An Index to

So Painful a Scandal: A Facsimile of the Original Manuscript of “The Adventure of the Three Students” by with Annotations and Commentary

Edited by John Bergquist, BSI

Index Prepared for the BSI by Adrian Nebbett

From the edition by The Baker Street Irregulars in association with Houghton Library of the Harvard College Library (2009)

5 February 2011

www.bakerstreetjournal.com

So Painful a Scandal is part of The Baker Street Irregulars Manuscript Series. Books from that series, along with volumes from the International Series and the History Series, are available from The Baker Street Journal website at . An Index to So Painful a Scandal

So Painful a Scandal Table of Contents

General Editor’s Preface to the Series by Andrew G. Fusco, BSI (pp. vii-xii)

Introduction by John Bergquist, BSI (pp. 1-5)

Notes on the Manuscript by Phillip Bergem (pp. 7-13)

Manuscript Facsimile of “The Adventure of the Three Students” with Annotated Transcription

Following “The Three Students”: A Manuscript History by Randall Stock, BSI (pp. 71-84)

Touring with “The Three Students” by Michael Eckman (pp. 85-88)

Three Students, Seventeen Problems by Nicholas Utechin, BSI (pp. 89-96)

“The Three Students” at Cambridge by Guy Marriott, BSI (pp. 97-110)

Oxbridge Camouflaged or Camford Obscured: Some Subfuscations of the Doylean Redactor by Oliver Nicholson (pp. 111-120)

Frederic Dorr Steele, and “The Three Students” by Andrew Malec, BSI (pp. 121-129)

Conventions Used in this Index:

Page numbers in italics refer to illustrations or photographs.

Page numbers in bold refer to an entire article or section of the book.

‘n’ refers to a footnote or an endnote.

Material within the story “The Three Students” is not indexed.

Names of books, stories, and articles are all shown in italic.

Dates indexed are only those relevant to the chronology of the story / publication or main topic of an article, and appear at the end of this Index.

www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 2 of 10 An Index to So Painful a Scandal

Abbey Grange, The, 72, 76, 78, 91, 92 Black Peter, 91 Abbot, Evelyn, Blackbeard, Bill, History of Greece, 116n. Sherlock Holmes in America, 122-123, 128n. Aberdeen, University of, 97 Blakeney, T.S., vii, 3 Absolute and Abitofhell (Ronald Knox), 119n. Sherlock Holmes: Fact or Fiction?, 99 Accardo, Peter, 83 Blau, Peter E., 78 Adventure of the Unique Hamlet, The (Vincent Blue, Sporting, 66, 89, 115n. Starrett), 91 Blue Guide to Oxford & Cambridge, The, 85 Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, The, 121 Bond, W.H., 82-83 Agate, James, 90, 102 Boston, Massachusetts, 82, 83 Agra, 103 Brambletye, 89 American Art Association, 77 Brattle Book Shop, 82 Anderson Galleries, 77 Brazil, 104-105, 120 Angels of Darkness (Arthur Conan Doyle), xi Brend, Gavin, Annotations (on the manuscript), xii, 3, 62-70 My Dear Holmes, 97-98 Antiquarian Bookman, 82-83 Brett, Jeremy, viii Arts Students League, 121 Brideshead Revisited (Evelyn Waugh), 120 Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters (Jon Briggs, Gray Chandler, 126-127, 128n. Lellenberg, Daniel Stashower & Charles Foley, Bristowe, W.S., 102 eds.), 72n. Three Students in Limelight, Electric Light and At the Sign of the Ship (Andrew Lang), 3 Daylight, The, 89, 108n., 113-114n., 115n Athens, 103 Brookfield, Connecticut, 77 Auerbach, Bart, Brooklyn, 105, 121 Detective Story Through the Ages, 75n. Brown, Father, 120 Baker Street, 85-86, 100-101 Bruce, Nigel, 128 Baker Street Irregulars, vii-xi Cambridge, 2, 4, 91-92, 94, 97-108, 113 Annual Dinner, 2n. Milton Road, 103 Expeditions, xi Cambridge Town Cricket Club, 102 History Series, x, 128n. Cambridge University, 2n., 62, 95, 98-108, 112, 115-117, International Series, x 120 Manuscript Series, viii, x, xi, 1 Caius College, 113 Baker Street Journal, vii, x-xi, 2n., 81, 90, 97, 108n., Gate of Virtue, The, 113 122 Cambridge University Athletic Club, 90, 103 Christmas Annual, x-xi Cambridge University Cricket and Athletic Club, 102 Editor’s Gas-Lamp, The, vii (n.) Cambridge University Cricket Club, 102 My First Meeting With Sherlock Holmes, 122 Fenner’s, 102, 102-103 Baker Street Miscellanea, 128n. Jesus College, 112n. Ball, Katy, 127 King’s College, 93 Baltimore, 121 Magdalene College, 112n. Bannister, 93, 95, 113, 125 Pembroke College, 106 Baring-Gould, William S., viii, 89, 100 Peterhouse College, 97, 99-100, 106-108, 107, 108, Barzun, Jacques, , 102 112n., 113 Few Trifling Paragraphs, A, 90, 108n. Chapel, 107 Bavaria, 105 Gisborne Court, 107 King of, 104 Old Court, 106, 107 Bell, H.W., vii Queens’ College, 112n. Bengis, Nathan, 3 St. Catherine’s College, 100, 112n., 113 Bergem, Phillip, 131 St. Edmund’s College, 100 Annotations, xii, 3, 62-70 St. John’s College, 100, 112, 113 Notes on the Manuscript, 3, 7-11 Scholars of the Bishop of Ely, Saint Peter’s College, Bergquist, John, BSI, 131 100, 106 Introduction, xi, 1-5 Sidney Sussex College, 85, 86 Bernard of Clairvaux, St., 112n. Sporting Blues, 66 Biographical Dictionary of British Architects 1600- Cambridge University Press, 101 1840, 87 Camford, 62 Birlstone, 89 Card Scandals, 66 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 3 of 10 An Index to So Painful a Scandal

