1 Month of October in the City of Samarra by Themselves. They 2 Had the Most Contacts of Any Platoon in the Entire Battalion 3 and They Suffered No Casualties
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 month of October in the city of Samarra by themselves. They 2 had the most contacts of any platoon in the entire battalion 3 and they suffered no casualties. There is no other platoon in 4 the battalion that can say that. He set up the first police 5 station in Balad and trained and monitored the Iraqis. 6 7 Balad was the geopolitical center of that region. It was 8 very unstable at the time and one of the hottest spots in Iraq. 9 Within a month we owned the city and built great relationships. 10 Subsequently, we spent a lot of money improving the 11 infrastructure. The periphery was mostly Sunni. Trying to 12 bring them into the government was difficult, but once we 13 controlled Balad and the city outlines, we controlled the 14 entire region. 15 16 Lieutenant Saville's platoon were the key to the success for 17 Alpha Company. He was put in for two bronze stars. His 18 rehabilitative potential is very high. He's very mature. He's 19 a faith-filled man, outstanding leader, outstanding officer and 20 he's earned the faith of his men. He's combat tested and he's 21 a man of integrity. I would take him anywhere, anytime. I'd 22 go to combat with him, I'.d stand by his side and I'd put my son 23 in his outfit if we were going back to war without thought. 24 25 CROSS-EXAMINATION 26 27 Questions by the trial counsel-Captain Schiffer: 28 29 The platoons were very autonomous because of the lack of 30 leadership in 1-66 Armor. The fight in Iraq is at the company 31 and platoon level. Squad leaders, platoon sergeants and 32 platoon leaders make the decisions on a daily basis that equal 33 success, the death of insurgents or the death of their 34 soldiers. 35 36 I am aware of what the accused had pled guilty to. This 37 incident has exposed the unit to a negative information 38 operations campaign by the enemy, a very effective one. It can 39 sometimes place soldiers at risk. If not dealt with, this can 40 affect the unit mission and our forward progress of Iraq on a 41 political level. 42 43 [END OF PAGE] 44 45 23 10008 1 REDIRECT EXAMINATION 2 3 Questions by the defense counsel-Captain Drake: 4 5 The charges Lieutenant Saville has been found guilty of does 6 not change my opinion about his leadership or any of the 7 observations or opinions I've stated today. I think the charges 8 are absurd. What you have is a hero who is revered by his 9 soldiers and his leadership. I've seen what he's done and what 10 his capabilities are. Instead of pinning medals on him, we're 11 making him sit in this courtroom. I think it's a travesty to the 12 Army and to our officer corps to allow this to happen. 13 14 The witness was permanently excused and remained in the 15 courtroom. 16 17 Sergeant First Class Carl Ironeyes 18 19 SERGEANT FIRST CLASS CARL IRONEYES, U.S. Army, was called as a 20 witness for the defense, was sworn, and testified in substance 21 as follows: 22 23 DIRECT EXAMINATION 24 25 Questions by the assistant trial counsel-Captain Shaw: 26 27 I'm Sergeant First Class Carl Ironeyes. I'm currently 28 stationed at Fort Carson, Colorado, with 1-68 Infantry. 29 30 Questions by the defense counsel-Captain Drake: 31 32 I've known Lieutenant Saville for over a year and half now. 33 He was my platoon leader. The op-tempo was high and very 34 dangerous. We would get mortar attacks in the morning. We 35 would start our day doing whatever PT we could and then we 36 basically did patrols. We enforced no weapons, no illegal 37 activity and keeping the peace. We detained Iraqis and 38 controlled insurgencies. We received hostile fire and returned 39 fire. 40 41 I've been in the Army for 17 years. I've been through a lot 42 of platoon leaders and you couldn't ask for anyone better than 43 Lieutenant Saville. I have no complaints. He treated everyone 44 very well. 24 10009 1 CROSS-EXAMINATION 2 3 Questions by the assistant trial counsel-Captain Shaw: 4 5 Keeping the peace was a very important part of our mission. 6 I was not aware I was in Iraq to win the hearts and minds of 7 the people. There were active insurgents who were to be 8 engaged or detained and there were Iraqis who were to be 9 safeguarded. 