Manuscript Cultures Manuscript Cultures Manuscript
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
mc NO 10 2017 mc NO 10 2017 manuscript cultures manuscript Hamburg | Centre for the Study of Manuscript Cultures ISSN 1867–9617 cultures ISSN 1867–9617 © SFB 950 “Manuskriptkulturen in Asien, Afrika und Europa” Universität Hamburg Warburgstraße 26 www.manuscript-cultures.uni-hamburg.de D-20354 Hamburg N O 10 PUBLISHING INFORMATION | MANUSCRIPT CULTURES Publishing Information Forthcoming 10 - Dividing Texts: Visual Text-Organization in North Indian and Nepalese Manuscripts by Bidur Bhattarai The number of manuscripts produced in the Indian sub- Editors Editorial Office continent is astounding and is the result of a massive Prof Dr Michael Friedrich Dr Irina Wandrey enterprise that was carried out over a vast geographical area Universität Hamburg Universität Hamburg and over a vast stretch of time. Focusing on areas of Northern Asien-Afrika-Institut Sonderforschungsbereich 950 India and Nepal between 800 to 1300 ce and on manuscripts Edmund-Siemers-Allee 1/ Flügel Ost ‘Manuskriptkulturen in Asien, Afrika und Europa’ containing Sanskrit texts, the present study investigates a D-20146 Hamburg Warburgstraße 26 fundamental and so far rarely studied aspect of manuscript Tel. No.: +49 (0)40 42838 7127 D-20354 Hamburg production: visual organization. Scribes adopted a variety Fax No.: +49 (0)40 42838 4899 Tel. No.: +49 (0)40 42838 9420 of visual strategies to distinguish one text from another [email protected] Fax No.: +49 (0)40 42838 4899 and to differentiate the various sections within a single [email protected] text (chapters, sub-chapters, etc.). Their repertoire includes Prof Dr Jörg Quenzer the use of space(s) on the folio, the adoption of different Universität Hamburg Layout writing styles, the inclusion of symbols of various kind, Asien-Afrika-Institut Astrid Kajsa Nylander the application of colors (rubrication), or a combination of Edmund-Siemers-Allee 1/ Flügel Ost all these. This study includes a description of these various D-20146 Hamburg Cover strategies and an analysis of their different implementations r Tel. No.: +49 40 42838 - 7203 Photo: Codex Azcatitlan, Ms. Mexicain 59-64, fol. 5 (detail) across the selected geographical areas. It sheds light on how Fax No.: +49 40 42838 - 6200 showing traces of Mesoamerican footprints. © Paris, Biblio- manuscripts were produced, as well as on some aspects of [email protected] thèque nationale de France. their employment in ritual contexts, in different areas of India and Nepal. Translations and Copy-editing Carl Carter, Amper Translation Service www.ampertrans.de Mitch Cohen, Berlin Forthcoming 15 - Studies on Greek and Coptic Majuscule Scripts Print and Books by Pasquale Orsini AZ Druck und Datentechnik GmbH, Kempten The volume contains a critical review of data, results and Printed in Germany open problems concerning the principal Greek and Coptic majuscule bookhands, based on previous research of the author, revised and updated to offer an overview of the different graphic phenomena. Although the various chapters address the history of different types of scripts (i.e. biblical majuscule, sloping poitend majuscule, liturgical majuscule, epigraphic and monumental scripts), their juxtaposition allows us to identify common issues of the comparative method of palaeography. From an overall critical assessment of these aspects the impossibility of applying a unique historical paradigm to interpret the formal expressions and ISSN 1867–9617 the history of the different bookhands comes up, due to the fact that each script follows different paths. Particular © 2017 attention is also devoted to the use of Greek majuscules in www.manuscript-cultures.uni-hamburg.de SFB 950 ‘Manuskriptkulturen in Asien, Afrika und Europa’ the writing of ancient Christian books. A modern and critical Universität Hamburg awareness of palaeographic method may help to place the Warburgstraße 26 individual witnesses in the context of the main graphic D-20354 Hamburg trends, in the social and cultural environments in which they developed, and in a more accurate chronological framework. O manuscript cultures mc N 10 CoNTENTS | MANUSCRIPT CULTURES 1 CONTENTS 1 FORUM 3 | A Case for the Study of Modern Literary Manuscripts by Christian Benne ARTICLES 15 | The ‘Marriage Charter’ of Theophanu: A Product of Ottonian Manuscript Culture by Bruno Reudenbach 31 | Medial Ambiguity: Liturgical Books of the Latin Church and their Changing Status in Mediaeval Tradition by Felix Heinzer 51 | Travelling the Time Line: The Visual Organisation of New Spanish Manuscripts about the Mexica by Anna Boroffka 73 | How Arabic Manuscripts Moved to German Libraries by Tilman Seidensticker 83 | A Manifold Heritage: Glimpses of a Family Collection of