Carr, John Dickson, 91-92 Detective Story Through the Ages (Bart Auerbach), 75n. Catalogue of 221B Culture, A (Dr Julian Wolff), 101, Devonshire, Earl of, 115 109n. Dictionary of the University of Cambridge, A (Charles Catharine of Alexandria, St., 112n. Dickens), 98, 108n. Catullus, 116 Dickens, Charles, Century Magazine, The, 122 Dictionary of the University of Cambridge, A, 98, 108n. Chapel, 86, 98, 107, 114 Dobson, Zuleika, 120 Characters (Theophrastus), 116 Dogs, 98 Charles Augustus Milverton, 91 Doyle, Arthur Conan, 89 Charles LeGeyt Fortescue Scholarship, 63 America, Interest in, 81 Charley’s Aunt, 120 Angels of Darkness, xi Charters, Early English, 92, 100, 101 Archives, 72 Chesterton, G.K., xi Brigadier Gerard stories, 73 Chicago, 77 Death of, ix Chimpanzee, 117 Duet, A, 81 Christie’s, 76 Favourite Holmes Stories, 73 Cinq leçons sur la méthode hagiographique (H. Green Flag, The, 77 Delehaye), 116n. Handwriting, xi, 1, 7, 64 Clay, 89-90, 94, 102, 115 Horror of the Heights, The, 74 Coleridge, Samuel Taylor, 79, 81 Letters from, 72-75, 81 Kubla Khan, 79 Manuscripts, xi-xii, 1, 8, 62, 73, 75-78, 84 Rime of the Ancient Mariner, The, 79 see also: Priory School: (note) Collier’s Weekly, 7, 9-11, 62, 66, 71-72, 74, 92, 122- Parliamentary aspirations, 72 123 Payments for stories, 9, 91-92 Advertising in, 10-11 Punctuation, 2, 7-8, 62-70, 74 Fiction Number, 10 Regimental Scandal, A, 66 Household Number, 10, 62 Sesquicentennial, 83 National Weekly, The, 10 Voice of Science, The, 66 Colophon, 122 White Company, The, 77 Columbia University Law School, 78 Writing & editing method, xi, 1-2, 8, 64, 71-72, 74, 75 Columbus Recording Lock Company, 10, 11 Writing, Quality of, 90-95, 120 Connecticut, 77 Doyle, Innes, 91-92 Consumer Price Index, 84 Doyle, Mary Foley, 72-74 Cornford, F.M., Doyle, Steven T., Microcosmographica Academica: A Guide for the Murderland, xi Young Academic Politician, 118n. Dublin, 97 Court, 101, 113 Duet, A (Arthur Conan Doyle), 81 Craven Scholarships, 115-116, 117n. Durham University, 97 Creeping Man, The, 62, 99 Dying Detective, The, xi (n.) Cricket, 102, 113 Eckman, Michael, 131 Crispin, Edmund, 112-113 Touring with “The Three Students”, 2, 3-4, 62, 85-88 Cromwell, Oliver, 86 Edinburgh, 118 Crotty, Dr. John P., 126-127 Edinburgh, University of, 97, 118 Curtis School for Boys, 77 Edison, Thomas, 106 Cutler School, 78 Edison & Swan United Electric Light Company, 106 Daily Mail, The, 75 Electric Light, 105-106, 109n. Dancing Men, The, 72, 78, 91 Ellis, Robinson, 116 Daulat Rao: see Rao, Daulat Ely, Bishop of, 100 Daulat Ras: see Ras, Daulat Empire Theatre, New York, 123 Davies, Bernard, 89 Empty House, The, 9, 66, 71, 90 Davis, Elmer, vii Faber, A.W,. 104-105 Davis, Richard Harding, 123 Faber, Eberhard von, 105 In the Fog, 122 Faber, Johann, 65, 104-105 de Balsham, Hugh, 100 Faber, Kaspar, 104 Delehaye, H., Faber, Lothar von, 104-105 Cinq leçons sur la méthode hagiographique, 116n. www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 4 of 10 An Index to So Painful a Scandal

