  • What's in a Name?
    EDITORIAL Vol.3 No.8 August 2007 www.nature.com/naturephysics What’s in a name? Britain has a new leader, and with him a new science minister in a new department: would you guess that the ‘Department of Innovation, Universities and Skills’ now holds the remit for science? On 28 June, Gordon Brown replaced development assistance’. Frustratingly, Tony Blair as UK Prime Minister. In the all budgetary increases in the game are days that followed, a wholesale reshuffle capped at 100% — but then that would of the Cabinet was announced, as be too much to expect, even in the most Prime Minister Brown set his mark on a optimistic of times. new ‘New Labour’ government. Change At the top of the list detailing the role3 is in the air across the administration, as of the new DIUS is “sustain and develop a Blairism makes way for Brownism. world-class research base”. That, of course, Change has also been decreed in the requires investment, and it is to be hoped governmental handling of science research. that the outcome of the Comprehensive Ian Pearson is the new Science Minister, Spending Review will set the UK on that under Secretary of State John Denham, course. At the bottom of the list is “increase who heads the newly created Department the supply of people in science, technology, of Innovation, Universities and Skills engineering and mathematics”. And there (DIUS). The DIUS comprises chunks of the declining profile of science in the UK what was the Department of Education hits home. and what was the Department of Trade A growing number of pupils in and Industry (DTI).
    [Show full text]
  • Year of the Multicurrency System’
    January 2016 The BulletinVol. 7 Ed. 1 Official monetary and financial institutions▪ Asset management ▪ Global money and credit Going their own way Multicurrency journeys Nick Butler on stranded assets Otmar Issing on euro impasse Kingsley Moghalu on central banks John Mourmouras on Europe’s future Athanasios Orphanides on Greece's non-rescue You don’t thrive for 230 years by standing still. As one of the oldest, continuously operating fi nancial institutions in the world, BNY Mellon has endured and prospered through every economic turn and market move since our founding over 230 years ago. Today, BNY Mellon remains strong and innovative, providing investment management and investment services that help our clients to invest, conduct business and transact with assurance in markets all over the world. bnymellon.com © 2015 The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation. All rights reserved. BNY Mellon is the corporate brand for The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation. The Bank of New York Mellon is supervised and regulated by the New York State Department of Financial Services and the Federal Reserve and authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority. The Bank of New York Mellon London branch is subject to regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority and limited regulation by the Prudential Regulation Authority. Details about the extent of our regulation by the Prudential Regulation Authority are available from us on request. Products and services referred to herein are provided by The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation and its subsidiaries. Content is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide authoritative fi nancial, legal, regulatory or other professional advice.
    [Show full text]
  • Making a Modern Central Bank
    CONSEQUENCES OF SUCCESS AND FAILURE: MAKING A MODERN CENTRAL BANK Bank of England book launch Virtual 23 November 2020 Bank of England book launch OVERVIEW A series of upheavals at the Bank of England in 1987-2003 provided the background to a monetary and economic revolution that reverberates still through global finance today. Harold James’ Making a Modern Central Bank – The Bank of England 1979-2003 examines the most turbulent period of change at the Old Lady of Threadneedle Street since its early years helping finance war with France after its foundation in 1694. The launch brings together leading figures from the UK and abroad to discuss past successes and failures which have shaped the Bank’s make-up. The session starts with a balance sheet of the Bank of England’s overall transformation, going on to discuss the impact on UK and international banking and finance. It ends by looking at the lasting legacies of changing regimes for monetary policy and banking supervision. MEETING AT A GLANCE GMT 15:00 - 15:05 Welcome address 15:05 - 15:15 Keynote address: Harold James, Professor of History, Princeton University 15:15 - 16:10 Session I: Consequences of success and failure: the making of a modern central bank 16:10 - 17:05 Session II: Development of banking and financial markets: the growth of financial globalisation 17:05 - 18:00 Session III: Balancing responsibilities: Banking supervision, monetary policy and the trials of independence 18:00 Closing remarks 2|Consequences of success and failure: Making a modern central bank MEETING PROGRAMME
    [Show full text]
  • Catch-Up and Constraints in the Twentieth and Twenty-First Centuries
    OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 29/5/2019, SPi 2 Catch-up and Constraints in the Twentieth and Twenty-first Centuries Robert H. Wade 2.1 Introduction The old-style development economists—including Gerschenkron, Prebisch, Lewis, Myrdal, Chenery, Hirschman, Adelman, Seers, and many more—would surely be disappointed by the record of global economic development in the past half century, at least when looking at the slowness of catch-up as distinct from the dramatic falls in global poverty even while population increased at the fastest rate in human history. Gerschenkron’s ‘late development effect’,or‘the advan- tages of backwardness’, seems noticeable more by its absence than its presence, despite new technology being widely available to people around the world and despite no shortage of people with entrepreneurial talent. But perhaps they would not be surprised. At the core of their understanding of the process of catch-up development were the following propositions: (1) Development is a disruptive process of non-marginal changes over time, opposed by many in the society, generating inevitable conflict, and placing a premium on fragile conflict-resolution institutions—a premium which calls for not exposing the economy to unmediated international competi- tive pressures. (2) The price system in a developing country cannot play the role accorded it in developed countries as the major allocator of resources, because markets are too undeveloped and because relying on markets would tend to sustain the existing production specialization based on static comparative advantage with decreasing returns to scale—a point which also implies the desirability of less than full-scale integration into the international economy.
    [Show full text]
  • A New Form of Progressive Politics
    BUILDING THE GOOD SOCIETY A NEW FORM OF PROGRESSIVE POLITICS Robin Wilson and Jon Bloomfield BUILDING THE GOOD SOCIETY A NEW FORM OF PROGRESSIVE POLITICS Robin Wilson and Jon Bloomfield 1 | www.compassonline.org.uk About the authors Robin Wilson is a former magazine editor and think tank director and currently independent researcher based in Belfast. He has been involved in the debate in the UK and the wider Europe on the ‘good society’ since the outset. Jon Bloomfield has worked in the public sector in the West Midlands for over 25 years. He is currently an honorary research fellow at Birmingham University specializing in European issues. Published by Compass − Direction for the Democratic Left Ltd Southbank House, Black Prince Road, London SE1 7SJ t: +44 (0) 207 463 0632 e: [email protected] www.compassonline.org.uk Designed by soapbox, www.soapbox.co.uk Contents Foreword, by Neal Lawson 5 1 Preface 6 2 Introduction: cohering the narrative 7 2.1 Philosophy matters: framing public debate 7 2.2 Addressing public opinion: ‘common’ and ‘good’ sense 8 2.3 Thatcherism’s success: the ‘property-owning democracy’ 8 2.4 The ‘good society’ as the progressive alternative 9 3 The ‘third way’ 10 3.1 The triumph of neo-liberalism 10 3.2 Globalisation, capital and labour 10 3.3 ‘Market fundamentalism’ and precariousness 11 3.4 ‘Free’ market, authoritarian state 11 3.5 Populism versus the public sphere 11 3.6 The US embrace 12 3.7 The collapse of the progressive constituency 12 4 Liberalism and socialism 13 4.1 The individualistic concept of
    [Show full text]