Arabic Manuscripts in Ilọrin (Nigeria) and Its Transregional Links by Stefan Reichmuth 101 | Fakes or Fancies? Some ‘Problematic’ Islamic Manuscripts from South East Asia by Annabel Teh Gallop 129 | What a Multiple-text Manuscript Can Tell Us about the Tamil Scholarly Tradition: The Case of UVSL 589 by Jonas Buchholz and Giovanni Ciotti 145 | The Novgorod Birch-bark Manuscripts by Imke Mendoza 160 | How to Make an Archival Inventory in Early Modern Europe: Carrying Documents, Gluing Paper and Transforming Archival Chaos into Well-ordered Knowledge by Markus Friedrich 174 | Contributors 176 | Announcement O mc N 10 manuscript cultures BOROFFKA | THE VISuaL ORGANISATION OF NEW SPANISH MANUSCRIPTS ABOUT THE MEXICA 51 Article Travelling the Time Line: The Visual Organisation of New Spanish Manuscripts about the Mexica* Anna Boroffka | Hamburg During the Spanish conquest (1519–1521) and subsequent of Central Mexican manuscripts that were produced during mission of the High Valley of modernday Mexico, all the Early Colonial Period (1521–c. 1600) and dealt with the the local preHispanic manuscripts were destroyed.1 This preHispanic history of the Mexica, the inhabitants of the destruction was not accompanied by a general halt in regional Aztec capital of Tenochtitlan5 (now Mexico City).6 Unlike manuscript production, however. On the contrary, numerous previous research, the paper focuses on the dialectic of new manuscripts were manufactured in Central Mexico on destroying, rewriting and restaging the indigenous heritage.7 behalf of the Spanish crown and Christian missionaries. In my article, I take pictorial and alphabetic manuscripts About 500 of these manuscripts have survived to this day.2 equally into account, as I believe this enables us to see things Over the last few decades, scholars have analysed these in a broader perspective and witness shifts and transformation handwritten and handdrawn colonialera documents in an processes within the visual organisation and visual narrative effort to detect traces of erased Aztec3 manuscript cultures of these manuscripts. and European influences.4 This article focuses on a subgroup I. Aztec manuscripts It is known that in preHispanic times, Central Mexico was * The research for this paper was carried out at the Sonderforschungsbereich populated by numerous small and large polities consisting 950 ‘Manuskriptkulturen in Asien, Afrika und Europa’, Hamburg 8 University, funded by the German Research Foundation (Deutsche of different groups of people and their territory. Several Forschungsgemeinschaft, DFG) and and was part of the general work of the larger communities seem to have been independent carried out by the Centre for the Study of Manuscript Cultures (CSMC). In this article, I refer to a definition of visual organisation elaborated at the citystates ruled by a tlatoani (‘speaker’) and surrounded CSMC. According to this definition, visual organisation relates not only to by smaller, dependent polities. The structure of such an the layout of the individual page, but regards the manuscript as a whole, including all its constituting factors (such as its size, form and materiality, independent preHispanic citystate is not completely known its architecture, its writings and its drawings). In a broader sense, the visual to us today and may have varied,9 but it seems that it was organisation of a manuscript is thus the visual arrangement of knowledge. often centred on a relatively large town and its dependencies, 1 Only 14 manuscripts have survived from the whole of Mesoamerica that including rural areas or civic and ceremonial centres, for can be dated to the preHispanic period with any certainty (three Maya codices, six codices of the Borgia Group and five Mixtec codices). None example. Colonial records indicate that in preHispanic times of these manuscripts are from Central Mexico. Federico Navarrete Linares some kind of connection was established between the cities connects the dialectic of burning and reproducing manuscripts to pre Hispanic traditions. He emphasises that due to the preHispanic valuation of orally transmitted knowledge, manuscripts were not regarded as unique and irreplaceable objects, but could be destroyed, reproduced, improved and 5 adapted; Navarrete Linares 1998. When Axayacatl, the ruler of Tenochtitlan, conquered the neighbouring city of Tlatelolco in 1473, both citystates were united. 2 Robertson 1959; Cline 1975, 3–252; Boone 1998a. 6 See Elizabeth Hill Boone’s fundamental study for a broader discussion of 3 The umbrella term ‘Aztecs’ subsumes the heterogeneous Nahuatl historiographical manuscripts, including Mixtec documents; Boone 2000. speaking groups living in the Valley of Mexico between the fourteenth and 7 early sixteenth century. According to legend, these groups