Faber-Castell, 104, 108n. Harper’s Art Department, 122 Faber-Castell, Count Anton Wolfgang von, 104 Harvard, 3, 71, 75, 78-83 Faber-Castell Topics, 108n. Harvard College Library, 80 Farrer, Austin, 117n., 119n. Harvard Crimson, 83 Farrer, Katherine, 117n., 119n. Harvard Law School, 83 Missing Link, The, 113, 117-118 Hats, Fellowship of American Bibliographic Societies, 1 Boater, 98 Fen, Gervase, 112-113 Deerstalker, 10, 11 Fenner, Francis, 102 Hawick, 72 Few Trifling Paragraphs, A (Jacques Barzun), 90, Heinrichs, Alfred E., 121 108n. History of Greece (Evelyn Abbot), 116n. Final Problem, The, 9 History of the Peloponnesian War, The (Thucydides), 93, Financial Times, The, 108n. 109n. Five Little Men (William Alexander Fraser), 10 Holmes, Alleyne, 114 Foley, Charles, Holmes, Sheerluck, 10 Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters (Jon Holmes, Sherlock, 2 Lellenberg & Daniel Stashower, eds.), 72n. Advertisements, Appearances in, 10-11, 11 Following “The Three Students”: A Manuscript Height, 69 History (Randall Stock, BSI), 3, 71-84 London, Early days in, 98 Fortescue, Charles, 63 Personality, 93, 100 Fortescue Scholarship, 63, 94, 103, 115 Relatives, 114 Foundations (B.H. Streeter), 119n. Studies in Early English Charters, 101 Fowler, W. Warde, 115-116 University, 2, 86, 89, 97-99, 101, 108 Fraser, Antonia, Homer, 116 Oxford Blood, 118n. Hopkins, Clare, Fraser, William Alexander, Trinity, 113n. Five Little Men, 10 Horror of the Heights, The (Arthur Conan Doyle), 74 Frederic Dorr Steele and Gray Chandler Briggs Houghton, Arthur, Jr., 81 (Andrew Malec), 128n. Houghton Library, 3, 75, 81-83, 82 Frederic Dorr Steele, Sherlock Holmes and “The Hound of the Baskervilles, The, xi, 9, 74, 88, 91 Three Students” (Andrew Malec), xii, 4, 121-129 1939 movie version, 128 Fry, C.B., 90, 102, 115 Housman, A.E., 116n. Fusco, Andrew G., BSI, Illustrations, Sherlockian, xi, 5, 10-11, 11, 98, 107, 114 General Editor’s Preface to the Series, vii-xii In the Fog (), 122 Gaudy Night (Dorothy L. Sayers), 113 India, 103 General Editor’s Preface to the Series (Andrew G. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, 63 Fusco, BSI), vii-xii Introduction (John Bergquist, BSI), xi, 1-5 Gerard, Brigadier, 73 Inventory of the Historical Monuments in the City of Germany, 104 Oxford, An, 114n. Gilchrist, 3, 89, 95, 103-105, 112, 115, 119-120, 125 Iowa, 77 Gillette, William, Ireland, 122 Model for Dorr Steele, 123, 125 Isocrates, Sherlock Holmes, 123, 128 Panathenaicus, 116 Glasgow, University of, 97 Jackson, Robert H., ‘Gloria Scott’ The, 98-99 What is the Future of the Book?, 1 Gloss, George, 82 Jesus Christ, 112n. Golden Pince-Nez, The, 11, 73, 75, 91 John the Evangelist, St., 112n. Great Historical Enterprises (D. Knowles), 116n. Joyce, David Gage, 76-78 Green, Richard Lancelyn, xi, 3, 74, 92, 127-128 Joyce, Stanley, 77 Green, Roger Lancelyn, 3 Keddie, James, Jr., 89 Green Flag, The (Arthur Conan Doyle), 77 Kelvin, William Thomson, Lord, 106 Groombridge Hall, 89 Kersting, A.F., Gryphon Club, The, 119n. Peterhouse An Architectural Record 1284-1984 (with Guardian, The, 88 David Watkin), 108n. Gwalior, 103 Kipling, Rudyard, Hall, Trevor, 3 Stalky and Co., 118n. www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 5 of 10 An Index to So Painful a Scandal