10 11 Lieutenant Saville is a good leader. It is important for 12 leaders to possess certain qualities like integrity. I wasn't 13 aware that he was found guilty of obstructing justice 14 yesterday. I find it hard to believe that he furnished a false 15 statement in order to not be prosecuted for certain acts. A 16 platoon leader should ensure his soldiers do the right thing 17 and counsel and advise them to do the right thing in not 18 violating the laws of war. From what I know of the situation, 19 what he did comports with being a good leader. I believe his 20 advising soldiers to throw non-hostile Iraqis into the water 21 comports with him being a good leader. 22 23 REDIRECT EXAMINATION 24 25 Questions by the defense counsel-Captain Drake: 26 27 Lieutenant Saville never did anything to compromise my 28 opinion of his integrity, leadership or care for his soldiers. 29 30 The witness was permanently excused and remained in the 31 courtroom. 32 33 Major Gavin Gardner 34 35 MAJOR GAVIN GARDNER, U.S. Army, was called as a witness for the 36 defense, was sworn, and testified in substance as follows: 37 38 DIRECT EXAMINATION 39 40 Questions by the assistant trial counsel-Captain Shaw: 41 42 I'm Major Gavin Gardner. I'm currently the S-4 of 3d 43 Brigade Combat Team, Fort Carson, Colorado. 44 25 10010 1 Questions by the defense counsel-Captain Drake: 2 3 Jack has worked for me since July of 2004. This is after he 4 returned from Iraq. I observed him on a daily basis. He has 5 shown up everyday and provided 100 percent of the work. He 6 could have easily not done any work, with this case pending 7 against him and I would have understood that, but that hasn't 8 been the case. He's provided more effort and does more work 9 than some of the branch-qualified captains that have been to 10 the advanced course in my office. I put that in his 11 evaluations. Of the 14 officers that have worked for me thus 12 far as the Brigade S-4, I put him at number four in effort. 13 What he might not know in technical knowledge of the S-4 arena, 14 he makes up for with effort and he tries to learn. 15 16 Because of this case, I told him I didn't want to give him 17 any long-term projects. He and Sergeant First Class Perkins 18 developed and monitored projects from companies we have 19 contracts with. He developed the brigade standard SOP, which 20 is also the division standard SOP for these products. He 21 accounts for these products and issues them to the units. He 22 also developed the brigade's paint program. Jack corresponds 23 with the NCOIC down at DOL and makes that mission happen. We 24 are ahead of schedule for the brigade and that's all due to 25 Jack's hard work. 26 27 Lieutenant Saville has very high rehabilitative potential. 28 I can't think of a person with more potential. Whether he 29 decides to make the Army a career or gets out and goes into the 30 civilian world, he's going to go very far. If I go back to 31 combat, I'd like to take him with me. If we were on the 32 outside and I was working for a civilian firm, I want him 33 working with me. None of the offenses that he's been found 34 guilty of changes my opinion of him. I've always believed in 35 him. I've told him to learn from his mistakes and move on out. 36 37 The witness was permanently excused and remained in the 38 courtroom. 39 40 Lieutenant Colonel Nathan Sassaman 41 42 [END OF PAGE] 43 44 45 26 10011 1 LIEUTENANT COLONEL NATHAN SASSAMAN, U.S. Army, was called as a 2 witness for the defense, was sworn, and testified in substance 3 as follows: 4 5 DIRECT EXAMINATION 6 7 Questions by the trial counsel-Captain Schiffer: 8 9 I'm Lieutenant Colonel Nathan Sassaman, HHC 1-8 Infantry. 10 11 Questions by the civilian defense counsel-Mr. Spinner: 12 13 I began my career as a platoon leader in the 7th Infantry 14 Division at Fort Ord, California. I deployed to Honduras and 15 Panama with the 7th Infantry Division. From there, I commanded 16 a company in Fort Lewis, Washington and went on several 17 training center rotations. From there I got a Master's Degree 18 from the University of Washington. I was an admissions officer 19 at the U.S. Military Academy.