Klinefelter, Walter, Mary Magdalene, St., 112n. Sherlock Holmes in Portrait and Profile, 129n. Mascall, E.L. Klinger, Leslie S., BSI, xi, 93 On Dispensing With Q, 119-120n. New Annotated Sherlock Holmes, The, 90, 92 Pi in the High, 119n. Tangled Skein, A, xi Masterman, J.C. (Sir John), Knowles, D., Oxford Tragedy, An, 112, 117 Great Historical Enterprises, 116n. To Teach the Senators Wisdom or An Oxford Guide Knox, Ronald, vii Book, 112n. Absolute and Abitofhell, 119n. Matthew, St., 119n. Some Loose Stones, 119n Memories of Victorian Oxford (Sir Charles Oman), 120 Studies in the Literature of Sherlock Holmes, 4n., Meyer, Nicholas, viii 119n. Miami, 77 Kubla Khan The (Samuel Taylor Coleridge), 79 Microcosmographica Academica: A Guide for the Young Lal Rao: see Rao, Lal Academic Politician (F.M. Cornford), 118n. Lang, Andrew, 94 Milton, John, At the Sign of the Ship, 3 Milton’s Poems, 81 Lawrence, Long Island, 79 Minnesota, 77 Lellenberg, Jon, Missing Link, The (Katherine Farrer), 113, 117-118 Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters (with Daniel Missing Three-Quarter, The, 11, 73, 91, 99, 100 Stashower & Charles Foley, eds.), 72n. Monro, D.B., 116 Lewis, Arthur H., viii Montague Street, 99 Limited Editions Club, 128 Montgomery, James, Lion’s Mane, The, xi-xii (n.) Study in Pictures, A, 129n. London, University of, 97, 99 Moran, Ursula, London Nights of Belsize, The (Vernon Rendall), 3 Second Thoughts on ‘The Three Students’ (with Chris Long Island, 79 Redmond), 11n Long Jump, 89-90, 102, 115, 116 Morley, Christopher, vii, x, 97, 98, 108 Longman’s Magazine, 3 Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson (ed.), x (n.) Lowes, Professor J.L., Sherlock Holmes Revisits Cambridge, 108n. Road to Xanadu, The, 79 Morley-Montgomery Award, xi Luke, St., 112n., 119 Morse, Inspector, 87 Lycett, Andrew, Mossbanker, Professor, 118n. Man Who Created Sherlock Holmes, The, 91-92 Murderland (Steven T. Doyle), xi Lyons, Iowa, 77 Musgrave, Reginald, 98-99 Lyttelton, George, 90, 102 Musgrave Ritual, The, 98 McClure’s Magazine, 122 My Dear Holmes (Gavin Brend), 97-98 McCurdy & Yard, 78 Mysterious Press, The, 123 McLaren, Miles, 95, 103, 112 Myths of Plato, The (J.A. Stewart), 116n. MacManus, Seumas, 122 National Academy, 121 Malec, Andrew, BSI, 131 Neal, Miss, 74 Frederic Dorr Steele and Gray Chandler Briggs, New Annotated Sherlock Holmes, The (Leslie S. Klinger), 128n. 90 Frederic Dorr Steele, Sherlock Holmes and “The New York, 10, 77, 78, 79, 121, 122, 123 Three Students”, xii, 4, 121-129 New Yorker, The, 129n. Other Master: Frederic Dorr Steele, The, 128n. Newnes, Ltd., 9 Man Who Created Sherlock Holmes, The (Andrew Nicholson, Oliver, xii, 132 Lycett), 91-92 Oxbridge Camouflaged or Camford Obscured: Some Mandate for Murder (Roy Pilot, ed.), xi (n.) Subfuscations of the Doylean Redactor, xii, 2, 4, 62, Manhattan, 105 111-120 Manuscript: see Doyle (Manuscripts) Norfolk, 98 Margaret of Antioch, St., 112n. Norton Perkins Memorial Fund, 80 Mark, St., 119n. Norwood Builder, The, 10-11, 78, 90, 100 Marriott, Guy, BSI, 2n. Notes on the Manuscript (Phillip Bergem), xii, 3, 7-11 Three Students” at Cambridge, “The, xii, 2, 4, 62, Nuremburg, 104-105 64, 90, 97-108, 113n., 115 Oak, 67, 69 Mary, St., 112n. Door, 117-119 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 6 of 10 An Index to So Painful a Scandal

Officer, Lawrence H., 84 Oxford University (…continued) Ohio, 10 St. John’s College, 85-88, 86, 100, 112 Oman, Sir Charles, Canterbury Quad, 87 Memories of Victorian Oxford, 120 Chapel, 86 O’Mara, Michael, 123 Front Quad, 86-87 On Dispensing With Q (E.L. Mascall), 119-120n. Holmes Building, 87, 87 On Fenner’s Sward (Giles Phillips), 108n. North Quad, 86-87 Order of St. John of Jerusalem, 75 St. Peter’s College, 100, 112n. Other Master: Frederic Dorr Steele, The (Andrew St. Stephen’s House, 100 Malec), 128n. St. Thomas’s College, 112 Oxbridge Camouflaged or Camford Obscured: Some Shrewsbury College, 113 Subfuscations of the Doylean Redactor (Oliver Somerville College, 113 Nicholson), 2, 4, 62, 111-120 Sporting Blues, 66, 89 Oxford, 2, 4, 85-88, 92, 99-100, 113 Trinity College, 113n., 117n., 119n. Broad Street, 87, 113 Wadham College, 113, 115 Holywell Street, 113 Front Quadrangle, 113 King’s Arms, The, 113n. Worcester College, 112 Merton Street, 113, 117 Paget, Sidney, 5, 98, 107 Oxford Gaol, 112 Panathenaicus (Isocrates), 116 St. Giles Street, 87, 117n. Parker Brothers, 11 White Horse, The, 87 Pastiches, viii, 91 Oxford Blood (Antonia Fraser), 118n. Peas, 116 Oxford City Police, 118 Peloponnesian War, 93, 103 Oxford English Dictionary, 69 Pencil shavings, 94, 104-105 Oxford Magazine, 119n. Pennsylvania, xi Oxford Sherlock Holmes, 74, 78, 92 Perkins, Edward H., Jr., 78-79 Oxford Tragedy, An (J.C. Masterman), 112, 117 Perkins, Margaret S., 79 Oxford University, 2, 62, 98, 101-102, 112-117, 120 Perkins, Mary Norton, 78-79 Athletics Team, 89 Perkins, Norton, 78-81, 82 Balliol College, 87, 113, 116n. Perspective in Scholarship, A (Edgar W. Smith), vii (n.) Christ Church College, 93, 116n. Peter, St., 112n. Corpus Christi College, 113 Peterhouse An Architectural Record 1284-1984 (A.F. Exeter College, 113 Kersting & David Watkin), 108n. Magdalen College, 112n. Philadelphia, 10 Merton College, 113 Phillips, Giles, Fellows Building, 113 On Fenner’s Sward, 108n. Mob Quad, 113 Pi in the High (E.L. Mascall), 119n. New College, 97, 112n., 113 Pilgrim Fathers, 86 Oriel College, 112n., 114 Pilot, Roy, St. Mary’s Hall, 114, 114-115 Mandate for Murder (Roy Pilot, ed.), xi (n.) St. Mary’s Quadrangle, 114-115 Plato, 116 Oxford University Calendar, 116n. Theaetetus, 116 Queens College, 90, 117n. Pondicherry Lodge, 64 St. Anne’s College, 100 Portsmouth Central Library and City Museum, 127 St. Antony’s College, 100 Portsmouth Museums and Records Service, 127 St. Benet’s Hall, 100 Prestige, Colin, 114 St. Catherine’s College, 100, 112n. Priory School, The, xi (n.), 90 St. Christopher’s College Profile by Gaslight (Edgar W. Smith, ed.), x St. Cross College, 100 Q-Hypothesis, 117n., 119n. St. Edmund Hall, 100 Quadrangle, 101, 113 St. Hilda’s College, 100 Quartering Press, The, xi St. Hugh’s College, 100 Queen’s Club, London, 115 Radegund, St., 112n. Rao, Lal, 64 Rao, Daulat, 64, 95, 103, 109n. Ras, Daulat, 64, 95, 103, 112 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 7 of 10 An Index to So Painful a Scandal

Rathbone, Basil, 128 Sherlock Holmes Revisits Cambridge (Christopher Red Circle, The, xi, 91 Morley), 108n. Red Cross Society, 75-76, 78 Sherlock Holmes Society of London, xi, 114 Redfearn, Dr Auberon, 97 Sherlockian scholarship, vii-xi, 89, 117 Red-Headed League, The, 121 Great Game, The, vii-viii, 90, 92 Redmond, Chris, Shore, Jemima, 118n. Second Thoughts on ‘The Three Students’ (with Shoscombe Old Place, xii (n.) Ursula Moran), 11n Siberia, 104 Regimental Scandal, A (Arthur Conan Doyle), 66 Sign of the Four, The, 9, 64, 77-78 Reichenbach Falls, 91 Six Napoleons, The, xi, 9, 71, 72, 74, 76, 91 Remarkable Mixture, A (Steven Rothman, ed.), xi Six Napoleons of Baltimore, 121 Rendall, Vernon, Sleepless Watchman, 10-11, 11 London Nights of Belsize, The, 3 Smith, C.F., 109n. Rendell, Ruth, 87-88 Smith, Edgar W., vii-x, xii Return of Sherlock Holmes, The, 9, 72, 74, 75, 90, 92, Perspective in Scholarship, A, vii (n.) 121, 123-124 Profile by Gaslight (ed.), x Rhodes Scholarship, 97 Smith, H. Greenhough, 72, 74, 92 Rime of the Ancient Mariner, The (Samuel Taylor Soames, Hilton, 3, 90, 95, 104, 115-120, 125 Coleridge), 79 Relationship to Holmes & Watson, 93, 100, 101 Road to Xanadu, The (Lowes, J.L.), 79 Rooms, 94, 105, 107, 111-112, 115, 117 Roberts, S.C., vii, x, 2 Societies, Sherlockian, viii Robertson, Allen, 121, 128n. Solitary Cyclist, The, 72, 90 Rosenblatt, Albert M., BSI, 83 Some Loose Stones (Ronald Knox), 119n Study in Crimson, 83 South Audley Street, London, 75 Rossakis, Costa, 5 Sparta, 103 Rothman, Steven, Spealls, 75 Remarkable Mixture, A (ed.), xi special.lib.umn.edu, 128n. To Keep the Memory Green (with Nicholas Speckled Band of Boston, 83 Utechin), xi, 132 Springfield, Ohio, 10 Royal Commission on Historical Monuments, 114n. Stalky and Co. (Rudyard Kipling), 118n. St. Andrews, University of, 97 Starrett, Vincent, vii-x, Saiont Louis, 126 Adventure of the Unique Hamlet, The, 91 St. Luke’s, College of, 93, 94, 100, 102, 106, 111- 221B: Studies in Sherlock (ed.), vii-ix (n.), xii (n.) 112, 115, 117 Stashower, Daniel, Sayers, Dorothy L., 2, 89 Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters (with Jon Gaudy Night, 113 Lellenberg & Charles Foley, eds.), 72n. Scribner’s Magazine, 122 Steele, Frederic Dorr, 4, 10, 121-129 Second Stain, The, 11, 92 Illustrations, Sherlockian, 10-11, 11, 123-129, 123-124, Second Thoughts on ‘The Three Students’ (Chris 126 Redmond & Ursula Moran), 11n Sherlock Holmes in Pictures, 128-129n. Sherlock Holmes (), 123 Veteran Artist Goes Reminiscent, 122 Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson (Christopher Stern, Peter, 126-127 Morley, ed.), x (n.) Stevens & Brown, B.F., 76 Sherlock Holmes & the Law exhibition, 83 Stevenson, Robert Louis, 80 Sherlock Holmes at Oxford (Nicholas Utechin), 89 Stewart, J.A., Sherlock Holmes: Fact or Fiction? (T.S. Blakeney), Myths of Plato, The, 116n. 99 Stock, Randall, BSI, xii, 132 Sherlock Holmes Game, 11 Following “The Three Students”: A Manuscript Sherlock Holmes in America (Bill Blackbeard), 122- History, 3, 71-84 123, 128n. Storrs, Sir Ronald, 106 Sherlock Holmes in Pictures (Frederic Dorr Steele), Strand Magazine, 2, 7, 9-10, 62, 72, 74, 92, 94, 98 128-129n. American edition, 9 Sherlock Holmes in Portrait and Profile (Walter Streeter, B.H., 117n. Klinefelter), 129n. Foundations (B.H. Streeter), 119n. Sherlock Holmes Journal, The, 11n., 89, 102, 108n., Studies in Early English Charters (Sherlock Holmes), 101 114 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 8 of 10 An Index to So Painful a Scandal

Studies in the Literature of Sherlock Holmes (Ronald Utechin, Nicholas, 2n., 62, 98, 132 Knox), 4n., 119n. Sherlock Holmes at Oxford, 89 Study in Crimson, A (Albert M. Rosenblatt, BSI), 83 Three Students, Seventeen Problems, xii, 2-4, 62, 89-95, Study in Pictures, A (James Montgomery), 129n. 102 Study in Scarlet, A, xi, 69 To Keep the Memory Green (with Steven Rothman), xi Swan, Joseph, 105-106 Valley of Fear, The, xi, 89 Tan, 69-70 Veteran Artist Goes Reminiscent (Frederic Dorr Steele), Tanbark, 69-70 122 Tangled Skein, A (Leslie S. Klinger), xi Voice of Science, The (Arthur Conan Doyle), 66 Taylor Company, N. & G., 10 Wadham College (Joseph Wells), 113n. Taylor Old Style Roofing Tin, 10-11 Watkin, David, Theaetetus (Plato), 116 Peterhouse An Architectural Record 1284-1984 (with Theophrastus, A.F. Kersting), 108n. Characters, 116 Watson, Dr. John H., Three Gables, The, 91 Medical Practice, 101 Three Students, The, Middle name, 89 Illustrations, 4-5, 107, 114, 123-128, 123-124, 126 Relationship with Holmes, 3, 92, 94, 101 Alternative cover, 125-128 Watt, A.P., 71 Inconsistencies & improbabilities, 2-3, 92-95, 101- Watts, Groundsman, 102, 115 105 Waugh, Evelyn, Location of, 2, 4, 62, 85-88, 89-90, 97, 99-108, Brideshead Revisited, 120 111-120 Wells, Joseph, Manuscript, 1-2, 7-8, 14-61, 62-70, 64, 71-84, 73- Wadham College, 113n. 76, 81, 92-95, 103 Westinghouse Corporation, 63 Auctions, 75-78 What is the Future of the Book? (Robert H. Jackson), 1 Harvard, at, 80-83 White Company, The (Arthur Conan Doyle), 77-78 Ownership of, 3, 71-83 Widener Library, 79, 81, 82 Theft of, 82-83 Friends of the Library, 79 Value, 76, 78, 84 Treasure Room, 81 Practical Joke, as, 3, 92 Williamson, Samuel H., 84 Publication history, 9-10, 73-74 Wimsey, Lord Peter, 87 Story number, 62, 72-73 Wolff, Julian, 89 Three Students” at Cambridge, “The (Guy Marriott), Catalogue of 221B Culture, A, 101, 109n. 2, 4, 62, 64, 90, 97-108, 113n., 115 Wolfson, Sir Isaac, 112n. Three Students in Limelight, Electric Light and Woodlawn Cemetery, 79 Daylight, The (W.S. Bristowe), 89, 108n., 113- Woolson’s Economy Expense Book, 11 114n., 115n. Wordsworth, William, 80 Three Students, Seventeen Problems (Nicholas www.bakerstreetjournal.com, 128n. Utechin), 2, 4, 62, 89-95, 102 www.bestofsherlock.com, xii Thucydides, 3, 93-94, 103-104, 116 www.maharajah.freeserve.co.uk, 109n. History of the Peloponnesian War, The, 93, 109n. www.measuringworth.com, 84 To Keep the Memory Green (Steven Rothman & www.theiet.org, 109n. Nicholas Utechin), xi Yale, 77 To Teach the Senators Wisdom or An Oxford Guide Book (J.C. Masterman), 112n. Touring with “The Three Students” (Michael Eckman), 2, 3-4, 62, 85-88 Trevor, Victor, 98 Trinity (Clare Hopkins), 113n. Trinity College, Dublin, 97 221B: Studies in Sherlock Holmes (, ed.), vii-ix (n.), xii (n.) United States of America, 9, 76, 91, 105, 122, 128 Unjust Steward, Parable of the, 119 Untermeyer, Louis, x Utah, xi www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 9 of 10 An Index to So Painful a Scandal

DATES 1948, 97 1955, 89 1870s, 97-98, 114 1956, viii, 102 1889, 121 1960, 114 1891, 121 1971, 82-83, 90 1892, 121 March, 82 1893, 98 April, 82-83 April, 98 1972, 78 May, 98 1977, 83 1894, 100 1980s, 126 1895, 89-90, 99, 102, 105, 111, 114-115, 120 1984, 127 1899, 122 October, 127 1900, 122 November, 127 1901, 74, 122 1987, 123 1902, 114, 115 1988, 83 1903, 9, 10, 71-73, 90, 91, 121, 123 April, 83 March, 91 June, 83 April, 71, 73 1989, 97 September, 9, 71-73 2008, 85, 127 October, 9, 10, 71, 92 December, 127 November, 72-73 2009, 83 December, 71-72 May, 83 1904, 2-3, 9-11, 62, 71-74, 92, 123 January, 73 April, 9-10, 71-74, 92 May, 9 June, 2, 9, 10, 62, 74 July, 3 August, 11 September, 9, 10, 62, 74, 123 October, 10, 11 November, 11 1905, 9, 10, 123 1913, 75 December, 75 1916, 75 February, 75 1917, 3, 75-76 February, 75 March, 76 April, 76 1920s, 91, 126 1923, 76 1925, 80-81 November, 80-81 1926, 80 1927, 73 1930, ix July, ix 1934, ix January, ix 1940, 81, 121 1942, vii-viii, 81 February, 81 1946, 81 1947, 80 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 10 of 10